True, because judged by what she likes. they have their own theme that suits their personality, and I prefer the ones that are like fun or relaxing or all of this. because i like music. ouh and the seiyuu's like horie yui and ueda reina. I wonder when elysia seiyuu is coming to genshin.
@@96shinvasc she has a unique fixation for cuts and needs for personality expression. Some extreme tendencies for music types as well. Definitely doesn’t appeal to general public for sure. Every thing she do screams self enjoyment. So this is just pure individual opinion.
It was the gold standard until Raiden's, so putting it as 'mid' over audio issues is 'cap,' isn't it? Still one of my favourite trailers, but then I also didn't enjoy Xiao's at all.
@@BrandonHeat243 she pick with feelings, the animation means nothing. She just put what she likes, maybe she just really likes the sensational or fun trailers
It's totally mid all he does most of the time is just standing then talking then casting his abilities....I mean it's understandable since he's an old folk
While I understand different people have different taste in character but like how tf are Nahida, Candace, Collei and Tighnari’s demo the same energy? While Nahida and Collei and both playful and childlike, Collei’s demo focused on the playful side, and Nahida’s demo focused on the purity side with some darkness of her situation. Candace’s demo focused on the Egyptian theme and her gentle personality and I think Tighnari’s demo focuses on the nature theme
Zhongli's demo singlehandedly brought me into playing genshin, and I didn't know anything about this game aside from this game being a popular anime game.
18:13 (about Raiden's) "This is what Zhongli's wanted to be - I'm just saying" Raiden's role in the story is that of the overwhelmingly powerful antagonist you have to overcome. Zhongli's role in the story is very different to that: his demo conveys power, but in a way that's more composed and elegant, as opposed to Raiden's which is more focused on being intimidating and, well, overwhelming. So no, Raiden's demo is not what Zhongli's wanted to be: Zhongli's demo is what Zhongli's wanted to be.
also i actually dont like those parts of raiden's and wanderer's trailers. they just seem out of place for me. maybe it sort of fits wanderer but raiden is also this sort of serious character
Unbiased but put pretty much every free spirited character demo on top of the lists... sure. Every demo tailor made to match the characters personality, not to show that editor having fun or whatever. Some demo even tied to the archon quest lore. Like Itto, Ayato, Nahida.
Another example is Kokomi. I don't like her character but i enjoyed her demo since it matched her and it was really beautifully made. I would've put her on pretty solid. But hey the "unbiased" part was half true half joke since tier lists aren't unbiased in the first place lol
Nahida was a 10 outta 10. You're looking for oomf and personality, and Nahida's demo had those, just not in the bombastic ways. It was a gentle trailer, reminiscent of the gentle god Nahida is, not to mention the music, editing, and pacing were absolutely on point.
@@komi7051 then what you want anything more than that a whole anime? it show the lore without spoil it his personality game play music and visual is so good and this trailer from 2 year ago
@@notdio7766 And why if his trailer is old? Klee's trailer is even better than him. I dont expect that much, but his trailer could've been better ( Aka with cool transitions ) a bit less like Raiden's. Dude his demo is literally only his Gameplay+Music which is basically every 4 stars character's demo 💀
I mean, I love zhongli with all my heart but there is something in his demo that's just... boring to me, don't get me wrong I don't think it's bad, but I just can't get myself to like it
I can forgive the top tiers being oversaturated with cutesy trailers. I can forgive Raiden's trailer being A instead of S. I can even forgive, though bitterly, that Zhongli's trailer isn't much higher. But putting Tighnari's trailer in MID and saying Collei's is better is a sin I CANNOT forgive. Big L for chat there, too.
Of course, there's a massive disparity between the early ones and the later ones, both stylistically and in how much of the story they involve. The PVs only really start to includes story elements in the run-up to the Battle of Schicksal, I noticed. Also I'm unbearably hyped for 6.3. New Bronya, even though I feel like I just got HoR's new equipment set.
Everything else aside.... Puting Zhongli on Mid should be a crime... His demo literally had a short intro, about a guy literally talking about his, meanwhile he listening pretending the story isn't about him, already says a lot, then the music popping of, the rhythm of the music and scenes not to mention the 2d dragons the put in the demo made it a full package. It was definitely not the best ever, but I feel nothing aside from Klee and Hu Tao before Inazuma, can even compare to it
One of the most enjoyable videos i´ve seen on the "Genshin Demo Reacting". Maybe I could be very wrong, but around 2.5 to the end of Inazuma there was a lot of negativity towards Genshin in the worldwide community. Maybe it affected the enjoyment and creativity of the developers. With Sumeru they tried to make a better job, and they actually did, but at the same time some things feels more scripted. But since the waters are calmer now, maybe they were having fun again with the last 3 demos.
Ngl though I also loved the ones that were on top because they had so much personality in their trailers. Kinda miffed about Tighnari though. Lol I actually thoroughly enjoyed his trailer very much. He was basically high the entire time throughout that video how was that not entertaining enough.
Tier lists are always biased in some way, because they are highly subjective. What I personally don't understand is your take after the Nahida trailer. On which metrics are you identifying that the recent trailers are not made by people anymore who loved mihoyo? Especially after you just watched the Nahida trailer.
Raiden Shogun has the best and most hype trailer to date what is this? Also, half of the good category plus Keqing and Fischl are surrounded by character trailers that significantly outclass them simply because they were seen early and all the high budget trailers came later.
also yae mako is 500+ but not up to 600 because in her ult she has 5 tails and a kitsune gains 1 tail every 100 years so she is 500 i just wanted to point that out
You should add some words behind your vid's name like [with Biased or my opinion only Etc.] so people that click onto it dont think that it's non-biased and judging from all aspects like editing / lore / Char's personality / music / release date Etc. But the vid is enjoyable thanks.
Since saw the Zhongli tier I'm not expecting the tier from now and focus on her having fun with reaction instead lol. His attack in slow looks so good. The shot with him only stands still while having his shield block enemies. The man words at the start talk about the line, and Zhongli say the line that the man trails off, followed by his cool attack and his burst. He's so calm but he can be serious if he needs to. There are also other characters I disagree with, so called this no bias is very suspicious. Though the video is fun.
I was kinda going to let it all slide till she put Eula over Zhongli and Cyno. Imo Eula's trailer is one hot steamy pile of nothing. She just kinda dances on screen, and Amber shows up at the end. Definitely not better than Zhongli and ABSOLUTELY not better than Cyno
I just really wanna say the hate she is getting in the comments about her ratings is not even worth it because mina has her opinions she tried to not be biased and i get you dont like zhongli being rated a bit bad but you have your opinions so u have no right to bash her opinion abt her ratings..
@@Syntherus Yes, Fischl's trailer truly shows of her personality and even the small edits in the character demo help express her skills/character, which is how most demos should be. Keqing's does the same, showing her skills/character, I'm just not sure if I wouldve placed keqing that high.
sure lmao Zhongli to the lowest point of A tier when it sits on top of the genshin channel's most viewed video and perfectly incapsulates the culture, theming and personality of the character. Screw off.
Based Zhongli take 👑👑👑 People are so mad because you have a different opinion from them it's so dumb haha, I disagree with some of your placements from my perspective but ain't gonna complain like others have haha
Yeah.. She did said that it will be controversial placement for some of the placement.. From my own opinion, of course I would differ from her (surprisingly not really much differences, maybe just less than 5 demos that i might beg to differ, but it all because from my own bias as well xD). But from what im trying to understand, Mina has tendency to rank the demo purely from how she is feeling engaged when watching the video demo, hence why she leans towards the more upbeat, comedic, fun demo, not easily swoon over by beautiful visual, animation, music, etc. From that, I can agree with most of her choice, in fact, I can guess all her placement correctly (incorrect guess only by one tier above or below, also she herself have a change midway in the video as well haha).. But it's all good. I like this kind of video from her. It really scream Mina xD We only have to know that, we all free to agree or disagree. It's fine if we don't like her tier list, complain is also fine. I mean everyone has their own preferences and we can do nothing much about it.. But the point is, I won't force Mina to change just to suit my taste if I disagree with her. It's her choice and I truly respect that. Keep up the great work Mina, Ganbare
I cannot comprehend how klee's demo is any better than raiden when you can clearly see where mihoyo dump all their budget for character demos at....there is more that i would argue with the tier list but one thing that i 100% agree with is that kaeya's and aloy's demo are just.....BAD
i probably disagree with 80% of her tier list lmao except for the SSS she chose. I think we can let her (sometimes) unbased opinion go just for that lol
this is not Tier list for the best demo this is the Tier list for Mina bias review
True, because judged by what she likes.
they have their own theme that suits their personality, and I prefer the ones that are like fun or relaxing or all of this. because i like music.
ouh and the seiyuu's like horie yui and ueda reina.
I wonder when elysia seiyuu is coming to genshin.
@@96shinvasc she has a unique fixation for cuts and needs for personality expression. Some extreme tendencies for music types as well. Definitely doesn’t appeal to general public for sure. Every thing she do screams self enjoyment. So this is just pure individual opinion.
Isn't that every tier list tho? Tier lists are just individual rankings based on personal opinion.
@@dianaahakim2001 Yep.
And that's why you never take tier lists as any sort of fact.
Wait until you figure out there is no such thing as a "best demo tier list" and the best demo is just from people's biases
The fact she said Qiqi demo is better than Zhongli I’m not even mad or disappointed, I’m just laughing lmao
SAME I DONT HAVE THEM TOO😂😂😂😂
Zhongli’s demo was literally what had me roll him
It was the gold standard until Raiden's, so putting it as 'mid' over audio issues is 'cap,' isn't it? Still one of my favourite trailers, but then I also didn't enjoy Xiao's at all.
Thta one place made me pause the video. Like, WOW!
I can respect not having it top tier. We all have different tastes. But to put it in the bottom half? Sacrilege.
@@BrandonHeat243 she pick with feelings, the animation means nothing. She just put what she likes,
maybe she just really likes the sensational or fun trailers
It's totally mid all he does most of the time is just standing then talking then casting his abilities....I mean it's understandable since he's an old folk
While I understand different people have different taste in character but like how tf are Nahida, Candace,
Collei and Tighnari’s demo the same energy? While Nahida and Collei and both playful and childlike, Collei’s demo focused on the playful side, and Nahida’s demo focused on the purity side with some darkness of her situation. Candace’s demo focused on the Egyptian theme and her gentle personality and I think Tighnari’s demo focuses on the nature theme
Zhongli's demo singlehandedly brought me into playing genshin, and I didn't know anything about this game aside from this game being a popular anime game.
Zhongli's demo singlehandedly brought me into liking men
18:13 (about Raiden's) "This is what Zhongli's wanted to be - I'm just saying"
Raiden's role in the story is that of the overwhelmingly powerful antagonist you have to overcome. Zhongli's role in the story is very different to that: his demo conveys power, but in a way that's more composed and elegant, as opposed to Raiden's which is more focused on being intimidating and, well, overwhelming. So no, Raiden's demo is not what Zhongli's wanted to be: Zhongli's demo is what Zhongli's wanted to be.
Raiden needs to show her powers to prove her strength while Zhongli doesnt need to show his powers to prove his strength
also i actually dont like those parts of raiden's and wanderer's trailers. they just seem out of place for me. maybe it sort of fits wanderer but raiden is also this sort of serious character
Unbiased but put pretty much every free spirited character demo on top of the lists... sure.
Every demo tailor made to match the characters personality, not to show that editor having fun or whatever. Some demo even tied to the archon quest lore. Like Itto, Ayato, Nahida.
Another example is Kokomi. I don't like her character but i enjoyed her demo since it matched her and it was really beautifully made. I would've put her on pretty solid.
But hey the "unbiased" part was half true half joke since tier lists aren't unbiased in the first place lol
Zhongli and Eula placements were sad for me.
Eula, in particular, the excitement from Mina didnt matched the placement I think haha
The arsonist, the prankster, and the fireworks maker. Sumeru needs a pyro troublemaker with an energetic trailer to complete the list.
I like how chat is collectively saying "Fair" as they realise they cannot reason with her xD
"Look at this emotes"
Followers and Subs proceed to use only cheese related emotes
Nahida was a 10 outta 10. You're looking for oomf and personality, and Nahida's demo had those, just not in the bombastic ways. It was a gentle trailer, reminiscent of the gentle god Nahida is, not to mention the music, editing, and pacing were absolutely on point.
Mina: "this video is non-biased"
Also mina: *doesnt put Kazu at first rank, puts Klee at S rank*
Me: "wow this really *is* unbiased"
?
klee at s rank is fine but she put zhongli at mid like how
@@notdio7766 It's boring, literally his gameplay+music
@@komi7051 then what you want anything more than that a whole anime? it show the lore without spoil it his personality game play music and visual is so good and this trailer from 2 year ago
@@notdio7766 And why if his trailer is old? Klee's trailer is even better than him. I dont expect that much, but his trailer could've been better ( Aka with cool transitions ) a bit less like Raiden's. Dude his demo is literally only his Gameplay+Music which is basically every 4 stars character's demo 💀
i love how the intro is klees literal first part of the demo
“Did they fire the person who made the fun trailers”
DAMN lol
L take on Zhongli's demo. Easily the best demo from the entire lot AND it perfectly encapsulates who Zhongli is.
I don't know about easily the best but it's definitely a contender for best along with a bunch of others that are lower than they should be.
I mean, I love zhongli with all my heart but there is something in his demo that's just... boring to me, don't get me wrong I don't think it's bad, but I just can't get myself to like it
tbf, his demo has aged compared to the newer ones. It's hard to still call it the best demo out of them all
@@annaairahala9462 doremy pfp W
@@annaairahala9462 Just rewatched it. Not finding it hard at all. It's still definitely top tier.
i think maybe it's just because those top 4 of 3 has a more cheerful personality ， so make you think their pv is more enjoyable
Her:oh I love albedos eng voice
His va:WELCOM TO HELL B**ch THE FOOKING AUDACITY
IM SORRY😭😭
I can't believe nahidas demo is below ganyu and fischl....
I can forgive the top tiers being oversaturated with cutesy trailers.
I can forgive Raiden's trailer being A instead of S.
I can even forgive, though bitterly, that Zhongli's trailer isn't much higher.
But putting Tighnari's trailer in MID and saying Collei's is better is a sin I CANNOT forgive. Big L for chat there, too.
W comment
I think collei's music was better than tighnari's
She is right tho... I don't think Tignari is mid... but I also don't think Collei is mid, they should have both been at least on very good
This is definitely enjoyable, glad you made it Mina. Also Faruzan theme music is just UMPPH
anyone notice a color scheme here. now that's content
zhongli will always be top 1 for me sorry mina big L, W on everything else
raiden better 🤷♂️
@Razwir Iwan yup and 90% of the community agrees
@@redacted-oo7ne No way 90% agrees. In fact, I doubt most of the community agrees.
If I would choose between the archons' demo themes
I'd definitely choose Nahida's theme is just really cute!
Especially the lalala part
i loved the intro
Just seeing childe surf the waterfall is enough to put him in ss tier.
YOU CAN SAY NO TO EVERYONE BUT NIHIDA'S TRAILER!!!!!!!!!! IT LEGIT MADE ME CRY
Why is Nahidas trailer music giving, "It's a small world after all" 😭💀
This was really interesting to see a different point of view normally eeveryone is basically the same.
Collei is treated better than Tighnari because Collei is everyone's child. We all watched her grow.
Mina when text appears on the screen: 😍😍😍
I wonder if Mina can do Honkai trailers one day they are different from genshin but they are still worth ranking
Of course, there's a massive disparity between the early ones and the later ones, both stylistically and in how much of the story they involve. The PVs only really start to includes story elements in the run-up to the Battle of Schicksal, I noticed.
Also I'm unbearably hyped for 6.3. New Bronya, even though I feel like I just got HoR's new equipment set.
@@BNuts I usually am only hyped when a new Kiana is on the market Bronya never suited me but this new one looks phenomenal
Maybe after she finishes the story. There's a few with big spoilers in it like Durandal's.
she likes fun trailer, i think arkhnigts can too. beacuse the music is so tight
@@96shinvasc I have never seen arknight trailers 👀 I would be down for that
Bruh she did zhongli dirty
Everything else aside.... Puting Zhongli on Mid should be a crime... His demo literally had a short intro, about a guy literally talking about his, meanwhile he listening pretending the story isn't about him, already says a lot, then the music popping of, the rhythm of the music and scenes not to mention the 2d dragons the put in the demo made it a full package.
It was definitely not the best ever, but I feel nothing aside from Klee and Hu Tao before Inazuma, can even compare to it
To the whole chat saying fair to every time she chose a tier, someones simping .(remember denial is a river in egypt)
One of the most enjoyable videos i´ve seen on the "Genshin Demo Reacting".
Maybe I could be very wrong, but around 2.5 to the end of Inazuma there was a lot of negativity towards Genshin in the worldwide community. Maybe it affected the enjoyment and creativity of the developers. With Sumeru they tried to make a better job, and they actually did, but at the same time some things feels more scripted. But since the waters are calmer now, maybe they were having fun again with the last 3 demos.
I think inazuma arc is where genshin had bit of controversy but still growing in popularity. They had a much better run in Sumerian arc.
Inazuma arc was overhated by far and I stand with that, I played and loved it, also was easily better than Liyue and tonnes better than Mondstadt imo
have a good christmas mina and anyone who celebrates!
that's a new meaning to biased
edit: the sumeru storyline was a bit too depressing so it reflects on the demos
If you check out fischl and keqing trailer on genshin x honkai collab their music there, it was much more of a banger
Ngl though I also loved the ones that were on top because they had so much personality in their trailers. Kinda miffed about Tighnari though. Lol I actually thoroughly enjoyed his trailer very much. He was basically high the entire time throughout that video how was that not entertaining enough.
Tier lists are always biased in some way, because they are highly subjective.
What I personally don't understand is your take after the Nahida trailer. On which metrics are you identifying that the recent trailers are not made by people anymore who loved mihoyo? Especially after you just watched the Nahida trailer.
Raiden Shogun has the best and most hype trailer to date what is this? Also, half of the good category plus Keqing and Fischl are surrounded by character trailers that significantly outclass them simply because they were seen early and all the high budget trailers came later.
alt title: Proving Entry of the gladiators is my theme song.
I agree 100% with the best demo tier tho. nobias
Did you make this tier list before Alhaitham's demo came out?🤔
also yae mako is 500+ but not up to 600 because in her ult she has 5 tails and a kitsune gains 1 tail every 100 years so she is 500 i just wanted to point that out
You should add some words behind your vid's name like [with Biased or my opinion only Etc.] so people that click onto it dont think that it's non-biased and judging from all aspects like editing / lore / Char's personality / music / release date Etc. But the vid is enjoyable thanks.
I love how the top tiers were only the people who were red, white or black
Mina will you make one for honkai?
Love your videoss
Since saw the Zhongli tier I'm not expecting the tier from now and focus on her having fun with reaction instead lol. His attack in slow looks so good. The shot with him only stands still while having his shield block enemies. The man words at the start talk about the line, and Zhongli say the line that the man trails off, followed by his cool attack and his burst. He's so calm but he can be serious if he needs to.
There are also other characters I disagree with, so called this no bias is very suspicious. Though the video is fun.
Ok you got me with that intro , let me follow you on twitch
for those characters that doesn't have a PV..... I hope they would get one in the future... but guess what???
*GENSHIN COULD NEVER*
Is it just me or do I see a pattern in s tier all being the colour red lol
I'M SORRY HOW IS RAIDEN NOT ON TOP???? NO BECAUSE THAT'S LITERALLY THE BEST TRAILER I SWEAR
The red bias is real
Yoimiya is so cute istg
I was kinda going to let it all slide till she put Eula over Zhongli and Cyno. Imo Eula's trailer is one hot steamy pile of nothing. She just kinda dances on screen, and Amber shows up at the end. Definitely not better than Zhongli and ABSOLUTELY not better than Cyno
Just here to say the intro fire though 🔥
I just really wanna say the hate she is getting in the comments about her ratings is not even worth it because mina has her opinions she tried to not be biased and i get you dont like zhongli being rated a bit bad but you have your opinions so u have no right to bash her opinion abt her ratings..
That intro was fire
this is the most bias review i have ever watch
The intro is everything 💖
EULA ASKING AMBER TO DO A BALLROOM DANCE HELLO??? EULAMBER SO REAL!!
okay, now I recommend you to watch all Honkai PV's they're FIRE
They're fire
And spoiler
WAIT WHOS THE NPC IN YAE MIKO’S?? IS THAT KUKI’S SISTER BECAUSE KUKI’S SISTER IS IN LOVE WITH YAE MIKO!!
It feels like i found my total opposite when seeing this list, I'm interested gonna subscribe 😂
The queen made a new post
I agree with the Tier list but i’m still salty about Ganyu rating but it’s fine lol
eiyo did you get Lyra?
just like Aponia her 3* skin is smokin hot
Definitely have a certain taste.
Yelans coming back are you gonna pull for her bc you should she’s op and awesome
qiqi trailer is what got me interested in the game
nah she is bias to char that looks like her avatar😂
Ain't no way Ayato's trailer is in the same tier as Xiangling
unbiased huh.
Ahh yes albedo and his flying saucer
please do more of this ^^
to me, the TRUE scaramouche and faruzan "demo" is the one who's in the trailer from 3.3.... its so good and aaaaaahhhh
Zhongli place made me angry at Mina for the first time😤😂
there's no way to see the vod of this huh ?
When is mom going to react to the new characters??
That Kokomi place broke my heart XD but its ok its your taste after all^^
But yao yao has a trailer / demo
Would've moved Wanderer and Raiden to S tier then moved Zhongli to the lowest point of A tier, but everything else I can completely agree with.
Even Keqing and Fischl being as high as they are with such brief and basic trailers?
@@Syntherus Yes, Fischl's trailer truly shows of her personality and even the small edits in the character demo help express her skills/character, which is how most demos should be. Keqing's does the same, showing her skills/character, I'm just not sure if I wouldve placed keqing that high.
sure lmao Zhongli to the lowest point of A tier when it sits on top of the genshin channel's most viewed video and perfectly incapsulates the culture, theming and personality of the character. Screw off.
@@dragoneater2596 mate some people have opinions
@@smashedgravy And some people can disagree with your opinion. Nothing wrong with that
I think Amber actually has a demo, though it’s just her getting carried by xiao
Welcome to another episode of my strange bias
That intro is so fire LOL
Based Zhongli take 👑👑👑
People are so mad because you have a different opinion from them it's so dumb haha, I disagree with some of your placements from my perspective but ain't gonna complain like others have haha
Yeah.. She did said that it will be controversial placement for some of the placement.. From my own opinion, of course I would differ from her (surprisingly not really much differences, maybe just less than 5 demos that i might beg to differ, but it all because from my own bias as well xD). But from what im trying to understand, Mina has tendency to rank the demo purely from how she is feeling engaged when watching the video demo, hence why she leans towards the more upbeat, comedic, fun demo, not easily swoon over by beautiful visual, animation, music, etc. From that, I can agree with most of her choice, in fact, I can guess all her placement correctly (incorrect guess only by one tier above or below, also she herself have a change midway in the video as well haha).. But it's all good. I like this kind of video from her. It really scream Mina xD
We only have to know that, we all free to agree or disagree. It's fine if we don't like her tier list, complain is also fine. I mean everyone has their own preferences and we can do nothing much about it.. But the point is, I won't force Mina to change just to suit my taste if I disagree with her. It's her choice and I truly respect that. Keep up the great work Mina, Ganbare
Plzzz anyone tell me how can I make animated character like in this video
Totally biased
But hey this is someone opinion so i can do nothing about it
im so proude to be a yoimiya main rn
Faruzan theme stomps, 13/10
Man I love discont hu tao's videos always much wow
I cannot comprehend how klee's demo is any better than raiden when you can clearly see where mihoyo dump all their budget for character demos at....there is more that i would argue with the tier list but one thing that i 100% agree with is that kaeya's and aloy's demo are just.....BAD
i probably disagree with 80% of her tier list lmao except for the SSS she chose. I think we can let her (sometimes) unbased opinion go just for that lol
My favourite character is Venti and damnnnn they did him dirty
the bias wrench chat lol
Love the intro
Putting raiden anywhere else but not S tier is criminal
Damn your model is fire fr🔥
this funny reading comment where people madly for their archon rating kekw