I respect this man.. But accept the reality that RAW was also there and they were not running a charity organization.... You people were also there for your own interest and simple is that you LOSS and ISI WON
True. As an indian, I'm not happy at the way things have turned out. But there's absolutely no denying that pakistani agencies have come out on top here - full marks to them.
Let's wait 2 years and see how much 'love' taliban will have remaining for Pakistan :) India wasn't doing anything in Afg/pak, proof is the fact that you just had a blast in balochistan on Chinese, even when there are no Indians left in Afg. In fact a taliban fully in control of Afg can be good for India in many ways : - you won't have any leverage on Afg any more. Taliban won't be in your control - US won't be easy on you, as they won't need your airspace and bases for Afg any more. And the aid money will end too. Sanctions may come. - you will have to front the bill for whatever happens in afg now - Durand line issue - TTP - isis-k - you are not the only player there - now China, Iran, Russia will all jostle for power and control in that region Indians are in fact happy..
Oh boy; the Indian media so confused and helpless, it is comical to look at their desperation. Indian TV program are littered with paradoxes. There is no doubt that Taliban and Pakistan have won, and India, Israel, and NATO have lost, big time.
India, Israel nato and USA are not one faction. Indo-israeli relationship is formal at best. India never even let NATO close and indo US relationship is quid pro quo. To put it simply.
I think war is not over yet. Only thing that changed is scenario. It's true that western power has left as well as lost the war but Islamic state & Amarulla Saleh have filled the place which western power left. The biggest question is How will Taliban run the government in Afghanistan. Because neither Talban have experience nor they have money. Second question is who will provide them money?? Because Pakistan don't have capacity to assist Taliban financially. China has no interest in benevolence/welfare activities, they only recognise buisness & profit. So it will be difficult for China to deal with Taliban. Third question is, Does Taliban have any credibility in international community?? Because even if world Community decide to recognise Taliban government yet it will be difficult to co-operate with them, because taliban are not civilized, and they will never abandon militant idiology. So it is clear that western power are the looser but Taliban is not the winner. Picture is not clear in Afghanistan. I guess it will take time to clear the scenario in Afghanistan. kistan
@@anoopshukla9375 India is the biggest looser not western world. You are simply beating around the bush to cover up Indian humiliating defeat at the hands of Taliban. Grapes seem to be sour. Ironically your vision of Afghanistan is still blurry. Indian presence in Afghanistan was not for humanitarian work but to create another permanent hot front for Pakistan. You lost billions mate. Pakistan has assured UN uninterrupted supply of food and essential items to Afghanistan. At present many of our industrial units produce exclusively for Afghanistan. For example, A good number of flour mills operate for Afghan market. If we cannot give them cash we can provide them goods and services on deferred payment basis. Other neighbors will also provide financial assistance after recognition. Western world will have no option but to recognize Taliban Government. All Afghan neighbors ( India is not a neighbor) China, Russia, Iran, Pakistan and Central Asian countries are going to recognize and Afghanistan will become a darling of the region. Afghanistan is a gateway to Central Asia. China has planned investment of 60 billion dollars. Russians have also committed to develop Afghanistan. A new era of peace and development is emerging. Don't underestimate Afghans. They know how to run the country and eliminate crimes from the society. Neighbors will provide expertise if needed. They will run the state better than many of the 195 sovereign states. You should not have any qualms for Afghanistan. You are pinning your hopes on Amar Ullah Saleh. Actually, son of Ahmed Shah Masood matters and he is negotiating with Taliban for bigger role in power sharing. Saleh will be finally eliminated. All neighbors are playing their role to bring peace between different factions. Anoop Shukla it is time for Indians, Americans and NATO to lick their wounds. Your game is up.
@@ziaullahkhan3228 well said my brother. Very good points made here on the few comments. I just wished each nation would focus on bettering their own conditions and for their people and do goodwill for others as possible and not meddle with or derail other nations to fulfill their own agendas. I live in the west (USA) and love this country as well as my homeland. I can speak from experience that whether it be America, Pakistan, Afghanistan or India, people deserve better and are wonderful. It is the damn politicians and bureaucrats everywhere who ruin it for their own citizens as well as other nations. I hope and pray that one day people of a nation hold these things and thief's accountable. Aameen.
Forget ISI. This time the Taliban have full support of China, Russia, Qatar, Turkey and even Iran! Why do you think USA ran away so fast! Indians love to give credit to ISI only.
@Red River بھائی آپ کی آسانی کے لیے اردو میں لکھ دے رہا ہوں تا کے آپ الٹا مطلب نہ نکالیں ۔ یہ انڈین میڈیا ہر وقت ISI کے گن گاتا رہتا ہے۔ حلانکے طالبان کو چین ،روس وغیرہ کی مکمل سپورٹ حاصل تھی۔ اتنا بڑا دوحہ میں دفتر نہیں نظر آتا انکو جہاں یہ تمام دنیا سے ملاقات کر رہے۔ ۔
As if, if evidences given there will be prosecution.....sugar is sweet.....given to someone and he says he can't say it's sweet becoz may be tastebuds to recognize sweet is damaged...for every evidence one can find counter-evidence.......find and replace ISI with RAW! may be
Karan is good anchor but in this interview he has shown that he was trying to build negative role of ISI by dragging ISI in his questions. Mr Banarjee candid comments are appreciable.
Soon Bannerjee finished each of his sentence, Karan repeatedly adding “So Pakistanj and ISI were supporting them arming them training them funding them” 😂
@@aanakrukavi And India is kicked out of Afghanistan and Iran after spending billions .By the way their FM practically lives in Iran begging them to grant their previous project which are now in China ‘s hands .
Generally Thapar is fair as an anchor.This interview shows that he is not onlly biased but full of hatred for Pakistan.Unfortunte to see him change probably due fall of Afghanistan which he could not digest.
Thapar isn't biased. He has profound knowledge of Afganistan and the military being the son of a former Army Chief. This interview is a comprehensive analysis of events.
Wrong is wrong. Right is right. Those that have committed atrocities must surely pay the price. Individuals should not take sides. Call a spade a spade
14:50 Jafferabad is ouside Quetta :))) Jafferabad is on Sindh-Balochistan border which is around 300 KMs away from Quetta and even more away from Afghanistan. If RAW chief's knowledge is of this level then what to say about their Bhakhats :))
Came here to comment the same thing about University town Peshawar. University Town Peshawar is right in the heart of Peshawar rather than on the outskirts. And interestingly University Town was famous for housing many Blackwater agents and some foreign embassies rather than Taliban. Previously many dignitaries of the city used to live in University Town as it was considered a very Posh area.
@9:42 Rana Banerji clearly mentioning "the refugee camps" along the borders of Afghanistan and Mr. Thapar twisted it and repeated "found sanctuaries". The learned journalist can differentiate between the two. What a shame and the disgusting role he is playing here, not only putting his words into the guest's mouth and also twisting what the RAW officer is sharing.
First let's stop mob lynching in the country, let's protect women/ girls and let's safeguard democracy in the country. Let's talk about religions politics which is destroying nations image internationally. After this we will talk about Afghanistan
Ye Wire Chu tiya h .Inhe Nahi Pata Pak Army America ki golam h .American Pak Army hi Pakistan me Chinese ko zahnum bheajwa rahi h .Aur America ka Order follow kar rahi h .Jo Pak Army Dollars ke Liye apne 4000+ Punjabi Al- Qada bol ke America ko sell kar choki h Wo American Dollars ke liye CPEC destroy & Chinese ko Chor de gi 😂. China pata nahi kon si Friend ship nibha raha h pappu ban ke 😁. American Pak Army Chinese ko zahnum bheje ja rahi h aur China ko sorry bole ja rahi h 😂😂😂😂
A Indian defence analyst recently said the following Indian raw was in Afghanistan and so was the Pakistani isi, when the The Taliban came back into power meant the pakistanis have won
I would like you to repeat according to current t scenario. Seems like pakistan on backfoot, terror attacks in pak , afg-pak dispute doesn't seem like this type of scenario ISI wanted
@@bhavyasinghchib9480 Misdirection What the eyes see, and the ears hear, the mind believes, The Indian news channels are constantly talking about Pakistan to keep Indians minds away from what is actually happening in Arunachel Pradesh, The Chinese army has walked almost 20 km into Indian territory and is currently sitting comfortably in tawang district, This is according to Rahul Gandhi
Thappar has turned this interview into a propaganda against issi , it is intellectual dishonesty , he did not asked a single question about Raw role in this scenario.
60% time of interview is Pakistan+ ISI. HEHEHE Long story short: Pakistan against other all countries agencies were in war at battle ground of Afghanistan who wins no need to tell.
If the interviewer is so smart then he would have pointed out his points years ago rather than celebrating Moodi's actions. Too late to blame now. India has been brutally lost against Pakistan in Afghanistan
...modi does what he likes - he is averse to hearing the truth since modi likes to create truth from his magic jhola of fiction to bully not only thr nation but the world at large
@@uzochiokeke4328 Agreed. My personal opinion is that Taliban is smarter now even if they are unlikely to change their way of governance .If they are reaching out to India , it is advantage Afghanistan .
I didn't know Karan graduated from Arnab School of Journalism. Instead of having a meaningful conversation with the guest, he simply wanted him to endorse his preconceived notions. SHAMEFUL!!
Its quite strange that it is the first time I have seen or heard from Mr. Rana Banerji even when he is such a highly intellectual person with rational and in-depth knowledge of the matter. I wish more and more of such true speaking and rationally knowledgeable people come out in the light. Thank you Mr. Thaapar for bringing this truly learned person on your show..! An absolutely crucial and highly informative interview that provides eye opening information..!!
@saurabh grover. The best person to ask about is former ISI major retired Amir. He was the contact person of ISI with taliban & other groups in Afghanistan. Just a few weeks ago he gave an interview to a Pakistani journalist, which he uploaded on his youtube channel. That was the most detailed insight & now this person is telling the same thing with some lesser extent which he didn't knew just a few weeks ago. 😂😂😂
It’ was very confused interview… the guest does not know much about Taliban, ISI and their connection … he is making assumptions with vague information … anyways I think it was a way to make Indian government and public happy …
The Indian audience was constantly tired of watching liars and fighting anchors and guests. Today thay all are very happy to hear a polite and sensible conversation.thats why they are praising so much . (Chacha Biden😁😁).
Yeah I agree and he belongs not to andabakt ( using andabakt on purpose because they make India zero with their zero thinking and India Pakistan hindu Muslim agenda which creates a sharp division in the society an irreparable loss to India) This man has awesome integrity. Rspect love and peace to Mr. Benarji and Karan Sir..
The interviewer came with a script and wanted it endorsed by the honorable guest in a hurried manner, kind of disrespectful. Well we can have some conclusions. Firstly, the Taliban were not created by ISI. Secondly ISI played alongside Taliban while RAW sided with the Northern alliance which certainly was openly helped by the CIA. Thirdly both the CIA and RAW had 20 years to achieve their goals and had enough resources and technology. The sudden collapse of the Afghan government is a clear failure of CIA and Pentagon. Soon the American people will raise this question. We may see some corruption stories in the US. Fourthly the Afghan rulers were never sincere and honest to the nation. The foot soldiers refused to fight for a corrupt regime. Lastly, the NATO members would never trust the US again. Except for the UK maybe.
interview could be for 22 minutes if the host would not repeat everything after Rana Banerji, it seems host was not believing Rana G as Rana G lying to him
At the beginning I thought, we are talking abt Homeland Season 3, where Carry mathison was trying to do good. But at later stage of the interview, Karan was enforcing ideas, while the Interviewee was replying and sharing his views with "may be" , could be, should be.
I thought I'll learn a thing or two but this interview like shooting darts in the dark. For starters Bannerji is treating the Pashtun tribal hierarchy like the Hindu caste system, which is simply laughable. Secondly , Afghan Taliban are portrayed as having no brains if their own. There is no nuance here, as in how Pakistani Pashtuns in the Army and ISI have an incomparable understanding of the ground situation and reality. Either R&AW sitting 1000s of miles away iss taking random guesses and connecting invisible dots, or this interview is a deliberate attempt to portray ignorance and mislead those watching that RAW knows nothing about what goes between ISI and the Taliban. The cluelessness is comfortabing to watch but should be treated as a deliberate ploy.
@@bittertruth6723 your first time with the English language or something? I said I did not write what I wrote towards the dumb video I was acknowledging the person you seem so vigorous to defend. haha your having fun with the English language?
@@AHR671 xactly....but he is taking interview....interview is about listening.....no one knows for sure what will happen in Afg.....at end interviwee gets so irritated that he says ur asking a desk anaylist who have retired 10 yrs back...😁
One of the most wonderful interview. Karan - if you could not pushed your agenda and ignorance on topic, this could have a little more better. One of the most knowledgeable personal I have seen on this topic.
All credit to gentleman from intelligence. Thappar tried his best to spin his words but the answers he gave exposed him very well. His statements “yes this is a way to look at it” tells it all
@@hasanbilgrami7945 I think China can transform Afghanistan with world class infrastructures in a very short time without firing a bullet that too in 1/12th cost.Pakistan and India can play their part minus politics.
@@anilbera9499 Pakistan is actually not at advantage. Yes but India with Modi is on a very big disadvantage, reason being instead of have back channel with Taliban he quoted and media quoted them terrorists. Mind it , India is only country who refuse to negotiate while Israel even contacted Taliban. If US can with whom they were in war , why not India ???
They discussed every thing. But they didn't discussed 80,000 sacrifices of pakistani peoples & 150 billion dollar loss to the economy in a war which have nothing to do with pakistan
i gone and verified all comments from muslims , in all other news of karan they support karan and wire views but when they talk about pakisran all indian muslims taking sides of pakisran and afghanistan and islamic state. Each and every comment of muslims i seen all their profiles and many are from India and u must know EYE is watching all.
You are right. Thapar thinks he is most knowledgeable! Still live in Congress patronage. He is a joke but got favours from Congress is waning and he is not a worth. People like him should disappear and enjoy retirement and their luxury lifestyle. Indians have moved on.
it is so irritating when Karan Thapar keeps interjecting and does not allow Mr Banerji to complete. We are interested in expert talking and not interviewer. Please dont treat audience as dumb and seek clarifications every 30 seconds.
Haha it's a quick-paced interviewing style which is his signature. He does not fawn over guests like fanboys "omg you were from raw, now you keep talking, i will just drool and make air kisses".. karan is mostly hated by people who ardently support the present day bjp. Besides that his guests dont seem to have a problem with the style.
Thapar : SO ISI IS VERY VERY BAD Rana RAW: YES BAD Thapar: SO ISI WE NEED TO DESTROY Rana RAW YES DESTROY Thapar: SO YOU ARE EXPERT AND KNOW EVERYTHING HOW TO THIS Rana RAW: YES EXPERT Thapar: OK THANK YOU INTERVIEW. Rana RAW: YES INTERVIEW.
Know the difference between obsession and facts. People all over the world need to know the truth. Both USA and Pakistan are responsible for the current refugee crisis in Afghanistan. And the corruption of Afghan government too. I don’t care about what politicians and powerful governments do or say. But people suffering is a humanitarian problem and therefore it concerns us all. FYI These journalists are not Indian government friendly therefore it’s not government propaganda. This is critical thinking that needs engagement of everyone’s brains. Only then solutions can be found. More chaos means more disturbance. Nobody wants that.
Even though Karan seemed a little biased against the ISI and Pakistan in this interview, I would still say that it was a well-conducted interview. The interviewee was quite knowledgeable and I actually learned something from this. I feel it was time well spent. Thanks from across the border!!
They failed to mention (?due to interruption by the anchor) that before Taliban came/were brought to power, A DECADE LONG gorilla war had been going on between Afghan war lords, or the jihadis who had fought and defeated Russian invasion! Taliban DIDN'T START WAR, BUT HAD STOPPED IT.
Not expecting a staged interview Mr Thapar, at 12:00 you jump to create ttp without adding the word funded and gathered by Indian to attack pakistan and created ttp
Even if that were true Tanveer, why would they stage an interview for average Indian viewer? We anyway think India is good, pakistan is bad. Adrian Levy's book also says what you are saying. But it says that staged stuff is done to create a clean image for india and bad image for pakistan in the West. I dont think western viewers are watching the Wire.
@@rdc515 well dear because they want to please a common Indian and sow the seed of Pakistan and Taliban Islam hate in your mind so you always whenever see a Pakistani or Muslim or Taliban you would see them with suspicion and think them. Bad as this sort off propaganda help Indian state to hide their failures in shadow of nationalism gab
@@HassanAli-xl8kr i agree about such tactics but the Wire is not considered by any pro govt indian to be a patriotic channel 😂 in any case, i have friends in Pak and dont see everyone with suspicion, however it is not false that a large number of Pakistanis also hate India, and those in ISI are trained to destroy India just as those here in India are trained to destroy Pakistan. Someday they both retire and start meeting in London and Bangkok for scotch and whiskey. I also don't suspect Taliban, it is pretty clear that they want Afghanistan to remain in the 15th century and its women as men's slaves. If islam says ban music, why isnt music banned in Pakistan or UAE or Saudi or Jordan? It seems only Taliban are true Muslims and others are just trying to be Muslim. If taliban is so great, why dont Pakistani boys and girls migrate to Afghanistan?
@@rdc515 well Afghanistan will have ideal system but when it come Pakistan all Indian news outlets get hostile toward us and all Pakistanis do not hate Indians that much like Indians hate us all godi media all Indian polticans just say bad about Pakistan even in City Council elections Indian sells name of Pakistan so it says lot
I should appreciate the intel guys professionalism and unbias in the answering. He did not malign taliban just because he doesn't subscribe to their ideas amd values. This is rare to see in India. He honestly said the origin of taliban was for a good cause of ending extortions etc. He also honestly mentioned that ISI may not have been that much instrumental in fall of Kabul this time and much of it was due to low morale of ANA. And it is highly appreciable that the intel guy didnt mix up his personal opinions as facts, but distinguished them well. As regards Mr Thapar, he played like a typical Indian anchor this time.
Fantastic Interview. Rana Banerjee has incredibly encyclopedic details. I like his caveats noww and then while somewhat irritatingly Karan tends to pin him down to some binaries.
Mr. Bannerjee knows more than Taliban and ISI than Taliban and ISI themselves 😂 the way he is answering every question feels like Taliban and ISI used to take him everywhere as their cameraman and reporter!! Applause 👏👏
Thoroughly enjoyed this interview. Although I believe some points needed more explanation and a few more questions could have been asked but still it was the best discussion on this issue I've heard. I wish all news programmes in India/Pakistan were like this, our people would learn to think and question instead of being brainwashed by the media.
To be honest the guest answered too appropriately. Unfortunately for Karan, he answered all of his wished anticipations in "may be". Clearly, India had a very big set back in Afghanistan. Throughout this discussion, Karan never asked a question about what RAW has been doing in Afghanistan for 20 years? All of that is because it was irrelevant? Oh man, even 20 years were not enough for you to influence Taliban and other factions.
15th August will be remembered as day when Indian puppets surrender in Kabul Afghanistan with out a fight biggest surrender in history of modern world as Indian army trained Afghan national Army surrender
@@kamlipaul8498 The best person to ask about is former ISI major retired Amir. He was the contact person of ISI with taliban & other groups in Afghanistan. Just a few weeks ago he gave an interview to a Pakistani journalist, which he uploaded on his youtube channel. That was the most detailed insight & now this former RAW chief is telling the same thing with some lesser extent which he didn't knew just a few weeks ago. 😂😂😂
This is one of the better interviews of Karan. Of course, when he is not discussing Modi, Karan is quite fine and bearable. Thanks to Mr. Banerjee, we have an excellent overview of the situation on the ground. Thankfully, Karan allowed him to speak freely! The conclusion is of course that we have to wait and see what happens there!!
Each and every leader of every group even the ppl in the govt are always well connected to Pakistan even if they are speaking against the Govt of Pakistan because of some policies. Hamid Karzai also lived in Pakistan. Even today his relatives are here in Pakistan. Same is the story for other Afghan leaders. We have a very deep connection, just like brothers who sometimes even fight agressively but at the end of the day sit togather and sort out everything.
Indians are not making anyone fool but themselves, I am happy for their wrong beliefs, in any India and Pakistan war such attitude will only help Pakistan, but I am must congratulate Indians on their capacity of digesting international hazeemat on such a large scale
So far I haven't seen even one analyst on Indian media who talks about Afghanistan and it makes sense... Regarding Afghanistan, Indian anchors and guests live in utopian world
Interesting interview from other side of the table. First time two Indians were not shouting their lungs out on Pak Afghan subject. However they were reluctant to discuss the Indian failure in Afghanistan.
I loved this interview... FULL STOP. The interviewer stayed in TOTAL command by doing ~80% of the talking. He did an excellent job of "interpreting" Mr. Bannergee with crafty "in other words" and the slick "as you said" or "as we have established." He caught Mr. Bannergee contradicting himself and towards the end even gave him a sharp scolding as he was trying to "confuse us" by saying things that could have clouded our judgement. Awesome journalism.
I thought this will be a non biased interview wish if this gentleman had shared these facts with the US army then today things would have been different; Karan give right facts to the audience that India has lost another war with the help of these illusionist type of officials
But current scenario points towards taliban against pak and terror attacks on wide scale in pak , also pak-afg border dispute is escalating. DON'T SEE HOW INDIA LOST...on the other pak lost.
Mr. Thapur, please do not start off the interview by making an accusation that everyone knows about this or that. Ask the question and let the expert answer.
Every time I watch a talk show on the current situation in Afghanistan and the Taliban take over and with all the uncertainties and confusions surrounding this country, there is only one thing that is certain, that ISI must be a very professional institution to have achieved all this, of course rights and wrongs beside.
🇮🇳 seems to be always on losing side as far as 🇦🇫 is concerned. When Soviet invaded 🇦🇫, India stood with Russia, result Zero . Similarly 🇮🇳 stood with 🇺🇸 and Puppet Afghan Govt , but result was again BIG ZERO. The consequence of this time BIG ZERO is indian govt is doing privatisation and assets being leased out for generation of cash
Would love to audience another program, where perhaps you fellows can talk about how RAW cooked butter chicken down there for twenty years & Since it's all bloody over please leave no khulbushan behind in your yaps.
Banerjee is absolutely brilliant on his assessments on each and every issue, he seems to know everything that is going on in Afghanistan Pakistan the ISI etc. like the back of his hand, this has been a riveting interview and Karan Thapar is as always on the top of his game
India should be ashamed of bringing up a coward Afhhan Army who couldn't even fire a bullet and ran away faster than Usain Bolt. Taliban swept the country by storm. Seen the difference in training?
Muslim taliban has decisively defeated hindu taliban. Shame on Indian intelligence, military its equipments, its training and its political leadership/ diplomats.
@ Aman Pasha. Where was this knowledgeable person a months ago? This whole story about Taliban told Major Amir of ISI 2 weeks ago in an interview with Rauf Klasra. Now after hearing that interview of major Amir I am also one of very knowledgeable person about Taliban😂😂😂
When Ajit Doval talk about funding terrorist outfits in Pakistan, he meant funding TTP as well. Why dont u talk about Indian state sponsored terrorism in Pakistan by using Afghanistan safe heavens.
I respect this man..
But accept the reality that RAW was also there and they were not running a charity organization....
You people were also there for your own interest and simple is that you LOSS and ISI WON
True. As an indian, I'm not happy at the way things have turned out. But there's absolutely no denying that pakistani agencies have come out on top here - full marks to them.
@@arvinds1538
As a Pakistani I feel there's little to celebrate with this supposed victory
Let's wait 2 years and see how much 'love' taliban will have remaining for Pakistan :)
India wasn't doing anything in Afg/pak, proof is the fact that you just had a blast in balochistan on Chinese, even when there are no Indians left in Afg.
In fact a taliban fully in control of Afg can be good for India in many ways :
- you won't have any leverage on Afg any more. Taliban won't be in your control
- US won't be easy on you, as they won't need your airspace and bases for Afg any more. And the aid money will end too. Sanctions may come.
- you will have to front the bill for whatever happens in afg now
- Durand line issue
- TTP
- isis-k
- you are not the only player there - now China, Iran, Russia will all jostle for power and control in that region
Indians are in fact happy..
@@mrgyani wait and watch 😁
@@mrgyani you really think isi Pakistan didn't considered and evaluatied all the scenarios what will or could happen in future then you are a fool man
Oh boy; the Indian media so confused and helpless, it is comical to look at their desperation.
Indian TV program are littered with paradoxes. There is no doubt that Taliban and Pakistan have won, and India, Israel, and NATO have lost, big time.
India, Israel nato and USA are not one faction.
Indo-israeli relationship is formal at best.
India never even let NATO close and indo US relationship is quid pro quo.
To put it simply.
I think war is not over yet. Only thing that changed is scenario. It's true that western power has left as well as lost the war but Islamic state & Amarulla Saleh have filled the place which western power left.
The biggest question is How will Taliban run the government in Afghanistan. Because neither Talban have experience nor they have money.
Second question is who will provide them money??
Because Pakistan don't have capacity to assist Taliban financially.
China has no interest in benevolence/welfare activities, they only recognise buisness & profit. So it will be difficult for China to deal with Taliban.
Third question is, Does Taliban have any credibility in international community?? Because even if world
Community decide to recognise Taliban government yet it will be difficult to co-operate with them, because taliban are not civilized, and they will never abandon militant idiology.
So it is clear that western power are the looser but Taliban is not the winner.
Picture is not clear in Afghanistan.
I guess it will take time to clear the scenario in Afghanistan.
kistan
@@anoopshukla9375 India is the biggest looser not western world. You are simply beating around the bush to cover up Indian humiliating defeat at the hands of Taliban. Grapes seem to be sour.
Ironically your vision of Afghanistan is still blurry.
Indian presence in Afghanistan was not for humanitarian work but to create another permanent hot front for Pakistan. You lost billions mate.
Pakistan has assured UN uninterrupted supply of food and essential items to Afghanistan. At present many of our industrial units produce exclusively for Afghanistan. For example, A good number of flour mills operate for Afghan market. If we cannot give them cash we can provide them goods and services on deferred payment basis. Other neighbors will also provide financial assistance after recognition.
Western world will have no option but to recognize Taliban Government. All Afghan neighbors ( India is not a neighbor) China, Russia, Iran, Pakistan and Central Asian countries are going to recognize and Afghanistan will become a darling of the region. Afghanistan is a gateway to Central Asia. China has planned investment of 60 billion dollars. Russians have also committed to develop Afghanistan. A new era of peace and development is emerging.
Don't underestimate Afghans. They know how to run the country and eliminate crimes from the society. Neighbors will provide expertise if needed. They will run the state better than many of the 195 sovereign states. You should not have any qualms for Afghanistan.
You are pinning your hopes on Amar Ullah Saleh. Actually, son of Ahmed Shah Masood matters and he is negotiating with Taliban for bigger role in power sharing. Saleh will be finally eliminated. All neighbors are playing their role to bring peace between different factions.
Anoop Shukla it is time for Indians, Americans and NATO to lick their wounds. Your game is up.
@@anoopshukla9375 NO worries they will run their govt just like Modi and Yogi...
@@ziaullahkhan3228 well said my brother. Very good points made here on the few comments. I just wished each nation would focus on bettering their own conditions and for their people and do goodwill for others as possible and not meddle with or derail other nations to fulfill their own agendas. I live in the west (USA) and love this country as well as my homeland. I can speak from experience that whether it be America, Pakistan, Afghanistan or India, people deserve better and are wonderful. It is the damn politicians and bureaucrats everywhere who ruin it for their own citizens as well as other nations. I hope and pray that one day people of a nation hold these things and thief's accountable. Aameen.
Thapar: ISI, ISI , ISI
Mr Banarjee: It Could Be, Its Possible, No Clear Evidence.. Why Talk if you can't surely comment...
Mr Thapar trying really hard to put his word into RAW officer's mouth but failed miserably. sad face of journalism.
Forget ISI. This time the Taliban have full support of China, Russia, Qatar, Turkey and even Iran! Why do you think USA ran away so fast! Indians love to give credit to ISI only.
@Red River بھائی آپ کی آسانی کے لیے اردو میں لکھ دے رہا ہوں تا کے آپ الٹا مطلب نہ نکالیں ۔ یہ انڈین میڈیا ہر وقت ISI کے گن گاتا رہتا ہے۔ حلانکے طالبان کو چین ،روس وغیرہ کی مکمل سپورٹ حاصل تھی۔ اتنا بڑا دوحہ میں دفتر نہیں نظر آتا انکو جہاں یہ تمام دنیا سے ملاقات کر رہے۔ ۔
As if, if evidences given there will be prosecution.....sugar is sweet.....given to someone and he says he can't say it's sweet becoz may be tastebuds to recognize sweet is damaged...for every evidence one can find counter-evidence.......find and replace ISI with RAW! may be
The tragedy today is, idiots are too sure of themselves, while intelligent are in doubt.
1 Col Tarar Trained the whole Taliban...and the whole of NATO weren't able to train Afghan Army? Logic RIP !!!
Hahahahahah, well said Afradi Sahib 😊🙏
Where is this Col we need send him to Kashmir 😅😅
pehle to aapne ghabrana nahin hey
Very nice and accurate, Sajid
By your logic US shud have never lost in Vietnam and Iraq, and USSR and British in Afghanistan.
Come in reality bro.
Karan is good anchor but in this interview he has shown that he was trying to build negative role of ISI by dragging ISI in his questions. Mr Banarjee candid comments are appreciable.
Very neutral comment from you.
I appreciate you to have clarity of observation.
True Mr. Thapar is desperately trying to implicate ISI and Pakistan but Mr.Bannerji is sticking to facts.
Soon Bannerjee finished each of his sentence, Karan repeatedly adding “So Pakistanj and ISI were supporting them arming them training them funding them” 😂
He sticks himself to the topic.
Indian ko next 100 years be samaj nahi aye ge kay ISI kya cheaz ha lol
@@muhammadijaz2387 That's why we beat u in 1971,Kargil and u r in FATF.
...this is unbiased for he is not a protigee of the GOI
@@aanakrukavi And India is kicked out of Afghanistan and Iran after spending billions .By the way their FM practically lives in Iran begging them to grant their previous project which are now in China ‘s hands .
Generally Thapar is fair as an anchor.This interview shows that he is not onlly biased but full of hatred for Pakistan.Unfortunte to see him change probably due fall of Afghanistan which he could not digest.
Taliban is now nightmare for Indian govt. :D
He is also an Indian so he will be biased because of his national interests
Thapar isn't biased. He has profound knowledge of Afganistan and the military being the son of a former Army Chief. This interview is a comprehensive analysis of events.
A fair way to put it is to say that ISI fared better. No hatred is needed.
Wrong is wrong. Right is right. Those that have committed atrocities must surely pay the price. Individuals should not take sides. Call a spade a spade
14:50 Jafferabad is ouside Quetta :))) Jafferabad is on Sindh-Balochistan border which is around 300 KMs away from Quetta and even more away from Afghanistan. If RAW chief's knowledge is of this level then what to say about their Bhakhats :))
Also university town was formed in 70,s or 80’s in Peshawar while he is saying after 9/11
😂😂😂
Jafferabad is just 120 Km away from Quetta
Came here to comment the same thing about University town Peshawar. University Town Peshawar is right in the heart of Peshawar rather than on the outskirts. And interestingly University Town was famous for housing many Blackwater agents and some foreign embassies rather than Taliban. Previously many dignitaries of the city used to live in University Town as it was considered a very Posh area.
@@AliSherrr @Shakeel Ahmed Exactly, and imagine this person being head of an intelligence agency.. :)
I just Loved seeing Modi's running out of Afghanistan with Tail between thier legs.... It was like.... Dhobi Ka Kuta Na Ghar Ka Na Ghat Ka.
U nailed it
Modi is singing song:
Jan bachi so lakhoon paye
Lot k budho ghar ko aye
hahaha amazing sir
So thats what you want.
@@gshrdy5415 if a swaggerer slips on banana peel, onlookers laugh more than on slipping of a Gentleman.
@9:42 Rana Banerji clearly mentioning "the refugee camps" along the borders of Afghanistan and Mr. Thapar twisted it and repeated "found sanctuaries". The learned journalist can differentiate between the two. What a shame and the disgusting role he is playing here, not only putting his words into the guest's mouth and also twisting what the RAW officer is sharing.
First let's stop mob lynching in the country, let's protect women/ girls and let's safeguard democracy in the country. Let's talk about religions politics which is destroying nations image internationally. After this we will talk about Afghanistan
Ye Wire Chu tiya h .Inhe Nahi Pata Pak Army America ki golam h .American Pak Army hi Pakistan me Chinese ko zahnum bheajwa rahi h .Aur America ka Order follow kar rahi h .Jo Pak Army Dollars ke Liye apne 4000+ Punjabi Al- Qada bol ke America ko sell kar choki h Wo American Dollars ke liye CPEC destroy & Chinese ko Chor de gi 😂. China pata nahi kon si Friend ship nibha raha h pappu ban ke 😁. American Pak Army Chinese ko zahnum bheje ja rahi h aur China ko sorry bole ja rahi h 😂😂😂😂
Well said sir
@@amanverma4843 is seems to be pseudo Pakistani created by propaganda cells established by RAW
Well said
Very true
A Indian defence analyst recently said the following
Indian raw was in Afghanistan and so was the Pakistani isi, when the The Taliban came back into power meant the pakistanis have won
Pakistan has won the war against India in Afghanistan
The party of Allah will always win. Alhamdulilah
Say that again
I would like you to repeat according to current t scenario. Seems like pakistan on backfoot, terror attacks in pak , afg-pak dispute doesn't seem like this type of scenario ISI wanted
@@bhavyasinghchib9480
Misdirection
What the eyes see, and the ears hear, the mind believes,
The Indian news channels are constantly talking about Pakistan to keep Indians minds away from what is actually happening in Arunachel Pradesh,
The Chinese army has walked almost 20 km into Indian territory and is currently sitting comfortably in tawang district,
This is according to Rahul Gandhi
Salamn Khan need to make another “Tiger zinda Hai” sequel from what Banrjee and Karan discuss.
hahahahahahahahaa
🤣😅🤣😅🤣
Being a Pakistani, I would say that MR.Banerji is well aware of the grounds and roots of Taliban.
Thappar has turned this interview into a propaganda against issi , it is intellectual dishonesty , he did not asked a single question about Raw role in this scenario.
60% time of interview is Pakistan+ ISI. HEHEHE
Long story short:
Pakistan against other all countries agencies were in war at battle ground of Afghanistan who wins no need to tell.
isn't ISI in power since decades
If the interviewer is so smart then he would have pointed out his points years ago rather than celebrating Moodi's actions.
Too late to blame now. India has been brutally lost against Pakistan in Afghanistan
...modi does what he likes - he is averse to hearing the truth since modi likes to create truth from his magic jhola of fiction to bully not only thr nation but the world at large
What did India lose in afghanistan?
@@uzochiokeke4328 Very good question. So , that is the reason why Taliban is outreaching to India .
@@independentnationalist1740 yes in fact taliban and afghan people want India to continue its work in afganistan
@@uzochiokeke4328 Agreed. My personal opinion is that Taliban is smarter now even if they are unlikely to change their way of governance .If they are reaching out to India , it is advantage Afghanistan .
I didn't know Karan graduated from Arnab School of Journalism. Instead of having a meaningful conversation with the guest, he simply wanted him to endorse his preconceived notions. SHAMEFUL!!
Its quite strange that it is the first time I have seen or heard from Mr. Rana Banerji even when he is such a highly intellectual person with rational and in-depth knowledge of the matter. I wish more and more of such true speaking and rationally knowledgeable people come out in the light. Thank you Mr. Thaapar for bringing this truly learned person on your show..!
An absolutely crucial and highly informative interview that provides eye opening information..!!
I urge you to listen to Pakistni side story as well, for an unbiased opinion.
th-cam.com/video/0uItZNTFzEU/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=ARYNews
@@little_laughs_family thanks for that, freewheeling insightful interview. Always helpful to hear perspective from the other side.
Without any credible evidence. . .
What will happened if indian govt recognized TALIBAN.
@saurabh grover. The best person to ask about is former ISI major retired Amir. He was the contact person of ISI with taliban & other groups in Afghanistan. Just a few weeks ago he gave an interview to a Pakistani journalist, which he uploaded on his youtube channel. That was the most detailed insight & now this person is telling the same thing with some lesser extent which he didn't knew just a few weeks ago. 😂😂😂
Thapar said "the Pakistanis" 137 times in this interview.
🤪🤪🤪🤣😂😂👍👍👍
and you had nothing better to do than counting them?
@@bigB987 i love counting actually. Just counted the number of floors in Serena hotel Kabul.
@@tahiriqbal543 that's not normal. could be a sign of OCD. You might want to see a psychiatrist and get checked
Yes because at right now he is sitting at hot Tawwa like thing and saying Pakistan he seeks some coolness from RAW
It’ was very confused interview… the guest does not know much about Taliban, ISI and their connection … he is making assumptions with vague information … anyways I think it was a way to make Indian government and public happy …
I didn't know Pakistan was THE super power of the world🤔
@@ghazalaghani4515 exactly they are just over estimating things …
The Indian audience was constantly tired of watching liars and fighting anchors and guests. Today thay all are very happy to hear a polite and sensible conversation.thats why they are praising so much .
(Chacha Biden😁😁).
I was thinking the same.
How about “ Ghani Baba”!!
“Chacha Biden”🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It's very rare that u see a truthful Indian analyst these days this man is an exception...thumbs up
Hence he is on the wire and not sat on a panel with Gaurav Arya, GD Bakshi with barking Arnab
True
Yeah I agree and he belongs not to andabakt ( using andabakt on purpose because they make India zero with their zero thinking and India Pakistan hindu Muslim agenda which creates a sharp division in the society an irreparable loss to India) This man has awesome integrity. Rspect love and peace to Mr. Benarji and Karan Sir..
The interviewer came with a script and wanted it endorsed by the honorable guest in a hurried manner, kind of disrespectful.
Well we can have some conclusions.
Firstly, the Taliban were not created by ISI.
Secondly ISI played alongside Taliban while RAW sided with the Northern alliance which certainly was openly helped by the CIA.
Thirdly both the CIA and RAW had 20 years to achieve their goals and had enough resources and technology. The sudden collapse of the Afghan government is a clear failure of CIA and Pentagon. Soon the American people will raise this question. We may see some corruption stories in the US.
Fourthly the Afghan rulers were never sincere and honest to the nation. The foot soldiers refused to fight for a corrupt regime.
Lastly, the NATO members would never trust the US again. Except for the UK maybe.
Singling out ISI is ridiculous. What are other secret agencies like CIA or RAW have been doing in Afghanistan? Were they there for humanitarian work?
interview could be for 22 minutes if the host would not repeat everything after Rana Banerji, it seems host was not believing Rana G as Rana G lying to him
At the beginning I thought, we are talking abt Homeland Season 3, where Carry mathison was trying to do good.
But at later stage of the interview, Karan was enforcing ideas, while the Interviewee was replying and sharing his views with "may be" , could be, should be.
The title should be Let's bash Pakistan
@@Matlabkuchbhijese Exactly, if you look at guest's body language, he is very uncomfortable, he is lying, and he knows it.
Mr Banerji is brilliant. Humble, knowledgeable, dispassionate and honest! Glad we have such folks !
Very true after a long time I listened a very professional and learned person on Indian media.
But unfortunately just 30 to 40% truth....but i must say much more better than mostly the Indian media
Thapar is simply repeating his answers! He is a joke.
They had the watch! ISI had the time!!
I thought I'll learn a thing or two but this interview like shooting darts in the dark. For starters Bannerji is treating the Pashtun tribal hierarchy like the Hindu caste system, which is simply laughable. Secondly , Afghan Taliban are portrayed as having no brains if their own. There is no nuance here, as in how Pakistani Pashtuns in the Army and ISI have an incomparable understanding of the ground situation and reality. Either R&AW sitting 1000s of miles away iss taking random guesses and connecting invisible dots, or this interview is a deliberate attempt to portray ignorance and mislead those watching that RAW knows nothing about what goes between ISI and the Taliban. The cluelessness is comfortabing to watch but should be treated as a deliberate ploy.
There going to bomb the fake country made by the British/India someday.
@@ashsuri1289 Dear your mentality is sooo obvious in your comments. I wonder if you understood even 10 percent of this INTERVIEW with your low IQ.
@@bittertruth6723 you iq is low to conclude I was responding to a video as you can see my comment is to some guys post.
@@ashsuri1289 Your comments further proves your low IQ levels. But don't stop and keep sending more evidences.
@@bittertruth6723 your first time with the English language or something? I said I did not write what I wrote towards the dumb video I was acknowledging the person you seem so vigorous to defend. haha your having fun with the English language?
Karan Sir need to have bit of pateince with interviewee.....its an interview....let him complete...its not interrogation😁
@Saif Khan congratulations
@Saif Khan congratualations
He is cutting him short because what Bannerji was saying didn’t come in line with the perception Tappar was trying to create.
@@AHR671 xactly....but he is taking interview....interview is about listening.....no one knows for sure what will happen in Afg.....at end interviwee gets so irritated that he says ur asking a desk anaylist who have retired 10 yrs back...😁
The ex-serviceman talking about pakistan and طالبان as if he was there filming all the events he is talking about....No material evidence
Karan Thapar after every sentence: So there was Pakistan supporting the Taliban?
Paid guest: Yes, yes, yes.
😁
Truth is bitter 😂
Jali na
Northern alliance was and is supported by RAW and they are asking help from Pak. What a shame for India and RAW
One of the most wonderful interview. Karan - if you could not pushed your agenda and ignorance on topic, this could have a little more better. One of the most knowledgeable personal I have seen on this topic.
All credit to gentleman from intelligence. Thappar tried his best to spin his words but the answers he gave exposed him very well.
His statements “yes this is a way to look at it” tells it all
No one will ever know what precise role ISI has played in Afghanistan.
Pakistan is at advantage now but for how long?
Pakistan role is long term to finish CAREC project. Don’t worry
@@hasanbilgrami7945 I think China can transform Afghanistan with world class infrastructures in a very short time without firing a bullet that too in 1/12th cost.Pakistan and India can play their part minus politics.
@@kaaaah2003 Very good idea .
@@independentnationalist1740
FREEDOM FOR KASHMIR ACCORDING TO U.N. SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION AND WISHES OF THE PEOPLE
The ISI is always many steps ahead of everyone else
Deputy director of the CIA
😂😂
YEAH AND THE PAKISTAN ECONOMY WILL BE ALWAYS TWO STEP BELOW BECAUSE ITS A TERRORISM COUNTRY THANK GOD WE BANGLADESHI GOT RID OF THEM 🇧🇩🇧🇩
@@maggietop123 you're a Indian pretending to be a Bangladeshi
@@maggietop123 no way, you’re Indian
@@maggietop123 Indian pretend to be Bangladeshi like many others here by Indians
Karan its better to interview ISI at this point 😆so many questions.Poor guy can't seem to keep up.He can only manage this much,indians have no clue.
Pakistan is at advantage now but for how long?
@@anilbera9499 for eternity All indians can do meanwhile is talks shows abt Pak.Stay obsessed ya'll
@@quratbaloch4480 Same to you...
Take it easy they only can win in bollywood movies ...
@@anilbera9499 Pakistan is actually not at advantage. Yes but India with Modi is on a very big disadvantage, reason being instead of have back channel with Taliban he quoted and media quoted them terrorists. Mind it , India is only country who refuse to negotiate while Israel even contacted Taliban. If US can with whom they were in war , why not India ???
This guy must of broken the world record for mentioning the word 'Pakistan' in one interview.
Afghan jalebi 🇦🇫
Mashuq farebi 🇺🇸
Ghayal hai tera dewana 🇮🇳
Bhai wah Bhai wah 🇵🇰
Lmao lol
They discussed every thing.
But they didn't discussed 80,000 sacrifices of pakistani peoples & 150 billion dollar loss to the economy in a war which have nothing to do with pakistan
When you try to tame snakes you should remember snakes cannot be tamed
Banerji Babu is a great story-teller. They don't make people like them anymore. Enjoyed this one.
i gone and verified all comments from muslims , in all other news of karan they support karan and wire views but when they talk about pakisran all indian muslims taking sides of pakisran and afghanistan and islamic state. Each and every comment of muslims i seen all their profiles and many are from India and u must know EYE is watching all.
FREEDOM FOR KASHMIR ACCORDING TO U.N. SECURITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION AND WISHES OF THE PEOPLE
Yeah sure. That stands cancelled after simla agreement!
I want some pork roast 🐷🐷🐷🐷 yummy!
They won't talk about the dirty role of India played in Afghanistan for last 20 years. Afghanistan was used against Pakistan
it would be more informative if guests are interrupted less often and allowed to speak freely.
Thappar cant do it. Its beyond his control.
Mr. Karan tried to defame and put all the reasons on the shoulders of ISI, but Banerji is a learned man and very technical.
Very knowledgeable but I have failed to understand whether it was an interview or interrogation of the guest.
You are right. Thapar thinks he is most knowledgeable! Still live in Congress patronage. He is a joke but got favours from Congress is waning and he is not a worth. People like him should disappear and enjoy retirement and their luxury lifestyle. Indians have moved on.
In his words the Pakistani trained Taliban beat the shit out of 52 countries.
Do Karan lost the art of interviewing?!
What an intellectual discussion
I always admire Mr Karan Thapur
Real face of intellectual India
it is so irritating when Karan Thapar keeps interjecting and does not allow Mr Banerji to complete. We are interested in expert talking and not interviewer. Please dont treat audience as dumb and seek clarifications every 30 seconds.
🤣🤣🤣
Haha it's a quick-paced interviewing style which is his signature. He does not fawn over guests like fanboys "omg you were from raw, now you keep talking, i will just drool and make air kisses".. karan is mostly hated by people who ardently support the present day bjp. Besides that his guests dont seem to have a problem with the style.
Thapar : SO ISI IS VERY VERY BAD
Rana RAW: YES BAD
Thapar: SO ISI WE NEED TO DESTROY
Rana RAW YES DESTROY
Thapar: SO YOU ARE EXPERT AND KNOW EVERYTHING HOW TO THIS
Rana RAW: YES EXPERT
Thapar: OK THANK YOU INTERVIEW.
Rana RAW: YES INTERVIEW.
😂😂
“Pakistan”, is undoubtedly the most spoken word in this video.
Guys you’re obsessed with us.
Know the difference between obsession and facts. People all over the world need to know the truth. Both USA and Pakistan are responsible for the current refugee crisis in Afghanistan. And the corruption of Afghan government too. I don’t care about what politicians and powerful governments do or say. But people suffering is a humanitarian problem and therefore it concerns us all.
FYI These journalists are not Indian government friendly therefore it’s not government propaganda. This is critical thinking that needs engagement of everyone’s brains. Only then solutions can be found. More chaos means more disturbance. Nobody wants that.
Even though Karan seemed a little biased against the ISI and Pakistan in this interview, I would still say that it was a well-conducted interview. The interviewee was quite knowledgeable and I actually learned something from this. I feel it was time well spent. Thanks from across the border!!
He is absolutely right on the part how it founded. It is becos lawlessness.
They failed to mention (?due to interruption by the anchor) that before Taliban came/were brought to power, A DECADE LONG gorilla war had been going on between Afghan war lords, or the jihadis who had fought and defeated Russian invasion! Taliban DIDN'T START WAR, BUT HAD STOPPED IT.
Not expecting a staged interview Mr Thapar, at 12:00 you jump to create ttp without adding the word funded and gathered by Indian to attack pakistan and created ttp
Karan has lost his credibility long time ago
Even if that were true Tanveer, why would they stage an interview for average Indian viewer? We anyway think India is good, pakistan is bad. Adrian Levy's book also says what you are saying. But it says that staged stuff is done to create a clean image for india and bad image for pakistan in the West. I dont think western viewers are watching the Wire.
@@rdc515 well dear because they want to please a common Indian and sow the seed of Pakistan and Taliban Islam hate in your mind so you always whenever see a Pakistani or Muslim or Taliban you would see them with suspicion and think them. Bad as this sort off propaganda help Indian state to hide their failures in shadow of nationalism gab
@@HassanAli-xl8kr i agree about such tactics but the Wire is not considered by any pro govt indian to be a patriotic channel 😂 in any case, i have friends in Pak and dont see everyone with suspicion, however it is not false that a large number of Pakistanis also hate India, and those in ISI are trained to destroy India just as those here in India are trained to destroy Pakistan. Someday they both retire and start meeting in London and Bangkok for scotch and whiskey. I also don't suspect Taliban, it is pretty clear that they want Afghanistan to remain in the 15th century and its women as men's slaves. If islam says ban music, why isnt music banned in Pakistan or UAE or Saudi or Jordan? It seems only Taliban are true Muslims and others are just trying to be Muslim. If taliban is so great, why dont Pakistani boys and girls migrate to Afghanistan?
@@rdc515 well Afghanistan will have ideal system but when it come Pakistan all Indian news outlets get hostile toward us and all Pakistanis do not hate Indians that much like Indians hate us all godi media all Indian polticans just say bad about Pakistan even in City Council elections Indian sells name of Pakistan so it says lot
I should appreciate the intel guys professionalism and unbias in the answering. He did not malign taliban just because he doesn't subscribe to their ideas amd values. This is rare to see in India. He honestly said the origin of taliban was for a good cause of ending extortions etc. He also honestly mentioned that ISI may not have been that much instrumental in fall of Kabul this time and much of it was due to low morale of ANA. And it is highly appreciable that the intel guy didnt mix up his personal opinions as facts, but distinguished them well. As regards Mr Thapar, he played like a typical Indian anchor this time.
Hello lovely Neighbours … Remember ‘Everything is Fair in LOVE & WAR’ … kisses 😘 from Pakistan 🇵🇰.
It’s very rare to listen something sensible from Indian media and I have thoroughly enjoyed watching it
Fantastic Interview. Rana Banerjee has incredibly encyclopedic details. I like his caveats noww and then while somewhat irritatingly Karan tends to pin him down to some binaries.
Mr. Bannerjee knows more than Taliban and ISI than Taliban and ISI themselves 😂 the way he is answering every question feels like Taliban and ISI used to take him everywhere as their cameraman and reporter!! Applause 👏👏
Thoroughly enjoyed this interview. Although I believe some points needed more explanation and a few more questions could have been asked but still it was the best discussion on this issue I've heard.
I wish all news programmes in India/Pakistan were like this, our people would learn to think and question instead of being brainwashed by the media.
The ISI will have as much role to play as its progenitor assign to it. Is Pakistan anything other than the proxy for the UK-US?
End story : Pakistan won 🏆
And Taaliban won, Alhamdulillah ❤️🇵🇰🇦🇫
All views of RAW Officer is tremendous..... From Pakistan
Excellent choice! These ppl who worked in the shadows are the best repositories of uncommon knowledge. Good one!
To be honest the guest answered too appropriately. Unfortunately for Karan, he answered all of his wished anticipations in "may be". Clearly, India had a very big set back in Afghanistan. Throughout this discussion, Karan never asked a question about what RAW has been doing in Afghanistan for 20 years? All of that is because it was irrelevant? Oh man, even 20 years were not enough for you to influence Taliban and other factions.
15th August will be remembered as day when Indian puppets surrender in Kabul Afghanistan with out a fight biggest surrender in history of modern world as Indian army trained Afghan national Army surrender
Before you spent 3 billion in that country. India should have investigate what is going on.
कौन-कौन भाई किसानों के साथ खड़े हैं गर्व से बोलो किसान एकता जिंदाबाद
The problem is no one has precise details. 👏👏👏👏👌 that's how Markhor works.
Karan Thapar is interviewing himself, answering to his own questions. LOL what an interview with minimum input from interviewee.
A very comprehensive explanation of TALIBAN , PAKISTAN & ISI. Better than any Pakistani Channel I ever watched. 👏
Mr. Banerjee keeps contradicting himself. Most of his answers seem to be assumptions.
What else? He is making up things on the hoof. An intelligence officer trying to be a historian.Unreliable source unconfirmed events.
The anchor continued to put his words in Mr Banerjee’s mouth throughout the interview.
karan please invite more guests like this. Also good to have interviews with the ex intelligence chief of friendly countries
What about ISI ex chief.?
@@kamlipaul8498 The best person to ask about is former ISI major retired Amir. He was the contact person of ISI with taliban & other groups in Afghanistan. Just a few weeks ago he gave an interview to a Pakistani journalist, which he uploaded on his youtube channel. That was the most detailed insight & now this former RAW chief is telling the same thing with some lesser extent which he didn't knew just a few weeks ago. 😂😂😂
Sorry bro... our army chief and DG ISI are too busy on certain tasks 😉
This is one of the better interviews of Karan. Of course, when he is not discussing Modi, Karan is quite fine and bearable. Thanks to Mr. Banerjee, we have an excellent overview of the situation on the ground. Thankfully, Karan allowed him to speak freely! The conclusion is of course that we have to wait and see what happens there!!
Each and every leader of every group even the ppl in the govt are always well connected to Pakistan even if they are speaking against the Govt of Pakistan because of some policies. Hamid Karzai also lived in Pakistan. Even today his relatives are here in Pakistan. Same is the story for other Afghan leaders. We have a very deep connection, just like brothers who sometimes even fight agressively but at the end of the day sit togather and sort out everything.
Indians are not making anyone fool but themselves, I am happy for their wrong beliefs, in any India and Pakistan war such attitude will only help Pakistan, but I am must congratulate Indians on their capacity of digesting international hazeemat on such a large scale
So far I haven't seen even one analyst on Indian media who talks about Afghanistan and it makes sense... Regarding Afghanistan, Indian anchors and guests live in utopian world
WATCH SEKAR GUPTA'S CUT THE CLUTTER...
As a Pakistani origin & fan of karan- this was great learnings thou a lot of assumptions
India play's there cards wrong way last 20 years.and still they chose same way.who played right way ?........
Interesting interview from other side of the table. First time two Indians were not shouting their lungs out on Pak Afghan subject. However they were reluctant to discuss the Indian failure in Afghanistan.
Honest opinion by the guest by obviously one sided. Karan should have some one on Pk side as well
I loved this interview... FULL STOP. The interviewer stayed in TOTAL command by doing ~80% of the talking. He did an excellent job of "interpreting" Mr. Bannergee with crafty "in other words" and the slick "as you said" or "as we have established." He caught Mr. Bannergee contradicting himself and towards the end even gave him a sharp scolding as he was trying to "confuse us" by saying things that could have clouded our judgement. Awesome journalism.
Well said😀
Very True... can't stop laughing.. So called Saine indian journalist gone totally mad hahaha 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😃😃
Karen, please learn to ask open-ended question.
Extremely informative with in-depth analysis and needs to be watched more than once.
I thought this will be a non biased interview wish if this gentleman had shared these facts with the US army then today things would have been different; Karan give right facts to the audience that India has lost another war with the help of these illusionist type of officials
But current scenario points towards taliban against pak and terror attacks on wide scale in pak , also pak-afg border dispute is escalating. DON'T SEE HOW INDIA LOST...on the other pak lost.
Mr. Thapur, please do not start off the interview by making an accusation that everyone knows about this or that. Ask the question and let the expert answer.
Every time I watch a talk show on the current situation in Afghanistan and the Taliban take over and with all the uncertainties and confusions surrounding this country, there is only one thing that is certain, that ISI must be a very professional institution to have achieved all this, of course rights and wrongs beside.
🇮🇳 seems to be always on losing side as far as 🇦🇫 is concerned. When Soviet invaded 🇦🇫, India stood with Russia, result Zero . Similarly 🇮🇳 stood with 🇺🇸 and Puppet Afghan Govt , but result was again BIG ZERO. The consequence of this time BIG ZERO is indian govt is doing privatisation and assets being leased out for generation of cash
70,000 maar to diye, 150 billon dollar ka nuksaan bhi
Would love to audience another program, where perhaps you fellows can talk about how RAW cooked butter chicken down there for twenty years & Since it's all bloody over please leave no khulbushan behind in your yaps.
Banerjee is absolutely brilliant on his assessments on each and every issue, he seems to know everything that is going on in Afghanistan Pakistan the ISI etc. like the back of his hand, this has been a riveting interview and Karan Thapar is as always on the top of his game
India should be ashamed of bringing up a coward Afhhan Army who couldn't even fire a bullet and ran away faster than Usain Bolt. Taliban swept the country by storm. Seen the difference in training?
Not coward than yours।85000 surrendered 🤪🤪🤪🤪
Muslim taliban has decisively defeated hindu taliban. Shame on Indian intelligence, military its equipments, its training and its political leadership/ diplomats.
@@mikespear5459 Mike the fake spear 🤪🤪🤪
@@Samurai4sale. Some people cannot digest bitter truth which the whole world knows.
@@mikespear5459 yeah whole world know who ran in night it's us force।।🤪
2 old men talked about themselves for more than half hour yet told us nothing ? at least new at the moment ?
The story about origin is absolutely true and very few know about it. Hmmmmm this person is knowledgeable
I knew the truck story in fact I read in the newspaper next day when it happened!
@ Aman Pasha. Where was this knowledgeable person a months ago? This whole story about Taliban told Major Amir of ISI 2 weeks ago in an interview with Rauf Klasra. Now after hearing that interview of major Amir I am also one of very knowledgeable person about Taliban😂😂😂
When Ajit Doval talk about funding terrorist outfits in Pakistan, he meant funding TTP as well. Why dont u talk about Indian state sponsored terrorism in Pakistan by using Afghanistan safe heavens.