an absolutely brilliant discourse! once again, I cannot understand how India ignores such academics and continues to sell western false historical narratives in history. further perpetuated by Ranveer with his plethora of ill informed archaeological survey of India "experts"
Because Indian academia is not Indian academia. It is a western views advertiser and we are made to believe and even pass exams based on Western advertisements.
@@rudolfdiezel1614 Unfortunately centre can't involve at present. As this belief is at its peak. Congress had many chances, but they were against India's unity even before 1947.
he is alright but he does not know how to do presentation when he said eeuropean were bblack sskin and iiranian were wwhite skin is not accurate assesment ..... the so called eeuropean were not wwhite they were bbrown sskin to fair skin people with majority of them had bbrown eyes and bblack hair.....
Namaste: 🕉🙏🕉🙏🕉🙏::: “””Mark Twain””” "India is the cradle of the human race, the birthplace of human speech, the mother of history, the grandmother of legend, and the great grand mother of tradition. Our most valuable and most artistic materials in the history of man are treasured up in India only!"Mark Twain (Writer, humorist, entrepreneur, publisher, lecturer, Florida America), 🕉🙏🕉🙏🕉🙏….
@@jimvj5897 Namaste 🕉🙏🕉🙏:: hahahaha but when those invaders who offered your ancestors with a bag of rice you will believe them, this is how low you can go,, anyways these are teachings of your converted ancestors,,,🕉🙏🕉🙏🕉🙏.
So then why suddenly your quoting Mark Twain ,how Hypocritical can you be,when you want you criticize and rest of the time use their words,Indians are definitely 2 faced!@@michelle-vedichuman3826
Also listen to Niraj Rai talk about the Burzahom sample. It reconfirms the fact that the steppe ancestry arrived on the Indian Continent is too late for the AMT model to work, and more importantly this ancestry was female mediated because L657 has never been found on the steppe.
The first split/migration is evidenced in the Rig Veda description of the battle or war of Dasharajna. It mentioned all the tribes which moved away towards Central Asia and closer home to Afghanistan and Iran. At the same time the Purus settled down in the east of River Indus. In Iran the religion of early Persians/Zoroastrians was the same as Rig Vedic but given a different name. The Indus people who traveled to Central Asia and Mesopotamia for trade as early as the Halaf period will have carried these goods on Bullock carts which explains the presence of Zebu bull (but not cow?) in these regions.
@@parmykumar8592 does'not matter u need to show the time - line of that plague i.e. how long ago and which mutation is not found or found in todays mice popul in iindia.
@@noice279 tribes are political units which include groups of families or clans with long lineages. Common factors being customs, beliefs and possibly even occupations. These tribes later went on to form kingships and even republics.
The current so called Tamil politicians are for the last 150 years are they avoid truth°e slaves to British, Muslims due to their inferiority complex and fell to their charm and oppose argue against own brethren, sinc
Them propagating is one thing - but going and shifting to Christianity which actually is foreign ( no one even tries to show any similarities ) is mind blowing. Let's Say - Tamil is first for our subcontinent. But still all languages are from it they aren't from any other land - cause we see innumerable mix of cultures , sounds, words, cross references . If you are against all that is from outside - all Muslims and Christians and English speaking idiots should also go why only hatred to Northern India. It's all politics. Logic less. Since originally Tamil lands are very strong and very rich in culture, sanatana Dharma they are fighting their own identity .
It's sad that the people in western academia do not take Indian academicians in the same light. And yet, the Indians continue to follow their definition of the Indian Subcontinent. Not only that, even politicians take the advantage and divide the people
So ancient Aryans had haplogroup J or L. Most probably J. They transferred their culture to CHG which later entered steppe and become yamnaya by mixing with EHG.
only rrig people used to called themselves aarya which was based upon as a creed however after few millennia in iiran they called themselves as aarya to distinguish them from people who used to live int he other side of zzagros mountain..... ( there is no such thing known as aarya haplogroup ....... coz it is not race it is ccreed )
What a genius! I always knew Iranian type ancestry is very deep in India and AASI os the new comer since R2 and L1a samples only had Iranian type ancestry.
One of the most brilliant and original discourse I have ever listened to. Most Indian scholars plough and tow the line of western scholars. His observations are novel, based on hard data and highly logical. Heartful thanks to Sangam for giving opportunity to hear him. And, salutes to him. He has a lot more to tell.
Excellent analysis . Please give a List of References in the end of the Video . Second , some beginning may be made by making additions in relevant entries in Wikipedia or creating New entries .
I tend to favor the out of India theory for a variety of reasons, at least for modern civilisations. Humans have been traveling the planet a lot before modern civilisations began to build stone temples. I doubt that there is even just a single group of people on Earth that have an unbroken presence of his ancestry where the first modern human originated, before stone temple making civilisations. Civilisations always moves. The ice age forced entire civilisations to migrate to warmer lands. The flood after the ice age caused an urge to migrate once more. It is safe to affirm that whoever was Lucy connected to, for example, she have no direct unbroken connection to the people living in Africa today. The oldest traces of civilisation have been found in India, Turkey, but also, there are underground ruins in Egypt that have been recently discovered. Then there's Derinkuyu that demonstrates the audacious craftsmanship of very ancient civilisations.
The out of India Theory makes so much sense!! And it feels right and clear with all living and dead prices….it just makes sense linguistically, archaeologically, genetically and demographically by all angles!! It is just clarifies everything so clearly :) Scientifically it feels genius!! Fits the puzzle correctly….Iranians looks so similar to Indians so do Arabs…. And the culture and language which is so rich in India kind of filters/dilutes out as u go to west…which makes sense if see the OOIM (Out of India Migration) we have to keep in mind that Map of India which was bigger just 100 years ago till Afghanistan could have been bigger earlier…and again as u move further from Motherland things are lost in the way…hence some of it is only kept which reflects in traditions, culture and language correctly…as they moved…and the Cattle moved with them and the food….this just makes sense! Very Importantly, I note that Indian tradition keep this Sutra or belief that we all are one family….Why?? Why only they believe that…because they know it :) people left from there….we still remember …💞💞
India must include such research findings in school and college textbooks to spread awareness amongst our GenNext and to ensure the right organic growth of our nation. Akanda Bharat ❤Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
I can say for a fact that we have tested 11 families in the South East USA. From Alabama to Maryland. It is a fact that we are White Presenting but we all have India DNA as well as Native Americans. We all have Gypsies and Jewish DNA and ironically no British DNA. We don't understand this result but we do know that American History cannot be correct. Our history is not just a little incorrect but extremely incorrect.
It becomes controversial as it does not prescribe to European theories, if the person asking questions was correct it may be the Europeans would have.known in advance 9 planets ,slintered piece of earth that they called a planet,wobbling of sun,weight of planets,and scientific knowledge written within Vegas,unfortunately they did not know all of this prior to Indians example Pythagoras theorem can be found in older Indian literature compared to the purported discoverer
सुना है भारत मे सिर्फ 2 परसेन्ट लोग ही इंगलिश सही अर्थ में समझ पाते हैं 98 परसेंट लोग भी अगर इस वीडियो को समझ पाते तो शायद आप नैरेटिव बदल पाते। लेकिन ये पक्का है कि इस भाषा मे नही कर पाओगे।
😏😏😏 ... But the first "Black Man", utilizing the term ONLY as an identifier, did come from the Ural Mountains area and later spread to Europe and what is now "Black Africa". They were the "Fomorians" the Irish Saga mentioned, more civilized than any of the Thuats , except Dan.
Do we have studies regarding ice age effects in Indian subcontinent? If snowline today in Himalaya at some altitude ,it could be at much lower levels around 5000 years BC than it is today .. Lowering alpine vegetation at lower levels than it is today.. It could have lowered temperature in North and North West India almost same as southern Europe.. do we have any studies regarding this ??
There is indeed a break in the cline in india. There is a geographic gradient but it is non-unform due to caste. For example, bhumihars and brahmins in gangetic plaims have more steppe ancestry than say dalit and many other castes.
10,000 bc /split (Iran/Sumer).. after the great flood that confirms the whole middle East ......, India was the foundation to Sumer now India should replace (out of Africa) ... Iranian Cattle .... that's a new find to add to my studies
The discoveries herein recorded should therefore appeal to the hearts and stir the religious and patriotic feelings of all educated Hindus who desire to know the first-found scientific proofs for the veracity of their Vedas and Ancient Epics (the Puranas), and to learn that their ancestral Vedic kings and sages were famous historical emperors, kings and priest-kings in Mesopotamia with multitudinous monuments still existing there to the present day. It must also be gratifying to the modern Hindus to find that the Vedic and Epic tradition which their ancestors preserved and handed down through the centuries, and in which they have steadfastly believed, is now proven substantially true, and has become a chief means of identifying as Aryans, the Sumerians, Phoenicians and Britons. " Indo-Sumerian Seals Deciphered - L.A. Waddell.
sumerian people used to called themselves " bblack headed people" and they said that they came to that place from the foothills of eastern mountains range there is only two mountain range east to that place first is zagros mmountain and second is hhimalayan mountain range .... they definitely didnot come from zagros mountain coz gutian people used to live in zagros mountains
Thank you for this 'Theory of Migration'--I am glad that someone-else other than myself--have Reasoned along these lines.'Out of Africa/'Out of India'--why not 'Out of China'?!
China is basically a colder country(though not as cold as North European countries,enough to use forks and spoons for eating purposes)not a tropical climate suitable for humans.
If PIE/OIT is true, then the migrations should have happened from India before 5000BC since AASI mixture with IVC estimated to "~5400 to 3700 BCE" CI as per Narasimhan paper.And boy, as per the Paul Heggarty paper, PIE split around 5000 BC. And the only scientific researcher who has given such dates from multiple angles is one and only Dr. Premendra Priyadarshi. Hats off to him if it turns out to be true. He gives date for RigVeda, Zagros-Pakistan connection, Halaf Culture connection, Migrations from Asia to Europe (Brandt) at around 6000BC to 5000 BC.
The fact of twenty two different languages, not dialects, is the best example of ethnic diversity. And for those who use social local politics to impose their hypothesis, please stop because you are wasting time. You have fone enough destruction already.
Barley crop has been mentioned in the Atharva veda, in one verse where it is said the path was fully encroached by bending barley crop with grains during the time of King Parikshit, the successor of Yudishtara and grandson of Arjuna of Mahabharat. While the determination of period of Kurukshetra war done by research scholars vary 5000 BC to 3000 BC, the mention of barley crop in vedic literature surely can be linked to the research done by Dr. Premendra. Thank you doctor for your elaborate research about migration from where to where.
Finally some real answers with examples. I have always wanted to know where did we come from? I am grateful. Remember Rakagiri woman ? They said she had Iranian and India dna.
A very nice research sir, it is awesome, I think there are more gray areas Ie linguistics, ancient cultures similarities,sea routes etc to strengthen the findings
Very interesting topic. I think it would be more helpful for viewers if the camera focused on the maps, graphs etc instead of the speaker. It would definitely help in understanding what the speaker is trying to demonstrate through them. Also I think the talk could be made a little more interesting from the point of view of lay listeners. I am assuming that the purpose of putting it on TH-cam is to spread the information beyond the small academic circle that studies this subject.
The talk needs to structured better. Your assertion is not clear. The data form the studies is also presented very haphazardly. Please take more time and present your theory in parts. If needed please use Hindi to explain. There seems to be great potential in these studies. Thank you.
Most importantly out of AFRICA migrations are along SOUTH ARABIA (Oman and Yeman) into India around 60,000 BCE . In 40,000 BCE OUT OF INDIA migrations are into UPPER NORTH ARABIA & IRAN , IRAQ & ANATOLIA ( not vice versa). see NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC
So everything began in India? How is it so possible? Why from Africa nobody went to South America and North America Directly or to Europe? Why from Africa they all who moved out ent to just India and then from India spread out ? It doesn't not make sense at all.
@@andreamessiasgomes7118There were many rivers in the Indian sub continent together with fertile soil at that time.The climate was most suitable for humans compared to the drier areas like Arabia or middle East.
@@andreamessiasgomes7118 Why not possible?You are estimating based on the trash India and trash Indians you generally find at present. But if you take the situation 5200 years ago,the Indians mostly were very disciplined,decent and pious,esp.the priests,kings and noblemen. So there was no poverty in ancient india since the priests and kings will donate to the poor every fortnight.And it was the richest region in the world. But now everything lost because the ancient system of religious education degenerated,still this system of education seems to be followed by the westerners,Japanese etc.
Please tell me 1) where the human beings are evolved on earth first. 2)what is the first language on earth? 3() how syllables are invented and word are made according to Grammar ? 4(How earth,sun and this universe were created and when created? 5) who is the father of sanskrit language. When sanskrit language is created? 6)who is the first civilized man on earth?
Air flow pattern; Vowels ( matras or Diacritics) signify no obstruction in air flow where as CONSONANTS SOUND PRODUCTION always cause AIRFLOW OBSTRUCTION for one time or another.
Harappan are FATHER of Sanskrit. Harappan Sanskrit Brahmi created between 3500 BCE and used till 2000 BCE. Harappan Script evolved as ABJAD to ABUGIDA to ALPHA SYLLABRY ABUGIDA . From this PROTO SANSKRIT INDO EUROPEAN script we have all ALPHA SYLLABRY ABUGIDA scripts of Asia and Europe including Japanese and Korean. See Dr Gupta Harappan code 2021 for details DGHC 2021
There are differences between people. Like skin tone etc these are the result of micro evolution . But we look at the big picture there is no significant difference in dna between a person in Kashmir and deep south. Infact it is less than that between a Spanish and a Norwegian. We can show by modifying the photos of a person from deep south using some software he will appear like a person in gharwal. We can look at dna maps. As he said differences in dna may be due to natural selection.the main reason so many crooks post lies is because they want to keep that fake narrative alive and these people have some wicked intentions.
Beauty of genetics is it doesn't support colonial racism. There is no such thing Caucasoid, Mongoloid, Nigroid and Australoid. Aryan and Dravidian are just linguistic division not biological. I also believe in Out of India Theory. Out of India Theory does not mean Homo Sapiens emerged in India but it just means after LGM human beings dispersed to Europe, and before to East Asia and Oceania.
@@RLekhy the way you have explained is like that your still in nursery, still trying to grasp the concepts 🤣, stay in school kid, comment only when your done with your PhD 😂.
@@andreamessiasgomes7118 Yes, kid I am a PhD in Anthropology and kids like you stay around me. And I urge you just shut up if you have no idea what you are talking. Just laughing at others not make you an adult.
@@andreamessiasgomes7118 Yes, I am a PhD holder in anthropology and kids like you stay around me for her graduations. Just laughing at others doesn't make you an adult.
Very intellectually stimulating discourse, dialogue and strengthening evidence based presentation. Thank you. Please make the presentation available for academic references in the description box, so that we can learn in detail his paper.
Natural calamities and invasion out of Arabia, towards eastwards, changed the original DNA composition of the east to a huge extent, to the point that it is now totally unrecovered to find the original actual inhabitants of Iran and North-Western India.
The most ubiquitous branch of R1a-Z93 found in about 20% of R1a - Z93 carrying Indian males (about 40 million males today) L657 never existed on the steppe and is not there even today. According to genetic modeler Ashish Kulkarni a single man carrying R1-Z93 migrated to the Indian Continent and was reproductively successful. His ancestors along the way developed the unique L657 branch in situ. For the curious, Kulkarni runs a genetic blog on the internet."
How do you factor lactose tolerance and the light skin genes based on a north and southeast cline? The light skin and lactose tolerance is based on a relationship of geography and caste.
this is not right every time migration in history like hun scithian and other upper to below where soils good for harvesting so people not going those aria where hard for live like dry aria so why they go to Europe even
present day theory aafrica he hai kyunki africa main he oldest bone mile hai aur africa main genetic diversity jada hai aur also the oldest dna mutation africa se he mile hai ..
an absolutely brilliant discourse! once again, I cannot understand how India ignores such academics and continues to sell western false historical narratives in history. further perpetuated by Ranveer with his plethora of ill informed archaeological survey of India "experts"
Because Indian academia is not Indian academia. It is a western views advertiser and we are made to believe and even pass exams based on Western advertisements.
Still in Tamil Nadu, the Dravidian parties propagates Aryan - Dravidian division theory vigorously.
@@rudolfdiezel1614 Unfortunately centre can't involve at present. As this belief is at its peak. Congress had many chances, but they were against India's unity even before 1947.
he is alright but he does not know how to do presentation when he said eeuropean were bblack sskin and iiranian were wwhite skin is not accurate assesment ..... the so called eeuropean were not wwhite they were bbrown sskin to fair skin people with majority of them had bbrown eyes and bblack hair.....
I agree with you
Namaste: 🕉🙏🕉🙏🕉🙏:::
“””Mark Twain”””
"India is the cradle of the human race, the birthplace of human speech, the mother of history, the grandmother of legend, and the great grand mother of tradition. Our most valuable and most artistic materials in the history of man are treasured up in India only!"Mark Twain (Writer, humorist, entrepreneur, publisher, lecturer, Florida America), 🕉🙏🕉🙏🕉🙏….
Nonsense! Just because a famous author said it doesn't make it true.
@@jimvj5897 Namaste 🕉🙏🕉🙏:: hahahaha but when those invaders who offered your ancestors with a bag of rice you will believe them, this is how low you can go,, anyways these are teachings of your converted ancestors,,,🕉🙏🕉🙏🕉🙏.
So then why suddenly your quoting Mark Twain ,how Hypocritical can you be,when you want you criticize and rest of the time use their words,Indians are definitely 2 faced!@@michelle-vedichuman3826
Also listen to Niraj Rai talk about the Burzahom sample. It reconfirms the fact that the steppe ancestry arrived on the Indian Continent is too late for the AMT model to work, and more importantly this ancestry was female mediated because L657 has never been found on the steppe.
Female mediated what it mean can you explain.
The first split/migration is evidenced in the Rig Veda description of the battle or war of Dasharajna. It mentioned all the tribes which moved away towards Central Asia and closer home to Afghanistan and Iran. At the same time the Purus settled down in the east of River Indus. In Iran the religion of early Persians/Zoroastrians was the same as Rig Vedic but given a different name. The Indus people who traveled to Central Asia and Mesopotamia for trade as early as the Halaf period will have carried these goods on Bullock carts which explains the presence of Zebu bull (but not cow?) in these regions.
The European house mice has it's DNA marker from India too!
@@parmykumar8592 does'not matter u need to show the time - line of that plague i.e. how long ago and which mutation is not found or found in todays mice popul in iindia.
not tribes, but Clans
@@noice279 tribes are political units which include groups of families or clans with long lineages. Common factors being customs, beliefs and possibly even occupations. These tribes later went on to form kingships and even republics.
Still in Tamil Nadu, the Dravidian parties propagates Aryan - Dravidian division theory vigorously.
The current so called Tamil politicians are for the last 150 years are they avoid truth°e slaves to British, Muslims due to their inferiority complex and fell to their charm and oppose argue against own brethren, sinc
To spread Christianity.
Them propagating is one thing - but going and shifting to Christianity which actually is foreign ( no one even tries to show any similarities ) is mind blowing.
Let's Say - Tamil is first for our subcontinent. But still all languages are from it they aren't from any other land - cause we see innumerable mix of cultures , sounds, words, cross references .
If you are against all that is from outside - all Muslims and Christians and English speaking idiots should also go why only hatred to Northern India. It's all politics. Logic less.
Since originally Tamil lands are very strong and very rich in culture, sanatana Dharma they are fighting their own identity .
Indian history is twice older that what academics states. Read the Vedic writings.
It's sad that the people in western academia do not take Indian academicians in the same light. And yet, the Indians continue to follow their definition of the Indian Subcontinent. Not only that, even politicians take the advantage and divide the people
This was absolutely riveting and enlightening.
So ancient Aryans had haplogroup J or L. Most probably J. They transferred their culture to CHG which later entered steppe and become yamnaya by mixing with EHG.
only rrig people used to called themselves aarya which was based upon as a creed however after few millennia in iiran they called themselves as aarya to distinguish them from people who used to live int he other side of zzagros mountain..... ( there is no such thing known as aarya haplogroup ....... coz it is not race it is ccreed )
*boycott aryans*
You are getting right.
What a genius! I always knew Iranian type ancestry is very deep in India and AASI os the new comer since R2 and L1a samples only had Iranian type ancestry.
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 R2 sample in iran had no aasi.
One of the most brilliant and original discourse I have ever listened to. Most Indian scholars plough and tow the line of western scholars. His observations are novel, based on hard data and highly logical.
Heartful thanks to Sangam for giving opportunity to hear him. And, salutes to him. He has a lot more to tell.
Excellent analysis .
Please give a List of References in the end of the Video .
Second , some beginning may be made by making additions in relevant entries in Wikipedia or creating New entries .
I tend to favor the out of India theory for a variety of reasons, at least for modern civilisations.
Humans have been traveling the planet a lot before modern civilisations began to build stone temples.
I doubt that there is even just a single group of people on Earth that have an unbroken presence of his ancestry where the first modern human originated, before stone temple making civilisations. Civilisations always moves. The ice age forced entire civilisations to migrate to warmer lands. The flood after the ice age caused an urge to migrate once more.
It is safe to affirm that whoever was Lucy connected to, for example, she have no direct unbroken connection to the people living in Africa today.
The oldest traces of civilisation have been found in India, Turkey, but also, there are underground ruins in Egypt that have been recently discovered.
Then there's Derinkuyu that demonstrates the audacious craftsmanship of very ancient civilisations.
The out of India Theory makes so much sense!! And it feels right and clear with all living and dead prices….it just makes sense linguistically, archaeologically, genetically and demographically by all angles!! It is just clarifies everything so clearly :)
Scientifically it feels genius!! Fits the puzzle correctly….Iranians looks so similar to Indians so do Arabs…. And the culture and language which is so rich in India kind of filters/dilutes out as u go to west…which makes sense if see the OOIM (Out of India Migration) we have to keep in mind that Map of India which was bigger just 100 years ago till Afghanistan could have been bigger earlier…and again as u move further from Motherland things are lost in the way…hence some of it is only kept which reflects in traditions, culture and language correctly…as they moved…and the Cattle moved with them and the food….this just makes sense!
Very Importantly, I note that Indian tradition keep this Sutra or belief that we all are one family….Why?? Why only they believe that…because they know it :) people left from there….we still remember …💞💞
India must include such research findings in school and college textbooks to spread awareness amongst our GenNext and to ensure the right organic growth of our nation. Akanda Bharat ❤Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
I can say for a fact that we have tested 11 families in the South East USA. From Alabama to Maryland. It is a fact that we are White Presenting but we all have India DNA as well as Native Americans. We all have Gypsies and Jewish DNA and ironically no British DNA. We don't understand this result but we do know that American History cannot be correct. Our history is not just a little incorrect but extremely incorrect.
You history is written by Christianism.they murdered your ancestor
If you're Latino then you shouldn't have British DNA anyway
Scam comment
It becomes controversial as it does not prescribe to European theories, if the person asking questions was correct it may be the Europeans would have.known in advance 9 planets ,slintered piece of earth that they called a planet,wobbling of sun,weight of planets,and scientific knowledge written within Vegas,unfortunately they did not know all of this prior to Indians example Pythagoras theorem can be found in older Indian literature compared to the purported discoverer
BEST GIFT TO EUROPEAN by OUT OF INDIA HARAPPANS was 40,000 BCE to 8,000 BCE PROTO Indo European PIE based vocabulary
सुना है भारत मे सिर्फ 2 परसेन्ट लोग ही इंगलिश सही अर्थ में समझ पाते हैं
98 परसेंट लोग भी अगर इस वीडियो को समझ पाते तो शायद आप नैरेटिव बदल पाते।
लेकिन ये पक्का है कि इस भाषा मे नही कर पाओगे।
Informative Session but Fools always cried on false narratives and try to prove Aryan invaders is True..
It is true
😏😏😏 ... But the first "Black Man", utilizing the term ONLY as an identifier, did come from the Ural Mountains area and later spread to Europe and what is now "Black Africa". They were the "Fomorians" the Irish Saga mentioned, more civilized than any of the Thuats , except Dan.
Do we have studies regarding ice age effects in Indian subcontinent?
If snowline today in Himalaya at some altitude ,it could be at much lower levels around 5000 years BC than it is today ..
Lowering alpine vegetation at lower levels than it is today..
It could have lowered temperature in North and North West India almost same as southern Europe.. do we have any studies regarding this ??
There is indeed a break in the cline in india. There is a geographic gradient but it is non-unform due to caste. For example, bhumihars and brahmins in gangetic plaims have more steppe ancestry than say dalit and many other castes.
A physician spreading gyan on "genetics" of migration. I would have loved to hear out the speaker had he been a geneticist.
10,000 bc /split (Iran/Sumer).. after the great flood that confirms the whole middle East ......, India was the foundation to Sumer now India should replace (out of Africa) ... Iranian Cattle .... that's a new find to add to my studies
The discoveries herein recorded should therefore appeal to the hearts and stir the religious and patriotic feelings of all educated Hindus who desire to know the first-found scientific proofs for the veracity of their Vedas and Ancient Epics (the Puranas), and to learn that their ancestral Vedic kings and sages were famous historical emperors, kings and priest-kings in Mesopotamia with multitudinous monuments still existing there to the present day. It must also be gratifying to the modern Hindus to find that the Vedic and Epic tradition which their ancestors preserved and handed down through the centuries, and in which they have steadfastly believed, is now proven substantially true, and has become a chief means of identifying as Aryans, the Sumerians, Phoenicians and Britons. " Indo-Sumerian Seals Deciphered - L.A. Waddell.
sumerian people used to called themselves " bblack headed people" and they said that they came to that place from the foothills of eastern mountains range there is only two mountain range east to that place first is zagros mmountain and second is hhimalayan mountain range .... they definitely didnot come from zagros mountain coz gutian people used to live in zagros mountains
@@parmykumar8592only you know what you are saying
@@urrasscal8380don't talk rubbish
@@andreamessiasgomes7118U r everywhere. Why ? U have an agenda ? Go out.
Great
Thank you for this 'Theory of Migration'--I am glad that someone-else other than myself--have Reasoned along these lines.'Out of Africa/'Out of India'--why not 'Out of China'?!
China is basically a colder country(though not as cold as North European countries,enough to use forks and spoons for eating purposes)not a tropical climate suitable for humans.
Recombinant dna technology
56:40 OTZI Iceman ( 3200 BC ) was Not white . Not Black . He was probably brown . Found in Alps mountains .
There was no iran or Europe every thing was ramaraj
Everyone was negroid
Wonderful. Thanks
Good Evening sir 🙏🙏🙏
If PIE/OIT is true, then the migrations should have happened from India before 5000BC since AASI mixture with IVC estimated to "~5400 to 3700 BCE" CI as per Narasimhan paper.And boy, as per the Paul Heggarty paper, PIE split around 5000 BC.
And the only scientific researcher who has given such dates from multiple angles is one and only Dr. Premendra Priyadarshi. Hats off to him if it turns out to be true. He gives date for RigVeda, Zagros-Pakistan connection, Halaf Culture connection, Migrations from Asia to Europe (Brandt) at around 6000BC to 5000 BC.
The fact of twenty two different languages, not dialects, is the best example of ethnic diversity. And for those who use social local politics to impose their hypothesis, please stop because you are wasting time. You have fone enough destruction already.
Barley crop has been mentioned in the Atharva veda, in one verse where it is said the path was fully encroached by bending barley crop with grains during the time of King Parikshit, the successor of Yudishtara and grandson of Arjuna of Mahabharat. While the determination of period of Kurukshetra war done by research scholars vary 5000 BC to 3000 BC, the mention of barley crop in vedic literature surely can be linked to the research done by Dr. Premendra. Thank you doctor for your elaborate research about migration from where to where.
Finally some real answers with examples. I have always wanted to know where did we come from? I am grateful. Remember Rakagiri woman ? They said she had Iranian and India dna.
A very nice research sir, it is awesome, I think there are more gray areas Ie linguistics, ancient cultures similarities,sea routes etc to strengthen the findings
Very interesting topic. I think it would be more helpful for viewers if the camera focused on the maps, graphs etc instead of the speaker. It would definitely help in understanding what the speaker is trying to demonstrate through them. Also I think the talk could be made a little more interesting from the point of view of lay listeners. I am assuming that the purpose of putting it on TH-cam is to spread the information beyond the small academic circle that studies this subject.
One thing that all indian channels must do is to put subtitles in English
The talk needs to structured better. Your assertion is not clear. The data form the studies is also presented very haphazardly.
Please take more time and present your theory in parts. If needed please use Hindi to explain.
There seems to be great potential in these studies.
Thank you.
Congratulations Sangam Talks, You finally got Dr Priyadarshi for a talk.
To support your view I am sharing a link
Great
Excellent Discussion
Syamal Das 🙏
Excellent work. Thanks for sharing.
Is it just a theory or proved one?
Need to teach these in our school books
Great info. Thanks for sharing
Most importantly out of AFRICA migrations are along SOUTH ARABIA (Oman and Yeman) into India around 60,000 BCE .
In 40,000 BCE OUT OF INDIA migrations are into UPPER NORTH ARABIA & IRAN , IRAQ & ANATOLIA ( not vice versa). see NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC
Who told u
Just forgot. The archaeological trail start in what is today India/Pakistan area, towards the Middle East/Persian Gulf. NOT the other way around !!!
So everything began in India? How is it so possible? Why from Africa nobody went to South America and North America Directly or to Europe? Why from Africa they all who moved out ent to just India and then from India spread out ? It doesn't not make sense at all.
@@andreamessiasgomes7118There were many rivers in the Indian sub continent together with fertile soil at that time.The climate was most suitable for humans compared to the drier areas like Arabia or middle East.
@@sunithaa.n.5028 that is simply not possible
@@andreamessiasgomes7118 Why not possible?You are estimating based on the trash India and trash Indians you generally find at present.
But if you take the situation 5200 years ago,the Indians mostly were very disciplined,decent and pious,esp.the priests,kings and noblemen.
So there was no poverty in ancient india since the priests and kings will donate to the poor every fortnight.And it was the richest region in the world.
But now everything lost because the ancient system of religious education degenerated,still this system of education seems to be followed by the westerners,Japanese etc.
True.
Please tell me
1) where the human beings are evolved on earth first.
2)what is the first language on earth?
3() how syllables are invented and word are made according to Grammar ?
4(How earth,sun and this universe were created and when created?
5) who is the father of sanskrit language.
When sanskrit language is created?
6)who is the first civilized man on earth?
1) HOMINIDS 200 Lac BCE, not able to talk and write.Homo Sapiens 20 lac BCE.
Home SAPIENS sapiens 2 Lac BCE.
Proto Indo European full script is HARAPPAN WRITING SYSTEM
See Dr Gupta Harappan code ( TH-cam & academia )
Air flow pattern; Vowels ( matras or Diacritics) signify no obstruction in air flow where as CONSONANTS SOUND PRODUCTION always cause AIRFLOW OBSTRUCTION for one time or another.
4) Cosmic celestial bodies Created by BIG BANG primordial matter around 14 billion years back.
Harappan are FATHER of Sanskrit. Harappan Sanskrit Brahmi created between 3500 BCE and used till 2000 BCE. Harappan Script evolved as ABJAD to ABUGIDA to ALPHA SYLLABRY ABUGIDA . From this PROTO SANSKRIT INDO EUROPEAN script we have all ALPHA SYLLABRY ABUGIDA scripts of Asia and Europe including Japanese and Korean. See Dr Gupta Harappan code 2021 for details DGHC 2021
Name of the Book written by Dr Priyadarshi ?
Origin and Spread of Domestication and Farming 2021; In Quest of the Dates of the Vedas 2014.
If we used our rationale like our holy books asked us to, he comes out as a blunt lier.
There are differences between people. Like skin tone etc these are the result of micro evolution . But we look at the big picture there is no significant difference in dna between a person in Kashmir and deep south. Infact it is less than that between a Spanish and a Norwegian. We can show by modifying the photos of a person from deep south using some software he will appear like a person in gharwal. We can look at dna maps. As he said differences in dna may be due to natural selection.the main reason so many crooks post lies is because they want to keep that fake narrative alive and these people have some wicked intentions.
are u trying to say we are all descendants from india?
They are trying to say this lol but it will backfire just watch
@@andreamessiasgomes7118Watching. What will u do huh ? Who the hell u think u r ? Stop spamming everywhere.
💐🙏
❤
Beauty of genetics is it doesn't support colonial racism. There is no such thing Caucasoid, Mongoloid, Nigroid and Australoid. Aryan and Dravidian are just linguistic division not biological. I also believe in Out of India Theory. Out of India Theory does not mean Homo Sapiens emerged in India but it just means after LGM human beings dispersed to Europe, and before to East Asia and Oceania.
No lol
@@andreamessiasgomes7118 Kid, What no lol? Do you think is this your nursery class?
@@RLekhy the way you have explained is like that your still in nursery, still trying to grasp the concepts 🤣, stay in school kid, comment only when your done with your PhD 😂.
@@andreamessiasgomes7118 Yes, kid I am a PhD in Anthropology and kids like you stay around me. And I urge you just shut up if you have no idea what you are talking. Just laughing at others not make you an adult.
@@andreamessiasgomes7118 Yes, I am a PhD holder in anthropology and kids like you stay around me for her graduations. Just laughing at others doesn't make you an adult.
Those horses and chariot riders were from North of India.
*Aryans came from Euresia and destroyed the native buddhist india and introduced caste system*
And Buddha told you in dreams
Very intellectually stimulating discourse, dialogue and strengthening evidence based presentation. Thank you. Please make the presentation available for academic references in the description box, so that we can learn in detail his paper.
Natural calamities and invasion out of Arabia, towards eastwards, changed the original DNA composition of the east to a huge extent, to the point that it is now totally unrecovered to find the original actual inhabitants of Iran and North-Western India.
The most ubiquitous branch of R1a-Z93 found in about 20% of R1a - Z93 carrying Indian males (about 40 million males today) L657 never existed on the steppe and is not there even today. According to genetic modeler Ashish Kulkarni a single man carrying R1-Z93 migrated to the Indian Continent and was reproductively successful. His ancestors along the way developed the unique L657 branch in situ. For the curious, Kulkarni runs a genetic blog on the internet."
Ashish is a dishonest fellow
The thing which didn't exist in the first place than how it migrated to the other place?
How do you factor lactose tolerance and the light skin genes based on a north and southeast cline? The light skin and lactose tolerance is based on a relationship of geography and caste.
this is not right every time migration in history like hun scithian and other upper to below where soils good for harvesting so people not going those aria where hard for live like dry aria so why they go to Europe even
These people are big time fools
david reich here 😂
La Scandale Genetique
David' dad here 😂😂😂😂😂
Racial supremacy got exposed😂
@@Viraj911it will backfire, Indians can be so gullible
@matterhornch they were different that's why
trolling hindus is fun 😂
trolling son of virgin is even more fun amen...
Good to see the forced attempt at humour. Keep it up, it will come
Why did Europeans try to "discover" sea route to India?
What was the need?
@@vinaybati4606 to suck hindu diks
This is what you can do.
अरे भाई हिंदी म भी डालो इस वीडियो को
मुझे तो ये भी हज़म नही होता कि मनुष्य जाति का उदय अफ्रीका म हुआ
वो तो अफ्रीका में ही हुआ है भैया। 😅😅😂😂
ये सब उस के लाखों साल बाद की बात हो रही है। 😂😂
present day theory aafrica he hai kyunki africa main he oldest bone mile hai aur africa main genetic diversity jada hai aur also the oldest dna mutation africa se he mile hai ..
@@urrasscal8380 अच्छा भाई।। पर भविष्य म हो सकता ह ये थ्योरी बदल जाए
@@Ultimatefitness360 not really ye theory quite fullproof hai 80 -75 hazar saaal pehle aafrica se log bharat pohoche thay.
@@urrasscal8380 अफ्रीकन तो देखने म अलग लगते ह भाई और हमारे भारत के लोग तो बिल्कुल नही मिलते अफ्रीकन से तो ये कैसे सम्भव ह