Star Wars: The Clone Wars 4x7 "Darkness on Umbara" Reaction #73 ll

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 พ.ย. 2024

ความคิดเห็น • 17

  • @girlsavorscreen
    @girlsavorscreen  หลายเดือนก่อน

    REX 🎉🎉🎉

  • @MyenaVT
    @MyenaVT หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    The gas in the helmets are a stimulant to heighten their senses and keep them awake. A lot of armies in WW2 did this especially Germany the most well known is “panzerschokolade”. Since it’s the Umbaran home planet it’s not toxic for them.

  • @aitipsea3909
    @aitipsea3909 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    Remember senator Deechi? The pale stock up dude going against Padme last season? If you remember him you'll also remember that he got assassinated by Lolo
    His death led to the umbarans to distrust the Republic's ability to protect them so they joined the Separatists, which leads to the invasion you see now
    Worse still is that you'll hear the clones and jedi talk about how they've never been to the planet and how the umbaran tech is unknown to them, showing how negligent they were of their allies
    This is space Vietnam and the Republic is the USA

  • @Howzerct2546
    @Howzerct2546 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    If only you know the he'll we want through that planet.......

    • @girlsavorscreen
      @girlsavorscreen  หลายเดือนก่อน

      I starting to get an idea

    • @Howzerct2546
      @Howzerct2546 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@girlsavorscreen you have no idea let's just say never trust anyone

  • @Max-vu2uo
    @Max-vu2uo หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    "this is gonna be a bloodbath" yes....

  • @marshalllatta2073
    @marshalllatta2073 หลายเดือนก่อน

    This is the best are ever made i watch this all the time so happy you're finally watching it 😊

  • @hehu4025
    @hehu4025 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

    The best clone arc for me.
    Let's start with the reason for Umbara joining the Separatists. The planet was relatively neutral during the war but had a strong pro-Republic political stance. Umbara's senator proposed a massive increase in war spending. So, what changed? Umbara's senator was assassinated. Many who sympathized with the Republic now leaned towards the Separatists. On Umbara, the senator's proposal to increasing spending on war was considered madness. Furthermore, it came at the worst time, right after the crisis on Rodia that could have influenced Umbara. Rodia wanted to remain neutral, but due to two massive battles, the Republic forced various concessions, essentially making the planet "non-neutral".
    Umbarans might have feared that the Republic would do the same to them, motivating them for a coup. After the coup, even if Umbarans wanted to remain neutral, they knew they couldn't. Umbara held a strategic military and trade position. Whoever controlled Umbara controlled the entire region.
    So who is the aggressor here?
    There are no droids on the planet because Separatists were only able to send a fleet to help. This only shows that Republic did not even consider the option of negotiations.
    Why did Palpatine want Anakin to stay away from that battle? Look at this battle. This is Vietnam. And notice who’s there:
    Kenobi
    Rex
    Ahsoka
    Barriss
    All the most important people, except for well Palpatine and Padme.
    (In the book, Ahsoka was almost killed here.)
    The actual battle is very developed. For now let's start with the space battle. There, Luminara achieved a massive victory, and thanks to Barriss and Ahsoka, the planetary landing became possible. (We see them in the introduction to the arc.)
    I will talk about all perspectives in later episodes.
    And regarding Barriss, it's worth mentioning her character growth.
    Well, this battle was too much for her. Barriss as Force Heler had to decide who would die and who would live. There were thoughts about leaving the order.
    This quote speaks volumes and perfectly represents her logic similar to Qui-Gon's:
    “They stood together on the edge of the battlefield, watching the smoke and rubble clear from the devastation of the last battle. Barriss stared with a heavy heart at the horror that was everywhere. She looked tired and defeated, her once-bright eyes dulled with internal conflict.
    "How long do you think we'll keep fighting like this?" She said calmly.
    Ahsoka turned to her with slight confusion. "What do you mean, Barriss?"
    Barriss turned her gaze to the destroyed Umbarian Tank Walker. She noticed many bodies around the vehicle. Both the clones and the crew were desperate and fought to the end. She looked at Ahsoka, her eyes full of doubt and criticism. "Does what we do really make sense? Does our fight actually lead to something good?"
    Ahsoka sighed and calmly replied. "There is much that is not going according to our plans, but we must fight for what we believe in."
    "But do we really believe in what we're doing? Doesn't our fight cause more damage than good?" Her voice tone sped up, doubt clouded her face, her eyes searched for answers.
    Ahsoka felt helpless as she tried to find words to calm her friend down. "There are many things that are not perfect, but we must do what we can to protect innocent people and try to keep the peace. We must fight for what we believe in."
    "But what else can we believe?" Her voice started to filled with an emotional struggle. "All I see is death and destruction. How can we fight for something that seems so hopeless!"
    Ahsoka took Barriss' hand in hers, feeling her friend's pain. "We have to believe in each other, Barriss, and the good we can do. We did what we could. We fought for good, to protect the innocent and defend justice. We can't control the outcome of this war, we can only fight."
    Barriss nodded slightly. "I know," she whispered."
    It's also worth noting that all Ahsoka says are empty Jedii definitions. She doesn't see a problem.
    Barriss ultimately decided to stay for several reasons:
    -Ahsoka - Well, nothing needs to be added here.
    -Knowledge - She wants to help, and with more knowledge, she'll be able to help more effectively.
    -And my personal potential argument: Would the Jedi leave her alone? I wouldn't be surprised if the Jedi would spy on her and didn't leave her alone because a few Jedi joined Dooku after leaving the Order.

    • @girlsavorscreen
      @girlsavorscreen  หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      I would like to know what Ahsoka or any of the jedi's think their fighting for

    • @hehu4025
      @hehu4025 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@girlsavorscreen Well Anakin taught Ahsoka that she has to fight to survive so her logic is similar: "I fight to survive so that my loved ones will not be harmed so that nothing bad will happen to the Order which is like family to me."
      As for other Jedi, everyone has a different opinion about the war and the purpose of their fight, but most often there are just empty words “in the name of peace.” - so they don't know or even care.
      There are few who, like Barriss, will look at the battlefield and ask themselves: what is it all for?

    • @girlsavorscreen
      @girlsavorscreen  หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@hehu4025 it's a good question, I am starting to ask too.