With this video, we can see that the speed of the ball could be fast, depends on the hit timing. My only concern is that this is player vs. player, if the ball marker is on, your ball marker should not be seen by your opponent, its only you should see it. This should be fixed on the actual release of the game.
I think with clay it’s more of little unforced errors compare to hard and grass again I’m not sure but it could also be the game settings may be it’s slightly off or it’s just an easy mode but will see the release day fingers crossed 🤞
Sometimes when they hit it looks like they are slapping the ball rather than mimicking the true motion of swinging a tennis racquet...just looks weird and they should fix that.
I think it looks great but it does need speeding up a bit. The modern day players like Alcaraz and Sinner hit the ball so fast. I think after a few patches this will be a fun game.
Its basically a modded top spin 4 and definitely has a lot of issues (mainly the reduced male roster) However, i will say that we should be patient because this is only the first of hopefully a long line of games. Hopefully they can learn from the mistakes of this game and improve it next time.
This actually looks so good now ! I watched a video of gameplay not long ago and it looked trash so whatever they’ve done since then is awesome I’ll be getting this for sure
Agreed animations arent quite faithful to players. If only. I had the same gripe when ts4 came out. But then we had 13 years of games getting unique animations horribly wrong, so I guess I’ll take it. Low key, the best unique player animations had to be Virtua Tennis series. Virtua Tennis 4 had Federer’s look and feel just right. And I don’t even think they mo-capped him.
This is what I don’t understand about this game thus far. In real tennis, when your timing is off hitting a ball, it typically goes errant, often out or into the net instead of just floating over the net.
Sometimes it results in the ball going out or hitting the net, yes, but most of times the ball goes easy to the opponent, so he can finish it… so at least there is a good thing about it
The problem with the gameplay videos is if the player is bad the ball moves slow because they miss timing and it looks unrealistic. If the players are good the gameplay looks realistic
lol, lightning and raytracing are 2 different things, god people like you who don't have a clue, plus a good game is not made by your fking raytracing hahahah, everything you noobs care nowadays is graphics graphics graphics, raytracing which is the most bullshit useless thing ever, who tf cares if 2 reflections are rendered real time, most of us don't even look at them, ESPECIALLY in a FKING TENNIS GAME HAHAH, this is about gameplay and animations, not your """"raytracing""""
An element that also makes this kinda realistic is the sliding. The problem is that so far I haven’t seen any sliding on hard courts in those demo matches
@@lte6983 Spot on. Another thing I've noticed is that the animation when the player fails to get the ball (at 0:20 for example) is the exact same one from Top Spin 4.
Actually or the standard one or the grand slam to play it early and have access to the full premium passes… I bought the grand slam version, tonight I’ll post a few videos of my gameplay!!
Appearance wise this a lot better than topspin 4…character models lighting etc….I played topspin 4 yesterday afternoon most people haven’t played topspin 4 in a while so there only frame of reference is TH-cam videos which doesn’t show it properly…the real question is do players have a type of weight to them and what’s the career mode looking like.
I loved topspin 4 sooooo much…. But this is disappointing…..I wait for tiebreak…..the graphics are awesome and they working in early access on the gameplay…. I’m very sure that tiebreak will kill topspin 25
Looks like Top Spin 4, which is fine considering that game was destined to always be stuck on 360/PS3. I don't think people realize the reality of making a tennis game in 2024. This isn't football, basketball or hockey. It was never going to break sales records as the fanbase simply isn't big enough for that. So it was clearly made with a moderate budget and we're lucky to get it at all tbh
i budget non era poi così basso sicuramente non a livelli di un gioco di electronic arts! però per fare dei visi decenti non ci vuole chissà quale programmatore, inoltre le maglie larghe nel tennis non si adoperano da almeno 20 anni...
@@_._._._X You can actually roughly judge budget on how a game looks of course wtf are you talking about lol Also yeah tennis game were so great at generating profit, they disappeared off the face of the earth for a full decade after TS4
Stupid thinking…. I pay for this….if I want….and if I pay , then I want a good tennis game….for this price….for 30,40€ it’s ok….but minimum 70€ for this undone game????never…..2k Shame on you….so much people has waiting for a new topspin and they give us this poor game…..graphics, license and gameplay is horrible…..
No depth to the ground strokes at all. Honestly, it's like two amateurs playing. And the ball striking sounds are horrible. Put a microphone at least in the four majors and nine 1000 masters. The ball sounds the same every tournament. There's no high bounces on clay. No attempted drop shots. The serves are just woeful. Someone please put the difficulty higher, for godsake, cuz if this is a high difficulty, TS5 is not worth looking at in my opinion.
unnatural ball movement topspin is way to high with a strange curve. every player has the same animation? sorry that’s awful look to Full Ace Tennis which destroys TS5. and that’s after 12 years? the same game?
Its because they are bad at the game. Everything you could do in topsin 4 you can do in this game aswell (Serve and volley, defence, counter, agressive and so on)
Few unforced errors, every rally is endless like it was "the best of the year", players hitting the ball 2-3 metres inside the court.... sorry but this is not Tennis 😑
Alcaraz and Agassi models look nothing like them,this game is so disappointing i am going back to AO TENNIS 2 where the community models are way better
@@charlscfc1114 Yes, thank you, I know Full Ace tennis is a very good tennis simulator, but I'd really like Top Spin to be as realistic, or at least about off-court errors.
Animations are terrible,players seem to stop in motion before hitting ball,the new Tiebreak game looks better animation wise with 2k25 having better overall graphics.
@@sergiosimbula Complete opposite been playing for 40 years,only topspin fanboys think topspin games are the best,if you think the speed is fast enough in 2k25 you don't watch professional tennis.
I disagreed that TS animations are terrible, its just that that moment where the player is almost static while waiting for the ball should be fixed. If you look closely and carefully, you will noticed that the TS2k25 has various animations implemented in different conditions. Looking closely to Tiebreak, you will noticed that it has limited animations. Furthermore, animations of TS2k25 is more realistic in the real sense where the formation of all body parts conform to natural formation of a real person in motion, otherwise it will look robotic like the other tennis games out there. Although I should admit, that the TS2k25 animations needs the fluidity of TS4. Its a shame, people complain without deeper investigation on matters.
With this video, we can see that the speed of the ball could be fast, depends on the hit timing. My only concern is that this is player vs. player, if the ball marker is on, your ball marker should not be seen by your opponent, its only you should see it. This should be fixed on the actual release of the game.
Ive watched hours of play from this game ...not a single drop shot so far
Is it available as shot ?
Av seen drop shots lol @@gruniste
@@gruniste I think its available, its that the players are not yet know how to do it, I guess.
This is not online… we wont see the ball marker while playing online
@@gruniste yes it is haha
This looks much better than the previous videos I’ve seen. I’m excited.
For sure 🙌
Ball speed is weird still
th-cam.com/video/jT_pjqNW96E/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=JEUXACTU
Needs more unforced errors such as balls going long and missing the lines
I agree, but the gameplay looks good
I think with clay it’s more of little unforced errors compare to hard and grass again I’m not sure but it could also be the game settings may be it’s slightly off or it’s just an easy mode but will see the release day fingers crossed 🤞
th-cam.com/video/jT_pjqNW96E/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=JEUXACTU
They arent even going for the lines though. It’s a shame. Every ball is hitting the service box.
Players 1-2 metres inside the baseline and they hit a half volley every 10 shots.😐
Sometimes when they hit it looks like they are slapping the ball rather than mimicking the true motion of swinging a tennis racquet...just looks weird and they should fix that.
I agree with you 100% . It doesn't looks like natural.
I think it looks great but it does need speeding up a bit. The modern day players like Alcaraz and Sinner hit the ball so fast. I think after a few patches this will be a fun game.
We really need Nadal 😭
Its basically a modded top spin 4 and definitely has a lot of issues (mainly the reduced male roster) However, i will say that we should be patient because this is only the first of hopefully a long line of games. Hopefully they can learn from the mistakes of this game and improve it next time.
Looks like TopSpin 4.1
If it ain't broken don't fix it
@@rabyanaz623 For 2024 it’s broke.
This actually looks so good now ! I watched a video of gameplay not long ago and it looked trash so whatever they’ve done since then is awesome I’ll be getting this for sure
yup same already pre-ordered it, looks a lot like TS4 which I loved.
Im a bit picky but alcaraz doesnt have that alacaraz feel to his game
Agreed animations arent quite faithful to players. If only. I had the same gripe when ts4 came out. But then we had 13 years of games getting unique animations horribly wrong, so I guess I’ll take it.
Low key, the best unique player animations had to be Virtua Tennis series. Virtua Tennis 4 had Federer’s look and feel just right. And I don’t even think they mo-capped him.
can you shot with guns in this game?
This game is clearly on the right tracks after recent horror show of tennis games but it still looks a tad stilted in my view.
Too soon and too late timing never results in ball going out or hitting net, always results in a softly hit shot ?
This is what I don’t understand about this game thus far. In real tennis, when your timing is off hitting a ball, it typically goes errant, often out or into the net instead of just floating over the net.
Sometimes it results in the ball going out or hitting the net, yes, but most of times the ball goes easy to the opponent, so he can finish it… so at least there is a good thing about it
They didn't get the Alcaraz forehand animation right.
Unfortunately not 😔
The problem with the gameplay videos is if the player is bad the ball moves slow because they miss timing and it looks unrealistic. If the players are good the gameplay looks realistic
Exactly
Never a fan of timing indicators, always feel better with natural adjustments
Needs raytracing. Lighting is last gen.
lol, lightning and raytracing are 2 different things, god people like you who don't have a clue, plus a good game is not made by your fking raytracing hahahah, everything you noobs care nowadays is graphics graphics graphics, raytracing which is the most bullshit useless thing ever, who tf cares if 2 reflections are rendered real time, most of us don't even look at them, ESPECIALLY in a FKING TENNIS GAME HAHAH, this is about gameplay and animations, not your """"raytracing""""
This looks exactly like top spin 4 but without Nadal and Djokovic ;/
An element that also makes this kinda realistic is the sliding. The problem is that so far I haven’t seen any sliding on hard courts in those demo matches
there isn't any sliding on hard courts, because this is just topspin 4 ported to new engine. ts4 didn't have it so this doesn't either
@@lte6983 Spot on. Another thing I've noticed is that the animation when the player fails to get the ball (at 0:20 for example) is the exact same one from Top Spin 4.
which version to buy?
Actually or the standard one or the grand slam to play it early and have access to the full premium passes… I bought the grand slam version, tonight I’ll post a few videos of my gameplay!!
A lot of the serve tosses are too far away from the body. Looks like they are falling over as they hit it.
Pros do EXACTLY that
@@ThePianoTester Alcatraz makes contact wirh his serve nearly in line above his head, not miles away to the right like in this video
The ball physics is still a problem
Same as in Top Spin 4
Im so exited to play Wimbledon with 7 male players and a graphic from 1989😂😂😂😂
The graphics are the worst part of this game unfortunately. A tennis game has to look really good. Stable imagine and no ray tracing. Unbelievable.
Haha, you can always play your robotic fav game out there.
Ball Speed too LOW
Shots not reaching the back line
No aces
No unforced errors
Why in 2024 we have something like this???
Totally agree
It is the most difficult tennis game I have ever played
@@LuminousBishops top spin 3 was even harder bro 😂
I still haven’t seen an ace in all the videos I’ve seen. Why is it that Topspin never has the correct amount of aces per game.
What's the average rally length ?
35 min
Why do they dress Alcaraz like Pete Sampras?
Topissimoooo❤
Neeee
No, the developers didn't give a damn about us, this game is an arcade game.
finally a decent game
Is this Agassi or his unknown crack brother after a car accident 😂😂😂
The gameplay looks like a copycat of Top Spin 4 which is a great game...but it's been 11 years...
Appearance wise this a lot better than topspin 4…character models lighting etc….I played topspin 4 yesterday afternoon most people haven’t played topspin 4 in a while so there only frame of reference is TH-cam videos which doesn’t show it properly…the real question is do players have a type of weight to them and what’s the career mode looking like.
after a decade, still far behind of topspin4
I loved topspin 4 sooooo much…. But this is disappointing…..I wait for tiebreak…..the graphics are awesome and they working in early access on the gameplay…. I’m very sure that tiebreak will kill topspin 25
@@bbbdalmacija3324 hhahahhahahahahahahahahha
@@bbbdalmacija3324 Ok, you can wait. Its your right. But on April 23 or 26 we will enjoy TS.
@@bbbdalmacija3324 Tiebreak looks good but I don’t think It will kill TopSpin.
Agassi didn't serve that way.
Looks like Top Spin 4, which is fine considering that game was destined to always be stuck on 360/PS3.
I don't think people realize the reality of making a tennis game in 2024. This isn't football, basketball or hockey. It was never going to break sales records as the fanbase simply isn't big enough for that. So it was clearly made with a moderate budget and we're lucky to get it at all tbh
FINALLY someone who understands how it works, I've been saying this for the past weeks but people are too ignorant to get it.
you don't know the budget or the profit, so how can you say how good it could look.
i budget non era poi così basso sicuramente non a livelli di un gioco di electronic arts! però per fare dei visi decenti non ci vuole chissà quale programmatore, inoltre le maglie larghe nel tennis non si adoperano da almeno 20 anni...
@@_._._._X You can actually roughly judge budget on how a game looks of course wtf are you talking about lol
Also yeah tennis game were so great at generating profit, they disappeared off the face of the earth for a full decade after TS4
Stupid thinking…. I pay for this….if I want….and if I pay , then I want a good tennis game….for this price….for 30,40€ it’s ok….but minimum 70€ for this undone game????never…..2k Shame on you….so much people has waiting for a new topspin and they give us this poor game…..graphics, license and gameplay is horrible…..
Nice video but the players are still bad 🤣
Ma la palla a me sembra troppo lenta
You just use to fast ball from playing tennis games. But the ball speed of the TS is very close to reality if you will compare with real play.
@@jespPH9196 i agree
Agree. Serve speed is slow, after bounce should be faster.
@@jespPH9196the ball speed is not close to reality at all 💀
@@WuzzaWombat because people who are playing doesnt know how to play properly this game yet.
No depth to the ground strokes at all. Honestly, it's like two amateurs playing. And the ball striking sounds are horrible. Put a microphone at least in the four majors and nine 1000 masters. The ball sounds the same every tournament.
There's no high bounces on clay. No attempted drop shots. The serves are just woeful. Someone please put the difficulty higher, for godsake, cuz if this is a high difficulty, TS5 is not worth looking at in my opinion.
Please somebody tell me that's not Murray at the end, he looks nothing like him
It is 😩
I was hoping he was a Myplayer character or smt. God, even Tiebreak Murray looks better 🤦🏼
Hit deeper pls
No Nadal and no GOAT Djokovic, no thank you.
No dirt on their clothes
Yeah 😕
Al take all them silly bars off the screen
Im gonna remove everything of my screen when I get the game 🙏
unnatural ball movement topspin is way to high with a strange curve. every player has the same animation? sorry that’s awful look to Full Ace Tennis which destroys TS5. and that’s after 12 years? the same game?
For ball physics yes. But animations, slide, textures, sounds etc.. no, TS5 is better than full ace
Eeeeh... Full ace tennis is a simulator, top spin isn't
All points are same
There is no cool drop shot
This is the players fault, not the game haha
Its because they are bad at the game. Everything you could do in topsin 4 you can do in this game aswell (Serve and volley, defence, counter, agressive and so on)
Looks not like murray
Esos rostros jajajjaajjajajajajaj están echo con el mismo editor del juego jajajaj
Is it even 60 fps?
Yes, it is
They play soooo short and are unable to finish rapidly easy points. Not realistic at all and moreover who recognize Agassi's style of play here ?!
again, for those slow in the head who STILL don't get it, they play short because they can't play, it's not a game issue........ -_-
And you believe in miracles 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Few unforced errors, every rally is endless like it was "the best of the year", players hitting the ball 2-3 metres inside the court.... sorry but this is not Tennis
😑
This was made by people that have payed very little actual tennis. Matchpoint has much more realistic pro movement.
Sure, buddy.
Alcaraz and Agassi models look nothing like them,this game is so disappointing i am going back to AO TENNIS 2 where the community models are way better
Those models are pretty bad no doubt about that but AO 2 ? Seriously? Gameplaywise it's the best game we've had since topspin 4
@@guy.h421 The gameplay isn't realistic, there are no mistakes, it sucks.
@@faysalzaza1922 go and play tiebreak then or whatever trash tennis games you happen to enjoy so much...
If you want a tennis simulator go for full ace tennis
@@charlscfc1114 Yes, thank you, I know Full Ace tennis is a very good tennis simulator, but I'd really like Top Spin to be as realistic, or at least about off-court errors.
Slow like amateur 60+ tournament😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Slow?
He speak about the Ball speed. Yes a little slow.
Yes perhaps
Nothing wrong with the speed, it’s a clay court.
@@icemandl6the game speed is the same on all surfaces..
Animations are terrible,players seem to stop in motion before hitting ball,the new Tiebreak game looks better animation wise with 2k25 having better overall graphics.
Bet you don't play tennis do you? Tiebreak better animations 😂
Tie break looks dreadful 😂
@@sergiosimbula Complete opposite been playing for 40 years,only topspin fanboys think topspin games are the best,if you think the speed is fast enough in 2k25 you don't watch professional tennis.
Tiebreahahahahahahahahahah
I disagreed that TS animations are terrible, its just that that moment where the player is almost static while waiting for the ball should be fixed. If you look closely and carefully, you will noticed that the TS2k25 has various animations implemented in different conditions. Looking closely to Tiebreak, you will noticed that it has limited animations. Furthermore, animations of TS2k25 is more realistic in the real sense where the formation of all body parts conform to natural formation of a real person in motion, otherwise it will look robotic like the other tennis games out there. Although I should admit, that the TS2k25 animations needs the fluidity of TS4. Its a shame, people complain without deeper investigation on matters.
Trash ahh old ahh lookin game
Looks pretty bad, sounds pretty bad.
Graphics sucks. Feels like Xbox 360. If they gonna charge full price why not fk make it next game graphics?
It's a shame to have this 13 years after top spin 4.
Looks good, but definitly not a 80 € game. Maybe max 30€. Ahhh these companies today, capitalism is a religion....sad times
because it sells, a few not buying it wont make the diff, the gamersgreed makes them get it when it comes out.