Thanks for these new researchers and authors who are bringing untold history of our independence struggle. Thanks to social media that this would reach millions.
The moot point is that they have become one too many. All that they do is rubbish the old perspective. Therefore it puts the onus on the reader seeking historical perspective to delve into several other versions to for his own view
Being from Vadodara (erstwhile Baroda state), I hear lot of criticism of Maharaja Sayajirao Gaikwad beeing British sympathiser, but he played a very clever game, he kept his identity a British leaned king but kept supporting independence warriors like shri Aurobindo ghosh and babasaheb ambedkar.
@@pankajmishra2410 well with that same logic Biharis chooses Nitish Kumar even after such a state condition! Would end by saying, its just a matter of time, Communists are a past, TMC soon will be just like the way SP BSP had been for the UPites
This is very interesting topic covered by the author. I wish this topic requires more intensive research at grassroots level. There were various streams involved in the freedom struggle and these used to be sense of cooperation among these streams. One such stream is related to role of various Saints of various streams who participated directly in the freedom moment and also blessed their devotees to go for freedom struggle. Reference is invited to one such great saint - Udiya Baba who himself participated in Bang Bhungh Andolan and later on devoted his life in the spirituality. There are three books containing the account of Udiya Baba and his devotees who were freedom fighters including some of them as Krantikaris. Udiya Baba encouraged his devotees to dedicate individual life for cause of nation and freedom struggle. The books are Hamare Sri Maharaj ji and Udiya Baba key Sansmaran vol I & II. I wishes Sanyal ji to take notice of books on Udiya Baba. My own family has been part of this stream.
Agree with last bit of discussion. I had heard from my grandmother tbe history of independence i was taught was much more than what was taught. And looking at the comment section those giving negative comments fit the description of those explained in the last sentence by saurabh dwivedi.
मुझे तो यह समझ नहीं आता कि भारत में रहते हुए भी लोग सच को सच कहने से डरते हैं साबरकर जी एक सच हैं फिर भी लोग उन्हें सबिकारने से कयौं डरते हैं कुछ चीजें पार्टी बाजी से उपर उठकर देशहित में सबिकारणी चाहिए। जय भारत
Kya sach bole? Sabarkar apne pehle half me kranti kiye the lekin ye v 100percent true he ki bad me unhone angrejo se bar bar mafi mang kar andaman jail se chhute. Ustime aur v 50 se jada jail me the. Lekin inke jaise koi v mafi nanhi manga tha. Aur ye krantikari mafi mang kar jail se chhutne ka bad angrejo se pension khake kaise kranti kar rahe the wo samajh me nanhi aa raha.
@@priyabratasamal5796 or jada samjhna hai toh unki book hai savarkar per 5 saal apni life ke lagake unhone book likhi hai usme real copies lagi hai ki kiss kiss ne mafi mangi thi or jo name hai vo shocking hai or ye bhi pta chal jaayega british ne unhe pension kaise di thi or kiss kiss ko milti this us time congress ke bade bade jo leader bane or jo bade bade revolutionary hue hai un sab ka name hai. Ab tum sirf ek propaganda ka shikar ho gue ho to koi kya he kar sakta hai
@@nikksharma5358Mafiveer ek baar jail gaya fatt gayee tau maafi maang Lee... Aur Bharat wapas akar Angrezo k agende k tahat hinduo aur musalmano ko ladwane mein lagg gaya
Bahut hi Achcha conversation raha hai sanyal sahab ke sath mein Lalan top ke chief editor ka Iske sandrbh mein Ek Aur mahatvpurn Suchna Sabhi darshkon aur channel ko bhi Dena chahta hun ya FIR yah pure Rashtra ko Dena chahta hun Ki Vastav Mein mahrshi Arvind ke bare mein Unki gehraiyon ke bare mein Unki Jo spiritual Khoj Hai Iske bare mein dekh raha hun Koi pahunch hi nahin Paya Hai Aur unhone Vastav Mein Ek Nai Bharat ko Janm De Diya Hai जिसकी अनुभूति मैं स्वयं कर पा रहा हूं यह मैं कपोल कल्पित बात नहीं कर रहा हूं main Mere Pyare deshvasiyon ko ek Shabd bhi Jhooth Nahin bata raha हूं वैसे मैं मूर्ख इंसान हूं क्योंकि सब मुझे ऐसा ही कहते हैं मगर मुझे ध्यान है कि मेरे प्रारब्ध जन्म जन्मांतर से ऐसे किए हुए होंगे तब मुझे मां भारती की कोख से जन्मे महान विभूतियों का अनुग्रह मिला और मुझे समर्थ गुरु की कृपा से Hamare Bharat Man Ka Sanatan Gyan pratyaksh Roop Se Mere Hriday mein bhi prakat hua तभी मैं यह सारी बात बता रहा हूं और मैं उसी मां भारती के उत्थान में लगा हुआ हूं कि मेरा महान भारत विश्व गुरु आज भी है बस संसार के सामने प्रकट करने भर की देरी है क्योंकि हमारा महान भारत विश्व गुरु के चिरंजीवी पद से सदैव आसीन है कभी जो च्युत हुआ ही यह सिर्फ हमारी मानसिक भूलों का परिणाम है जो हम कालांतर में भटक गए थे aur Usi bhulon ko mahrshi Arvind ne apni karunamai Tapasya se Itna update kar diya jitne yah Dharti chahti thi aap Bharosa Karenge is baat ka जी हां वही बात में बता रहा हूं और आज मैं उनकी इस तपस्या की पवित्र यात्रा को संसार पर्यंत आगे ले जाने के लिए आत्मविश्वास के साथ निकल पड़ा हूं Jo shighra ATI shighra sampurn Vishva Ke Samne Aane Wali Hai ज्यादा विवेचना नहीं कर सकता क्योंकि यह कभी खत्म नहीं हो सकती बंधुओं इसलिए मेरा इतना ही कहना है सभी देशवासियों को खुशियां मनाइए आपका भारत विश्व गुरु है और इसका प्रकाश संपूर्ण विश्व में फैल चुका है शीघ्र iska aapane antrgat ke Madhyam se Didar Karenge aur Param खुशी से धन्य anubhut Karenge.
सबसे पहले इतनी सुंदर सी रचना के लिए आपको कोटिशःधन्यवाद।India के बदले यदि हम Bharat लिखना शुरू करें तो ज्यादा गर्वपूर्ण लगेगा क्योंकि यह नाम अंग्रेजो का दिया हुआ है जिसका concept था पिछड़ा देश जो अनजाने में हमारे दिल मे हीनता का भाव ला सकता है।Please Sanyal Jee अगर मेरी बात चिंतन लायक है तो विचार करेंगें। वैसे भी किसी proper noun के लिए अलग से किसी दूसरे भाषा के शब्दों की जरूरत नही होती यह मात्र अंग्रेजों की चाल थी ताकि विश्व के मानचित्र से हमारा नाम मिटाया जा सके। धन्यवाद
Thank you Lallantop & dear Sanjeev Sanyal. You ignited a new chapter of thought in me. Connecting Lahidi Mahashay, my Great Guru in this process of Independance was a great eye opener.
Mr. Sanyal: It was Pandurang's grandfather T V Khamkoje who worked with Tatya Tope in 1857. He later told stories of his armed struggle with Pandurang (born in 1884). Dr P
"Villains of India" bhi kithab likhnay ko bolo. Bengal Famine / Genocide British maalik ke liye Shyama Prasad Mukherjee ( grandpa ) ne proactive steps liya thaa calling freedom fighters as "Anti-National" Mukherjee wrote a letter to Sir John Herbert, Governor of Bengal as to how they should respond to "Quit India" movement. In this letter, dated 26 July 1942 he wrote: "Let me now refer to the situation that may be created in the province as a result of any widespread movement launched by the Congress. Anybody, who during the war, plans to stir up mass feeling, resulting internal disturbances or insecurity, must be resisted by any Government that may function for the time being"
@@rutvikrs These are half-baked knowledge seekers brainwashed by hearsay theories. There were undoubtedly many Indians who were towing the British line, which lead to famine.
@@rutvikrs Wah beta. Letter keh raha hain War time main British ke saath ladaee Deshdroh ka kaam hain! Aur sahab ko kuchchh galath nazar nahin aa raha hain. Kaun se desh ke agent ho? 1943 Bengal Famine kyaa hain kaisay hua kuchchh pathaa bhi hain Churchill ke aukaad? Famine ke baad sorry kahnay se sab teekh ho jaatha hain, kyun?
@@shyamraa Abe ghonchu chuttad gawar, timeline toh dekh. 1. Japan has descended on SE Asia by that time, devastating every single non Japanese city in East and South East Asia. India was about to face the same fate. 2. There isn't an agreement between INA and Japanese at this point. Azad Hind fauj was formed three months after this statement. 3. If quit India movement was the path, I hy did both Gandhi and Nehru support the war effort? Why did they change their stance?
Ras bihari bose, arvind ghose, subhash chandra bose, sachin sanyal, udham sing, kanhere, savarkar, balvant fadake, khudiram bose etc. hundreds of forgotten heros should be honoured. It will be our foolishness to forget them.
You did not mention Chnadra Shekhar Azad, Shivaram Rajguru, Sukhdev Thapar, Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, Ram Prasad Bismil and many more. So shall we conclude that you have forgotten about them? You don't consider their contribution to the independence efforts? Don't assume that people are incompetent. People know who has contributed to independence efforts.
@turbulantarchitect they were not forgotten but drilled into our heads by the communist congressi historians . They selectively avoided the others because then it would not suit Chacha ji and his dynastic goals by dalali of british
@@ikay1966 I don't agree. India is capitalist democracy not a communist country even after congress being in government for more than 4 decades. How can it be concluded that congress people are communist? If people related to National Congress contributed to Indian independence efforts and historians documented that, that doesn't make them communist or "congressi". Facts can not be denied. Nehru has made some bad decisions and some good decisions, just Modi or Manmohan Singh. We should not hate someone for wrong reasons.
@@turbulantarchitect5286 bro can you just search for carrot and stick policy? And tell me just one incident where INC had received Stick so that I can convince myself that INC was fighting for independence
@@turbulantarchitect5286 Japan was in worse situation than india post independence when meiji era started, it took them just 30-40 years to change their mentality and the rest is history. people always say why blaming the past and nehru but it was him who injected this slave mentality to his countrymen. He was a hardcore socialist and blind believer of ahimsa that he was a critic of army, he rejected UN's offer for a permanent membership and gave it to chinese and we're still suffering because of it, we all know how irresponsible he was in Indo-Sino war. if only he had balls to take some hard decisions for greater good his party would have been the biggest party in indian history. congress is the sole responsible for what happened here and what's happening here. because of their incompetency we're still suffering and now the party who is responsible for countless riots and emergency is saying the democracy is in danger?? only a delusional can support them.
Why there is so much obsession with some ppl?? Why you can't read and create your own opinion rather than watching reels with aarambh hai prachand as a background and getting obsessed with a person.
Also why there is so much "extremisim" In any part? I mean why tf one can't criticise and appreciate any person/party at the same time? Koi paise toh tmhe de nahi rha Toh neutral hi rehlo
Saurabh dwibedi Ji - Hm upsc ke aspirent h, hm prayagraj ki ek suprashidy coaching se taiyari kr rhi hu , mahgai bahut h, Hm sabhi asprirent kahi na kahi isase presan h, gharvale maa pita Ji apne jarurto me kami kr hme padha rhe h, sab me to Hm kaise katauti kr lete h, pr sabse jyada paresan h room rent se,, room mahiko ke vyohar aise hote h jaise Hm pr ahsan kr rhe h, ghar ki rasoi me ek chauki dal kr uska rent 4000/5000₹ lete h, please sir iske liye kuchh kariye
Please send a complementary copy to each of RG,KHARGE,JRAMESH etc.who are so biased against Revolutioneries in general & Savarkar in pert.Nice work by Sanyalji.Many thanks
Would have felt happy if Deshbandhu CR Das, who was a lawyer and stand for Shree Aurovindo in court and get him released Would have come in the discussion..also reference to his Guru
Sanjeev ji was taking about Akhadas and in back of my mind, i was thinking about RSS shakha system. A place for physical activities and then a big network was created providing cultural education and now biggest organisation in the world. I think these Akhadas were the inspiration
What fantastic stories of valour courage , spying , intelligence , fighting , etc etc ... Textbooks me to bass nam mention rehta h kisi kone me What a inspirational figures our ancestor , how intelligent they r, My New Idol is - Mr Rash behari Bose , i liked his character what a man Thank u sanyal sir , for bringing him.
क्रांतिकारी सोच और आंदोलन का मूल दर्शन महर्षि अरविन्द के चिंतन में ही निहित था और उनके चिंतन से ही अनुप्राणित था।यह तथ्य सर्वविदित है। स्वतंत्रता आंदोलन के अध्येता इन तथ्यों से अनजान नहीं हैं।
महात्मा गांधी भी इन सारे तथ्यों से अनजान नहीं रहे होंगे। स्वतंत्रता के सभी सेनानी अरविंदो घोष के विचारों से पूरी तरह परिचित थे। अरविंद घोष के दर्शन में ही क्रांति के बीज निहित थे। इससे स्वतंत्रता आंदोलन में महात्मा गांधी के नेतृत्व और योगदान का महत्व कहीं कम नहीं होता।
he was clearly struggling with hindi, please let them speak in English or other languages, get it subtitled. He could have packed so much more in this duration.
नमस्ते टीम लल्लनटॉप और सौरभ दिवेदी, आपसे आग्रह करता हूं की अगर हो सके तो कृप्या सूरज येंगेड को भी किताबवाला, बैठकी या गेस्ट इन द न्यूज रूम में जरूर बुलाएं। धन्यवाद शुभम कुमार
Sourabh dwivedi , ko sunane main maja aatahai ! Yaddyapi ye bahut bareek kism ke chatukar buddhijivi hain ! Phir bhi koshish karate hain ki Modi bhakti jahir na ho! Itani maryada banaye rakhana bhi achchha lagata hai ! Itane kabil salahkar ke hote ,Modi ji kyon desh , javano , kisano , mahila pahalwano ka bantadhar kar rahe !
लफ़्ज़ों के हेर-फेर से इतिहास को बदला नहीं जा सकता चाहे कितना ही संज्ञा के साथ खूबसूरत से खूबसूरत शब्दों से क्यों ना संवारा जाए l पिछले दौर में भी सत्ताधारी ने अपने फायदे के लिए इतिहास को बदलने की कोशिश की है लेकिन इतिहास इतिहास रहा है चाहे ओह दौर खंडहर में ही कइयों ना बदल जाए l
@@vickydonor5922 mere comment per tipni kren se se pahle dheyan purwak wakkiyon per wichar to kr liye hote.. Sawarker Kala pani jis Jai me the Kiya ager oh khandhar ban jata hai to Kiya itihas badal jaye ga..chahe koyi bhi sttadhari aa jaye....aur use kitni hi shbdon ka her pher kre...apne vivek me raha kro..
सुभाष चंद्र बोस ने महात्मा गांधी को ऐसे ही नहीं बापू का संबोधन नहीं दिया। स्वतंत्रता आंदोलन में सशस्त्र प्रति रोध का भी एक महत्वपूर्ण योगदान रहा है।इसे रेखांकित करने के लिए सान्याल साहब का धन्यवाद।
PM Modi के सलाहकार Sanjeev Sanyal is a gem ....wonderful to listen his interview
Sanyal sahab is my cousin . proud of his erudition ❤
Is it true that he is related to Sachhindranath Sanyal?
@@tejas8211 yes
धन्य हैं डॉ संजीव सान्याल जी ,आपको हृदय की गहराइयों से शत शत नमन🚩🙏❤️🕉️
Thanks for these new researchers and authors who are bringing untold history of our independence struggle. Thanks to social media that this would reach millions.
The moot point is that they have become one too many. All that they do is rubbish the old perspective. Therefore it puts the onus on the reader seeking historical perspective to delve into several other versions to for his own view
@@wanderingmystic6968what?
Being from Vadodara (erstwhile Baroda state), I hear lot of criticism of Maharaja Sayajirao Gaikwad beeing British sympathiser, but he played a very clever game, he kept his identity a British leaned king but kept supporting independence warriors like shri Aurobindo ghosh and babasaheb ambedkar.
Babasaheb Ambedkar was not a freedom fighter
Babasaheb was never a freedom fighter.
This is one of the most awaiting interviews. JSDeepak v chahiye tha but Saurabh ji hi kare to..
Truly appreciate Sanyal’s attempt to fill the required gap in the indian independence history. There are plenty of unsung heroes still. Best wishes
An in-depth discussion, in very easy Hindi language, especially for non Hindi person like me. Thank You so much for discussion on Veer Sawarkar !
Good to know so much great chapters in our pre independence history
Always a pleasure to listen to Mr. Sanyal. Learnt something new today. Thank you Saurabh.
We Bengalees all know these History since our childhood.
@@soumyadebchatterjee1442yet u choose communist and tmc all thse years huh!??
@@pankajmishra2410 well with that same logic Biharis chooses Nitish Kumar even after such a state condition!
Would end by saying, its just a matter of time, Communists are a past, TMC soon will be just like the way SP BSP had been for the UPites
@@deb5730and ?? Calling someone Bihari has become a modern day gaali. Are you trying to compete 😂
@@creativemaster007 I haven't used any derogatory word for Biharis, I just spoke about the regime....It's you, who took the term in a different way.
This is very interesting topic covered by the author. I wish this topic requires more intensive research at grassroots level. There were various streams involved in the freedom struggle and these used to be sense of cooperation among these streams. One such stream is related to role of various Saints of various streams who participated directly in the freedom moment and also blessed their devotees to go for freedom struggle. Reference is invited to one such great saint - Udiya Baba who himself participated in Bang Bhungh Andolan and later on devoted his life in the spirituality. There are three books containing the account of Udiya Baba and his devotees who were freedom fighters including some of them as Krantikaris. Udiya Baba encouraged his devotees to dedicate individual life for cause of nation and freedom struggle.
The books are Hamare Sri Maharaj ji and Udiya Baba key Sansmaran vol I & II.
I wishes Sanyal ji to take notice of books on Udiya Baba. My own family has been part of this stream.
Lallantop को इस बेहतरीन विश्लेषण के लिए बहुत शुक्रिया । बहुत ही रोचक एवं उपयोगी 🙏🙏
Chacha and Bapu asked INDIANS to support British against hitler. Why didn’t they support Indian revolutionaries against British
Agree with last bit of discussion. I had heard from my grandmother tbe history of independence i was taught was much more than what was taught. And looking at the comment section those giving negative comments fit the description of those explained in the last sentence by saurabh dwivedi.
LAND OF SEVEN RIVER'S is a must read, wonderful writer
मुझे तो यह समझ नहीं आता कि भारत में रहते हुए भी लोग सच को सच कहने से डरते हैं साबरकर जी एक सच हैं फिर भी लोग उन्हें सबिकारने से कयौं डरते हैं कुछ चीजें पार्टी बाजी से उपर उठकर देशहित में सबिकारणी चाहिए। जय भारत
Bhai galat itihas samne aa jayega naa inka jo inhone jabardasti ek ideology ko desh ka pita banaya tha voh propoganda khatam ho jaayega
Kya sach bole? Sabarkar apne pehle half me kranti kiye the lekin ye v 100percent true he ki bad me unhone angrejo se bar bar mafi mang kar andaman jail se chhute. Ustime aur v 50 se jada jail me the. Lekin inke jaise koi v mafi nanhi manga tha. Aur ye krantikari mafi mang kar jail se chhutne ka bad angrejo se pension khake kaise kranti kar rahe the wo samajh me nanhi aa raha.
@@priyabratasamal5796 vikram sampath search karo or debate dekho lallantop per he hai jnu ke professor ke sath sab samjh mein aa jayega.
@@priyabratasamal5796 or jada samjhna hai toh unki book hai savarkar per 5 saal apni life ke lagake unhone book likhi hai usme real copies lagi hai ki kiss kiss ne mafi mangi thi or jo name hai vo shocking hai or ye bhi pta chal jaayega british ne unhe pension kaise di thi or kiss kiss ko milti this us time congress ke bade bade jo leader bane or jo bade bade revolutionary hue hai un sab ka name hai. Ab tum sirf ek propaganda ka shikar ho gue ho to koi kya he kar sakta hai
@@nikksharma5358Mafiveer ek baar jail gaya fatt gayee tau maafi maang Lee... Aur Bharat wapas akar Angrezo k agende k tahat hinduo aur musalmano ko ladwane mein lagg gaya
I feel pleasure because I listening Dr.Sanjeev sanayal
Love this Guy and Bibekji as well.
Have bought and read Sanyal Sir Books but still waiting for Bibek Sirs books as well.
Woh bhi padhna hai...❤
No one talks of our own Pandurang Khankhoje but everyone knows Norman Borlog and Green revolution.
ज्ञान से समृद्ध हो गया इस interview se.
Bahut si nayi aur rochak jankari mili.
Very interesting discussion. I wasn’t aware of Khankhoje and his contribution
A gem person sanjeev sanyal great to listen him
Bahut hi Achcha conversation raha hai sanyal sahab ke sath mein Lalan top ke chief editor ka Iske sandrbh mein Ek Aur mahatvpurn Suchna Sabhi darshkon aur channel ko bhi Dena chahta hun ya FIR yah pure Rashtra ko Dena chahta hun Ki Vastav Mein mahrshi Arvind ke bare mein Unki gehraiyon ke bare mein Unki Jo spiritual Khoj Hai Iske bare mein dekh raha hun Koi pahunch hi nahin Paya Hai Aur unhone Vastav Mein Ek Nai Bharat ko Janm De Diya Hai जिसकी अनुभूति मैं स्वयं कर पा रहा हूं यह मैं कपोल कल्पित बात नहीं कर रहा हूं main Mere Pyare deshvasiyon ko ek Shabd bhi Jhooth Nahin bata raha हूं वैसे मैं मूर्ख इंसान हूं क्योंकि सब मुझे ऐसा ही कहते हैं मगर मुझे ध्यान है कि मेरे प्रारब्ध जन्म जन्मांतर से ऐसे किए हुए होंगे तब मुझे मां भारती की कोख से जन्मे महान विभूतियों का अनुग्रह मिला और मुझे समर्थ गुरु की कृपा से Hamare Bharat Man Ka Sanatan Gyan pratyaksh Roop Se Mere Hriday mein bhi prakat hua तभी मैं यह सारी बात बता रहा हूं और मैं उसी मां भारती के उत्थान में लगा हुआ हूं कि मेरा महान भारत विश्व गुरु आज भी है बस संसार के सामने प्रकट करने भर की देरी है क्योंकि हमारा महान भारत विश्व गुरु के चिरंजीवी पद से सदैव आसीन है कभी जो च्युत हुआ ही यह सिर्फ हमारी मानसिक भूलों का परिणाम है जो हम कालांतर में भटक गए थे aur Usi bhulon ko mahrshi Arvind ne apni karunamai Tapasya se Itna update kar diya jitne yah Dharti chahti thi aap Bharosa Karenge is baat ka जी हां वही बात में बता रहा हूं और आज मैं उनकी इस तपस्या की पवित्र यात्रा को संसार पर्यंत आगे ले जाने के लिए आत्मविश्वास के साथ निकल पड़ा हूं Jo shighra ATI shighra sampurn Vishva Ke Samne Aane Wali Hai ज्यादा विवेचना नहीं कर सकता क्योंकि यह कभी खत्म नहीं हो सकती बंधुओं इसलिए मेरा इतना ही कहना है सभी देशवासियों को खुशियां मनाइए आपका भारत विश्व गुरु है और इसका प्रकाश संपूर्ण विश्व में फैल चुका है शीघ्र iska aapane antrgat ke Madhyam se Didar Karenge aur Param खुशी से धन्य anubhut Karenge.
सबसे पहले इतनी सुंदर सी रचना के लिए आपको कोटिशःधन्यवाद।India के बदले यदि हम Bharat लिखना शुरू करें तो
ज्यादा गर्वपूर्ण लगेगा क्योंकि यह नाम अंग्रेजो का दिया हुआ है जिसका concept था पिछड़ा देश जो
अनजाने में हमारे दिल मे हीनता का भाव ला सकता है।Please Sanyal Jee अगर मेरी बात चिंतन लायक है तो विचार करेंगें।
वैसे भी किसी proper noun के लिए अलग से किसी दूसरे भाषा के शब्दों की जरूरत नही होती यह मात्र अंग्रेजों की चाल थी ताकि विश्व के मानचित्र से हमारा नाम मिटाया जा सके।
धन्यवाद
Thank you Lallantop & dear Sanjeev Sanyal. You ignited a new chapter of thought in me. Connecting Lahidi Mahashay, my Great Guru in this process of Independance was a great eye opener.
Sanyal ji West Bengal ki economy sudhar ne ke liye aap ki jarurat hai.
West Bengal next finance minister.
Bjp jitle Ashok Lahiri ache finance minister hoar janyo
Mr. Sanyal: It was Pandurang's grandfather T V Khamkoje who worked with Tatya Tope in 1857. He later told stories of his armed struggle with Pandurang (born in 1884). Dr P
Unke khandan (family) history ki baat kar rahe the
खूप चांगली, मनोवेधक चर्चा.
Thanks Saurabh ji for wonderful presentation of outstanding program lean lot of new issues and new understanding of our great freedom fighters!
Very Exciting..Too interesting..Ultimate..Trully inspired.
Dhanyavad 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Beautiful narration by learned Sanyaljee
Awesome discussion. Time just flew by..
Thank you for your kind words.
@@TheLallantop Please invite Dr Hilal Ahmed for his book Allah naam ki siyasat
@@TheLallantophow come pandurang fight in 1857 with tatya tope , even when he was born in 1884
My respect to Mr. Sanjeev Sanyal.
"Villains of India" bhi kithab likhnay ko bolo.
Bengal Famine / Genocide British maalik ke liye Shyama Prasad Mukherjee ( grandpa ) ne proactive steps liya thaa calling freedom fighters as "Anti-National"
Mukherjee wrote a letter to Sir John Herbert, Governor of Bengal as to how they should respond to "Quit India" movement. In this letter, dated 26 July 1942 he wrote:
"Let me now refer to the situation that may be created in the province as a result of any widespread movement launched by the Congress. Anybody, who during the war, plans to stir up mass feeling, resulting internal disturbances or insecurity, must be resisted by any Government that may function for the time being"
What is wrong with the letter here? Could you explain?
@@rutvikrs These are half-baked knowledge seekers brainwashed by hearsay theories. There were undoubtedly many Indians who were towing the British line, which lead to famine.
@@rutvikrs Wah beta. Letter keh raha hain War time main British ke saath ladaee Deshdroh ka kaam hain!
Aur sahab ko kuchchh galath nazar nahin aa raha hain.
Kaun se desh ke agent ho?
1943 Bengal Famine kyaa hain kaisay hua kuchchh pathaa bhi hain Churchill ke aukaad?
Famine ke baad sorry kahnay se sab teekh ho jaatha hain, kyun?
@@shyamraa Abe ghonchu chuttad gawar, timeline toh dekh.
1. Japan has descended on SE Asia by that time, devastating every single non Japanese city in East and South East Asia. India was about to face the same fate.
2. There isn't an agreement between INA and Japanese at this point. Azad Hind fauj was formed three months after this statement.
3. If quit India movement was the path, I hy did both Gandhi and Nehru support the war effort? Why did they change their stance?
क्रांतिकारियों का सम्मान होना चाहिए। इससे किसी को मतभेद नहीं हो सकता । संन्याल की सोच मे अपरिपक्वता है।
आप कितने परिपक्व हैं, सान्याल जी की सोच की परिपक्वता में टिप्पणी कर रहे हैं ?
मोदी जी ने यदि इन्हें चुना है तो सही ही होंगे ।
Great chapter in our independence history . Jai Hind .
Ras bihari bose, arvind ghose, subhash chandra bose, sachin sanyal, udham sing, kanhere, savarkar, balvant fadake, khudiram bose etc. hundreds of forgotten heros should be honoured. It will be our foolishness to forget them.
You did not mention Chnadra Shekhar Azad, Shivaram Rajguru, Sukhdev Thapar, Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, Ram Prasad Bismil and many more. So shall we conclude that you have forgotten about them? You don't consider their contribution to the independence efforts? Don't assume that people are incompetent. People know who has contributed to independence efforts.
@turbulantarchitect they were not forgotten but drilled into our heads by the communist congressi historians . They selectively avoided the others because then it would not suit Chacha ji and his dynastic goals by dalali of british
@@ikay1966 I don't agree. India is capitalist democracy not a communist country even after congress being in government for more than 4 decades. How can it be concluded that congress people are communist? If people related to National Congress contributed to Indian independence efforts and historians documented that, that doesn't make them communist or "congressi". Facts can not be denied. Nehru has made some bad decisions and some good decisions, just Modi or Manmohan Singh. We should not hate someone for wrong reasons.
@@turbulantarchitect5286 bro can you just search for carrot and stick policy? And tell me just one incident where INC had received Stick so that I can convince myself that INC was fighting for independence
@@turbulantarchitect5286 Japan was in worse situation than india post independence when meiji era started, it took them just 30-40 years to change their mentality and the rest is history. people always say why blaming the past and nehru but it was him who injected this slave mentality to his countrymen. He was a hardcore socialist and blind believer of ahimsa that he was a critic of army, he rejected UN's offer for a permanent membership and gave it to chinese and we're still suffering because of it, we all know how irresponsible he was in Indo-Sino war. if only he had balls to take some hard decisions for greater good his party would have been the biggest party in indian history. congress is the sole responsible for what happened here and what's happening here. because of their incompetency we're still suffering and now the party who is responsible for countless riots and emergency is saying the democracy is in danger?? only a delusional can support them.
Please, Call J Sai deepak and Anand Ranganathan on the show
Read books not recommended books
Why there is so much obsession with some ppl??
Why you can't read and create your own opinion rather than watching reels with aarambh hai prachand as a background and getting obsessed with a person.
Also why there is so much "extremisim" In any part? I mean why tf one can't criticise and appreciate any person/party at the same time?
Koi paise toh tmhe de nahi rha
Toh neutral hi rehlo
VEER SAVARKAR WAS THE UNSUNG HERO OF OUR COUNTRY
Saurabh dwibedi Ji - Hm upsc ke aspirent h, hm prayagraj ki ek suprashidy coaching se taiyari kr rhi hu , mahgai bahut h, Hm sabhi asprirent kahi na kahi isase presan h, gharvale maa pita Ji apne jarurto me kami kr hme padha rhe h, sab me to Hm kaise katauti kr lete h, pr sabse jyada paresan h room rent se,, room mahiko ke vyohar aise hote h jaise Hm pr ahsan kr rhe h, ghar ki rasoi me ek chauki dal kr uska rent 4000/5000₹ lete h, please sir iske liye kuchh kariye
Excellent analytical scholarly presentation should be studied by all the true seekers of kn😢. Best wishes to sanyal
Savarkar is real Hero of India
one day India will give his due respect
The heroes are not given respect, they earn it on their own
@@gurmanaujla8926 pahle english likhna sikh..😂😂koi logic hai tere baat ka
@@gurmanaujla8926 heroes don't ask for respect,they earns....
Savarkar earned that even after historical suppression by congress
@@Lets_win o English k chodde your dad wrote it right nibbu
They earn it
@@Lets_win he didn’t earn anything he just ask for Britishers’ mercy 😂 lol
Thank You Lallantop for this
Saurabh Ji # No words for Lallantop. Still any time we can listen an independent true view. Rab Raakha. FR # Suniel Kummar/BiharSharif/Bihar/India
Please send a complementary copy to each of RG,KHARGE,JRAMESH etc.who are so biased against Revolutioneries in general & Savarkar in pert.Nice work by Sanyalji.Many thanks
Saurav bhai uttarakhand se pranam! Aapka gala betha hua hai. Iswar aapko aur aapki team ko achha swasthya de. Keep doing the great work ;)
Pl 0p😊
Excellent interaction! So much I learned... Thank you🙏❤
Would have felt happy if Deshbandhu CR Das, who was a lawyer and stand for Shree Aurovindo in court and get him released Would have come in the discussion..also reference to his Guru
Sanjeev ji was taking about Akhadas and in back of my mind, i was thinking about RSS shakha system. A place for physical activities and then a big network was created providing cultural education and now biggest organisation in the world. I think these Akhadas were the inspiration
Gem 💎
Shree arbindo kitne bde visionary the... Kitna satik anuman lgaya tha... ❤
We need to make movie on all forgotten revolutionary to keep their memories alive
What fantastic stories of valour courage , spying , intelligence , fighting , etc etc ...
Textbooks me to bass nam mention rehta h kisi kone me
What a inspirational figures our ancestor , how intelligent they r,
My New Idol is - Mr Rash behari Bose , i liked his character what a man
Thank u sanyal sir , for bringing him.
Look at the difference:
Progeny of Gandhi - Tushar Gandhi
Nehru- Rahul gandhi
Sachin sanyal- Sanjeev sanyal
Underrated comment 👍
@@abhilak007 true
Very interesting and politically suppressed truth about India’s freedom struggle
Please invite Niranjan Takale who has written data on Savarkar for such debates
This Niranjan Takale falsely claimed that Savarkar was convicted for attempted rape in 1908. That's his achievement. Complete Idiot!!!
Very interesting history prior to Gandhiji is not known to masses .Thanks Mr Sanyal for your research and books .Thanks Lalantop
We Bengalees all know these History since our childhood.
@@soumyadebchatterjee1442 that is good ,nut we were not taught in history books anything about it.
Aaj ka Chanakya 😊
Economic interview lena chahiye tha inka.
Great to see him on lallantop😊
सौरभ जी ,आज अभिनंदन के पात्र हो।
संजीव की उम्र देखके अभिमान लगा।
Bring J. Sai Deepak, Nilesh Oak, Vikram Sampat.
Kitab likha kar aap ne hume ak nayi disha me sochne k liye madad ki ...Aabhar 🙏👍🌟
वीर सावरकर जी अमर रहे।
Lekin dalal ke rup me.
@@priyabratasamal5796 jehadi hi ban jao
क्रांतिकारी सोच और आंदोलन का मूल दर्शन महर्षि अरविन्द के चिंतन में ही निहित था और उनके चिंतन से ही अनुप्राणित था।यह तथ्य सर्वविदित है। स्वतंत्रता आंदोलन के अध्येता इन तथ्यों से अनजान नहीं हैं।
महात्मा गांधी भी इन सारे तथ्यों से अनजान नहीं रहे होंगे। स्वतंत्रता के सभी सेनानी अरविंदो घोष के विचारों से पूरी तरह परिचित थे। अरविंद घोष के दर्शन में ही क्रांति के बीज निहित थे। इससे स्वतंत्रता आंदोलन में महात्मा गांधी के नेतृत्व और योगदान का महत्व कहीं कम नहीं होता।
he was clearly struggling with hindi, please let them speak in English or other languages, get it subtitled. He could have packed so much more in this duration.
खुपच सुंदर विश्लेषण...
What a book and fantastic conversation
I’ve just bought the book.
नमस्ते टीम लल्लनटॉप और सौरभ दिवेदी,
आपसे आग्रह करता हूं की अगर हो सके तो कृप्या सूरज येंगेड को भी किताबवाला, बैठकी या गेस्ट इन द न्यूज रूम में जरूर बुलाएं।
धन्यवाद
शुभम कुमार
Intro faltu....baki bohot badiya
पुस्तक की लिंक भी कॉमेंट और description में दे दीजिए द्विवेदी जी।।
J sai deepak is must on Kitabwala
Suggestion noted, sir.
@lallantop जे साई दीपक कब आ रहे हैं ?
Thank you 🙏
I had never heard of Pandurang Kankoje before and that he was the originator of Green Revolution concept. Thanks
अच्छा काम किया है किताब पर ❤
This is how history should be taught
रियल हीरो जो राष्ट्र के लिए अपनी जान दे दिए, और जो अंग्रेजी के रखैल थे वो सता पर बैठ गए 🤬🤬🤬🤬
My request to u keep this "KITABWALA" Series separate playlist in your channel. Plz it's a request.
Sourabh dwivedi , ko sunane main maja aatahai ! Yaddyapi ye bahut bareek kism ke chatukar buddhijivi hain ! Phir bhi koshish karate hain ki Modi bhakti jahir na ho! Itani maryada banaye rakhana bhi achchha lagata hai ! Itane kabil salahkar ke hote ,Modi ji kyon desh , javano , kisano , mahila pahalwano ka bantadhar kar rahe !
Maharashtra me Chatrpati Shivaji Maharaj ke samay me bal ki upasana par bahut jor Diya tha .bal yane Shakti .
બહુજ સરસ ભાઇ આભાર 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Brilliant interview!
Great discussion..
Thanks Sanjeev Sanyal for such excellent book. Is he in any way related to Sachindra Nath Sanyal
Description me book buying link na ho kar shilajeet???
लफ़्ज़ों के हेर-फेर से इतिहास को बदला नहीं जा सकता चाहे कितना ही संज्ञा के साथ खूबसूरत से खूबसूरत शब्दों से क्यों ना संवारा जाए l पिछले दौर में भी सत्ताधारी ने अपने फायदे के लिए इतिहास को बदलने की कोशिश की है लेकिन इतिहास इतिहास रहा है चाहे ओह दौर खंडहर में ही कइयों ना बदल जाए l
Asli tu hi bata de motherboard...Abdul teri herogiri band karwa dunga.
@@vickydonor5922 mere comment per tipni kren se se pahle dheyan purwak wakkiyon per wichar to kr liye hote..
Sawarker Kala pani jis Jai me the Kiya ager oh khandhar ban jata hai to Kiya itihas badal jaye ga..chahe koyi bhi sttadhari aa jaye....aur use kitni hi shbdon ka her pher kre...apne vivek me raha kro..
Mahan veer savarkar ji ki jai ho🙏
Pleasant conversation
Thanks Lallantop for enlightening us through genuine sharp minds
Great job by saurabhji. Keep it up
Angint kranti karyon ki kurbani sa hman mili ha.unko koti2 naman ji
सुभाष चंद्र बोस ने महात्मा गांधी को ऐसे ही नहीं बापू का संबोधन नहीं दिया। स्वतंत्रता आंदोलन में सशस्त्र प्रति रोध का भी एक महत्वपूर्ण योगदान रहा है।इसे रेखांकित करने के लिए सान्याल साहब का धन्यवाद।
વીર સાવરકર સાહેબ ❤
👌 bohot sahi
આભાર 🙏
Movie is needed, on bigger screen, under powerful direction for greater impact!