You all probably dont give a shit but does someone know a trick to log back into an Instagram account..? I was dumb lost my password. I would love any assistance you can offer me!
@Connor Korbin I really appreciate your reply. I got to the site through google and Im waiting for the hacking stuff atm. I see it takes a while so I will reply here later with my results.
Interesting film and I quite enjoyed it, but I must correct one careless and erroneous point that was brought up. Culzean Castle was built in 1780 by Robert Adam, we are informed. We are later told (43:19) that "we know from documentary sources that he used dynamite to level the site of the previous castle" (-- Mark Davis, expedition leader narrating). Um... Mark -- dynamite was invented by Alfred Nobel in 1867, nearly a hundred years after Robert Adam constructed Culzean Castle. Dynamite consists of nitroglycerin stabilized in a sawdust mixture, making it relatively safe to handle and use. In 1780 Robert Adam would have used blasting powder, which is simply coarsely grained, packed black gunpowder.
@@kflo8634 we have them in NZ too and years ago my husband said he had surprise for me and to close my eyes and hold out my hand. Huntsman spider, which when I freaked, ran up the sleeve of my jumper. I was so trusting then...
@@jowalden-evans2951 lol, years ago my husband and I were watching a scary movie which I don’t like so I cover my eyes at what I deem scary parts. My husband told me it’s not a scary part so I trusted him, and yeah needless to say I don’t trust him like that anymore.
When speaking in her own native accent (as opposed to the refined Queen's English she reserves for her own TV programs), Alice Roberts reminds me of Phil Harding from Time Team.
The culvert came from "a" castle above, who is going to build a culvert for a cave , - a easy way for toilet and maybe getting rid of a chopped up body
We found human remains encased in a sheep's bladder within a earthen vessel on top of a hearth... Either a primitive souse vide or early attempt at human based haggis.
It makes me happy that he learned "culvert" and is using it properly and enthusiastically in context whenever possible. Good on you mate. I'm not even English.
Of course. I think everyone was a cannibal at some point during the animalistic religion era. Jealousy is a powerful thing. If you believed that eating someone would endow you with their ‘powers’... add a dash of hunger.... it’s too easy to imagine.
Not only are those ladies serious scientists, they are just plain badasses! The supply team made work for themselves by not thinking of boats. Using one to take the gear round at high tide, lletting it settle on the beach, then leaving with the next convenient tide would have saved a lot of hauling.
We found human remains encased in a sheep's bladder within a earthen vessel on top of a hearth... Either a primitive souse vide or early attempt at human based haggis.
Worthy exploration, very enjoyable! However, reasons to employ gloves include protecting hands from wear and applied substances, such as hydrochloric acid, and preventing oils from despoiling the dig. As gloves have been around since at least 440 BC, I do wonder why this team didn't know about them.
People seem to be obsessed with this idea on so many history/historical documentaries. While human hands do contain some natural oils they don't contain quite as many as other body parts might - and many oils get pulled away from the skin through normal use and in harsh conditions (like cold). So there are far fewer oils on your hands than you realize. Gloves can interfere with a lot of dexterity. Even surgical gloves - which can stick or pull. Other types of gloves can snag or deposit fibers. The environment these fragments have been in is not hermetic so they are already being exposed to a variety of environmental factors that might erode or damage them. The minuscule trace contact that might occur when a professional picks them up or touches them isn't likely to change their level of decomposition. Once they have moved to a lab or new location there is a VERY good chance that hands have been washed before handling. You can see when they begin to examine the infant bone that her hands are quite clean and the bone is, too. Additionally, the sense of touch can be quite good when it comes to texture. You lose that sense when you use gloves. Gloves are not always required and can hinder many investigations.
@@SilverXeno All very good points! I suppose the reaction many have (and certainly I had) was more from watching human hands sift through really dreadful-looking muck rather than despoiling artefacts. But I will say, when he was using hydrochloric acid bare-handed, that was a tipping point for me; I think a pair of well-fitting protective gloves might've been in order. : )
@@SilverXeno It’s not about changing the level of decomposition, for me personally, it’s about contamination. Science is far beyond “fibers” at this point. Pollens and even bacteria specific to certain bodies of water are regularly presented as evidence in modern criminal and environmental trials. It’s about epithelials. It’s about not calling some shmuck regurgitating googled mixed facts (like Adams using dynamite to build the castle🤪), “history”. It’s inconceivable to me that in the field of medicine, which is now forever intertwined with archaeology, not wearing gloves would be in any way, anything but unacceptable ...yet you’re babbling about them pinching? Really? That wouldn’t fly at a taco stand let alone a professional dig.“How *strange* ”! It’s as if the walls have just emerged out of the rock.” 🙄 what castle is anyone aware of that didn’t drain into nearest water source? Just yikes. It’s a scientific abomination and now we may never know to what family that poor baby belonged in the world. Pinched. Pffft!
@@i50519 We won't find that 'poor baby's family', because they likely were long dead with no records, much less DNA for them. But sure, it's got something to do with a small bit of extra contamination as opposed to the crap it's been stewing in for decades. Get over yourself.
Are there any follow up videos detailing what the team experts found and concluded after studying all the artifacts? At this stage, what can be said about their findings?
"Dear Sir, I am glad to hear that your studio audience disapproves of the last skit as strongly as I. As a naval officer I abhor the implication that the Royal Navy is a haven for cannibalism. It is well known that we have the problem relatively under control, and that it is the R.A.F. who now suffer the largest casualties in this area. And what do you think the Argylls ate in Aden? Arabs? Yours etc. Captain B. J. Smethwick in a white wine sauce with shallots, mushrooms and garlic."[
_all the finds were unfortunately lost_ This sounds so awfully familiar... As a kid, I found an antique in a river bend, but a relative of mine tossed it to scrap metal. My mother found fossils and her mother trashed them and beat her for playing with rocks... However, the saddest story goes to one German guy, who made revolutionary discoveries studying dinosaurs and he was happy enough that a special exhibition in a museum honored his lives work. The museum and all his finds were soon thereafter destroyed in WWII...
I don't think the 1960s archeologists really wanted to be there. Oh no a spider. I guess that means we're done. Can you imagine telling your boss that you have to stop working because you saw a spider? Caves are full of spiders. That one was just introducing itself. Get back to work.
And define "huge spider". It's Scotland. They don't have actual huge spiders in the UK. Unless the thing is at least the size of your palm, get back to work. If it is that big, kill it, then get back to work.
Well, they were amateurs, so no boss, but still it sounds rather implausible unless they were preteen girls. (not being sexist- I just know how most preteen girls are!)
I realize this is a little bit older of a show but they had bright lights that are fairly small. Why don't they light the cave up better. It will be an advantage for the arciologists and for the viewers.
I think this is the only time anyone is ever excited to know that there was cannibalism going on. If someone were to find a cannibal now, they would probably be sentenced to death.
No need to waste dead enemy bodies - and prisoners of war. Someone needs to feed the dogs of the farmsteads, palaces, and military bases. Cannibalism is not expected, but boiling down the meat, skin, and bones for these critters - and they would be highly fed.
what year is this originally from? bc the equipment looks outdated and the photography style seems quite late 90s - early 00s. I wonder what it would look like if it were made with new technology and... you know... a bit of professionalism
@@ninchennino4451 I don't even know if technology is substantially better... They're still 3d modeling the site just with more data points. The best analysis they got in this case was still based on educated humans identify discrete sets of bones visually. Maybe Inexpensive rapid DNA analysis by taking samples and proving the relationships and ages between individuals. I answered my own question. Nevermind.
With new studies there is a vast horde of racial-national populations of people across Scotland, Wales, and England. There were the ancient British, who were conquested by the Romans, who left. And the Anglo-Saxons (Chinese Huangs) came into the Isles and walked all over England, (pushing the British into Wales and Scotland) and the Picts to the North. The there were Irish who invaded into northern Wales, across Galloway-Carrick all the way across and into Northumbria-York, and up along all the Irish sea Islands and western Scotland. Then the (first wave) of Finngaills (Finn-gaelics) of Norse who first invaded all of northern Scotland, Orkneys, Shetlands, Irish sea islands (King of Isles, Man, and Hebrides, and into northern kingdom of Tyrone (Ulster) and eastern Ireland (Kingdom of Meath), and also walked around Galloway-Carrick across to Northumbria-York. The second wave of Dano-Norse, that Dubgaills, Dub-gaelics traversed across the same lands (as the known Vikings) of greater Scotland, Ireland, sea islands, and that of the middle Galloway-Carrick to Northumbria-York lands. In fact, in those 750-1000 CE times, there was a vast GREAT ARMY of Dano-Norse that fought against all these other national populations - and infighting amongst themselves for the High Kingship of Ireland, Galloway-Carrick, and Northumbria-York. Then you have the Normans from Norway into northern Neustria down into Normandy and Brittany, and eventually into England and southern Scotland, and with time expanding into Wales. Scottish and English adventures since the times of King John of England, and later King Robert Bruce of Scotland getting involved with the sea islands and that of Northern Ireland and Dublin area. In those post-1066 times, international immigration was allowed up into the 1300s, when national identity and isolationism stopped such Scottish and English importing of Flemish, Germans, Italians, Bretons, and Spanish during the times of King Edward I - II - III and English-Scottish, English-French wars for imperial expansionism. The whole area of the British-Irish Isles is a polyglot of native and western EURO bloodlines ... and the Chinese/Asian populations of the Huns, Angles, Saxons, Jutes, Varangians.
@@anneangstadt1882 It is recent discoveries of the all histories of those Asian/Indian nations. The Wu Hei (from the Siberian Steppes) were the first invaders of China and India, (that was repeated by the Monghols in the 1200s across the same Chinese and Asian lands. Looking at all of the migratiung hordes of 400s-500s tribes in the failing Byzantine and Roman Empires, on sees that all these groups were all associated in some fashion of location and race. It was first found that the Goths (Ostrogoths/East Goths and Visigoths/West Goths) were descended from the Indian Gautama tribe. This caused further increased discoveries that the Vandals were the Indian Panthali tribe. The CATHARS (of later times) were from the Indian Kothari tribe. The Visigoths settled into the Neustria (southern Normandy and Breton region, as well as taking over the abandoned Roman villas of Portugal, Spain, and into North Africa - of which the dark-skinned Berbers (not originally of Arabic descent) were these dark-skinned Berbers. Huns, Angles, Saxons, Jutes all have the implied German origin - but they were migrants THROUGH the German lowlands into the Dutch/Holland/Lowlands areas, settling also into the northern Neustria regions (west Gaul/France and Flanders). It is these groups that came into the Scottish and English lands as noted with Hengist and Horsa. It is then with studies of Chinese history, Chinese civil war, eventual failure (like Roman Empire) that the Huang dynasty and Huang capitol were these named refugee populations. Huns are these Huangs. Angles (a bastardized EURO word) is another Huang-les tribal group. The Sax-ons were the Southern Chinese group of these Huangs - South Huangs, just like the many names of the Anglo-Saxons with their petty kingdoms of Wessex (West Saxons), Essex (East Saxons), Sussex (South Saxons), Anglia (Angles), Norfolk (North Saxons). Another group that migrated into the western region of Russia were the Varangians and Slavs. The Varangians are a hybrid group of Persian/Parsi/Farsi - Chinese Huangs. The Slavs, Tsu Laus appear to be a religious group much like Confucius (Kung "Fu Tse", Rabbi Kung), Lau Tsu (Rebbe Lau ... Lav), Sun Tsu (Rebbe Sung). The Jutes (Ju Tse, Rabbi Yu) would be another religious group. There is also strong suggestion that the name of Scandinavia would be the Saxon Huangs and Varangian groups from Norway to the Russian borders. It might be hard to accept, but these are the times when such (modern) linguistics are said to be Indo-Aryan (east to western movement), versus the more ancient languages were Aryan-Indo (EURO into Mideast into India/Asia). And to say that these refugee groups were pure Chinese or pure Hindu is NOT SAID. They were also a mixture of peoples in each group with other intra-nationals. The Anglo-Saxons of Scotland and England were not epicanthial fold eyes, but having a darker, more yellow Asian appearance than the ancient British-Welsh that were shoved out. Over time these oriental features were bred out during the times of the Anglo-Saxons 450s-750-900s with the intrusions of Irish, and Dano-Norse Finngaills and Dubgaills coming into the land and having political marriages and peace treaties with these Angles and Saxons across England and Northumbria-York. At the time or the Normans, another branch of those same peoples coming down into the Lowlands and western shoreline of western France, Normandy, and Brittany, their features were also outbred, and still not looking like any modern Welsh, Brit, Scot, or Irish. There are other substantiations that truly compare actual ancient knowledge of events with (said) modern historian "interpretations," that is not being told - and should be.
Interesting, but too little information, too short a dig, insufficient evidence, and overall not thorough enough. It seems overly glamorized for tv and not a true effort to examine the caves.
It has to be ruled out by the local police before they can continue on. It didn't necessarily have to be a murder case, could be a missing persons one. Human remains wasn't something they expected to find. It probably didn't take more than an hour or so for police to conclude it. Quite easy when you already have an expert in such things on site. She knew by looking at it it wasnt recent but they're required to tell local police.
I don't think they called the police for the sake of drama, I believe that's what you're supposed to do even in the US. Even if they look old as shit, you are best served by getting the police out and reporting it. I don't think any of them assumed it was a recent murder, just being diligent.
The weird thing is that NOWHERE do they speak of the possibility that these human remains were a food source. The title is extremely misleading. They don't speak of legends of cannibals inhabiting the caves, but of smugglers...
There have been acts of cannibalism everywhere in the world. They didn’t have McDonald’s a few miles down the street or Applebee’s next door 😂 people would get hungry so they would... eat other people... sorry that’s not funny
I read the Wikipedia write up on Alexander "Sawney" Beane and his small Clan in the 16th century and over a period of 25 years according to legend 1,000 victims were mentioned, that would be a lot of bones. Poor Alexander and his wife had as reported eight sons and six daughters 18 grandsons and 14 granddaughters. Childhood death was common and living in the cave they may have been buried deeper in the cave and washed down the common path. There were many who claimed this highway man not only robbed his victims and hid the booty in the cave but also their butchered bodies in the cold cave to be consumed later as needed. Another note: This legend also was in the time when the English disliked the Scots and portrayed them as a bunch of wild men and the tale would have supported that theory or propaganda at that time. It was quite different then, there is much written upon this topic, legend or myth. As legend goes they were tracked down, the men executed and the women burned in Edinburgh.
Im an archeologist, and its bullshit that you cant use your bare hands, you cant use your bare hands whit books only. And you have to be extra carefull whit leather, and glass. But pottery and bones are pretty touchable, but of course you must be carefull whit it. They were professionals.
This Charlie's angels format of archeological theme is really annoying. I mean what's the purpose of this guy there? What is he adding to this expedition and why the ladies have to answer to him about everything. Go and check it out yourself in your are of expertise or be a producer.
Sadly this series just doesn't gel. Time Team was much better. Marc comes across too DRA-MAT-IC as presenter. Hopefully trips were planned better and editing made it less sensible!
You can tell she's a real archaeologist by how often she says "it's difficult to say at this stage".
I like that better than one's who claim something and force the evidence to fit their pet theory
Critical thinking... If only it were more common .
You all probably dont give a shit but does someone know a trick to log back into an Instagram account..?
I was dumb lost my password. I would love any assistance you can offer me!
@Cayden Xzavier Instablaster =)
@Connor Korbin I really appreciate your reply. I got to the site through google and Im waiting for the hacking stuff atm.
I see it takes a while so I will reply here later with my results.
Interesting film and I quite enjoyed it, but I must correct one careless and erroneous point that was brought up. Culzean Castle was built in 1780 by Robert Adam, we are informed. We are later told (43:19) that "we know from documentary sources that he used dynamite to level the site of the previous castle" (-- Mark Davis, expedition leader narrating).
Um... Mark -- dynamite was invented by Alfred Nobel in 1867, nearly a hundred years after Robert Adam constructed Culzean Castle. Dynamite consists of nitroglycerin stabilized in a sawdust mixture, making it relatively safe to handle and use. In 1780 Robert Adam would have used blasting powder, which is simply coarsely grained, packed black gunpowder.
Thank you, that's very interesting
I noticed that too. Thanks for explaining.
Ooops!
Thanks Charlie
i'm hoping it was a slip of the tounge no one noticed
"It's an animal bone"
"How do you know?"
" Because I have a PhD you frikken bellend!"
"Ginormous spider."
Me: *laughs in Australian*
Probably sounds like _oi oi oi_
I nearly died of freight when I almost ran into a golden orb's web. Thankful I haven't seen a huntsman yet.
@@kflo8634 we have them in NZ too and years ago my husband said he had surprise for me and to close my eyes and hold out my hand. Huntsman spider, which when I freaked, ran up the sleeve of my jumper. I was so trusting then...
@@jowalden-evans2951 lol, years ago my husband and I were watching a scary movie which I don’t like so I cover my eyes at what I deem scary parts. My husband told me it’s not a scary part so I trusted him, and yeah needless to say I don’t trust him like that anymore.
I would love to explore those caves. Did anyone else get nervous when they were digging around the base of the pillar that was holding up the roof?
Alice,s team are fantastic. The all contribute to a very informed dialogue. Thankyou ladies.
I read about a Scottish cannibal named "Sawney Bean" when i was young.
Yeah, I have as well. Except his name was Groundskeeper Willie and he had to turn to cannibalism when his retirement grease was stolen.
@@robertschumann7737 He's got an entire school of children to eat.
Wait like hange's Titans from aot
People will eat anything when they are in desperate need.
Including the rich according to Rousseau
@LAFOLLETTER which is often the logical result of food deserts and over priced healthy foods
@LAFOLLETTER Yup. That is the most ignorant thing I've read all day.
That still doesn't justify boiled cabbage 🤢
@@speakupriseup4549 Nothing justifies boiled cabbage
YES DISCOVER THAT OLD CASTLE
@LAFOLLETTER you beat me to it lol
@5:05 I thought I saw a tuft of Phil Hardings hair 🤣
This is a mind numbing dig ,it got me intrigued to know more ,so you gotta go back again
Is there a part 2?? Some kind of summary or more complete commentary was needed.
Recognize Katie n Alice from Time Team digs! Great to see they're advancing and still digging!!
“Ah a mug”
*tucks back into the clif*
Honestly the delivery team are the hero’s of these episodes.
When speaking in her own native accent (as opposed to the refined Queen's English she reserves for her own TV programs), Alice Roberts reminds me of Phil Harding from Time Team.
If Phil was involved in this there would be flint everywhere... and Mick would have found saxon graves 😆
The culvert came from "a" castle above, who is going to build a culvert for a cave , - a easy way for toilet and maybe getting rid of a chopped up body
If they don't find an ancient deep-fat fryer then the answer's 'No'.
We found human remains encased in a sheep's bladder within a earthen vessel on top of a hearth... Either a primitive souse vide or early attempt at human based haggis.
It makes me happy that he learned "culvert" and is using it properly and enthusiastically in context whenever possible. Good on you mate. I'm not even English.
with all that expensive equipment around would it have been to difficult to set up a portable generator and have some good lights in the caves?
Of course. I think everyone was a cannibal at some point during the animalistic religion era. Jealousy is a powerful thing. If you believed that eating someone would endow you with their ‘powers’... add a dash of hunger.... it’s too easy to imagine.
This was really cool, but why does he keep saying "hoo-man"? Is he Ferengi?
Probably not, but it may show that the Ferengi are Scottish.
He's a cat.
Welsh
He said, "Hooge Boulders, too."
Same pronunciation when he says "new" and "view".
the mere presence of one bone does not automatically equal murder
Not only are those ladies serious scientists, they are just plain badasses!
The supply team made work for themselves by not thinking of boats. Using one to take the gear round at high tide, lletting it settle on the beach, then leaving with the next convenient tide would have saved a lot of hauling.
As a kid I would have loved to see this. It's so nice to see lots of women in interesting fields of study nowadays. I hope it continues!
Passionnant ! Merci !
How come this dude Marc is the “leader of the expedition”? He is not an expert archeologist it seems; presenter would be more appropriate?
The introduction was a brief flash back to 1968 and broadcast color TV.
We found human remains encased in a sheep's bladder within a earthen vessel on top of a hearth... Either a primitive souse vide or early attempt at human based haggis.
Worthy exploration, very enjoyable! However, reasons to employ gloves include protecting hands from wear and applied substances, such as hydrochloric acid, and preventing oils from despoiling the dig. As gloves have been around since at least 440 BC, I do wonder why this team didn't know about them.
People seem to be obsessed with this idea on so many history/historical documentaries. While human hands do contain some natural oils they don't contain quite as many as other body parts might - and many oils get pulled away from the skin through normal use and in harsh conditions (like cold). So there are far fewer oils on your hands than you realize. Gloves can interfere with a lot of dexterity. Even surgical gloves - which can stick or pull. Other types of gloves can snag or deposit fibers. The environment these fragments have been in is not hermetic so they are already being exposed to a variety of environmental factors that might erode or damage them. The minuscule trace contact that might occur when a professional picks them up or touches them isn't likely to change their level of decomposition. Once they have moved to a lab or new location there is a VERY good chance that hands have been washed before handling. You can see when they begin to examine the infant bone that her hands are quite clean and the bone is, too. Additionally, the sense of touch can be quite good when it comes to texture. You lose that sense when you use gloves. Gloves are not always required and can hinder many investigations.
@@SilverXeno All very good points! I suppose the reaction many have (and certainly I had) was more from watching human hands sift through really dreadful-looking muck rather than despoiling artefacts. But I will say, when he was using hydrochloric acid bare-handed, that was a tipping point for me; I think a pair of well-fitting protective gloves might've been in order. : )
@@SilverXeno It’s not about changing the level of decomposition, for me personally, it’s about contamination. Science is far beyond “fibers” at this point. Pollens and even bacteria specific to certain bodies of water are regularly presented as evidence in modern criminal and environmental trials. It’s about epithelials. It’s about not calling some shmuck regurgitating googled mixed facts (like Adams using dynamite to build the castle🤪), “history”. It’s inconceivable to me that in the field of medicine, which is now forever intertwined with archaeology, not wearing gloves would be in any way, anything but unacceptable ...yet you’re babbling about them pinching? Really? That wouldn’t fly at a taco stand let alone a professional dig.“How *strange* ”! It’s as if the walls have just emerged out of the rock.” 🙄 what castle is anyone aware of that didn’t drain into nearest water source? Just yikes.
It’s a scientific abomination and now we may never know to what family that poor baby belonged in the world. Pinched. Pffft!
@@i50519 Okay.
@@i50519 We won't find that 'poor baby's family', because they likely were long dead with no records, much less DNA for them. But sure, it's got something to do with a small bit of extra contamination as opposed to the crap it's been stewing in for decades. Get over yourself.
Are there any follow up videos detailing what the team experts found and concluded after studying all the artifacts?
At this stage, what can be said about their findings?
The best of archeology,Thank You
"Dear Sir, I am glad to hear that your studio audience disapproves of the last skit as strongly as I. As a naval officer I abhor the implication that the Royal Navy is a haven for cannibalism. It is well known that we have the problem relatively under control, and that it is the R.A.F. who now suffer the largest casualties in this area. And what do you think the Argylls ate in Aden? Arabs? Yours etc. Captain B. J. Smethwick in a white wine sauce with shallots, mushrooms and garlic."[
The built human bone drama takes away
_all the finds were unfortunately lost_
This sounds so awfully familiar... As a kid, I found an antique in a river bend, but a relative of mine tossed it to scrap metal. My mother found fossils and her mother trashed them and beat her for playing with rocks... However, the saddest story goes to one German guy, who made revolutionary discoveries studying dinosaurs and he was happy enough that a special exhibition in a museum honored his lives work. The museum and all his finds were soon thereafter destroyed in WWII...
I hope they give an update on the caves ☺
The culvert was probably a sewer drain from the old castle.
I don't think the 1960s archeologists really wanted to be there. Oh no a spider. I guess that means we're done. Can you imagine telling your boss that you have to stop working because you saw a spider? Caves are full of spiders. That one was just introducing itself. Get back to work.
And define "huge spider". It's Scotland. They don't have actual huge spiders in the UK. Unless the thing is at least the size of your palm, get back to work. If it is that big, kill it, then get back to work.
Well, they were amateurs, so no boss, but still it sounds rather implausible unless they were preteen girls. (not being sexist- I just know how most preteen girls are!)
I realize this is a little bit older of a show but they had bright lights that are fairly small. Why don't they light the cave up better. It will be an advantage for the arciologists and for the viewers.
I love the show.
Why only 3 day dig?
How old is this.? Need 2022 tech in there.
Love that ancient ingenuity.
Did he actually say “jerry built” pillar at 28:21??? Must mean something different in this part of the world than the U.S.
The world does not revolve around the USA
Fascinating!!😮
I thought that the drainage was from the castle.
To my literal mind there is a vast difference between archaeology (which interests me and spelunking, which frightens me stiff, just like spiders do.
I think this is the only time anyone is ever excited to know that there was cannibalism going on. If someone were to find a cannibal now, they would probably be sentenced to death.
Not in this cave (unless it escaped my notice that the UK has reintroduced the death penalty?)
Not in Scotland they'd get out of jail in a few years
Wow you guys are really ruff, chucking rocks around, destroying everything.
Yes its extremely disrespectful to do that
I woner how many spirits were running around the castle?
Wonder above corr.
...lol.
A smuggler can murder people and still be a smuggler
But now they are also a murderer, ya knob.
Thank you...my mother and her lineage are scots. They come from Edinburgh...
What year was this?
No need to waste dead enemy bodies - and prisoners of war. Someone needs to feed the dogs of the farmsteads, palaces, and military bases. Cannibalism is not expected, but boiling down the meat, skin, and bones for these critters - and they would be highly fed.
Has anyone set this Radar Scan up for VR Tour ??? If so i would Love to see it through my HMD and see things for myself .
what year is this originally from? bc the equipment looks outdated and the photography style seems quite late 90s - early 00s. I wonder what it would look like if it were made with new technology and... you know... a bit of professionalism
According to The Movie Database it’s from 2004, it’s pretty good considering we probably have better technology today.
@@ninchennino4451 I don't even know if technology is substantially better... They're still 3d modeling the site just with more data points. The best analysis they got in this case was still based on educated humans identify discrete sets of bones visually. Maybe Inexpensive rapid DNA analysis by taking samples and proving the relationships and ages between individuals. I answered my own question. Nevermind.
With new studies there is a vast horde of racial-national populations of people across Scotland, Wales, and England. There were the ancient British, who were conquested by the Romans, who left. And the Anglo-Saxons (Chinese Huangs) came into the Isles and walked all over England, (pushing the British into Wales and Scotland) and the Picts to the North. The there were Irish who invaded into northern Wales, across Galloway-Carrick all the way across and into Northumbria-York, and up along all the Irish sea Islands and western Scotland. Then the (first wave) of Finngaills (Finn-gaelics) of Norse who first invaded all of northern Scotland, Orkneys, Shetlands, Irish sea islands (King of Isles, Man, and Hebrides, and into northern kingdom of Tyrone (Ulster) and eastern Ireland (Kingdom of Meath), and also walked around Galloway-Carrick across to Northumbria-York. The second wave of Dano-Norse, that Dubgaills, Dub-gaelics traversed across the same lands (as the known Vikings) of greater Scotland, Ireland, sea islands, and that of the middle Galloway-Carrick to Northumbria-York lands. In fact, in those 750-1000 CE times, there was a vast GREAT ARMY of Dano-Norse that fought against all these other national populations - and infighting amongst themselves for the High Kingship of Ireland, Galloway-Carrick, and Northumbria-York. Then you have the Normans from Norway into northern Neustria down into Normandy and Brittany, and eventually into England and southern Scotland, and with time expanding into Wales. Scottish and English adventures since the times of King John of England, and later King Robert Bruce of Scotland getting involved with the sea islands and that of Northern Ireland and Dublin area.
In those post-1066 times, international immigration was allowed up into the 1300s, when national identity and isolationism stopped such Scottish and English importing of Flemish, Germans, Italians, Bretons, and Spanish during the times of King Edward I - II - III and English-Scottish, English-French wars for imperial expansionism.
The whole area of the British-Irish Isles is a polyglot of native and western EURO bloodlines ... and the Chinese/Asian populations of the Huns, Angles, Saxons, Jutes, Varangians.
What evidence can you cite to support the statement that Anglo-Saxon=Chinese Huang (genetically East Asians? Not critical just curious.
@@anneangstadt1882 It is recent discoveries of the all histories of those Asian/Indian nations. The Wu Hei (from the Siberian Steppes) were the first invaders of China and India, (that was repeated by the Monghols in the 1200s across the same Chinese and Asian lands. Looking at all of the migratiung hordes of 400s-500s tribes in the failing Byzantine and Roman Empires, on sees that all these groups were all associated in some fashion of location and race.
It was first found that the Goths (Ostrogoths/East Goths and Visigoths/West Goths) were descended from the Indian Gautama tribe. This caused further increased discoveries that the Vandals were the Indian Panthali tribe. The CATHARS (of later times) were from the Indian Kothari tribe. The Visigoths settled into the Neustria (southern Normandy and Breton region, as well as taking over the abandoned Roman villas of Portugal, Spain, and into North Africa - of which the dark-skinned Berbers (not originally of Arabic descent) were these dark-skinned Berbers.
Huns, Angles, Saxons, Jutes all have the implied German origin - but they were migrants THROUGH the German lowlands into the Dutch/Holland/Lowlands areas, settling also into the northern Neustria regions (west Gaul/France and Flanders). It is these groups that came into the Scottish and English lands as noted with Hengist and Horsa. It is then with studies of Chinese history, Chinese civil war, eventual failure (like Roman Empire) that the Huang dynasty and Huang capitol were these named refugee populations. Huns are these Huangs. Angles (a bastardized EURO word) is another Huang-les tribal group. The Sax-ons were the Southern Chinese group of these Huangs - South Huangs, just like the many names of the Anglo-Saxons with their petty kingdoms of Wessex (West Saxons), Essex (East Saxons), Sussex (South Saxons), Anglia (Angles), Norfolk (North Saxons).
Another group that migrated into the western region of Russia were the Varangians and Slavs. The Varangians are a hybrid group of Persian/Parsi/Farsi - Chinese Huangs. The Slavs, Tsu Laus appear to be a religious group much like Confucius (Kung "Fu Tse", Rabbi Kung), Lau Tsu (Rebbe Lau ... Lav), Sun Tsu (Rebbe Sung). The Jutes (Ju Tse, Rabbi Yu) would be another religious group. There is also strong suggestion that the name of Scandinavia would be the Saxon Huangs and Varangian groups from Norway to the Russian borders.
It might be hard to accept, but these are the times when such (modern) linguistics are said to be Indo-Aryan (east to western movement), versus the more ancient languages were Aryan-Indo (EURO into Mideast into India/Asia).
And to say that these refugee groups were pure Chinese or pure Hindu is NOT SAID. They were also a mixture of peoples in each group with other intra-nationals. The Anglo-Saxons of Scotland and England were not epicanthial fold eyes, but having a darker, more yellow Asian appearance than the ancient British-Welsh that were shoved out. Over time these oriental features were bred out during the times of the Anglo-Saxons 450s-750-900s with the intrusions of Irish, and Dano-Norse Finngaills and Dubgaills coming into the land and having political marriages and peace treaties with these Angles and Saxons across England and Northumbria-York. At the time or the Normans, another branch of those same peoples coming down into the Lowlands and western shoreline of western France, Normandy, and Brittany, their features were also outbred, and still not looking like any modern Welsh, Brit, Scot, or Irish.
There are other substantiations that truly compare actual ancient knowledge of events with (said) modern historian "interpretations," that is not being told - and should be.
No just no on every level you are wrong words spouted in confidence should not be taken as facts
@@johnlord8337 I guess this could explain why I find Asian women so hot...
@@johnlord8337 What a load of old cobblers! Is the earth flat in your world too?
Interesting, but too little information, too short a dig, insufficient evidence, and overall not thorough enough. It seems overly glamorized for tv and not a true effort to examine the caves.
"Different age in geology, no in archeology" :D
🎯British documentary are the most interesting!
BRAVO 🤘👨🏫👍📡
Culd it be so simple as they used it as access to the see?
The fact that you found bones in a cave doesn't necessarily mean a murder took place. I did enjoy the video though.
It has to be ruled out by the local police before they can continue on. It didn't necessarily have to be a murder case, could be a missing persons one. Human remains wasn't something they expected to find. It probably didn't take more than an hour or so for police to conclude it. Quite easy when you already have an expert in such things on site. She knew by looking at it it wasnt recent but they're required to tell local police.
I don't think they called the police for the sake of drama, I believe that's what you're supposed to do even in the US. Even if they look old as shit, you are best served by getting the police out and reporting it. I don't think any of them assumed it was a recent murder, just being diligent.
The one's I track have given us a great example of what they the Supernatural Beings are up to in a natural pattern of their beingness. Ian Armstrong.
I want time team!
Bars on the window down the side if the castle,thats an odd place to put them!
It’s to keep people out
The weird thing is that NOWHERE do they speak of the possibility that these human remains were a food source. The title is extremely misleading. They don't speak of legends of cannibals inhabiting the caves, but of smugglers...
21:36 she explains why they’re not likely victims of cannibalism
Creepy ass place.
This series promises and promises ... and never delivers. Sigh.
Castle Volkihar
Graveyard? Just a thought how close etc
There have been acts of cannibalism everywhere in the world. They didn’t have McDonald’s a few miles down the street or Applebee’s next door 😂 people would get hungry so they would... eat other people... sorry that’s not funny
Yes it is! I'm hungry! 😈
People still eat people today. Sometimes it's not a hunger thing.
Most of the time it is a hunger thing, though.
@james cowboy trying to get the link to work. I'm on a tablet.
@james cowboy got it, thanks! I watched it and it was interesting.
Why all the fuss to rappel down the cliff when they could have just used the sea level entrance to the finds as was done by the police?
Not only in this castle...
why the repetitive noise in the background, It distracts and is really, really annoying!
Early! Also sometime so wonder why schools don't teach us this qwq
It's a school
@@user-yd3sp9fd2d hm true true
Of course schools teach archaeology, anthropology and AP history. None are required, unfortunately.
Survival cannibalism?
Canibalism in Scotland?? Oh yes!! That is wide spread there! Personally, I like nibbling a matured scotch myself .... on the rocks.
I recognize Katie from her occasional involvement in Time Team episodes.
I read the Wikipedia write up on Alexander "Sawney" Beane and his small Clan in the 16th century and over a period of 25 years according to legend 1,000 victims were mentioned, that would be a lot of bones. Poor Alexander and his wife had as reported eight sons and six daughters 18 grandsons and 14 granddaughters. Childhood death was common and living in the cave they may have been buried deeper in the cave and washed down the common path. There were many who claimed this highway man not only robbed his victims and hid the booty in the cave but also their butchered bodies in the cold cave to be consumed later as needed. Another note: This legend also was in the time when the English disliked the Scots and portrayed them as a bunch of wild men and the tale would have supported that theory or propaganda at that time. It was quite different then, there is much written upon this topic, legend or myth. As legend goes they were tracked down, the men executed and the women burned in Edinburgh.
Now way I could not not click on that title
What are the odds that McDonalds were eaten.
Mc is Irish, Mac is Scottish.
My last name is Donald
We are going to name our next son Ronald Mac
two people from (TimeTeam) Yea
well some of them clearly arent experts because THEYRE TOUCHING THINGS WITH THEIR BARE HANDS! THE O I L S
Im an archeologist, and its bullshit that you cant use your bare hands, you cant use your bare hands whit books only. And you have to be extra carefull whit leather, and glass. But pottery and bones are pretty touchable, but of course you must be carefull whit it. They were professionals.
@@johannakadar4314 Why glass?
@@componenx because glass is realy demagable, and if it get exposed too much to the sun, or water it can easily broke, or get damaged.
LOL, what bs is that? It's not a crime scene. You can absolutely touch artifacts with your hands when digging/searching, I've done it multiple times.
This Charlie's angels format of archeological theme is really annoying. I mean what's the purpose of this guy there? What is he adding to this expedition and why the ladies have to answer to him about everything. Go and check it out yourself in your are of expertise or be a producer.
early this is my favourite channel to watch.
(First comment to even comment in this video)
Same
@@knightshade1297 yes 🙌
Why does Time Team not have the police come when they find human bones?
Actually, i think they did once or twice.
Ha someone told him to tone down the accent lolz 😆
Oh Alice ... It's always wonderful to hear your explanations ... but your hair color ... I need sunglasses ...
Alice, yumm
I'm a super smart archeologist. What's a culvert?
Dem drains and tunnels
Well he is actually a geologist, he studies rocks not what they make.
@@fezt.v.1569 Still, he's not the sharpest pick in the shed...
😱😱
What the hell is this "spoopy" background music?! It really isn't needed and doesn't fit the video
Why did the police personnel not do the rappelling down the cliff? Was there a safety concern about the cliff activity?
Don't think modern police are trained in it.
Ah the archaeology ladies. Excellent watch. They let the man do the work. I love bones-lady.
What
@Jhalmuriম্যাটার More like dragging that peace of radar around the slope.
@Jhalmuriম্যাটার what?
@Jhalmuriম্যাটার *what*
@Jhalmuriম্যাটার dude what?
cancarius sablbdston
Sounds a little too fake for my taste... No thanks
Hey remember the time I only had 1 toothbrush and I had to excavate?
Nothing saves time like brushing teeth while brushing dust off bones...
"hooman"
okay lm creeped out now seeing that spider
Sadly this series just doesn't gel. Time Team was much better. Marc comes across too DRA-MAT-IC as presenter. Hopefully trips were planned better and editing made it less sensible!
That where’s before Noach
Its a cannibal from de pride isle sanatorium
Dis is a joke :)
basaltcave