I really dislike this saying as it oversimplifies the matter and encourages people to simply ignore statistical data that doesn’t align with their beliefs instead of deducing shortcomings and inaccuracies based on the biases of the one that compiled the data to get a more accurate picture.
I feel like these videos are just being made to get watch time. Usually they just recite facts without much thought... i am a bit jaded on these low quality "professional sounding" channels...
If you want to look at charts, find them somewhere else. This channel's videos tell a story quoting various sources, so charts don't fit the style used here.
@@TheRavensOmen I meant the statement has valid ground, essentially the attacker has goals they need to achieve, land they need to take, the defender only has to stay still. the defender doesnt have to "push" for a victory they just need to hold out
But the terms of a “win” is different for both sides. Russia can claim a successful campaign by fully occupying the Donbas region, while Ukraine could also claim comity by successfully maintaining their sovereignty.
@@stevemawer848 Rofl oh my god it always entertains me to see clips of USA tv media (with fox being the worst by far) if they report on a dog snapping after being hit... fox would describe it as the most vicious attack in history by an animal! Blood was everywhere and there is no doubt that the leaders of the dog nation are plotting to overtrow society! Wish I was kidding but fox is beyond bullshit with most of the clips i see. Good laugh though for sure, but for me it almost amazes and scares me that people watch 'Interpretations of very select footage' instead of a factual coverage.😂
@@stevemawer848 as compared to bbc and cnn yes they’ve been caught posting faulty stories on many people and if you don’t want to admit it then you’re just brainwashed sorry bud
Ukrainian here. We have enough troops, we don’t have enough equipment. There are tens of thousands of soldiers sitting in reserves without ammo or armor or equipment. We need western support more than ever right now
Tak mają 14 brygad bez uzbrojenia ćwiczą na starych polskich bwp1. To zlom ,nie wolno wyszkolonych ludzi wysłać na mieso. . W polsce tworzymy legie ukraińska. Będzie brygada. Wyszkolona jako jednostka,,metoda nato. Uzbrojona i dzialajaca jak jedność. Nie jako uzupełnienie jednostek w ukrainie. Również jest gwarancja rotacji,i wyposarzenia w broń. Gdyby kazdy kraj zrobil to ukraina miałaby kilkanaście porządnych brygad.
หลายเดือนก่อน +41
Some is ready and some is there, but it's moving slowly and being distributed too slowly. The logistics flowing in must exceed the other side to ensure triumph. WW2 was won by the US industrial base. So far, DPRK and China are sending much more ammo than the West sends to Ukraine. This gap must be filled as soon as possible as a matter of pride of coalition partners to ensure a Ukrainian victory.
I just voted in a local primary in the USA, making it a priority to nominate only representatives and senators who support sending equipment to Ukraine. There's a second election after this, from those who passed the first mark, and I--and others--will again make it a priority to elect those who will keep you supplied. Most of us have been horrified that a few truly crazy politicians managed to tie up aid for you for so long, and we will do everything we can to see that this doesn't happen again.
Don't forget there's thousands and thousands of unclaimed Russian soldiers lying in fields and the ones that died in their vehicles and tanks which have been incinerated and buried in collapsed cellars and buildings. Its all very well checking cemeteries but you have to accept those unclaimed too.
Exactly. The figure produced by that pointless study only offers an absolute bare minimum that would be far more inaccurate than any reasonable guess. It's been clear since the start of the war that the Russian government just labels a serious percentage of their dead as MIA to keep the KIA numbers down and avoid paying out to families.
“You will kill ten of us, we will kill one of you, but in the end, you will tire of it first.” Ho Chi Minh The Navy Seals had a 200/1 kill death ratio in Vietnam. It’s a mistake to underestimate the power of your enemy’s resolve. The Vietnamese fought the Chinese, then the French, then the Japanese, then the French again, the US.
I remember they actually used 'war crime' carpet bobmardments along with agent orange and napalm Also, do you know what nation is the only one in history that used nuclear weapon against humans?
It's a prop'g'nda piece, I came here to laugh, and I'm somewhat suprised Ya folks belive in this. To recap: Ukr, had 300k, added more then 1mln, supposedly has small losses, and is "slowly" pushed back. Ru had 180k, did 1 mobilization, and got some 30-40k convicts, +some foreign Legion of their own, and had insane losses, but continues to advance. 👌 The only possible explanation: Ru BABUSHKAS are CHEATING by using NECROMANCY!!! confirmed 🤯 Checks out right? Greetings
หลายเดือนก่อน +1
The have to emulate Ross Perot and communicate with graphs and tables.
Depends, during the Iran Iraq war, Iraq had just abit more casualties during the invasion but when Iran took its land back and invaded, their casualties succeeded that of Iraq's.
@@blackbox9641 There's nothing to watch. Only the Ukrainian MoD knows the actual Ukrainian losses and only the Russian MoD knows the Russian losses. Not one of them will reveal the losses in the near future (which is absolutely logical) or even shortly after the war, we will have to wait decades for that.
@blackbox9641 False,the dude behind this video is clearly pushing his own agenda,whoever is folowing this war closely like myself knows that casualities reported on both sides are insanely bloated since both russians and ukraine use betwean 3 and 7 man to attack positions,so theres no way you can suffer 1k casualities a day when 90% of the front is inactive
If you don't know, after drank alcohol, they have a national amusing - sating each other onto (“back doors”) an empty from vodka glass bottles, it's called “planting”...
To be fair, as funny at it sounds it served in the past the purpose of keeping people warm in winter so they don't die from the cold. Thats why is is practically part of their culture.
I watched until 6:38 but bruh you say independent then show US based source lol then give ISW stats like it's truth . Also Russia using human wave tactics and lost more despite having one of the most complex and well prepared defensive line to defend is absurd. I guess no need to contunie because this is extremely biased.
same as reporting that russia ran out of rockets during the first couple of months of the war , it is indeed a bias report when he mentioned human waves tactics as if russia have no regards of their on people while ukr fascist gov cares so much about their people enough to throw them into an offensive as cannon fodder , that also not including the atrocities committed by ukraine against the dombas and luhansk civilian population. Ukrainians fought bravely but there's no point of continuing just to satisfy US weapons manufacturers when they are losing more and more territories year after year . When the Kursk offensive fails eventually it will be game over.
@@filiptodorovic9752 Rusland ? No lendlease ? No millions tons of food from UAS ? No 3500 000 cars for logistics from UAS ? Rusland is tribe from mongolia. And this nation lose war vs Ukraine now xD
It has reached the point where Ukrainians are actively resisting the press gangs and torching their vehicles. Nobody wants to be sent to the front, and no wonder.
You mean abductiong people and brute forcing them Also why ukrainian borders are shut? Why does western borders have more border guards than any other borders including the frontline? And why Zelenskiy admitted that he will temporarily cease to adhere to certain provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights???
The Ukrainian number of russian casualties is not as inflated as you might think. There are countless paramilitary groups like Vagner, Kadyrov's battalions, conscripts from Donetsk and Luhansk "Republics" that were never counted as the russian army to begin with. The cemetaries around cities like Mariupol are full of those, and even more were cremated hastily or left without a proper burial. 2023 was particularly brutal towards those poorly equipped conscripts, with multiple "meat assaults" on launched to stop the Ukrainian troops from taking hold of strategically important settlements. It's a double tragedy, because many of those people were not particularly willing to serve and even to become russian citizens. Another thing that is not inflated is civilian casualties. We now know a reliable estimate of civilian death toll in Bucha and Irpin, because we have access to those towns... But with Mariupol, for instance, we might not know it for years. So many people went missing, buried under debris or hastily buried in their own yards that it's just haunting. How many were forcibly taken to Russia is also unknown. There no intent to inflate the numbers just to show russia is bad - it's evident. It's just due to inability to conduct a proper investigation, like in Bucha.
Bucha didn't happen and you know that. There's literally zero proof of Russian forces executing anyone and with all the modern reality of cameras everywhere it's hard to believe they have ZERO evidence. Putin was declared as a wanted persona for some other reason, if Bucha was real it would be a case against him.
A totally unbiased study from the totally least biased sources to deliver fully educted facts without any bias, lies, nonsense, agenda or demonizing anyone, for sure. I believe Big Brother.
Seriously, about 10,000,000 Ukrainians left Ukraine, and you say only 20,000 were of military age. To the contrary, commonly young men are of higher proportion in immigration, while old people stay. Especially with the reluctance of Ukrainians to be drafted to the military, it is likely much higher proportion of emigration fleeing Ukraine is exactly of military age men.
you don't assume that all men over18 and under 60 were strcitcly prohibited to leave the country from the day 1 of a full scale ru invasion. Those 20k is about 19-59 y o men who escaped the country during the last 2 years
The only accurate information is the one former president Zelenskyy offered, saying that Ukraine lost about 31,000 soldiers, but did not specify in which month.
@phvaessen His presidency ended a few months ago, but he declared himself president for a second term without holding the election required by the constitution. Technically, he is no longer the president and has no legal authority.
@phvaessen His presidency ended a few months ago, but he declared himself president for a second term without holding the election required by the constitution. Technically he is not a president anymore and has no legal power.
Wtf? The data used in this video is at least almost half a year old. Therefore it seems as if the Ukrainian estimates of Russian casualties are not that far off.
They're very much off, look at the amount of mobilizations, seriously... Ru isn't doing forcible mobilizations, Ukr is... whose running out of soliders? The ones who don't force people into service? I'm not a fan of Put¡n, but that doesn't mean I will accept media lies... Many of ukr troops d¡e from wounds, not getting med evac, or because there are supply issues... + most of said wounds come from artillery shelling. Ru uses way more ammunition then ukr... so even if We assume They're inept, at some point there is no more cover to hide behind... - so even the "inept orks" will score a hit Esspecially as there is a massive difference in the artillery shell supply between Ru and ukr. Greetings
I remember thinking on day 1 that this was going to be the biggest mistake of Putin's rule, and to this day I haven't seen anything that proves me wrong. If anything, I didn't fully anticipate how big of a clusterfuck this would be for Russia.
I have seriously wondered if the attack on Kyiv was Putin's doing. He seems like the kind of strategist who would use the troops in Belarus as a massive feint to draw Ukraine's troops to the capital, leaving the Donbas practically undefended which is exactly what happened. They took nearly all the objectives in the east with very few casualties. Most of the troops in the north, including field-grade officers, had no idea they were attacking. Had they left that sector of Ukraine alone, and without the massive war crimes, the west would not have offered the support they have. I honestly wonder if some of the top brass were so overconfident that they decided to pull the trigger themselves.
Those hundreds of thousands of people fleeing Russia not only affect military replacements. They are also the key demographic to work in science, engineering, manufacturing, emergency services, and a hundred other elements needed for society to operate.
My uncle lives in a small city near the front line in Ukraine. They are shelled on a daily basis. Fortunately for him, his father had served in the Great Patriotic War (WW2) and so had dug deep cellars that also served as bomb shelters.
It would have been nice to have side by side comparison numbers. Also, if totals for both sides for all three years were listed, I missed them. It was very scattershot with different sources and different years all be addressed for different sides. I admire the way you discuss pros and cons of the varying sources, but it was hard for me to follow the totals in comparison aside from, “Russia lost more.”
I wonder why video author talks about russian war crimes but not a single word about ukrainian adhere to certain provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights. Basically, Ukraine violated so many human rights, that even Kim Jong Un is shocked. Also for some reason nobody talks how Zelenskiy's presidential term actually expired months ago, but he claims he can't give up power because of martial law that is illegaly extended Also why did ukraine had to pass a law that removes all criminal responsibility for losses of soldiers or vehicles during the war?
Ironically, nuclear weapons made the world much more peaceful than statistics suggest it ought to be. But the risk of the total destruction of civilization with hundreds of millions of deaths always looms over everything.
Pretty shure, Ukraine has, higher casualties then Russia. One report in October 2023, Ukraine sustained 500.000 KIA’s. By now it’s estimated to be, well over 700,000.
Ukraine casualties doesnt include the multiplier of Russian massive artillery, missiles, and FOAB strike. Such a multiplier will cause minimum 5x -7x ukraine casualties.
The economic losses of Russia is unpalatable. Billions upon Billions, and a loss of respect and fear by its neighbours who it has bullied for hundreds of years.
Right. Switzerland is where various nations keep the spoils of conflict. Bc it's a neutral nation, it's the safest place to keep ill gotten gains and traditionally Switzerland over the years has made no distinction between lawful assets and those stolen in war time.
What we kinds forget is that each of those numbers represents a LIFE, a FATHER, a SON, a BROTHER, a SISTER, a MOTHER, a DAUGHTER, a CHILD......also it is an immense number of animals, pets...etc.....So many young souls.....and all this because of a few crazy politicians in Moscow and some corrupt politicians in Kyev. Yeah.....Every time a politician fails, regular people suffer and die!
Wealthy people in both countries have fled to their other homes in different countries or are on travelling visas around the world whereas poor have gone as refugees to different countries
The saddest thing about all these deaths is that this war never had to happen, Putin's ego and paranoia and his desire to somehow reclaim Russia's old imperial glory caused all this...and others are paying the price.
I have to apologize for this LONG rant beforehand!!! ;-) It's certainly Putin's war, but it really IMO reflects Russians' state of mind and their attitude toward their nation. Historically, Russia, as big as it is, has a 'little kid' complex... that it is never taken seriously enough. To show the world that it isn't to be trifled with, it goes about bullying, and then absorbing its little neighbors. It has always done this! Russia hardly needs to be as big as it is, and it is truly an unmanageable size! Even if it was set up with semi-self-governing states like the US, it is still too big. Everything 1000 miles east of Moscow is treated like an unwanted vacant lot, fit only to be used up and as a place to throw their trash and pollution. The Czars acted this way, as did the Bolsheviks, and now Putin. Britain was almost exactly the same since before the Elizabethan era! Not having land at their fingertips though, they went out and stole from any and everyone! After the end of WWII, they found that was no longer to their benefit or had the ability, to maintain AND protect all these colonies! Independence was granted to tons of them and by the '60s, most had gone their own way even while staying within the Commonwealth itself. Even that has dwindled to almost nothing. Canada and Australia are the two big ones remaining. The US has done it as well, obviously, and I'm curious what might have transpired if North America was identical to Russia in terms of size and latitude location!
No, its a grave mistake to lay the responsibility of this war on Putin alone. No, its the russian population in its entirety which, some noble exceptions aside, are die-hard imperialists who think its their God-given right to enslave and brutalize their neighbours. Putin is just a great representative of the russian population at large. But the real evil here is not Putin but russian imperialism.
Sự kiện đáng tiếc này có thể đã không bao giờ xảy ra nếu không có cái tôi của những người tham gia vào cuộc cách mạng Maidan cũng như NATO. Tiêu chuẩn kép.
This is not about Russian egos. It is about not having NATO/US military stationed on Russia's borders. This is the Cuban missile crisis in reverse. If anything, this is because of Westerners' megalomania and egos and their belief that they are to rule the world. This war is in reality a NATO-Russia war and the fight is between a globalist one world order where the West gets to set the rules for the rest of the world on the one hand or a world of sovereign and independent states.
No it isn't. NATO is not at war with Russia. Its Russia and Ukraine who are at war and 50+ Countries (inc NATO countries) support Ukraine financially and militarily. Get it right.
There is only one truth. It is a pity that the people are injured and killed and the beautiful country is reduced to rubble, just because of the greed of people from other countries and other lands.
@@Milan_Openfeint not realy. Half were civilians. Plus Russia's population is smaller as it not the Soviets unions + russas people won't tolerate such high casualtie.s the war in Afghanistan shook the nation apartnin 89
Both spent billions of dollars,both contributed on pollution ( dirtying the air, water and soil),both destroyed the nature,both suffered their respective buildings citizens, economy etc .😢😢😢
@@Sergiu.antifascist Nope. Not even a little. The russian IT market is insane. There are openings everywhere, but most of the top talent has either fled or has been dragged into government service. There are a lot more russian names popping up on candidate lists around the world. The low side of estimates is about 700,000 people in the tech industry gone. That's about a third, minimum, of all tech workers before Putin's mad war to relive lost glory.
@@Canthus13 they have a huge population but their economy is still suffering because most of them men are going to the front buddy nice try ; only mainly those in West Russia and governors in Eastern Districts are alive and surviving
@@chadbrad8100 It's not so deliberate like the Great Purge, but most dictators seem to favor fewer people smarter than them. I wonder if Putin is really that upset about them leaving without him having to spend money on the 'problem'?
They lost so much They didn't do more the one mobilization? While Ukr did 11?! And is considering draging back their men from abroad? That's Ru losing? Please share Your supplier, I never been high enough for that sh¡t to make sense for Me. Greetings
The ones who can finish the war don't fight it and they don't care about those who actually suffer from it. Those who had enough of the war just can not finish it
How can a channel with such a name come up with this assertive, clearly false title, how can anyone have a true number, i doubt the Russians are sharing accurate information about their losses
Neither side are, if you read both the ukrainian and russian claims you see imiediatly that they are totally fake. The overinflate the numbers to the point that neither side would have had any army left if they where true in old soviet style.
Life is what we're living for. Near Sao Paulo Brazil yesterday, 62 souls were lost when the flight they were on crashed. The incident was a tragic accident. War is not a tragic accident but the purposed infliction of death and horror along with total destruction of facilities. Young people are being sacrificed, giving up decades of life they would have otherwise lived. Kurt Vonnegut jr. likened war to an alcoholic puking over the toilet, saying, "I've got to quit drinking". Mark Knopfler wrote and sang, "We are fools to make war on our brothers in arms". Vast monies are involved that could go to other uses or just to have for future needs. It just makes us sick; the destruction, murders, and overall stupidity. Anthony Bourdain said, "The "isms" are now "wasms".
You know... There are always 2 sides to a story. One says this, the other says something else. I don't think any country can give the exact amount of casualties, this war has caused already.
Well Ukraine and Russia know their own losses, but that's about it, nobody else has access to those numbers, even the US probably doesn't know for sure the Ukrainian losses and can only estimate them.
Childish of me but I thought the same, and came to the comments thinking I’d see more of that. Thankfully the comments didn’t go there (much) but I admit I immediately thought it humorous.. looking at that acronym thinking who would seriously make that official? An acronym that reads like “penis”??
In this invasion only RU are sending waves of cannon fodder for a 100 meters of burned land. So it's not very hard to figure out who's in a disadvantaged position for that matter.
It's the Ukrainian dictator who refuses to negotiate for peace. He cancelled elections making himself an illegal dictator. He banned the Orthodox church. Zelensky is the real villain of this story.
Below this I get an ad about "Meet beautiful 35+ slavic women. Lots of Ukrainian women, increasing numbers willing to chat". Oh the irony. Or cynicism. And it's illustrated with a woman standing in a field of poppies. Poppies. Flanders. Lest we never forget.
Your analysis is old all the things your Western Generals mentioned have already occurred, and Ukraine came out on top! You and the Grnerals are still operating under the old But Russia is so big and strong theory. Ukraine has proved that wrong! Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦
The video starts with a lie. The objective wasn't Kiev. It was Donezk, Luhansk and Crimea from the beginning. The US Generals said so. The "Kiev in 3 days" nonsense was invented by the same people who invented "The Ghost of Kiev". The move to Kiev was supposed to bind Ukrainian troops in... Kiev! They then moved on to the regions they annexed. I can't explain in simpler terms. Russia didn't even send a large enough force to capture Kiev, that's why the US analysts (not the pundits) said, that Russia is carrying out a diversion, so Donezk, Luhansk and the land bridge to Crimea can be occupied with less fighting. What's the point in carrying on with the "3 days" joke? NATO was in AFG for 20 years and lost!
So why send a miles long convoy to Kiev from the beginning then? Or better yet, why did they deploy an air assault group to, and they actually tried, to take Kievs airport to airlift troops and gear from a Russian airport that's conveniently standing by? Actions speak louder then words.
@@eddapultstab2078 Yes, listen to your own words! The actions taken were a move on Kiev and then those same troops occupied Luhansk and Donezk. If I want a diversion I actually have to do something to make it believable. The only visible clue was that Russia sent 20% of the troops actually required to sustain a siege on Kiev. Putin was hoping there would a peace deal, but that fell flat after Johnson talked to Zelensky, and we both know he showed him pictures of Saddam and Qaddafi post mortem. Why do you think Volodomyr is always surrounded by Azov instead of the regular troops? in 2019 Azov openly threatened to kill Zelensky, because he wanted a ceasefire and "disrespected" an Azov commander. They expected him to apologize to Azov. The President of Ukraine apologizing to Nazi-scum who refused to follow his orders!
@@UberTankred however they did try to take kievs airport and had several transports waiting to airlift reinforcements there. And if putin really wanted to force negotiations he could have just ordered his troops to simply occupy the donbas and dig instead of a half baked rush to the capital. All your saying is complete rubish.
The problem with Russians is that they value strenght, so expect them allways doble or nothing. Failure is a sign of weakness, so they found a way out of it, they are masters of excuses. That helps them preserve their faces in Russian society, but not addmitting mistakes makes it hard to learn from them, this is like a closed circle. If your plan doesnˇt work, then deny its existence! Fact is, taking Kiev was one of the main objectives of the Russian Army. They wanted Ukrainian leadership to flee or capture and to set up a puppet government, who would have ordered Ukrainain Army to lay down their weapons. If Russia had taken Kiev and lost Donetsk, then you would have said that Donetsk was just a diversion to take Kiev. Classic act. It was Putin who told Poroshenko "If I wanted, Russian troops could be not only in Kiev, but also Riga, Vilnius, Tallinn, Warsaw and Bucharest in two days".
They’re protecting their country from invasion. Pretty sure yours would do the same. Always people like you using “politicians” for everything war related. It’s part of it but it’s overshadowed.
In Kursk there are nuclear and power stations. Kursk, historically on Ukrainians land. Ukrainians going to sell power to EU countries. 😂. The station is the biggest in Europe
The BBC study numbers may be a massive underestimate. They couldn't account for every cemetery, especially those in more rural areas that russia is drawing a lot of its recruits from. Many dead russians are also either not buried, cremated (either at their death or afterwards), or buried in hastily created graveyards in Ukraine.
Russian casualties are at least half a million in total (killed & wounded). Not saying they are higher or lower than those of Ukraine, its just that there's no way russia would need to recruit so many men if they had such low casualties
Biggest loss of human life in this conflict is caused from artillery fire, and Ukraine has suffered heavy losses because Russian fire 60-70000 rounds per day,Ukraine fires nearly 6000.
@@besconst it’s huge number of mercenaries from around the world including some brainwashed Albanians who fought on Ukrainian side that lost their lives in this senseless war.
Putin was a KGB officer before he became the president, he has a military background, selenskiy was a comedian before he became or lets face it, he kinda forced himself into the role and everyone accepted it.
This war is reminiscent of America’s Civil War. No matter how many casualties were suffered by Union armies, every battle was to their advantage as the numerically inferior Confederate army could not sustain similar losses.
It pains me that I am being shown WWI and WWII all over again, the nightmares of 80 years ago coming back to haunt me. Victory! Victory! War, destruction, and killing will not end as long as people continue to cry for victory. And even when the country's chances of victory are lost, politicians, the media, and the people will continue to cry victory until the last day.
As many may remember, at the beginning of the war there was video of a Ukrainian woman telling a Russian invader, "Take these seeds and put them in your pockets so at least sunflowers will grow when you all lie down here." Ukraine must have had some bumper crops of sunflowers the past couple of years. I like sunflowers. The western countries need to send Ukraine more weapons and ammunition so we can have more sunflowers.
One thing you can count on is if Russia is the perceived winner they will dramatically overestimate their own losses to make it seem more heroic. If Russia is seen as the loser they will dramatically underestimate their losses to make it seem closer than it actually was.
I doubt Putin and his regime would inflate their man casualty numbers to make it seem like some “heroic sacrifice”. The war is already becoming unpopular, and high casualties would make the Russian army seem incompetent and make Putin look like a butcher, with no regard for the lives of his troops.
Money is the blood of war. Let's talk about money. We don't know how much Russia spent on the war, it's all classified. But we know how much money Ukraine received. And so, since 2022, Ukraine has received $400 billion in military aid + its costs for the war. For comparison, Steel from 1941-1945 received $ 10 billion, or $ 160 billion at current prices, adjusted for inflation. With this money, Stalin clothed, shod and fed about 11 million soldiers. He built 50,000 tanks, he stormed Berlin, largely thanks to this money. The question is, what did Ukraine do in the amount of 3 times more? And how much more help will she get over the next 2 years? And where did the money go?
![[UNCUT] The Loyal Pin ปิ่นภักดิ์ EP.6 (1/4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/m05kZ2GDKXg/mqdefault.jpg)
That reminds me of something my father used to tell me:
"Never trust statistics you didn't falsify youself."
thats an good piece of advice
We will know when this end someday
That's gold.
It’s been said that if you torture the data enough it will confess to anything
I really dislike this saying as it oversimplifies the matter and encourages people to simply ignore statistical data that doesn’t align with their beliefs instead of deducing shortcomings and inaccuracies based on the biases of the one that compiled the data to get a more accurate picture.
Since the video is about numbers, don’t you think showing some data on a chart or two would make more sense than random clips and cartoons?
I feel like these videos are just being made to get watch time. Usually they just recite facts without much thought... i am a bit jaded on these low quality "professional sounding" channels...
@@julkkis666 The script and voice narration are both AI generated
If you want to look at charts, find them somewhere else. This channel's videos tell a story quoting various sources, so charts don't fit the style used here.
This film was poorly done. The information presented was basically useless.
he has not the proofs for what he talks
The attacker loses if they don't win. The defender wins if they don't lose.
This changes every game ever played thru-out history! In order to win, don't lose! And if you lose, you don't win! Whoaa!!
@@TheRavensOmen *throughout.
How high are you? Also, where can I get some? 😂
@@TheRavensOmen I meant the statement has valid ground, essentially the attacker has goals they need to achieve, land they need to take, the defender only has to stay still. the defender doesnt have to "push" for a victory they just need to hold out
But the terms of a “win” is different for both sides. Russia can claim a successful campaign by fully occupying the Donbas region, while Ukraine could also claim comity by successfully maintaining their sovereignty.
Crazy they use BBC as a reliable source
Yeah, better to rely on Fox.
@@stevemawer848😂😂
@@stevemawer848 Rofl oh my god it always entertains me to see clips of USA tv media (with fox being the worst by far) if they report on a dog snapping after being hit... fox would describe it as the most vicious attack in history by an animal! Blood was everywhere and there is no doubt that the leaders of the dog nation are plotting to overtrow society!
Wish I was kidding but fox is beyond bullshit with most of the clips i see. Good laugh though for sure, but for me it almost amazes and scares me that people watch 'Interpretations of very select footage' instead of a factual coverage.😂
Yeah, that's crazy.
@@stevemawer848 as compared to bbc and cnn yes they’ve been caught posting faulty stories on many people and if you don’t want to admit it then you’re just brainwashed sorry bud
Ukrainian here. We have enough troops, we don’t have enough equipment. There are tens of thousands of soldiers sitting in reserves without ammo or armor or equipment. We need western support more than ever right now
Tak mają 14 brygad bez uzbrojenia ćwiczą na starych polskich bwp1. To zlom ,nie wolno wyszkolonych ludzi wysłać na mieso. . W polsce tworzymy legie ukraińska. Będzie brygada. Wyszkolona jako jednostka,,metoda nato. Uzbrojona i dzialajaca jak jedność. Nie jako uzupełnienie jednostek w ukrainie. Również jest gwarancja rotacji,i wyposarzenia w broń. Gdyby kazdy kraj zrobil to ukraina miałaby kilkanaście porządnych brygad.
Some is ready and some is there, but it's moving slowly and being distributed too slowly.
The logistics flowing in must exceed the other side to ensure triumph. WW2 was won by the US industrial base. So far, DPRK and China are sending much more ammo than the West sends to Ukraine. This gap must be filled as soon as possible as a matter of pride of coalition partners to ensure a Ukrainian victory.
Ukraine needed money NOT WEAPONS
I just voted in a local primary in the USA, making it a priority to nominate only representatives and senators who support sending equipment to Ukraine. There's a second election after this, from those who passed the first mark, and I--and others--will again make it a priority to elect those who will keep you supplied. Most of us have been horrified that a few truly crazy politicians managed to tie up aid for you for so long, and we will do everything we can to see that this doesn't happen again.
@@ClaireBallsmoney and weapons
War is when the young and stupid are tricked by the old and bitter into killing eachother
- Niko Belic
It's a fact! But a lot of people are ignorant
Fine, so if somebody invaded your country, you would immediately surrender?
... 'forced'... conscription is real in both Russia and Ukraine.
Conscription is only a year and all countries should do this- if not for war for preparedness in life at 19 years old both sexes
Ukraine hasn´t been "tricked" into killing anyone. This is 100% on the Russian Federation.
Don't forget there's thousands and thousands of unclaimed Russian soldiers lying in fields and the ones that died in their vehicles and tanks which have been incinerated and buried in collapsed cellars and buildings. Its all very well checking cemeteries but you have to accept those unclaimed too.
Exactly. The figure produced by that pointless study only offers an absolute bare minimum that would be far more inaccurate than any reasonable guess. It's been clear since the start of the war that the Russian government just labels a serious percentage of their dead as MIA to keep the KIA numbers down and avoid paying out to families.
That makes Russian casualties even worse.
Good point!
I think the numbers still would be closer to the 3rd party numbers than the official ones stated by either side
Thousands of deaths will be counted forever as MIA as the remains were vaporised in massive explosions
So sad.
Using BBC for source is the stupid thing i ever see
using western media in general as primary source is the major source of stupidity.
It's true
right!!! only russia today tells the truth.
@@blackbox9641 i dont know what russia say and i dont care but BBC are bunch of liers
@@blackbox9641 Would be enough if you just type "I'm Dumbass"
Didn’t the US claim crazy enemy casualities in Vietnam..
Yes, they did. We were inundated with massive numbers every day. All it did was make us wonder why Vietnam was holding up.
Yep and that was fine for Robert McNamara. The reality was different.
“You will kill ten of us, we will kill one of you, but in the end, you will tire of it first.”
Ho Chi Minh
The Navy Seals had a 200/1 kill death ratio in Vietnam. It’s a mistake to underestimate the power of your enemy’s resolve. The Vietnamese fought the Chinese, then the French, then the Japanese, then the French again, the US.
I remember they actually used 'war crime' carpet bobmardments along with agent orange and napalm
Also, do you know what nation is the only one in history that used nuclear weapon against humans?
@@mystey1 if the USSR was the one with the nukes at the end of ww2, Japan would have been bombed 11 times, not twice.
When giving comparative data, it's always nice to leave both up. i.e. Leave the Ukrainian numbers on the screen while pulling up the Russian numbers.
I'm about to stop watching this channel, I don't even know why it appears in my recommendations. The videos are just a waste of time.
It's a prop'g'nda piece, I came here to laugh, and I'm somewhat suprised Ya folks belive in this.
To recap:
Ukr, had 300k, added more then 1mln, supposedly has small losses, and is "slowly" pushed back.
Ru had 180k, did 1 mobilization, and got some 30-40k convicts, +some foreign Legion of their own, and had insane losses, but continues to advance.
👌
The only possible explanation:
Ru BABUSHKAS are CHEATING by using NECROMANCY!!! confirmed 🤯
Checks out right?
Greetings
The have to emulate Ross Perot and communicate with graphs and tables.
🤔 I’ll make this simple…
history has proven that statistically the attacking force takes double if not more the casualties.
3 to 1
Depends, during the Iran Iraq war, Iraq had just abit more casualties during the invasion but when Iran took its land back and invaded, their casualties succeeded that of Iraq's.
It’s depends cuz hitters invasion of Russia
Attacker Germany: about 10million
Defender Soviet Union: about 16 million
@@TheGeodudes-tv8re weren't the soviets in worse conditions.
@@TheGeodudes-tv8reThe Soviets were woefully underprepared for the invasion
This video is the definition of "i believe sources that give me information i like"
Um, I saw multiple sources cited with wildly different numbers quoted for the same data sets being examined
this comment is " i comment a video without watching it".
@@blackbox9641 There's nothing to watch. Only the Ukrainian MoD knows the actual Ukrainian losses and only the Russian MoD knows the Russian losses. Not one of them will reveal the losses in the near future (which is absolutely logical) or even shortly after the war, we will have to wait decades for that.
@blackbox9641 False,the dude behind this video is clearly pushing his own agenda,whoever is folowing this war closely like myself knows that casualities reported on both sides are insanely bloated since both russians and ukraine use betwean 3 and 7 man to attack positions,so theres no way you can suffer 1k casualities a day when 90% of the front is inactive
Russian 'abuse of alcohol' is common throughout the country. Not just among soldiers experiencing mental health issues, lol.
Im still surprised people needed proof that russians lose 4 times more people than Ukraine. I mean russians always use meatwave attacks. In all wars.
If you don't know, after drank alcohol, they have a national amusing - sating each other onto (“back doors”) an empty from vodka glass bottles, it's called “planting”...
I’ve been in Ukraine and they have just as big a problem with this if not a worse one
Maybe the west needs to send more alcohol to Russia?
To be fair, as funny at it sounds it served in the past the purpose of keeping people warm in winter so they don't die from the cold. Thats why is is practically part of their culture.
Its just 2 number but it took 19 mins to get answer
I watched until 6:38 but bruh you say independent then show US based source lol then give ISW stats like it's truth . Also Russia using human wave tactics and lost more despite having one of the most complex and well prepared defensive line to defend is absurd. I guess no need to contunie because this is extremely biased.
Но это правда. Руские не умеют воевать.
@@zeusfthfghhfhfh2883Sure, they just defeted Napoleon and Hitler.
same as reporting that russia ran out of rockets during the first couple of months of the war , it is indeed a bias report when he mentioned human waves tactics as if russia have no regards of their on people while ukr fascist gov cares so much about their people enough to throw them into an offensive as cannon fodder , that also not including the atrocities committed by ukraine against the dombas and luhansk civilian population. Ukrainians fought bravely but there's no point of continuing just to satisfy US weapons manufacturers when they are losing more and more territories year after year . When the Kursk offensive fails eventually it will be game over.
@@filiptodorovic9752 Rusland ? No lendlease ? No millions tons of food from UAS ? No 3500 000 cars for logistics from UAS ? Rusland is tribe from mongolia. And this nation lose war vs Ukraine now xD
Super biased
Why is Ukraine taking people off the streets to recruit them into the army ,if they have so many people ?
It has reached the point where Ukrainians are actively resisting the press gangs and torching their vehicles. Nobody wants to be sent to the front, and no wonder.
You mean abductiong people and brute forcing them
Also why ukrainian borders are shut? Why does western borders have more border guards than any other borders including the frontline?
And why Zelenskiy admitted that he will temporarily cease to adhere to certain provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights???
I've never seen that in Ukraine
@@caresvlbdjz serach "У Харкові люди у формі ЗАКИНУЛИ чоловіка у бус" on youtube
There are tons of these vids on youtube and telegram
@@caresvlbdjz There are plenty of videos on yt.
17min and we still didnt know the ukraine losses
This channel is pro Ukrainian so.
Clickbait
If you see how large ukrainian graveyards are AND the forced mobilization, you will get the idea of who has higher losses
The Ukrainian number of russian casualties is not as inflated as you might think. There are countless paramilitary groups like Vagner, Kadyrov's battalions, conscripts from Donetsk and Luhansk "Republics" that were never counted as the russian army to begin with. The cemetaries around cities like Mariupol are full of those, and even more were cremated hastily or left without a proper burial. 2023 was particularly brutal towards those poorly equipped conscripts, with multiple "meat assaults" on launched to stop the Ukrainian troops from taking hold of strategically important settlements. It's a double tragedy, because many of those people were not particularly willing to serve and even to become russian citizens. Another thing that is not inflated is civilian casualties. We now know a reliable estimate of civilian death toll in Bucha and Irpin, because we have access to those towns... But with Mariupol, for instance, we might not know it for years. So many people went missing, buried under debris or hastily buried in their own yards that it's just haunting. How many were forcibly taken to Russia is also unknown. There no intent to inflate the numbers just to show russia is bad - it's evident. It's just due to inability to conduct a proper investigation, like in Bucha.
✌️
Kadyrovs don’t do any fighting though 😂
Gospodine ,koja Buča. Prestanite gledati vladine vjesti. Igrajte poker. Manje će te se nervirati. Mnogo ,mnogo lažu. Iao ovaj bloger...
@@dogewanderlust4359how many ukrainian civilians has russia fired hypersonic missiles at?
Bucha didn't happen and you know that. There's literally zero proof of Russian forces executing anyone and with all the modern reality of cameras everywhere it's hard to believe they have ZERO evidence. Putin was declared as a wanted persona for some other reason, if Bucha was real it would be a case against him.
A totally unbiased study from the totally least biased sources to deliver fully educted facts without any bias, lies, nonsense, agenda or demonizing anyone, for sure. I believe Big Brother.
The numbers are flashed on and off or only mentioned, so it is difficult to compare themn
Freeze the screen.
Someone,please just tell me the number?
@@andrewbrenner7120 There is no answer. there are various hypothetical answers through time... but nothing tangible. A waste of time really.
Seriously, about 10,000,000 Ukrainians left Ukraine, and you say only 20,000 were of military age. To the contrary, commonly young men are of higher proportion in immigration, while old people stay. Especially with the reluctance of Ukrainians to be drafted to the military, it is likely much higher proportion of emigration fleeing Ukraine is exactly of military age men.
you don't assume that all men over18 and under 60 were strcitcly prohibited to leave the country from the day 1 of a full scale ru invasion. Those 20k is about 19-59 y o men who escaped the country during the last 2 years
Seems like a lot of Ukrainians themselves don't even believe in the bullshit! 😂
over a million dead soldiers from both sides combined and people are still cheerleading, where's the humanity?
thats what im asking too. This war is nothing but a meatgrinder for innocent people and whoever comes out on top, it wont be a victory.
In palestina.
The only accurate information is the one former president Zelenskyy offered, saying that Ukraine lost about 31,000 soldiers, but did not specify in which month.
U mean in which week
"former" president Zelensky ?
@phvaessen His presidency ended a few months ago, but he declared himself president for a second term without holding the election required by the constitution. Technically, he is no longer the president and has no legal authority.
@phvaessen His presidency ended a few months ago, but he declared himself president for a second term without holding the election required by the constitution. Technically he is not a president anymore and has no legal power.
'People never lie so much as before an election, during a war, or after a hunt'. Otto von Bismarck
Wtf? The data used in this video is at least almost half a year old. Therefore it seems as if the Ukrainian estimates of Russian casualties are not that far off.
They're very much off, look at the amount of mobilizations, seriously... Ru isn't doing forcible mobilizations, Ukr is... whose running out of soliders?
The ones who don't force people into service?
I'm not a fan of Put¡n, but that doesn't mean I will accept media lies...
Many of ukr troops d¡e from wounds, not getting med evac, or because there are supply issues...
+ most of said wounds come from artillery shelling.
Ru uses way more ammunition then ukr...
so even if We assume They're inept, at some point there is no more cover to hide behind...
- so even the "inept orks" will score a hit
Esspecially as there is a massive difference in the artillery shell supply between Ru and ukr.
Greetings
I remember thinking on day 1 that this was going to be the biggest mistake of Putin's rule, and to this day I haven't seen anything that proves me wrong. If anything, I didn't fully anticipate how big of a clusterfuck this would be for Russia.
I have seriously wondered if the attack on Kyiv was Putin's doing. He seems like the kind of strategist who would use the troops in Belarus as a massive feint to draw Ukraine's troops to the capital, leaving the Donbas practically undefended which is exactly what happened. They took nearly all the objectives in the east with very few casualties. Most of the troops in the north, including field-grade officers, had no idea they were attacking. Had they left that sector of Ukraine alone, and without the massive war crimes, the west would not have offered the support they have. I honestly wonder if some of the top brass were so overconfident that they decided to pull the trigger themselves.
I marvel at the logic of saying "about" followed by a number to four significant figures.
Those hundreds of thousands of people fleeing Russia not only affect military replacements. They are also the key demographic to work in science, engineering, manufacturing, emergency services, and a hundred other elements needed for society to operate.
The video also did not mention that Russias last mobilization order also caused over 1 million able body and skilled men to flee the country.
Są też tam na pewno ludzie od dywersji i szpiegostwa.
All mentioned--- also valid for Ukraine.
@@eddapultstab2078 : All mentioned--- also valid for Ukraine.
Japan taking back the Kuril Islands would be an interesting move at this point in time.
While China takes back Manchuria? 😂
@@thorr18BEMthey certainly did have that in the table. The Border area there have always heavily guarded😅
Tak.ale to się stanie po wojnie chinsko rosyjsko kontra Japonia Tajwan Republika Korea I usa.moze tez Filipiny i Australia.
Nobody vote for jalan in kuril island
I reckon if it wasnt for the nuke factor Japan would of tried to take them back now 2
My uncle lives in a small city near the front line in Ukraine. They are shelled on a daily basis. Fortunately for him, his father had served in the Great Patriotic War (WW2) and so had dug deep cellars that also served as bomb shelters.
So he is zhdun
It would have been nice to have side by side comparison numbers. Also, if totals for both sides for all three years were listed, I missed them. It was very scattershot with different sources and different years all be addressed for different sides. I admire the way you discuss pros and cons of the varying sources, but it was hard for me to follow the totals in comparison aside from, “Russia lost more.”
@@marcosolo6491 just BS, it's what it is
I wonder why video author talks about russian war crimes but not a single word about ukrainian adhere to certain provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights. Basically, Ukraine violated so many human rights, that even Kim Jong Un is shocked. Also for some reason nobody talks how Zelenskiy's presidential term actually expired months ago, but he claims he can't give up power because of martial law that is illegaly extended
Also why did ukraine had to pass a law that removes all criminal responsibility for losses of soldiers or vehicles during the war?
@@mystey1 Your English is very good for a North Korean.
@@gunhildrandom tnx comrade, so what do you think about violation of human rights?
One day man will learn to live in peace and stop killing each other
Just don’t hold your breath.
Climate wars will be next on the agenda.
I won’t be here for it but I fear for my grandchildrens’ future.
Ironically, nuclear weapons made the world much more peaceful than statistics suggest it ought to be.
But the risk of the total destruction of civilization with hundreds of millions of deaths always looms over everything.
When is there ever peace in history? Not on this planet
I don't want peace through the Liberal World order. Look up the current "Liberal Hegemony"
Maybe you love it
when?
You know shit is bad when he starts off the video by discussing the entire countries populations 💀
W obydwu przypadkach już po 2.5 roku nieaktualne.
Pretty shure, Ukraine has, higher casualties then Russia. One report in October 2023, Ukraine sustained 500.000 KIA’s. By now it’s estimated to be, well over 700,000.
nope
@@f.beckeroh, yep
lions do not argue with donkeys
Citation
Sounds the sort of figures Putin gets given by his military but alas in the real world - NOT A CHANCE.
Ukraine casualties doesnt include the multiplier of Russian massive artillery, missiles, and FOAB strike. Such a multiplier will cause minimum 5x -7x ukraine casualties.
Too many for both sides
The economic losses of Russia is unpalatable. Billions upon Billions, and a loss of respect and fear by its neighbours who it has bullied for hundreds of years.
Doesn't seem to be reflected in their gdp or the value of the ruble..
you forget that the financial losses of Russia, big as they are, are hundred times lower than the value of Ukraine incorporated in Russia
Russia's economy is doing better than pre-war levels
@@keegan5765 Yeah that is why they shut their markets since day 1. They froze the markets as was. Funny how Putin has upped the taxes to almost 35%.
@@Joe-PrzybranowskiYou must be joking ...
13:20 The International Criminal Court is in The Hague, Netherlands, not Switzerland.
Right. Switzerland is where various nations keep the spoils of conflict. Bc it's a neutral nation, it's the safest place to keep ill gotten gains and traditionally Switzerland over the years has made no distinction between lawful assets and those stolen in war time.
@@GentleGiantAudioYes, that's why they are so rich.
*The truth (August 2024): Russian loses: 188K. Ukranian loses: 1M 165K. International mercenaries (otan): 12K.*
Both countries can lie about the numbers
There's no reason for both sides to reveal their actual losses, it would be really stupid to do so.
What we kinds forget is that each of those numbers represents a LIFE, a FATHER, a SON, a BROTHER, a SISTER, a MOTHER, a DAUGHTER, a CHILD......also it is an immense number of animals, pets...etc.....So many young souls.....and all this because of a few crazy politicians in Moscow and some corrupt politicians in Kyev. Yeah.....Every time a politician fails, regular people suffer and die!
Civilians 150,000 dead….Ukraine 400,000 KIA……Ukraine wounded 500,000
Russia 650,000 KIA………. 650,000 wounded
its strange to use data from western agency who knows exactly the Russian loses ,but have estimated clue about Ukrainians
Wealthy people in both countries have fled to their other homes in different countries or are on travelling visas around the world whereas poor have gone as refugees to different countries
Now start telling the truth.
The saddest thing about all these deaths is that this war never had to happen, Putin's ego and paranoia and his desire to somehow reclaim Russia's old imperial glory caused all this...and others are paying the price.
I have to apologize for this LONG rant beforehand!!! ;-)
It's certainly Putin's war, but it really IMO reflects Russians' state of mind and their attitude toward their nation.
Historically, Russia, as big as it is, has a 'little kid' complex... that it is never taken seriously enough.
To show the world that it isn't to be trifled with, it goes about bullying, and then absorbing its little neighbors. It has always done this!
Russia hardly needs to be as big as it is, and it is truly an unmanageable size!
Even if it was set up with semi-self-governing states like the US, it is still too big.
Everything 1000 miles east of Moscow is treated like an unwanted vacant lot, fit only to be used up and as a place to throw their trash and pollution.
The Czars acted this way, as did the Bolsheviks, and now Putin.
Britain was almost exactly the same since before the Elizabethan era! Not having land at their fingertips though, they went out and stole from any and everyone!
After the end of WWII, they found that was no longer to their benefit or had the ability, to maintain AND protect all these colonies!
Independence was granted to tons of them and by the '60s, most had gone their own way even while staying within the Commonwealth itself. Even that has dwindled to almost nothing. Canada and Australia are the two big ones remaining.
The US has done it as well, obviously, and I'm curious what might have transpired if North America was identical to Russia in terms of size and latitude location!
No, its a grave mistake to lay the responsibility of this war on Putin alone. No, its the russian population in its entirety which, some noble exceptions aside, are die-hard imperialists who think its their God-given right to enslave and brutalize their neighbours.
Putin is just a great representative of the russian population at large. But the real evil here is not Putin but russian imperialism.
Sự kiện đáng tiếc này có thể đã không bao giờ xảy ra nếu không có cái tôi của những người tham gia vào cuộc cách mạng Maidan cũng như NATO. Tiêu chuẩn kép.
That's very simplist and elementary explanation, in truth the war was unavoidable
This is not about Russian egos. It is about not having NATO/US military stationed on Russia's borders. This is the Cuban missile crisis in reverse. If anything, this is because of Westerners' megalomania and egos and their belief that they are to rule the world.
This war is in reality a NATO-Russia war and the fight is between a globalist one world order where the West gets to set the rules for the rest of the world on the one hand or a world of sovereign and independent states.
its NATO - VS Russia ... lets get it right!
shhhh you cant tell the truth, they get angry if they find about they were getting brainwashed all the time.
No it isn't. NATO is not at war with Russia. Its Russia and Ukraine who are at war and 50+ Countries (inc NATO countries) support Ukraine financially and militarily. Get it right.
@@TimMountjoy-zy2fd Hahahahaha
53 countries against one Russia.
There is only one truth. It is a pity that the people are injured and killed and the beautiful country is reduced to rubble, just because of the greed of people from other countries and other lands.
Putin needs to pay for what he has done.
so does Zelensky and the Ukranian people
Yea you show him, cowboy
Yes after Obama pays.
make sure that you're " neutral " before making the video
can we just agree both sides have lost enough? this whole thing is fucking insanity
Yeah Putin needs to back down, its hurting Russia too
Yes but the peope of ukriane are willing to die standing. For freedlm it is better doe then live in chaisn.
They have both lost enough, it's only putin that wants to keep it going.
In other words, clearly Russia needs to lose much more before it gets enough. Remember that some 22-27 million Russians died in WW2.
@@Milan_Openfeint not realy. Half were civilians. Plus Russia's population is smaller as it not the Soviets unions + russas people won't tolerate such high casualtie.s the war in Afghanistan shook the nation apartnin 89
They say "It ain't the size of the dog in the fight. It's the size of the fight in the dog". Indeed.
Both spent billions of dollars,both contributed on pollution ( dirtying the air, water and soil),both destroyed the nature,both suffered their respective buildings citizens, economy etc .😢😢😢
Russia hasn't just lost military age men. They've lost a TON of IT folks. Their IT workforce was one of the worst hit.
they lost hundred time lower than you pretend, and you know it
@@Sergiu.antifascist Nope. Not even a little. The russian IT market is insane. There are openings everywhere, but most of the top talent has either fled or has been dragged into government service. There are a lot more russian names popping up on candidate lists around the world. The low side of estimates is about 700,000 people in the tech industry gone. That's about a third, minimum, of all tech workers before Putin's mad war to relive lost glory.
@@Canthus13 they have a huge population but their economy is still suffering because most of them men are going to the front buddy nice try ; only mainly those in West Russia and governors in Eastern Districts are alive and surviving
@@chadbrad8100 It's not so deliberate like the Great Purge, but most dictators seem to favor fewer people smarter than them. I wonder if Putin is really that upset about them leaving without him having to spend money on the 'problem'?
They lost so much They didn't do more the one mobilization?
While Ukr did 11?! And is considering draging back their men from abroad?
That's Ru losing?
Please share Your supplier, I never been high enough for that sh¡t to make sense for Me.
Greetings
What's the saying? It's old men who starts wars in which young men die? Such a tragic loss of lives on all sides. 😢
It's only Putin who started it,he's a narcissist
The ones who can finish the war don't fight it and they don't care about those who actually suffer from it.
Those who had enough of the war just can not finish it
How can a channel with such a name come up with this assertive, clearly false title, how can anyone have a true number, i doubt the Russians are sharing accurate information about their losses
Best estimates based on information provided by other sources
@@michaeldunham3385 like what? Konashenkov? or pedo-Ritter?)
@@michaeldunham3385 thing is we can't trust any sources
Neither side are, if you read both the ukrainian and russian claims you see imiediatly that they are totally fake. The overinflate the numbers to the point that neither side would have had any army left if they where true in old soviet style.
Clickbait title. The true deathtoll's presentation ends up being "its complicated"
Ukrainian forces cracked the first 2 of the 3 defensive lines? Ukraine barely contacted the second line, and only in a very few select areas.
Life is what we're living for. Near Sao Paulo Brazil yesterday, 62 souls were lost when the flight they were on crashed. The incident was a tragic accident. War is not a tragic accident but the purposed infliction of death and horror along with total destruction of facilities. Young people are being sacrificed, giving up decades of life they would have otherwise lived. Kurt Vonnegut jr. likened war to an alcoholic puking over the toilet, saying, "I've got to quit drinking". Mark Knopfler wrote and sang, "We are fools to make war on our brothers in arms". Vast monies are involved that could go to other uses or just to have for future needs. It just makes us sick; the destruction, murders, and overall stupidity. Anthony Bourdain said, "The "isms" are now "wasms".
💯👍
You know...
There are always 2 sides to a story. One says this, the other says something else.
I don't think any country can give the exact amount of casualties, this war has caused already.
Just ask yourself a question 'how does Russia count how many ukrainians they've killed? or vice versa?'
Well Ukraine and Russia know their own losses, but that's about it, nobody else has access to those numbers, even the US probably doesn't know for sure the Ukrainian losses and can only estimate them.
i can never get over the pnas acronym
I thought it was a fallacy? 🙂
@@stevemawer848 Flaccidly, not fallacy...
Oh noon, you didnt!
Childish of me but I thought the same, and came to the comments thinking I’d see more of that. Thankfully the comments didn’t go there (much) but I admit I immediately thought it humorous.. looking at that acronym thinking who would seriously make that official? An acronym that reads like “penis”??
The USSR won the Afghan war, because it was more populated. USA won in the Vietnam war (and Taliban in Afghanistan). Darius won Alexander...
what?
In this invasion only RU are sending waves of cannon fodder for a 100 meters of burned land. So it's not very hard to figure out who's in a disadvantaged position for that matter.
All these are BIG numbers!😢😢
War is terrible isn't it?
@@dankengine5304I don’t mind war I live in a nuclear armed country protected by 2 oceans 😂
I hope Ukraine and Russia stop this war it won't happen but too many are dead and Russian people and soldiers are suffering because of a dictator
It's the Ukrainian dictator who refuses to negotiate for peace. He cancelled elections making himself an illegal dictator. He banned the Orthodox church. Zelensky is the real villain of this story.
but ukrainians also suffer from the other dictator
Below this I get an ad about "Meet beautiful 35+ slavic women. Lots of Ukrainian women, increasing numbers willing to chat". Oh the irony. Or cynicism.
And it's illustrated with a woman standing in a field of poppies.
Poppies. Flanders. Lest we never forget.
Unfortunately another clear BIAS video with nothing new in the agenda .
Nothing to do with actual statistics just some cute maps and circles with some bla bla
Exactly, try to make a video mega long that should be like 1:30 and present numbers side by side.
The International Criminal Court is in Switzerland now?
Amateur hour....
Your analysis is old all the things your Western Generals mentioned have already occurred, and Ukraine came out on top!
You and the Grnerals are still operating under the old But Russia is so big and strong theory. Ukraine has proved that wrong!
Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦
Those slavs ain't super soldiers, if the Russians get a hold you will lose
How humiliating it would be for the family of the soldiers that their sons were not being counted among the dead.
Ukraine manpower is so low, they actually have childsoldiers, were talking about 16+years and above, but still they are considered childs.
The video starts with a lie. The objective wasn't Kiev. It was Donezk, Luhansk and Crimea from the beginning. The US Generals said so. The "Kiev in 3 days" nonsense was invented by the same people who invented "The Ghost of Kiev". The move to Kiev was supposed to bind Ukrainian troops in... Kiev! They then moved on to the regions they annexed. I can't explain in simpler terms. Russia didn't even send a large enough force to capture Kiev, that's why the US analysts (not the pundits) said, that Russia is carrying out a diversion, so Donezk, Luhansk and the land bridge to Crimea can be occupied with less fighting. What's the point in carrying on with the "3 days" joke? NATO was in AFG for 20 years and lost!
So why send a miles long convoy to Kiev from the beginning then? Or better yet, why did they deploy an air assault group to, and they actually tried, to take Kievs airport to airlift troops and gear from a Russian airport that's conveniently standing by? Actions speak louder then words.
@@eddapultstab2078 Yes, listen to your own words! The actions taken were a move on Kiev and then those same troops occupied Luhansk and Donezk. If I want a diversion I actually have to do something to make it believable. The only visible clue was that Russia sent 20% of the troops actually required to sustain a siege on Kiev. Putin was hoping there would a peace deal, but that fell flat after Johnson talked to Zelensky, and we both know he showed him pictures of Saddam and Qaddafi post mortem. Why do you think Volodomyr is always surrounded by Azov instead of the regular troops? in 2019 Azov openly threatened to kill Zelensky, because he wanted a ceasefire and "disrespected" an Azov commander. They expected him to apologize to Azov. The President of Ukraine apologizing to Nazi-scum who refused to follow his orders!
@@UberTankred however they did try to take kievs airport and had several transports waiting to airlift reinforcements there. And if putin really wanted to force negotiations he could have just ordered his troops to simply occupy the donbas and dig instead of a half baked rush to the capital. All your saying is complete rubish.
The problem with Russians is that they value strenght, so expect them allways doble or nothing. Failure is a sign of weakness, so they found a way out of it, they are masters of excuses. That helps them preserve their faces in Russian society, but not addmitting mistakes makes it hard to learn from them, this is like a closed circle. If your plan doesnˇt work, then deny its existence! Fact is, taking Kiev was one of the main objectives of the Russian Army. They wanted Ukrainian leadership to flee or capture and to set up a puppet government, who would have ordered Ukrainain Army to lay down their weapons. If Russia had taken Kiev and lost Donetsk, then you would have said that Donetsk was just a diversion to take Kiev. Classic act.
It was Putin who told Poroshenko "If I wanted, Russian troops could be not only in Kiev, but also Riga, Vilnius, Tallinn, Warsaw and Bucharest in two days".
What are they even fighting for? Some politicians egos lmao
They’re protecting their country from invasion. Pretty sure yours would do the same. Always people like you using “politicians” for everything war related. It’s part of it but it’s overshadowed.
In Kursk there are nuclear and power stations.
Kursk, historically on Ukrainians land.
Ukrainians going to sell power to EU countries. 😂. The station is the biggest in Europe
Vladimir Gluten
Lol
The BBC study numbers may be a massive underestimate. They couldn't account for every cemetery, especially those in more rural areas that russia is drawing a lot of its recruits from. Many dead russians are also either not buried, cremated (either at their death or afterwards), or buried in hastily created graveyards in Ukraine.
This war is madness, with no regards to life or end game.
Ukraine losses Kia 650k+ injured 200k+ Russia losses Kia 60k+ injured 75k+
ok, bud, whatever you say
Russian casualties are at least half a million in total (killed & wounded). Not saying they are higher or lower than those of Ukraine, its just that there's no way russia would need to recruit so many men if they had such low casualties
Biggest loss of human life in this conflict is caused from artillery fire, and Ukraine has suffered heavy losses because Russian fire 60-70000 rounds per day,Ukraine fires nearly 6000.
@@ilirshima692 how accurate their fire?
@@besconst it’s huge number of mercenaries from around the world including some brainwashed Albanians who fought on Ukrainian side that lost their lives in this senseless war.
meat wave tactics? where? show us , show us the hundreds and thousands of soldiers charging together
Putin without military background
Putin was a KGB officer before he became the president, he has a military background, selenskiy was a comedian before he became or lets face it, he kinda forced himself into the role and everyone accepted it.
Wrong.
@@allendulles2481 he was only KGB
Ukraine knows better than British. British is not on the war
So you only take the accuracy of the West vs Independent sources
Lies! Nothing else.
Russia with 10-2 weapons and manpower loosing men 4-1, you can tell with the Britsh accent who is he twisting the story to
Russia has gone to great lengths to avoid civilian deaths in Ukraine! Far different to what Israel has done in Gaza!
This war is reminiscent of America’s Civil War. No matter how many casualties were suffered by Union armies, every battle was to their advantage as the numerically inferior Confederate army could not sustain similar losses.
For the Confederates it was more of a lack of resources rather than a lack of manpower
Great Britain and France suffered many more casualties in World War One, with similar populations to Ukraine now.
It pains me that I am being shown WWI and WWII all over again, the nightmares of 80 years ago coming back to haunt me.
Victory! Victory! War, destruction, and killing will not end as long as people continue to cry for victory. And even when the country's chances of victory are lost, politicians, the media, and the people will continue to cry victory until the last day.
A few months ago i heard a report say Russia lost 600,000 troops. And by the end of the year there looking at 1 million.
A few months ago I heard a report that Elvis was at the local supermarket. By the end of the year he will be joined by Marilyn Monroe. Report, sure...
Totally randomized numbers without any backup sources.
As many may remember, at the beginning of the war there was video of a Ukrainian woman telling a Russian invader, "Take these seeds and put them in your pockets so at least sunflowers will grow when you all lie down here." Ukraine must have had some bumper crops of sunflowers the past couple of years. I like sunflowers. The western countries need to send Ukraine more weapons and ammunition so we can have more sunflowers.
If Donald Trump hadn't assured me that Putin was a genius...... these results might have suggested he was in fact an idiot.
He was a genius by waiting til an idiot was leading the US before he invaded .Thats a fact that cost the US 100 s of billions of$$$$$$$$$.
To a fresh recruit, those killed numbers look like that's the only way to get back home.
Especially for Russians
One thing you can count on is if Russia is the perceived winner they will dramatically overestimate their own losses to make it seem more heroic. If Russia is seen as the loser they will dramatically underestimate their losses to make it seem closer than it actually was.
I doubt Putin and his regime would inflate their man casualty numbers to make it seem like some “heroic sacrifice”. The war is already becoming unpopular, and high casualties would make the Russian army seem incompetent and make Putin look like a butcher, with no regard for the lives of his troops.
First here
Yes, congrats
Excellent Video on actual state of Devastation
Modern wars are way more deadlier than we think imagine a ww3...
Money is the blood of war. Let's talk about money. We don't know how much Russia spent on the war, it's all classified. But we know how much money Ukraine received. And so, since 2022, Ukraine has received $400 billion in military aid + its costs for the war. For comparison, Steel from 1941-1945 received $ 10 billion, or $ 160 billion at current prices, adjusted for inflation. With this money, Stalin clothed, shod and fed about 11 million soldiers. He built 50,000 tanks, he stormed Berlin, largely thanks to this money. The question is, what did Ukraine do in the amount of 3 times more? And how much more help will she get over the next 2 years? And where did the money go?
They won't last 2 years but only 2 more months!
What mother would send their child off to war!!!! May peace, prevail 🕊️
“The war is not meant to be won, it’s meant to be continuous”
This man has a flashlight with the phrase "war" written across the top so he can get himself off to war, both physically and metaphorically.