Judiciary beyond redemption? Katju speaks his mind
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 พ.ย. 2024
- In this thought-provoking episode of #Dilsewithkapilsibal, renowned former Supreme Court judge Markandey Katju shares his unfiltered views on the state of India’s judiciary post-2014. Hosted by Kapil Sibal, this conversation delves into critical issues surrounding judicial independence, corruption, and the challenges the judiciary faces today.
Always a blessing to hear justice katju.
I really admire justice katju may god bless a very long life
Kapil Sibhal Ji is doing such a great service....and bringing Justice Kakju Sahab is one among many such services... Definitely both the two speak truth to power...! Both r the gems of a real India!
बहुत-बहुत hi ज्यादा experience जो हमे बहुत कुछ सीखने को मिला है autonomous बॉडी को कैसे होना चाहिए
Both of you ate gems. Kudos to both of you sir.
Delighted to see this beautiful interview ....worth seeing
Great service by Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal to the nation by bringing the Dilse episodes to the people.
I really appreciate Mr. Justice katju I salute him. God bless him 🙏
आज़ देश को वास्तविक नागरिको की जरूरत है जो संविधान क़ानून व्यवस्था के बारे में जानकारी रखते हों उन्हें जनता के हितों की रक्षा के लिए आगे आना चाहिए था Thanks both are super personality talking about nation.
Kapil sibal ji you are taking very important issues for indian democracy but the most important is Supreme Court must appoint neutral election commissioners with consultation of opposition, government, and CJI for providing level plying fields, now questions are raised against Maharashtra, and UP by elections.
When BJP got lost in jharkhand why you don't doubt EVM there, you have nothing to do with EVM but you know you can't defeat BJP, Try your best to DEFAME BJP but it will continue to rule you for next 50 years, cry more about it you can't do nothing 😂😂😂😂
These people are so pure.
See what a beautiful word Mr Kaju said about the people he said the people are the masters and the masters have the right to know what is happening in the courtroom and the systems let there be judges of the supreme court high court policeman and even the defence forces are the servant of the people VAO love those words
Sir, plz do interview with justice katju time nd again. He is highly Rational, Intellectual man who has a high Moral ground. Although I'm not from legal fraternity but i have lot to learn from justice katju, his words come from deep inside the depth of Rationalism
The proceedings in the courts should be televised.Justice katju is right.
approach dushyant Dave and Prashant bhushan. call them for a talk. death of democracy through evm and eci
VERY TRUE TAUGHTS WHERE PROPOSED BY MR.KATJU.
THANKS MR.SIBAL FOR BRINGING THE CONVERSTION TO US
But I wanted to point on some think that are--
There is no point in typing in the comments that MR. Katju is right and we need a great revolution.
Instead we should think on the question is --- WHO will bring the Revolution?
we should be united forgetting the caste, religion of HE or SHE.
Its very easy to say that we need a revolution but NO one is taking at least a single step towards revolution.
WE say that every one is giving vote on the bases of religion and caste, but no one thinks that, what can we do to avoid the voting on the bases of caste and religion .
If someone says that lets start a revolution on a xyz issue then half of the people will laugh at that person and those who did`nt laugh will oppose him or her.
If we see todays generation and the upcoming generation then it is total useless, of thinking or expecting revolution from these and upcoming generations .
India is not only facing problems in politics , education system , industrialisation and etc but also in sports .
FOR Example
India has a very vast population then Australia but then also Australia has large number of Olympic medals than India ,
WHY is it so? IS our country is so week in producing good athletes?
IN the current year of 2024, 117 people out of which 70 where men and 47 where women went to play Olympics from India.
IS it correct to send only 117 athletes from the country having population of 142.86 crores ??
I will windup only saying that , IF India need revolution then its should started as fast as possible because as the time is passing the conditions are geeting wrost day by day.
THANK YOU!!!!
@mr.Kapil Sibal , @Justice (retd) Markanday Katju
Very thoughtful debate. It should be of 1 hrs.or more.
Katju sahab is upright and lots of affection to you
Good insight
Always there's something new to lern from this channel.
DEAR SIRS ONLY ONE PERSON IS CO OF ALL INSTITUTIONS IF THIS ONE IS CLEAN HONEST DEDICATED TO NATION WE WILL HAVE NO DISCUSSIONS GOD BLESS
Beautiful conversation
Respect Sir.
2 करोड़ से जयादा मुकदमे हिन्दुस्तान की कोर्ट मे दशको से पड़े हैं। आप एक एपिसोड बनाईये sir.
भारत वर्ष की समस्याओं का समाधान राजनीति , कार्यपालिका, न्याय पालिका, मीडिया सब जगह परिवारवाद, भाई-भतीजावाद
की समाप्ति की जाय।
I have a suggestions... CJI should have min 2 years of tenure ‼️
He was all about talking very high words and controversies without any base
If Hon'ble ex-CJI C'Chud was 'one of the greatest judges of India', as per you (Mr Sibbal Saab) in your speech on the occasion of justice C'chud's farewell ceremony as the President of SCBA (if my memory doesn't deceive me), then OUR JUDICIARY IS BEYOND ALL REDEMPTION. NO DOUBT. He was the most petulant sitting judges ever. Sibbal Saab, you had better ask this question to yourself. We want to be educated from you.
आज़ देश को वास्तविक नागरिको की जरूरत है जो संविधान क़ानून व्यवस्था के बारे में जानकारी रखते हों उन्हें जनता के हितों की रक्षा के लिए आगे आना चाहिए था
Thanks sir!!❤
25:40 Kapil Sibbal 😂😂😂
27:20 Katju (My Claps...)
Excellent discussion
its a pleasure listening to you sir.
Its high time people need to open their eyes and see the clear picture. India is slowly crumbling we must act to save our country.
Long live justice katju
Judges in India feel that they are the last words in wisdom and they must, impress this often uncertain wisdom on their litigants and audiences. The beauty is that while they are often so voluble about a situation the judgements are not on that line. Opposed to a razor sharp, shrewd Sibal, Katju is bluntly in your face. Sibal having raised Chandrachud to heights clearly finds himself uncomfortable in the company of an unrestrained Katju.
Great discussion
कपिल जी को मेरा 🙏
Electoral Bond scheme... Supreme Court should have desired modifications of the same rather than nullifying the same! How come cash collections by earlier regimes
were correct!
One suggestion... Legal Fraternity is busy.. Why so many parties on retirements...!
Good evening sir🙏
Sibbal saab played diplomatic role in farewell of CJI DYC function, may be opportunistic.
Thanks sir ji
Bebaak ...Dil se ..Facts
Always blessing to hear you sir..
Atleast someone speaking truth..
Maybe there is hope..
But still there will be people who will do revolution..
U will only loose when u under the dirt and everything else is blessings.
Indian people are sovereign if u go by religion Indian people will never e sovereign.. so stop
Saying religion based country will be ultimate truth.. it can never be..
nice to hear intellectuals
Salute katju sr
Bhut khushi huyi ki aaj bhi insaf. jastis ki bat karne wale maujud hain Varna logon ko insaf to yad aata Hai jab apne uopar zulm hota hai
Flamboyance and Judiciary can never be compatible.
Katju sahab is fabulous as always...
नमस्कार कपिल सर 🙏
Apex Court is beyond any redemption 😢
काश आज़ katju साहब जैसा CJI होता तो इतिहास और ही होता
आज़ सारी जनसेवक संस्थाएं केवल दबाव में लगती हैं और जनता को ही निचोड़ रहे हैं बेरोजगारी मिलावट महगाई घोटाले जीएसटी टैक्स पर टैक्स मनमानी जनविरोधी नीतियों के कारण त्रस्त हैं
Mr. Katju did u know after 1947 there was no Media like we r having today ....I mean the judges r also in tremendous pressure compared to judges at that time
Both are highly educated and qualified
Sir, next time you interview justice Kathju please, ask him' he said janta is master in democracies, (in this talk), other place he says 90% in Indian are fools' how to upgrade these fools? It is dangerous for our country.
What a convo Truth of India this days bjp made India dhram ka khada
M M Punchi... Will come soon.
❤
Katzu Saab...
Very sad of u to say that judiciary is suffering from Cancer! Suggest measures are for redemption!
काटजू साब
Aap bhi retirement ke बात bahut jyada नहीं bol rahe hai!
No world for Kapil and Katju sir...........GREAT
I am 100% agreement with Katju on the disgraceful Babri Masjid decision. Chandrachud’s decision has opened the door to endless court cases against any and every masjid in Bharat. Chandrachud, like many, is an RSS stooge who chose his social status over actual justice. He will be remembered for being a coward who contributed to the failing state of Bharat. The economists who won the 2024 Nobel peace prize wrote, “Why Nations Fail.” The book states that nations fail because they no longer have credible institutions the people have faith in. The RSS installed stooges in the Supreme Court, other high courts, lower courts, educational institutions, key govt institutions, etc. are prime examples of why Bharat is failing as a nation. The Chief of the Supreme Court, in a secular country, is on camera doing puja with the PM, then states that he made his cowardly decision on one of the most important cases of the past 30 years based on his consultations with a deity, not the law. How utterly shameless.
Humble request to mr sibal to have a chat with Shri Pratap Bhanu Mehta
🎉❤
Muguls were great lovers of Justice‼️
I don't agree..
If Justice of SC not agreeing with Ram Mandir Verdict..
this is just unacceptable...
If we consider today's scenario ....mr.katju is commentator but not a player on ground ...
I salute this brave judge
I think there was one mistake, several american courts do broadcast their proceedings and the us supreme court does a audio broadcast of the oral proceedings. So the point that American courts do not televise their proceedings is not entirely true.
Sibbal Saab
Don't leave discussion on collegeum system in midway.. It seems u r in agreement!
Why article 370 not discussed
❤🙏❤
I have one question. Will the current judge, Justice Khanna uphold the constitution and save constitutional Institutions?
Nirav modi supporter ka interview lena par rha h😂😂
What's at stake is the very spirit of india that we cherish a lot and that is the diversity of our country. But current dispensation is hell bent on exploiting the social fault lines for political gains. Non adherence by judges to places of worship act 1991 might prove fatal for our beloved country.
चर्चिल ने कहा था कि हम तो देश को छोडकर चले जायेंगे परन्तु आप देश की आज़ादी पचास वर्ष भी नहीं रख पाएंगे क्या वो सही थे या नहीं
No control over judiciary in the Indian constitution.our constitution maker did not envisage such situations
Mr..Katju u also did not work during this pressure era of today ....
Deepak Mishra & Bela Trivedi made verdicts full of PREJUDICES. Left sorry state of Judiciary
Sir, iss Desh k Institutions ki Kursi toh Unchi hai Lekin unke Kirdar nahi...
Do you get my Point!!
Katju cleverly calling cc as chand chood 😅😅😅
Dear Respectable Gentlemen, Why was EVM forcefully implemented on Indian Democracy, Why can't a 15 member bench decide as to whether it is mandatory or not mandatory. Why can't the Judiciary be voted by the top authorities who are impartial like CAG , CIC , RAW , INTELLIGENCE AND A VERY HONEST JUDICIAL OFFICER and make it 5 or 6 member selection committee. Judges choose judges and decide benches accordingly. As per opinion of Shri Katju ji as Ex CJI what is his opinion on Constitution of India. Does it really suit country like India , Where there are so many cultures , Religions , Caste , Traditions , Languages , Foods , Gods , Different race people. Can one constitution suit our such a diverse country. Can't we have 28 Supreme courts like USA, Instead of one in India. With Kind Regards.
Katju achieved Moksha before death.
33:13 😂
Aaj k yuk mein Dhoot ka dula koi nahin hein, India ka kuch nahin hoga ab 😢😢
judiciary me CJI नए आ गए हैं चुनावों में वोट के लिए नोट देकर ग़रीब आम आदमी को दो चार हजार रुपये दे कर वोट लिया है तो चुनाव रद्द होना चाहिए इंदिरा गांधी जी की सदस्यता रद्द हो गई थी
Aadarniy katju sir Aise halat mein Aam Muslim Kya Karen agar aap yah message padhe to please answer dijiye
Katju g acha bolte hain lekin inko apne per control nahin hai
Sir ya to pura hindi me ya pura inglish
I find Katju to be quite a loose cannon, but every know and then, he makes a lot of sense. With regard to the court hearings to be televised, why not? The US Supreme Court cases are open to the public. Why not have it televised. The facts are not up for discussion, it’s the law that is being discussed, so why not? Are you afraid, Kapil, that laws like the UAPA that were passed with you as the lead attorney might have been questioned by the public? The law that has sent thousands of Muslim minorities and others to jail on baseless charges with no chance of bail. It’s people like you who have used your privilege and power to push through laws that should never have been passed and are truly anti-national.
Sir what kind of a justice is our judiciary giving to common people where even a probate petition regarding a registered hand written Will of a father in Punjab and Haryana high court does not move an inch in 4yrs ,even issues have not been framed in 4yrs.case is listed at the end and never gets heard .The person contesting the only legal WILL has produced 2 fraudulent WILLS and sitting on entire estate.But the other legal hiers are going to die soon without getting any inheritance .Same with district courts where judge s do not pass any orders for months even after hearing arguments twice .
Mr Katju thinks courts prevent aam junta doing mara mari to get justice.
Sir what is the use of such courts who go on giving endless adjoùrnments favouring the person sitting on entire estate of father with the help of Corrupt area police and extremely corrupt revenue officials of Punjab Govt ( including a Financal Commissioner (FCR R)who does not even understand what is Hindu Succession Act regarding Ancestral Agricultural Land. ).
In nut shell our Judicial system is extremely faulty.
Justice delayed is justice denied - is very true .
I think first need to discuss the below points 👇
👉 How to deliver justice within year.
👉 Is our judiciary really made to give justice specially to poor people or it's made to save criminal
👉 Why criminal / goons / rapist / corrupted politician afraid to do crime when senior advocate are ready to advocacy for them and trying best to save them.
👉 If law is equal for all then why there is there is too much gap in fees between lower court and Supreme or high court advocate
👉 Does we really need advocate for small cases . Why not direct hearung between judge and plaintiff/ defendant.
👉 Why judiciary should be unaccountable in a democracy
People are loosing faith from judiciary. I believe 2 inch of your land belong to me and you believe 4 inch of my land belong to you - this type of stupid case take atleast 5 to 10 year to solved in district court. Our judiciary is completely broken and it's need a complete overhaul.
Sir mehghai berojgari pr ek dedate or🎉🎉🎉
Sibbal sir apne to ek farewell programme me Chandra chood ke bahut tareef ki hain kam se kam uske samne sach bolte na ki usko ahsas hota kam se kam wohi batain bol dete jo apne katju ke sath ki chandra chood Kr baare me
आज बहुत ही कम लोग हैं जो देश के लिए लोकतंत्र न्याय की बात कर रहे हैं 140 करोड़ की जनता चुप चाप मनमानी सहन कर रही है देश में हज़ारों वकील हैं विद्वान हैं राजनेता एक्स सर्विस मेंन है सभी चुप क्यों हैं
Respect sir
😅😅😅😅❤❤❤❤
Dear Respectable Gentlemen par Excellence, Please even speak on EVM Machines operations and it's credibility. Is EVM usage constitutional or unconstitutional. Why there is no law for conducting Common Exams to become Advocates or judges like CA , JEE , TOEFL and etc. Why is that almost 95 % judges are selected from one particular community. When almost all are Immigrants, How come only one community is dominating all the major positions in India. Why judges are free from any impeachment and is it the same world over. Does Supreme Court has the power to dissolve Lok Sabha. With Regards.
sibal sir seems to disagree a bit but yh judge thoda sathiya gaye h ,,,,