@@sandykhp Well her act was for sure. But der aye toh durust aye. She is a changed person now as she admits in this interview. Abb teri bari hain change honey kii.
@@newajulhoque9309 ha paisa sabko chaiye. ideology, religion, activism ye sab middle class cheeze he. kal tujhe b agar mil gaye 10 lakh free me, tu b modi modi karega. Use dekh. kitni sundar lag rahi he, makeup, dressing, foreign jesi elite english. Paisa sab kuch kharid sakta he. sab kuch
@@muditarya On the one side Shehla Rashid is talking about reforms, stop polygamy, increase women rights but durkha dutt is continuously spinning around left-wing, right-wing, centrewing burkha is such a lol
This discussion indicates that both Barkha Dutt and Shehla Rashid experienced a major turnaround and realised that reality was way different from what they imagined. Narendra Modi has indeed changed India for the better. Even if people don't vote for him he ensures that they are provided all facilities that all citizens should have. Moreover, he is working to change the eco-system in India in a way that enables everyone to rise.
I am very happy to watch Sehla becoming matured. She thinks positive and reality unlike polititians of today. I wish she remains the same when she joins politics and works for the betterment of people of india specially Kashmiris though I don't belong to Kashmir. God bless Sehla.
Would you like it if an outsider came and rescued you in your own state. You will resent him, it is not logical but emotions are not always logical. Kashmiris resentment of Modi are understandable
Mindset is a collection of narrative propagated by leaders, be it religious, political or literary leaders. Common Muslim minds are hijacked by such conservative and radical leadership and those who have different opinion like APJ Abdul Kalam has castigated for being liberal and disowned as being true Muslim. Most importantly these radicals derive their Legitimacy from religious scriptures and hence Muslims have no chance.
Shehla Rashid is a true intellectual because she is ready to change her opinions while keeping her core principles . It shows she doesnt have an ego about her belief systems . And her rationality is above political ideology. She also has a beautiful voice, the podcast could have been longer 😎.
Superb women… what a transformation…. I hope she becomes the voice for Muslim and change them and make India a better place and become symbol of humanity
A very good interview. Consistency of views in politics irrespective of the changing times would be foolish.She is right when she says that Modi has done lot of good in Kashmir and in the country.
Really impressed with her thoughts on different issues. May she enter politics and serve the people of her state who have been under immense hardship. God bless her for her future assignments.
Very well said that the Kashmir was made a problematic state by NC & PDP. These politicians never allowed people of Kashmir to integrate with the Country that is India.
The two, She and Shah Fasil were / are wonderful Indians and have done everything for the country under BJP. They were party of 370 and withdraw once the court started hearing. This sacrifices for BJP is remembered the way , Mr. S. Soz have uprooted Atal jis govt for Congress.
Shela U nailed it down..Its even hard for Barkha to deviate from your logical arguments ...It's called maturity when u can put your mind without prejudice and being in prison of your past.Pls join politics and be part of change
I am amazed at how smart and intelligent she is - hats off to her. And secondly she is right Muslims also write that their dhaba or biryani house is halal - so that Muslims wouldn't have any issues eating their meat. Also while travelling Muslims also try to have pure veg food when they don't get halal - they would also prefer Jain bhojanalayas, etc - so it shouldn't be a problem having the name of the owner - the names serve as a brand in themselves - and using a brand in a deceitful manner is also wrong
Younger generation out of the common people has to be encouraged to get chance to take part in politics and other economic issues. The situation has changed and people want genuine leadership and sound political system.
Shehla Rashid, once a fierce critics of Modi government, now finds herself navigating the difficult terrain of balancing two seemingly opposing roles-on one hand, defending the policies of the BJP government with skills that bjp’s own spokesperson lack, and on the other, trying to stay true to her progressive ideals and her true authentic self. The challenge of reconciling these two responsibilities is immense, and no one would wish to be in such a position. Yet, Shehla manages to do so with remarkable conviction and grace. One can only hope that, in time, the weight of political pressure or necessity will lift, allowing her to fully embody the ideals of a progressive society and become a true role models of intellectual courage and strength she is destined to be for her people.
Obvious certainty of regressive mind, nothing of progressive spark to b an ideal for anyone at home or abroad, defined by her utilitarian principles dat push her to rollover from critic to crazy fan
She was very articulate with her positioning of BJP as a welfare party and why that resonates with her political leanings. Not many in Indian public space have the critical argument making skills to pivot across ideological leanings, when questioned. She is an exception and that would serve her well in future.
Shehla is brilliant!! such a bright girl, bold, honest to the point replies to Barkha who tried her best to corner her & get at least some negative, controversial comment...
Beautiful thoughts, Sheila. You really have to come to the forefront and bring a change to whatever you think best. Because l really echo the sentiments of youri. God bless you dear
Remebering Barkha first to interviewing KK... in JNU.. that was raw & full of apriori.. But this interview with SR is far excellent that with that of KK... Full of heuristic... the JUN original style of 90s of Prakash Karat, Sitaram Yetchuri, DPT, David Thomas, D. Raghunandanji, Anand Kumar & J. Benerjee time... Full of free thinking.. Real pluralism... Jai Hind.
As a Modi voter, to be fair she was trying to ask tough questions the same way when politicians switch parties it's natural to expect from journlauts to grill them.
Regardless of how well she did, but certainty she looks ravishing and presentable to the eye, her views her rudimentary and will certainly never refine, reflected from her poor drawing of parallel of oranges and apples
@@AjayKumar-uk4sp u made the opening comment by saying that she demolished Barkha, could u unmake certain arguments she had that in no uncertain terms reflected demolition. Having a pre determined mindset with cynical bias makes anyone to write the script of his/her choice. Read between the lines, hopefully u might learn the subtlety of words
I really enjoyed this conversation, what a refreshing view of opinions from an Indian kashmiri muslim women, may this pave a way forward for many from Kashmir and hopefully put an end to radicalization there or anywhere in India
This was really insightful. We have seen so many people change their Political Stand in the past; but very few have explained the move with facts & observations! Watching this was refreshing as it did not seem anything like a political talk. It was about facts that are changing the Indian Political Framework & the social perspectives in J&K. For everybody who is actually interested in understanding social upliftment in the country & on-ground shifts in J&K, this video would be insightful. We need more such discussions! 👏👏
0:05 Sheila is talking perfect sense. India needs to encourage this kind of Indian Muslims in public life. It will be good for the country, as well as the impoverished section of Indian Muslims. Muslims should come out of the victim mindset and start working towards the upliftment of their society. As she concluded, " We are masters of our own destiny. "
@@putinisbiden8588 Always Negative Means Madrachaped, dadi-topi folowers, Owaisi's fan who always plays victim card of minorities in the name of democracy.😂😂😂
" One must be authentic about oneself " has made Shella Rashid a beautiful women , a wonderful person as well. We are waiting for Barkha to be " authentic with herself "
what an interview! totally floored by the answers and clarity given by Ms Sheila Rashid, hat's off to this lady for bringing such beautiful thoughts to light, the best part is that she did not at point of time hesitated about her past and current analysis/perception of the concept of India and the people
Regardless of her so called progressive nd feministic presentation compounded by liberal reflections, she will certainly b labelled a radical unless she doesn't fall on the platter of people's choice e
Very articulate lady. It is up to Modi to retain her support either outside BJP or inside BJP. We need more such leaders from J and K who should advocate development of Kashmir. They have every right to ask for Kashmir’s legitimate expectations within the four corners of Indian Constitution . Nice interview!!
Shehla Rasheed's ambition of presenting postive sides of Kashmir and exposing hypocrite who are doble face is admirable.Respect for her,Would have liked if she had not that dark past but i also know everyone changes with time as they learn and experience something new and different.Change in life should also be welcomed while keeping the ideology intact.
It’s a matter of perspective. From the extreme right, she may still appear to be on the left, while from the left, she might seem to be leaning right. Even though her position is now in the center, how people perceive her depends on where they themselves are standing.
@@krishanrathi9119Her position in center? not by choice If you take an average of her stands it is left wing ( nothing wrong being left wing but as journalist one should be always be neutral as much as possible) any way
It's quite evident why all the Islamists comments are hating her, but they should realise it's not her who has been brainwashed or pressurised but you all. She's much more educated and intelligent and could have gotten a party ticket from Congress or any other party just for trashing central government and our country, but she choose to stand for the betterment of her own people. Kudos to her, der aaye durust aaye.
No you may not know the whole story They formed a party which was welcomed by the whole j&k especially youth As they were the best brains of jk who politically & administratively would have represented jk at every level. But they betrayed!!
@@mudasirgul7650bcz they realised the people hv still deep interest in licking boots of dynasty like Abdullahs and Muftis so what could these young people could do without any Money, Infrastructure and political background so choose different path and now writing book to show Positive side of Muslims and Kashmir later on she might join politics who knows if a so called independent journalist like Rajdeep's Wife Can join TMC then why she can't.😊
An excellent interview . Barkha is always great . Shehla appeared to be outspoken and frank . Change in Shehla Rashid as said by many may not be true . She was a studious and brilliant girl of India and not different from other youths of our country . In Kolkata we are acclimated with the student unrest and protest like JNU . It is very normal . But many good students and youths were killed by the security forces during the rule of Congress in our state . We can not forget those days . However , JNU students’ protests could not determine the mainstream politics of the country but remain always remarkable as part of progressive movement .
The summary of shehla Rashid and Shah Faisal U Turn is:- There was always a major section of muslims in kashmir who thought they are Indians and with India..but they hold 370 sacred because of many other emotional kashmiris... ...these intellectuals thought that they cant outrightly reject evry demands of minority kashmiri who thinks otherway.. ..And section like this exist form North Eastern state...and they thought its historical and does no harm..but benifits them. -Now they changed because they see its too far,... and its too less to give everything for this article...while gain for kashmiri is going to come Even without this...and this might normalise and completely change kashmir..so they changed....and forgave the cruel move, while government also did lot of good things after that move ...😊
If every one is honest with himself or herself , all problems of the world will be over . We are seeing a great honest lady showing the way to others . Kudos !
I thought the same but later when she mentioned that “disability” word needs to be added in the constitution section… that shows how strongly she felt for that cause
What was funny was that of all the things she thought deserved criticism, she put GST on wheelchairs at the top. It was pretty disingenuous given her past ideas.
Its interesting to hear the interview. But only if Barkha can shut down her political leanings and agenda, just let people express their opinion before leading questions. And purely from a neutral perspective, for once can she leave the Muslim perspective and interview Hindus, Christians or Buddhists from J&K or Ladakh. I am just tired of one perspective that’s regressive and so religious oriented and not policy based.
Shehla Rashid's clear and progressive speech was refreshing and inspiring, contrasting with Barkha Dutt, who appeared to struggle with her agenda on certain areas. Shehla effectively turned challenging questions into constructive dialogue, focusing on solutions and creating an uplifting atmosphere that emphasized the potential for positive change through thoughtful conversation.
Could congress conduct J&K election at any time with more than 30% polling? First time, J&K people voted like any other state with more than 65% polling. It shows the change.
Hats off to you Sehla👍You are very practical and authentic.You are now really a role model for the present younger generation.Hope the younger generation take it seriously.
I used to be an anti-Modiji and supporter of the Congress.. I was so stupid but now I don't Modiji instead I WORSHIP HIM.. He has changed India.. being an NRI I am so PROUD OF TODAY'S INDIA.. I want RAHUL and SONIA KHAN TO LEAVE INDIA SO INDIAN CAN HAVE PEACE..JAI HIND
You don't need to worship him rather I would suggest you not to worship any politician sir in a democratic set up I'm myself a BJP voter but on many occasions I have criticised BJP govt.One one point I angry Rahul Gandhi recent remarks in media makes him look very dangerous for India.
I am a BJP & Modi supporter. You can support Modiji but no need to make him a God like figure. He has done a lot of good things for India and that is his job and responsibility. In India we have gotten so used to corrupt Politicians who only look after self interest that anything good a politician for the people and the country feels extraordinary. I live in Singapore and we are used to seeing the Politicians doing their job and there is a high level of integrity amongst Politicians and Public servants. The citizens do not feel grateful and or worship the Politicians for doing their job.
The interviewer can do the favour of not interrupting so frequently to break the chain of thought of the very focused interviewee who is treated like someone facing an interrogation
She knows what to do & where to do it. Initially started criticizing Modi to gain publicity lateron fearing risk of arrest she changed tune to praise Modi which benefited her in all ways.
or maybe, just maybe...you are not the all-knowing God and are wrong about her....maybe shes just being honest and bravely facing abuses from hate filled idiots like you for speaking the truth
Brother try to understand what she is trying to explain.....don't always use islamic chasma......and work on your own what was kashmir and what is now..... don't go with propaganda..... students going against army with stone means they will die... Right
Very heartening to listen to an open minded, scholarly lady like Shehla Rashid. I wish there are more people in all the communities, not only among Muslims, like her. She should play an important role in Kashmir for the sake of all Kashmiris.
Of course Kashmir is not Gaza,,, Indians want Kashmiris to be part of India and Jammu and Ladakah is on board it is the Islamist mindset in Kashmir that is a trouble
Great Sheila, This is the reality, Yes BJP has to do more for Kashmiri people.There shouldn't be any discrimination against Muslim community. As a Hindu,I do have great interaction and integration with Muslim community.
Her change of heart looks real. What problem can a Hindu like me have with such a Muslim? None whatsoever . She can practice her faith, I will practice mine. Unfortunately, a vast majority of people practicing her faith are not like her.
So commendable that Shehla is been so openly own her change of stance on the Kashmir issue! I was exactly in the same boat, and since then evolved my understanding of the issue. Kudos to Shehla!
Clean chit in Gujarat Riots has made her to change her stand. What a joke? Lady, go to Gujarat and talk with Bilkish, talk with family of Mr Jaafari, talk with family of Prof. Bandukwala. You will learn what did they face and why. It pains when youngsters like Shehla speak so soullessly. You are future of India. India certainly can’t afford you.
Perhaps she realised the same. If she doesn't matter to Kashmir or never did, what's the point of doing stupid activism when she can get money and fame and make a good life for herself ? She looks much more sophisticated and rich and pretty now. Sitting in AC rooms, earning lakhs every month is far better than burning in sun on streets shouting slogs
"We need to be united"....... love it . This should be the attitude... This should be the enlightened thoughts from a student from a JNU like Universities . Truth remain truth ...and it will come out one day ....!!
Without merit? You mean she is not educated or capable to become even an ASSISTANT professor?? You are talking as if she was made the dean or Principal of the college or made CM candidate or president of the political party!
Her speech itself proves that she is intelligent enough to get job on her merit. Dogale aur jahil log hi bina kisi mehnat se matlab nikalke apna mouth shut karte hai.
So nice to see the new generation seeing politics with a development and welfare perspective and not through a religion or caste perspective ! Sheila 👏👏 and Barkha high time you changed your perspective! Learn from the new Gen 🙏🏽
Shela Rashid, once a fierce critic of Modi and his autocracy, now a fan because Courts exonerated on the Gujrat riots and people like Bano and her family were murdered and she was raped. On the other hand Modi was about to arrest Shinde on corruption charges but overnight defected to the BJP. Charges forgotten and the rascal is made CM of Maharashtra. First Barkha does not bring up instances like this, and even as a mature journalist does not remind Shela that Modi was fully aware of the murders, in Gujarat riots. He did not even summon the army as in Manipur 2yrs ago. Now she very condescendingly says, "“What caused my change of heart is the realisation that the Hon’ble PM Narendra Modi is a selfless man who is taking radical decisions to transform India". For someone who has changed overnight, to become another Ranaut, certainly has its temptations. She is more fake than anyone seen so in a long time
Sheila is seeing things from the lens of Kashmir just like you are seeing from the lens of a leftist (anti right). I agree that Modi may be anything but selfless. But you have to give to people to change their mind. People evolve and Sheila will evolve too. Modi is no messiah for sure but then which politicians is? We all have our biases.
@@vs9324 No one can change the spots of a leopard. And Modi cannot change. People themselves have to find hones people who want to do something for their States. Is is that difficult in a country of over 1.5 billion?
Evolution as implied here x surely a regressive form of evolution where u distort even the factual imprint to quash urself of the possible blot that variably or invariably had either the deep seated interest fulfillment or delusional optics of a person who identifies herself leftist but rhymes for the far right
If Shehla has really realised that Kashmir and Muslims fate is in sync with and depends on India’s and other communities development and prosperity and equal treatment in all sphere, then she is really evolving for the good of everyone including herself. Having done extremely regressive job in the past, she will have to put extreme efforts to come up clean as well, more further Good luck Shehla 👍
Barkha's interview with Shehla and Samdish Bhatia's with Sajjad Lone are 2 of the best interviews we have had on Kashmir in ages - kudos to both and more power to the actual Free press
Shehla comes across as an 'honest' intellectual, which is a rarity. A true gem who has questioned and observed the machinations of politicians and her people in Kashmir.
What ideology you are talking? Dogale aur jahil soch vale sach ka samana nahi karte hai. Agar kisi ka hridaya pariwartan sach janane me hota hai to isme ideology ka kya sambandh hai?.
What amazing multifaceted, multi talented lady. You are a perfect role model for the distracted youth of the current generation & an embodiment of confidence, grit & determination. There is not an iota of doubt that you will reach great heights & flourish in what ever vocation you choose.My heartiest wishes young lady.
Or she may have realised that the path she was on,was a dead end....one needs to change according to circumstances and time otherwise one will become history that no one cares about....
Or how money and power can change your life for the better. Other than media headlines, what did activism bring to her ? now with money, she is looking so pretty. Her dressing, makeup, english all are sophisticated 🤣🤣
God bless Shehla Rashid. It is very difficult to see the truth at large once you give in to a religious identity and that too when it is quite Orthodox. If we can see the right or wrong in a situation , forgetting our identity as a Hindu or Muslim, that wakes up our conscience to side with the right and we can always school people to also know their wrongs in the side we take. I am very proud of the fact that you had a great Conscience to weigh the same issues at two points of time and finally even endorse the other side you were in conflict. The point to be emphasized is that we as humans are Hypocrites and only if Institutions and Society start showing the mirror to every hypocrite, the reality will strike at him and he will be aware that humanity is the religion that should bind us across other beliefs and faiths followed by us, subject to of course reasonable reasonable restrictions. WE ARE VERY PROUD OF YOUR HIGTENED SENSE OF DISCERNING AND your courage of identifying yourself with the Right which you believe, no matter where and how you started.
![[Live สด] การออกรางวัลสลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล งวดวันที่ 16 พฤศจิกายน 2567](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wPd7VFfWHIA/mqdefault.jpg)
What a wonderful woman and an example of how a real Indian Muslim should be. May Allah bless her and give her more strength.
Can't say anything don't trust anybody
Yes Sir, amazing, we all should be Indians first.
Waah kal toh tuu anti national bula rahe the isskoo
@@sandykhp Well her act was for sure. But der aye toh durust aye. She is a changed person now as she admits in this interview. Abb teri bari hain change honey kii.
Who is She ? She has no credibility in kashmir.
Barkha looks unhappy, a staunch leftist couldn't see a good leftist is shifting towards right.
Heh! Heh! Same feeling ham bhi parakh paye !!😂
Paise mille hain😂 bjp se
@@newajulhoque9309 ha paisa sabko chaiye. ideology, religion, activism ye sab middle class cheeze he. kal tujhe b agar mil gaye 10 lakh free me, tu b modi modi karega. Use dekh. kitni sundar lag rahi he, makeup, dressing, foreign jesi elite english. Paisa sab kuch kharid sakta he. sab kuch
@@newajulhoque9309dard hua kya 😂
She looks sad
Her answers were like straight forward, no nonsense. She was totally right about APJ Abdul Kalam.
Ya, u r saying correct.
But muslims won't accept her as they liked Shabana Azmi, they'll abuse her and blame for being sold off
Being a Kashmiri i am 1000% with her.
tu Kashmiri nehin Hain tu 2 rupee coolie Hai
Good that Kashmiri youth or awaam have choosen the path to 🕊️
Yes Azhar, I believe you also agree with me, we are Human Beings first and definitely we are Indians first too.
We all should be good Human Beings first and be empathetical to another Human Being too.
Look up ex-muslim Sahil
The best turnaround story I have come across in decades.
Very practical and authentic.
Ya, it seems so.
@@muditarya On the one side Shehla Rashid is talking about reforms, stop polygamy, increase women rights but durkha dutt is continuously spinning around left-wing, right-wing, centrewing burkha is such a lol
Her thoughts are matured and logical
She presented in articulated manner
demonstrating her practical and rational forward thinking approach
Agreed
She would be a bit credible if she had done a interview like this before joining BJP.
What is rational about being left liberal of Marxist kind, ot leninist kind. Most inhuman, irrational ideology next only to Islam.
but her constitution first or religion,, truth will come
@@Alice-th9lu When did she join the BJP?
This discussion indicates that both Barkha Dutt and Shehla Rashid experienced a major turnaround and realised that reality was way different from what they imagined. Narendra Modi has indeed changed India for the better. Even if people don't vote for him he ensures that they are provided all facilities that all citizens should have. Moreover, he is working to change the eco-system in India in a way that enables everyone to rise.
I am very happy to watch Sehla becoming matured. She thinks positive and reality unlike polititians of today. I wish she remains the same when she joins politics and works for the betterment of people of india specially Kashmiris though I don't belong to Kashmir. God bless Sehla.
Very soon she will be given BJP ticket against Kanaiya Kumar 😃
Barkha is shocked that Shehla changed sooooo much …..and also Shehla could not find a bad thing in Modi
😢😢😢WhatsApp uncle modi the murder of haren pandya
@@Indian1-100chamcheee chup
Barkha nahi sudharegi😂😂😂
Modi changed Kashmir but Muslims mindset is no change this is unfortunate.
True that.
कडवा सच
Muthalman ka jazbaa muuth marne Tak simit hai😅😅
Would you like it if an outsider came and rescued you in your own state. You will resent him, it is not logical but emotions are not always logical. Kashmiris resentment of Modi are understandable
Mindset is a collection of narrative propagated by leaders, be it religious, political or literary leaders.
Common Muslim minds are hijacked by such conservative and radical leadership and those who have different opinion like APJ Abdul Kalam has castigated for being liberal and disowned as being true Muslim.
Most importantly these radicals derive their Legitimacy from religious scriptures and hence Muslims have no chance.
Excellent conversation. The young lady is a pride of India. My best wishes for her success in life.
Shehla Rashid is a true intellectual because she is ready to change her opinions while keeping her core principles . It shows she doesnt have an ego about her belief systems . And her rationality is above political ideology. She also has a beautiful voice, the podcast could have been longer 😎.
She is a very matured lady who thinking sensibly.
Superb women… what a transformation…. I hope she becomes the voice for Muslim and change them and make India a better place and become symbol of humanity
Muslims will disown her soon
Usually, I dont like Bharkha Dutt's podcasts, but this one I really liked. Way to go girl Shehla....Best wishes to you.
Barkha is becoming more balanced and open in her functioning.
She now realised Kashmir is peaceful. She wants peace.
again you are being misled by their secret hidden agenda,,,al taquiya
do you know about kalnemi
Muslims talking about azaadi look what is there in Iran Iraq Pakistan tell me one Muslim democratic country
A very good interview. Consistency of views in politics irrespective of the changing times would be foolish.She is right when she says that Modi has done lot of good in Kashmir and in the country.
Really impressed with her thoughts on different issues. May she enter politics and serve the people of her state who have been under immense hardship. God bless her for her future assignments.
Brilliant . The future of J &K as well as the country is in safe hands with people like Shehla Rashid in the grooming . Best wishes to her
When you turn the criticism into aprreciations.. then both, your leadership & the turnaround of the opponent should be equally cheered!!🇮🇳🇮🇳✨
Very well said that the Kashmir was made a problematic state by NC & PDP. These politicians never allowed people of Kashmir to integrate with the Country that is India.
The two, She and Shah Fasil were / are wonderful Indians and have done everything for the country under BJP. They were party of 370 and withdraw once the court started hearing. This sacrifices for BJP is remembered the way , Mr. S. Soz have uprooted Atal jis govt for Congress.
Shela U nailed it down..Its even hard for Barkha to deviate from your logical arguments ...It's called maturity when u can put your mind without prejudice and being in prison of your past.Pls join politics and be part of change
Love modi from arunachal n Shaila mem❤
LOVE YOU BRO ...
I am amazed at how smart and intelligent she is - hats off to her. And secondly she is right Muslims also write that their dhaba or biryani house is halal - so that Muslims wouldn't have any issues eating their meat. Also while travelling Muslims also try to have pure veg food when they don't get halal - they would also prefer Jain bhojanalayas, etc - so it shouldn't be a problem having the name of the owner - the names serve as a brand in themselves - and using a brand in a deceitful manner is also wrong
I am your fan Shela. You are a great brand ambassador for the modern muslims. Jai Shri Ram.
Younger generation out of the common people has to be encouraged to get chance to take part in politics and other economic issues. The situation has changed and people want genuine leadership and sound political system.
Loved the interview
Agreed ! They should be motivated and inspired for constructive future.
Absolute fan of Shehla Rashid. Hope we as a country unite to move ahead
Good to see the change coming from
Tukde tukde & chicken neck gang from JNU. But can one trust her?
Shehla Rashid, once a fierce critics of Modi government, now finds herself navigating the difficult terrain of balancing two seemingly opposing roles-on one hand, defending the policies of the BJP government with skills that bjp’s own spokesperson lack, and on the other, trying to stay true to her progressive ideals and her true authentic self. The challenge of reconciling these two responsibilities is immense, and no one would wish to be in such a position. Yet, Shehla manages to do so with remarkable conviction and grace. One can only hope that, in time, the weight of political pressure or necessity will lift, allowing her to fully embody the ideals of a progressive society and become a true role models of intellectual courage and strength she is destined to be for her people.
Obvious certainty of regressive mind, nothing of progressive spark to b an ideal for anyone at home or abroad, defined by her utilitarian principles dat push her to rollover from critic to crazy fan
She was very articulate with her positioning of BJP as a welfare party and why that resonates with her political leanings. Not many in Indian public space have the critical argument making skills to pivot across ideological leanings, when questioned. She is an exception and that would serve her well in future.
chacha ,,dont go for sweet al taquiya...its theri strategyto be silent or sweet in times of minority...once they are in majority then you wil see
Shehla is brilliant!! such a bright girl, bold, honest to the point replies to Barkha who tried her best to corner her & get at least some negative, controversial comment...
Shehla is so admirable in her fairness and love for justice and love for people
Beautiful thoughts, Sheila. You really have to come to the forefront and bring a change to whatever you think best. Because l really echo the sentiments of youri. God bless you dear
Remebering Barkha first to interviewing KK... in JNU.. that was raw & full of apriori.. But this interview with SR is far excellent that with that of KK... Full of heuristic... the JUN original style of 90s of Prakash Karat, Sitaram Yetchuri, DPT, David Thomas, D. Raghunandanji, Anand Kumar & J. Benerjee time... Full of free thinking.. Real pluralism... Jai Hind.
Barkha very unhappy that she lost one young tool to use.
Ms Dutt trying so hard to get her to say some negative stuff about Modi 😂
Always negative energy@@srishtit1796
shes just doing her job bro..get a life
Yeah! Yeah! 😂. I noted that too ! 😂
As a Modi voter, to be fair she was trying to ask tough questions the same way when politicians switch parties it's natural to expect from journlauts to grill them.
@@daveinvictus Modi bashing/baiting is just doing her job, as a journalist, like fixing ministers and ministries during UPA regime. Right bro?
This is the best interview. She has passively demolished brakha from within
Regardless of how well she did, but certainty she looks ravishing and presentable to the eye, her views her rudimentary and will certainly never refine, reflected from her poor drawing of parallel of oranges and apples
@@zahidganai7997 example? you are full of vagueness without specifics. i am here to solve your confusion
@@AjayKumar-uk4spNo confusion whatsoever, get clarity in ur understanding, cloud of ur judgemental mind will evaporate
@@zahidganai7997 still word salad no specific. So far you just said words no pointa
@@AjayKumar-uk4sp u made the opening comment by saying that she demolished Barkha, could u unmake certain arguments she had that in no uncertain terms reflected demolition. Having a pre determined mindset with cynical bias makes anyone to write the script of his/her choice. Read between the lines, hopefully u might learn the subtlety of words
I really enjoyed this conversation, what a refreshing view of opinions from an Indian kashmiri muslim women, may this pave a way forward for many from Kashmir and hopefully put an end to radicalization there or anywhere in India
This was really insightful. We have seen so many people change their Political Stand in the past; but very few have explained the move with facts & observations! Watching this was refreshing as it did not seem anything like a political talk. It was about facts that are changing the Indian Political Framework & the social perspectives in J&K.
For everybody who is actually interested in understanding social upliftment in the country & on-ground shifts in J&K, this video would be insightful.
We need more such discussions! 👏👏
chatukar? or 2 rupee coolie?
0:05 Sheila is talking perfect sense. India needs to encourage this kind of Indian Muslims in public life. It will be good for the country, as well as the impoverished section of Indian Muslims. Muslims should come out of the victim mindset and start working towards the upliftment of their society. As she concluded, " We are masters of our own destiny. "
A very enlightened, deeply thought out position. I admire Sehla for the strong sense of fairness and clarity of thought.
What is beautiful isn't always good, but what is good is always beautiful seeing shela is more beautiful now
Adani's fan means you are beautiful?😂
@@putinisbiden8588 Always Negative Means Madrachaped, dadi-topi folowers, Owaisi's fan who always plays victim card of minorities in the name of democracy.😂😂😂
" One must be authentic about oneself " has made Shella Rashid a beautiful women , a wonderful person as well.
We are waiting for Barkha to be " authentic with herself "
what an interview! totally floored by the answers and clarity given by Ms Sheila Rashid, hat's off to this lady for bringing such beautiful thoughts to light, the best part is that she did not at point of time hesitated about her past and current analysis/perception of the concept of India and the people
Very brave girl. She is flourishing.
Hmm, She thinks. That's how Shehla matured and grown. Only brave, mature, and honest can do it. ❤
Bharak is more radiclasied than this girl
Ha ! Ha ! True. True. 😂
You mean not andh bakth?
@@niazkamaruddeen632 what I mean u understand
Radiclasied
R u one of tham
Regardless of her so called progressive nd feministic presentation compounded by liberal reflections, she will certainly b labelled a radical unless she doesn't fall on the platter of people's choice e
You mean Burqa thu thu
Very articulate lady. It is up to Modi to retain her support either outside BJP or inside BJP. We need more such leaders from J and K who should advocate development of Kashmir. They have every right to ask for Kashmir’s legitimate expectations within the four corners of Indian Constitution . Nice interview!!
100% right shehla mam
Shehla Rasheed's ambition of presenting postive sides of Kashmir and exposing hypocrite who are doble face is admirable.Respect for her,Would have liked if she had not that dark past but i also know everyone changes with time as they learn and experience something new and different.Change in life should also be welcomed while keeping the ideology intact.
A Rashid can change but a Datta won't change .. tragedy of Indian Hindus
Dutt has changed too but just a little!
@@bharatpandit4796 h.....mmmm hard top believe
It’s a matter of perspective. From the extreme right, she may still appear to be on the left, while from the left, she might seem to be leaning right. Even though her position is now in the center, how people perceive her depends on where they themselves are standing.
@@krishanrathi9119Her position in center? not by choice If you take an average of her stands it is left wing ( nothing wrong being left wing but as journalist one should be always be neutral as much as possible) any way
bengal bane of India
Seriously, a drastic change...and thats welcome🎉.....hope u change also influence all muslims in this positive way...
It's quite evident why all the Islamists comments are hating her, but they should realise it's not her who has been brainwashed or pressurised but you all. She's much more educated and intelligent and could have gotten a party ticket from Congress or any other party just for trashing central government and our country, but she choose to stand for the betterment of her own people.
Kudos to her, der aaye durust aaye.
No you may not know the whole story
They formed a party which was welcomed by the whole j&k especially youth
As they were the best brains of jk who politically & administratively would have represented jk at every level.
But they betrayed!!
@@mudasirgul7650bcz they realised the people hv still deep interest in licking boots of dynasty like Abdullahs and Muftis so what could these young people could do without any Money, Infrastructure and political background so choose different path and now writing book to show Positive side of Muslims and Kashmir later on she might join politics who knows if a so called independent journalist like Rajdeep's Wife Can join TMC then why she can't.😊
An excellent interview . Barkha is always great . Shehla appeared to be outspoken and frank . Change in Shehla Rashid as said by many may not be true . She was a studious and brilliant girl of India and not different from other youths of our country . In Kolkata we are acclimated with the student unrest and protest like JNU . It is very normal . But many good students and youths were killed by the security forces during the rule of Congress in our state . We can not forget those days . However , JNU students’ protests could not determine the mainstream politics of the country but remain always remarkable as part of progressive movement .
The summary of shehla Rashid and Shah Faisal U Turn is:-
There was always a major section of muslims in kashmir who thought they are Indians and with India..but they hold 370 sacred because of many other emotional kashmiris...
...these intellectuals thought that they cant outrightly reject evry demands of minority kashmiri who thinks otherway..
..And section like this exist form North Eastern state...and they thought its historical and does no harm..but benifits them.
-Now they changed because they see its too far,... and its too less to give everything for this article...while gain for kashmiri is going to come Even without this...and this might normalise and completely change kashmir..so they changed....and forgave the cruel move, while government also did lot of good things after that move ...😊
If every one is honest with himself or herself , all problems of the world will be over . We are seeing a great honest lady showing the way to others . Kudos !
that thing about GST on wheelchairs was funny.
I thought the same but later when she mentioned that “disability” word needs to be added in the constitution section… that shows how strongly she felt for that cause
She was just trying to fool Charkha who was continuing to finger Shehla and ignite the fake left narrative she left long ago
Its not funny Sir once you realise that if India is to become developed country we need to look after our disabled people
What was funny was that of all the things she thought deserved criticism, she put GST on wheelchairs at the top. It was pretty disingenuous given her past ideas.
Shaila is a woman of modern ideas. She has a rational thinking and accepts frankly the shortcomings of her religion also. Commendable interview !
Its interesting to hear the interview. But only if Barkha can shut down her political leanings and agenda, just let people express their opinion before leading questions.
And purely from a neutral perspective, for once can she leave the Muslim perspective and interview Hindus, Christians or Buddhists from J&K or Ladakh. I am just tired of one perspective that’s regressive and so religious oriented and not policy based.
Yup. Correctly noticed and expressed.
YOU SAID IT!
Shehla Rashid's clear and progressive speech was refreshing and inspiring, contrasting with Barkha Dutt, who appeared to struggle with her agenda on certain areas.
Shehla effectively turned challenging questions into constructive dialogue, focusing on solutions and creating an uplifting atmosphere that emphasized the potential for positive change through thoughtful conversation.
Could congress conduct J&K election at any time with more than 30% polling? First time, J&K people voted like any other state with more than 65% polling. It shows the change.
Hats off to you Sehla👍You are very practical and authentic.You are now really a role model for the present younger generation.Hope the younger generation take it seriously.
I used to be an anti-Modiji and supporter of the Congress.. I was so stupid but now I don't Modiji instead I WORSHIP HIM.. He has changed India.. being an NRI I am so PROUD OF TODAY'S INDIA.. I want RAHUL and SONIA KHAN TO LEAVE INDIA SO INDIAN CAN HAVE PEACE..JAI HIND
You don't need to worship him rather I would suggest you not to worship any politician sir in a democratic set up I'm myself a BJP voter but on many occasions I have criticised BJP govt.One one point I angry Rahul Gandhi recent remarks in media makes him look very dangerous for India.
I am a BJP & Modi supporter. You can support Modiji but no need to make him a God like figure. He has done a lot of good things for India and that is his job and responsibility. In India we have gotten so used to corrupt Politicians who only look after self interest that anything good a politician for the people and the country feels extraordinary.
I live in Singapore and we are used to seeing the Politicians doing their job and there is a high level of integrity amongst Politicians and Public servants.
The citizens do not feel grateful and or worship the Politicians for doing their job.
The interviewer can do the favour of not interrupting so frequently to break the chain of thought of the very focused interviewee who is treated like someone facing an interrogation
She knows what to do & where to do it. Initially started criticizing Modi to gain publicity lateron fearing risk of arrest she changed tune to praise Modi which benefited her in all ways.
Ok gareeb..
or maybe, just maybe...you are not the all-knowing God and are wrong about her....maybe shes just being honest and bravely facing abuses from hate filled idiots like you for speaking the truth
Brother try to understand what she is trying to explain.....don't always use islamic chasma......and work on your own what was kashmir and what is now..... don't go with propaganda..... students going against army with stone means they will die...
Right
OR OR OR she understood the truth and how things should be done.
She is talking very logical not under fear
What a positive change !
Shehla , so constructive in her thoughts now !
Well done 👍
Shehla you have a sharp intellect and you are absolutely articulate! Kashmir should benefit from that.
Rashid had so many valid points. Show world better side not the stereo type by being violent and so on.............
Very heartening to listen to an open minded, scholarly lady like Shehla Rashid. I wish there are more people in all the communities, not only among Muslims, like her. She should play an important role in Kashmir for the sake of all Kashmiris.
Of course Kashmir is not Gaza,,, Indians want Kashmiris to be part of India and Jammu and Ladakah is on board it is the Islamist mindset in Kashmir that is a trouble
Great Sheila,
This is the reality,
Yes BJP has to do more for Kashmiri people.There shouldn't be any discrimination against Muslim community.
As a Hindu,I do have great interaction and integration with Muslim community.
Nice interview! Journalist is trying to trap left nd right but the guest is also very smart!
Her change of heart looks real. What problem can a Hindu like me have with such a Muslim? None whatsoever . She can practice her faith, I will practice mine. Unfortunately, a vast majority of people practicing her faith are not like her.
Very nicely explanation about life and situation in kashmir. Great 👍
So commendable that Shehla is been so openly own her change of stance on the Kashmir issue! I was exactly in the same boat, and since then evolved my understanding of the issue.
Kudos to Shehla!
Clean chit in Gujarat Riots has made her to change her stand. What a joke? Lady, go to Gujarat and talk with Bilkish, talk with family of Mr Jaafari, talk with family of Prof. Bandukwala. You will learn what did they face and why. It pains when youngsters like Shehla speak so soullessly. You are future of India. India certainly can’t afford you.
Talk to the family of 72 Hindus burned alive ????
She is talking out of shame. Pple of kshmir do not know her 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@ghulamhassandar4091 Shame of supporting killing of Kashmiri Hindus !
Talk of 22 percent hindu population come to 8 percent since 1947 till now in east Pakistan and bangladesh
May be she spoke to the Hindus driven out of kashmir amid carnage and pacified herself ‘it happpens‘, and moved on?
Shehla Rashid never mattered for the people of Kashmir. Neither she matters now nor she mattered earlier. She can change her views every now and then.
It shows our double faces😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Are You guys from Kashmir and going to vote for 370 restoration??
@@dr.s.square1491 Yes from Kashmir but not going to vote for the restoration of Article 370. It's history now.
For you only hatred for hindus and India matter
Perhaps she realised the same. If she doesn't matter to Kashmir or never did, what's the point of doing stupid activism when she can get money and fame and make a good life for herself ? She looks much more sophisticated and rich and pretty now. Sitting in AC rooms, earning lakhs every month is far better than burning in sun on streets shouting slogs
"We need to be united"....... love it . This should be the attitude... This should be the enlightened thoughts from a student from a JNU like Universities . Truth remain truth ...and it will come out one day ....!!
She got an Assistant Professor Job out of nowhere to shut her mouth..... Ask her, ye AP kaisay ban gayi without merit ...
Without merit? You mean she is not educated or capable to become even an ASSISTANT professor?? You are talking as if she was made the dean or Principal of the college or made CM candidate or president of the political party!
Apparently she was the epitome of philosophy for you people when she was protesting in JNU. Tells us about the merit of people in this conversation.
She is atheist, she has put muslim mask and she is BJP puppet
Her speech itself proves that she is intelligent enough to get job on her merit. Dogale aur jahil log hi bina kisi mehnat se matlab nikalke apna mouth shut karte hai.
Then kaniya and Umar Khalid should be made AP as well according to u@@mbxyz463
So nice to see the new generation seeing politics with a development and welfare perspective and not through a religion or caste perspective ! Sheila 👏👏 and Barkha high time you changed your perspective! Learn from the new Gen 🙏🏽
Shela Rashid, once a fierce critic of Modi and his autocracy, now a fan because Courts exonerated on the Gujrat riots and people like Bano and her family were murdered and she was raped. On the other hand Modi was about to arrest Shinde on corruption charges but overnight defected to the BJP. Charges forgotten and the rascal is made CM of Maharashtra. First Barkha does not bring up instances like this, and even as a mature journalist does not remind Shela that Modi was fully aware of the murders, in Gujarat riots. He did not even summon the army as in Manipur 2yrs ago.
Now she very condescendingly says, "“What caused my change of heart is the realisation that the Hon’ble PM Narendra Modi is a selfless man who is taking radical decisions to transform India". For someone who has changed overnight, to become another Ranaut, certainly has its temptations. She is more fake than anyone seen so in a long time
Sheila is seeing things from the lens of Kashmir just like you are seeing from the lens of a leftist (anti right). I agree that Modi may be anything but selfless. But you have to give to people to change their mind. People evolve and Sheila will evolve too. Modi is no messiah for sure but then which politicians is? We all have our biases.
@@vs9324 No one can change the spots of a leopard. And Modi cannot change. People themselves have to find hones people who want to do something for their States. Is is that difficult in a country of over 1.5 billion?
@@paddysingh8487 All politicians are wolves in sheep's clothes.
Evolution as implied here x surely a regressive form of evolution where u distort even the factual imprint to quash urself of the possible blot that variably or invariably had either the deep seated interest fulfillment or delusional optics of a person who identifies herself leftist but rhymes for the far right
she is really something special the way she is actually explaining is something special👌
She doesn't know Omar Khalid case details. shameless woman
why? is she his mother? or his begum? do u know details of every person in jail?
Bhai tumhe hoga Umar Khalid pe crush. Tu jaa ke padh case details.
You the One *SHAMELESS* , Kuck Change, Progress Hajam hi Nahi kerte
the terror accused?
Tumhe pata hai to jake ke ladho court me umar khalid ke liye.
If Shehla has really realised that Kashmir and Muslims fate is in sync with and depends on India’s and other communities development and prosperity and equal treatment in all sphere, then she is really evolving for the good of everyone including herself.
Having done extremely regressive job in the past, she will have to put extreme efforts to come up clean as well, more further
Good luck Shehla 👍
Shela Rashid 💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻
Barkha's interview with Shehla and Samdish Bhatia's with Sajjad Lone are 2 of the best interviews we have had on Kashmir in ages - kudos to both and more power to the actual Free press
How the removal of article 370 stopped moral policing? What's the connection?
Shehla comes across as an 'honest' intellectual, which is a rarity. A true gem who has questioned and observed the machinations of politicians and her people in Kashmir.
She talks about ideologies when she doesn't have one of her own. Shameless!
What ideology you are talking? Dogale aur jahil soch vale sach ka samana nahi karte hai. Agar kisi ka hridaya pariwartan sach janane me hota hai to isme ideology ka kya sambandh hai?.
Search about Al taqya she is doing that@@shrikrishnachinchanikar900
Ek hi ideology mein zindgi nikal di.
She has sold her conscious for money. She is a classic eg of a hypocrite.
@@appodeepo sahi kaha aapne...ek baap aur ek ideology mein zindagi kaat di apni...par aap aisa mat karna...roz badliye ideology aur....
Barkha just saved her career through this podcast. She will be accepted now
Simply excellent, barkha did great bringing sheleja so open and frank so truthful
Oh....she is bothered about tax on wheel chairs. Interesting
Trying to fool people
Ohh..you are the secular one.....
She is worried about disabled people (she later clearly spelt it out). So, what is wrong in that?
I do hope Sehla Rashid does well we need thinking like her. Take our country to not just Kashmir but the whole of India to greater heights !
shela rashid shora....women with two faces.....article 370 exposed her
How?
Triggered by a woman having a different opinion from maulvi
What amazing multifaceted, multi talented lady. You are a perfect role model for the distracted youth of the current generation & an embodiment of confidence, grit & determination. There is not an iota of doubt that you will reach great heights & flourish in what ever vocation you choose.My heartiest wishes young lady.
Shela rashid is a classic example of how money n power corrupts a personality
How? Please explain...
Or she may have realised that the path she was on,was a dead end....one needs to change according to circumstances and time otherwise one will become history that no one cares about....
Judgement day is as true as the fact that earth is flat.
Or how money and power can change your life for the better. Other than media headlines, what did activism bring to her ? now with money, she is looking so pretty. Her dressing, makeup, english all are sophisticated 🤣🤣
What about dutta 😂
Shehla is so beautifully settled!
So nice for the state .
She is now probably BJP spokesman! Whom she wants to make fool? Better stand in front of a mirror Shela!
So what if she is a BJP spokesperson? Aapko mirchi lag rahi hai?
God bless Shehla Rashid. It is very difficult to see the truth at large once you give in to a religious identity and that too when it is quite Orthodox. If we can see the right or wrong in a situation , forgetting our identity as a Hindu or Muslim, that wakes up our conscience to side with the right and we can always school people to also know their wrongs in the side we take. I am very proud of the fact that you had a great Conscience to weigh the same issues at two points of time and finally even endorse the other side you were in conflict. The point to be emphasized is that we as humans are Hypocrites and only if Institutions and Society start showing the mirror to every hypocrite, the reality will strike at him and he will be aware that humanity is the religion that should bind us across other beliefs and faiths followed by us, subject to of course reasonable reasonable restrictions. WE ARE VERY PROUD OF YOUR HIGTENED SENSE OF DISCERNING AND your courage of identifying yourself with the Right which you believe, no matter where and how you started.