War and Remembrance - "Selection" Scene at Auschwitz-Birkenau
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 พ.ค. 2011
- One of the first films to be filmed on location in Birkenau. The opening scene of the train approaching Birkenau is exactly the view we got when we marched with "March of the Living 2011" on May 2, 2011.
Branko Lustig, the creator of the series, was one of the speakers this year, and, at 80 years old, he had his Bar Mitzvah in front of the block in Auschwitz where he was a prisoner. Survivors who have seen this scene say it was eerily close to how "selection" really worked at Birkenau. One flick of the thumb determined whether the person would be dead within the hour or live to see another day.
The scene following this one shows the gas chambers and crematorium - this is a MUST SEE series (available on Netflix).
![[TH] VCT Pacific Stage 2 - Playoffs Day 2 // PRX vs GEN | DRX vs TLN](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gmrSk-_ahlA/mqdefault.jpg)
Two survivors of Auschwitz had a bakery in my town. They rarely said anything about that time, but when I expressed my horror (and my fear it could happen again), the wife, Helga, said, “always remember…a human being can get used to anything, whether it is watching their homeland become a Nazi wasteland, or watching human beings turn each other into ash.” Wasn’t true for her…two weeks after her husband died of a heart attack, she committed suicide. He had saved her in the camp by smuggling her bites of food (he worked outside the gates)…and she didn’t want to go on without him. I will always feel like she was one of the last of Hitler’s victims…she never got over finding out her entire family was gone after the war, and she didn’t want to be left behind without her beloved husband, without anyone. RIP, Ari and Helga. Be at peace….
@@randomboyig Stalin tötete mehr
How very sad, God Bless...
@N/A ok, but not before wishing the same for Stalin & chairman Mao, they killed far far more people but they mostly escape criticism being left wing.
Thank you for sharing that story. What a kind, thoughtful person you must be.
Oh my goodness, what a very sad story 😢
"To forget the dead would be akin to killing them a second time."
~Elie Wiesel~
He spoke at my school to a very small group and my bf and I got tickets. We got to meet him and he was lovely; I was just in awe as I’d read his Night trilogy and he read a particular passage from a death march that haunted me since I read it. So to hear him speak and see him in a small room afterwards for tea etc., was truly an indescribable experience. It was like I was shaking hands with a part of history. RIParadise Mr. Wiesel
“To remember the dead would be akin to the living dying a thousand times.”
~Anon Ymous~
You can say a lot about Elie Wiesel, but he was not a moral philosopher. Of course nobody have killed anybody by just forgetting about them. What an absurd phrase to come up with! Elie Wiesel would have counted as a serial killer himself, as often as he probably forgot about people.
Can there ever be forgiveness for this level of cruelty and inhumanity? If God had been willing to give us one more chance after this what must he think of the hundreds of thousands of people worldwide continuing to harbor sympathies for Hitler and Nahtzees. Wretched people living among us promoting the exact same nationalistic ideology and racial intolerance that made the Holocaust possible. And Americans watch as the exact same evil grows right under our noses. We watch as millions entertain a willingness to install a despotic demagogue that would replace democracy with a fascist regime that would resurrect the 3rd Reich right here in the US. Perhaps it's best to imagine that there is no God for I cannot imagine him forgiving people willing to allow this to happen again.
"...First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me..." - Martin Niemoller
@@HarvardChickie l
Imagine the trauma of being ripped apart from your family never to see them again
💔😢
Most of them died shortly after getting there.
😢😢
There all together in Paradise!! How can another human do this to another human?? Animals are nicer!!
You mean become a Palestinian ?
No matter what sort of day you may have had, remember this and give thanks that you did not have to suffer as they did. Rest in peace.
Already happening again with the vaccinations
Durirg the c19 scare, we came very close to putting people into camps to "save" Grandma. Are you aware of the internment of Japanese-Americans in the early 40's? It has happened here before.
they just suffered in the imagination of hollywood movie makers
@@shauny2285well the last time I checked Japanese-Americans weren’t put into camps and murdered on a mass scale..
@@michaelram3411🤦🏼♀️
The selection officer actor played the role of pure evil perfectly. Not talking, using only his thumb and his stares is haunting ..
Bo tak było naprawdę tylko zamiast kciuka używali kawałka trzcinki. W wagonach transportujących ofiary było znacznie więcej ludzi niż na filmie, był totalny ścisk, nie było możliwości żeby usiąść, ludzie stali nawet 72 godziny
They teach me left or right
He is in hell himself, but like the demons he thinks himself free to come and go,
It's Dr Joseph Mengele
@@sofiastern1653 no its not Mengele
The history of humanity consists of a billion cruelties, most of which have never been recorded.
but for 17 centuries, in the west, when it came to questions of faith, the same people almost EVERYWHERE... people who just wanted to work, raise their families, pay their taxes and CONTRIBUTE were marginalized, robbed, exiled, tortured . or killed outright... even down to their babies and toddlers.... you sorta kinda tend to remember that.... Were their tormenters operating on a distorted 'take' on religion?... of course... but that didn't stop anybody.
@@billykravitz4993 Holodomor
I know Im asking the wrong place but does any of you know of a trick to get back into an instagram account..?
I was stupid forgot my password. I love any tricks you can offer me!
@Emory Bodhi instablaster :)
@Shawn Trace i really appreciate your reply. I got to the site thru google and im in the hacking process now.
Takes a while so I will get back to you later when my account password hopefully is recovered.
Even after all my years of studying the Holocaust (16 years), this scene still stops me dead in my tracks. I cannot feel anything nor blink. I feel as though I’m standing on a balance beam divided between raw emotion and desensitization.
It’s the eyes. I sincerely hope that the millions who perished have everlasting peace and comfort in the sky.
I weep for humanity.
You didn’t research the false chimney then?
Arbiet Macht Frie
The Germans like Romans thumbs left or right thumbs up or down
Nous allons disparaître de la surface de la terre. La terre vas avoir grosse fièvre pour ce débarrasser de l humanité. Le changement climatique va être catastrophique il ça falloir 'attendre 500 ans pour retrouver les conditions d avant. Nous nous serons plus là. Les âmes' humaines auront une autre histoire en se réincarnant ailleurs sur d autres planètes avec d autres 'conditions.... Ne riez pas...
That's exactly what you're supposed to say. Congratulations.
My friend's mother was in a camp and when they came to America she ended up in a mental hospital because of her memories.
So sad..
lol
☹
Sadly, the mental hospitals back then often had horrific conditions of their own. I believe it was a rare thing for them to actually help people in any meaningful way.
@@tiemuzhen8896 lol ?? 🤮🤬
I have visited Auschwitz today. I am not religious but this is a most unholy place. All should visit, all should remember, none must repeat.
Thank you for uploading.
Holocaustianity religion of the koi nidre
kevin church Well done for making a fake word up. Top marks. I bet you have an education don’t you!!
Morons like you help the Zionists. You blame ALL Jews. You are an ignorant little fool to do that. Suppose you think I am a Tory voter because I’m from England? Gullible prick.
@@robertbishop5357 it hardens the realist in me. we live in an existential world where use of power must be justified but when applied, knocks yer enemy totally down so evil doesn't rise up again.
Jim bob Really? I felt the exact opposite. It’s probably one of the largest grave yards in the world. I felt like I was standing on sacred ground not unholy ground. I had the same feeling at the 9/11 memorial
And your point is?
My grandfather was among the British forces who liberated Bergen-Belsen. All, he ever said about it was "It must never happen again."
My Grandmother's uncle was also one of those British soldiers who liberated Bergen-Belsen, and what he witnessed literally sent him mute. He didn't speak for years, only finally opening up to his Granddaughter in later life. When asked about his prolonged silence, I was told he said that what he saw literally took his breath away. Horrendous.
Your father was part of the Greatest Generation. Men like him saved us!
So was mine
But it has. and will.
It will always happen again - human beings never learn. It could happen anywhere and at any time. Beneath the skin, we’re little more than ravening beasts.
I remember the miniseries when it aired at the time, and it was an enormous hit. Truly a historic moment for television.
Yeah, I remember watching this series (and winds of war) in the 80s with my mom when it came out. It still stands as an incredible accomplishment.
It was a critical smash and multiple award winner, but its overall ratings weren't great. Esp by this point in the series. The network made a serious mistake by splitting the series in two, separated by a hiatus. Really hurt the momentum.
I have this series on DVD and it is worth it to buy and watch.
@@Choices2aa what film is this
It was far less successful than "The Winds of War".
"Untersturmführer, your honor ... aren't you making a very serious mistake??"
The smugness then denial of that one elder over his ultimate fate, up until the last moment, is both comical and heart-rending.
I don't think movie scenes like this are helpful. They make you laugh with the perpetrators rather than make you feel sympathy with the victims.
It’s definitely “absurd” in the way only real life can be 😢 but I wouldn’t say it’s “ha-ha” funny, I definitely did not feel like laughing.
Who were they? They looked like they were initially treated a tiny bit better
@@stevenrodriguez1394Members of a so called "Judenrat", they were in a very difficult position in the ghettos, having to help the Nazis running the ghettos :organising deportations was also one of their tasks, at the same time they were also Jews, and as such, ultimately to be murdered as well
@@stevenrodriguez1394 Probably members of the Jewish Counsel in their former ghetto.
This is only acting, it must have been absolutely terrifying the real thing.
Elizabeth Stephenson I cant even imagine...
There were thousands of them and only hundred of the guards.
I keep thinking what could have happened if everyone riled up against them. Surely better than acting like passive lambs to the slaughter.
@@ziudra91 well, the guards were armed
@@ziudra91 It is easy in hindsight,
But when you live the moment and are part of it, you always have hope,
maybe they are not going to kill us all,
maybe something will happen and we will be released from this camp and survive...
why would i dare throw my life away with such certainty by jumping armed guards?
it is hard to judge the futility of that when you are there, and part of the process.
@@ziudra91 Check out Escape from Sobibor.
The most intense 10:39 minutes in TV history. RIP to all those who suffered and perished and those who went through this horror. NEVER FORGET.
The sad part is we haven't learned anything. This whole world is not a control now
@@kevinjohnston4512Вы ошибаетесь: весь мир контролируется теми же НЕлюдям, которые организовали, совершили ужасы против ЛИЧНОСТИ ЧеловЕков.. НИКТО в Европе НЕ извлёк урока, что натворили НЕлюди
Seriously? It began repeating immediately & has gone on ever since to Palestinians.
and this happened just 70-80 years ago when mankind already started calling itself civilised is what astounds us
Me too. Man did not learn atall. The Cold war, Mao and the millions who perished in China, The Khmer rouge and horrific massacre of so many in the killing feilds. The various baulcon conflicts ...Syria. So much death and senseless horror
The further back you go in time the more rotten you will find people to be. It's one reason I believe in reincarnation.
The Russian soldiers who liberated the camps had seen worse, and ironically, those who had been prisoners, and who had seen life in the west, were themselves sent to the Gulag, the Soviet camps, which were just as bad. The Nazis and the Soviets were like two great beasts who had fought and while the Soviet won, he was gravely wounded and finally died in 1992.
@@carolhutchinson7763More rotten people back in time?? Are you joking or just clueless?
It should astound you even more that ever since, survivors have been convinced to support doing the same things to Palestinians.
I am a black woman. ...a faithful Christian. But I am obsessed with the Holocaust in a way that I do not even understand. I feel more than horror, sadness, and compassion. It's more like empathy. I feel actual anxiety and pain in my body as I study and learn more and more about what happened. I feel shame and disgust with humanity alongside deep grief. I think about each individual person that experienced horrific brutality and felt alone and forsaken in their sufferings. My heart is broken for them. I am baffled and bewildered by what the planners and perpetrators of the Holocaust allowed themselves to do to others...to just one individual, let alone millions. I cannot conceive of this kind of hatred toward my fellow man. My own people have been and continue to be horribly discriminated against and wronged, yet I would never support such evil against another human being. ...no, not even an enemy.
Sister Linda Taylor...
.Roman COLOSSEUM
..
LIONS 980 Verses CHRISTIANs 0....
1 Peter 📖 Chapter 5 verse 8...
🐺 🌎 🦁
Matthew 📖 Chapter 10 vs 16 thru 18
🌿✨📜🕯️✨🌎✨🕯️📖🌿.
sadly King Of The Jews Jesus Christ CRUCIFIED....
VERY SOON
Revelations Apocalypse 📖 Chapter 21 verses 4 and 5
ASK YOUR 📱 OR 🖥️📡🌎🛰️💻 FOR THESE KING 📖 JAMES GOSPEL SCRIPTURES......
⚖️
ECCLESIASTES 📜 CHAPTER 12 VERSE 14 ......
Sister Linda Taylor....
Please ask your 🎤or 📱 or 💻🛰️🌎📡✨ for FREE 🎶 MUSIC
JIM REEVES SINGING 🎶
This World ✨🌍✨ is Not My Home.....
But Sister this is....
1 CORINTHIANS 📖 CHAPTER 2 VERSE 9....🐑🐑🐑🐑😊🐑🐑🐑🐑
Looking forward to meeting you their....
CARROL ROBERTS SINGING 🎶
ONE PAIR OF HANDS 🙏🏻✨
John 📖 Chapter 1 verse 1 thru 5
Revelations Apocalypse 📖 Chapter 19 verses 11 thru 16....
Isaiah 📜 Chapter 44 verse 24...
Matthew 📖 Chapter 28 verses 18 thru 20
Andre BOCELLIA SINGING 🎶
The Lords prayer 🙏🏻
NANA MOUSKOURI SINGING 🎶
AMAZING GRACE.
PERCY SLEDGE... SINGING 🎶
My special pray 🙏🏻 prayer
ELVIS PRESLEY SINGING 🎶
HELP ME....
PERCY SLEDGE SINGING 🎶
WHEN A MAN LOVES 💕 A WOMAN
MAHALIA JACKSON SINGING 🎶
It is no secret what God can do
I am going to live the life
The upper room
You’ve so eloquently put into words exactly how I feel and have felt for years regarding this atrocity. It truly blows my mind and I don’t think that I’ll ever get over it.
Linda Taylor.....
Acts 📖 Chapter 10 verses 33 thru 35......😊👍
When pence and some of the Republicans from Congress visited the internment camps for the border refugees they couldn't stand the smell in the old converted Walmarts,how come there never was an investigation into this.Private security companies that got rich off this and all they gave the detained was a bottle of water and a package of Ramens a day.Trump and his cronies did this and to you non believers out there this happened in America.It doesn't matter if it was Mexican,Jews , Haitian, Jamaican ,latin American it happened in America.
The fact that there are people in the world who vehemently deny this ever happened ASTOUNDS me. The personal recollections, the PHOTOS, the videos, the artifacts/belongings, the hair and shoes, the victims... 75 million people died in the world war and almost 10 million of that was by extermination. 10 MILLION. That’s the entirety of NYC AND THEN some.
🐷th-cam.com/video/gNV26q89zYg/w-d-xo.html ...
Michele, revisionism is called politicing and politicing is devoid of both truth & morals.
Genocide is happening as we speak, East Timor, the middle east, Central and South America
@Billy The Kid But Joesph Stalin wasn't trying to kill off a whole race like Hitler was. Neither were the Japanese. This made the Nazis unique in the annals of evil.
@Billy The Kid That story of Adolf Hitler being Jewish on his father's side because he was the illegitimate son of a housekeeper who had a sexual relationship with Jewish man named Leo Frankenberger is not true.
How anyone was able to do this to another human is beyond me.
It is called EVIL and it takes flesh, blood and steel to defeat...
rayman 760, there are no easy answers to your comment because there are many facets to the Holocaust. Some were brainwashed into doing it after years of indoctrination by Hitler and the Nazis. Some did it because it was their job but that didn't mean they liked what they did. However, the majority of them did it because it gave them a power trip and of course, they, like Joseph Mengle were virulent anti-Semintists.
Unfortunately it was made simple in the twentieth century
@Mike OZ No it really doesn't
Im proud to be german even though this happend.
And while theres no way to redeem this, we at least try to prevent another uprising while in the US Nazis exist without beeing punished.
@@mariusgustavus6522 That's because as long as they harm nobody they have the right to free association and freedom of speech and press.
The answer to the nazis.is not to surpress people through the state as is done against people in Europe today. Such laws are absurd because those societies claim to be free but then use repression on such a small minority for disagreeing or spreading hate. I'd rather defend the rights of such individuals because they're the easiest ones to move against and once you begin with those people it will move on against other people.
All the babies and little ones. Omg this breaks my heart
For what
@HQ too bad 🤣
@HQ serious we all have to die someday. Don't worry I don't think kids go to hell 😂😂😂
You we would to die that way!!!
@@JasonWilliams-jo7hb youre a total fucktard!😡😡😡
Never again people. We can’t let this happen EVER AGAIN. And we CANT EVER FORGET
I hate to say this but it’s still going on in China
I dont know where you've been, but it's already happening and it's been happening even after the Holocaust. Look at Palestine, Xinjiang, Kashmir, Congo, North Korea.
Definitely still going on tha6s for sure. Palestine has been demolished by the Israeli government.
Survivors immediately began the genocide of Palestinians, going on to this day, much longer than the Nazis were in power.
Tears are rolling down from my eyes after watching this.... God bless these souls...
Ir is impossible to describe the beauty and sadness of this series. I have watched it countless times and every time I See it I am deeply moved again. right now watching this scene I am crying.
Excuse me, can you tell me the tittle of this movie? Thanks 🤗
@@cascas7451 war n remembrance
I don't see anything beautiful, you monster!
This looks terrifying just by watching it on film. Now imagine it 1000x worse. Many of us get worried just when our mom or dad doesn’t come home in time. Nothing can be compared to this hell. May they all rest in peace.
The original Holocaust movie is a 1948 Polish feature film called "The Last Stage" by Wanda Jakubowska who was a political prisoner at Auschwitz. The copywriter and set designer were also interred there. It looks realistic because it was filmed on location at Auschwitz only 2 years after liberation using actual prison clothes and SS uniforms. Several of the actors and actresses were former inmates, especiallythe ones playing Kapos and Block Elders. Soviet soldiers and German POWs are also used as extras. It won a BAFTA in 1950.
Free on TH-cam.
My 6th grade music teacher in the early 60s husband was a Auschwitz survivor. He came to school and she introduced him to us and showed us his tattoo the Nazis gave him on his arm. Then I watched the Adolph Eichmann Trial on TV that showed the horrors of the Death Camps. It was exactly as he described.
And yet there are some who say this didn't happen.
Remeber one thing, there was German nazi death camps, not only nazi!
Hyyy,
Ohh really !
There are also those that think the earth is flat. Everyone is entitled to there opinion does not mean we need to give them any credence
And yet how much do most know of the Kempeitai and Unit 731.......
The scene where the dead baby was thrown off the train 😭😭😭 i still can't comprehend the fact all this happened. Truly.. humanity's darkest hour
Ploy Haruansong they threw live babies also
not humanity's darkest hour... just those 'humans' who were actively or passively guilty.
Awful just tossed on the ground like a piece of trash
That is tame compaired to what this German unit did to 500 children .
medium.com/war-is-boring/the-vile-story-of-the-nazis-dirlewanger-brigade-8a7da5ded0c7
Watch some interviews on the massacre at Babi Yar in Kiev. The early days were all with bullets, large pits, not gas chambers. There was actually a scene in War and Remembrance showing how they did it. A survivor said that he saw a baby in the dead body pit still suckling on their dead mothers breast a day later. He also said that a baby was taken from their mothers arms and bayoneted. Really despicable stuff.
As bad as this is, it was a million times worse in life.
i wish i could of been a prisoner there pointed to the right for the selection process
Gee, you really mean being put to death for no good reason is worse than being paid to act in a movie? That is so profound.
@@devondavies4372 why
it's in humanity
@Devon Davies you need help saying something like that
The segment after this where they are escorted down the stairs into the undressing room at the actual gas chamber, then pushed into the large room to be gassed is breathtaking. To think normal ss guards did this day after day, as if just a normal job. Madness.
I guess it would be breathtaking
most of those SS men involved in the operations of the gas chamber would have been highly ideologically driven sociopaths, probably didn't bother them i imagine
Some SS Guards were true Psychopaths others simply viewed it as a job . Regardless they did not see them as human beings but Vermin to be exterminated . This was in part thanks to the many propaganda pamphlets around and even trusted medical research at the time that stated jews and other ethnic European races were sub human and backward and filled with illness and Ill equipped DNA and were holding back humanity's progression and evolution. When your head is chucked full of that you do not see them as humans as I stated before and thus feel no pitty they have been Dehumanized and 'Otherd" which is how it was so easy for many to be able to do these awful things
Whoever the selection officer is in the final minutes of this excerpt it's incredible. No words between the two individuals no external monologue nothing. Justice amazing character acting on both the lady and the selection officer. Incredible
@Wez Okeeffe his name wasn't said by the narrator.
@Wez Okeeffe but the narrator didn't say the name of the Selection officer so how do you know it was Mengele? Besides, I'm sure there were other S.S. selection officers at Auschwitz besides him. The actor playing the selection officer was Stellio Candellio who played a scar faced Gestapo officer in the WINDS OF WAR, forerunner to W&R.
@Wez Okeeffe You mean monster. A Nazi movie or documentary is gonna say that the actor from WAR AND REMEMBRANCE playing the selection officer was Mengele?
@Wez Okeeffe ok.
@Wez Okeeffe I know that! What I'm asking is how do you know that that S.S. selection officer was Mengele when the narrator didn't say who he was. It probably wasn't Mengele since he was so infamous; the narrator would most definitely have said he was Mengele.
"Winds Of War" and "War And Remembrance" are both on here in their entirety last time I checked, and very good to binge watch. The books are good too.
can someone tell me, should Winds of War and War and Remembrance be watched together? Are they related?
I know its war related, but is it tied in?
@@Irishjay_94 just read your question, so it may have already been answered. Start with “Winds of War” as it begins as Hitler lays out his plans to invade Poland, and runs through the attack on Pearl Harbor. “War and Remembrance,” with the same characters, even though some of the actors were recast, picks up immediately after that and runs through the end of the war. It’s all one long piece, divided into two series. But Winds of War and then War and Remembrance is the correct order.
My Grandfather recorded this series with his VCR back in the '80s. He was a WW2 veteran who served in the Pacific. I remember him telling us that we should watch the series as a family. We did and it was pretty much my first real exposure to the Holocaust and the true horrors of WW2.
After the abolition of slavery in the United States in 1865, the so-called Jim Crow Laws established the separation between African Americans and whites and lasted until the 1960s.
until 1950 there were lynchings of black citizens in the United States of America. There is a picture on the internet of a black one hanging from a tree in America.
The situation was so grotesque that white German POWs in the US were held above black citizens.
To maintain racial segregation during World War II, there were separate formations (including the 93rd Infantry Division) and units such as the 761st Tank Battalion, 758th Tank Battalion, 784th Tank Battalion, and the Tuskegee Airmen that served almost exclusively African Americans.
I think there is a hypocrisy there
You probably weren't old enough to watch mini series Holocaust in seventies
@@irish89055 We only had three channels in the '70s. Four if the weather was perfect. I was more into the Dukes of Hazzard then.
Почему не боролись с нацистами могли взять оружие зачем подавались ведь мужчины были же не надо было боятся их
What is mowie name?
My dad was 8. He was on a train near Treblinka and the sky was black with smoke from the crematoriums per what he remembers. The front wagon had totenkopf SS as he saw those shiny black uniforms of the people who had always the front of the train for themselves and the rest was for Poles and untermenszen. Then the train went into those cloud and he says he will never forget the smell of burned flesh that filled the car. This is the reality of mass murder one cannot depict in anything possible and only approximated. Even if it was from afar from his young eyes.
My father was in the Polish army in 1939, his fellow soldier and friend Anton Golba later joined the Polish underground and was caught and sent to Auschwitz and tortured. He survived the death March in 1945. I grew up with his two sons in New York. One of the stories he told of the Germans was that the gas chambers were getting so overloaded with prisoners every day ( trains came in every half hour) that the Germans had the prisoners dig giant pits to burn the bodies. Anton mentioned that one Christmas the German guards got trucks full of babies and children and were throwing children and babies LIVE by the children’s legs and hair into one of these burning pits while the Germans were singing a German. Christmas song Oh Tannenaum! I have been to Auschwitz and you can still see these pits in the back of the camp ( covered with grass) My mothers family from Vienna had 24 members killed the youngest being 3. My father and his friend Anton hated the Germans for the rest of their lives,I can’t blame them. My father said the only reason Germans say they’re sorry now is because they’re sorry the lost the war. To hell with them! .
Heartbreaking. And I cannot blame the jews and the East Europeans for feeling like they do towards the Germans after what they did. I feel so much anger and hope there is a burning hell for the ones responsible. But the feeling of sadness is even greater. Millions of people dead. But I don't wanna talk about numbers. Each family destroyed is a gigantic tragedy in itself. And nothing good came out of it.
Horror movies no longer feels scary once one have read lots about the holocaust and seen a few movies. The holocaust is more scary than horror movies. And reality was for more horrible than the movies see about the holocaust.
Hell is too fine a place for Nazis!
@@nattygsbord Did you knew that Hitler got the idea from the turks? Or at that time the ottoman empire? In 1915 they built concentration & death camps for the armenian population and they were deported there in trains. They invented the "armenien question" to annihilate them ... sounds familiar, right? In the second world war there where the massacre of the serbs by the croats ... they killed them with knifes in the most cruel ways. Even the Nazis needed to put an end to that because everybody got mad about it. Then there are the japanese who massacred the chinese at that time ... don't act like we germans are cursed or something and more capable of cruel things.
@@noodles6390 Look, this is a very emotional issue. But what can one say about a country that decided twice to take the entire world to a war, in which tens of millions died, by that hands of the most educated people?
This was not the middle ages, but rather a country that was at the peak of civilization.
I'm Jewish. I don't blame any Germans living today. I work with them and have good friends in Germany. However, what their past relatives did cannot be forgiven or forgotten.
As a German you will need to go on with this burden forever. History absolutely needs to be taught in Germany as raw as possible. There's no whitewashing possible here.
It's a pity this dialogue can only happen here and not in the real world.
@@edielynch7819
Hell was probably created by the Nazis...
I was a child when this aired. At the time I did not know that I was watching what it was likely very much like for my great aunts and uncles who were taken to this very camp. Like many, they did not make it out. May they all rest in Peace.
Oh my dear I'm so so sorry. May they all rest in peace.
What would modern kids think of this
Many were lied to. They were told the train would take them to a resettlement camp where they could start new lives and shown propaganda videos of some kind of Urlablager or summer camp. They were never told they were being taken to a death camp.
ELPaso1990TX we must WARN PEOPLE ABOUT IT HAS STARTED AGAIN
Not many, ALL, people with nothing to lose will run and fight
Constantine Joseph I even read somewhere in the archive that many German ss put numbered tattoos on and are claiming to be survivors, which made me sick.
Nah, Ausschwitz was known for killing compared to the other ones.
Grandpa told me about that
ELPaso1990TX yep so true
I visited a Holocaust museum in Dallas this week, and part of the tour is walking through a replica of one of these box cars. Walking through it in the middle of a warm, safe building as an observer in 2021 gave me anxiety. I just can’t even imagine how frightened these poor people must have been to actually experience this. Just mind boggling this happened in recent history.
It’s got to be horrible and we are so glad the Americans were tougher and if not we would have all been Slaves today.
Hat Amerika denn auch ein Museum für die Indianer die abgeschlachtet wurden?
@@Evita1418_ why do you ask?
@@Evita1418_ Indians also slaughtered each other as well as settlers. What an odd question to ask
@@ronniebishop2496 well half your country is ex slaves you gimp
One of the saddest most heartbreaking scenes I’ve ever seen
Very good filming. And I think that finding a music piece that suits this kind of an event is hard, but here have they found one that fits great. Both the bottomless sorrow and tremendous horror tied to this place.
I totally agree
On the remote and unthinkable possibility that any sort of 'good' arose from the process depicted, the "selection officer" seems minimally qualified and certainly arbitrary in performance of his "duty".
@@schoolssection - The selection officers didn’t care. It was just an assembly line process to them. Folks to the left folks to the right. They did it as quick as they could
Pathetic...
It was actually much more brutal from what I have read and seen. It was toned down for tv.
I think you are right, they would have wanted this done quickly so they would use brutality to speed up the process.
That was toned down?
el mundo vive vdiariamente OLOKAUSTOS en este momento te puedo nombrar SIRIA Y NADIE LO FRENA el mundo se comporto asi se comporta y se comportara por siempre el ser humano es ASI
@@jmstowe yes and no. It’s much easier to send a mother and her baby to the gas than to separate her from her child which is shown happening in many movies. What’s the loss of one worker? It’s better to not create a panic during the Selection.
el ser HUMANO es recentido vengativo y ASCESINO
My music teacher's wife survived one of the death camps. She still had the serial number tattooed on her arm.
+laboral : Cualquiera que deseaba cobrar una reparación por el holocausto desde 1953 puede tatuarse un número, esto lo denunciaron judíos como Goldberg, Domerge, Chomsky, Gimsburg, Finkelstein, etc. etc. etc. ... ¿Averiguaste si ese número se correspondía anatómica y numéricamente cómo REALMENTE lo hacían los "malvados nazis" ? ... ¿Te tomaste la molestia de cotejarlo con las series DOCUMENTADAS y rastrear si era genuíno y a quién correspondía? ... apuesto que NO ¿Verdad? porque dudar es ofensivo a los muertos o porque te dijeron que era como volverlos a victimizar ...
UNAS PREGUNTAS DE PURA LÓGICA: (poniéndote en el plano del supuesto asesino) si vas exterminar a una víctima y no deseas queden pruebas ni siquiera que la tuviste en tus manos ¿Por qué tomarte el tiempo, logística y gasto en marcarlo como ganado? ...Si ella te dijo que era un campo ¡¡¡de EXTERMINIO!!!...¿Cómo es que sobrevivió? ...¿Te contó que milagroso suceso la libró de ser "exterminada"? ... ¡¡¡si todavía te queda un poco de juicio crítico HONESTO pronto te darás cuenta como del engaño has pasado al AUTOENGAÑO!!!
I “met” a survivor of Auschwitz in the summer of 1994, he was a friend of the female acquaintance with whom i was sharing a noon meal.
His number was tattooed on his outer left forearm.
I think he was surprised that “20something” me knew what the tattoo meant, but he said nothing.
I can not even imagine living through something like this. How aptly fits the phrase Mans inhumanity to man
Who needs to imagine? Just take a look at what has been happening to Palestinians ever since.
The section of War and Remembrance about the transport and selection/gassing at Auschwitz was extremely powerful. Everyone should watch it. Particularly now that there are massive crowds marching through the streets of many western capitols chanting from the 'river to the sea' meaning the end of the Jewish state. People are simply ignorant of history. By the way the two books by Herman Wouk, Winds of War and War and Remembrance from which the series are taken are absolutely some of the best works of fiction about WW2. If you haven't read them, do yourself a favor and do so. They are compelling in every way.
The fact that they're just randomly deciding who lives and who dies is sickening.
The cruelty of these so-called human beings astounds me.
@ImNotMad ButUR and it's happening now..
@ImNotMad ButUR It is not that suprising.
Just look up germany in the late 20s and you'll understand the simpleness of brainwashing the people.
We mustn't believe that that level of cruelty is only in the past. It didn't take long for the German people to fall under the spell of justified murder and it could and will happen again. And sadly it has.
@Billy The Kid It starts with small encroachment on our guaranteed freedoms and gradually they disappear. Then the rewards for turning in your neighbors...the creation of "strike teams" to enforce regulations and rules of an administration gone power crazy. Keep your head buried in the sand and the world will deteriorate chaos, which is exactly what many want. That is what has happened in California!
@Billy The Kid Try studying the build up to world war 2 in Germany, since you don't seem to understand the correlation between those events and current ones.
Humans are so harsh to other humans. WHY can we not live in peace and harmony? WHY NOT SUPPORT EACH OTHER?? Call me a 'fool', but my heart goes out to all persons persecuted for just being. God bless you who is reading this. Indeed.
Jusus give to us the right way but lot of us prefer follow evil way. Auschwitz is the most horrible product of this choise
We never have and we never will…
God bless you. Be at peace now. MrJR
May God Bless you Mr.Blake. I have prayed that all of my Jewish friends will open their eyes and stop voting for the American Nazis who are destroying this country now. Please wake up
.
War is a Big Big business for the rich. Soldiers are paid workers. Innocent and weak people are there goods to make their business become a success.
This world is full of hypocrisy, jealousy, foolishness, arrogance, pride, ego, envy, liars, greed, selfish, show off, innovate, competition
This happened. You can still feel the anguish when are there.
i remember watching this miniseries when it was first run on ABC in the late 1980s. And this scene is probably the most heartbreaking thing I've ever seen on any media. :-(
I saw that in my Freshman year of high school.... It really made me think!
What is the name of the mini series, would like to see it.
1988
@@maritzalara6222 "War and Remembrance"
War and Remembrance. It was part 2 of a two-part series. The first part, Winds of War dealt with earlier aspects of WWII; War and Remembrance the latter portion. Both were based on books by a man named Herman Wouk. Amazing series - both of them.
This scene above (and I've studied the Holocaust more than a little bit) is unnerving and ice-cokd chilling...and very realistic from all evidence (witness statements, both survivors and guards and a former commandant, Rudolph Hoess - executed in Poland after he wrote an incredible biography!)
We seem to have learned very little from history! Ethnic cleansing still goes on in some conflicts!
That isn't even approaching an analogy....your language comment is hyperbolic nonsense. And last I checked native populations of the southwest corner of North America were forced to speak Spanish and become Catholic by Europeans.
Whataboutism is really a big epidemic in and about germany.
Alan Witton That’s an understatement 😕
good
Where did you get that info? I don't believe it. Out of the Thousands and thousands of people that have ever crossed paths with me...... maybe 4 or 5 made that claim.
One of the saddest times in history, I’m more obsessed with this thing than anything in Historic times…
Why! It gives a sense of depression, help, and hopelessness…..it’s just like written in a story book 📖
I can remember watching this movie as a child. It still terrorizes me as an adult. Man’s inhumanity to man seems to know no limits.
It was a tv series, Not a movie!
This is a great mini series. The acting, writing and filming are superb.
Name of TV Series!?
War and Remembrance. It can be found here on TH-cam. @@micheleonofri293
War And Remembrance @@micheleonofri293
This is War and Remembrance, the sequel to Winds of War - both were 1980's television miniseries.
IIRC WaR was never broadcast or if it was I missed it despite watching for it. I'd already read the books, then found the VHS tapes in the library.
Thank u
yup.
To think that some people deny this ever happened, bagatalize it or even applaud it makes me sick....
You are not alone.
video struggente, bellissimo....non ho parole. Il migliore film televisivo che sia mai stato girato
Humanity's darkest hour.
Certainly one of them. All of which seemed to take place in the twentieth century
@@kevinbrown4073 that's because of the rising nationalism at the end of the 19th century. Lead to ww1, ww2 and many other wars fought because of the feeling of superiority.
brian sedlock The founding of Islam was humanities darkest hour. Haunts us to this day.
The perpetrators did not get their just deserts. I cannot understand how humans can be so evil.
@@cyberhermit1222 Hey and the earth is flat.
My brain cannot understand how can someone be so cruel and evil. Watching holocaust documentaries scares and saddenes me. I cannot imagine what they must have felt 😢 separated from their family
Man's inhumanity towards Man has been going on centuries. Only the technology has changed.
I'm breaking my heart watching this and I know it's actors. Nobody unless they were there will truly no how horrific this was.
Not all were actors. Many of the extras in this scene were survivors of the Holocaust and of the camp itself. They saw it their duty to come back for this scene. To show the world. Can you imagine the courage. This how they arrived originally into camp in 1940s. Only to come back 30 years later the same way. This time of course for a movie.. But still can you imagine what was going on within them.
The Blind leads the blind and both Fell into Lake of Fire. Have been 5000 years ago. Ask : what the Country can Do For You ! Not What You can Do for the Country!!!.. Then this Holocaust can be averted.
The original Holocaust movie is a 1948 Polish feature film called "The Last Stage" by Wanda Jakubowska who was a political prisoner at Auschwitz. The co-writer and set designer were also interred there. It looks realistic because it was filmed on location at Auschwitz only 2 years after liberation using actual prison clothes and SS uniforms. Several of the actors and actresses were former inmates, especially the ones playing Kapos and Block Elders. Soviet soldiers and German POWs are also used as extras. It won a BAFTA in 1950.
Free on TH-cam.
I am german and i cant believe that my countrymen have commited all of these crimes against humanity
Your current government is destroying the country from within. I suggest you watch “Er it’s wierder da”. It’s like a Borat but Hitler waking up in 2015 and interviews people unscripted. Many still support this. All it takes is the government to contribute to erode the Deutchland morale before they get fed up and do this type of thing again.
your countrymen have been lobotomized since low and middle school
The selection officer will spend eternity in hell at his post making selections. He will constantly agonize; trying to forget the faces that will haunt him forever.
Unless he repents. He might be OK.
History will hunt Germany forever for these atrocity made to mankind.
he probably died in his sleep ...
@@gradimirdordevic3235 Well we teach it in schools ...
@@georgegordonmeade5294
He will have to be truly sorry because you can’t just ask God for forgiveness and be done with it you need to actually mean it
Dear God i can never watch this again i am a mother of 3 and the realism this brings is too much.
Jesus is sorry and weak
The devil had been at work for far too long
What's really scary is the fact that even after the horrors of the concentration camps were known to the world and humanity cried out, "NEVER AGAIN!", it still just stood by with its collective thumb up its own ass and did absolutely nothing to stop the genocides in Uganda, Rwanda, and Cambodia.
Sudan as well
XJ 900's
And Yugoslavia😔
Its a shame. And it is pathetic. Especially how China and USA sided with Pol Pot when Vietnam were trying to liberate the country after they had been forced into a defensive war by Pol Pots attacks and genocide on the vietnamese population.
und Nordkorea, da wird von den Amis nicht gegen angegangen. Diese Heuchler!
@@Evita1418_ - Warum kämpft ihr Deutschen nicht gegen die Nordkoreaner?
Please never ever let this happen to anyone.
Sadly it happened to people in several instances of history. How humans can be like this and just murder others without any feelings of remorse scares the s**t out of me.
@Ben Lui Wow, you just had to bring Israel. You probably missed the news. They are killing thousands of innocent Palestinians every year. Someone needs to step in and break this bad habit of Israel.
One today can only imagine. Those people were tired, sick, cold and hungry. Pulled out of a livestock railroad car, and immediately subjected to more indignities and rough treatment. Physically pulled away from family members, without a goodbye. Some going straight to the gas while others were "spared", only to live in filth and be worked to death. This was truly Hell on this Earth.
It was dr. mengele who decided at selection and hummed or sang classic music while pointing his finger left or right!! Craziness and beyond belief
Brawo za znajomość historii👏
My favorite war classics. Mr. Robert Colbert and his classical musical masterpiece of symphonic compositions of background soundtrack music will tell you so.
Jane Seymour's performance in this miniseries was overlooked and underappreciated!
Yes so so overlooked
Both Natalies turned in a brilliant performance along with Sir John Gielgud. Also underrated were the performances of the Nazi camp officers, particularly Roehm
She lost massive amount of weight to be as realistic as possible.
Almost 80 years later…..still find it hard to fathom that many people could be implicit in this kind of behavior. Hitler yes, generals yes but ordinary citizens, clergy, medical staff, administration etc….
My mind does not want to understand how a human could do this to another human being.
Neither my heart.
Какой ужас они пережили... Те, кто пережил... Невозможно даже себе представить... 😭😭😭
Don't know if I should feel pity for that one Jew for thinking he and his friends would be spared or contempt for his casual indifference for what was happening to the other Jews.
Why would he think he'd he spared? For being optimistic? I dont get it...
I think he said to the guard being prominent. So they perhaps thought to BE treated diffently.
@@neveragain2421 Early in that episode while on board the train, he thought the group of men would be spared because of their status as prominents.
I think in the world we live in with media and social media it’s so easy to say what we would have done if we would have been in their shoes but back then the concept of what was to be their fate was inconceivable and must be something that should never be aloud to repeat. 🇮🇱💙 🕯
I consider myself a Christian and a man who loves the Lord...I must ask the Lord in the most humble way I can to help me with the distasteful and hate and hurt I feel about anyone who were involved or still have this sort of this meaningless atrocities to a race of people due to an ideal of a person who could not succeed in anything else in his life ..Please God ...forgive me ✝️🙏😢
my heart just aches and feels like its being shattered when i think about these poor people. another video a little boy holding his teddy bear being led to the gas chambers. cant stop crying, to think about the sheer terror these children and adults were in makes me sick.
I remember watching a little girl crying for her mommy and Aaron consoles her. Poor girl, she didn't know what was in store for her and her family.
ive found scenes like this have more of an impact if they leave out the incidental music!!
s gordy s They actually played music like that when the train arrived at Aushwitz so that the people in the cars would be clam and think that they were at a nice place.
@@remember4ever409 I believe he's talking about the background music not the music played by the inmates. It would have been all the more horrifying if there was no added background music.
I couldn't watch scenes like this. It was too traumatic. This Scene, Schindler's List and Escape From Sobibor were the heaviest Movies about The Concentration Camps. My Father (RIP) saw Schindler's List when it was on PBS TV and his jaw dropped.
The original Holocaust movie is a 1948 Polish feature film called "The Last Stage" by Wanda Jakubowska who was a political prisoner at Auschwitz. The co-writer and set designer were also interred there. It looks realistic because it was filmed on location at Auschwitz only 2 years after liberation using actual prison clothes and SS uniforms. Several of the actors and actresses were former inmates, especially the ones playing Kapos and Block Elders. Soviet soldiers and German POWs are also used as extras. It won a BAFTA in 1950.
Free on TH-cam.
How you could get so many heartless ppl that this could happen is mind numbing
The organisation was phenomenal, all these people had to be kept calm, even if they suspected the worst. Arriving at a camp and needing a shower after travelling from say Crete or Marseille sounded reasonable, how it was then carried out, music being played even. Do visit if you can, out of respect for these poor families.
There's a great example of the music that was played in a movie called The Grey Zone from 2001. Watch it, it'll shake you to your core.
@@tommyt1971 The bastards used musician inmates for a string quartet. A few survivors are still alive. What could they DO?!?
@@drpoundsign nothing else.
As dark as this scene is, it is important. This can NOT happen again. Everyone needs to see this when they are old enough and understand how horrific humanity can be.
The denial of this horrible chapter of our country should be punishable worldwide. Just like that, these horrible symbols show. It is hypocritical of all the countries that have not banned it.
It happened again in Cambodia during the 1970s.
@@67nairb And then it was intellectual politcos educated in Europe who were mass-murdering anyone who could _read ..._
@@RideAcrossTheRiver King Nordom Sihanouk of Cambodia compared Pol Pot to Hitler. Have yo seen the the KILLING FIELDS?
@@67nairb Pol Pot went to university in France. He used his education to mass-murder other educated people.
That whole scenario is pretty hard for me to wrap my mind around
Same , it breaks my heart
Повезло тем умершим по дороге не доехавших до этих смертных лагерей ада
The Holocaust scenes were chilling and Upsetting to the core ,To think this was acting doesn't bare thinking about what happened to those real victims of the Holocaust to Little Children,The Elderly,The Disabled ,Those who were too ill to Innocent Men ,Woman and Children who were murdered in this unholy place ,We remember those murdered by Fanatics to those who collaborated with the third Reich ,Never forget what happened in Auschwitz,Belzec ,Chelmo,Sobibor ,Treblinka,Majdenek and Terezinstadt.Just awful t of watch and Heartbreaking 🥺
👏
This one emotionally broke my heart too. So sad :(
My Großvater und Großmuter survived Aushwitz, and the things they told me were absolutely horrible, I still have a hard time believing the country I was born and raised in is responsible for the atrocity.
Your country stopped the murderous Soviet Union from invading Europe. In 1933 "Judea Declares War on Germany".
Don't believe the Greuelpropaganda spewed today to keep the reparations blackmail money flow going.
My foster grandfather survived five concentration camps and he learned to never hate the nazists because of what they did. He said. The love I got when I was a child couldn't even the nazists take from me. He was a good man
Can you imagine having to go through this
It is almost unbelievable that this type of sadistic brutality among other human beings is truly a part of 20th century history. Astonishing. I cannot help but feel bold contempt at those who willingly participated in such atrocity! Those who knew and did nothing to help these people are dispicable as well!
And one of those people was the Pope.
My direct line great-grandfather was a train driver during Ww II
He should drive one of these "special trains" one day. He refused and was immediately relieved and sent home... there was a group of thugs waiting for him. He was beaten half to death... only the name he had made with the upper management of the Reichsbahn saved his life... he was not allowed to drive on the route for a relatively long time. only shunting service in the depot
This is gut wrenching. I am a proud Muslim, NO joy.
Oh, I was hoping that you would post the second half of this scene too. I sent this to a young cousin in Italy to watch, and I was hoping that she would be able to view the conclusion. If you change your mind in regards to posting the following scene, could you please let me know. Thank you.
the entire series War and Remembrance is on youtube and free. You'll find the entire scene, including the gassing and death of Aaron Jastro, in Episode 11. It is really well done and so horrific. The director Curtis made it as real as possible.
When I first saw this movie didn't know any Americans were killed in Auschwitz-Birkenau but there was at least one well known soccer player Eddy Hamel he was born in NYC 1902 and had been playing in Netherlands for a club there when war broke out. They tried to get papers to exchange him for Germans took too long he was deported to Auschwitz.
I imagine this as horrific as it is is totally censored from the actual Hell that these devils made.
Those that did this are burning for eternity.
ImAgine being a man seeing your wife or daughter or mother treated like this. I would probably have to die on the spot
I was thinking. HOW did the train engineer feel handing
over a train load of souls. Ready to return with more.
It depends on when they started doing it. Early 1940-41 they were die hard Nazis.
Those who got orders to work in the camps in 1944-45 were most likely relieved they did not have to go to the Eastern Front.
I've often wondered about that as well. Some time ago I heard that early during the Dutch occupation the Dutch train drivers tried to protest and the Germans dealt with it brutally. Either beat them up, or increased the persecution of the Jews. I can't recall. Whatever it was, the Dutch train drivers had to keep doing the deportations. The German's were utterly ruthless in punishing any resistance to the holocaust by non-Jews in the occupied countries. One has to feel for them as well, as they watched helplessly.
@@stephenhosking7384 The choice was simple. Do it or die. I would have run away from that job, period. Vanished. I am a proud Muslim.
If he refused to drive the train someone else would and he would have been taken and put in a camp suffering the same fate along with his family. In Nazi Germany if you wanted to live or more importantly did not want your family to suffer the consequences of your refusal, you did what you were told. Parents lived in fear for and of their own children who were indoctrinated in National Socialism who encouraged them to 'inform' on their parents. Such was the strangle hold this regime had over its people that failure to comply was equivalent to death sentence. Yet despite this there was a resistance movement in Germany operating throughout the war.
These ppl must have questioned God's existence. I would have.
@mywaymn lol keep telling yourself that
@@Billygoatsgrruff keep telling yourself he does and Santa Claus as well
@@eduardojones6411 please don’t compare God to Santa clause
@@pippaschroeder9660 please don’t try and make me believe in something so incredibly unbelievable like the existence of a God that’s an insult to my intelligence if you want to believe in a magical being that’s your silly business
@@eduardojones6411 I’m not making you believe in God
What gets me with the older gentleman’s character is the way he practically ask for it.
I am absolutely sick to my stomach!!! Lord may this NEVER HAPPEN AGAIN!!!!!!
Where can u find this film? I watched part two of the auschwitz scene in the has chambers and couldn't even look at the computer screen. It was terribly real. Instead of reading about it u see it and that is really hard to stomach
Beyond imagination the horror, fear and pain experienced by these people
They used actual holocaust survivors who volunteered as extras in some parts of the series
Cette série est bouleversante l'interprétation de Jane Seymour est exceptionnelle ✨ . J'ai le coeur brisé de savoir que toutes ces horreurs ont réellement exister de pauvres gens tués par la folie d'un monstre des femmes , des hommes des enfants 💔 réduits en cendre. Nous ne devons jamais oubliée sinom nous serons condamnés à reproduire le passé !!
Adults knew what was going on...but the children.....oh God bless them
Nah, plenty of people had no idea what was going on, and the SS would lie to them to give a false sense of security and hope.
The Nazis tried to keep this from the German people but there were rumors everywhere. One German woman tried to tell everyone what was happening because a relative knew about it and her husband called her an idiot and told her you cannot fight a dictatorship this way. He said you have to be able to cut off it's head, not bite it's tail. The Allies pretty much did that.
@@carolhutchinson7763 Yes, and it had been stated several times in different history shows and books that the nearby town at times could get smells from the crematory when the wind was right.
This is so hard to watch. Everyone should make a point of it.
Bad Alice true that I wasn’t looking for most of it I find this horrifying disgraceful and absolutely terrible
Thank Roosevelt.
That demorat refused to bomb the tracks leading to ACHEWITZ.
@@stuartlee6622 you dumb fuck one you can't spell two your fucking stupid
@@stuartlee6622 racist piece of shit
@@joannsalmen4842 Are you German ?