Column design - Are you Interpreting the minimum reinforcement in column in the right way?

[@ashlardesignandinfra1774]

Sir truly amazing

[@CIVILERABangalore]

hey thanks for your kind words 🙂

[@indramlimbu6886]

Explained very well. Thank you for sharing the knowledge

[@CIVILERABangalore]

Thanks for the comment and great to know you liked it

[@indramlimbu6886]

@@CIVILERABangalore welcome sir. Keep uploading such videos, sir.

[@struct-architecture2779]

How we will come to know about the "concrete area required to resist direct stress" in etabs, if the column is oversized?

[@CIVILERABangalore]

ETABS will not show this. You need to check all your columns that shows up as 0.8%

[@RohitChoudharyoffical]

Great video 🙏🏻

[@CIVILERABangalore]

Nice to see you liked it 🙂

[@subanjitsaha9915]

Very informative.

[@CIVILERABangalore]

Glad you liked it

[@shareqinamdar8903]

Informative

[@CIVILERABangalore]

Thanks for the comment

[@mohammedraihanan5858]

Sir could you please make an vedeos on side face reinforcement for beams

[@CIVILERABangalore]

Let me try 🙂What do you do now?

[@mohammedraihan4580]

​@@CIVILERABangaloresir now I am working as design engineer.

[@CIVILERABangalore]

ok which one and location

[@mohammedraihan4580]

@@CIVILERABangalore Bangalore Sir

[@ramonbaccomperi7871]

Hello, such an informative video. I want to know how you will determine if etabs use the gross area or the tributary area for the steel reinforcements calculation. Thank you

[@CIVILERABangalore]

Thanks a lot for your comments.
Am a little concerned about your question as I feel that your understanding is slightly different. The tributary area comes in to picture when you calculate the load. Am not 100% sure what you meant though.
The comparison wrt rebar area is gross area vs required area to take the actual axial stress.

[@ramonbaccomperi7871]

So tributary area is the area where the load is acting if I'm right so it's different from the actual area or?

[@CIVILERABangalore]

Am not sure of your question
@@ramonbaccomperi7871

[@ramonbaccomperi7871]

Please I will like to know the meaning of tributary area.

[@CIVILERABangalore]

@@ramonbaccomperi7871 See this video th-cam.com/video/LFpST17F5Bk/w-d-xo.htmlsi=nt64sgUYbO2Z84h2
I have mentioned about an area in this

[@subhajit2210]

thank you sir ❤ pls make video on yield line theory in rcc slab design

[@CIVILERABangalore]

Thanks. there are some videos on slabs already. Plz chk

[@Er.RamanjaneyuluNingampalli]

Great video

[@CIVILERABangalore]

thanks for your comment

[@nramanjaneyulu2842]

sir
if we provide more than max. Reinforcement, is there any problem? in beams, we have over/under reinforced, but in columns, no such things?na?

[@CIVILERABangalore]

It should not be creating congestion

[@shaileshgupta9624]

Great information regarding IS456 .
But if column is part of LLRS means ,column to be designed for ductility for seismic loading as per is13920 , in that case also can we reduce pt

[@CIVILERABangalore]

See, this point is when you get a min steel as an end result.
For ductility, there are many criteria including the strong column and weak beam!
If you have rightly sized, the chances of getting such a condition of min steel is rare in large projects.
But the world is not just with large projects, we do also have smaller projects. There are quite a lot of engineers who in the search of knowledge miss to remember the fact that there is a huge amount of clients looking to solve simple issues economically. I have a large number of audience on YT who are looking to freelance on their own and they do smaller projects. The motto is to enable engineers to do economically but at the same time with no compromises.

[@ramonbaccomperi7871]

Thank you.