Tool - Schism REACTION & REVIEW! FIRST TIME HEARING!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ส.ค. 2024
- Tool Fans.....FEELIN' YOU!!! Tonight we're coming back to Tool, with a song entitled "Schism". How's this one gonna go? Only one way to find out...
Come on in, enjoy the show...I'll see you inside.
Scoring System Guide
10 = Perfection (Unobtainable)
9.0 - 9.9 = Awesome, Amazing
8.0 - 8.9 = Great
7.0 - 7.9 = Really Good
6.0 - 6.9 = Pretty Good
5.0 - 5.9 = O.k.
4.0 - 4.9 = Not So Good
3.0 - 3.9 = Pretty Bad
2.0 - 2.9 = Really Bad
1.0 - 1.9 = Horrible, Awful
0.0 - 0.9 = A Travesty, An Affront To Nature
Link to Original Video Here:
• TOOL - Schism (Officia...
My Patreon Page, where you can MAKE REQUESTS (As a Bronze Tier Member or higher) as well as view ALL the videos I try to post that TH-cam is forced to block, can be found here: www.patreon.co...
(Please note, you must be at least a Bronze Tier Member to be able to make fresh requests. All requests must be made on the Patreon page.)
My Twitter: / bassist4aw
My Instagram (I've just started learning how to use it): / davidheretic666
Our P.O. Box (yeah, we listened to you all and we got one):
P.O.Box #355
19360 Rinaldi St
Porter Ranch, CA. 91326
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. I have no intent on claiming this music for my own, I'm simply reacting to the video and giving my constructive criticism and feedback. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W3D1 | Fall | สัปดาห์ตัดสิน ทีมไปไฟนอล](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZBU3GyzqErI/mqdefault.jpg)
Seeing the way your face lit up when you asked "Is that bass?!?" was awesome. I love seeing someone enjoy music that much. Keep being you.
Yup. Love that too. That's how you listen to this band. Love that enthusiasm.
gotta say, never seen someone be won over by the first 8 notes of a song. But this is tool
Subbed because of that
100th like
To be fair it’s one of the best intros to a song of all time
Do NOT apologize for breaking a song down in your own way. #1 It is your channel #2 It's the reason I am subscribed lol. Keep it going man!
One of the greatest albums ever written. Parabol and Parabola go together and Disposition- Reflection- Triad go together as well. Great reaction brother, looking forward to the next one 🤘🤘
👍
i disagree with triad being part of Disposition/Reflection the energy is totally off
aenima is better imo, but I could be bias as that was the first tool album I heard back in the day
@@Pyregazer Lateralus goes deeper than Aenema - it feels more sophisticated through my ears since 2001
Do it Dave. Livestream the whole album. Or listen to the entire album and release it one track at a time. I'll bring the POPCORN 🍿. 💯🔥🤯✌
I'll watch and 😃, watching someone else react to Tool is like hearing it for the first time all over again.
The world just didn't believe that Tool is the best band then and now and forever. I love reactions from normal non Tool fans but watching a musician who understands music and theory lose thier minds its just the best thing ever. No band has come close or ever will.
Word…
When I saw you react on the first notes, I thought to myself: OMG he's not ready for what's coming.
That bassline is my ringtone for about 15 years now, and stil find it incredible.
My ringtone is "Sober."
Hi David,
There’s only 4 reactions left on this album, the patient, parabol and parabola (should be done as 1 song but do parabola if you think both would be too long), ticks & leeches, then disposition/reflection/triad it’s one song in 3 parts often referred to as the holy trinity, please try to do it as one (21 minutes) reaction.
Parabol is a soft gentle buildup to parabola so you only miss a bit of the feel of the song but disposition/reflection/triad are 3 distinct movements and you would miss out on the overall experience doing these individually.
Plus I’m pretty sure Pneuma is written in 33/8 with multiple ways of making the 33/8 being used.
THis guy gets it
Surprised you never heard this one, it got as much airtime on the radio as Sober did back in the day
Nothing out of this world. There are tones of bands like that.
@@russvasquez9571 oh yeah, I hear 27/8 measures on the radio all the time.
What an epic meltdown on their time signatures. Seriously, I love seeing it. Dave, this is kind of a dig, but meant in a good way. The fact that you and so many others are so perplexed by their time signatures shows how much deeper they are than the majority of people as well as most in the industry. TOOL is not for everyone, but I think that is because most people want simple easy stuff and don't have the depth to experience it. Please keep it coming.
Man, always nice to see someone about to learn that the pieces fit.
Cold silence has a tendency to atrophy any sense of compassion, between supposed lovers.
Great video man, really like your breakdowns, but I appreciate you then go back and let it play.
Some musically gifted reactors have a tendency to get a bit intricate, and end up not seeing the forest through the trees if you get me.
Much love
I like your comment, agreed.
Side note: I always thought it was “can’t see the forest for the trees”; with a modern grammar re-phrasing being “can’t see the forest, but for the trees”.
@@pro-v7500 it may well be! I think the message is the same with the way I phrased it, but I think you might be right in terms of what the saying actually is.
You just took me back a lot a years ago when I heard this for the first time! Ty
Dude. Do 46 & 2. You’re a bass player, you’ll like it, much like this one.
Also, show me the damn bass! Teasing me isn’t nice.
This is the song that made me a Tool fan. I remember the first I time I heard it, January 15, 2001, sitting in a Taco Bell parking lot and it came on the radio. I found it confusing, then mesmerizing, then absolutely amazing. I've heard it hundreds of times since then and it gets better every time.
Your enthusiasm for music makes me smile. Thank you
I watched your reaction a couple of times, and I still don't understand why you are apologizing for figuring out the bass line...THIS IS AWESOME!!!!...CHEERS!!!
Been waiting for this one. Thanks for the beautiful bass footage 🤩 Really appreciate Justin's creativity and all he adds to the band. Great reaction
A true MASTERPIECE. This is Tool at their absolute best. There is no other. I saw the magnificent 4 3X on this tour. Life changing, beautiful, otherworldly and surreal. Reflection brought me to my knees when I first heard it live. I'm still talking about this album and tour 20 years later. That says something.
I also seen them 3 times on this tour reflection is still my favorite live tool song so mesmerizing 2001-2002 was tool at they're pinnacle this album will never be touched in my opinion
David TOOL is a ONCE IN A LIFETIME BAND. Start at the beginning and listen in order and you'll hear and experience the growth of the band.
Early TOOL is raw and angry. Present TOOL is Progressive Rocks gift.
This is an ALBUM ORIENTED BAND and the Artwork and engineering is at the highest level. People miss out on the ALBUM experience. This band has backword messages, hidden tracks, 3D glasses and Artwork and Vynl. Who does that anymore. TOOL does that. 🔥
Absolutely. I also think he should listen to the songs straight through and comment after. The start and stop doesn't work well with Tool.
This is the music Einstein would have made if he was a musician
The bassist told that the time signatures are based on his breath after he did exercise
This reaction is one of the most geniune I have seen and that's very appreciated, you earned yourself another subscriber! Greetings from Sweden!
Excellent break down, Tool takes a long time to release music, I think they start with no time signatures in mind at all , one of them just starts playing till they get the vibe or groove they really like and presenting it to the others then they all add in elements that fit that groove. And then they polish and find the signatures that logically completes the song. Its why it takes so long.. I dunno just a pure layman guess. Nonetheless they are amazing, one of the best bands ever imo... Always fun watching you react to tool. But if I were you, as much of a backlog you have.. and want to listen to that album do it ! 🤘✌
Dave can never go wrong doing a reaction, review and rant on anything made by Tool. If you want to guarantee seeing his ears shoot smoke from an overworked brain, request a Tool song! Always a good thing.
Im obsessed with Tool reactions… this is one of the best ever!!!
🤘🏼❤️🔥🤘🏼 Watching a professor ramble on about something that interests us is cool! Keep rocking!
This was the song that got me hooked
I love that you spent the past few minutes breaking down the first few chords… then the bass line kicks in and your eyes light up!
What I like about Tool is they defy classification. They were the same time as the grunge bands more or less but with a trippier, more experimental vibe. It's fun to watch you go all bass nerd, lol. Love this song, they're such great musicians. Jinjer plays these games with bass right now. Great score, great reaction!
As for writing process.. so there's a vid somewhere ( i think joe rogan) where Maynard says he writs the melodies and the others write there parts to the melodies and they work from there
edit: they also do a lot of work separately as far as I understood. and Maynard will just sit in his car in a vacant parking lot and write these melodies... also gotta sub love these vids
I forgot to comment that the sense of the sequence is due to the Fibonacci numbers.
I love how you have to grab your bass to figure it out. That's awesome.
Love your reaction and breakdown. Don't apologize for stopping to "gather" your thoughts...it is much better than watching someone just headbang for 6 minutes and then say "I liked it" and end their "reaction".
Hiya, Dave. 👋 I came back to revisit this reaction again today. This was fun to watch! I think as a person who knows nothing about music theory (such as my), Tool songs never sound "off" or "weird" to me. I am able to listen to it as a song without breaking down. Lol. I'm sure TOOL is a complicated band to break down like you do. You know what you're doing with your counts, I have no clue. I always appreciate the time you put in to figure the music out that works best for you. ✌️
I just binge-watched all your Tool reactions this far and thoroughly enjoyed watching your mind melt. Tool reactions are the only thing I watch on TH-cam and I love your perspective. I subscribed in hopes to see you spiral out to the rest of their catalog 🌀🤘
love your channel. you trying to figure out the riff reminded me of high school being around my friends in a metal band on weekends and before we’d go out and party.
they would hear a song and they would sit there and figure out the song while we were all drinking beers. took me back 30 years… awesome.
21:09 - I could see Adam and Danny having their own Pythagorean school where they're drawing geometric figures in the sand with a stick and trying to figure out whether the Neoplatonist source of all that is is more present in a 21/8 or an 27/8. They probably do it to mess with themselves though and since they're veteran musicians it hits anyone else that much harder.
I confess, at first I was annoyed...and then I was Impressed how quickly you figured it out even before grabbing the bass so good job on that!👍 This is the song that made me fall in love with this band. Justin Chancellor is a God among men.
This was me too dude. Welcome to the family. We have cookies.
Hahaha I love it! I love your review. Now I know why I felt like that the first time I heard it. Just because of that!!! That thing that I couldn't explain but I understand like going and back in a loop... I love that song so much and that album blew my mind. One of my favorites ❤
I love the 27/8 time rant lol. This channel is hilarious! Keep the fun coming!
What the heck? Don't apologize, it was cool as heck seeing you just figure out those riffs off of pure knowledge of the bass alone, that was super enjoyable to watch.
David doing some weird time signatures on his FPS there at 22:57 too
The amount of times I've seen pub bands try and do this intro and failed is crazy, yet it's simplicity is crazy. They just (as you say) make it sound far more complicated than it actually is.
This was just recommended to me. Glad I found you man!! Your ability to hear the notes and immediately be able to know the notes and then play it was SUPER cool to watch. Thoroughly enjoyed this my man. Keep up the reacts
FEELIN' YOU Benjamin!!!
Every tool song is an experience like watching a movie. At least on their last few albums.
Love ur vids dude. You spit some knowledge breakin down the math and times of things and talking the musical terms.
I love how Dave breaks down these increasingly complex things Tool song after song to conclude, “It’s simple!”
Pure joy!
I don't know you man but that was fun. I watch reactions all the time and watching you get lost in figuring it out was golden. Don't feel bad about that. Thanks brother
David this track is my Ringtone.
same here
Was mine for a while. Now I have the beginning of Fear Inoculum.
OH MY GOD THEY SPLIT UP 12/8 AND CREATED A SCHISM
My first time on your channel and I can already tell I'll really enjoy your reaction to Red Miso by Animals As Leaders.
Its awesome to watch your videos buddy. I`m happy to see you took your time to actually listen to the beauty of the music too this time. Cheers :)
I play guitar, but I started with bass. I love a good groove, and Justin Chancellor knows how to groove! Watching you try to find the notes and use your ear and theory to figure out that riff...damn man, nice work 🤘I picked up my guitar and played it along with you. 😃🎸🎶 subscribed.
Also, the best TooL album for me personally is 10,000 Days. They don't have a bad album in my mind but that album deserves some attention. Jambi, The Pot, Lost Keys + Rosetta Stoned, Vicarious etc.
He’s done the math enough to know!
Impressive how you identified the chords before touching the instrument to verify audibly.
Thanx for coming 🎶
That riff sounds soo complicated and you just showed how simple it was 🤯jUst shows more how genius it is
Hammer-ons for that triplet. It is absolutely that simple 🤘
5/8 - 7/8 really is 12/8 "They split it, and made it sound far more complex than it really is." Could it possibly have anything to do with the title and lyrics of the song? I am not a rythm genious, but so happy you explained this in this exact way. IMO theres a corelation there. As schism means a split or divide, and the lyrics are about an argument between lovers, wich often is made more complex than it needs to be. You know the pieces fit, but you still want to argue before coming to an understanding! Im curious now if there is any point in the song or album where the rythm isnt split :P
I'm only 10 minutes in. But I love your passion - and you make me regret selling my bass.
Just found your channel, like how you break down music. Amazes me how you just know what note it is .
D is the easiest not for me to find, it's the same starting note as "Anesthesia (Pulling Teeth)".
Hell yeah more TOOL!
That’s what they said let’s do it
I envy you for being able to listen this album for the first time with the musical knowledge you have.
I'm listening to this album for 20 years.. and still loving it.
Fellow bass player here and seeing you figure out the intro line made me smile because I try to do the same thing 😂
Man never feel bad about taking up time figuring it out on your instruments, it was really cool to watch. I picked up a bass not too long ago and it’s been so much fun trying to learn so I was in awe watching you figure it out so fast.
As much as I want to watch you react to all the songs on the album in their proper groupings, I think I’d rather you listen to the whole album yourself on your own time when you’re in the right mood for it and play it all the way through without stopping at all. Then do a synopsis video afterwards once you gather all your remarks and tell us what you thought. I’m not really fond of the broken up choppy album listens and I don’t think anyone wants to watch a full album reaction in real time, so just an idea. Because this album definitely needs a front to back undivided attention listen to really appreciate why so many people say it’s their peak.
I Watch guys like you and Doug Halvering with astonishment. The way you two know music theory is so impressive. Makes me wish I had paid more attention when I was in 11th grade!
I love your passion for music. It's palpable!
@davidheretic - As far as the time signatures go, the whole band embraces 'mixing it up' but I truly believe Danny Carey is to blame. Dude is flat out nuts in the best way possible. Absolute unit of a Drummer that the entire band plays off of. MJK deserves TONS of credit for being able to write such intense lyrics and fit them around all the time changes. Really each of them, Adam and Justin too. Band is best ever.
Their new album is also REALLY fucking good, but so is 10000 days aswell.
This is the song that made me buy a bass a couple years ago. It was literally the first bassline I ever learned. The bass is collecting dust now lol
Subscribed and following. Hope to see more great reactions.
That was not boring at all! That was extremely interesting to me. I hope you do more of it as you react to other songs as well
Good job
No need to apologize. We love your reactions and no one is bored.
mate best reaction on you tube 🤘🤘 l
Solid reaction. A great band for showcasing the bass.
Before you listen to the album as a whole, which is a masterpiece, you should react to Parabol+Parabola (2 tracks but one piece). This was a blast thanks for the vids.
The whole notes in the guitar and lyrics over that sixteenth note triplet of the bass is amazing
Lv this song when it came out
One of my favorite Tool songs of al time. If I remember correctly, the band said there are around 50 time signature changes and the overall time signature of the song is "6.5/8"
You liked how they flipped the 5/8, 7/8 to 7/8, 5/8.... Inversion Went perfectly with the lyrics switching from i know the pieces fit to there was a time when the pieces fit...
I was guitarist back in the early 2000's , that song made me a bass player after i heard it , and still i am \m//
David, if you were to do a reaction to the entire album, that would be great to watch, but I'd be a little worried about you. Afraid that you'd end up losing your mind and end in in a sanitarium you know just sitting in a corner repeating three words over and over: "Damn it, Tool!". But he'll would be a great idea for a reaction . Stay safe
Tool may be hurtful to you health symptons included PTSD.
@7:12 exactly. Even if I don’t love a tool song, I’ll like it because it’s so original.
I liked Tool enough from hearing Sober and the various singles from Aenima on rock radio in the mid-to-late 90s
But this song (the lead single off this album) is what sold me on loving this band. That breakdown at the end is astounding.
I love this reaction if I could give this two thumbs up I would, I love this so much just cuz of you figuring it out then playing it
But you want what I'll do one better new subb ur welcome, and you deserve it
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
🤘🤘🤘This album is a masterpiece.🤘🤘🤘
Once Tool added Justin Chancellor it just took them to another level
Just caught up on all 7 available Tool vids, great job!! I'm going to give ya 2 choices for the next vid: "Right in Two" or "46 & 2"!! 🤙🏽🍻
i do like hearing you find out the time signatures and such but i feel like you're missing the beauty of the songs itself by focusing too much on counting measures. still good reaction tho. just a thought
Yesssssss been waiting for more Tool lol
Rush & Tool are the time change gods 😅
David, amazing video! Quick thought.. Everything in Tool's music is so purposeful, I have a hard time believing that they picked the number 27 out of a hat. Likely, Maynard's cat was born on the 27th, or something like that. (The song Mantra, that leads into Schism is a recording of Maynard's cat, tweaked with post processing, so that's why I picked the cat as a subject.)
Some of the core principles underlying Tool's music lie in numerology and sacred geometry, evidently. So, are they messing with us? Yes. Is it random? Possible, but not likely.
You wand simplicity check out "Grinnin' in Your Face by Sun House.
I recently discovered Tool. I know nothing about writing or reading music. Always been a Led Zeppelin fan . Six months ago I accidentally listened to ,"The Pot" . Instant
Tool Fan. As a Bass player you should give it a try. Trust me.. He Rips it up!!!
Scheduled for release on July 5th as long as the block is removed.
Your ear is highly calibrated, you a boss 🙏🏆
Lateralus must review?:
1. The Grudge
3. The Patient
5. Schism - This video, so uh. yeah.
6.7.Parabol/Parabola - have to be done together. The transition is stark, but they do go together and should be reviewed that way(imho).
8. Ticks and Leeches
9. Lateralus
11. Reflection
12. Triad - largely instrumental, but still good.
Don't blame you for wanting to dive into the album. It's pretty much all awesome, just a few are sort of instrumental transitions and perhaps not worth a whole review.
Obviously you do you, but I'm sure these will all eventually get a request.
That's one of the best Tool's songs...don't think too much about time, dynamic, technics, whatever, enjoy the song and you'll have less headaches...trust me, I learned the hard way...I'm a drummer....man alive!!...was I pulling my hair...!!! (Scored?....I figures 9.2....I was closed !)