If I remember the story correctly, their crew were killed by poison. I don't think the Rock crew the strongest at that time would defeat someone with a poison. Or I'm just remembering it wrong. 😅
It was when the Rocks Pirates was just starting up Xebec was on the same type of mind as his son Blackbeard during this time. So unless you think Teach would be above fighting dirty like this at the beginning of his career it's nonsensical to point it out for his dad!
Brook is the coldest character in one piece🥶. Bro just casually pulled up on big mom and asked her to show her panties. And just called roger a rookie.
Roger(if he was still alive) will be 72 years old the same age as whitebeard, when he died. bigmom is 68 and Brook is 90 years old so it kinda makes sense.
I know right cause if we’re looking closely in D. Zebek time their was no king of the pirates 🏴☠️ so that would mean he know it all the guy did call Gol D. Roger à rookie
@@DanielAntunes1 "İ have seen this place before. Wait, i dont have eye. YOHOHOHOHO" (İf that was the case he would have been alive when he saw it but i couldnt resist the joke.)
If Rocks pirates did attack his crew, wouldn't he recognize big mom and kaido a bit? I mean he still remembers his promise to Laboon so I'm pretty sure he should also be able to remember something so tragic (aka the death of his crew)
@@nick_j3831 I think she was but you know who needs to learn haki. Go D. Ussop he needs some armament same with nami and chopper because they’re low tier fr fr
Brook is basically an immortal and he will be the one to tell the stories of legend that is the Straw Hat Crew to future generations to come. It's really bitter sweet.
You said Law has a stronger connection to Luffy than Brook? I agree with your main point, but Laboon connects him to the straw hats. I might be misunderstanding tho
Yeah. The main point supporting the idea that rocks attacked the rumbar pirates. Is that both the ship that attacked brooks crew, and rocks ship had 3 rows of canons
Hear me out… I may burn the entire kitchen but let me cook The reason why Blackbeard kidnapped Moriah, Garp and Pudding was to revive Rocks, but rather than use Garp’s memories for it, he’ll lure Luffy by using Garp, then kidnap Brook and revive Rocks D. Xebec by using pudding’s memory fruit and Moriah’s shadow fruit He failed in doing so but may try to do it again in the future and succeed
Buddy bigmom was on the rocks pirates and when Brook fought bigmom it was very clearly their first encounter so Brook faced the rocks pirates that would mean he had to have faced bigmom alongside kaido but again it doesn’t seem like he met kaido before Wano and there’s a big timeline discrepancy bc the rocks pirates were only a crew for around 6 years and xebec died at god valley 38 years ago defeated by the alliance of garp and Roger so even when the rocks pirates were formed around 44 years ago Brook would still be in the florian triangle considering he was trapped alone for 50 years and is around 90 so a rookie is all Roger would be by this point considering he conquered the grand line around 25 years ago which is half the time of brook wondering the seas alone and Brook might be strong but u think Brook would survive in a fight against whitebeard, kaido, bigmom, shiki not to mention the only pirate Roger was unable to defeat on his own and the rest of the rocks pirates because imagine how strong he has to be to have such big names on his crew not to mention most of the people on his crew split up and became legends capable of rivalling Roger with whitebeard and Roger being near equal and whitebeard was vice captain to xebec
I remember seeing a theory that Luffy will erase devil fruits at the end of the story, if this is true then that would mean brook would cease to exist, as he is held together by the revive revive fruit
At the mountain at the left side of the video at the end of the video, we see a black mountain with glowing red eyes, which is a theory that that mountain is Imu.
Since the god valley war took place 30 years ago, brook would’ve been dead by then since he’s been dead at sea for 50 years. So he might known a younger Xebec.
I don’t thinks so because Brook was alone for so long on the ship while time past by since he didn’t have any way to know what was going on for so long so the war happened and he was never aware of it
What if Brook visiting Loguetown set Roger on the path to piracy or Mihawk is from brook's country and he became a swordsman after hearing Brook's feats as the leader of the battle convoy.
What if Brook was the one who is telling the story of one piece and at the end it shows him sitting in front of the crews graves and says “ yohohoho looks like that’s the end of my story with my friends long ago”
They even cut him off when they was talking about rogers pirates and the doctor and baboon. Also they haven’t give much history behind his crew or life other than baboon.
If I remember correctly the Rumble pirates defeated the pirates that killed them but they were poisoned by them before dying. So I don't think the Rock purates defeated them but it is likely that Brook will know the Rocks pirates since he knew Roger then he should've at least heard about Rocks.
it wasn't the rocks pirates who attacked brook and his crew in the Florian triangle brooks crew talks about how they managed to win the fight but the enemies used poison brooks crew had no shot of winning against the rocks pirates
I mean, bro died almost 50 years ago I believe. Roger died around 20 years ago. There is a time laps of 30 years, Roger would have been of a similar age of Luffy's today. The battle of God Valley happened around 10+ years prior to Roger's execution because Shsnks was a baby, meaning that Brook was already dead 20 years before Roger and Garp defeated Xebec. So I guess that if Rocks D Xebec was already active he would've been a Foxy level pirate
Honestly I wouldn't be surprised if the part about Rocks personally seeing to the rumbar pirates getting decimated is true. From what we know about the rocks pirates is that they were known for infighting and were ruthless. I wouldn't put it pass a captain like Rocks to end the rumbar pirates in one of the most gruesome and harsh ways possible
Soooo what i think disproves this is the fact that the rumbar pirates ended up winning the fight qgainst the enemy pirates but it was the poison that killed them qnd what tells me they never encountered them is because they were killers who even killed amount there own crew so they would have definitely killed them them moved on
Brook, I don't think those timelines add up. Ace was only, like 20 when he died. Roger didn't start being a pirate until after he was diagnosed with terminalitus. Which ended up being a 5 year pirating career? Certainly not a 30yr career. Brook was alone in the Florean Triangle for 50 years.
Fun Fact: Brooks old Pirate Crew was named Song Pirates and it was said in Chapter 932, it was named Song Pirates because the most Iconic Icon in the Pirate Crew was Brook so the Oofed Pirate named his Pirate Crew the "Song Pirates"
Well there was a panda joly roger on the ship who attacked rumbar pirates and now i leave the rest to you find that sunken ship in some episode or something
That's one spicy theory. But imagine if Brook awakened his Devil Fruit can he revive dead people? 🧐 ( just like Edo tensei from Naruto but without any. Draw backs... )
This leaves a gaping ppot.hole if so bc crocus joined roger as.a.rookie and roger would have to have been king of the pirates for crocus to stay with laboon
Zoro had wano as underlings, jinbei lead fishmen, sanji is germa, chopper had his kingdom, ussop has 5000 underlings, nami had sky island for weather, robin revolutionary army, franky waterseven and egg head, what about brook????
I have got a question, on when the straw hats were on Enies lobby Rob Lucci says that when you eat a devil fruit you know automatically know it's name. So why does Luffy think his fruit is called the gumu gumu nomi when it's the human human fruit model nika.
I dont believe the rocks pirates killed brook's crew, because its said that they had poisoned weapons and they were gonna die for sure, the rocks pirates doesn't seem to be capable of using poisons, unless rocks used poisons or had a venomous DF
![🍑ONE PIECE GIRLS+ MAKINO REACT TO ONE PIECE BOYS 🍑 [PART ?/?]|||GACHA REACTION||](/img/n.gif)
brook : Roger, that rookie. I hope he's doing well
Brook let me tell you, he was... He was!!!
@@worminaround The keyword is 'was'... He was...
Legends don't die 😂
They just lose weight 😂
@@donovanulrich348alot of weight
@@joyuwaekwe7788some might even say they’re bare-bones, yohohohoho!
This MF is soooo BASED that he is now beyond the algorithm💀. Truly a CHAD 🗿
Damn if this is true brook has the highest possible character developement 🎩💀🤵♂️🩻
Even if this doesn't happens in future, oda already has cooked this character very hard
Nah, old characters dont really develop that much
☠️☠️☠️Facts
Yohohohohohohooohooh
Brook: man I. DDed 💀
"Brook doesn't connect to the Straw Hats"
Laboon: Hey mate!!!
Forgetting Laboon is a cardinal sin
Lol right!!!
Not a very strong connection whatsoever. That just makes him a passenger who helps out sometimes.
@@agreatmannamedlieu ? luffy freed him and gave him a crew to sing for hes literally the musician
People forget Luffy wanted a musician more than anyone(not even a navigator) in his crew
I think if the rocks pirates attacked the rumbar pirates, their wouldn’t be a pirate ship left. Let alone body’s to decay into skeletons
If I remember the story correctly, their crew were killed by poison. I don't think the Rock crew the strongest at that time would defeat someone with a poison. Or I'm just remembering it wrong. 😅
It’s just strawhat fanboys trying to give any meaning to the fodder of the crew🗣️🗣️
It was when the Rocks Pirates was just starting up Xebec was on the same type of mind as his son Blackbeard during this time. So unless you think Teach would be above fighting dirty like this at the beginning of his career it's nonsensical to point it out for his dad!
@@noctimereaper460 son? We don’t accept head canons in something that has nothing to do with the comment
@@DripJambeBrook disrespect will not be tolerated.
Brook has so much goddamn potential
Brook is the coldest character in one piece🥶. Bro just casually pulled up on big mom and asked her to show her panties. And just called roger a rookie.
Roger(if he was still alive) will be 72 years old the same age as whitebeard, when he died. bigmom is 68 and Brook is 90 years old so it kinda makes sense.
True or False :
Don’t y’all think brook know the location of the one piece but just doesn’t know if it’s that island everyone is looking for
That would honestly be hilarious
Imagine they get there and this mf just says "oh, this island, i remember this"
I know right cause if we’re looking closely in D. Zebek time their was no king of the pirates 🏴☠️ so that would mean he know it all the guy did call Gol D. Roger à rookie
@@DanielAntunes1 "İ have seen this place before. Wait, i dont have eye. YOHOHOHOHO" (İf that was the case he would have been alive when he saw it but i couldnt resist the joke.)
@@richardomilos8686 I based on what you said I just pictured the crew it’ll be so funny 🤣
At this point I’m surprised brook ain’t go that will of D ,he must’ve pulled out something to top big mom cause my man is Brook D.soul king
If Rocks pirates did attack his crew, wouldn't he recognize big mom and kaido a bit? I mean he still remembers his promise to Laboon so I'm pretty sure he should also be able to remember something so tragic (aka the death of his crew)
What if it was the fleet of rocks?
@@heh.5358why would it be the fleet?
@@Chris56076i think he means a member of the fleet
The Flashback showed a Ship battle without any Boarding
He may not have even seen the faces if the crew
Compare the young Big Mom with the actual, obviously he wouldn't recognize her
And Kaido was a teenager
brooks pirate crew was prior to the generation before Roger it would be lovely to see what pirates wer before that like his crew
Brook, Frankie and robin NEED to get some form of haki soon.
Robin got haki now but for her move that she got from sabo spinning dragon claw or something similar
@@garynebus8717 I don’t think that was actually haki tho?
@@nick_j3831nah her arms are black
@@HeroTTMYT thats what i thought, but apparently she wasn't using it i guess?
@@nick_j3831 I think she was but you know who needs to learn haki. Go D. Ussop he needs some armament same with nami and chopper because they’re low tier fr fr
When Brook met Rayleigh, he said that he remembers a rookie by the name of Gold Roger
If he did fought the rock pirates he would have remembered big mom and recalled that during their meeting
Big mom was hot back then, ain't no way he sees the big mom from now and recognizes her.
@@rowentaylor looool actually makes sense knowing brook
@@laranja5678fax
@@rowentaylorhe would have connected the dots on Big Mom and Kaido regardless.
i think rumbar pirates won the battle, the weapons were poisoned if I recall correct
Brook is basically an immortal and he will be the one to tell the stories of legend that is the Straw Hat Crew to future generations to come. It's really bitter sweet.
Brook owns this 💀
I love it when doron uploads
You said Law has a stronger connection to Luffy than Brook? I agree with your main point, but Laboon connects him to the straw hats. I might be misunderstanding tho
Cool, that's not a bad theory.
You're right, it's not bad, it's terrible.
The only pirate from the old era that will never die because he is already bones
A theory is still just that, a theory.
A lot of people seem to forget that the last couple of years
Yeah. The main point supporting the idea that rocks attacked the rumbar pirates. Is that both the ship that attacked brooks crew, and rocks ship had 3 rows of canons
Hear me out… I may burn the entire kitchen but let me cook
The reason why Blackbeard kidnapped Moriah, Garp and Pudding was to revive Rocks, but rather than use Garp’s memories for it, he’ll lure Luffy by using Garp, then kidnap Brook and revive Rocks D. Xebec by using pudding’s memory fruit and Moriah’s shadow fruit
He failed in doing so but may try to do it again in the future and succeed
what if the series end with brook saying "This is the pirate king Luffy's story"
Laboon? And brooks music itself, it hurts when someone says brook has least significance, we love brook
Buddy bigmom was on the rocks pirates and when Brook fought bigmom it was very clearly their first encounter so Brook faced the rocks pirates that would mean he had to have faced bigmom alongside kaido but again it doesn’t seem like he met kaido before Wano and there’s a big timeline discrepancy bc the rocks pirates were only a crew for around 6 years and xebec died at god valley 38 years ago defeated by the alliance of garp and Roger so even when the rocks pirates were formed around 44 years ago Brook would still be in the florian triangle considering he was trapped alone for 50 years and is around 90 so a rookie is all Roger would be by this point considering he conquered the grand line around 25 years ago which is half the time of brook wondering the seas alone and Brook might be strong but u think Brook would survive in a fight against whitebeard, kaido, bigmom, shiki not to mention the only pirate Roger was unable to defeat on his own and the rest of the rocks pirates because imagine how strong he has to be to have such big names on his crew not to mention most of the people on his crew split up and became legends capable of rivalling Roger with whitebeard and Roger being near equal and whitebeard was vice captain to xebec
He also mention roger too if y’all pay attention
Brook has been my fav strawhat since his introduction. I want him to have more development so badly and get an actual meaningful 1v1
Sir brook called the piret king a mere rookie what else we need to support this theory
I remember seeing a theory that Luffy will erase devil fruits at the end of the story, if this is true then that would mean brook would cease to exist, as he is held together by the revive revive fruit
That's really make sense
I think brook deserves a glow up
Brook is honestly my favorite character Fr
At the mountain at the left side of the video at the end of the video, we see a black mountain with glowing red eyes, which is a theory that that mountain is Imu.
No connection? My brother in christ, LABOOOOON
In the song "binks brew" it said the rumbar pirates.
Brook is the grand grand grand father of Rocks D Xebec 😂🤣😂
Since the god valley war took place 30 years ago, brook would’ve been dead by then since he’s been dead at sea for 50 years. So he might known a younger Xebec.
Not pirate king but he is the one of members of Rock D Xebeck crew
I don’t thinks so because Brook was alone for so long on the ship while time past by since he didn’t have any way to know what was going on for so long so the war happened and he was never aware of it
What if Brook visiting Loguetown set Roger on the path to piracy or Mihawk is from brook's country and he became a swordsman after hearing Brook's feats as the leader of the battle convoy.
What if Brook was the one who is telling the story of one piece and at the end it shows him sitting in front of the crews graves and says “ yohohoho looks like that’s the end of my story with my friends long ago”
Brook:who are you? Roger: i am going to be the King of pirate and who are you spooky scary skeleton?
Brook and luffy connect by the same promise they made to laboon
They even cut him off when they was talking about rogers pirates and the doctor and baboon. Also they haven’t give much history behind his crew or life other than baboon.
That would be INSANE if that was the case
If I remember correctly the Rumble pirates defeated the pirates that killed them but they were poisoned by them before dying. So I don't think the Rock purates defeated them but it is likely that Brook will know the Rocks pirates since he knew Roger then he should've at least heard about Rocks.
No because names like Whitebeard and Big Mom would have brought up something by now.
it wasn't the rocks pirates who attacked brook and his crew in the Florian triangle brooks crew talks about how they managed to win the fight but the enemies used poison brooks crew had no shot of winning against the rocks pirates
I mean, bro died almost 50 years ago I believe. Roger died around 20 years ago. There is a time laps of 30 years, Roger would have been of a similar age of Luffy's today. The battle of God Valley happened around 10+ years prior to Roger's execution because Shsnks was a baby, meaning that Brook was already dead 20 years before Roger and Garp defeated Xebec. So I guess that if Rocks D Xebec was already active he would've been a Foxy level pirate
My guy brook has some of the most badass moves though 🗿
I think brook will get a MAJOR POWER UP
it might sound weird, but I myself found this theory in my dreams.. and searched whether this theory was popular.. but yeaa not much
I like how these people start coming out with facts when the netflix Episodes release
animelisa would be like "brook is actually rocks d xebec"
the last one makes me think it so true
What If brook is the ultimate Trojan horse. What if he’s lowkey not who he said he was? Never thought about it but he’d be the perfect spy
Brook is the most underrated in the crew if not all of one piece.
No that whale entering into grand line meet brook when whale was a child has whale lives upto 50 years so that cannot be possible
I wonder if rocks would have left that many people onboard alive
Honestly I wouldn't be surprised if the part about Rocks personally seeing to the rumbar pirates getting decimated is true. From what we know about the rocks pirates is that they were known for infighting and were ruthless. I wouldn't put it pass a captain like Rocks to end the rumbar pirates in one of the most gruesome and harsh ways possible
That’s why he said he remembers a rookie named silvers Reyleigh
Soooo what i think disproves this is the fact that the rumbar pirates ended up winning the fight qgainst the enemy pirates but it was the poison that killed them qnd what tells me they never encountered them is because they were killers who even killed amount there own crew so they would have definitely killed them them moved on
Brook, I don't think those timelines add up. Ace was only, like 20 when he died. Roger didn't start being a pirate until after he was diagnosed with terminalitus. Which ended up being a 5 year pirating career? Certainly not a 30yr career. Brook was alone in the Florean Triangle for 50 years.
PLEASE I WANT MORE BROOKE CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT
Dude just decided to ignore Laboon existence
New theory: Brook is Rocks D Xebec
Lol. Brook staying on Florian triangle for yearsm
mh dude talked about Brook and the past and the thing that came to mind was Brook saying he thinks he remember a rookie by the name Gol D Roger 🙂
Brook is old af He remembers young roger so take that as u will
Yea broke is in his 80s
This theory makes sense
Bro eat theory theory fruit
Fun Fact: Brooks old Pirate Crew was named Song Pirates and it was said in Chapter 932, it was named Song Pirates because the most Iconic Icon in the Pirate Crew was Brook so the Oofed Pirate named his Pirate Crew the "Song Pirates"
Ok my bad the Sub dude made a Mistake on doing it so yeah its called Rumbar Pirates
Brook is 90 yrs old ,It's was 50 yrs ago Roger is 13-15 yrs old at that time
Day 11 of the journey to 450k by fall
Well there was a panda joly roger on the ship who attacked rumbar pirates and now i leave the rest to you find that sunken ship in some episode or something
Let’s not get ahead of ourselves
That's one spicy theory. But imagine if Brook awakened his Devil Fruit can he revive dead people? 🧐 ( just like Edo tensei from Naruto but without any. Draw backs... )
This leaves a gaping ppot.hole if so bc crocus joined roger as.a.rookie and roger would have to have been king of the pirates for crocus to stay with laboon
Brook is going to be huge help to Robin sometime in the near future.
Omg rocks is black beards father
No wonder Brook said to Rayleigh in Sabaody that he remembered Roger as a rookie back then....
That's why he called the dark king a rookie
Zoro had wano as underlings, jinbei lead fishmen, sanji is germa, chopper had his kingdom, ussop has 5000 underlings, nami had sky island for weather, robin revolutionary army, franky waterseven and egg head, what about brook????
I have got a question, on when the straw hats were on Enies lobby Rob Lucci says that when you eat a devil fruit you know automatically know it's name. So why does Luffy think his fruit is called the gumu gumu nomi when it's the human human fruit model nika.
Brook might be the person to share the history that imu made vanish
Brook stated that he knew about Rocks during Thriller Bark
I dont believe the rocks pirates killed brook's crew, because its said that they had poisoned weapons and they were gonna die for sure, the rocks pirates doesn't seem to be capable of using poisons, unless rocks used poisons or had a venomous DF
What about Laboon? He was was friends with both luffy and brook
This is actually not possible as Brook's crew died over 50 years ago. And Rocks pirates were active 40 years ago. So yeah. Debunked.
People be forgetting about laboon
This guys a chad
idk man I think they have some connections
Wait..... BROOK MIGHT KNOW WHERE THE ONE PEICE IS!
Bruh imagine if brook beat xebec when he was a complete rookie
And don’t forget Laboon
Imagine he know's laboon since he was a baby😊
Bro forgot laboon exists
bro forgot laboon exists