Kingdom Hearts 1: Game vs. Novel
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.ค. 2024
- Patreon:
/ regularpat
Twitch:
/ regularpatyt
Twitter:
/ thesubparpatsby
Join the Discord!
/ discord
2nd Channel:
/ regularpatscleverlynam...
Ko-Fi:
ko-fi.com/regularpat
Or, regularpat.com for all of the above!
Thumbnail by Kinode, God of Little Images
/ kinodekh
/ kinodevgm
Outro music by Nora Q. Rosa!
/ noraqrosa
/ @noraqrosa
00:00 - Intro
02:09 - General Thoughts
09:09 - Dive to the Heart, Destiny Islands & Disney Castle
12:20 - Traverse Town I
16:01 - Wonderland
18:37 - Deep Jungle
20:27 - Traverse Town II
24:45 - Agrabah
27:47 - Monstro
29:26 - Neverland
30:56 - Traverse Town III & Hollow Bastion I
34:46 - Traverse Town IV
36:21 - Hollow Bastion II
38:40 - End of the World
42:39 - Closing Thoughts & Outro
Music used (in order):
"A Walk in Andante" from Kingdom Hearts II (2005)
"Shipmeisters' Humoresque" from Kingdom Hearts (2002)
"Deep Jungle" from Kingdom Hearts
"Olympus Coliseum" from Kingdom Hearts
"Piccolo Resto" from Kingdom Hearts Re:Chain of Memories (2007)
"The Escapade" from Kingdom Hearts II
"Dive into the Heart" from Kingdom Hearts
"Destiny Islands" from Kingdom Hearts
"Mickey Mouse Club March" from Kingdom Hearts
"Night of Fate" from Kingdom Hearts
"Traverse Town" from Kingdom Hearts
"Precious Stars in the Sky" from Kingdom Hearts
"Welcome to Wonderland" from Kingdom Hearts
"Villains of a Sort" from Kingdom Hearts
"Merlin's Magical House" from Kingdom Hearts
"A Day in Agrabah" from Kingdom Hearts
"A Very Small Wish" from Kingdom Hearts
"Captain Hook's Pirate Ship" from Kingdom Hearts
"Hollow Bastion" from Kingdom Hearts
"End of the World" from Kingdom Hearts
"La Pace" from Kingdom Hearts Re:Chain of Memories - เกม
omg hearing that Sora invites Donald and Goofy to the islands almost out of a fear of never seeing them again melts my heart
And the fact that DONALD of all people suggests having him visit the Queen.
The other novels never talk down to kids with their writing style at all. I'm reading the Birth By Sleep novel to my 6 year old and she's loving it. Her favourite is Terra, poor child.
"Dad, why did Terra become evil and then die?"
"Because this is Kingdom Hearts, dear."
Awww that’s adorable!
@@Aurilaushe Darkness
Oof.
Sora's "no sad face" smiles in both the game and the manga are so beautiful in different ways
Also them adding Enigmatic Man fight right after fighting the Behemoth at Hollow Bastion is the coolest thing ever
Manga one is cursed asf
@@RealCGH same ngl
Too bad the manga is laughably rushed. one issue containing all of hollow bastion's first visit then straight to the final boss ANSEM DIES IN 3 PAGES
@@thatitalianlameguy2235
At least the Days Manga worked out well
I love how you used the game´s cutscenes and gameplay to fit the narration of the novel on that moment.
Very effective
now that you've mentioned it, all the world not in the Novel are KH1's optional worlds, (minus Monstro but most people play monstro) Olympus, Halloween Town, 100 Acre Wood and Atlantica.
I write Kingdom Hearts fanfiction, so I read the novels for extra reference. I’m currently reading the DDD novel (I skipped the Coded one, which yes, does in fact exist). And not gonna lie, KH1 is probably the most barebones one. A lot of the novels don’t really change most stuff, but add new things instead. The Reverse Rebirth part of CoM has some chapters on Repliku’s POV, KH2 has a lot of new scenes showing what Riku, Naminé and Axel were doing throughout the game, Days describes a bit of what Xion was doing in her time away from the Organization, and BBS is probably everyone’s favorite. It shows TVA’s POVs for every world, but also includes Vanitas’ POV, and even has two whole chapters dedicated to the four year period between Ventus arriving in Land of Departure and the start of the game, which once again includes Vanitas’ POV. I won’t say what happens in case anyone wants to check out, but just know that whenever you see someone wanting or writing fanfic about a Vanitas redemption arc, those people probably read the BBS novel.
Ooooh a fellow fanfic writer! Nice, I'm doing something similar where I'm writing my own KH 1 re-imagined novelization and im adding a bunch of stuff.
@@joeldavis9298 NO WAY! I’m doing pretty much that too, except it’s also a roleswap of Sora/Kairi and Roxas/Xion, and I plan on covering the entire series and slightly change some other stuff! Is your fic published? If yes, what’s the name? I’d love to check it out.
Thee BBS novel adress the fact that Terra, Aqua and Ven look exactly the same before and after that 4 year timeskip?
@@AlexxxMYLSince2013 Nope, but we actually have that answer already: The game developers didn’t want to create three more models for like, three scenes
@@dekuisagreatmaincharacter darn you PSP!!
And low budged
A Moogle named Kupo would be like a Canadian named Eh
It was nice hearing Pat call me a "real die-hard". Congrats on hitting a hundred uploads, and on all these other nice things going on in your life!
Hearing about the novel just now, like I'm certain many commenters are, and honestly. I kinda get it, as in "why make it." Since the main appeal of the series is Disney worlds, I could see a novel appealing to Disney fans who might not like video games. The first thing to comes to mind is moms. My mom for example loves reading novels, but she only started reading, say, the original Alice books after she saw the Disney movie and got curious.
Makes me really wish this came over.
Also being a huge One Piece fan, I am already aware that, over in Japan, there's already a large demographic of middle-aged women who love Shonen anime, which KH also falls a bit into. So yeah, making it makes a bit of sense.
There's also the fact that video game consoles and the games for them are quite expensive and not every parent wants to buy them for young children, or if they do have game consoles they usually get one brand (if not just one game console) and stick with it over the years. When i was growing up i only had Nintendo stuff and wouldn't dare ask for a Playstation when i already had plenty of games to play. So when i saw games i wanted from other consoles i would usually see if there were manga/novel adaptations so i could at least experience the story that way. When i was in Elementary school, there were actually a lot of people who only knew Kingdom Hearts as a manga and not a video game because they either weren't gamers or just didn't have Playstation, and read it in the school library.
I read the manga to my mom when we were living apart for a time. All of one and COM. She loved it!
I'd be keen to see a series comparing the games to the books.
As a new KH fan since January, I’ve been reading these KH novels myself for the last 2-3 months (having ordered the entire collection not long after completing KH1 for the first time in late February), and I’ve gotta say, these novels are very good reads! I’m currently almost halfway through the KH2 novel, and in spite of most of the changes, it’s actually a LOT better than the original KH2 so far, especially with ALL of its additional scenes featuring Riku, Namine, and Axel)! Thanks for talking about this, Pat! If you can or haven’t done so already, definitely give the other KH novels a read! I really can’t wait to read the rest of them myself!
Also, congratulations on publishing your 100th video! I subscribed to your channel just about a month ago, and as a brand new KH fan myself (again, since late January this year), you’ve really helped me become a much bigger KH fan than I’ve already been for the last 6-8 months! Keep up the good work, pal! May your heart be your guiding key! 😊😊😊😊😊😊
I haven't read the novels but in my opinion they sit in the same place as the manga: they're not really a replacement for the games, but they're a fun companion piece as a new way to experience a story I already know I love and enjoy
Video Idea Request: What would KH be like if you COULD bring Disney party members to other worlds? Like what if you took Tarzan back on the Gummi Ship and he joined you for Agrabah and Atlantica? What if Aladdin was allowed to join you and not just Genie? How might dialogue change with Halloweentown or Neverland with more characters (and would Ariel get to be human Ariel when you're not in Atlantica)? How differently might the impact of Donald and Goofy abandoning Sora in Hollow Bastion be if other party members stuck by him (or would they ALL abandon him there)?
Lots of interesting questions that would be fun to explore, and that's just KH1.
Good to see that Pat’s finally become a booktuber.
I just wanted to say, the very end of the video where you talked about how well things are going for you and how happy you are. I don't know what about it, you didn't say all that much, but it tugged at a heartstring. I'm glad you're doing well, I've been here since your treasure guide video, and I'm happy for your success, and your videos have given me hope that things will get better for me too, so thanks! Stay regular!
Never read the KH novel but I definitely recall reading Pokémon and Sonic novelizations as a kid. The Pokémon one was funny because it was literally just a guy plowing straight through a copy of Red and constructing a story out of it, so it was also pitched as a “strategy guide,” but all he did was beast through the campaign with a level 80 Charizard.
A Kingdom Hearts novel series, but in a different continuity so they can have creative freedom, would be a great idea. They could really dig deep into the themes and characters, like how Traverse Town is literally a planet that exists to give people who lost their worlds a home, imagine what they could do with that in book form. I just want Disney characters interacting and dealing with the existential crisis of a universe ending apocalypse, but the MC rallies them all together to save the day and make the universe a better place in the future. A story like that would sell like hotcakes, the KH games are literally just a diet version of that idea and look at how much money they make.
This was a great video. It really makes me want to read the novel. Congratulations on 100 videos.
HAPPY 100!!! So proud of you, Pat. Thanks for adding so much to the KH community. Excited to hear the good news, and I hope things keep looking up for you!!! Cheers man
Happy 100 Pat! Finding this channel in the thick of the pandemic relaunched a love for Kingdom Hearts that was put away like so much else at the end of childhood. Since that world ranking video showed up in my recommends I've played through the games I missed (which meant just about everything after Days) and got to work on building 100% files for the mainline titles (cracking down on 2 now!) I wouldn't have been reintroduced to this wonderful series that was so integral to my childhood if it weren't for you, so thank you and again: Congratulations!
Congrats on your 100th video! 💯
hearing the ending bit made me very happy for you 🙂coming from similar mentalities (from what i can put together at least, i don't wanna assume too much), it's always very heart warming to hear people coming from mental places that aren't so happy or nice to them, to really discovering happiness and getting a lot more from life and coming into it all with hope and a sense to move forward. i've been on the updraft of "this is the best year of my life" for about three years myself now and again, i'm just happy to see it happening to other people. thank you for sharing!
I love this video SO much! Thank you for making it!
Big 100th special! You deserve everything you have now, hopefully 2023 and year 4 can even surpass all of the years so far
I'M SO HAPPY YOU MADE THIS VIDEO! cant wait to watch it in a bit when i'm in a quiet space 😭
Congrats on 100 videos! I'm happy to hear you're doing so well! I know the feeling, not expecting to meet someone special to love, only to get the best surprise of your life. Here's to the next few years continuing to look up, cheers!!
thank you for making content for my favorite franchise and favorite game of all time and i hope to keep seeing videos from you long into the future especially when kh4 comes out
Thank you for this video Pat! I've been wanting to do a comparison of the books vs the games but didn't really have the energy to do it, so this caters to my interests exactly, it's great!
Really enjoyed the wholesome essay, and 100 videos is a huge accomplishment. Congrats!
Congrats on the 100th vid and the 3 year anniversary of regular goodness!
Excellent video Pat! Congratulations for everything, can’t wait to see what’s next!
I don't really comment often but I watch all of your stuff and wanted to say I'm really glad to hear you're doing so well in life Pat! Makes me happy to see and not only inspires myself to keep going but others too I'm sure
I also really loved this video I played KH1 and every KH game on release and had never heard of the novels, I would love to see you cover the rest of them
I have been watching you since about halfway into your second year on YT and I have loved every minute of it. Happy 100 videos, and thank you so much for the content you make!
Congrats on your 100th video! I loved this one. It's always great to see stuff from such a big fan of KH like you! 🙂
Hey it’s so good to see someone talk about the novels, I hope you continue doing this as later entries do add a lot more. Above all I would recommend reading the doing videos on KH2 novel and the Birth By Sleep novel, you are in for a treat!
Very thorough video as always! I don't read so.... I appreciate getting this information about the novel in video format, great job!
Congrats on 100 vids! Always happy to have a new Pat video to listen to while working. Also, really glad to hear that ur having a good year!
Congrats on hitting 100 videos man! They're truly such a fun watch every time.
Really enjoyed this a lot more than i thought i would, and also very pleased to hear that life has been looking up for you these past couple of years ❤️ we love to see it. I started watching in late 2020 and was hooked immediately, you have such a thoughtful insight in everything you do, and it gives me the same buzz that i get playing the new games for the first time, that award is well deserved.
Here's wishing you an equally if not happier 2022\23 both online and in your personal life ❤️
Happy 3 year anniversary to your channel! It's nice to hear that you're doing great
Aw Pat that was a really lovely video and such a sweet message at the end. Glad I watched all the way through to hear it. I will say this video actually got me pretty interested to read all of the novels. I've read Coded and BBS so far. The BBS novel for sure has a lot to talk about if you were going to make this a series.(There is like 20+ pages just dedicated to Vanitas and the tortures he goes through under old man werthers. It's a good read for sure.) Anyway Congrats on your 100th video! We are all so proud of you!
Happy 100th, Regular Pat! Awesome vid digging into the Kingdom Hearts novel!
Would be cool to see the other novels in this video style! Congrats on 100!
Aww heartwarming closing thoughts ! Happy 100th video !
Congratulations on the 100th Video, Regular Pat. You put a lot of effort in this videos and I found quite fun and interesting to watched this videos from time to time dispise it more nieche and lazer focous subject matter. You are legit funny guy and you had changed or at least challagen my opinions about various things in Kingdom Hearts. Glad that you are also living your best life because of it. Hope it get to stay like this for videos to come.
Pat I love you to death but did you just say "SRK and Donald and Goofy" And not "SORA, DONALD, GOOFY!"?! I'm gonna call Nomura and he'll sick the darkness on you.
Fucking congratulations! I know it's late but I'm a new commer. 100 videos, love, recognition in your community! Thriving and hope the year kept up pace to be your new best! Happy to find a KH community 😃
Definitely wanting to check out the book(s), had no idea they existed. Thanks for all you do Pat and congrats on 100! 🎉
ye we diehards. congrats on the 100th vid. keep running those laps and don't stop. also love the keyblade at the end.
Happy your year is going great!
Amazing video and never heard of the novel. Thanks for making this video. Needed my KH fix and some Pat videos
Someone's probably said something about this before, but I just noticed that the volume "numbers" on the japanese covers don't say "1" and "2", but instead they say "Above/Over" and "Below/Under"
I am happy for you man, happy 3-year anniversary 😁
Thanks for the awesome kh content as always!!
Whoo! Congrats on your 100th video Pat! I was somewhat curious about the novel and I'm glad I never have to read it now thanks to you. Would be interested in your coverage of the other volumes if you ever read them.
Congrats on 100 videos! The best KH TH-camr out there.
I stick around for after the jingle, I always watch, I always see, you can’t hide from Castle, he knows all your secrets
Congrats on the 100th video! It's been a ride :D
I've been looking for a video like this.
Congrats again on 100! 🖤 Thank you for the great content as always, and also bringing "rIKU" back
great vid as always
congrats for hitting 100 uploads
i would really like for you to take a look at the other books too
i really enjoyed this
but honestly, as i said before, you could upload a vid of you reading the phone book and i would watch it lol
the way you present things just really works for me
Congrats on 100 and also the love!
I can't even imagine consuming Kingdom Hearts as 100% story with no game play to break it up. I think my head would explode.
The Kingdom Hearts story is more than just lore dumps, obviously. There's plenty of pure character moments as well, also almost no lore happens in the actual Disney worlds, they're like their own self-contained thing (which is by design).
100th video let's go
it's interesting how the novel chooses to approach the story, the little added character moments really sound like the highlights. Can't really imagine though that reading about platforming, puzzle-solving and boss-fights is all that stimulating.
If I were to rewrite it my first instinct would be to focus a lot more on the Ansem Reports. After let's say every chapter the story shifts to Ansem's backstory written in first person, almost running parallel as a C-story to Sora's and Riku's adventure in the present day, so that in Hollow Bastion all these plot-threads meet up and collide.
16:40 the Wyverns are the only "dragon" like heartless in KH1 so yeah Wyverns
Also at least the novel kept an Ansem fight.
The manga legit had zero fights against Ansem. Riku-Ansem just hands Sora the Keyblade of Heart for the sacrifice before leaving and outside of World of Chaos just showing up, Ansem's entire thing is skipped in favor of the "Kingdom Hearts is Light" bit.
Congrats Brayden on the 100th video my dude🎉🎉🎉!! It feels like only yesterday I was watching your board game video!! (Manga versus game video WHEN! LMAO?)
Congrats on 100! Let’s get to 1000!!
Sorry to comment on an older video, congratulations on 100+ videos!! And great to hear life's been great recently, it brought a smile to my face. Always happy to hear what you have to say, you could talk about the evolution of the skill menus throughout the series for 2 hours and I'd get excited to see the notification for it
To answer your question, the 358/2 Days novelization is actually very good. It adds quite a bit of prose and Roxas's introspective thoughts. There's like poetry at times describing the high emotions. It also adds a lot of scenes like Marluxia and Axel talking before Castle Oblivion and such. I still haven't had the time to read some of the other ones but I do recommend the Days novel if you're bored and want to revisit that game's story. It helps Tomoco Kanemaki helped write the game itself and named Xion.
Congratulations on 100 videos!!!!!!!!
I've always wanted to get it and I found this inisght into it pretty interesting but I'd still like to have it at some point. Also congrats on 100 videos!!! Looking forward to seeing wherever your journey is headed :)
Aw Pat, happy one hundred
Yoooo 100 videos?! Congrats!
Congratulations, or I'm sorry, for having the best year of your life in these trying times. Keep up the good work/inventive videos going, no pressure.
I wonder how KH2 novel handles the Land of Dragons or Pride Lands, if at all, since summons were completely omitted in this novel. They wouldn't have ever "met" Mushu or Simba.
Congratulations on 100 videos!
Congrats on 100 videos and your 3 year anniversary
Wow, what a good pronunciation of Tomoco Kanemaki. I am very proud (not sarcasm, actually impressed)
for anyone reading this comment, i literally had Frosty send me a pronunciation of it so I didn't utterly biff it
I’m glad you did this video for the novel
Kingdom Hearts actually taught me a lot of words growing up too. I had teachers in middle school baffled that I didn't know what the vocabulary words for the week meant but I explained to my math teacher what doppelganger means when she asked my English teacher. (And as an adult, I was assessed for autism, a lil vocab test included, and I did annoyingly well on it and will forever be amused that the word they stopped me on was panacea, which was a word I had only seen in DDD at that point, and could only express that is was some kind of medicine lol).
I'm very glad you've come so far with this channel. I love your deep dives into things as well as your humorous shorter things (and the humor in the deep dives, of course). I still remember the first video of yours I stumbled upon, and the "oh thank fuckin god there's actual subtitles bless this man" and lo and behold, there's still subtitles lol. Thanks for all the effort you put into your videos, and I'm glad you find so much meaning and joy in making them too.
I think I wanna get my hands on the novel. Would be a fun little read. It was cool to see the differences between the two and your thoughts on the novel. Great video as always and congrats on the 100 videos, that’s no easy feat and the time and effort you put into them is very apparent :)
What a novel idea! (Manga next please!)
Came back after the video ended. Once again, you deserve the award you received and likely all you'll receive in the future. Love your content man
That outro mini speech 💕
I did NOT give you permission to make me cry with your epilogue at the end of this video. I'm so glad things are going well for you. It brings me great joy that you're successful and it sounds like you're happy
It's always interesting to know that depending on the medium for a series first like Kingdom Hearts on the PS2 or Harry Potter books and when it was put into different media like manga and movies respectively there were gonna be cuts to the story and it was going to be interesting to see what they omitted from the second medium and how they can justify it if applicable like Deep Jungle for Kingdom Hearts.
Nice to see a fellow kingdom hearts AND Harry Potter fan! :-)Would really love The latter to show up/be featured in the former eh? :-)
@@SuperMoviemaster21 Kingdom Hearts and Harry Potter crossover. Now that sounds pretty dope.
@@beeniecat9411 Yes indeed :-) and not only from what you get from the movies and books, but have you played the Harry Potter games? The earlier games Play very similarly To kingdom hearts with their use of spells; heck, you could literally rename them the kingdom hearts spells and they do/mean exactly the same thing and vice versa! :-)
This was a very interesting video considering I didn't even know that there was a kingdom hearts novel.
I'd love to see you cover the other Kingdom Hearts novels like this one. This was such a sweet comparison/reading experience.
congrats on video 100!
man we have to comment regularpats editing cause my god he has literally picked the perfect scene for every line he speaks
ohhh exciting this is gonna b fun to watch
Good to hear you're doing well pat :)
Perhaps their fight against the Darkside after their "fall into the endless abyss" is happening while they're still falling?
For some reason, the Deep Jungle Chapter made me stop and remember that Tarzan knows what Heartless are. Not just, he knows they’re monsters, but he knows that people can literally be so consumed by their own vices that they PHYSICALLY transform into monsters. This guy figured out in 5 minutes what took Ansem SoD a decade of unethical experimentation
26:20 I’ll give them this one just because it’s acknowledged very early on that Kairi isn’t from Destiny Islands originally, and the way she vanished was so out of the ordinary, so Sora WOULD have reason to fear she had been abducted somehow
Now I'm curious about the other novelizations...
Congrats on 100 videos! To the next 100 🍾
Holy crap, I didn't realize he made a hundred. And they're full of qualities as well.
Awesome edit
“My thumb hurts” lol those pages were dry!!!
New Pat Video ‼️‼️
I absolutely love the novels so far so I'm happy to see someone talk about the novels.
This was so good, had me cracking up with laughter
@41:35
You mentioned earlier in the video that the Darkside fought at Destiny Islands never got named as such. Was it still described as a big shaggy haired shadow man? My first thought was they somehow reinterpreted Darkside to be Ansem’s Guardian instead. Or maybe because the Guardian was viewed as just a curious trait of Ansem’s back then and not anything/anyone important it wasn’t considered a big deal to sub in Darkside