ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Is GPU Water Cooling Worth It? (or is Liquid Cooling Dead?) - Probing Paul #85
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ส.ค. 2024
- Should You Water Cool Your GPU? (or is Liquid Cooling Dead?) - Probing Paul #85
▷ MY STORE - shirts, pint glasses & hoodies: paulshardware.net
► TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Welcome to Probing Paul #85
0:51 Pre-Probing Notes
1:01 Should I Water Cool My GPU? (or is Liquid Cooling Dead?)
• Liquid Cooling is Dead...
6:18 How does a monitor’s resolution/size/refresh rate affect gaming performance?
10:23 What keyboard is the white one you use?
www.corsair.co...
11:43 How is the DIY home surveillance system doing?
• DIY Home Surveillance ...
• I Have a LOT to Learn ...
• I told myself this wou...
• The Final Teardown - P...
13:57 Was that a Radeon RX 7900 GRE??
• Cleanest Build Ever - ...
14:29 Looking forward to the Mini ITX build!
• Maximum Upgrade, Minim...
14:56 MAIL TIME (Sort Of) - Big Overhead Softbox Light Parts
Philips LED Flicker-Free Frosted Dimmable A19 Light Bulb, Daylight (5000K) 8W=60W - geni.us/hSqg
Kasa Outdoor Smart Dimmer Plug - geni.us/yETP7
Neewer 12x5 feet/3.6x1.5 meters Polyester White Seamless Diffusion Fabric - geni.us/sZZXH
FocusFoto 4-in-1 E27 Base Socket Splitter Light Lamp Bulb Head Adapter - geni.us/SmwwU7T
Please note that links above may be affiliate links -- clicking them earns me a small commission if you make a purchase and helps support my TH-cam channel. Thank you!
▷ MY STORE - shirts, pint glasses & hoodies: paulshardware.net
▷ SOCIAL
Twitter: @paulhardware
/ paulhardware
Facebook:
/ 195425877329550
Instagram:
/ paulhardware
:::Send Me Stuff:::
Paul's Hardware
P.O. Box 4325
Diamond Bar, CA 91765
► Edited by Joe Aguilar - ShaostylePostProductions
/ joe_editing
Audio file(s) provided by Epidemic Sound
www.epidemicsou...
Paul I'm not going to lie to you you could make a video of you just cutting what little grass you have in the backyard with the occasional thumbs up towards the camera and I would watch it because I like you as a person and have enjoyed all of your content... 🙂 So yes I would thoroughly enjoy watching you build this little rig or set up for lighting
Yes, Yes, I'd like to see a DYI video on a soft box.
It's funny, you can tell Paul and GN Steve both came from humble beginnings. They both very pro-consumer and keep budgets in mind with sensible upgrade paths despite having large platforms where they could easily say "bigger number better, go get bigger number". Cheers Paul.
I've often found it odd that CPUs get all kinds of crazy exotic cooling solutions everywhere from cheap hunk o' metal to "you're gonna need to sign a release form for this", but GPUs get hunk o' metal to bigger hunk o' metal and maybe a paltry 240 AIO with a Chinesium pump that will likely die in a year. Not only do GPUs pull far more wattage than CPUs on average, but they're far more likely to be running full tilt in realistic everyday scenarios like playing a game, while CPUs are only running full tilt if your favorite game is Cinebench.
I'd like to see GPU cooling become as ubiquitous as CPU cooling where you can upgrade your solution with a few screws and $100 instead of needing an engineering degree and $500 in hardware to upgrade it.
It's because CPUs are commonly sold without a Cooler anyway, while GPUs always come with a cooling solution....sadly...
Would immediately buy a bare GPU, even if it would be only a 10% discount or so
Well, you could actually just mount the same cpu blocks on your gpu, and have it work. Just make sure your vram and vrms are cooled.
@@clavicol6875 but that's exactly the problem...VRM cooling on high end cards is nothing to neglect...
@@florihae I understand your concern. Would be a pretty terrible Idea. In my case, got a 90mm fan over vrms with heatsinks, then again i've only a 5700 xt. Good day
@@clavicol6875 I have a 7900XTX, and with my curret OC it uses 450W 😅
Water cooling makes a bigger difference for GPU performance than for CPUs due to GPU running at 100% almost continuously while gaming. It also reduces the amount of heat the GPU is dumping right below the CPU, which matters a lot if your CPU is air cooled. Add on to that it reduces the weight and size of the card itself so it isn't prone to sagging.
This
Water blocks aren’t exactly light weight… But lighter than heat sinks, yeah by a little bit.
I agree with other comments on here; I added my custom loop because of how quiet it is compared to other options. Even an AIO cannot compare because you generally cannot control an AIO's fan speed based on water temperature delta over ambience, which is really the only metric your loop's fan speed should be based on.
I'm using a $20 transmission radiator for 20 bucks, And a $20 12 V wholehouse water pump for 20 bucks And hoses from home depot and everything runs fine.
This is how my Mechanical Mind works and put things into functional applications. If computer parts weren't so extremely expensive it would be cool to see a DIY build that is completely functional yet using non-functional computer parts to build. If I were you I would have added some duct tape to the joints just for good measure LOL and for the added aesthetic of course. It would be sweet to see a picture!
@@cj_guinn I am on tictok as hellscapedmn there some pictures
I love watercooling. Had been doing it since the 90's. Love all about it. The tinkering. We used to make our own cooling blocks. The lower noise. The better temps.
Yet, my system right now does not have water in it.
Performance wise the difference has gotten super small, with "air" collers, which are basicly liquid coolers, without pumps. Heat pipes are little liquid coolers, after all.
The only thing I miss is the quiet running. Custom loop watercooled PC is a whole different world of quiet, than the best air cooled one. It has gotten better too on that front and 80% of people won't mind the fan noise.
The main reason, why I have at least 1000€ worth of watercooling stuff laying around, but nothing in my personal PC is that I cannot afford to break stuff, with those prices.
Custom loops are always slightly dangerous. I have not killed any components with water, yet. But I have seen enough GPUs with dribbled water on them that have gone the way of the Dodo. Also, I have seen water on my own parts, but never burned anything, yet.
AIOs I could never get behind. Mainly because of the limited lifespan.
I will go back in the future. Mostly for the silent running and the tinkering. Water is life.
Of COURSE we want to see the light box build!!
I am for watercooling a GPU.
What I don't get is why AIB partners make large size, dual-slot ITX and Low Profile GPUs like the RTX 4060 and don't try tapping into more the huge SFF market.
For example, I own an off brand case that's 7.3L and fits a Micro-ATX motherboard. It's comfortable enough for one to fit a 67mm+ high CPU cooler and can still fit in a backpack, but it only uses low profile cards.
And yet the case is spacious enough to fit a dual 80mm radiator setup which would be good to mounting a low profile version of a GPU like the 4070 or 7700XT in it.
This would help remove the 8GB bottleneck gpu most sub
The first card I put an AIO on was a reference R9 290. It turned a literal hair dryer into a whisper quiet GPU that never saw above 55c, that's with a single fan 140mm AIO. GPU dies are so massive compared to CPUs that the benefits of watercooling are insane. Even today with my 7900XT on a custom loop, my GPU temps rarely break 45c, 65c hotspot.
If you take the money you save by going from an AIO to a regular air cooler, and then spend the money to go from say a 14700k to a 14900k, you may regret not having an AIO... even worse if you stretch to a 14900ks. I probably spent too much on a Corsair H150 AIO for my build, but I read before I bought that their warranty was good (even replacing damaged components from an AIO leak), so decided to go with that. My PC looks great, I'm happy with the performance of the 13700k, and it's totally silent.
I say build it they way *you* like it.
As an photographer it would be interesting to a light defuser box build.
Thanks for all Paul
I would love to see more DIY videos for any project you do. They've always been informative and inspiring. 👍
Totally agree 100% and even on the top tier hardware, it is merely optional. you can also underclock/undervolt if you want less noise. It is just generally good practice these days if you don't want your 500W CPU to run at 100C and burn itself up in a couple of years. You quite literally can't have it all. You can chose a statistically insignificant boost to benchmark performance and appearance or you can just have a solid gaming/streaming/productivity PC that will just work. Do some basic maintenance, tolerate slightly more noise (it isn't hard - I have extra sensitive hearing and I'm not quibbling over a couple dB) and have a reliable PC that will work the same in a decade as it does today, with few worries.
I use cheap 87 key keyboards with genuine MX switches that cost around $70. They have been rock solid for several years. The only real improvement I could make to them would be PBT caps. They are heavy and stable keyboards.
Even Cherry only charges around $90 for a wired mechanical RGB keyboard. Some of the companies building 'gaming keyboards' are really just taking consumers for a ride. They're building their own pale imitations of Cherry switches just to squeeze even more money out of the uninitiated.
Thanks for the GPU water cooling and AIO topic… It’s actually great timing with the upgrade I’m considering right now!
I have custom water cooling, not because it has high-end components, but because the computer works much quieter. And because of the gpu temperature too. 48c(now) vs 70c
This is my deal right now, My XFX Merc 310 7900 XT in a close case with good fans runs a 90C on the hot spot and 65-70C on the package (90C is its throttle limit and she walked a fine line with it). I have now got the system in an open wall mount case (Thermaltake p3 pro TG) as I have an Alphacool AIO coming for the GPU and the old case could only handle one 360 rad and my CPU AIO was already using it. Now that its in the new case it holds about 85-87C on the hot spot and 60 on the package. the AIO will help a ton in keeping it cool. A cool running chipset is a long life chipset and I don't plane on needing to upgrade for the next 4-5 years lol.
That's not the way to go anymore if you care about the noise. You get a cheap fanless computer as your general use computer and if you want to game or do something that takes more performance then you just connect to the big PC remotely. Just keep the computer somewhere you can't hear it. Technology has come so far that doing it that way is obsolete
You don't even need wires between the basic computer and the server. WiFi 5 is just good enough for 4k, but WiFi 6E and WiFi 7 would be even better. Moonlight+sunshine is da way
Ah yes, remote gaming. I love huge input latency.
Seriously, I tried Steam's remote play once with both computers connected to the same switch and it was so laggy that even playing Ace Attorney was unbearable.
Get outta here with your complete nonsense.
Okay but WHY do you want to keep the temperature so low? There's no tangible benefit for it, the PC outputs the same amount of joules as heat regardless. Also watercooling setups can be noisy.
For your PC at home, watercooling is mostly done as a hobby. Just for the fun of it. And it's okay to admit that
I quit aio 6 years ago . Not missing them
. Air is
Good , silent , and waterproof
Did you have something leak? 😅
i have 18 noctua fans (including the dual nhd-15s) in my single corsair 900D tower. dead quiet, ice cold, and it's not gonna stop working for AGES
and last longer than 3-5 years AND will be able to go from build to build for 10+ years (AM3/4/5 is goated)
Soft Box Video? Yes, please! I look forward to seeing the process (should you choose to make a video of it).
when it comes to purely performance, I agree that liquid cooling is largely impractical. However, when we factor in acoustics, I would argue that liquid cooling is in certain cases the only good option since you can achieve the same performance but at lower DB.
I like my PCs to be whisper quiet, and on my desk. It is hard to achieve this with specific CPUs due to [surface area : power draw] ratio (5800x over here) even with water cooling. Without hampering performance you have to do some tweaks to get it performing well while being quiet (undervolting + limiting power so the clocks are the same but it runs cooler).
With GPU is can be worse depending on your stock cooler. My 3080 ICX 2.0 (i think) could not run at max performance for more than a few min. and it was LOUD. In order to run it at max settings, i needed to liquid cool it. That also came with the added benefit of making run nearly silently.
Given the option, I would air cool everything IF i could get the performance and acoustics of watercooling. Until then, ill be watercooling as needed.
I've been running the same pump (Laing DDC) on a custom loop for the last 12 years.
Here I am planning on switching everything over to air cooling so I don't have to worry about maintenance
Dust removal is still kinda maintenance.
@@minskwatcher hoesntly dust isnt tht big of a deal nowadays. maybe back in the early 90s and 2000s but now its not even a problem. bought my pc in 2016 and i dusted it out the first year and after that never again and still no problems. cant wait to drop 5k on my next pc once the new gpus come out RTX 5090 here i come
I went to air cooling because I really didn't like that looming worry of something leaking.
After a decade my Corsair closed loop finally failed so I went with an air cooler for the first time on the old Haswell 4770k overclocked to 4.4g. I'm happy I did because the tech has come a long way. A well chosen $25 cooler now easily handles the 110 watts or so the chip puts out. When I built this rig it would have taken a super larger and expensive air cooler to OC at good temps.
@@ZiggyAndTheSpiderFromMars If you have a 4770K, the first thing you should do is delid it and put liquid metal on the die. Temp will drop drastically. After all these years , the thermal poop that Intel put between the IHS and the die will dry out . Those are the dark years that Intel use thermal poop instead of using indium solder to cut cost.
In the response to the first question I just want to say that I love my PowerColor Liquid Devil 7900TXT.
I remember you saying last time that you didn't have time to re-organize the office/set. It looks like you got to that! I have to say, it looks really nice! 👍🏻
Back in 2010 I built a custom fully water cooled system with an EVGA X58 Classified motherboard, an Intel Core i7-980X CPU and two AMD Radeon HD 6970 graphics cards in crossfire setup. This system has been running every day for 14 years and is currently being used by one of my friends without any issues. The main reason why I'm building water cooled system is to have a silent system, with benefits being reliability and low maintenance. Of course I have overclocked the system but the benefits aren't really worth the cost in my opinion, especially these days since overclocking CPU's and CPU's us much more restricted than before. Maybe the pumps aren't as reliable as before, but that water cooling has been way more reliable than any air cooled system. To conclude: if you build a water cooled system do it for the extremely low noise properties.
For the white keyboard Paul is using, there's simply a newer version of the K70 in white, which is widely available. I recently bought the K70 PRO WHITE.
After careful consideration of lots of keyboards. And I'm very happy with it. I've been using it for around 3 weeks now. I upgraded from my old K65 TKL from 2017, to this one. Well worth the upgrade. I most definitely wouldnt want to go back.
The K70 Pro White has PBT keycaps, so no ABS which wears. It has optical switches, which means a long lifespan of the switches. 150 mill clicks. And as was tested on Rtings, this keyboard has a response time of only 3,8 ms. Which is short, also compared to other top tier keyboards.
As for how the keyboard feels in use. The keycaps have a bit of a rough texture, which is nice. Your fingers won't slip, even when sweaty. And this texture will remain because it's made from PBT plastic and not the cheaper ABS plastic. The total travel distance feels pleasant as well, and most notably it has a somewhat soft landing at the end of it's travel distance. Which is especially nice in use, for typing or gaming. It doesnt make much noise either, although it is still audible. Compared to the K65 it's a night and day difference in sound.
The RGB is really well done, and it shines amazingly with the white keycaps, and the brushed aluminium top. Enough ways for the light to bounce, and stay bright. It has the option to save RGB-profiles on the onboard memory. With this, after having stored the profile on the onboard memory, the iCue software doesnt even need to be running on the pc anymore.
In my case, I built my latest system for modding Skyrim/Nolvus. That mod took my MSI 4090 to 84 deg solid/100%. Clocks didn't like it. At all. So I went to a custom loop for the card. Block/pump/res and a monsta 360 w/nf12 industrial fans.
Temps now under 50 deg under max load and clocks happy. Worth it for me. Much better. One fan will keep it cool on max speed. but 3 at lower speed is a much quieter experience.
I custom loop my 4090, I couldn’t stand how big the air cooler was. Just my personal preference though, plus it runs cooler.
Would appreciate an assembly video indeed. I really liked your home fixing videos / how to build etc as well to be both educational and enjoyable. Gives a lot of great ideas and a good step by step feel to it as well.
Keep up the great work and have a nice day.
I dont think there's anything inherently wrong with liquid cooling, but with the current state of air coolers, it is really something that you buy because you *want* it, for one reason or another, rather than something you buy, because you *need* it.
If you want to spend en extra 50-100 dollars or more on an AiO, because you highly value the aesthetics or being able to run the fans really slowly for nower noise, thats perfectly fine in my eyes - as long as you know that's where your money is going and can make that informed buying decision.
On the other hand, I dont think its wrong to keep mentioning that liquid cooling is largely unnecessary from a technical standpoint, because the old believe that "air cooling is lowend and liquid cooling is just better" still holds strong in a lot of people.
This seems to hold particularly true with products like the current AM5 CPUs that run hot by default despite not actually using that much power thus not actually requiring a lot of cooling to keep them under control.
Lots of people just dont understand that the cooling you need correlates primarily to the power that goes through the CPU rather than the actual temperature it's runnning at.
7800X3D is probably the worst offender here - it caps out at like 90w, petty much any tiny, cheap air cooler can handle that, yet i've seen so, so many people thinking they absolutely need a 360 AiO for it because of a mixture of "AM5 runs really hot" and "Its one of the most powerful CPUs, it *must* need a ton of cooling, right?"
These days, the CPU will just boost right up to the temp limit regardless of what cooler you put on it and gains for getting a couple hundred MHz extra on a modern CPU are negligible which is why I tune my CPUs myself. Intel can say it is ok to run at 100C all they want but that doesn't make it true. When testing a Haswell i7 recently, I noticed it just ran at 70C regardless of what cooler I put on it. They've been doing it for a long time but this last generation or two, both AMD and intel have lost the plot, choosing utterly suicidal temp limits and hitting them constantly as a matter of 'normal operation', lol.
My hypothesis is that x86 is nearly dead and we'll all be using ARM CPUs in a few years. MS full on commitment to Windows on ARM is some clear evidence. I think they are basically just tuning your CPUs according to planned obsolescence at this point and your 14900K is only going to last 3-4 years running at 100C. There will also likely be noticeable performance degradation well before then if you run your CPU hard.
@@Lurch-Bot lol my cpu *tries* to boost to temp limit (7950x3d) but never gets beyond 81°c in stress tests.
The thing with air cooled systems is you need to think not only about the air cooler on your CPU/GPU but also you MUST think about the air flow of your case. Air coolers in a glass box just don't really work.
completely agree on the water cooling assessment. Only really worth it when overclocking, etc. the highest version cpu or gpu. So many excellent air coolers out there. I've had to change out a couple of aio water coolers already due to pump failure and moving to air cooling works fine and much more reliable imo.
Yes, very much, so I love DIY projects of any description, but I have a special love for lighting and studio type projects that are geared towards saving money…. So I guess what I’m saying is YES, PLEASE PAUL !
I did watercooling for my 2080ti back in the before time. My current system GPU (6950) I couldn't care less about such things.
Well said about water cooling. I am a technician and work on pumps. In time, pumps fail.
I have two separate AIOs, and the GPU dumps heat out of the top of the case. It absolutely helps.
The air cooled card heated everything inside the case because it's blowing hot air directly onto the motherboard and everything.
my aio has lasted 8 years so far. still chugging
Thanks for considerable probing, Paul 😁!
Yes we want to see the light box build!
Great subject matter, Paul! And great edit, Joe! I'm excited to see the build of the soft box too!
All in all and beyond those potential issues, it's never a good idea to mix water and electrical systems, and even more when the PC parts prices are like we have nowdays.
I enjoy building custom loops, mainly for the look and a quieter set up. As I refresh all hardware, at least every other generation, I’m not too concerned about cleaning, I replace everything including the case when I rebuild. My eldest son has a 14900K and RTX4090 custom loop whilst my youngest is on the 5800X3D with RTX3090, so he will get an upgrade when the AM5 and 5000 series come out.
Yes, lighting video please.
I have the Corsair K70 MK.2. Got it new a few years ago for $80 USD on sale at Best Buy. Great Keyboard!
I was doing water cooling back in 1999-2000. Made most of my own parts, and cooled my second-gen Athlon with icewater from a 10-gallon Igloo cooler. I learned one important fact: A liquid cooling system WILL eventually leak, and damage your computer. And before it leaks, it will likely clog up. In the last few years I have replaced several folks' liquid cooling systems with air cooling, and there were no regrets.
my rule of thumb, since that same era, is: "if it HAS to run, it's on air. if it's FUN to run, you can throw water at it."
If it leaked, you did it wrong. Most water cooling suppliers make it hard to do it *right*, but if you do, it'll run more or less indefinitely, aside from the possibility of a pump failure.
Water cooling doesn't have to leak. It is used in data centers to cool servers. IBM mainframes with 99.9999% uptime are water cooled. If you can pressurize the water loop to 10x pressure for 24 hours and it doesn't leak then it probably won't leak in production use.
@@ghomerhust It's actually the other way around. You just can't have the workstation on air. Well, you can but it's far worse. Why? If something is running almost 24/7 and it's on air, you will have literal boeing engine next to your ear, plus it will overheat leading to not only worse performance (and thus more time spend on a single task), but also it will die faster (due to the hot "airbag" inside). So yeah, if it HAS to run it's on WATER
I built my first custom water cooled PC, and I built a custom case. It's currently Open air simply because I haven't cut the acrylic side panels. It has an Asus ROG STRIX B650E-I, AMD Ryzen 7 7700x, Asus ROG STRIX GeForce RTX 3080 Ti, 32gb of DDR5-6000 CL30, a Silverstone SX1000-LPT 1000w SXF PSU, a 1Tb gen3 m.2 SSD for OS, and a 1Tb Crucial T700 gen5 SSD for games. As for the water cooling setup I have two Alphacool NexXxoS UT60 radiators with push/pull fans and a Quantum Velocity² DDC pump/res/block from EK. My GPU NEVER gets hot, but the CPU gets hot no matter how fast the pump and fans are running. Yes, I know that's how the CPU is designed to work.
Now for the questions: How thick does the radiator need to be before you recommend to have the fans in push/pull? What is the minimum radiator size you recommend per overclocked component that it cools? What quiet fans would you recommend for having a good price with decent pressure/airflow? I'm currently using eight ARCTIC P14 PST 72.8 CFM, would you recommend an upgrade?
I love just how silent my computer can be while staying very cool, that's why I water cooled. Oh, and the performance of this custom setup kicks any AIO I've ever used to the curb.
Another scenario is if you enjoy tinkering with overclocking not for game performance but just to maximize and see how fast you can make your components run.
ive literally never watercooled anything and never had a single overheating issue at all
Only for top end stuff which 85% of PC playerbase does not have ..it's for aesthetics mostly
As someone that has an insane custom loop, I wholeheartedly agree that it is absolutely impractical but incredibly rewarding to see your system run so cool and quiet.
you put 1980 instead of 1920 for the math problem. But it'd still be an even lower number.
You don't have to ask if we want more videos of you putting stuff together! The answer will always be YES!!!
Definitely yes on the light box build. Love the DIY videos.
as a veteran builder and repair tech (started in late 1998), i personally run air on my primary system (which is 2 side by side full atx builds in a single tower, modified to fit 2 atx boards), my DayZ server is on air, and the house's media server is also air. every other computer we have is on water, some AIOs and some open loops. if it HAS to run, it's on air. if it's FUN to run, it's on water.
SECURITY: ive been using an off-the-shelf Night Owl security system. up to 10 1080 night vision cameras (that look like they're made by samsung), tiny DVR unit, i upgraded the stock drive with a 3tb WD Red NAS drive. it's been insanely reliable, good desktop and phone app, fully stand-alone. and it was pretty cheap as well, i added extra cams, up to 8 of em now!
I've always hated hearing " don't watercool, just but the next step up product that looks plain and is slightly faster", water cooling is fun and the looks are sooo much better than a plain Jane air build. I would rather get 160fps instead of 180fps if that meant looking at an awesome water-cooled system.
Exactly. I have a 3700X and an RX6900XT(that comes with a waterblock). I honestly don't need the extra frames at the moment, since the GPU is doing all of the heavy lifting, and with the FPS counter off, I don't notice a difference. It does look cooler now though, and I hear absolutely nothing from any fans, about a foot from my head. .
And I've had no problems with it neither.
I have 2 computers. One is running a Corsair AIO on the CPU that has been through 2 upgrades, is about 6 years old and still cools just fine. The other has a custom loop cooling the CPU and GPU. It has been running, almost 24-7, for 3 years now. Neither have ever hiccupped. In the custom loop I run straight clear Primochill PC Ice coolant with no dyes. I keep thinking I might tear it down an check the water blocks, but my temps haven't gone up and I don't want to risk creating any leaks. the only real problem with liquid cooling your GPU is the expense of a water block.
@7:44 I think you meant to type 1920 instead you typed 1980
Paul, you are truly one, possibly the only one, of the few True Humans left on youtube. Thank you for your rock-steady lazer-gaze, my fren.
I have a custom water cooling loop for my AMD Ryzen and RTX 3080TI based system. I use an Alphacool NexXxos Monsta 560mm radiator and Byski water blocks on my Ryzen and 3080Ti. I have the fans on the radiator and the PWM pump plugged into a powered fan hub that shares the PWM fan header for the CPU so that it varies the pump and fan speeds based upon CPU temp. It keeps my CPU in the upper 50s C under load and low 30s C when idle. My GPU core tops out in the upper 60s C while auto boosting to 2150 Mhz and the RAM is OC'd to 10,300 Mhz and stays in the low 70s C under load. It works amazingly well although was rather expensive when I built it. It cost nearly $1000 U.S. for the radiator, XSPC fittings, Alphacool quick-connects, tubing, XSPC pump and reservoir, and the two Byski water blocks. Despite the 8 fans on my radiator and two at the top of my case, my system is nearly silent because the fans are all quiet, low RPM fans.
I'm planning to buy a 16GB VRAM GPU. My current preference is NVidia and I always go for the 60series. Currently using 6GB 1060 with a 1440p monitor. My past GPUs are 4GB 960, and ~800MB 260 (till it broke). I am stating all this to give you context as I always go for a higher ram within my budget. For some reason, I think that higher ram will serve better in the long term. Whatever games I am playing right now are working well (racing games). So the Q is, is buying 4060 16GB is a good idea right now if I want to keep it for ~6years? Or should I wait another generation. Note that I used GTX 260 for ~6years, GTX 960 for ~7years, then 1060 for ~2years now (got it second hand).
My main reason for getting AIO 4090 (msi suprim) was the physical size of the card .... the 3.75 slot air cooled cards just seem overboard and I needed access to my other full size pci slots. However the AIO does do a good job of cooling
Same for me with the a Inno3D RTX 4090.
An aircooled card will not fit in my pc case and the temps stay very low, even in pathtraced Cp 2077.
The biggest payoff for me is projects, as a prosumer item. Poor mans professional card.
The steady temperature state over 24-48 hour jobs using things like Topaz AI prevents spikes and instability. Once the temp is saturated, that's what you get over the course of the whole render. No surprises, no fans ramping up and down, and no pipeline crashes.
The argument that it makes more sense to spend on a better component than to watercool it, depends on the reason for the watercooling. If it is only to provide better performance then that would be true. But if it's to provide silence, or to enable the component to run at very extended loads at low temperatures, or if you live in a very hot environment, then yes, watercooling has a huge benefit.
i have a dual 360 hard lined loop on my 3080ti. i did this to fit a look i wanted, and to keep it quiet. its wall mounted as my media center pc in my living room so i wanted zero fan noise. i also have a 360 hard line on my 5600x as well. it has its uses but it takes time. this was a two day build that took band saws, drills, paint guns, welders, and 3d printing
I basically just moved my pc to another room and ran 10m long displayport, usbc fibercables. Did the whole custom watercooled spiel, but the maintenance was just too exausting for me, plus couldn't run the pc while asleep. My mind wasn't at easy knowing water was near electronics without me present.
Custom water cooling was always a pain in the ass. I've never had a problem with any AIO or air cooled setup.
I had a 1080ti FE that was loud as hell, and over time the blower fan wasn’t working well, with the temp hitting as high as 88C. So I used an NZXT G12 kit to add a 240mm AIO to the 1080ti. It worked great. Much quieter and temps were mid 50s to 60C under load.
I just built a luchbox size pc. 14900k with a 135mm tower cooler wasn't working to well. Lowered the wattage to 275 too. Once I did a custom dual 92mm radiator, temps were much better and took longer to hit 100c before throttling down to 90c.
I personally like water cooling for one primary reason. I can run my PC wide open forever with a couple rads and I never hear my fans running. I sit about 1.5 feet from my PC and I can't hear it at all.
I enjoy these so much; thank you, Paul! I have been following you since the Newegg days, and I commend you on all your hard work! I am not too sure if anyone has asked this in a previous probe, but whatever happened to Arctic Panther? Cheers! 🍻
The better question is, what choice is there? The GPU's are not getting bigger, but the power requirements are. And power means heat, because that power has to go somewhere(conservation of energy). So either the GPU's have to be liquid cooled going forward, or everyone is going to be forced to get tower cases just to accommodate the passive cooling required to keep the GPU's at operating temperatures.
Which is a more meaningful monitor upgrade? 2K To 4K, or VA to OLED? Or should I go for both?
They have to go water cooled in the future. Gpus can’t keep getting bigger. Thus the house mounted gpu memes
I don't think so, but we'll have to see what happens this and next year.
Honestly it not even the actual card itself, it's the dang coolers these companies make that are sometimes way over kill
@@BajaBlastMyNuts by 7900 xtx gets over 500 watts usage. Just so much heat. It rarely gets over 60 deg gaming tho
no way water cooling will be standard, at least in near future, even 600W card will be fine on big chunky air cooler. Overall I don't expect GPUs coolers to be bigger than 4090.
@@daniil3815 well then they have to get more energy efficient which has not been the trend.
I have a rtx 3080 functioning as a video processor. Given the high rendering demands, it operates at 84-98% gpu usage constantly for the entirety of a movie. As it sits in our home cinema it needs to be near silent at those operating parameters. It hits around 68 Celsius with a custom loop. Loud fans will be the death knell in this use case.
Coming back to PC gaming after a decade, I think VRR is the best new popular thing. It almost completely removes the need to find a stable 60/ 120/ etc. fps to match the refresh rate, by fine tuning graphics settings.
All I have to do now is pick my resolution then play, if I want more frames I can lower or disable some settings real quick.
As someone with an open loop, I would like to see more GPUs come with a water block from the factory. It feels bad to have an unused GPU cooler wasting space.
Your light project looks interesting, why not!!! People who attempt any sort of media forget the importance of good lighting. Lighting is the third leg of the production chair, right after video quality and sound.
sure bud, give us the DIY Overhead Soft-Box Light video . . . i'll be here for it.
I just build custom loops for fun. It also capitalizes on my laziness and keeps me from upgrading too soon, which comes with somewhat diminished returns, in terms of actual experience.
I upgraded like five times in a span of five years (2012-2017), and I never really reminisce about the FPS (or res, or quality settings) I had, and I honestly don't even know what I was running when I played anything during those times. Now I'm only really interested in upgrading for noticeable reasons and/or because my HW doesn't seem up to reasonable par for a decent number of new things.
I have a 3080-10GB and my next upgrade will likely be back to Radeon with more VRAM, since Nvidia's been doing single gen planned obsolescence anyway.
Custom loop for anything is not worth it. It's a hassle, expensive and maintenance is a pain.
However, it is a very fun and interesting hobby.
Very interested in seeing the attempt at a softbox construction.
Thank you for your answer Paul! Never thought I would actually get an answer directly from you! I'm super grateful for the insight thanks!!
Yes please make the build vid as I raise a pint of "Brown Gold" to your health and all who appreciate your channel.
Erin go Bragh! to all next Sunday
If you're at the top tier cpu/gpu you're better off spending money on a case with a vertical gpu mount, a rotated motherboard, or a desktop case instead of a tower. There are numerous reports of board and solder joint cracking on these new heavy cards even with some gpu support. It's one of the few real arguments in favor of water cooling GPUs. After that, you're better off spending money on expanding the storage and secondary capabilities of your system. What about a better motherboard with a better pcie layout or a post code reader? What about another m.2 or a 20TB 3.5in drive so you can move those games to when you're not actively playing them and not have to delete them and re-download them? Why not add a blu-ray drive? What about an internal card reader? A few more USB ports? After that, what about peripherals? How's your keyboard and mouse? What about a second display? Is your primary display good enough for you? Speakers? Headset? USB DAC/sound card? How about your desk and chair? How about a recliner? (One of the best setups is a wall mounted tv and a lazboy with a piece of shelving board as a keyboard/mouse tray.) Controller or Joystick? Do you have a UPS yet? There are many things you'd be better served spending your money on than water cooling. But those are just my opinions. RGB and water cooling are at or below the bottom of my interests when it comes to spending money on computers, if you couldn't tell already.
Yes, I'd like to see a build video for you light box.
I have a liquid cooled RX6800XT nearly 3 years old and I am pushing it to near 6900XT reference performance. I don't regret it.
I have an EVGA 360 CLC AIO for my CPU that I bought for my 5800x. The reason I bought it was because it was literally on sale for 50% off for Boxing Day. I can justify spending $70 USD on it, but I'm sure as hell not spending $140. It's now perfectly cooling my 7600X.
I have the corsair h100i closed loop cpu cooler. I have been running it for about 10yrs without having to do any maintenance. Cpu under full load sits at a average of 63 degrees.
As a general thing for me: if you have some knowledge about water cooling and extra money (just in case something happen with the aio and damage your pc-rare but still a threat) then go for it.
Or you are like me just go for air cooling and set for a long time. Lower settings and stuff
I think when it comes to AIO's it's a personal choice and also who's going to maintain the computer. In particular graphics cards i think there are of course unique use case where it may not only make sense, but the case/build doesn't give you air cooled options that generally are available in general case designs.
Yes Paul, I would like to see a video on the dimable lightbox you are building. Keep up the great work on your content, thanks...
The biggest reason to go with GPU liquid cooling is simply that graphics cards are too big to fit in many cases with decent airflow, especially for vertical mounts. The more compact cards also free up other motherboard slots if you actually need them.
I have been building my custom machine since 2004. I have had PSU, GPU, Mobo, and Harddrives all fail on me. In my experience, your CPU can damage your Mobo over time if you are not managing your heat enough. I have not had a Mobo fail on me since I put a Corsair H100 in my machine. Also, my Corsair H100 is pretty quiet. Performance isn't everything. That being said, my current gpu Msi Geforce GTX 1080TI is kind of loud(yes it is old it wasn't when i bought it).
I agree with spend the extra money getting higher spec parts if possible....imo the benefit of watercooling these days is silence on higher parts.
My Phantom Spirit 120 EVO box came with a wrinkle in the exact same corner of the box as Paul's. I don't think it's a coincidence
So no you are not better off buying a better CPU most of the time. It depends on your use case. If you are strictly gaming you aren't getting more performance from i9 or Ryzen 9. So I feel like if you have an i7 or a Ryzen 7 and you're using it for gaming and you're debating between liquid cooling or air cooling and higher tier CPU either is fine. I agree with you except maybe the 4080 super since the price difference is $600-1000 at which point you can probably eke out a bit more performance from water cooling and it would be significantly cheaper. Now personally I've used a water-cooled system as my production rig for like 5 years it's hard-lined and it had no problems with uptime. I've even done upgrades for the CPU, RAM, SSDs, and GPU and all of them have been relatively painless. I feel like if you planned the loop right and bought good components a custom water-cooled system will last a very long time with very few issues.
Hey Paul, quick question for next probing paul: I'm thinking about upgrading RAM capacity from 16 to maybe 32 or 64GB on my 5800x3D rig. My question is, do I give my PC a mullet and go with 64GB of ECC 3200 or just stick with 32GB B die?
Context: I am on a Vision D-P B550 (ECC support), my current 16GB ram is OC'd to 3600 CL 14. I do way more single player games than I do Solidworks & FEA , but I keep running into situations where I'd like at least 32GB of Ram. The motherboard, cpu, and ram are all destined to be server hardware (currently a i5 2500k & 32GB ddr3).
What about the pros of reduced sound levels and dust with the lower fan speeds through liquid cooling? Maybe I’m weird really valuing these apparent benefits.
I literally never thought to check if it was possible to have multiple instances of calculator open at the same time. I learned something new today!
Question, though: I've typically gone 3-5 years between builds, but this time around, it seemed more difficult to get a build that felt "future-proofed" enough to last that long. I've finally be able to "settle down" with a build (went from 10700 + 3060, to 5600X3D + a750, and now to 5600X3D + 7800 XT). I know it's impossible to see into the future, but how long do you think a build like that would stay 'relevant' to use before upgrading? I'm a bit burnt out of building stuff at the moment lol
Edit: And in case anyone asks, that 10700 + 3060 build was given to a family member as a gift, since he was running an IED of a SFF 4th gen optiplex with an RX 570 shoved in there...somehow.
I am wondering how you like the Corsair chair after you have used it for more than a year?
Great video, as always. I totally agree with you that water cooling is okay, not a necessity, but nice to have if you want to spend the cash. I do have my complete system water cooled but I have enjoyed it and the performance over the past couple of years.
Heck yeah, let’s do the soft box video