The man who opened 130+ schools 100 years ago and change PakhtunKhwa dynamics. The man who spent 37 years of his life in prison but never compromised on his Principles. The man who presented and followed Philosophy of NonViolence 100 years ago when everyone was busy in WW-1 and WW-2. He stood against patriarchy. His voice always echoed for underprevilged classes. This man prevented Hindu-Muslim riots in Peshawar through his wisdom. The wisdom which is now desired, has been given by him a century ago. This is Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan aka Bacha Khan !
@@Football-Pundit-n9myes cos he wanted to make Pukhtunistan cos pakhtunkhwa was a Bufferzone between Afghanistan nd India rest i will tell u someday if we talk on voice man cos it will be long if i type here😂. More love u bro from Pashtun boy ❤
Yes Baccha Khan is our Hero. I respect him more than Gandhiji. Khan saheb never wanted division of India. He said if u r going to create Pakistan then we need separate Pakhtunistan for Pathans. It did not happened so he said, “aapne humko bhediyoke samne dal diya”
@@binurajs somnaath 800 saal tak banjar tha. Ab kuch picchle 80 saal se abaad hai. Jab iske andar phir se sona chaandi jama ho jayegi tab hum ghazi ise todney pohonch jayenge.
In India every child knows about Badshah Khan, known more here as Sarhadi Gandhi. I don't remember the class now but we I had read about this best human being in my school. @@navneetparmar3084
@navneetparmar3084 I remember learning about him in class 7 or 8 CBSE NCERT syllabus back in 2014 but it could be just the teacher and not text. But I vividly remember him and the nickname lol.
I am old and fortunate enough to have met the GREAT BACHA KHAN in Delhi. My father who had known Bacha Khan from pre-partition times, took me to seek his blessing when he visited India. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
@@judhajitsarkar1852Gandhi ji himself felt betrayed. He was not a party to Partition, in fact he refused to even participate in the independence ceremony and celebrations in August 1947. He went away to Noakhali in Bengal to fast and quell the Hindu Muslim riots there.
Your conclusion that invasion is a far right narrative is questionable. Shehzad, I understand that you may not be able to visit India, but there is a very lived and evidential history even till date where you can see the destruction of temples. In cases where the structure itself could not be damaged, the figures of the Deity were beheaded. And this is not restricted to a certain region of India but rather is very systemic across temples in the south and even more so in the North. So hence I would be very mindful if I were you to say that invasion is just a colonial narrative and is not a lived reality of the times being discussed
Invasion by whom is what he is saying, lol you gobar bhakts don't even watch his full video properly, usne Kaha ghaznavi lutera tha, air Uske destruction ki, masala ya hai ki tum jaahil andhbhakto ko har Muslim mai ghaznavi nazar aata hai, aur har koi tumhare hisaab se forcefully convert hua hai, history itni simple nhi hai
He doesn't want to see the gyanvaapi one side wall of temple under masjid All old temples hampi, kailash ,ect all the structures are been crashed he doesn't see 🙈
Quit this victim narrative. The Northern part of the subcontinent was invaded by numerous tribes. Some conquered large territories, ruled and stayed. Some looted and went back. That’s what was the tradition those days.
@ABHI-7111 you are absolutely right, I have seen the pictures of those temples and as a Muslim I can only say that I am extremely sad for that. Islam did not asked muslims to do that. What mulsjms did in the course of history is mostly what Islam prohibited. Again, I am extremly sorry about all those barbarian act done by the Muslim invaders.
Bhai Muslim invaders could not destroy all temples because of Rajputs, Marathas and Sikhs and Muslim rulers wanted to rule with the help of these rajputs Marathas warriors. Most of the Sardars in Mughal army’s were Marathas and Rajput like, Mirxa raje, Shahaji and many others. These guys protected Hindus and their temples
Talked with fellow students about Bacha Khan, was shocked when noone knew about him. We definitely need to know more about our national heroes. Kudos to u❤❤
By now I feel sad for indians who still hope any.. I mean literally ANY pakistani soo called self proclaimed intellectuals will go any further than romilla thapar. Please my countrymen just be a spectator... Don't waste your energy for anything else.
@@ms10J23 Who wasn't a Lootera in South Asia?? Why does no one talk about the Biggest looters from the northwest ( current Pakistan) like Chandragupt Maurya, Kushans, etc, who always looted and plundered current India ( minus Chinese Burmese regions of Northeast India captured by the British) . Mauryans alone killed 30 million gangajamnis. They didn't know what Hindu, hindusthan Bharat or India was. Ask South Indians. They hate the Indus valley and its kings and refused to call themselves " Hindus" ( a name given by persians to ppl of Indus Sindh) until Indra Gandhi bombed Tamil Tigers twice. Both India and Pakistan are teaching lies to their kids. South Asia is a region like Europe and never a natural country. It has dozens of historically, culturally, religiously and linguistically sepearted nations. Whoever united it had to go through each nation's blood bath via sword and gun. Even now, both countries will disintegrate without the British given army and guns. There was no Hindusthan before ghouri and no India before British. Bharat is a lie concocted in late 1800's and is not verified by any Western, Japanese, Russian or Israeli historian.
@@AbhishekTiwari-d6u He doesn't realise whole Pakistan is right wing..ye smartly Indian audiance ko attract karne ke liye ghori ghazni ko gaali deta hai aur baad me kahega unka koi religious motivation nahi tha .. we all know how chisti of ajmer came here and spread Islam.. slaughter cows .. married with girl won in battle.. these bastards can't hide history easily.
Having said that Romilla Thapar, a Nehuruvian, Left, Marxist, Colonial and Anti Hindu Historian has crafted a Historical perspective that downplays the Islamist aggression and an inherent Violent Ideology where Kuffars were to converted and eliminated derived from Al Kitab....In this way Shahzad is in Denial Mode while underplaying destruction of Hindu Temples which happened extensively and was the norm.
@@PrashasyaGautam he says 'they didn't destroy all temples in India' - when literally there is virtually no major storied/historical hindu temple left in all of north India after muslim conquest. Just because they focused on the biggest temples and the smaller ones escaped their wrath doesn't mean what they did was not bigoted. Just because important temples in the south and east survived doesn't give them any brownie points.
Right Wing hate agenda has brianwashed gullible, educated class. India's RW propganda by RSS and its ilks is nothing to do with Hinduism, just same way as Islamists in Pakistan has nothing to do wtih Islam. RW agenda is just to spread Hatred , Divide Society for grabbing Power . RW are no different from Ghausris and Ghazanvis. RW extremistse are preaent in all Religions- Hindus, Muslis, Christians, Sikhs, Jews etc. These religious extremists are real threat to humanity
There was no India before British and no Hindusthan before Ghouri. South Asia is region like Europe and not a natural country. Maurya, Kushan from NorthWest ( current Pakistan) have looted and plundered gangajamuna. Mauryans alone killed 30 million gangajamnis. They didn't know what bharat, India hindu or hindusthan was. Ask South Indians
@@sabrinakhan8217 So when the British came to the Sub-continent, they came here under an enterprise, a company if you will in 1601... What was its name again? The "British Afghanistan to Burma Company"? No, no, was it the "British South Asia Company"? No, no, no was it the "British Europe like continent in Asia" Company or was it "The Barwe Sageer" Company? Never mind, they came here to learn "Ganga Jamuni Tehzeeb", lol. And that's actually the first time I'm hearing the name of a set of people called "Gangajamunis". Did they just eat gullab jamoon and nothing else? I'm sure the Greeks when they coined the term Hindus, were high on pot. And Huen Tsang was doing Kung Fu when he wrote about Bharath.
@Indus720, 😡Here is an example of an idiot….. even after listening to the podcast, still repeating the sanghi/ islamist mentality…. Have some mercy on Indian civilisation and make an effort to read books and real history….
@@sabrinakhan8217Go get a reality check. Bharatiya civilization goes back 10000 years, known as the land bound by Indus river, the Himalayas and the ocean ( a fact difficult to digest for those who believe in cruel joke played on mankind in the sixth century arising out of hallucinations due to heat and mirages in a sandy desert...) as far as INDIA goes see the time line..Year c. 350 - c. 290 BC, Megasthenes was an ancient Greek historian, diplomat and Indian ethnographer and explorer in the Hellenistic period. He described INDIA in his book Indika. Year 476 AD End of Roman Empire. Year 927AD formation of Kingdom of England. Year 1451AD Christopher Columbus embarks on a voyage to find a sea route to INDIA. Year 1600AD British East INDIA company was founded. Year 1648AD the idea of a nation-state / the rise of the modern system of states, often called the “Westphalian system” emerged. Year 1707 AD formation of United kingdom.
Are you joking 😃 Don't make such history Before maharaja Ranjit Singh no one attacked afganistan part or pashtun part they use to come and attach india
Ye "atleast train to di" wala mindset India me bhi tha kuch saal pahle tak. Now people have realised we were the richest geography in the world, now divided into 3 countries and utterly poor.
@ThePakistanExperience Jab tak khud ko is geography ka nahi maanoge or khud ko turks or arabs bologe, impossible. Culture > Language > Nationality > Religion
We love Ahmad shah Abdali & Bacha Khan because Abdali give us freedom and he is the founder of Modern Afghanistan & Bacha Khan give us knowledge about politics. As Pakistan is a federation & I'm Pashtun from Pakhtunkhwa, so i hope that u must respect our heroes . If u can't praise them than don't blame our Ancestors and Heroes. Much respect for you Shehzad ❤
Being a pashtun Salute to you, brother. An eye-opening video for all pashtun youth who blindly follow establishment pro narrative since 1947. It started from jamat e islami and now pti. But the positive thing that a small fraction of pashtun youth has started studying Bacha khan.
app be kise or ka batooo ma akar kahtay hoo sahi karah hai.Afsooos hai tum pa history ko sahi study karo pir patwa Dana app qasier Raja ka video dek pir pata chalaga 🎉🎉🎉
Even gaznvi was a turk not belong to our land of Undivided India and pashtun is our brother about pashtun mention in rig veda in a battle of ten king In mahabharat this area is know aa Gandhar famous queen of mahabharata queen ghandari and his brother shakuni mahabharat is not about Hindu stories it's also a stories of pashtun and bro religion change hone se ancestors or blood change nhi hota hai
I don't think three podcaster will dare to call Vikram Sampath, Meenakshi Jain, J Sai Deepak etc to his show... they will school him proper in Bharatiya history and that of the subcontinent...
I am truly speechless.....salute to u.....from an older brother from KP 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 .......waiting for u to visit.....plz let us know in advance.....meeting u will be an honor beyond words ...❤❤❤
I rarely comment on TH-cam videos but Shehzad I want to thank you on behalf of my Pukhtoon community, most of whom will hate you for speaking up for them. They don't realize the fact that Bacha Khan ka vision pukhtoon society k liye ek blessing tha, but we didn't live up to it.
Kyuki musalmano ne sare mandir nahi tode isliye koi religious angle nahi hai Bhai us hisab se to israel ne abhi sare phalestini bhi nahi mare To ye genocide ka rona kyo rote ho
14:03 Maqsad to wahi tha .. Tabhi aaj Iran , Afganistan,pakistan musalmaan hogaya .. Hindus ke resilience ke kaaran bach gaye .. nahi to Persia jaise bade empire , Byzantine jaisa bada empire me sabko convert ker diya
@@Justpeace-j7warmy me hindu hone ka mtlb ye thode hua ki antihindu kaam nhi kiya h Pakistan aur afganistan ko musalman bnne k kaam ghaznvi ne ki kiya h aur by force kiya
@@Justpeace-j7w who told you that he had Hindus in his army? And he had nothing to do with Islam. His father converted Pathans in Pakistan to Islam. Read history from proper sources. Unless forcibly converted noone will change their religion, percentage of people willingly converting is less than 1%. So it is either force or Money. Christians convert using money. I am from Goa, Christian missionary converted poor Hindus in 18th century just for a bag of rice. They tried force too, so my family fled to Mumbai
@@yashpednekar331 we fought Mughals, we fought British, and when entire India laid their weapons in 1857, only one nation stood, go and search, anglo Indian wars , from 1857-1947, imagine what percentage would be fought of the list would be Pathan (Pashtuns), it was almost entirely our struggle, just search and tell me, you really think people can force us for conversion?
@@DataCrusade1999i don't like savarkar and his ideology but the point is savarkar was indian. But these Gauri Gaznavi ,Babar and abdali etc were invaders likes Britishers
This guy in future: Sunnis are breaking shia's mosque but wo koi Shia Sunni masla nahi hai 😃 Far right kare to hindu muslim British kare to hindu muslim Lekin invader kare to .. are wo to lutere the .. hindu muslim kuchh nahi tha ..😂
Wonderful piece of work Shehzad. One thing you missed about Bacha khan’s life were his religious beliefs which are often overshadowed by his secular and nonviolent movement. He had a wonderful relationship with the muslim clergy or alim deens of that time. This aspect of his life is often times overlooked.
This guy should do a Podcast on Middle eastern colonialism (Turko Persian) as well - How the Moghuls and sultans suppressed locals like imposed their language and taxed non muslims .. Why only British colonialism if it suits the narrative 😂
Good Work Shahzad! 👏 Bacha Khan devoted his life to promoting nonviolence, education, and social reform, striving tirelessly for the upliftment of marginalized communities and the unity of the subcontinent. Meanwhile,Mahmood Ghaznavi is often mistakenly glorified as a hero, despite his invasions being driven by plunder and personal ambition rather than the noble ideals of justice or cultural advancement. I think I'm gradually being derived towards FOMO on this seminal series of your 😅 💯👏
@@AbhishekG026Oh indian ko tab pasand hai kou ky woh phalay Pakistan mukhalif thy or woh bangaldesh ko itna dhoor nhi rakhna chahtay thy humay maloom hai.per itna zikar nhi hota
Bacha khan says he's ancestors was hindu he was muslim but he give her sister to hindu for marriage he dont accept islam he was liberal thats why this liberals support another liberals
آپ غدار نہیں آپ سچے پاکستانی ہیں۔ جو سچا محب وطن ہوتا ہے اسے تنقید کا بھی حق ہوتا ہے۔ آپ سندھی ہو کر ہم پنجابیوں کے لیے بھی کام کر رہے ہیں شناخت کے بحران کو ختم کرنے کی کو شش کر رہے ہیں جس کی ہم پنجابیوں کو سب سے زیادہ ضرورت ہے۔ شکریہ جناب۔ اللہ آپ کی حفاظت فرمائے۔ آمین
And I also believe that regional languages should not be subjugated; instead, all major regional languages like Punjabi, Pushto, Baluchi, and Sindhi must be declared official national languages, and all the monetary notes and official documentations should follow that suit too. It is strange that our currency notes are in a language which most of the people at their respective demographics don’t really understand; they just use it.
Islamic conquest/ destruction of sindh is so complete that we don’t even know what script was used to write Sindhi before arabic marauders won sindh. It is so spectacular that there are historical records of a grand Sun temple somewhere in Multan. These iconoclasts devastated that temple so badly, archeologists couldn’t even find the exact location of that temple anymore. They didn’t even leave any ruins.
Sindhi lohanas community converted to form memon community There are Punjabi/ kutchi / Sindhi lohanas and they are closely related with khatri community All Sikh gurus were Khatri themselves Jinnah was vaishnavite lohana with surname thakkar which actually comes from takkar province of Afghanistan When mohammad bin Qasim attacked today's sindh , it was ruled by a pushkarna Brahmin king dahir sen whose forefather chach Brahmin had married the widow of lohana Dynasty king rai and took over the kingdom from lohana Dynasty ruler
Romila Thapar ko Sanskrit Nahi aati, Toh Wo Indian History ki Historian kese Ho Sakti hai ? Yah ek Simple Logic hai ! Opinion har koi de sakta hai, Lekin wo Historian nahi ban jaega
Well, Shezad. It was an interesting discussion. But you should consider reading other great Indian historians, too, like Jadunath Sarkar, R.C . Majumdar, Manu Pillai ( which you called on your podcast earlier), Dr. Vikram Sampath, etc, to know more nuanced history. Because Thaapar's lack of Sanskrit Knowledge also lacked many details in her books. You can't get everything right just by Romila Thaapar's books. I am glad you called Dr. Janaki recently for Savarkar discussion, and I really liked that. Because unlike her historians from Romila, Thaapar made Savarkar clear Fascist villain because they didn't study Marathi literature written by Savarkar. They couldn't study Sanskrit either.
@dharmeshparikh7837 when they don't have answer then then laugh at u. I think u know the answer. He is a leftist so why he will agree with anything that favours right
@@fakebatli frankly, I don't know what he is trying to convey here by laughter emoji instead of proper reply or sentence. 🤷🤷 is he making fun of my initial message, or he doesn't agree or anything he wants to convey, which I couldn't understand.
We Indian also love him yaar unke dil me dard tha jab india aaye tab kaha tha m wo yahan nhi khna chta shazad knows very well k aap ne Hume...... .....
@@ravigodara887indian ko tab pasand hai kou ky woh Pakistan alag karnay ky mukalif thy shuro mai but woh bangladesh ko dhor rakhnay ki waja sy tha woh kahtay thy bas
@@affaqmalik5876 galat padha hai aap ne Pakistan alag ho gya koi baat nhi lekin Pakistan apne aap ko nhi Sambhal saka bhai her baar apni land rent per de di kisi cheez pe dhayaan nhi diya akhir aaj haal dekh lo Hume khushi nhi dukh hota hai ye dekh kr Pakistan bhi grow krey hum bhi ye he chate han education sari ki sari jhooti padhai gyi zia ne barbaad krne me koi kasar nhi rakhi or aaj modi bhi zia ke raah per india ko le jana chata hai but hamara congratulations bhot mazboot hai sab ko equal rakhta hai iss liye Hume dar nhi ke zia wala kaam yahan hoga han chand pagal han jo history ko nhi Mante
love this series . much much respect shahzad .Just not narrating history but also analyzing how it was shaped and affects are collective conciousness about pushtoons. This is why i pakistan experience is in a league of its own.
I have read and all his books are based on what if it didn't happened what if that happened and he builds all his arguments on history that never existed alternate history kind of bs , all he says he are taught wrong and don't tell what is real history then
Both Khan Abdul Gaffar khan and Khan Abdul Jabbar Khan were great leaders forgotten by history and buried by their contemporaries to ensure their ideas, ideals and perspectives wouldn't drown out their own. Hope these two get their due someday soon in Pakistan too.
@@kalidasswaminathan4341😊 also khan market was established for refugees and it honours both brothers kyuki NWFP mein Khan Abdul Jabbar Khan ki govt thi aur unhone Jo Jo idhar aana chahta tha unke liye raasta diya ensuring no harm on his watch. Vaise I do think itne comments ke baad lag bhag har koi jaanta hai yeh cheezein
Ghaffar Khan was a great hero of subcontinent whereas Mahmood Ghaznavi was an extreme robber who looted India and went back leaving behind his remanants.
Dear Shehzadbhai, greetings from Mumbai, India. Very interesting issues raised about distorting or weaponising History or narrative to push hidden agenda of one particular way of thinking, which is "Right Wing, Majoritarianism". my few comments : 1. Pakistani State has weaponised "History" and set agenda for people so that dissenting voices / diverse views / liberal inclusive thinking is crushed. Homogenisation is pushed in the name of "national security, national indentity etc etc " 2. Pakistan failed miserably in the Homogenisation exercise in all areas- Security , Unity , economic development , Cultural growth etc. People of Pakistan have been torn away from their roots of diverse identities of Pasthuns, Sindhi, Balochs, Punjabis, Seraikis etc. 3. India was fortunate to have leaders like Pandit Nehru, Patel, Azad, Dr Ambedkar, Prasad , Shastri who gave a Constitution encouraging equality, diversity , tolerance etc. We celebrated Unity in Diversity , which kept diverse Bharat unitted for last several decades. 4. Because if liberal, tolerant State , India allowed rise of Right Wing and Left Wing to not only sprout but also flourish. Because of Liebral constitution we have seen RW groups like RSS, Hindu Mahasabha and its associates to survive and thrive in India. These RW groups , instead of celebrating the Diversity and learning from Pakistan about how not Homogenise the masses, have gone opposite way. RW / Hindutvawadis are just copying actions of Islamist Pakistani's RW agenda of majoritarianism . Hindutvawadis have failed in last 10 years on all fronts - Economy, Employment generation, Society unity , Rise in Communalilsm, poor neighbourly relations etc. 5. Right Wing agenda around world can be phenoenon of few years, but it bound to fail in long run ( sadly adter destroying the economic and social progress ). Regards
Nonetheless, Mahmud of Ghazni was an extraordinary person. Persians and Tajiks have a better appreciation of him. On the other hand, Pakistanis and Indians have reduced him to a pissing contest. Reducing him to simply a "looter," as many feeble-minded people do, is an injustice to his history
Khudai Khidmatgars exhibited the spectacle of liberation theology of Islam. It demanded better distribution of land and decried the large estates. Khan wanted to build a socialist society. Ghaffar Khan was a great secularist. "It was in Punjab jail that he formed friendship with Hindus and Sikhs and studied the Hindu scriptures, especially the Gita and the Granth Saheb, the Holy Book of the Sikhs."
And yet he remained one of the bigger land holders in the area. The hypocrisy is that it starts from home, where his ancestors are still one of the wealthiest families amongst the Pashtuns he was so driven to liberate.
Thank you for making a video on this. Baccha khan us underrated. While radical muslims like to simp for bisexual ghazni. Also baccha khan also took inspiration from Hindu scriptures too.
asking my cousins and friends, who are all graduation-level students, if they had ever heard of someone called "Bacha Khan." It pains me to see "none of them even knew this name", Pakistan erased a hero from its history just bcz bacha khan didn't fit in the colonial sculpture of real Pakistani
I went through the podcast. Felt that you took a very strong subject and tried to present just after reading few history books. Romila ji is proved wrong at so many times that now historians don’t take her names that much in Bharat.
What a fine podcaster you are Shehzad..! I am far rightist of India. I am convinced by you... Iam starting my journey to become centrist... Thnx sir 🙏🙏🙏
Ghaffar Khan was a Good Person and he was Hero of Pashtoons only NOT rest of the Pakistan. Please, don't try to make him Hero of rest of People of Pakistan. He is NOT Hero of Muslim Panjabis, Muslim Sindhis and Balochs. And, everyone have their own people to whom they consider as their Hero.
Look at the speeches of Bacha Khan.He was against the creation of Pakistan and he clearly said We pashtoon would be under Punjabis if Pakistan is created. For him his ethnicity matters.We Pakistanis only work for religion irrespective of ethnicity.Bacha khan is a hero for those who work for ethnicity but not for those who work for Islam like Quaid e Azam,Allama Iqbal, Abdul Sattar Edhi, Dr Abdul Salam, Dr Abdul Qadeer Khan and many more.
China and the West are interested in Pakistan. Not Pakistanis. Ditto Bangladesh. Let's not forget that. The more chaos and confusion in our countries, the more advantageous for them. Divide and conquer - the age old strategy.
Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan winner of India's highest civilian award the Bharat Ratna is still a great hero of the freedeom struggle for Indians with many streets, markets and instituitions named after him
Jab congress ne British pressure me NWF se congress ko withdraw karne ka decision liya tha.. Tab Abdul Gaffar Dilli me Aa kar Gandhi ji ke Samne Roye the.. Ki Aapne Hame Bhediyon ke Bichh chhord diya hai..
The correct answer is both are considered heroes of pashtun, i mean for Taliban from Afghanistan who are pashtuns called him a hero in response to khwaja asif statement, in Pakistan, i would much prefer bacha Khan to be considered our hero despite our state narrative
I still consider Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan as one of the greatest leaders in the Indian subcontinent. India, Pakistan and Bangladesh have not remained together because of political machinations and manipulation. Colonial interperetration of history divided us divided us. People like Romilla Thapar initially. Today it's the quest and greed for power that creates this animosity. Not RELIGION. The West and China would build on this and we forget the thousands of years that all coexistence in United Bharat - inspite of a millenia of foreign conquests. Let us accept each other’s religions and become one again.
Thank You for such a great explanatory video. I wish every Pashtun understands it and think the way Bacha khan used to think. Oh dear Pashtuns Follow Bacha khan’s vision. Bacha Khan, My Leader ❤️
29:34 jab bantware ko Congress ne man liya to unhone kya kaha dekhi Khan vehemently protested against Congress when in June 1947 agreed to the partition of the country. He told Gandhi in June 1947 after CWC meeting, "We Pakhtuns stood by you and had undergone great sacrifices for attaining freedom. But you have now deserted us and thrown us to the wolves…The decision about partition and referendum in the Frontier Province was taken by the High Command [Congress] without consulting us…Sardar Patel and Rajgopalachari were in favour of partition and holding referendum in our province. Sardar said I was worrying over nothing. Maulana Azad was sitting near me. Noticing my dejection he said to me, 'you should now join the Muslim League'. It pained me to find how little these companions of ours had understood what we had stood for and fought for all these years."
we were taught about Bacha Khan in school with reference to the Indian Independence Movement, don't know if he is still in the current books, but everyone my age knew about him
Who says he wasn’t but looting other nation was the culture and norm nothing to do with if Hindus were strong would do the same and British did the same mahmood Gaznavi had 3500 Hindu soldiers and 7 Hindu generals in his army
Bacha Khan and mahmood Ghaznavi both are heroes for pashtuns .your method of comparison 2 giant personalities from different time of history and then portraying one against the other. it seems like you’re trying to justifying Khawaja Asif narrative of distorting historical pashtun heros is villains ?
It's amazing how my fellow Indians will want to speak like intellectuals judging Pakistan, when our own country is turning a hellhole!!! Can't handle criticism? Bye, Felicia!! 👋🏻
Maybe you can't. Our country is getting net-net better. But we might have different perspectives. I'm open to every view. Only intolerant views are an issue, as per karl popper.
@ I didn't. I think understanding isn't your strong suite. I judge every country, and my final line was literally being okay with not only my country's but my own criticism. Brain mein thoda zor do, you'll get it, I believe in you. He didn't even put his real name on these comments which made me write maybe he can't stand criticism. I made sure I wrote "maybe" and that means I can't be certain of the reservations he might have had.
Frontier Gandhi mein where does Hindu Muslim come from. Whole India has great respect for him. He fought for our freedom and he’s our Bharat Ratna. Come out of your binary thoughts about Indians Shezad.Apj Abdul Kalam is also our hero. He also became our president. Anyone who keeps their nation India above their religion is our hero
The man who opened 130+ schools 100 years ago and change PakhtunKhwa dynamics.
The man who spent 37 years of his life in prison but never compromised on his Principles.
The man who presented and followed Philosophy of NonViolence 100 years ago when everyone was busy in WW-1 and WW-2.
He stood against patriarchy. His voice always echoed for underprevilged classes.
This man prevented Hindu-Muslim riots in Peshawar through his wisdom.
The wisdom which is now desired, has been given by him a century ago.
This is Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan aka Bacha Khan !
He was also against Partition of India. He stood with INC till the end.
Bacha Khan is revered by my generation of Indians.
Yes Bhai khan Sahab is our hero, we studied him in our school history books in India.
Yes
@@Football-Pundit-n9myes cos he wanted to make Pukhtunistan cos pakhtunkhwa was a Bufferzone between Afghanistan nd India rest i will tell u someday if we talk on voice man cos it will be long if i type here😂. More love u bro from Pashtun boy ❤
Indian Government awarded Khan Abdul Gaffar khan Bharat Ratna award.We Indian has lot of respect for Frientier Gandhi.
Very True.....
Absolutely 👍
❤
❤❤❤❤
Yes Baccha Khan is our Hero. I respect him more than Gandhiji. Khan saheb never wanted division of India. He said if u r going to create Pakistan then we need separate Pakhtunistan for Pathans. It did not happened so he said, “aapne humko bhediyoke samne dal diya”
Today Somnath stands tall and ghazni is *ahem ahem*. Karma spares none.
കൊള്ളക്കാരുടെ അവസ്ഥ അങ്ങനെ ആണ്
Ghazni ki tabahi main Pakistan ka haath hai. Nothing is black and white unfortunately
Phir se toobe ko taiyyar hua hai Somnath. 😂😂
@aadilansari5997 on what basis
@@binurajs somnaath 800 saal tak banjar tha. Ab kuch picchle 80 saal se abaad hai. Jab iske andar phir se sona chaandi jama ho jayegi tab hum ghazi ise todney pohonch jayenge.
We Indians study Abdul Gaffar Khan in schools. Shocking to know Pakistanis don’t study about him.
Where when? Name class and chapter
In India every child knows about Badshah Khan, known more here as Sarhadi Gandhi. I don't remember the class now but we I had read about this best human being in my school. @@navneetparmar3084
@navneetparmar3084 I remember learning about him in class 7 or 8 CBSE NCERT syllabus back in 2014 but it could be just the teacher and not text. But I vividly remember him and the nickname lol.
I read about Frontier Gandhi during class 9-10 history in West Bengal's State board.
@@govuxyz I remember studying about him in text as well.
I am old and fortunate enough to have met the GREAT BACHA KHAN in Delhi. My father who had known Bacha Khan from pre-partition times, took me to seek his blessing when he visited India. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
❤❤❤❤❤
❤️
Bacha Khan told Gandhi in 1947 " you have thrown us to the wolves"
@@judhajitsarkar1852Gandhi ji himself felt betrayed. He was not a party to Partition, in fact he refused to even participate in the independence ceremony and celebrations in August 1947. He went away to Noakhali in Bengal to fast and quell the Hindu Muslim riots there.
Respect❤
Your conclusion that invasion is a far right narrative is questionable. Shehzad, I understand that you may not be able to visit India, but there is a very lived and evidential history even till date where you can see the destruction of temples. In cases where the structure itself could not be damaged, the figures of the Deity were beheaded. And this is not restricted to a certain region of India but rather is very systemic across temples in the south and even more so in the North. So hence I would be very mindful if I were you to say that invasion is just a colonial narrative and is not a lived reality of the times being discussed
Invasion by whom is what he is saying, lol you gobar bhakts don't even watch his full video properly, usne Kaha ghaznavi lutera tha, air Uske destruction ki, masala ya hai ki tum jaahil andhbhakto ko har Muslim mai ghaznavi nazar aata hai, aur har koi tumhare hisaab se forcefully convert hua hai, history itni simple nhi hai
He doesn't want to see the gyanvaapi one side wall of temple under masjid
All old temples hampi, kailash ,ect all the structures are been crashed he doesn't see 🙈
Quit this victim narrative. The Northern part of the subcontinent was invaded by numerous tribes. Some conquered large territories, ruled and stayed. Some looted and went back. That’s what was the tradition those days.
@ABHI-7111 you are absolutely right, I have seen the pictures of those temples and as a Muslim I can only say that I am extremely sad for that. Islam did not asked muslims to do that. What mulsjms did in the course of history is mostly what Islam prohibited. Again, I am extremly sorry about all those barbarian act done by the Muslim invaders.
Thank God those walls are intact to show the hypocrisy of us (muslims).
Bhai Muslim invaders could not destroy all temples because of Rajputs, Marathas and Sikhs and Muslim rulers wanted to rule with the help of these rajputs Marathas warriors. Most of the Sardars in Mughal army’s were Marathas and Rajput like, Mirxa raje, Shahaji and many others. These guys protected Hindus and their temples
Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan was great freedom fighter and most sensible pashtun of his time. We must be proud of him. My Salutes to him.
Yes 🙌
Talked with fellow students about Bacha Khan, was shocked when noone knew about him.
We definitely need to know more about our national heroes.
Kudos to u❤❤
❤️❤️❤️
As an Indian , I read about Frontier Gandhi as a child
Trollers are far right 😂😂😂😂...
Wah wah bhai wahh
But but but Romila thapar far left nhi hai😂😂😂😂
Bahut he rational opinions hai apke sir😂
By now I feel sad for indians who still hope any.. I mean literally ANY pakistani soo called self proclaimed intellectuals will go any further than romilla thapar. Please my countrymen just be a spectator... Don't waste your energy for anything else.
@@ms10J23 Who wasn't a Lootera in South Asia?? Why does no one talk about the Biggest looters from the northwest ( current Pakistan) like Chandragupt Maurya, Kushans, etc, who always looted and plundered current India ( minus Chinese Burmese regions of Northeast India captured by the British) . Mauryans alone killed 30 million gangajamnis. They didn't know what Hindu, hindusthan Bharat or India was. Ask South Indians. They hate the Indus valley and its kings and refused to call themselves " Hindus" ( a name given by persians to ppl of Indus Sindh) until Indra Gandhi bombed Tamil Tigers twice. Both India and Pakistan are teaching lies to their kids. South Asia is a region like Europe and never a natural country. It has dozens of historically, culturally, religiously and linguistically sepearted nations. Whoever united it had to go through each nation's blood bath via sword and gun. Even now, both countries will disintegrate without the British given army and guns. There was no Hindusthan before ghouri and no India before British. Bharat is a lie concocted in late 1800's and is not verified by any Western, Japanese, Russian or Israeli historian.
@@AbhishekTiwari-d6u
He doesn't realise whole Pakistan is right wing..ye smartly Indian audiance ko attract karne ke liye ghori ghazni ko gaali deta hai aur baad me kahega unka koi religious motivation nahi tha .. we all know how chisti of ajmer came here and spread Islam.. slaughter cows .. married with girl won in battle.. these bastards can't hide history easily.
Sanghi log apne id kyon nahi reveal karte? Sharm aati hai.
Not shocked, comment section is filled with Pajeet Npcs
Having said that Romilla Thapar, a Nehuruvian, Left, Marxist, Colonial and Anti Hindu Historian has crafted a Historical perspective that downplays the Islamist aggression and an inherent Violent Ideology where Kuffars were to converted and eliminated derived from Al Kitab....In this way Shahzad is in Denial Mode while underplaying destruction of Hindu Temples which happened extensively and was the norm.
@@PrashasyaGautam Don't sympathise with romila she is not historians
@@PrashasyaGautam he says 'they didn't destroy all temples in India' - when literally there is virtually no major storied/historical hindu temple left in all of north India after muslim conquest. Just because they focused on the biggest temples and the smaller ones escaped their wrath doesn't mean what they did was not bigoted. Just because important temples in the south and east survived doesn't give them any brownie points.
Right Wing hate agenda has brianwashed gullible, educated class. India's RW propganda by RSS and its ilks is nothing to do with Hinduism, just same way as Islamists in Pakistan has nothing to do wtih Islam. RW agenda is just to spread Hatred , Divide Society for grabbing Power . RW are no different from Ghausris and Ghazanvis. RW extremistse are preaent in all Religions- Hindus, Muslis, Christians, Sikhs, Jews etc. These religious extremists are real threat to humanity
For Romila Thappar all Invaders like Ghazani Ghauri and Babar came India to do charity and welfare 😂 Aurangzeb was most secular and bright of them !
What about aryan and why bramin wrote allah is and and told akbar there bramhin brother
There was no India before British and no Hindusthan before Ghouri. South Asia is region like Europe and not a natural country. Maurya, Kushan from NorthWest ( current Pakistan) have looted and plundered gangajamuna. Mauryans alone killed 30 million gangajamnis. They didn't know what bharat, India hindu or hindusthan was. Ask South Indians
@@sabrinakhan8217
So when the British came to the Sub-continent, they came here under an enterprise, a company if you will in 1601...
What was its name again?
The "British Afghanistan to Burma Company"?
No, no, was it the "British South Asia Company"?
No, no, no was it the "British Europe like continent in Asia" Company or was it "The Barwe Sageer" Company?
Never mind, they came here to learn "Ganga Jamuni Tehzeeb", lol.
And that's actually the first time I'm hearing the name of a set of people called "Gangajamunis". Did they just eat gullab jamoon and nothing else?
I'm sure the Greeks when they coined the term Hindus, were high on pot. And Huen Tsang was doing Kung Fu when he wrote about Bharath.
@Indus720, 😡Here is an example of an idiot….. even after listening to the podcast, still repeating the sanghi/ islamist mentality…. Have some mercy on Indian civilisation and make an effort to read books and real history….
@@sabrinakhan8217Go get a reality check. Bharatiya civilization goes back 10000 years, known as the land bound by Indus river, the Himalayas and the ocean ( a fact difficult to digest for those who believe in cruel joke played on mankind in the sixth century arising out of hallucinations due to heat and mirages in a sandy desert...) as far as INDIA goes see the time line..Year c. 350 - c. 290 BC, Megasthenes was an ancient Greek historian, diplomat and Indian ethnographer and explorer in the Hellenistic period. He described INDIA in his book Indika.
Year 476 AD End of Roman Empire.
Year 927AD formation of Kingdom of England.
Year 1451AD Christopher Columbus embarks on a voyage to find a sea route to INDIA.
Year 1600AD British East INDIA company was founded.
Year 1648AD the idea of a nation-state / the rise of the modern system of states, often called the “Westphalian system” emerged.
Year 1707 AD formation of United kingdom.
In a maratha history mentioned that the door of somnath was came back by Maratha sardar Mahadaji shinde way before british colonization of India
😊😅
Are you joking 😃
Don't make such history
Before maharaja Ranjit Singh no one attacked afganistan part or pashtun part they use to come and attach india
The door is still there.
Ye "atleast train to di" wala mindset India me bhi tha kuch saal pahle tak. Now people have realised we were the richest geography in the world, now divided into 3 countries and utterly poor.
Yahan say bhi mai ye mindset Khatam karo ga
@ThePakistanExperience Jab tak khud ko is geography ka nahi maanoge or khud ko turks or arabs bologe, impossible.
Culture > Language > Nationality > Religion
@@manishjoshi1798bhai saray turk nhi hai or ager iss Geography ky hai bi per bharat jasay nhi hai alag hai
@@affaqmalik5876 bharat jaise nahi hain matlb?
We love Ahmad shah Abdali & Bacha Khan because Abdali give us freedom and he is the founder of Modern Afghanistan & Bacha Khan give us knowledge about politics.
As Pakistan is a federation & I'm Pashtun from Pakhtunkhwa, so i hope that u must respect our heroes . If u can't praise them than don't blame our Ancestors and Heroes.
Much respect for you Shehzad ❤
My hero is usa because he gives us technology😂
Being a pashtun Salute to you, brother.
An eye-opening video for all pashtun youth who blindly follow establishment pro narrative since 1947. It started from jamat e islami and now pti.
But the positive thing that a small fraction of pashtun youth has started studying Bacha khan.
❤️🙌
app be kise or ka batooo ma akar kahtay hoo sahi karah hai.Afsooos hai tum pa history ko sahi study karo pir patwa Dana app qasier Raja ka video dek pir pata chalaga 🎉🎉🎉
@@ThePakistanExperiencehistory ko sahi study karo bhaie
Im Pakistani yousafzai Pashtun ...Bacha khan is our hero ....not Mahmod ghaznavi never. Mahmod was against Pashtuns ....
Perfect, you are right. He plundered Pakistanis first as it was on his way. But Pakistanis don’t understand it.
Even gaznvi was a turk not belong to our land of Undivided India and pashtun is our brother about pashtun mention in rig veda in a battle of ten king
In mahabharat this area is know aa Gandhar famous queen of mahabharata queen ghandari and his brother shakuni mahabharat is not about Hindu stories it's also a stories of pashtun and bro religion change hone se ancestors or blood change nhi hota hai
Even gaznavi wasn't a Pashtun he was a Persian who lived in Ghazni
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Pustun were never hindus for your kind info@@anandian1995
There is GAFFAR Market in Delhi & PM Modi Bows down & touched his Feet ❤
BHARAT RATNA Awarded ❤
I suggest you call Vikram Sampath for a podcast on Indian history and the perspective of the Indian right. It will be fun to watch.
I don't think three podcaster will dare to call Vikram Sampath, Meenakshi Jain, J Sai Deepak etc to his show... they will school him proper in Bharatiya history and that of the subcontinent...
Nahi bulayega , Can't pelt his propaganda then 😂
He's trying to rectify Pakistan's identity crisis , Although through another farce Lol
Vikram sampath is just another RSS mouthpiece . nothing else
Do you really think this shallow people can handle J Sai Deepak.... You guys really have very high hopes.
@muzzamkhan very true and the secular history was written by rahul gandhi.
Great video as always. I would suggest a great book 'Facts are Facts' - by Khan Abdul Wali Khan, the son of Khan Bacha Khan.
🙌
Omg... The most awaited video for me ❤.... Hats off 🎉
❤️
I am truly speechless.....salute to u.....from an older brother from KP 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 .......waiting for u to visit.....plz let us know in advance.....meeting u will be an honor beyond words ...❤❤❤
❤️🙌
Plz don't call KP.what is KP? Plz Pakhtoonkhwa Bola awr lekha karien.Ku NWFP SE KP pi aye.ANP NI shanahat ki liye buht Kuch Kiya
The army served software inside your mouth, your Ghaznavi and Osama bin Laden will also be called poor and helpless 😂@@ThePakistanExperience
I rarely comment on TH-cam videos but Shehzad I want to thank you on behalf of my Pukhtoon community, most of whom will hate you for speaking up for them. They don't realize the fact that Bacha Khan ka vision pukhtoon society k liye ek blessing tha, but we didn't live up to it.
🙌❤️
Kyuki musalmano ne sare mandir nahi tode isliye koi religious angle nahi hai
Bhai us hisab se to israel ne abhi sare phalestini bhi nahi mare
To ye genocide ka rona kyo rote ho
Mahmood Gajanvi didn't took away Doors. He had nothing to do with Islam. Rather he looted Gold Or Silver. Easy to be taken away.
I think jinnah is the only one who is undebatably respected by every Pakistani. From Bangladesh
Lol, Undebatedly..🤣🤣
@@PrashasyaGautam All of them had good and and qualities.
@@PrashasyaGautam Although some extremist hindus dislike gandhi but every Pakistani loves jinnah
Indira Gandhi bhi Abdul Gaffar se unke Aakhri Dino me, hospital me milne Gai thi .. Jab unka Bharat me Ilaj chal raha tha..
14:03 Maqsad to wahi tha .. Tabhi aaj Iran , Afganistan,pakistan musalmaan hogaya .. Hindus ke resilience ke kaaran bach gaye .. nahi to Persia jaise bade empire , Byzantine jaisa bada empire me sabko convert ker diya
Gaznavi converted Pakistanis to islam from Hindu by force and now he is hero for Pakistanis. What an irony
He had nothing to do with Islam, had hindus in his armies like everyone else, open your eyes
@@Justpeace-j7wnope, he never had hindus in his army. That was shah jehan who had hindus in his army.
@@Justpeace-j7warmy me hindu hone ka mtlb ye thode hua ki antihindu kaam nhi kiya h
Pakistan aur afganistan ko musalman bnne k kaam ghaznvi ne ki kiya h aur by force kiya
@@Justpeace-j7w who told you that he had Hindus in his army? And he had nothing to do with Islam. His father converted Pathans in Pakistan to Islam. Read history from proper sources. Unless forcibly converted noone will change their religion, percentage of people willingly converting is less than 1%. So it is either force or Money. Christians convert using money. I am from Goa, Christian missionary converted poor Hindus in 18th century just for a bag of rice. They tried force too, so my family fled to Mumbai
@@yashpednekar331 we fought Mughals, we fought British, and when entire India laid their weapons in 1857, only one nation stood, go and search, anglo Indian wars , from 1857-1947, imagine what percentage would be fought of the list would be Pathan (Pashtuns), it was almost entirely our struggle, just search and tell me, you really think people can force us for conversion?
Imagine making someone hero just because you are jealous of hindus 😂😂
Imagine making someone hero just because you are jealous of Muslims.
That's Savarkar for you bhakts.
@@DataCrusade1999i don't like savarkar and his ideology but the point is savarkar was indian. But these Gauri Gaznavi ,Babar and abdali etc were invaders likes Britishers
We feel proud to have you Thank You❤
❤️
This guy in future: Sunnis are breaking shia's mosque but wo koi Shia Sunni masla nahi hai 😃
Far right kare to hindu muslim
British kare to hindu muslim
Lekin invader kare to .. are wo to lutere the .. hindu muslim kuchh nahi tha ..😂
As a pashtoon i accept ghaffar khan my idiol rather than quiad e azam and i really appreciated his non violence policy
Wonderful piece of work Shehzad.
One thing you missed about Bacha khan’s life were his religious beliefs which are often overshadowed by his secular and nonviolent movement. He had a wonderful relationship with the muslim clergy or alim deens of that time. This aspect of his life is often times overlooked.
❤️🙌
Very true.
This guy should do a Podcast on Middle eastern colonialism (Turko Persian) as well - How the Moghuls and sultans suppressed locals like imposed their language and taxed non muslims .. Why only British colonialism if it suits the narrative 😂
Good Work Shahzad! 👏 Bacha Khan devoted his life to promoting nonviolence, education, and social reform, striving tirelessly for the upliftment of marginalized communities and the unity of the subcontinent. Meanwhile,Mahmood Ghaznavi is often mistakenly glorified as a hero, despite his invasions being driven by plunder and personal ambition rather than the noble ideals of justice or cultural advancement.
I think I'm gradually being derived towards FOMO on this seminal series of your 😅 💯👏
❤️🙌
Being a Punjabi, didnt know any thing about Bacha khan before this video. Thank you for the enlightment
Lol this isn't enlightenment but awareness😂😂😂 Shehzad isn't Buddha, he's Shehzad.
❤️
@@AbhishekG026Oh indian ko tab pasand hai kou ky woh phalay Pakistan mukhalif thy or woh bangaldesh ko itna dhoor nhi rakhna chahtay thy humay maloom hai.per itna zikar nhi hota
Bacha khan says he's ancestors was hindu he was muslim but he give her sister to hindu for marriage he dont accept islam he was liberal thats why this liberals support another liberals
آپ غدار نہیں آپ سچے پاکستانی ہیں۔ جو سچا محب وطن ہوتا ہے اسے تنقید کا بھی حق ہوتا ہے۔ آپ سندھی ہو کر ہم پنجابیوں کے لیے بھی کام کر رہے ہیں شناخت کے بحران کو ختم کرنے کی کو شش کر رہے ہیں جس کی ہم پنجابیوں کو سب سے زیادہ ضرورت ہے۔ شکریہ جناب۔ اللہ آپ کی حفاظت فرمائے۔ آمین
Ameen
Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan was a great person & leader.
Great insan.
Yes
It’s with sadness that his legacy has lost. Bacha Khan was a true son of the land and a Hero. Whose legacy shouldn’t be forgotten.
And I also believe that regional languages should not be subjugated; instead, all major regional languages like Punjabi, Pushto, Baluchi, and Sindhi must be declared official national languages, and all the monetary notes and official documentations should follow that suit too. It is strange that our currency notes are in a language which most of the people at their respective demographics don’t really understand; they just use it.
Yes
Islamic conquest/ destruction of sindh is so complete that we don’t even know what script was used to write Sindhi before arabic marauders won sindh. It is so spectacular that there are historical records of a grand Sun temple somewhere in Multan. These iconoclasts devastated that temple so badly, archeologists couldn’t even find the exact location of that temple anymore. They didn’t even leave any ruins.
For writing Sindhi language the script used was lohanki or hatwanki and is similar to Brahmi script
Sindhi lohanas community converted to form memon community
There are Punjabi/ kutchi / Sindhi lohanas and they are closely related with khatri community
All Sikh gurus were Khatri themselves
Jinnah was vaishnavite lohana with surname thakkar which actually comes from takkar province of Afghanistan
When mohammad bin Qasim attacked today's sindh , it was ruled by a pushkarna Brahmin king dahir sen whose forefather chach Brahmin had married the widow of lohana Dynasty king rai and took over the kingdom from lohana Dynasty ruler
Romila Thapar ko Sanskrit Nahi aati, Toh Wo Indian History ki Historian kese Ho Sakti hai ? Yah ek Simple Logic hai ! Opinion har koi de sakta hai, Lekin wo Historian nahi ban jaega
Aiseu toh kaafi philosophers ko greek Persian nhi aati thi, toh kya Woh philosopher nhi rahega, translation naam ki cheez suni hai gawar
You do know that linguistics field of study exists and they do work with historians regularly.
@DataCrusade1999 You cant be a historian with reading a translation.
Ignorant sanghi remark.
@@kalidasswaminathan4341 Its a Logic, How can you be a historian of Ancient India without knowing the Sanskrit, Tamil and Prakritik.
Bacha Khan was called Frontier Gandhi, I guess?
I read about him in our history textbooks.
Yes
Well, Shezad. It was an interesting discussion. But you should consider reading other great Indian historians, too, like Jadunath Sarkar, R.C . Majumdar, Manu Pillai ( which you called on your podcast earlier), Dr. Vikram Sampath, etc, to know more nuanced history.
Because Thaapar's lack of Sanskrit Knowledge also lacked many details in her books. You can't get everything right just by Romila Thaapar's books.
I am glad you called Dr. Janaki recently for Savarkar discussion, and I really liked that. Because unlike her historians from Romila, Thaapar made Savarkar clear Fascist villain because they didn't study Marathi literature written by Savarkar. They couldn't study Sanskrit either.
🤣
@ThePakistanExperience why ? 😅😅 I couldn't get that.
@dharmeshparikh7837 when they don't have answer then then laugh at u. I think u know the answer. He is a leftist so why he will agree with anything that favours right
So, Dharmesh bhai, what did you learn from this interaction with a Pakistani "leftwinger" ?
@@fakebatli frankly, I don't know what he is trying to convey here by laughter emoji instead of proper reply or sentence. 🤷🤷 is he making fun of my initial message, or he doesn't agree or anything he wants to convey, which I couldn't understand.
Sir ❤❤, We pukhtoon Love Bacha khan and his Ideology. Thank you for making this video.
❤️
We Indian also love him yaar unke dil me dard tha jab india aaye tab kaha tha m wo yahan nhi khna chta shazad knows very well k aap ne Hume...... .....
@@ravigodara887indian ko tab pasand hai kou ky woh Pakistan alag karnay ky mukalif thy shuro mai but woh bangladesh ko dhor rakhnay ki waja sy tha woh kahtay thy bas
@@affaqmalik5876 galat padha hai aap ne Pakistan alag ho gya koi baat nhi lekin Pakistan apne aap ko nhi Sambhal saka bhai her baar apni land rent per de di kisi cheez pe dhayaan nhi diya akhir aaj haal dekh lo Hume khushi nhi dukh hota hai ye dekh kr Pakistan bhi grow krey hum bhi ye he chate han education sari ki sari jhooti padhai gyi zia ne barbaad krne me koi kasar nhi rakhi or aaj modi bhi zia ke raah per india ko le jana chata hai but hamara congratulations bhot mazboot hai sab ko equal rakhta hai iss liye Hume dar nhi ke zia wala kaam yahan hoga han chand pagal han jo history ko nhi Mante
love this series . much much respect shahzad .Just not narrating history but also analyzing how it was shaped and affects are collective conciousness about pushtoons. This is why i pakistan experience is in a league of its own.
❤️🙌
North India ke to lagbhag sare mandir tord diye .. south India me bache rahe ..
this duffer has no idea what he's talking about
U r r8.
Aissa lgta h isko history' ki nhi padi h bss apna dukaan chlana h.
Sare am jhut bol rha h@@AKumar-co7oe
Shehzad you should read J Sai Deepak's book
He doesn't read if he read he will be shamed
I have read and all his books are based on what if it didn't happened what if that happened and he builds all his arguments on history that never existed alternate history kind of bs , all he says he are taught wrong and don't tell what is real history then
@@navneetparmar3084lol. He clearly states the sources in his book. Looks like your librandu rear got fired due to his truth Bombs 😂😂
Both Khan Abdul Gaffar khan and Khan Abdul Jabbar Khan were great leaders forgotten by history and buried by their contemporaries to ensure their ideas, ideals and perspectives wouldn't drown out their own. Hope these two get their due someday soon in Pakistan too.
Yes
We in India still remember Dr Khansahab very well. One of Delhi's most popular markets is named after him.
@@kalidasswaminathan4341😊 also khan market was established for refugees and it honours both brothers kyuki NWFP mein Khan Abdul Jabbar Khan ki govt thi aur unhone Jo Jo idhar aana chahta tha unke liye raasta diya ensuring no harm on his watch. Vaise I do think itne comments ke baad lag bhag har koi jaanta hai yeh cheezein
Ghaffar Khan was a great hero of subcontinent whereas Mahmood Ghaznavi was an extreme robber who looted India and went back leaving behind his remanants.
Bacha Khan was an inspiration for all of us
Yes
Dear Shehzadbhai, greetings from Mumbai, India. Very interesting issues raised about distorting or weaponising History or narrative to push hidden agenda of one particular way of thinking, which is "Right Wing, Majoritarianism". my few comments :
1. Pakistani State has weaponised "History" and set agenda for people so that dissenting voices / diverse views / liberal inclusive thinking is crushed. Homogenisation is pushed in the name of "national security, national indentity etc etc "
2. Pakistan failed miserably in the Homogenisation exercise in all areas- Security , Unity , economic development , Cultural growth etc. People of Pakistan have been torn away from their roots of diverse identities of Pasthuns, Sindhi, Balochs, Punjabis, Seraikis etc.
3. India was fortunate to have leaders like Pandit Nehru, Patel, Azad, Dr Ambedkar, Prasad , Shastri who gave a Constitution encouraging equality, diversity , tolerance etc. We celebrated Unity in Diversity , which kept diverse Bharat unitted for last several decades.
4. Because if liberal, tolerant State , India allowed rise of Right Wing and Left Wing to not only sprout but also flourish. Because of Liebral constitution we have seen RW groups like RSS, Hindu Mahasabha and its associates to survive and thrive in India. These RW groups , instead of celebrating the Diversity and learning from Pakistan about how not Homogenise the masses, have gone opposite way. RW / Hindutvawadis are just copying actions of Islamist Pakistani's RW agenda of majoritarianism . Hindutvawadis have failed in last 10 years on all fronts - Economy, Employment generation, Society unity , Rise in Communalilsm, poor neighbourly relations etc.
5. Right Wing agenda around world can be phenoenon of few years, but it bound to fail in long run ( sadly adter destroying the economic and social progress ). Regards
شکر ھے ھمارے پٹھان بھاٸیوں کو اب یہ احساس ھوچلا بہت ھوچکا اب لڑاٸ جھگڑوں کے بجاۓ امن کی اشد ضرورت ھے
Nonetheless, Mahmud of Ghazni was an extraordinary person. Persians and Tajiks have a better appreciation of him. On the other hand, Pakistanis and Indians have reduced him to a pissing contest. Reducing him to simply a "looter," as many feeble-minded people do, is an injustice to his history
Khudai Khidmatgars exhibited the spectacle of liberation theology of Islam. It demanded better distribution of land and decried the large estates. Khan wanted to build a socialist society.
Ghaffar Khan was a great secularist.
"It was in Punjab jail that he formed friendship with Hindus and Sikhs and studied the Hindu scriptures, especially the Gita and the Granth Saheb, the Holy Book of the Sikhs."
And yet he remained one of the bigger land holders in the area. The hypocrisy is that it starts from home, where his ancestors are still one of the wealthiest families amongst the Pashtuns he was so driven to liberate.
Thank you for making a video on this. Baccha khan us underrated. While radical muslims like to simp for bisexual ghazni. Also baccha khan also took inspiration from Hindu scriptures too.
🙌
asking my cousins and friends, who are all graduation-level students, if they had ever heard of someone called "Bacha Khan." It pains me to see "none of them even knew this name", Pakistan erased a hero from its history just bcz bacha khan didn't fit in the colonial sculpture of real Pakistani
Yikes
I went through the podcast. Felt that you took a very strong subject and tried to present just after reading few history books. Romila ji is proved wrong at so many times that now historians don’t take her names that much in Bharat.
Thanks for this Shehzad!
🙌
What a fine podcaster you are Shehzad..! I am far rightist of India. I am convinced by you... Iam starting my journey to become centrist... Thnx sir 🙏🙏🙏
❤️🙌
12:43 Bro , are you implying Invading and plundering India every year was like an annual vacation for Ghaznavi ? 😂
The background music is very distracting.
Thanks for this one Shahzad.
🙌
Ghaffar Khan was a Good Person and he was Hero of Pashtoons only NOT rest of the Pakistan. Please, don't try to make him Hero of rest of People of Pakistan. He is NOT Hero of Muslim Panjabis, Muslim Sindhis and Balochs. And, everyone have their own people to whom they consider as their Hero.
Look at the speeches of Bacha Khan.He was against the creation of Pakistan and he clearly said We pashtoon would be under Punjabis if Pakistan is created. For him his ethnicity matters.We Pakistanis only work for religion irrespective of ethnicity.Bacha khan is a hero for those who work for ethnicity but not for those who work for Islam like Quaid e Azam,Allama Iqbal, Abdul Sattar Edhi, Dr Abdul Salam, Dr Abdul Qadeer Khan and many more.
Our Frontier Gandhi - Gaffar Khan ♥️
❤️
I studied about Bacha Khan in school when I was in 7th or 8th standard. He is really a great man 🫡
China and the West are interested in Pakistan. Not Pakistanis. Ditto Bangladesh. Let's not forget that. The more chaos and confusion in our countries, the more advantageous for them.
Divide and conquer - the age old strategy.
Only Bacha Khan my Hero ❤
❤️
Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan winner of India's highest civilian award the Bharat Ratna is still a great hero of the freedeom struggle for Indians with many streets, markets and instituitions named after him
"That there's some good in this world, Mr. Frodo, and it's worth fighting for".
- Lord of the Rings
Great video as always. History lesson for all. Respect from Bangladesh.
🙌
Jab congress ne British pressure me NWF se congress ko withdraw karne ka decision liya tha.. Tab Abdul Gaffar Dilli me Aa kar Gandhi ji ke Samne Roye the.. Ki Aapne Hame Bhediyon ke Bichh chhord diya hai..
Disagree with Shehzad by quoting facts. He will declare you
- Indian Far Right
- Hindutva
- Gali de raha hai
This was your attempt to disagree with me by quoting facts? 🤣
Im in tears.. thanks a lot bhai
Love you shehzad bhai. keep doing the great work of awareness
❤️
Among the non-violent leaders, I respect Bacha Khan more than any other leader of pre-partitioned India.
The correct answer is both are considered heroes of pashtun, i mean for Taliban from Afghanistan who are pashtuns called him a hero in response to khwaja asif statement, in Pakistan, i would much prefer bacha Khan to be considered our hero despite our state narrative
I still consider Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan as one of the greatest leaders in the Indian subcontinent. India, Pakistan and Bangladesh have not remained together because of political machinations and manipulation.
Colonial interperetration of history divided us divided us. People like Romilla Thapar initially.
Today it's the quest and greed for power that creates this animosity. Not RELIGION.
The West and China would build on this and we forget the thousands of years that all coexistence in United Bharat - inspite of a millenia of foreign conquests.
Let us accept each other’s religions and become one again.
Bravo
Great work. Thank you.
Please share more details of Bacha Khan. His quotes. Life. And work.
🙌❤️
We studied about him... The #frontierGandhi he was very famous due to his non violence ideology like gandhi
Shehzad, Thank you.
🙌
Absolutely right . Shahzad Sir The most important video
🙌
Thank You for such a great explanatory video. I wish every Pashtun understands it and think the way Bacha khan used to think.
Oh dear Pashtuns Follow Bacha khan’s vision.
Bacha Khan, My Leader ❤️
❤️🙌
sirf pashtoon ky hero thy kya or bhai ghaznavi ko apnay hi hero banaya howa hai
29:34 jab bantware ko Congress ne man liya to unhone kya kaha dekhi
Khan vehemently protested against Congress when in June 1947 agreed to the partition of the country. He told Gandhi in June 1947 after CWC meeting,
"We Pakhtuns stood by you and had undergone great sacrifices for attaining freedom. But you have now deserted us and thrown us to the wolves…The decision about partition and referendum in the Frontier Province was taken by the High Command [Congress] without consulting us…Sardar Patel and Rajgopalachari were in favour of partition and holding referendum in our province. Sardar said I was worrying over nothing. Maulana Azad was sitting near me. Noticing my dejection he said to me, 'you should now join the Muslim League'. It pained me to find how little these companions of ours had understood what we had stood for and fought for all these years."
Molana azad🤣🤣🤣🤣
Correction:
37 years jail mai Bacha Khan baba nahi thay blkay eis mai self exile ka time b included hai.
we were taught about Bacha Khan in school with reference to the Indian Independence Movement, don't know if he is still in the current books, but everyone my age knew about him
Mahmud Ghaznavi the real follower of Islam
Who says he wasn’t but looting other nation was the culture and norm nothing to do with if Hindus were strong would do the same and British did the same mahmood Gaznavi had 3500 Hindu soldiers and 7 Hindu generals in his army
@@Rajputnaru007 ok so both of us agree what Mahmud Ghaznavi was following the teaching from Quran. rite
I am lost for words how to thank you Shehzad Bahi. ❤
❤️
Bacha Khan and mahmood Ghaznavi both are heroes for pashtuns .your method of comparison 2 giant personalities from different time of history and then portraying one against the other. it seems like you’re trying to justifying Khawaja Asif narrative of distorting historical pashtun heros is villains ?
It's amazing how my fellow Indians will want to speak like intellectuals judging Pakistan, when our own country is turning a hellhole!!!
Can't handle criticism? Bye, Felicia!! 👋🏻
Maybe you can't. Our country is getting net-net better. But we might have different perspectives. I'm open to every view. Only intolerant views are an issue, as per karl popper.
@@srijandatta287 You just proved his point.
@ I didn't. I think understanding isn't your strong suite. I judge every country, and my final line was literally being okay with not only my country's but my own criticism. Brain mein thoda zor do, you'll get it, I believe in you. He didn't even put his real name on these comments which made me write maybe he can't stand criticism. I made sure I wrote "maybe" and that means I can't be certain of the reservations he might have had.
@@srijandatta287karl papur and enemies of open societies, if you apply him on India, CM yogi would be in jail by now.
It's so refreshing to watch your content, may U be protected.
Do make video on sir ganga Ram too
🙌
Bhai Pakistani pashtoon Bacha khan ko apna hero manega to pakka pashtunistan banega 😂😂😂
Hum pagal nhi hain
Great effort. Pashtoons need to listen these like lectures.
🙌
24:30 very subtle, loving this video
🙌
You only believe what suits your ideology.
You ignore the views of others by calling them extreme right wing.
Yar ... I'm listening to you since 2021. Pr aaj rula diya .
In Pashta we say
شب پرسته په سحر درنه قابض شول
د رڼا مبلغینو څه نیستمن شوئی
سلیم راز
🙏 Thank u Bhai.
❤️
Ustad audio quality ne mera OCD, ADHD sab trigger kardia 😭
🙈
Frontier Gandhi mein where does Hindu Muslim come from. Whole India has great respect for him. He fought for our freedom and he’s our Bharat Ratna. Come out of your binary thoughts about Indians Shezad.Apj Abdul Kalam is also our hero. He also became our president. Anyone who keeps their nation India above their religion is our hero
TRUE ❤