He is incorrect that only sports are segregated by gender. Bathrooms are segregated by gender and that is what drives fear more than anything else. Bathrooms are largely unresolved as well. The rest of what he says is great.
No, he does not "make more sense than anyone". On the contrary, he ignores the real biological difference in sports performance between the sexes. He also ignores the effect of these mythical genders on a major institution of society, the family.
I may disagree with these Others , but as long as I am civil ill think what i want . Its called a thinking, feeling civil person , who can tvunk what i like. Not getting your buttons pushed is a start
I guess Neil isn't concerned about "forced" personal pronouns, stripping top-tier psychologists of their licenses, and the chemical-based transgenderization of children. ... It should all just be about how we "feel."
Jordan Peterson is absolutely not a top tier psychologist. He is a psychologist, yes. Top tier? Not in any lifetime. Any doctor of the human sciences who implies someone should kill themselves is in no way top of anything but a shitpile.
You make it sound as though children are being lined up to be transgenderized. That’s absurd. How long do you want a miserable kid to be miserable until such age as you dictate that it’s ok to be transgender? After breasts develop? And periods start? After a beard is grown? You don’t care about children. You just hate transgenders.
Exactly! Neil appears to be very naive about this matter, which makes sense - as a scientist, he relies on reason and can't wrap his head about all insanity out there...
@johncollins7062 I'm so glad women's sports are so important to you that you spam this into every comment. Really taking care of the big issues there. Cuz yeah, its all about sports...
But it's not JUST sports or people dying their hair or simply what people would prefer to be called. If that's all it is I agree. It isn't. There are real concerns beyond all this. Free expression of who and what they are? So who and what are they? Who am I is a really great question in fact. That question is still thrown around in Philosophical circles. The answer depends on who you ask. So is personal truth THe Truth or your truth. Is truth your truth? Truth is however you see the world? They are free to identify with whatever they want, but must I agree with that identification? But how does it affect you personally is the wrong question. Are you taking away my freedoms for yours?
@@TheNate206 I Am NOT I Am. BUT!!! However!!! I am who I am. R U who U R?? Hey better late than never TheNate206, maybe your higher than supremely higher than highly enlightened brain & mind will capisce/grasp/know/understand what I mean IF You read what is written in Matthew Chapter 8 verse 58.
Didn't you know in ancient Greece men and women competed in the same sports against each other? Yeah they didn't. This is what it sounds like when a used to be scientist turns into an activist.
That is not even close to true. On the contrary: women were not even allowed to watch the Olympics. And not just because the competitors were naked. Now Sparta OTOH, had women exercise, and they too did it naked just like the men, but *not* in the same place. They had to do their exercises where men would not see them. Besides: Sparta was atypical in many ways, so don't hold them up as an example of how Greeks in general did things.
Everything was cool till it became front page news ,these people made it not private spilled onto the public, keep your sexual preference to your damn self and leave children and the rest of us out of it.
Best line - "If we actually live in a free country as we tell ourselves, peoples freedom to behave in any of those ways, should not concern you at all." Yet here we are, with American "patriots" espousing the Bible to demean others while forgetting one of Christianity's basic tenets: Matthew 7: "Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you." Shame on all you Hypo-Christians who seek bigotry over God's ultimate love and acceptance. God would never hate one of his creations, no matter what, but he would condemn one who judges what he has made.
“Judge not by appearance, but judge righteous judgement.” - John 7:24 The Bible specifically tells us that we are to make judgments. Go back and reread the full context of the chapter in which “judge not that ye be not judged” is written and you will find that that comment is written in regard to hypocrisy-as opposed to never judging anyone. Meaning that we must not judge others in hypocritical ways. After all, commonsense dictates that if you’re a parent who just had someone on the child sex offender registry to in next to you-then as a parent you had better start making some judgements. Regardless, by making judgements in order to better point out the sins of others we have the opportunity to help someone turn away from their sins in order to escape an eternal hell. Obviously those who don’t believe that simply means that a very unpleasant eternity awaits.
Christians have always been that way, and especially cruel to gays. They’ve been burning, torturing, and murdering gay people for nearly two thousand years.
Some women want to be in locker rooms and restrooms with the comfort of knowing they aren't sharing them with men. Some of us don't want to use incorrect grammar and pretend something that is not objectively true to accommodate someone else's fetish. Some of us don't want children to be allowed to make life altering decisions before they are old enough to get a tattoo. Some parents want their kids to be free to be kids without being introduced to adult topics. Some of us don't want our tax dollars going to help members of the military get cosmetic surgery to look like the opposite sex. Some of us don't want to pay higher insurance premiums for the same reason.
To the fake concerns of people below, so worried about the integirty fo sports: way to YET AGAIN miss the point. It is the very obsession by sports that even brings this topic into discussion. His point is that it makes no difference to anyone other than the people involved directly, but "Lets protect women's sports!". Uh uh. Sure. Couldn't possibly just admit you don't get it, or you are trained to feel 'oogy' with anything remotely sexual in topic, maybe? The Puritians would be so proud of you.
Boxing has a weight class, chess has a rating, football, baseball, nearly every sport has age, league, whatever, difference.The solution is easy, people are just lazy.
@Debbie338 He is coming to Jacksonville FL.and I was considering going. I have anxiety about driving that far but I'm going to get tickets and go. Its the chance of a lifetime to see 1 of my heroes. I Appreciate your reply.
and then you watch suicide rates and correlations with anxiety disorders. I think people should care about an issue that makes individuals place gender on such an important pedestal that it dictates if they want to live. "shouldn't concern you at all" he's going against both the for and the against sides...
That’s not what he’s saying. He’s saying any issue of sex or gender should not concern you in the sense that it’s none of your business and you should butt out.
@@Debbie338 wrong. He's arguing it in the sense of freedom, ignoring that it's something that abnormally revolves around people with mental health struggles. and if it's "non of your business", again, he's just arguing against both sides on this, it's not productive.
@@yellowblobby I’ve been following the man for twenty years and I’ve seen him in person a few times. I think I have a good idea of how he thinks, but if you want to die on this hill, go ahead.
Time to get real. The "just leave us alone to live our lives" train left the station long ago. Neil doesn't know because he's just another out of touch old celebrity speaking as if he's an authority on everything. I would say he's only an authority on science but he seems to have conceded that one now.
He’s only half correct. This is as relevant in regular lifestyle as it is in sports because it’s trying to establish a position of authority on it’s normalcy and whether or not it should be taught as a valid option to children, who are not old enough to understand how to discern properly regarding such subjects. Correlated to this he says they’re not requiring us to do what they’re doing, however they are pushing requirements on us to accept their ideologies and reinforce them by calling them by their delusional titles (pronouns). He doesn’t see humanity as anything more than a scientific experiment. Thank God the majority still isn’t accepting this nonsense that’s all based on a made up theory that has endlessly failed since it’s initial trials. It’s pretty obvious to discerning, rationally thinking adults which side of understanding gender is a social construct. This whole movement is literally just made up, and has won absolutely no legitimate debate in real trials. In fact it’s only supported the prophecies of major religions as true, which they are ironically validating with their existence. Native American prophecies saw it coming too, with warnings, not fuzzy feelings of positive revolution. Also, Alan Watts- “You could have a plague of ‘virtuous people’, so you gotta watch out for these ‘revolutions of love’. Do you know what i do when i hear about these revolutions of love on the horizon? I buy a gun and lock my door, because i know there’s a storm of hypocrisy coming.”
Greg You may think I'm a sinner and it has no effect on me because that word is only relative to your train of thought and even that is simply subjective. I will see in hell buddy
1 Corinthians 6:9-11 9 Or do you not know that wrongdoers will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolaters nor adulterers nor men who have sex with men 10 nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God. 11 And that is what some of you were. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God. Hebrews 13:4 Marriage should be honored by all, and the marriage bed kept pure, for God will judge the adulterer and all the sexually immoral. Romans 1:26-28 26 Because of this, God gave them over to shameful lusts. Even their women exchanged natural sexual relations for unnatural ones. 27 In the same way the men also abandoned natural relations with women and were inflamed with lust for one another. Men committed shameful acts with other men, and received in themselves the due penalty for their error. 28 Furthermore, just as they did not think it worthwhile to retain the knowledge of God, so God gave them over to a depraved mind, so that they do what ought not to be done.
Your BIIIIG ASSUMPTION AND MISTAKE Mr. Tyson is that those "mentalists" do not require others to behave "that way"! They do!!! Screaming and insisting that everyone shall subject to their view of genders and sexuality and that laws shall be in place to smash anyone who may dare to think differently...
"Why do we even give a sh!+?" EXACTLY!! Well said Doctor.
He is incorrect that only sports are segregated by gender. Bathrooms are segregated by gender and that is what drives fear more than anything else. Bathrooms are largely unresolved as well. The rest of what he says is great.
Unresolved bathrooms no they ain't ... hairy arsed men in dresses wanting to deficate with young girls .... pervert much 🤮🤮🤮🤮
He makes more sense than anyone.
The issue it's very simple. Are fanatic of both sides the complicated
No, he does not "make more sense than anyone". On the contrary, he ignores the real biological difference in sports performance between the sexes. He also ignores the effect of these mythical genders on a major institution of society, the family.
Ew. I smell a .....
Learn how to love people and not live in ancient times mentally
I may disagree with these Others , but as long as I am civil ill think what i want . Its called a thinking, feeling civil person , who can tvunk what i like.
Not getting your buttons pushed is a start
I guess Neil isn't concerned about "forced" personal pronouns, stripping top-tier psychologists of their licenses, and the chemical-based transgenderization of children. ... It should all just be about how we "feel."
Jordan Peterson is absolutely not a top tier psychologist. He is a psychologist, yes. Top tier? Not in any lifetime.
Any doctor of the human sciences who implies someone should kill themselves is in no way top of anything but a shitpile.
birdman7135
Write yore ore. U turr-purr-N-tape shun write!! Write on.
You make it sound as though children are being lined up to be transgenderized. That’s absurd. How long do you want a miserable kid to be miserable until such age as you dictate that it’s ok to be transgender? After breasts develop? And periods start? After a beard is grown? You don’t care about children. You just hate transgenders.
Exactly! Neil appears to be very naive about this matter, which makes sense - as a scientist, he relies on reason and can't wrap his head about all insanity out there...
The content was spot on but the layout of the footage was but a mix of banality.
Neil, you can’t shout this loud enough! It is SO simple yet too many people don’t get it… it’s one of the many ignorant scourges we face today…
@johncollins7062 I'm so glad women's sports are so important to you that you spam this into every comment. Really taking care of the big issues there. Cuz yeah, its all about sports...
This was an excellent point in and of itself, which was ruined in its presentation by an editor with an agenda.
Neil was asked if he watched the game last night.
But if I consider myself special in the universe theeeeeen he’s got a problem with what I identify as
Not a biologist. Paid mouthpiece.
But it's not JUST sports or people dying their hair or simply what people would prefer to be called. If that's all it is I agree. It isn't. There are real concerns beyond all this. Free expression of who and what they are? So who and what are they? Who am I is a really great question in fact. That question is still thrown around in Philosophical circles. The answer depends on who you ask. So is personal truth THe Truth or your truth. Is truth your truth? Truth is however you see the world? They are free to identify with whatever they want, but must I agree with that identification? But how does it affect you personally is the wrong question. Are you taking away my freedoms for yours?
👁am not 👁am, BUT!! 👁am who 👁am same way U R who U R. K peach e?
@@allenelman1233 Which means what?
Get some help.
@@TheNate206
I Am NOT I Am. BUT!!! However!!! I am who I am. R U who U R?? Hey better late than never TheNate206, maybe your higher than supremely higher than highly enlightened brain & mind will capisce/grasp/know/understand what I mean IF You read what is written in Matthew Chapter 8 verse 58.
@@chris_schenkel OK. Not sure who that's directed at.
WRITE YOAR OAR!! THINGalley lew lew yuh.
I shared this.
Didn't you know in ancient Greece men and women competed in the same sports against each other? Yeah they didn't. This is what it sounds like when a used to be scientist turns into an activist.
That is not even close to true. On the contrary: women were not even allowed to watch the Olympics. And not just because the competitors were naked.
Now Sparta OTOH, had women exercise, and they too did it naked just like the men, but *not* in the same place. They had to do their exercises where men would not see them. Besides: Sparta was atypical in many ways, so don't hold them up as an example of how Greeks in general did things.
The editing of this made it unwatchable
Everything was cool till it became front page news ,these people made it not private spilled onto the public, keep your sexual preference to your damn self and leave children and the rest of us out of it.
Neil , so cool . I like you ..
Best line - "If we actually live in a free country as we tell ourselves, peoples freedom to behave in any of those ways, should not concern you at all."
Yet here we are, with American "patriots" espousing the Bible to demean others while forgetting one of Christianity's basic tenets:
Matthew 7: "Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you."
Shame on all you Hypo-Christians who seek bigotry over God's ultimate love and acceptance. God would never hate one of his creations, no matter what, but he would condemn one who judges what he has made.
“Judge not by appearance, but judge righteous judgement.” - John 7:24
The Bible specifically tells us that we are to make judgments.
Go back and reread the full context of the chapter in which “judge not that ye be not judged” is written and you will find that that comment is written in regard to hypocrisy-as opposed to never judging anyone.
Meaning that we must not judge others in hypocritical ways.
After all, commonsense dictates that if you’re a parent who just had someone on the child sex offender registry to in next to you-then as a parent you had better start making some judgements.
Regardless, by making judgements in order to better point out the sins of others we have the opportunity to help someone turn away from their sins in order to escape an eternal hell.
Obviously those who don’t believe that simply means that a very unpleasant eternity awaits.
Christians have always been that way, and especially cruel to gays. They’ve been burning, torturing, and murdering gay people for nearly two thousand years.
There's no religious freedom in the US. Who do you think decides the ratings of movies?
Some women want to be in locker rooms and restrooms with the comfort of knowing they aren't sharing them with men. Some of us don't want to use incorrect grammar and pretend something that is not objectively true to accommodate someone else's fetish. Some of us don't want children to be allowed to make life altering decisions before they are old enough to get a tattoo. Some parents want their kids to be free to be kids without being introduced to adult topics. Some of us don't want our tax dollars going to help members of the military get cosmetic surgery to look like the opposite sex. Some of us don't want to pay higher insurance premiums for the same reason.
@@Lu-MingPan-b5w You have not got a clue! So *what* if a movie is rated? No free speech right is violated by a rating.
To the fake concerns of people below, so worried about the integirty fo sports: way to YET AGAIN miss the point. It is the very obsession by sports that even brings this topic into discussion. His point is that it makes no difference to anyone other than the people involved directly, but "Lets protect women's sports!". Uh uh. Sure. Couldn't possibly just admit you don't get it, or you are trained to feel 'oogy' with anything remotely sexual in topic, maybe? The Puritians would be so proud of you.
❤❤😂😂
Boxing has a weight class, chess has a rating, football, baseball, nearly every sport has age, league, whatever, difference.The solution is easy, people are just lazy.
He’s exactly right. The only place it matters is in sports and there only specifically with trans women. The rest of it irrelevant.
Thanks Debbie,what brings you to a Neil Tyson video? I’m a fan he is a great writer.
@@james9269-8n I’ve been a fan for twenty years. Seen his live shows three times. I love the way he thinks.
@Debbie338 Wow I'm glad you get him. That's actually very cool. I always like to learn something new every day.
@@james9269-8n If you ever get the chance to see him in person, do whatever you have to do to do it.
@Debbie338 He is coming to Jacksonville FL.and I was considering going. I have anxiety about driving that far but I'm going to get tickets and go. Its the chance of a lifetime to see 1 of my heroes. I Appreciate your reply.
and then you watch suicide rates and correlations with anxiety disorders. I think people should care about an issue that makes individuals place gender on such an important pedestal that it dictates if they want to live.
"shouldn't concern you at all"
he's going against both the for and the against sides...
That’s not what he’s saying. He’s saying any issue of sex or gender should not concern you in the sense that it’s none of your business and you should butt out.
I'd like to know the age distribution of gender based suicides.
@@Debbie338 wrong. He's arguing it in the sense of freedom, ignoring that it's something that abnormally revolves around people with mental health struggles.
and if it's "non of your business", again, he's just arguing against both sides on this, it's not productive.
@@yellowblobby I’ve been following the man for twenty years and I’ve seen him in person a few times. I think I have a good idea of how he thinks, but if you want to die on this hill, go ahead.
@@NoferTrunions If you Google “gender-based suicide” you can find out.
Time to get real. The "just leave us alone to live our lives" train left the station long ago. Neil doesn't know because he's just another out of touch old celebrity speaking as if he's an authority on everything. I would say he's only an authority on science but he seems to have conceded that one now.
😐?
something wrong with you
He’s only half correct. This is as relevant in regular lifestyle as it is in sports because it’s trying to establish a position of authority on it’s normalcy and whether or not it should be taught as a valid option to children, who are not old enough to understand how to discern properly regarding such subjects. Correlated to this he says they’re not requiring us to do what they’re doing, however they are pushing requirements on us to accept their ideologies and reinforce them by calling them by their delusional titles (pronouns). He doesn’t see humanity as anything more than a scientific experiment. Thank God the majority still isn’t accepting this nonsense that’s all based on a made up theory that has endlessly failed since it’s initial trials. It’s pretty obvious to discerning, rationally thinking adults which side of understanding gender is a social construct. This whole movement is literally just made up, and has won absolutely no legitimate debate in real trials. In fact it’s only supported the prophecies of major religions as true, which they are ironically validating with their existence. Native American prophecies saw it coming too, with warnings, not fuzzy feelings of positive revolution. Also, Alan Watts- “You could have a plague of ‘virtuous people’, so you gotta watch out for these ‘revolutions of love’. Do you know what i do when i hear about these revolutions of love on the horizon? I buy a gun and lock my door, because i know there’s a storm of hypocrisy coming.”
Sinner repent
Greg You may think I'm a sinner and it has no effect on me because that word is only relative to your train of thought and even that is simply subjective. I will see in hell buddy
1 Corinthians 6:9-11
9 Or do you not know that wrongdoers will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolaters nor adulterers nor men who have sex with men
10 nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God.
11 And that is what some of you were. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God.
Hebrews 13:4 Marriage should be honored by all, and the marriage bed kept pure, for God will judge the adulterer and all the sexually immoral.
Romans 1:26-28
26 Because of this, God gave them over to shameful lusts. Even their women exchanged natural sexual relations for unnatural ones.
27 In the same way the men also abandoned natural relations with women and were inflamed with lust for one another. Men committed shameful acts with other men, and received in themselves the due penalty for their error.
28 Furthermore, just as they did not think it worthwhile to retain the knowledge of God, so God gave them over to a depraved mind, so that they do what ought not to be done.
Sir this is a Wendy's
I don't think there any Bible readers in here man. Your shouting into a vacuum
You’re hilarious. 😂
@@james9269-8n And you are living in quite a vacuum yourself. Why couldn't you at least read it before you scoffed?
@SpectatorAlius Read what? Are you asking about what the Corinthians thing?
Your BIIIIG ASSUMPTION AND MISTAKE Mr. Tyson is that those "mentalists" do not require others to behave "that way"! They do!!! Screaming and insisting that everyone shall subject to their view of genders and sexuality and that laws shall be in place to smash anyone who may dare to think differently...
You ruined a good interview with your childish editing. Thumbs down.