The Hungarian's refusing to fire on the Poles isn't the cause of the bromance, it's just another example of it. It goes back centuries. Hungary and Poland have shared a king in the past, and continually had the back of each other, often when nobody else would help.
Steve Evans I sure it’s cuz since there sandwiched in the middle of Russia’s Germany plus England and France were supposed to back them up then but in the past saw them more as a pawn. Just like other Slavic and Southern European countries.
So true. Actually, Hungarian units offered to fight (yes, fight!) on polish side in the Uprising, only if soviets later recognised this and gave them "allies" status. Which soviets, ofcours, refused. (sorry for any misspelling). Polak, Wegier, dwa bratanki,i do szabli, i do szklanki!
World: Hey Poland who was the best ally in WW2? Poland: Hungary World: but Hungary were with german Poland:Yea World:And you were with allies right? Poland:Something like that World: So who was the best ally? Poland:Hungary World:*visible confusion
@@bm952 Tak, Królestwo Węgier było w sojuszu państw Osi(1941) i nie, Królestwo Węgier odmówiło pomocy w napaści na Polske w 1939, nawet pomogli przechowywać Polskich uchodźców do 1940.(Edit : In English : Yes, Kingdom of Hungary did join Axis Powers in 1941 and no, Kingdom of Hungary refused to help in Invasion of Poland in 1939, they even helped keep some refugees until 1940.)
Eastern Europe, and Poland in particular, did get a raw deal. The problem stems from it not being a two sided war. Russia had their own agenda, and I think the allies were a bit caught between keeping the Russians on-side and actually trying to do the right thing. I think Stalin was hugely underestimated.
@@jordansblabbering6303 Calling warsaw, city at war Voices from underground, whispers of freedom Rise up, and hear the call History's calling to you WARSZAWO, WALCZ!
One thing I can't figure out is: If the poles hate the soviets so much, why would they expect the red army to save their ass when things went bad in Warsaw? ?
@@thecreepnextdoor7560 yeah at the start But the soviets were uneasily allied with Poland during the invasion of Germany They just wouldn't help them because they are power hungry pigs
Hungarian bros! I summon thou to bromance in the comments! Lengyel, magyar - két jó barát, Együtt harcol s issza borát, Vitéz s bátor mindkettője, Áldás szálljon mindkettőre. TBH. Aside from "Lengel" and "Magyar" I have no clue what I just pasted. xd
Can I join in? I'm an Englishman who likes both countries and has survived both Polish and Hungarian weddings! :-D - If it helps my name is Stephen/Istvan, same as Bathory :-D
Don't forget about the Polish boy and girl scouts who, rather than be thrown in jail for being scouts, joined the rebellion and were among the best soldiers during the Warsaw Uprising, even helped in the liberation of the Gęsiówka Camp. Then were tragically slaughtered by the Nazis and USSR.
Oweniee 21 I wouldn’t say short. Poland was an autonomous region in the Russian Empire since the partitions of poland. They had things happen in Poland, even if they were not a real country for that time. That is kinda like saying that Getmany has a shirt history, because they didn’t exist until the mid 1800’s, but thats not the case because the HRE and German Confederation, and Prussia,Bavaria, ect.
@@Litwinus as a 4th generation polish american. I find it pretty triumphant. They (with lithuania) were the largest country in europe for hundreds of years, the largest on eastern europe for even longer. Longest running republic in european history if I remember correctly. Freedom loving and peace loving people. It took all of their neighbors to destabilize them enough to rip them apart. And even after being stateless split between the borders of multiple empires for several hundred years, they grew and prospered and maintained their culture and language and heritage and identity. Incredibly robust group of people and I'm pleasured to be nearly half polish.
No i kozak, wegrzy podpisujcie się pod komentarzem :D Polak Węgier dwa bratanki i do szabli i do szklanki 🇵🇱 Lengyel, magyar - két jó barát, együtt harcol, s issza borát 🇭🇺
on the night of August 3-4, allied planes - one halifax and three liberators - appeared for the first time over Warsaw with the Polish crews of the 1586th Special Squadron. It would not be surprising if it were not for the fact that this drop was the result of insubordination of Polish crews. Despite the intervention of the representatives of the Polish government with the British authorities, the action over the city was not approved by the deputy commander of the Mediterranean Allied Air Force (MAAF), marshal of aviation John Slessor, who claimed that such flights are marked by a high risk (the route was 1,400 km long and led over the Adriatic, Yugoslavia and Hungary, where there was a strong anti-aircraft defense and base of night fighters), and in addition Warsaw is in the operational zone of the Red Army and it is Soviet aviation that should support the insurgents www.polska1918-89.pl/pdf/zrzuty-dla-powstania,1797.pdf
@@Ake-TL if you look on the numbers of killed then communist were much worse than nazis Communist weren't rasistic i will give them that but they operated at basicali same principe as nazis (executions concentration camps etc.)
As a descendant of Poland living in the US, I must say, you're not "demonizing" the Russians... You're just accurately portraying them. And Communism; portraying that properly as well. Both cruel and senseless the Ruskiis and Commies were...
@@arczi1309 who do you think started with the train cars and labor camps... They "relocated" the shit out of people according to ethnic group, especially in Lithuania and Ukraine
When I saw the title, my first thought was the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising, which was a year earlier and - spoiler alert - didn’t go any better for the Poles.
3:35 Yes, indeed, it would be foolish from Soviet perspective, if they weren't liberators... Ah, but the essential question for Russians is, "were they liberators, as they claim, or just a third party to the conflict?" They claim to be liberators... who just a week ago have pompously celebrated the anniversary of liberating a dead ruin and were outraged Poland doesn't celebrate with them. About the same time Paris revolted, and Allies, although it ruined their plans and they weren't fond of the French aspirations in general, dropped everything and rushed to help.
@Tom Fury Soviet radio was calling the Poles to rise up, that's first. Second, so reestabilishing a free state fighting common enemy is somehow directed against the "liberator"? I thought that's the very definition of the word... Third, even if I'm willing to accept that there were valid logistical reasons for halt of Red Army's advance: banning allied aircrafts from landing on soviet airports and destroying Polish resistance units from Eastern Poland heading to support Warsaw is nothing short of proof that Soviets put greater priority on subjugating Poland than on driving the Germans out of it. Such "liberators". If the USA liberated France the same way Soviets did Poland, de Gaulle would die in Alcatraz for "collaboration with Nazis" and Paris would be a pile of rubble instead of world's cultural capital.
I mean I liked the video, but I'm not sure how happy I am with it being comedic. Both of my great grandparents were killed in world war II. One on the German front and the other was an officer who died in the Katyn massacre. My grandmother had her father murdered is still alive.
I appreciate this comment. I definitely understand how topics like this can be difficult, especially for people who have personal connections. I like to use humor as a way to break through those emotions and teach people about these important events. I tend to use humor as a “coping mechanism,” but I fully respect that some people don’t feel that way. Your family has my sincere condolences.
@@арефнар i don't understand what do you mean. This joke is about Russia propaganda spreding lies that Russia dosen't attack any country in history. In this context Soviet Russia with Russian troops.
@@арефнар Because it's true. Lend lease was signed within weeks of the former ally of the Soviets stabbing them in the back and the first convoy reached Murmansk well before the Germans got to Moscow. Stalin himself admitted that it was the surety of lend lease that allowed the Soviets to stop the Germans in the suburbs of Moscow. You can whine all day about the number of Soviet soldiers that died fighting the Germans, it's not the Allies' fault that the Soviets were lousy soldiers with lousy equipment lead by mostly lousy officers and commanded by a supreme leader that didn't care how may he killed. If it wasn't for American trucks delivering bread baked from American wheat powered by American gasoline, the Russians would have lost. I'm not sure that would have been a bad thing.
@@Mishn0 well on that idea every crime comited by soviets is because land lease,that means that lots of unnocent,non-german,civilians died by american arms. Well i like to see that US never changed it's horrible way,if they would only stop to lie.
@@Mishn0 you just right now called 12 millioon misled warriors "louse". You know what it is to be louse? To say a lie and think that this "lie" gives you a kind of "national superiority" and pride. Pride you don't get for the things you didn't do. If USSR did bad, remember that it was a conspiracy of westerners, led by germans and supported by french and british afterwards. We are all equally grateful of those who fought against fascism that now is replenishing under the name of "holy lovely democratic world".
I'm new here, and i like it there, subscribed :D. Honestly, your videos are educational and funny and the Warsaw Uprising is something, that everyone should know about. Poles are great nation and this is sad part of their history, but it shows, that the will of those polish people was really strong and they wanted to help the country and the allies. Big respect to the people that were fighting for their city and against the nazis. Sending Greetings from Czech Republic.
Can you talk later of countries that had somewhat important contributions in ww2 but aren't taught as it need, in example: The Brazilian campaign in Italy by the Brazilian Expeditionary Force
“...an SS brigade comprised of released violent criminals...” Dirlewanger Brigade video please? It’ll be bordering the realm of DEMONETIZATION but you’d be the first channel that’s actually good or known to cover them. Literally the single German military unit that got most of the bad rap for the rest of the SS. Other SS quite literally hated these guys because of how brutal and depraved they were. Anyway, awesome video. The quality has definitely been going up.
"The rest of the ss hated these guys because of how brutal and depraved they were" They were a group comprised of war criminals and murderers who rounded up civilians and organized mass shootings regularly. I doubt there is anything that anyone could do to be hated by the ss unless you were born polish or Jewish.
"Even if you don't help and are just watching as we fighting your 'ally' , it is still better than those who gave false hope. I love you my Hungary brothers" -Some guy in poland
there were supposedly - dont know it if it is a rlaible soruce negotiaitons about hungarian forces literally joining poles fighting in the uprising, but the home army wasn't able to guarantee anything for the hungarians if they soviets came in; hungarians really were tired and wanted to go back home
Dude, great video but why did you upload it just minutes after the latest WW2 episode? :) Seriously though, thanks for popularising this topic. Despite that the video is short and not so serious, you managed to put a lot of information in it (including some often overlooked even in serious discussions about the Uprising). Since you were trying to be fair to the Soviets, I might add that there are some further arguments to be made in their defense (although they all come with counter-arguments to which I will get). 1. The Bagration offensive that brought the Red Army close to Warsaw was already running out of steam before the Uprising and another offensive was starting way down South on the other side of Carpathians, so there were some legitime reasons for Soviets to stop BUT their Polish radio station was still encouraging the people of Warsaw to rise up. 2. That little attempts at assistance to the insurgents in September included not only artillery shelling but also some limited air-drops, the Soviet Air Forces finally stopping letting Luftwaffe do whatever it pleased over Warsaw, and finally even letting some of the Polish troops under Soviet command to cross the river. HOWEVER, the drops were made in sacks without parachutes by low-flying small biplanes, which did little besides endangering the pilots and the troops that crossed the Vistula were far too weak to make any real difference, so it looks like sacrificing some Poles to make a semblance of helping Poles. All it achieved was prolonging the agony of the Uprising because the Home Army broke the first round of the capitulation negotiations, which they just started. The eventual capitulation was BTW kinda a little "success" because the German forces originally got directives from both Hitler and Himmler to literary kill everyone in the rebellious city (they did pretty much that in the districts of Ochota and Wola, which were the first to fall) and they generally weren't in a habit of negotiating with the resistance fighters or taking them as POWs. The bitter Polish resistance eventually made them propose terms of surrender instead. Also, the Western Allies issued a proclamation reminding that the members of the Home Army are in fact allied soldiers (too bad it didn't work on the Soviets).
Another super great comment my guy! Yeah, the Soviets did send the Polish contingent of their army across, but they all got mowed down pretty much. Another cool fact about the Polish surrender is that as several units were leaving the city, the SS lined up to salute them! I thought that that was pretty interesting.
Allies: We will defend Poland 1939 Comes Poland: Where ya at Allies have left the chat also It a me, loyal fan-ario me dude and I still dont have hoi4 ;-;
I swear I read books about uprising that didn’t have all those facts and made it look like poles just foolishly rose up with no plan . And jokes made me craic several times . Good job
Warsaw Uprising: Poles outnumbered and outgunned were supposed to fight a couple of days, fought over TWO months. Fall of France: French had better equipment, more less the same amount of soldiers, and great defensive lines. They were supposed to win, surrendered in ONE AND HALF month. French: wHy cALL uS cOwArDs? wE hAd iMpOrTaNt rOLe iN dEfEaiTinG gErMaNs
Fun fact after the uprising polish soldiers and German worked together to evacuate civilians from the city Some of the civilians ended up in work camps And u failed to mention that ukrainians soldiers were killing polish civilians sometimes against greman orders And German focused on hospitals they were bombing them and they were killing doctors and nurses they also burned alive sick or wounded people form the hospitals
I wish my history teachers were this good. Thanks random youtuber I accidentally stumbled upon while trying to keep my sanity during the coronavirus self quarantine.
I love most of the history channels on TH-cam but this is by far one of my favorites. Also damn I feel bad for Poland like they deserve some serious “WINS” soon to balance out all the monumental historical “L’s” they’ve taken
I’m not sure if it’s appropriate or even how you do it but I love that I learn and laugh (maybe we are both bad people) at historical events........ that really aren’t funny. We have a very similar sense of humor. Keep up the good work!!!!
I knew that Poland was betrayed by her allies during WWII, but I had no clue that the United States played any part in that. That shames me deeply. Though we became closer and closer from 1980 until the present day, which I am very proud of, I see no reason whatsoever for Britain and France to have betrayed her. The Poles are a great, strong, courageous, and freedom loving people and I'm very thankful that President Trump declared them an ally of the United States. 🇵🇱🇺🇸 Great video, as always. Please keep the outstanding videos coming and God bless you, my friend!
![Uprising - The 1944 Warsaw Uprising - Sabaton History 076 [Official]](/img/n.gif)
Try Dashlane for free! Use the VPN to make me the first TH-camr with an audience primarily based in North Korea! bit.ly/39G95XM
You finally got a sponser.
Epicccc
@Caleb Hall Nah. When the sewers start speaking polish
im so happy u finally blew up
I've been here since 1.9k
The Hungarian's refusing to fire on the Poles isn't the cause of the bromance, it's just another example of it.
It goes back centuries. Hungary and Poland have shared a king in the past, and continually had the back of each other, often when nobody else would help.
we often supported each other's uprisings... and dictators
Steve Evans I sure it’s cuz since there sandwiched in the middle of Russia’s Germany plus England and France were supposed to back them up then but in the past saw them more as a pawn. Just like other Slavic and Southern European countries.
So true. Actually, Hungarian units offered to fight (yes, fight!) on polish side in the Uprising, only if soviets later recognised this and gave them "allies" status. Which soviets, ofcours, refused. (sorry for any misspelling). Polak, Wegier, dwa bratanki,i do szabli, i do szklanki!
god dammit man its just a joke
".. often when nobody else would help"
So basically, most of the time of Poland existence?
World: Hey Poland who was the best ally in WW2?
Poland: Hungary
World: but Hungary were with german
Poland:Yea
World:And you were with allies right?
Poland:Something like that
World: So who was the best ally?
Poland:Hungary
World:*visible confusion
Me:I am polish
I dont get it i am stupid
@@bm952Węgrzy są naszymi najlepszymi przyjacielami nawet jest takie powiedzenie.
I dont get it
@@bm952 Tak, Królestwo Węgier było w sojuszu państw Osi(1941) i nie, Królestwo Węgier odmówiło pomocy w napaści na Polske w 1939, nawet pomogli przechowywać Polskich uchodźców do 1940.(Edit : In English : Yes, Kingdom of Hungary did join Axis Powers in 1941 and no, Kingdom of Hungary refused to help in Invasion of Poland in 1939, they even helped keep some refugees until 1940.)
@@bm952 nie wspierali Niemców kiedy oni zatakowali polske. a nawet podczas okupacji węgrzy chowali Polaków przed niemcami
To summarise: Allies are great, unless you're Poland.
Eastern Europe, and Poland in particular, did get a raw deal.
The problem stems from it not being a two sided war. Russia had their own agenda, and I think the allies were a bit caught between keeping the Russians on-side and actually trying to do the right thing.
I think Stalin was hugely underestimated.
Or Republic of China XD
Or Czechoslovakia
And Hungary
Or Romania.,i fact any country that was "liberated"(what soviet called it) by the commies. If you ask me they are only nazis who speak russian.
Sabaton: Makes a song about tye polish uprising
History house productions: Uses the winged hussars
Should've used "Stuck in the Middle with You"
Its literally called Uprising, it couldnt have been easier
@@Rustikreign voices from underground, whispers of freedom
@@UwU-xk5cx NINE TEEN FORTHY FOUR!
HELP THAT NEVER CAME!!
@@jordansblabbering6303 Calling warsaw, city at war
Voices from underground, whispers of freedom
Rise up, and hear the call
History's calling to you
WARSZAWO, WALCZ!
Polish: were free
Soviets: I wouldn’t say free, more like under new management
dang i was gonna make that up
One thing I can't figure out is: If the poles hate the soviets so much, why would they expect the red army to save their ass when things went bad in Warsaw? ?
@@TheMachenbin because weren't they on the same side of the war?
Sure uneasy alliance but an alliance is an alliance
@@themorebike880 the soviets literally agreed with germany to split poland. Not exactly allied
@@thecreepnextdoor7560 yeah at the start
But the soviets were uneasily allied with Poland during the invasion of Germany
They just wouldn't help them because they are power hungry pigs
Hungarian bros! I summon thou to bromance in the comments!
Lengyel, magyar - két jó barát,
Együtt harcol s issza borát,
Vitéz s bátor mindkettője,
Áldás szálljon mindkettőre.
TBH. Aside from "Lengel" and "Magyar" I have no clue what I just pasted. xd
Your ancestors hate you for that profile picture, dishonorable.
Polak, Węgier - Dwa bratanki
I do szabli i do szklanki,
Oba zuchy oba żwawi,
Niech im Pan Bóg Błogosławi.
Piękne porzekadło Polsko-Węgierskie.
@@BudMasta I've already committed sudoku for it.
Can I join in? I'm an Englishman who likes both countries and has survived both Polish and Hungarian weddings! :-D
- If it helps my name is Stephen/Istvan, same as Bathory :-D
Love from hungary my polish broder
POLAND: ...
ALLIES: ...
RUSSIANS: *It's free real estate.*
Don't forget about the Polish boy and girl scouts who, rather than be thrown in jail for being scouts, joined the rebellion and were among the best soldiers during the Warsaw Uprising, even helped in the liberation of the Gęsiówka Camp. Then were tragically slaughtered by the Nazis and USSR.
Grey Ranks ftw
During liberation of Gęsiowka concentration camp was used with great succes captured german Panther tank.
Allies: "You're gonna help Poles in Warsaw against Wehrmacht??"
Stalin: "Well DA, But Actually NYET!"
Poles in Warsaw; Polish Government in London; Allies: *Surprised_Pikachu_Face.jpg*
Stalin is shit
Just curious why were the Soviet hostile towards the polish in the first place
ну да но на самом деле нет
@@ncrsoldier5275 you’re shit
You can do video about this Bromance between Poland and Hungary
I’d have to take so many screenshots
History House Productions true
@@HistoryHouseProductions i beg you do it!
@@HistoryHouseProductions Please do it
Polish history is cool.
But sad.
I mean for most of it they were out of it
Yeah, and it’s easy to learn since it’s so short!
Oweniee 21 I wouldn’t say short. Poland was an autonomous region in the Russian Empire since the partitions of poland. They had things happen in Poland, even if they were not a real country for that time. That is kinda like saying that Getmany has a shirt history, because they didn’t exist until the mid 1800’s, but thats not the case because the HRE and German Confederation, and Prussia,Bavaria, ect.
@@Litwinus as a 4th generation polish american. I find it pretty triumphant.
They (with lithuania) were the largest country in europe for hundreds of years, the largest on eastern europe for even longer.
Longest running republic in european history if I remember correctly.
Freedom loving and peace loving people.
It took all of their neighbors to destabilize them enough to rip them apart.
And even after being stateless split between the borders of multiple empires for several hundred years, they grew and prospered and maintained their culture and language and heritage and identity.
Incredibly robust group of people and I'm pleasured to be nearly half polish.
You officially better than school for teaching this thank you
Thanks man! I appreciate it!
History House Productions 👌
Long live Hungary ! Wish the best from Poland !
Polish people:were free soviets: I DoNt tHiNk so
Slightly more complicated than that.
More like under new management
@@HistoryHouseProductions more like under new psychopath
That why Stalin suck
That's BS the soviets were clearly fighting the Germans/Nazis., the last thing they would want is Germany gaining control of Poland lmao
Imagine getting Rick Rolled while watching a video over Polish Resistance.
living in Warsaw for 25 years, and still can feel the presence of this events
“Do you wanna get assassinated” best line of the video😂
This was a great vid thanks for honouring my peeps and hi Hungarian brothers.
"Well sometimes people just disappear"
Yeah, and sometimes they definitely don't not not kill themselves.....
Somethings never change.....
adhi sekar sometimes people just get bullet holes in the back of their heads
@@tikalthewhimsicott2736 they just casually close the window after jumping.
cringe reference
Super good topic and not discussed enough great job man!
Thank you! Looking forward to your next video!
Just discovered this channel and found this. Keep up the great content man
Thank you so much! I’m glad you enjoy it!
@@HistoryHouseProductions :D
Bro, I discovered your channel like a week ago and watched almost every Poland history vid. Keep up the great content you're a great educator!
Thank you!
Germans when the sewers starts speaking Polish:
*"cat pauses"*
No i kozak, wegrzy podpisujcie się pod komentarzem :D
Polak Węgier dwa bratanki i do szabli i do szklanki 🇵🇱
Lengyel, magyar - két jó barát, együtt harcol, s issza borát 🇭🇺
I've never seen the detail of the Polish planes dropping supplies, it's always so nice to get new details on a topic. Great job!
Thanks! I thought that was pretty interesting too!
on the night of August 3-4, allied planes - one halifax and three liberators - appeared for the first time over Warsaw with the Polish crews of the 1586th Special Squadron. It would not be surprising if it were not for the fact that this drop was the result of insubordination of Polish crews. Despite the intervention of the representatives of the Polish government with the British authorities, the action over the city was not approved by the deputy commander of the Mediterranean Allied Air Force (MAAF), marshal of aviation John
Slessor, who claimed that such flights are marked by a high risk (the route was 1,400 km long and led over the Adriatic, Yugoslavia and Hungary, where there was a strong anti-aircraft defense and base of night fighters), and in addition Warsaw is in the operational zone of the Red Army and it is Soviet aviation that should support the insurgents
www.polska1918-89.pl/pdf/zrzuty-dla-powstania,1797.pdf
WHEN THE WINGED HUSSARS ARRIVED!
COMING DOWN THE MOUNTAINSIDE
WHEN THE WING HUSSARS ARRIVED
France: German occupation was terrible
Polska: * visible confusion *
its kinda hard to not demonize communists
actualy its the same like trying to not demonize nazis
petr súkeník it’s hardly an excuse, but Nazi were kinda bigger evil
@@Ake-TL I don't agree.
@@Ake-TL Both the communists and the nazis were evil, it just so happened that the communists were just fighting the same enemy as the west.
@@Ake-TL if you look on the numbers of killed then communist were much worse than nazis
Communist weren't rasistic i will give them that but they operated at basicali same principe as nazis (executions concentration camps etc.)
@ShardyTechTips there were allso non german nazis and colaborants so as it seems every nation have ist evil guys
Channel growing faster than Coronavirus' death toll
Haha! Hopefully it stays that way....
OOOF
@@HistoryHouseProductions My Boii gettin' sponsored!
History House Productions know it isn’t
**The Snow Speaks Finnish**
**The Trees Speak Vietnamese**
**The Rocks Speak Japanese**
**The Hills Speak American**
**The Sewers Speak Polish**
**The Rubble Speaks Russian**
**The Guillotine Speaks French**
**The Cities Speak Irish**
Why rubble? Is it because of the Stalingrad battle?
"The roads Speak Spanish"
As a descendant of Poland living in the US, I must say, you're not "demonizing" the Russians...
You're just accurately portraying them. And Communism; portraying that properly as well. Both cruel and senseless the Ruskiis and Commies were...
If anything he is to kind to them.
@@alexandrub8786 Bingo.
@@arczi1309 tell that to ukrainians.
@@arczi1309 who do you think started with the train cars and labor camps... They "relocated" the shit out of people according to ethnic group, especially in Lithuania and Ukraine
@@arczi1309right, they didnt try.. they did it.
Amazing! Keep the great content up!
When I saw the title, my first thought was the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising, which was a year earlier and - spoiler alert - didn’t go any better for the Poles.
3:35 Yes, indeed, it would be foolish from Soviet perspective, if they weren't liberators... Ah, but the essential question for Russians is, "were they liberators, as they claim, or just a third party to the conflict?" They claim to be liberators... who just a week ago have pompously celebrated the anniversary of liberating a dead ruin and were outraged Poland doesn't celebrate with them.
About the same time Paris revolted, and Allies, although it ruined their plans and they weren't fond of the French aspirations in general, dropped everything and rushed to help.
@Tom Fury Soviet radio was calling the Poles to rise up, that's first.
Second, so reestabilishing a free state fighting common enemy is somehow directed against the "liberator"? I thought that's the very definition of the word...
Third, even if I'm willing to accept that there were valid logistical reasons for halt of Red Army's advance: banning allied aircrafts from landing on soviet airports and destroying Polish resistance units from Eastern Poland heading to support Warsaw is nothing short of proof that Soviets put greater priority on subjugating Poland than on driving the Germans out of it. Such "liberators".
If the USA liberated France the same way Soviets did Poland, de Gaulle would die in Alcatraz for "collaboration with Nazis" and Paris would be a pile of rubble instead of world's cultural capital.
I mean I liked the video, but I'm not sure how happy I am with it being comedic. Both of my great grandparents were killed in world war II. One on the German front and the other was an officer who died in the Katyn massacre. My grandmother had her father murdered is still alive.
I appreciate this comment. I definitely understand how topics like this can be difficult, especially for people who have personal connections. I like to use humor as a way to break through those emotions and teach people about these important events. I tend to use humor as a “coping mechanism,” but I fully respect that some people don’t feel that way. Your family has my sincere condolences.
Russian: Russia never attack anyone !
Poles: I HAVE SEVERAL QUESTIONS !
And here we go again? Crimes committed by soviet convicted to Russians and victories gained by them committed to the lend lease plan?
@@арефнар i don't understand what do you mean.
This joke is about Russia propaganda spreding lies that Russia dosen't attack any country in history.
In this context Soviet Russia with Russian troops.
@@арефнар Because it's true. Lend lease was signed within weeks of the former ally of the Soviets stabbing them in the back and the first convoy reached Murmansk well before the Germans got to Moscow. Stalin himself admitted that it was the surety of lend lease that allowed the Soviets to stop the Germans in the suburbs of Moscow. You can whine all day about the number of Soviet soldiers that died fighting the Germans, it's not the Allies' fault that the Soviets were lousy soldiers with lousy equipment lead by mostly lousy officers and commanded by a supreme leader that didn't care how may he killed. If it wasn't for American trucks delivering bread baked from American wheat powered by American gasoline, the Russians would have lost. I'm not sure that would have been a bad thing.
@@Mishn0 well on that idea every crime comited by soviets is because land lease,that means that lots of unnocent,non-german,civilians died by american arms. Well i like to see that US never changed it's horrible way,if they would only stop to lie.
@@Mishn0 you just right now called 12 millioon misled warriors "louse".
You know what it is to be louse?
To say a lie and think that this "lie" gives you a kind of "national superiority" and pride.
Pride you don't get for the things you didn't do.
If USSR did bad, remember that it was a conspiracy of westerners, led by germans and supported by french and british afterwards.
We are all equally grateful of those who fought against fascism that now is replenishing under the name of "holy lovely democratic world".
Mate,not that Sabaton song,we got another one shouting Warzawo Walcz.
It's called Uprising.
Isn't 40 to 1 about Poland?
@@pestilenceplague4765 that about protecting the capital agains the invasion not liberating it,uprising is about the warsaw upr.
@@pestilenceplague4765 40 to 1 is about Battle of Wizna
That 1 dislike is shitler in Argentina
Nope, is a Putin himself
@@marekgumowski3578 would that mean putin is stalin reborn?
17
@@Iberian_XAVO it was 1 at the time so he made a few accounts
All the other dislikes are the other officers who escaped with shitler
Thanks for making this video, warsaw uprising is underrated
Hahaha ”do you want to get assassinated”
I'm new here, and i like it there, subscribed :D. Honestly, your videos are educational and funny and the Warsaw Uprising is something, that everyone should know about. Poles are great nation and this is sad part of their history, but it shows, that the will of those polish people was really strong and they wanted to help the country and the allies. Big respect to the people that were fighting for their city and against the nazis. Sending Greetings from Czech Republic.
Finally yes! Also I have an Idea for a video about Austria-Hungary, it would be really fun or you can do a nother ww1 video. Also keep it up man
Can you talk later of countries that had somewhat important contributions in ww2 but aren't taught as it need, in example: The Brazilian campaign in Italy by the Brazilian Expeditionary Force
.
Warsaw city of war
voices from underground
whispers of freedom
If you understand this then nice
1944!
Help that never came!
CALLING WARSAW, CITY AT WAR!
Rise up and hear the call
History calling to you,
*WARSZAWO WALCZ!*
The trees: Speak Vietnamese
The snow: Speak Finnish
The sewers: Speak Polish
Make a video on greece in WW2 I would love to see that!🇬🇷👍🏻
That’d be cool!
Nothing like reliving Italy getting it's booty spanked 😂
I really like your sense of humor. Great Video!
Thanks!
anyone see the 420 on the panzer?
Edit: Thanks for the like also I just saw the 69............I have to stop rewatching your videos so much
Lol i died when "Never gonna give you up" played
Poland:we love hungary
Hungary:we love poland
Meawhile Romania who let polish soldiers enter their country back in 39:why am i here just to suffer
“...an SS brigade comprised of released violent criminals...”
Dirlewanger Brigade video please? It’ll be bordering the realm of DEMONETIZATION but you’d be the first channel that’s actually good or known to cover them. Literally the single German military unit that got most of the bad rap for the rest of the SS. Other SS quite literally hated these guys because of how brutal and depraved they were.
Anyway, awesome video. The quality has definitely been going up.
"The rest of the ss hated these guys because of how brutal and depraved they were"
They were a group comprised of war criminals and murderers who rounded up civilians and organized mass shootings regularly. I doubt there is anything that anyone could do to be hated by the ss unless you were born polish or Jewish.
"The sewers... speak Polish." dawg lmfaooooo
Thank you so much for bringing the Uprising up and making people aware that this happened.
AND THEN THE SAD POLISH HISTORY ARRIVED
Man I really like this channel, these videos are really nice! see ya soon with a lot more subs
Thank you!
Glad that I'm able to watch this video without KGB fear,who they are to kidnap me to a gulag in ru-
It's really rare to see someone from outside of Poland to grasp the essence of the uprising. Nice of you.
And finally, Polska can into space!
No
@@hunterbg7531 it actually can
@@hrdeforda4154 Real shit?
Black Honker SPACE. that means three things: Space bar, territory and outer space.
Awesome new video! Keep them coming! Love from your eastern neighbour, Finland❤
History House Rickrolled us all. 🤣🤣🤣
"Even if you don't help and are just watching as we fighting your 'ally' , it is still better than those who gave false hope. I love you my Hungary brothers"
-Some guy in poland
there were supposedly - dont know it if it is a rlaible soruce negotiaitons about hungarian forces literally joining poles fighting in the uprising, but the home army wasn't able to guarantee anything for the hungarians if they soviets came in; hungarians really were tired and wanted to go back home
Poland: can I get Independence?
USSR: how bout no?
Video about Polish-Hungarian's bromance would be epic ;)
5:01 😭😂😂😂😂
Imagine they actually use that song 😂
The AK and Soviets: "The enemy of my enemy... is still my enemy"
Warsaw uprising in a nutshell
True
He’s alive
Sempai Conner noticed me
Dude, great video but why did you upload it just minutes after the latest WW2 episode? :)
Seriously though, thanks for popularising this topic. Despite that the video is short and not so serious, you managed to put a lot of information in it (including some often overlooked even in serious discussions about the Uprising).
Since you were trying to be fair to the Soviets, I might add that there are some further arguments to be made in their defense (although they all come with counter-arguments to which I will get).
1. The Bagration offensive that brought the Red Army close to Warsaw was already running out of steam before the Uprising and another offensive was starting way down South on the other side of Carpathians, so there were some legitime reasons for Soviets to stop BUT their Polish radio station was still encouraging the people of Warsaw to rise up.
2. That little attempts at assistance to the insurgents in September included not only artillery shelling but also some limited air-drops, the Soviet Air Forces finally stopping letting Luftwaffe do whatever it pleased over Warsaw, and finally even letting some of the Polish troops under Soviet command to cross the river. HOWEVER, the drops were made in sacks without parachutes by low-flying small biplanes, which did little besides endangering the pilots and the troops that crossed the Vistula were far too weak to make any real difference, so it looks like sacrificing some Poles to make a semblance of helping Poles. All it achieved was prolonging the agony of the Uprising because the Home Army broke the first round of the capitulation negotiations, which they just started.
The eventual capitulation was BTW kinda a little "success" because the German forces originally got directives from both Hitler and Himmler to literary kill everyone in the rebellious city (they did pretty much that in the districts of Ochota and Wola, which were the first to fall) and they generally weren't in a habit of negotiating with the resistance fighters or taking them as POWs. The bitter Polish resistance eventually made them propose terms of surrender instead. Also, the Western Allies issued a proclamation reminding that the members of the Home Army are in fact allied soldiers (too bad it didn't work on the Soviets).
Another super great comment my guy! Yeah, the Soviets did send the Polish contingent of their army across, but they all got mowed down pretty much. Another cool fact about the Polish surrender is that as several units were leaving the city, the SS lined up to salute them! I thought that that was pretty interesting.
Allies: We will defend Poland
1939 Comes
Poland: Where ya at
Allies have left the chat
also It a me, loyal fan-ario me dude and I still dont have hoi4 ;-;
buy it, great game, especially with some good mods and DLCs
@@swift1014 I do have it and used to play it but it does not support my laptop
Some kiddo good luck with getting a new one :)
@@swift1014 thanks
Don't play with Poland. When you will be holding west, Russia came in to anal rape. Impossible to win. ;)
The dodo water tour guide. Probably the best way I’ve seen that worded in the history videos I’ve seen of the uprising.
9:10 you forgot to mention that the Alps speak swiss ;)
French or German
@@dreamofspring7930 italiano or rumantsch
I have been waiting for this!
Germany: I want 🇨🇿🇦🇹🇵🇱 france,Britain: no....fine!
I swear I read books about uprising that didn’t have all those facts and made it look like poles just foolishly rose up with no plan .
And jokes made me craic several times .
Good job
Thank you! I'm glad you liked it!
You should make a video on the American revolution...
*And blame it on the Russians*
Awesome dude thanks. Hopefully this will blow up!
Thank you!
As a kid i compared Poland as the dude who is sitting between two fat women in the plane...
still do
I love your videos keep up the hard work!
Knock knock , ze flammerwerfer
Poland have such a sad history man >:( Thank you for making this funny animation xD
The sewers speak Polish. That's why only Poles get to become plumbers because they can communicate with the sewer
Nice video mate! I'm new to the channel and I think I'm slowly getting addicted to it. Keep on the nice work!
Do one of 9/11
Warsaw Uprising: Poles outnumbered and outgunned were supposed to fight a couple of days, fought over TWO months.
Fall of France: French had better equipment, more less the same amount of soldiers, and great defensive lines. They were supposed to win, surrendered in ONE AND HALF month.
French: wHy cALL uS cOwArDs? wE hAd iMpOrTaNt rOLe iN dEfEaiTinG gErMaNs
"Azeris from Soviet Azerbaijan fought for Germans in Poland"
me an azerbaijani: *confused screaming*
Its actually the best video about warsaw uprising, seriously the polish are trying to learn everyone about their history but you did it 10x better
Thank you! That means a lot.
@@HistoryHouseProductions secret pro tip: if you want more subs, make more videos about polish history, polish are obsessed with it
Fun fact after the uprising polish soldiers and German worked together to evacuate civilians from the city
Some of the civilians ended up in work camps
And u failed to mention that ukrainians soldiers were killing polish civilians sometimes against greman orders
And German focused on hospitals they were bombing them and they were killing doctors and nurses they also burned alive sick or wounded people form the hospitals
"When the Winged Hussars arrive!" the get shot down by artillery....
Aww Hungarians :3
Do an entire video about Miklos Horthy and Hungary during WWII
I have a video on Hungary between the wars
Welp, sometimes people just disappear in democracies
I wish my history teachers were this good. Thanks random youtuber I accidentally stumbled upon while trying to keep my sanity during the coronavirus self quarantine.
Haha! Thank you! Stay safe!
I love most of the history channels on TH-cam but this is by far one of my favorites. Also damn I feel bad for Poland like they deserve some serious “WINS” soon to balance out all the monumental historical “L’s” they’ve taken
L implies also moral L so no
I was feeling so down today, this video cheered me up! Thanks HHP
Doo doo water tour guide.
Im learning new things here.
I’m not sure if it’s appropriate or even how you do it but I love that I learn and laugh (maybe we are both bad people) at historical events........ that really aren’t funny. We have a very similar sense of humor. Keep up the good work!!!!
I think that it’s important to laugh a little even at tragic events. It makes them more approachable for people.
The Tet celebrations are making my ears go kaboom
I knew that Poland was betrayed by her allies during WWII, but I had no clue that the United States played any part in that. That shames me deeply. Though we became closer and closer from 1980 until the present day, which I am very proud of, I see no reason whatsoever for Britain and France to have betrayed her. The Poles are a great, strong, courageous, and freedom loving people and I'm very thankful that President Trump declared them an ally of the United States. 🇵🇱🇺🇸 Great video, as always. Please keep the outstanding videos coming and God bless you, my friend!
Poland Hungary relationship is worth a video
I have a wz. 29 in my collection. I like to imagine that maybe it was there.
That’s really cool!