"R2 and Obi Wan would begin their journey to rebuild a fallen order. This would start with finding Cal Kestis and Cere Junda." Of course he had to do that.
I like how you highlighted an aspect of Obi-Wan that most people miss. His wisdom and intelligence. Because he was one very smart person and he knew how to use it to the best of his ability. And you used it quite well in this video PP. Nice job.
Not sure if Obi wan even could survive the way Anakin did. Anger and hatred seems to have a far better track record at keeping people who were cut in half to fall in a deep hole or left without limbs on the shore of a lava bank alive. Still an interesting story.
Honestly this was great especially the whole part about Padme, Luke, and Leah along with Anakin still having redemption. However I was hoping Sidious would come get Obi-Wan and turn him sith or keep him prisoner while torturing him without Anakin knowing. If that were to have happened along with the Sidious training Luke and Leah it would definitely make a great story. There's a few different avenues you could explore with him being turned or tortured
Around the 9:00 mark I was a bit confused why you mentioned Anakin disobeyed Palpatine, which I didn't see at all. Other than that, I have to admit I really enjoyed this fanfiction. I think this is the best one I've seen in a long time...maybe ever from you. You didn't throw any of the Disney stories/plots in there to ruin the fanfiction, which was wonderful, and it had some unexpected twists. For once you went out of your comfort zone, and didn't try to follow the plot line from one of the stories, and went your own direction, based on the characters and events. I applaud you, this was phenomenal.
Heres some what ifs. 1.What if the Rebel Alliance was crushed on Hoth? 2.What if the Trade Federation peacefully resolved the Naboo crisis? 3.What if Qui-Gon Jinn had trained Darth Maul as a Jedi? 4.What if the Jedi Council discovered Palpatine's true identity earlier? 5.What if Leia became a Jedi Master in the sequel trilogy? and finally 6. What if the Jedi and Sith coexisted peacefully? PLEASE DO ONE OF THESE THEYRE ARE SO INTERESTING🙏🙏🙏
The story of the Blackwing virus (both its origins in "Red Harvest" and "Death Troopers") is so interesting, I would love more what if stories based on it, a series or even a 40mn-1h movie.
What if; Darth Talon was Aayla Secura daughter, Lei knew Darth Vader was her father as a child and saved him, Lando was a Jedi, Han Solo never meet Chewbacca, Padma and Anakin were only friends, Hera Syndulla was force sensitive and finally, what if Mace Windu didn’t get his seat on the Council but Dooku did?
The Separatists had advanced battle droids, they just weren't mass produced like the B1 and B2 and some of them were either secretly sabotaged by Sidious agents or infos on said droids were leaked to the Jedi & GAR.
What if Talzin brought up Maul from the day he was born to be her future successor and the ruler of Dathomir and convinced The Nightsisters to consider or look or see or view him as a exception compared to other Nightbrothers?
Great story, love the Skywalker kids being hellions. There is one thing that bugs me... Once a burn passes Second degree, it doesn't hurt. At a Third Degree burn, the nerve endings are burnt away. When it comes to debriding, doctors love it, because there is no pain to the patient. The chance of infection is much higher though. Bacta or kolto would keep that low to none existence and reduce the rejection of the skin grafts that would be necessary after a Third Degree burn. Most people wouldn't know, unless you've delt with these kinds of burns, as a victim, a doctor or a physical therapist or just extremely morbidly curious. Or tried to make a Table Top RPG using the medical percentile system for damage. Keep up the good work
Been loving these darker what ifs, while I love your redemptive arcs, I always wondered about some other alternatives to Anakin not burning his tail off at Mustafar and perhaps making one smart move for once despite his dark mania-- though I know you've covered a few in your videos, but you never covered many where he enjoys his dark mania long enough to be completely deluded while also not suffering immediate consequences just yet. This one covered that path and I'm glad you did. Also your incredible storywriting and ability to maneuver around Canon events to tell a very great what if that sound realistic within that universe is very inspiring to me. Though I don't specialize in fanfic writing, I'm a writer with my own universe and your ability to see other perspectives and make it sound so real has inspired to do similar things with my own writings. All this to say, keep it up. I'm loving it and this is clearly your talent. Take care!
When you consider that Aniken went there to Musta far in his starfighter, and didn’t have a way to fit in the cockpit with a pregnant woman I can totally see him leaving it behind. He just dismisses it as a transport vehicle, and he is ignoring all emotional attachment, except the incredibly possessive feelings he has for his wife.
Listening to this while playing wii sports solo at 12 am. Life is good Edit:I finished the video, great experience, 10/10 would play wii sports and listen to pente again
I really enjoyed this video. Is there any possibility of any chance of another two further episodes of this story. I think that it would be cool to see and that others will like to enjoy it too. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
Wow, a story where is indeed more than one predictable way and where Palps infact wasn't just an old skull to throw off. Must say I'm gladly impress to feel Star Wars essence for once and to see you actualy payed atention to it this time. It didn't even feel rushed at all as some before. Bravo must say.
I have some names to add to your list of "What If Anakin Was TRAINED By...." videos. These names come from the Old/High Republic. I saw the Revan video and I know you have a video coming soon of Satele Shan being Anakin's Master. The other names (Jedi and Sith) are: 1. Arca Jeth (Jedi), training Anakin alongside Ulic and Cay Qel-Droma 2. Vandar Tokare (Jedi) 3. Marka Ragnos (Sith) 4. Freedom Nadd (Sith) 5. Naga Sadow (Sith) 6. Ludo Kreesh (Sith) 7. Vodo-Siosk Bass (Jedi), training Aankin either alongside or instead of Exar Kun 8. Exar Kun (Jedi then Sith) 9. Ulic Qel-Droma (Jedi then Sith then Jedi) 10. Darth Bane (Sith) 11. Ood Bnar (Jedi) (I like that he's studied Light and Dark for centuries, knowledge that can help Anakin become balanced. If Ood's friend Vodo-Siosk Bass joined him in training Anakin, it could help even more.) 12. Xo Lahru, Pra-Tre Veter, and Yoda (Jedi Grand Masters)
What if Nightsister Merrin was raised in the Jedi order and became Obi Wans padawan alongside Ahsoka being made Anakins. What if Anakin and Obi-Wan weren't sent to protect Padme, Instead, Barriss and Luminara were sent in their place. What if the Super Tactical droid joined the rebellion.
What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin was an Jedi bounty hunter
What if Ahsoka joined Maul after she left the Jedi Order? In my opinion she would after long partnership with Maul, open him to the light becoming something in between jedi and sith and they could encounter Bendu. Rest is up to you (Sorry if you don't understand some words or what I mean, English is not my first language)
I feel like obi-wan wouldn’t just rush into the temple I feel like he would stay low maybe even gather info and upon gathering said info he would then go into hiding to try and build a secret Jedi order
What if Yoda and Obi-Wan saw the potential in Luke and trained him in the Jedi arts, just enough to give him an awareness of the force, just enough to give him enough abilities that they could aim him at Darth Vader. To use him as a weapon to take down Lord Vader and eventually the Emperor?
1. What if Jango Fett freed Shmi and adopted Anakin? 2. What if Anakin was trained by Pong Krell? 3. What if Katooni survived order 66 and found her way to Hondo and became a pirate? 4. What if Ahsoka got into contact With Lux Bonteri and they both made their own rebel cell? 5. What if Jyn Erso was a spy for the Empire? (The type of story where she does not have a change of heart) 6. What if Death troopers were used in the clone wars? 7. What if Grand Admiral Thrawn fell in love with a rebel?
What if master dooku became a member of the jedi Council and eventually master of the jedi order. Also what if master of the order master dooku told Qui-gon jinn that when the naboo mission was complete then the jedi Council will inform him whether or not anakin skywalker would be allowed to become a jedi. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
Been watching your videos for awhile now and I think this is my favorite one that you have made. Incredible story telling and incredible idea and to see what you did with it was incredible. Can’t wait to see the next, keep up the good work
Ah the irony. Had Anakin not been arrogant he wouldn't turn into a machine of evil. (What If idea) What if Kenobi lost on the moon during the Kenobi show
Just watched an older video and read a comment saying that you are almost on the level of star war theory. But I my opinion he couldn’t fill your shoes when it comes to writing what if’s. That being said I love both channels.
Your earth what if. It's beautiful. But what if Middle earth was in star wars? Would it have the same effects in the modern era? Or would things be different?
Great Story, but I highly doubt that Obi-Wan's rescue would happen on Mustafar, because, 1. he did not call for help for a rescue ship 2. He would already be dead before someone decided to look for him, 3. Palpatine would just gloat and leave him for dead; you recall that Palpatine only saved Anakin in the Episode III movie storyline, because he was a tool for his power.
I always wanted to see more Han What If's. Listed these before What if Han stayed with the Empire? What if Han ended up raising Rey? What if Han was trained a Jedi? Also what if Obi-Wan hired Hondo instead of Han for some reason?
7:28 Nobody:
Padme the entire time in the facility: Where is Obi-Wan? Is he safe? Is he alright?
"it would seem in his own arrogance he burned to death"
"R2 and Obi Wan would begin their journey to rebuild a fallen order. This would start with finding Cal Kestis and Cere Junda." Of course he had to do that.
What if Anakin accidentally killed Palpatine during the duel with Dooku on the Invisible Hand?
What if Grievous killed Palpatine in an act of desperation?
*Written and directed by George Lucas*
"Now let's get you out of he-....FU-"
@@Dumb_Gaming05 Anakin: He just lost the will to live
I like how you highlighted an aspect of Obi-Wan that most people miss. His wisdom and intelligence. Because he was one very smart person and he knew how to use it to the best of his ability. And you used it quite well in this video PP. Nice job.
Dude. This thumbnail is DARK.
Yeah I'm glad it had at least a happy ending
@@hamstey1603I'm never opening the comments section before watching 😂
Thx for the news
@@ZeKermetgeneral rule of thumb..
@@imperious8905 yea that's my bad
This thumbnail is fire
… and don’t miss our next episode, ‘What if Yoda had snorted ket and took 7 viagra before facing Sidious?’
Sidious would feel a different kind of force used against him.
#YodaTouchedMe
sidious would have two green things attacking him
"Anakin would find a new partner"
Plo Koon shows up in the bottom left corner
"You were my brother Obi Wan, I loved you" 😢
"I hate you" 😡
What if General Grievous killed Palpatine on Coruscant instead of kidnapping him?
grievious killing sidious? u think he has that typ[e of power losing to obie one?
“Whoops.”
Dooku is still alive during that time right? I wonder what he would do.
@@814TrumpArmyit prob would’ve been by surprise because the plan was to kidnap palps
@@814TrumpArmygrievous didn't know that sidious was his master's master he thought the chancellor was a random old man
Not sure if Obi wan even could survive the way Anakin did. Anger and hatred seems to have a far better track record at keeping people who were cut in half to fall in a deep hole or left without limbs on the shore of a lava bank alive.
Still an interesting story.
Honestly this was great especially the whole part about Padme, Luke, and Leah along with Anakin still having redemption. However I was hoping Sidious would come get Obi-Wan and turn him sith or keep him prisoner while torturing him without Anakin knowing. If that were to have happened along with the Sidious training Luke and Leah it would definitely make a great story. There's a few different avenues you could explore with him being turned or tortured
Around the 9:00 mark I was a bit confused why you mentioned Anakin disobeyed Palpatine, which I didn't see at all. Other than that, I have to admit I really enjoyed this fanfiction. I think this is the best one I've seen in a long time...maybe ever from you. You didn't throw any of the Disney stories/plots in there to ruin the fanfiction, which was wonderful, and it had some unexpected twists. For once you went out of your comfort zone, and didn't try to follow the plot line from one of the stories, and went your own direction, based on the characters and events. I applaud you, this was phenomenal.
What if Yoda followed Dooku instead of Yaddle?
What if Anakin have a vision of him choking Padme to death in the Revenge of the Sith?
Heres some what ifs. 1.What if the Rebel Alliance was crushed on Hoth? 2.What if the Trade Federation peacefully resolved the Naboo crisis? 3.What if Qui-Gon Jinn had trained Darth Maul as a Jedi? 4.What if the Jedi Council discovered Palpatine's true identity earlier? 5.What if Leia became a Jedi Master in the sequel trilogy? and finally 6. What if the Jedi and Sith coexisted peacefully? PLEASE DO ONE OF THESE THEYRE ARE SO INTERESTING🙏🙏🙏
Leia = Sith. Period.
i would only watch like maybe 3 of em
@@dantegean2810 which ones? (just say the number ill know which ones)
Jedi and Sith cohabit is curious
@@Slasher33521 2 5
Congrats Pente Patrol, you've earned yourself a new subscriber! Excellent Fanfiction!
The story of the Blackwing virus (both its origins in "Red Harvest" and "Death Troopers") is so interesting, I would love more what if stories based on it, a series or even a 40mn-1h movie.
What if Anakin had a zygerrian Padawan after ahsoka left the Jedi order
What if; Darth Talon was Aayla Secura daughter, Lei knew Darth Vader was her father as a child and saved him, Lando was a Jedi, Han Solo never meet Chewbacca, Padma and Anakin were only friends, Hera Syndulla was force sensitive and finally, what if Mace Windu didn’t get his seat on the Council but Dooku did?
The thumbnail actually makes me feel bad bro
R2 Doesn't Fucking Forgive So easily 😂
What if the Separatists used advanced battle droids instead?
What if Ashoka was trained by Count Dooku?
The Separatists had advanced battle droids, they just weren't mass produced like the B1 and B2 and some of them were either secretly sabotaged by Sidious agents or infos on said droids were leaked to the Jedi & GAR.
What if Talzin brought up Maul from the day he was born to be her future successor and the ruler of Dathomir and convinced The Nightsisters to consider or look or see or view him as a exception compared to other Nightbrothers?
What if Ray turn into the dark side ?
I feel like would be similar to What if Anakin was raised by mother Talzin but definitely would have more to add
@@jdgreen1802Maybe Sidious was caught trying to take Maul and he shot Sith Lightning at him while he took Savage Opress.
12:16 "not being able to breathe while being able to breathe"
Great story, love the Skywalker kids being hellions. There is one thing that bugs me... Once a burn passes Second degree, it doesn't hurt. At a Third Degree burn, the nerve endings are burnt away. When it comes to debriding, doctors love it, because there is no pain to the patient. The chance of infection is much higher though. Bacta or kolto would keep that low to none existence and reduce the rejection of the skin grafts that would be necessary after a Third Degree burn. Most people wouldn't know, unless you've delt with these kinds of burns, as a victim, a doctor or a physical therapist or just extremely morbidly curious. Or tried to make a Table Top RPG using the medical percentile system for damage. Keep up the good work
"Softly in the Sulfur" would make for a great band name.
My what if idea would be:
what if anakin suffered from ptsd from the clone wars?
Been loving these darker what ifs, while I love your redemptive arcs, I always wondered about some other alternatives to Anakin not burning his tail off at Mustafar and perhaps making one smart move for once despite his dark mania-- though I know you've covered a few in your videos, but you never covered many where he enjoys his dark mania long enough to be completely deluded while also not suffering immediate consequences just yet. This one covered that path and I'm glad you did.
Also your incredible storywriting and ability to maneuver around Canon events to tell a very great what if that sound realistic within that universe is very inspiring to me. Though I don't specialize in fanfic writing, I'm a writer with my own universe and your ability to see other perspectives and make it sound so real has inspired to do similar things with my own writings.
All this to say, keep it up. I'm loving it and this is clearly your talent. Take care!
"What if" The Jedi had discovered the Sith Temple under their own on Coruscant was corrupting them all.
When you consider that Aniken went there to Musta far in his starfighter, and didn’t have a way to fit in the cockpit with a pregnant woman I can totally see him leaving it behind. He just dismisses it as a transport vehicle, and he is ignoring all emotional attachment, except the incredibly possessive feelings he has for his wife.
What if Qui-Gon AND Obi-Wan lived in Phantom Menace?
The demon children got me so hard😂😂😂
Can we get what if the Jedi found the Sith during the High Republic?
High republic with or without anakin was prime Jedi. Ez dub
Dude this was so good!
What if Qui-gon was Anakin's Father
Then he wouldn’t have turned to the dark side.
What if they both burned? Perhaps it was slightly to warn on Mustafar that day and both died to hyperthermoia
Love the hello from grand inquisitor at the beginning makes me 😅
Listening to this while playing wii sports solo at 12 am. Life is good
Edit:I finished the video, great experience, 10/10 would play wii sports and listen to pente again
Damn Anakin got it in the end with the kids. Like Thrawn in charge
Palpatine made Luke and Leia freaking Chucky and Tiffany
This sounds like a fate worse than death.
What If Anakim Acidentally Killed Padmé In The Conflict With Clovis?😂
OMG! Anakin would def reach his fp
I really enjoyed this video. Is there any possibility of any chance of another two further episodes of this story. I think that it would be cool to see and that others will like to enjoy it too. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
What if order 66 was that all battle droids betrays the Sith instead of the clones betraying the jedi
Wow, a story where is indeed more than one predictable way and where Palps infact wasn't just an old skull to throw off.
Must say I'm gladly impress to feel Star Wars essence for once and to see you actualy payed atention to it this time.
It didn't even feel rushed at all as some before.
Bravo must say.
I have some names to add to your list of "What If Anakin Was TRAINED By...." videos. These names come from the Old/High Republic. I saw the Revan video and I know you have a video coming soon of Satele Shan being Anakin's Master. The other names (Jedi and Sith) are:
1. Arca Jeth (Jedi), training Anakin alongside Ulic and Cay Qel-Droma
2. Vandar Tokare (Jedi)
3. Marka Ragnos (Sith)
4. Freedom Nadd (Sith)
5. Naga Sadow (Sith)
6. Ludo Kreesh (Sith)
7. Vodo-Siosk Bass (Jedi), training Aankin either alongside or instead of Exar Kun
8. Exar Kun (Jedi then Sith)
9. Ulic Qel-Droma (Jedi then Sith then Jedi)
10. Darth Bane (Sith)
11. Ood Bnar (Jedi) (I like that he's studied Light and Dark for centuries, knowledge that can help Anakin become balanced. If Ood's friend Vodo-Siosk Bass joined him in training Anakin, it could help even more.)
12. Xo Lahru, Pra-Tre Veter, and Yoda (Jedi Grand Masters)
"What if" Meetra Surik didn't leave to find Revan after she defeated the Sith Triumvirate?
What if Nightsister Merrin was raised in the Jedi order and became Obi Wans padawan alongside Ahsoka being made Anakins.
What if Anakin and Obi-Wan weren't sent to protect Padme, Instead, Barriss and Luminara were sent in their place.
What if the Super Tactical droid joined the rebellion.
What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin was an Jedi bounty hunter
What if when the lightning hit palps it messed with his brain and gave him his robot chicken personality
When we feel great pain, it either makes us bitter and cold, or it makes us compassionate and merciful, understanding of pain.
What if Obi Wan and Yoda turned to the dark side before they fought Anakin and Sidious?
What if Ahsoka joined Maul after she left the Jedi Order?
In my opinion she would after long partnership with Maul, open him to the light becoming something in between jedi and sith and they could encounter Bendu.
Rest is up to you
(Sorry if you don't understand some words or what I mean, English is not my first language)
What if Luke was Anakin's father? A story where the timeline is changed. Where Luke and Mara have Anakin instead of Anakin and Padme having Luke.
What if Ahsoka Tano was a Sith Lord...
38:26 Sounds like A typical fatherhood.😂😂😂
What if the Jedi council believed in and fought to prove Ashoka’s innocence during the bombing
What if Obi-Wan and Yoda went to attack Palpatine in the emergency session of the senate instead of the Jedi Temple?
what if Thrawn deemed Palpatine unworthy of ruling the galaxy and somehow managed to kill him.
What if Darth Malgus took over the sith empire
What if Padme was a corrupt politician Or a supporter of Palpatines politics?
What if Luke Failed to destroy the First Death Star? Good video i really enjoyed this story!
then obi wan woke up on coruscant after chasing the bounty hunter "why did I take those bloody death sticks"
What a skill issue, imagine getting defeated by the high ground as the user
I feel like obi-wan wouldn’t just rush into the temple I feel like he would stay low maybe even gather info and upon gathering said info he would then go into hiding to try and build a secret Jedi order
loved the video part 2 pls
Here is a goofy one: what if in someway and somehow R2D2 was the sith lord? 🤣
What if Yoda and Obi-Wan saw the potential in Luke and trained him in the Jedi arts, just enough to give him an awareness of the force, just enough to give him enough abilities that they could aim him at Darth Vader. To use him as a weapon to take down Lord Vader and eventually the Emperor?
That would be a great movie. They should turn that into a movie one day
1. What if Jango Fett freed Shmi and adopted Anakin?
2. What if Anakin was trained by Pong Krell?
3. What if Katooni survived order 66 and found her way to Hondo and became a pirate?
4. What if Ahsoka got into contact With Lux Bonteri and they both made their own rebel cell?
5. What if Jyn Erso was a spy for the Empire? (The type of story where she does not have a change of heart)
6. What if Death troopers were used in the clone wars?
7. What if Grand Admiral Thrawn fell in love with a rebel?
I like the idea of 3
Jango adopting Anakin's is an Very interesting Idea
Day 10 of asking for a what if the Sith Empire returned during the High Republic era
What if master dooku became a member of the jedi Council and eventually master of the jedi order. Also what if master of the order master dooku told Qui-gon jinn that when the naboo mission was complete then the jedi Council will inform him whether or not anakin skywalker would be allowed to become a jedi. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
i aint going to sit here and list a bunch of what if's ...just goin to give ya props on what you made ! Great content thanks from me!
Been watching your videos for awhile now and I think this is my favorite one that you have made. Incredible story telling and incredible idea and to see what you did with it was incredible. Can’t wait to see the next, keep up the good work
Vader: "YOU WERE MY BROTHER OBI WAN!!!! YOU WERE SUPPOSED TO HELP ME BRING BALANCE TO THE FORCE NOT TRICK ME!!!!!"
Obi wan: "HOW DARE YOU!!!!!!"
This is a very good story. I loved it
I hate seeing Obi wan in pain 😔
What if the rebels found another death star fully functional and took it over to fight the empire
Ah the irony. Had Anakin not been arrogant he wouldn't turn into a machine of evil. (What If idea) What if Kenobi lost on the moon during the Kenobi show
What if a jedi from the high republic was found frozen in carbonite during the clone wars?
Just watched an older video and read a comment saying that you are almost on the level of star war theory. But I my opinion he couldn’t fill your shoes when it comes to writing what if’s. That being said I love both channels.
What if anakin and yoda switched places?
That one was dark.
Your earth what if. It's beautiful.
But what if Middle earth was in star wars? Would it have the same effects in the modern era? Or would things be different?
Part 2 please
What if Anakin Skywalker was born a girl and Padme Amidala a boy?
How would *Revenge Of The Sith* change in this scenario?
Great Story, but I highly doubt that Obi-Wan's rescue would happen on Mustafar, because, 1. he did not call for help for a rescue ship 2. He would already be dead before someone decided to look for him, 3. Palpatine would just gloat and leave him for dead; you recall that Palpatine only saved Anakin in the Episode III movie storyline, because he was a tool for his power.
Have you ever thought about having a channel dedicated to Harry Potter What Ifs
Idea for a what if: What if both Anakin and Obiwan burned on Mustafar?
Who is Luke and Leia’s Motherly Figger
Please make what if luke and Anakin were brothers
This is another banger
Lord Darth Sidious, if it pleases me... I am ALL the Sith!
Those poor clones
What if obi wan during the clone wars turned to the dark side after losing satine ??
Day 2 of asking for “What if the Dark Jedi escaped from the dawn temple five years before the clone wars?”
Could you do a part 2 where Anakin meets Ashoka
What if pong krell trained anakin
Very very cool, but in all of this...where is ahsoka?
What if Plo followed Dooku?
I always wanted to see more Han What If's. Listed these before What if Han stayed with the Empire? What if Han ended up raising Rey? What if Han was trained a Jedi? Also what if Obi-Wan hired Hondo instead of Han for some reason?