ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Puella Magi Madoka★Magica is a series thought to have ended in a definite way, that is until Rebellion came and introduced a twist that shattered the very fabric of the story itself. This ending is seen to have created an unnecessary cliffhanger for a story that was done...but what if Madoka and Homura's story was never complete to begin with? What if the wishes of these two girls who lie at the center of this story remained unresolved? In fact, what were their wishes to begin with?
The answer lies in the power of love...and also how that power has the potential to corrupt.
Blog Form:
wtwhivemind.co...
Check out Craftsdwarf's counterpart video here:
• Video
Join the "fan" Discord server:
/ discord
Avatar made by JSPicturePlace. Hit him up!
/ jspictureplace
Support me on Patreon lol:
/ watthewut
Or check out my Ko-fi:
ko-fi.com/W7W7...
Thank you to Nunmanji for editing this video!
/ @nunmanji
Isekai has been a fairly popular genre as of late, with there being over 6 of them in the current Fall 2019 season, from Shinchou Yuusha, Ascendance of a Bookworm to Kemono Michi, there are so many just within this season that it makes you wonder if the genre is oversaturated or possibly that...it's getting worse? The genre that contains such stories as Overlord, No Game No Life, KonoSuba, Re:Zero and so many others...could it be getting worse?
Avatar made by JSPicturePlace. Hit him up!
/ jspictureplace
Support me on Patreon lol:
/ watthewut
Or check out my Ko-fi:
ko-fi.com/W7W7...
Visit my website:
wtwhivemind.com
Follow WattheWut on Twitter:
/ watthewut
Check out my kitsu:
kitsu.io/users...
DISCLAIMER
Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
I might think your vid is better than mine but ur still lame
Get back in your grave you corpse
@@WatTheWut Can't we all just... get along? ;-)
@@Asehpe I'm sure they're actually friends. Usually TH-camrs like this just fuck with eachother in a friendship type of way. They don't mean it, you don't have to worry
@@WatTheWut How can Homura make another wish when she is already a magical girl ?..the wish to become a devil
@@jidhindharanm.p9351 her wish is to be the ONE who protect madoka, it didn't came true, until she became a demon to protect the God from the world
"the road to hell is paved with good intentions"
Thats deep
@@jow932 we already know it's deep dood
actually that is so true
and the road to heaven is paved with bad intentions,
it is ultimately through selfishness that we do good,
And the opposite is true for heaven.
I think Homura's actions in Rebellion also make sense if you consider what EXACTLY it means for one to become a witch, and that is the loss of their purpose/wish. We only really get a look into Sayaka's and Homura's magical girl to witch cycles, but they both lose the things they truly wished for. Sayaka wished for Kyosuke to be healed, not because she truly wanted him to be happy but because she wanted him to return her feelings, and when he continued to shut her out instead of being indebted to her, she lost her purpose and fell into despair. The same happened with Homura: when Madoka wished to save the world and disappeared from it, Homura could no longer go back to meet and protect her, and thus her purpose was lost. She also began to lose sight of her wish just before Madoka made hers in the series finale, when Homura began to realize she would never save her and that it was pointless to try.
Sayaka, when Madoka becomes the Law of Cycles, sees the error of her ways in the end: how not only was her wish at its core selfish, but how it was foolish and naive of her to expect Kyosuke to ever have feelings for her when she never spoke up. Despite how she rags on him a little bit for his density, she still wishes him and Hitomi real, unconditional happiness. Homura never makes this revelation.
Ironically, by saving Homura, Madoka ultimately condemns her. By erasing herself from the world, Madoka contradicts Homura's entire reason for ever becoming a magical girl in the first place, and in so doing paves the way for Homura to inescapably fall into despair. Homura's turn in Rebellion, however, is also ironic--she splits up the Law of Cycles to keep Madoka for herself, driving an even bigger wedge between them, but if she had simply surrendered herself to the Law of Cycles, she could have been with Madoka as she desired. The Law of Cycles, through Sayaka and Bebe, is implied to be a sort of paradise for magical girls where Madoka can manifest, and Homura could have met her in that place again.
But this series doesn't hinge on happiness. :^)
Actually, the happy ending was only temporary. They failed to deal with the actual problem which is Kyube.
So instead of getting everything she wants, Homura gives it up in order to gain the power to protect everyone through betrayal.
This wasn't the ending that she wanted. In the end she always chooses to sacrifice herself for others.
She doesn't only care about Madoka. She does care about all the other girls, but in the end she probably felt that she didn't have what it takes to save all of them. When she finally gained "God" power, she rewrote things in a way that would make them happy. But how could she have known what would've made them happier if she was only focused on Madoka?? If you look at the changes, she clearly thought very deeply about what led to the unhappiness of each and every one of them.
She's definitely a hero. And I think that manifesting a ridiculous power like time travel/manipulation is proof.
Just a correction, Madoka's wish for saving the universe (yes, universe, alien maho shoujos exist too) was also a selfless wish with selfish intent, she admited that she felt worthless/useless and wanted to be important, and being the savior, well... guess what? she got her *Selfish* wish after all.
everyone is selfish, it's better to assume than pretend.
Holy sheet these likes. Thanks.
Unetéro Kenora she doomed the world for the expense of the temporary happiness of some
@@nisankajayasekara7803 who? madoka? she saved a lot of lives with her wish, you talking about homura? she did that because more sooner than later kyuubey would find how to control madoka's powers and return to the original system of witches, she did the necessary to save, even if their friends hate her for it.
Very true. Also, Madoka damned the universe with a now substandard system of counteracting entropy in the result of her wish. Fighting wraiths are no where near as effective as the previous system with witches. In return for saving magical girls, she closed the distance of the world and universe to it's doom than it was in before, making the wish quite imperfect in reality. It only truly benefited magical girls. Selflessness can be argued....
@@TackyAnimootions
In all honesty, it may not be a selfless wish for herself, but saving humanity at the cost of the universe is very selfish and arrogant of us. STILL, I don't object to it, she saved innocent people from the mental torture of being a witch, and when entropy kills the universe no one will be alive here to experience that anyway.
I thought that since madoka's god power is so big she could say 'fuck you' to entropy and create energy from nothing and save the universe, but her wish really limits her powers. like a colorful bird encaged.
Kyuubey intent was good, his/they methods were terrible .-.
@@TackyAnimootions : Nope. She made a more stable and fair system that eliminated lots of the bad feelings between the magical girls and the Incubators. At no point is it ever stated that the Incubators aren't getting ENOUGH energy in order to 'save the universe' (assuming that's what they are really doing, but their little disappearing act when Madoka becomes Gretchen in episode 10 might throw their honesty into question). I forget who, but one of the main creatives on this series said the Incubators are meant to represent a toxic form of utilitarianism, which he sees is one of the big problems with those running this world.
You hit the nail on the head with this one... this is probably one of the best interpretations of the series I’ve seen bravo
I think that Homura IS a god, but just a demon-god, and her case is the exact opposite of Modoka's, with the same ending: Becomes a god, effects world forever.
Essentially she transcended and became a deity just the same as Madoka. Light cannot exist without darkness, and darkness cannot exist without light. They need each other to define each other.
Madoka: I wanna die so everyone else can be saved
Homura: I want to be with Madoka whether we live or die
It's more like Homura wants Madoka to be happy.
But in Rebellion, Homura's intention changes to: I want Madoka to be happy and safe whether I live or die.
Isn't that why she considers herself to be Madoka's possible enemy? She's sacrificing her relationship with Madoka. Seriously, how can she be together with Madoka if the two of them become enemies? Homura's self-loathing gets worse and now she thinks she doesn't deserve Madoka anymore. If anything, I can only see in the next movie that Homura tries to stay away from Madoka and avoid her as much as possible, and only observes her from far distance, and worst of all, willing to be destroyed by her. She just doesn't care anymore.
Comprise huh, I think Homura just presented that at the end of rebellion everyone was alive and happy, Mami not alone anymore, Sayaka and Kyouko finding happiness from each other, Madoka technically still keeps every magical girl from becoming witches and Homura gets what she wants to be with Madoka, So does that mean it technically ended in happy one? Everyone gets what they want? I think? This reeeeeally needs a sequel that will answer everyone prayers or just destroy them
I know its a 4 year comment but still
There is a person who is not happy and that is on purpose
Homura doesn't allow herself to be happy, she purposely antagonizes the other girls and distances herself from Madoka because she sees herself as the villain who will be defeated in the end. She who betrayed Madoka doesn't deserve to be happy
This shows with her familiars throwing tomatoes at her while talking to Sayaka showing that everything she said to her was a lie
Homura is basically following the advice that Madoka's mother said in the anime that sometimes it's better to make a mistake for your friend even if he doesn't understand why and mistakes your intentions.
RuPaul: *”If you can’t love yourself, how in the hell are you gonna love anybody else? CAN I GET AN AMEN?”*
I always wonder why the girls did not make wishes that both helped others and themselves.
I...finally understand the story of madoka magical! Thank you so much WattheWut I loved this amime but it was so confusing beforehand. Now I know and love it even more because of how beautiful it truly is
Madoka Magica was a messed up but hopeful anime.
Really messed me up but made me see things in another light (or dark).
I dunno man, between Homura's initial willingness to die in the labyrinth to protect Madoka, the clara dolls, the flower scene, the epilogue, and listening to Homura's final words again, I can't help but feel like you're making homura's actions out to be a little more selfish than I think they really are.
Edit: I also believe that Homura giving Madoka her red ribbons back at the end of the movie signified Homura accepting the real Madoka for who she is and not just an idealized copy that she can be possessive of, even if that means they'll eventually be at odds with each other in the future.
If that were the case homura would have accepted madoka’s choice and left her to be the law of cycles instead of taking that away from her. The real madoka was the one that isn’t affected by Homuras idealistic beliefs of her. The whole reason why homura did what she did was that she believed what madoka was doing to herself was horrible and didn’t think she had the mental fortitude to make that wish even though she did. If homura loved madoka, she would have respected her wishes, not take it away from her and try to give her an idealistic world that is fragile at heart.
It’s like someone’s lover is in a coma because of a terminal illness that caused them pain. If the lover said “if I ever end up in a coma or in a situation where you could pull the plug then pull it” but then the person decides to not do that, become a doctor to find a cure, and keeps this person on life support. Do you think they made a choice out of the kindness of their heart? Or out of selfishness for their lover?
@Covered Donuts "Homura didn't think she had the mental fortitude to make that wish, even though she did."
That's wrong, actually. At the end of the flower field scene, Homura directly tells Madoka "When the time comes, you do have the strength to make that decision. You're far kinder and stronger than you know." Homura is far more self-aware than I feel some people give her credit for.
She's knows that Madoka is strong-willed, but that doesn't change the fact that she wouldn't have left her friends and family behind it she didn't have a self-imposed obligation to become a savior. "Mata Ashita" was proof enough back in 2011, and that point was driven home again in the movie.
@@covereddonuts1279 Hi I know this is an old comment and I mean no disrespect in responding, but I take issue with this "If homura loved madoka, she would have respected her wishes, not take it away from her and try to give her an idealistic world that is fragile at heart." Although shes been through the same month several times, Homura is still a 14 yr old girl. She's still a child. This child had her friend go away and permanently become the Law of Cycles. And that friend's family, friends, etc don't even know that she really existed anymore and she cant just go see them. I don't think simply because she disagreed with Madoka's decision that means that she didnt really truly love her. In real life you can love someone and make a decision that people think is incorrect or wrong. Adults make mistakes in love and Homura is still just a kid who went through the same month a bunch of times and made a forceful decision that many people see as being wrong. In truth we don't know if Madoka was truly right in what she ultimately did, maybe she could have made a different wish that would have still brought about some kind of proper resolution. But again, ultimately she did still clearly love Madoka, she just made a particular choice.
@@covereddonuts1279 Hi I know this is an old comment and I mean no disrespect in responding, but I take issue with this "If homura loved madoka, she would have respected her wishes, not take it away from her and try to give her an idealistic world that is fragile at heart." Although shes been through the same month several times, Homura is still a 14 yr old girl. She's still a child. This child had her friend go away and permanently become the Law of Cycles. And that friend's family, friends, etc don't even know that she really existed anymore and she cant just go see them. I don't think simply because she disagreed with Madoka's decision that means that she didnt really truly love her. In real life you can love someone and make a decision that people think is incorrect or wrong. Adults make mistakes in love and Homura is still just a kid who went through the same month a bunch of times and made a forceful decision that many people see as being wrong. In truth we don't know if Madoka was truly right in what she ultimately did, maybe she could have made a different wish that would have still brought about some kind of proper resolution. But again, ultimately she did still clearly love Madoka, she just made a particular choice.
How I see it:
The cup is always full of air and Water. Compromises are the reason why I see the world as it is.
This is hands down the best Madoka analysis I've ever seen
I really enjoyed this video and the Mistaken Burden video. I love the Madoka Magica series, but these analytical videos just INCREASED my appreciation for the series even more!
I may be a year late but I genuinely do appreciate how much thought was put into this amazingly put together video and after reading/watching other peoples views and interpretations on the show, this was the video that was the final nail that gave me the proper closure that I wanted to hear! :)
so this video is basically telling me madoka magica is evangelion but with magical girls in terms of both being a dark remix of the genre but also in its themes of loving yourself and taking care of yourself
Ironically enough though, Homura's most selfish wish of having God/Madoka to herself is what overthrew entropy while Madoka's most selfless wish would have eventually led to the universe running out of energy and the end of existence itself. I don't know if this implies that the most selfish wishes would have been the better ones to make, but this irony created a very interesting narrative!
18:23
"without love directed inwards, the power of love only has the potential to corrupt"
Whoa
"How can you love another when you can't love yourself" hits uncomfortably close to home even now that im in my 30s....
Yours is the video with the better thesis. Well done
This was a really good analysis of such a deep show! Thanks!
Editing is superb on both of these vids. Super happy to see another collab :D
Man i love this video so much, i actually shed some tears
This video is criminally underrated
Lots of dope words, mate. I didn't understand a thing.
A Madoka analysis in mid 2019? What a blessing. I did love this video, but ironically I disagree in a key argument; Homura's selfishness. In my view, and backed by two essential scenes from the movie (flower field dialogue and Homura's dialogue with Kyubey), I think it's very clear that Homura didn't purely act out of selfishness. It may even be more selfless than Madoka. And let's not forget that Madoka's wish didn't change much _in practise_. It only gave Magical girls a "better" afterlife. On the other hand, in Homura's world, the concept of magical girls doesn't exist in the first place, freeing these girls from the incredible amounts of despair they would be facing regardless of their fate as witches or being absorbed by the Law of Cycles. I'd say that Homura did more good than Madoka from this point of view. But she still respected herself, too, by finally fulfilling her desire - being together with Madoka. So in my eyes, Homura grew from a meek person hating herself to a strong (and maybe a little bit strict) person who started loving herself. This aspect is backed by the tons of Nietzsche references spread throughout the movie.
Also, I just need to say this, I love how you highlighted Madoka's mom with her wisdom because I think she sometimes goes a bit underrated. With that little screentime, she still manages to prove herself to be a fantastic character.
Well, Madoka is still pretty much a thing, especially considering Magia Record.
EveRosell True. Maybe I'm easily excitable but I'm really happy to see content still being made about Madoka. And even if it's "just a gacha adaption" I love how beautifully Shaft has been animating MagiReco till now.
I am interested to see how the plot will be adapted (cause many changes were made here and there).
And yes, agree, Record is very pretty.
One thing though, the Concept movie shows that YES, there are still Magical girls in Homura's world, but If I remember she's making the INCUBATORS take in all those emotions and despair so either way, You can be a magical girl or not and you won't end up a witch because Homura also said "I only took a small sliver of it" Meaning the Law of Cycles TECHNICALLY STILL exists. She just took Madoka out of that.
Brah, i subbed to your channel thanks to this vid, the opening clip is ❤❤🔥. AMAZING VIDEO
If I can understand this any test in my future would be easy
wonderful video, the editing and research and accuracy and passion are highly respectable in this video. Great job! You earned a subscriber!
Always wondered why I connected so much with this show
I guess I could see all the girl's self hatred reflected in myself ^^;;
Bro are you okay ?
You should probably have that checked on.
this is literally amazing good job
Craftsdwarf’s video is gone! I really wanted to share it with someone who just finished the series
Interesting take - namely the love and/or self loathing bit.
Dropping your glass does not make you a badass, it make you blind.
If Homura loved herself, perhaps she could've understood Madoka's feelings and wishes and convince Madoka to also love herself and tell her that she doesn't need to make the ultimate sacrifice to save everyone. Actually, she should convince Madoka to not become a witch because that's just escaping from the pain and suffering of telling people how you really feel without having to hear their feedback that could potentially hurt you. The best solution for Homura and Madoka is to love themselves and not become magical girls in the first place. If you really love yourself, you wouldn't need to become a magical girl in the first place.
Impressive video.
finally someone who says Madoka right
Excellent video.
Damn, son....... best video ever, period!
This is better than thinking homura is bad af
You're a genius :000
Homura is not wrong but isn't entirely right either.
Madoka should not be the cycle, it’s a duck tape fix. Magical girls shouldn’t be a thing, so Homura rescues her humanity. Seems like her god being still exists. In the newest timeline Madoka isn’t a magical girl, in the movie she even says she doesn’t really like being the cycle
Wow this was just wow good video
Kyoko never became witch she died but she never fallen into dispare.
I didn't watched the movie but dang.
ok, thats nice and all... but what the fuck was happening to Incubator at the end?
There's gonna be a new madoka magica movie. I hope to watch a new video like this based on the new movie if possible.
Yeah The Lizard Girl
You said that all of these girls' problem was that they didn't love themselves. You 're right. That left me with a thought though. Why would someone who loved themselves as they were make a wish to change? The answer is they wouldn't. And that is the true evil of the incubators' plot, of their apathy. The system is set up so the only ones who fall prey to it are those who are already vulnerable
I thought that was the whole point! If I remember right, the incubator once said that more emotion means more energy to be released, therefore the universe could be sustained for a longer time. So by getting kids that are already emotionally vulnerable, you get higher output of energy, therefore energy to sustain the universe heh
Yup, precisely what Kyubey means when he says a girl "qualifies" .
So that's why Hitomi wasn't chosen!
DANG.
It is very interesting that, with this insidious plot in mind, Kyuubi stated that there was once a magical girl who lasted, despite all this vulnerability and exploitation, and managed to live till 30 or something... Incubators are really some kind of devil cause wtf
The entire show is based on a simple logic, all action is reaction.
The universe tends to equalize itself to 0, so if you create happiness, an equal amount of despair will comeback to you.
Sayaka is the most wise of them all! XD
''The entire show is based on a simple logic, all action is reaction.''
Did Newton reincarnated into a Phoenix ??
Am I remembering it wrong or did kyubey say something like this like “any wish you make is warping the universe so the universe tries to snap back and correct yourself so any wish will fall apart”
except happiness is subjective,
for example some people love seeing people suffer, or even relish in geting hurt or killed,
its also possible to stay happy regardless of situation it really is subjective, the universe is more of a chaos theory where everything is random,
Homura created happiness for all that live in her world. So it's likely that everyone in her world would despair just as she did.
Moral of the story, Homura and Madoka should get a relationship counselor and teenage girls shouldn't be making deals with Intergalactic mephistopheles wannabes
Madoka is straight.
Yet another issue.
@@yoursinisterdoge2785 Evidence? The Wraith Arc Manga says that the reason for Homura retaining her memories of the Old World is that her and Madoka's "strong reciprocal feelings" literally caused a miracle to happen.
@@yoursinisterdoge2785 ok where does it say that? The series never shows her having a crush on a guy, and it seems near the beginning she has sort of a crush on Mami (though that could have just been their mutual desire to not be lonely)
@@yoursinisterdoge2785 /Says whooooooo?/
Hot take: romantic love and platonic love are equal. Just because someone really cares about someone else doesn’t mean they want to get in their pants.
Imagine if Homura and Madoka could love themselves
That’d be like if Shinji could
@@tatarsauce6314 Shinji does now, though. That's why he rejected Instrumentality.
@@yoursinisterdoge2785 Actually Shinji just knows that he can love himself as he still stated at the end of the movie that he hates himself.
@@tatarsauce6314 ENTER THE FUCKING ROBOT SHINJI!!!
-sorry couldnt resist-
@@uneterostardust8233 He would be entering his own mom, which is incest...
They both love each other so much more than they love themselves that they both feel unworthy of the other.
I loved the comment about how Homura would be perfectly fine with death if she was still together with Madoka. In that scene shown, Homura just flat out argues in favour of becoming witches, but only if both of them do. The only reason Madoka wasn't on board was because she loved everyone else as strongly as they each loved each other and couldn't risk sacrificing anyone other than herself.
"When neither of them loved themselves, how could either of them understand the feelings and wishes of the other..."
Holy shit... Hoooly shit... That's it. Their whole dynamic makes sense now! But... Damn that's heartbreaking...
That line was.... *perfect*
that hit me in the face pretty hard, I had some very hard times with depression and I have almost none self-worth, I just started feeling a little love for myself after long years of suffering.
And, I still didn't care for myself as long as someone else loved me, and I could give them my love.
Madoka's mom teachings are a big punch on the gut for me.. in a weirdly good way '-')
well, if acting like you have secret admirers is a good way to feel self worth then here I goo
This part hit me in a way I didn't think this video could...
But on another note (also don't wanna be that person but) did your comment include a Jojo reference? Lol
I feel like there entire problematic dynamic could be solved in a couple quick conversations
Yeah it makes sense now
Madoka content in 2019... thank you.
Magia Record just isn't enough to quench our thirst for Megucas and Despair
Watch out for Magia Record, the anime on 4th of January 2020 !!
@@nellyd6344 the magia record anime is going to (at one point or another) tie in to the main story. Change my mind
@@franciscoaparicio434 I dunno. If it's based around the game, it's gonna take place in a different alternate "universe" in which Madoka's wish doesn't really apply.
Nelly D it’s bombbbbbbnbbbb!
Everyone: love conquers all.
Homura: allow me to introduce myself.
Cortez Films *Homura
Kyubey: Oh, does it now? *twirls non-existent handle-bar mustache* We'll see about that :3
I would say Homura is the embodiment of that phrase actually
Homura is the embodiment of love conquers all
Everyone: love conquers all.
Homura: Yes.
People often skip over the fact that without homura there is no God madoka her reseting the timeline over and over is what gave madoka the karma to have her wish granted while madoka's name is in the title it's always been homura's story
I don't know. Ask "The Legend of Zelda". :P
@@Medulan45 since this is made at 2019, how about asking Dororo too
Objection! I like to believe that the story has always been about Madoka! Yes, the Madoka Magica wouldn't exist if it I wasn't for Homura being gay and down bad, but Madoka is the centre of the story, everything Homura did, is for her, everything that happened in the series is because of her existence. It's just my own opinion but I disagree when others say it's Homura's story because it's always been about Madoka, and for Madoka.
In regards to Homura's decision in Rebellion, I think you're forgetting about two crucial points.
First is that the Incubators we're still a threat and there was absolutely nothing stopping them from trying their stunt over and over again until they successfully take control of the Law of Cycles.
My second point is at Homura wasn't in the right state of mind, remember, the experience of being a Witch is pretty much mind rape. Absolutely no one could go through something like that without being affected.
It's also pretty clear that Homura isn't really happy with what she's done. The Clara Dolls (familiars that are representations of her self hatred) are throwing Tomatoes at her and killing themselves, and the film ends with Homura dancing off a cliff.
I think there's more than enough evidence that she's out right suicidal.
Indeed
How are those little rabbits a threat anyway, they constantly get destroyed and yet they think they can control Madoka.
Even at the start of errr... The very first time she met Madoka, I think she might be suicidal. Then Madoka became her light, and she now wanted Madoka, to be happy, to be living, to be with her. I was like "damn right" when he said Homura wanted to possess Madoka. Yes she did love her, but I'd say her love is quite unhealthy.
Good points!
Do you happen to have a scene in mind where the Clara dolls kill themselves?
I guess I always overlooked that and didn't notice
@@abcxyz9852 when Sayaka is confronting Homura at the end of the movie. Right after the dolls threw tomatoes at Homura.
Mania, in it's original Greek form, was known as a form of love, but not a positive one (unlike eros, philia, or agape). Mania was a consuming, obsessive love, a love that sought to control and/or own a person, to keep them close and never let them go, regardless of the other person's desires, and even dismissive of their thoughts and feelings. With that definition of mania, Homura fits it to a T.
@bruce wayne I had thought that mania was the word, because I did look it up, but I'm not a linguistics expert by any means and maybe I should've looked further. I did know about the other forms of love (all seven others) and even that some manic love can be caused by an inbalance of ludus and eros, but I left them out because I didn't find them particularly revelant. But you're right in the way it started, but thanks to the movie, sadly manic is where it ended up.
I guess so, Homura did become a yandere in Rebellion.
But I stand by the fact Homura had a good intention all along, it’s not her fault.
As a greek I have to say that while the word mania means an obsessive love, our people hardly ever use it nowadays for this meaning. They use mania for other meanings such us, psychosis, obsession, fury, hatred and a weather phenomenon to its extremes metaphorically. The word or better phrasing we use for obsessive love, is just that. An obsessive love. But, well done for the research you did. :)
THIS! Fuck, I kept forgetting the term but this is it. And Mania is seen as a horrific emotion.
@@Scailalia ΑΓΑΠΑΜΕ ΜΑΝΤΟΚΑ ΜΑΤΖΙΚΑ
The conclusion: You need to love yourself first before you can love others. Otherwise, the love you want to give isn´t grounded. Interestedly my master thesis about ppl with borderline deals with the same kind of topic. :)
What's your master thesis abt?
Well I mean just because I don’t love myself doesn’t mean I don’t and can’t love my friends and family
@@AkireraStraberri3 It's a shakey love because you might not think you're worthy of any love in return, which will sour your relationship with people. No one wants to deal with a perpetual debbie downer.
@Pubg islam Malaysia are you having a stroke?
And not hide you're feelings I guess and think everything is either black or white c::
Sure Homura hated herself, but she was the only one to never regret her wish.
She knew exactly what the deal is, when she made the wish and judged, that it was still worth it.
She loved Madoka in the first palce, because of her selflessness, decided to protect her and just never backed away
She hated herself for not being good enough.
At "It's all right, Homura-chan" she was proven right, that all she did was worth it, but her wish was not yet fulfilled.
The exact moment Homura decided to take Madoka's powers is the flower field scene (just watch it again).
My interpretation is that despite hating herself for it, Homura accepted her role (devil) as long as it saved Madoka.
She just centered her morality around it and said fuck you to The World, Good and Evil
Thinking further about it Homura's wish was the only wish that wasn't actually granted(of the main 5), that is until the end of Rebellion, for now at least
@@variedadesonline3926 Her wish was almost granted she wished to meet Madoka again and this time to be stronger to protect her.
I'm sure Homura didn't know what outcome her wish would have
“The power of love can only corrupt if it is never directed inward” I had to stop and re-hear this three times a great work.
But love only for oneself is equally destructive. A balance of love both outward and inward is necessary
That's incredible. If Madoka did what her mother said in the first episode, _none of this would have happened!_
Moral of the story: mOtHeR kNoWs bESt
@@spaghetti5914 I hate this comment, but you have a point...So I have too.......
@@figurefactory5299 don't worry I hate it too
Wait what did her mom say again? 👁👄👁
@@_once_upon_a_toast_1109 "I don't have secret admirers!" "But you should act and behave like you do, that's a secret every pretty girl should know."
Madoka acts like she doesn't matter exactly counter to what her mom told her, and because of that, she didn't understand why Homura would care about her.
I wonder if the show was an allegory for heroes in real life. Not many heroes get recognized, often losing themselves to the work, in pursuit of an unattainable goal. Modoka would be a representation of the self-doubter who rises to the top, and Homura being the follower, who only leads herself more astray, witches as the disheartened former heroes who became so disheartened, only others can salvage their work to improve, moving the cycle. Just a theory.
I think it’s about capitalism
I'd say Homura didn't necessarily want to "possess" Madoka. Rather, Homura wanted Madoka to be happy (as in have a happy life happy not being satisfied with sacrificing everything happy) and would have hypothetically been okay with something like sacrificing herself or otherwise being separated from Madoka, but since Madoka's own wish is to save everyone even at the expense of her own happiness, then Homura can only achieve her own wish by restraining Madoka or by keeping the shitty parts of the world hidden from her.
But yeah, this conflict is ultimately "I'll sacrifice myself to save you (and everyone else)" "no I'll sacrifice myself to save you (because fuck everyone else they're delusional pkers)" "no I'll..." and the only satisfactory solution I could see was maybe some sort of compromise or working together to find a solution that doesn't require sacrifice.
@bruce wayne The wording of Homura's wish doesn't matter. There is no wish without a cost. Madoka's ability to protect Homura and everyone else comes with a cost, be it dieing to defeat Walpurgisnacht, running out of grief seeds (or choosing to give them away) and witching out or being mercy killed, or wiping herself out from existence. Homura can only gain the power to protect Madoka by taking on the cost, which for this particular wish is intense emotional trauma and disillusionment with both the world and ultimately herself. It just took Homura until Rebellion to realize that. If Homura made any other wish to help Madoka, Homura would still be taking on a cost to protect Madoka from her own wish's cost, and Homura would still be putting inflicting harm onto herself and thus arguably be undoing Madoka's efforts to protect her from harm.
Anyway, yes, their wishes are paradoxical, since they desire the wellbeing of the other, but they can't achieve their wishes without sacrificing their own wellbeing.
Madoka made many wishes. It seems the first one was "to not be shy anymore",then save a cat's life,then turn Sayaka into a magical girl again,then help out other magical girls. The result was always the same,she either died or became a witch.
Just one wish was for herself. Changing her personality a tiny bit,she was still kind and cheerful,she was just less shy. And then all her wishes have no benefit for her. Save an unknown's cat life,having Sayaka back but how sure she is it won't happen again?,sometimes she didn't even KNOW the magical girls she helped.
All her wishes,so selfless... And it seems it was all because she didn't loved herself,and she thought *she didn't **_deserve_** a wish for **_HER_*
Moral of the story: Don't give reality-warping powers to goddamn teenagers.
Qyuube says as much...right before homura bitches them into an eternity of servitude
In the beginning Homara was a shy girl when you remember the scene is framed that madoka is standing on the left and Homara to the right but after all she is been through in the future, Homara is now standing on the left and madoka to the right therefore creating The mirror effect.
Slyness = confidence
Confidence = slyness
It insane how someone adolescent allows since extreme thoughts of absolute. There passion they drive us our youth doesn't exactly feel the same older. Watthewut video really does speak the distance people will go to without understand how to love. Congrats on 10k
Love, like any emotion, left uncontrolled, & unchecked is a dangerous force of desctruction just awaiting the right opportunity to express itself. In some cases, with deadly consequences.
Parts of this video could almost read like a bible reading lol. Spreading the good word of Godoka amiright?
But bringing up that none of the girls loved themselves hit different, damn :( it was a great point and overall I really loved the analysis you gave
Homura's story is so depressing but so interesting, imagine loving someone so deeply that you would pass several lifetimes trying to save them but at the end you know you will never be together, like it was impossible for you two to exist at the same time, so now that deep love becomes an obsession and that obsession could destroy the person you love the most...sounds horrifying if you ask me
wdym by obsession?
homura is turned into the devil to protecc madoka/the law of cycle from incubator/kyubey
@@aiya5777 it was suggested at almost the end of rebellion that Homura wanted madoka to take her so they could finally be together, only Homura and Madoka. This is really my own perspective but i felt like Homura only wanted to save Madoka in the first place so she could haver her for herself
@@majito-6176 before homura chose the devil path,
she was ready to kill herself for the sake of preventing the law of cycle from popping up in kyubey's presence
kyubey told homura that as long as he could confirm the existence of the law of cycle, he might be able to control her one day
homura obviously quite angry and didnt want anyone to threat madoka's life, but madoka and the others stopped her
then homura had no choice
but to subdue kyubey by becoming the devil
Your channel name
is exactly my reaction to the Madoka Magica plot
Samia dosita
Ari aditia
Sori arito asora...
It is not enough to love another, if you cannot first love yourself.
Madoka: I think the world is precious!
Homura: I think you are precious
I hope the FBI person that's seeing what I'm watching learns to love themselves.
And is also emotionally broken after making them watch all of Madoka Magica and Rebellion.
Same.
I hope my fbi agent is okay with me re watching the intro madoka and homura talking
Love is Destruction
Did not expect the Evangelion route on this film. Thank you to you and Craftsdwarf for finally getting me to watch it. Im astounded fans did not like it. I never felt the original was an exactly happy or conclusive ending. My biggest thought after the original was "Well, what about Homura?" And this film followed it up in a very satisfying manner, as you both have so eloquently put. Besides, it has some of the coolest art direction and audio/visual presentation I have ever seen. It was a very intense cinematic experience!
Wow. That was amazing. Every time u watch a video of yours, a new thought about an anime enters my mind. I learn new possible aspects to a show and my appreciation for an anime grows.
I never thought about how powerful the power of love is, amazing job.
This videos makes so much sense! But I must admit because you’re talking so fast it made a little confusing.
However, I love the passion behind it! It was amazing! This video was beautiful!!!
This is just an Intense Lesbian Yuri anime.
Yeah lol XD
So much talking,so much videos and debates and it is "JUST" lesbian anime ?
@@damesayo4656 God your panties is surely wet
@@lebro4401 And that was not humorus, but very, very rude and vulgar even. Not everyone react like you do and can see more, video above is an example. Some people also can be asexual, so do not be so sure ==
Take care of your underwear, I beg you pardon, not of some strangers in internet. I was not rude to ya, just surprised.
@@damesayo4656 Calm your tiddies holy shit. It's the internet.
Very interesting take on the Madoka-Homura relationship, and one that gives me a lot of food for thought. Just one question: do you think that your thesis of a midpoint ('golden mean') between Madoka's selfless love and Homura's selfish love is a new idea introduced by Rebellion? At the end of the TV series, the impression I had was that Madoka's selfless love seemed to be the show's answer to how to break the magical girl cycle. Madoka's sacrifice was framed as good, she was wiser and more powerful than Homura (see e.g. their final conversation), and Homura appeared to be moving on ('...and that is why... I keep fighting!" were her -- and the show's -- final words). As if the original intended message was that selfless love is better, and that sacrificing oneself for others is a good thing (a very Japanese thing at least). Then came Rebellion, and the yin-yang of selfish-selfless raised its head. What do you think?
@bruce wayne Could be, but without the Incutabors and their isolation field, what would she have done?
@@Asehpe die??? because she meets madoka anyways regardless?? are you people stupid?
@@50bottlesofpinklemonade But the Madoka she would meet this way couldn't be saved, and Homura wanted a Madoka she could save. What are you, stupid? ;-)
This video is really something you know? I love how you address selfworth and selflove as the cause and confliction that moved everything, and that's so important because for the things that you mentioned and described, I love this show so much.
The path to self love is so convoluted and complicated even if you're not a teenager. Sometimes we're stuck in this mindset for so long that we can't tell anymore what love and hate really are, and this is depicted in the show and the video oh so well!
Thank you so much for sharing this!!
This is such a fantastic analysis of their wishes and the series as a whole. Great job!
I’d love for Homura and Madoka to fight while screaming their ideologies at each other kinda like Sasuke and Naruto
Still better love story than Twilight.
When the video ended I just leaned back, let out an elongated "DAAAAMN" and clicked like. This is SO good, I honestly dont have the vocabulary to describe how this video made me feel. This was amazing, thank you so much for you work.
Amazing essay, I knew the writing of Madoka Magica was genius but I never viewed it this symbolistically and didn't thought about the adults' speeches that much.
This is the most beautiful thing to come out of MM, and that's saying a lot. That's truly and deeply profound. I was one of those who said Homura did nothing wrong, and technically, I still am, but the singular argument that Madoka is reckless and suicidal and Horuma is right to rescue her from it doesn't hit the thematic head on the head, where NONE of the magical girls truly loves themselves. Not only do I think it's true, I wish there wasn't this sense of lingering that needs a comment on this. I wish Urobatchi would have come out after Rebellion and said: Consider this. None of the magical girls love themselves, Madoka is only the most visible.
This story is important, like deeply spiritually important. It's one thing to like something, it's another to know it's a reflection of truth. And for that, I thank you, I really do.
That moment when your waifu becomes a goddess so you turn yourself into satan to stop her from suffering like a mad boss.
This vid is rlly good! This helped contextualize why Rebellion was needed; to tell that selfless love without self-love will end in despair.
Homura clearly never heard that song "If you love me let me go"
Once you make a wish you’re already a witch. Homura is able to become a demon not just because she took a piece of the law of cycles but because she was able to embrace herself as a witch
God, I love this show.
The apathy of the incubators, the plot, the story, the feeling of love that is both power and corruption, the value of love, the layers are all too perfect. It's a beautifully presented show. Having a wish come true does not mean it will come true and you will have to learn the hard way. It's such a good show.
"Love is the world's infinite mutability; lies, hatred, murder even, are all knit up in it; it is the inevitable blossoming of its opposites, a magnificent rose smelling faintly of blood"
Moral of the story: You can't love someone in a healthy way if you don't love yourself
I so hope that the spin-off anime in the works is enough of a success that they'll FINALLY make the movie that the "concept movie" hinted at.
I think you kind of got to it in an indirect way near the end, but I always find it troublesome when people frame Madoka's wish in such a simplistic black and white way, especially when they in the next breath deeply analyze another character. Madoka's wish wasn't selfless, and she didn't *really* save anyone. Yes of course not turning into witches is a marked improvement, but they're still children duped into a contract that 100% guarantees an early if not gruesome death, on top of trauma from fighting literal nightmares.
I liked the conclusion you reached, however.
Now I'm curious, and magia record is out now. What would be the perfect wish in which everyone benefits. One that is not entirely selfish, but at the same time selfless. One that has kept in mind the fact that you love yourself and wouldn't change anything about yourself or your circumstances. S wish that, while paradoxical in nature, is a wish without cost.
I wish for entropy problems to be solved- boom you become a strong enough witch or chain react the witchification of a hundred magical girls.
I wish for world peace- entropy has expanded or there is a greater threat that forces others to get along.
I wish to control my witch-you control your witch form, but you're stuck in that form forever.
I wish to never become a witch- You die before you become a witch, or your despair is transferred to the adjacent magical girl.
Tbh there really wasn't that much of an option. If she wished that the system never existed not only would the universe stop progressing the wishes of the many magical girls would've been abandoned. People like mami wouldn't even be alive. Like the comment above said, there is pretty much no such thing as a perfect wish that would benefit everyone.
@@obikim11 There might not be a perfect wish, but a subtle one might do more good than harm-one that is blatant in what it wants, how it will benefit the person themselves, and incremental enough not to cause some horrid chain reaction. But girls are often taught to put others before themselves and also to bottle their feelings up (see anything that isn't "ladylike" as an example). Therefore, of course the Incubators would go after teenage girls; they're the most emotionally vulnerable and don't have enough life experience or patience to make a wish that would do the most good with the least harm.
That's a really good point. Madoka had to choose between saving them, or honoring their wishes, and she chose the latter.
@@obikim11 Ultimately any wish made for this motivation would be a wish for a better world than this.
Holy moly this was incredible.