⏳ TIMESTAMPS ⏳ Introduction - 00:00 Chapter 1 - Of Selfish Wishes and Hope 02:48 Chapter 2 - Rebellion, from the Cave to the Übermansch 14:05 Chapter 3 - Homura’s true feelings 23:24 Interlude - On Gen Urobuchi, Camus, and Nietzsche 37:17 Chapter 4 - Encomium of Homura: the Fifteenth Doll 44:58
Hey you mentions they redid Homura transformation scene so it sounded like she reverted a bit. Where can I find the non-cannon version of the scene? I'm having some difficulty tracking it down. Thanks and I love the video essay!
I can honestly say I never tied Madoka's conversation with her mother about intentionally making a 'big mistake' for someone you love to the end of Rebellion. You're right though, it's a central theme of the show, and it fits Rebellion perfectly
aaaaaa I know!!! it's been more than 10 years and people just belive Homura is bad because that's her persona or something, but they didn't get it, like I know madoka has a lot of symbolism the teeth, the chairs, flowers, dolls, even some of the fruits, etc. and some of them will say "it wasn't that good" but, they weren't there. The time it took to analyse each chapter when it was airing because "that's a lot of different chairs in a single room and there is too little people" and others saying "for some reason this reminds me of Faust and I don't know why". Even after, when the DVD and BD where out people looking for different things, like "why the siren and the unicorn?" in the recopilation movies why did they add the cementary scene, what was the purpose, why they need to add bone crunching sounds in the Mami scene. and sometimes is a lot for a 12ep anime. not counting the real life circumstances like the storm that delayed the last episodes. I was there when it was on season, I was there with everyone losing their minds in ep 3, 8, 10. I watched Rebellion in the movie theater. also when people dropped the series in ep 1 because it was too cute. I'll be honest, when the season was starting I watched madoka because Aoki Ume did the desings and then my world was different. Anyways, I really liked all the essay, Homura is misunderstood by people who only see in black and white. and those who refuse too see more because "is not that deep" I would love too see you talking about all the other topics, like the clara dolls, which are an important part in the rebellion plot.
“for some reason it reminds me of faust” i wonder why lmao im so glad you enjoyed this video! people always want to see complex or morally grey characters but when presented with one they suddenly get black and white vision, which is truly a pity. posting this video for public consumption was a bit less nerve-wrecking than i expected, so i think i will be creating more content like this on the mentioned topics! thank you for your comment ✨
What is the symbolism of the chairs? I just started watching the series a few days ago and I pointed it out to my husband how it's weird that there's so many chairs in each room. He's like that's some autistic s*** to notice that😂
The way this essay has shaken me to my CORE. I couldn’t love this show more. Homura, they could never make me hate you.😭 With the upcoming movie hastening us towards the end of their story, I wonder how it will all turn out. I’m scared but hopeful too. I appreciate your memes and knowledge of the hidden in plain sight things I couldn’t understand before. Thank you so much!!! ♥️
Found this video linked on I _think_ Reddit, and have had it saved in my Watch Later for the last few days. Seriously, thank you for this, it's so refreshing. I can't believe that so many fans of a show that explicitly makes a point to reject black and white morality keep falling into it. The philosophical lens you bring has given a contextual framework for many of the things I've picked up on but struggled to articulate concisely. Your friends were very right to suggest you upload your musings ♥ (P.S. the memes were delightful, lol. Glad to see someone else noticed the parallel between Madoka's conversation with her mother and Homura's decision to remake reality as a silver cage to protect her.)
This video is so good in how it thoroughly explores concepts, and i must say i really enjoy the editing especially the choice of clips being shown relating to the topic being spoken!!
First of all I appreciate and admire the courage you had to openly share your feelings about philosophy with us in that intro. I love that, thank you❤ Swcondly, I could talk about philosophy and Madoka all day anyday, as Madoka is one of my top shows of all time. So thank you for making this video, I will savor it to it's fullest extent❤
Hey, I'm late as hell and haven't finished the video yet, but I really like the way you explain things so far and would absolutely listen to you talk about any of the other topics in the description. Like, literally any of them.
What Homura did was evil? Yes. Was she wrong? Hell to the no. You have to take into consideration that Homura stripped Madoka of her own free will. That's....yes? That's kinda evil. However, no one that heavily criticizes Homura has ever taken into consideration that Madoka's decision is just a temporary solution to a complicated problem. And Homura has watched Madoka suffering because of her own decisions and Kyuubei's manipulation over *a HUNDRED* of times. Human mind and soul is only that strong and resilient, you know. If she loses her dreams and hopes is over. And, well, she refuses to give up without a fight. *Anyone who tries to do something over A HUNDRED OF TIMES refuses to give up* so she clings to her sole wish. In the end, she re does her meeting with Madoka, being strong enough to protect her. She doesn't look too happy about it, perhaps facing finally the expectative vs reality of her wish, hence why she falls at the very end of rebellion.
argh now tiis makes me want to make a video essay on madoka magica and honkai impact 3rds parallels n shit but BUT i know its gonna take more than the two years of yours
honestly do it, who cares how long it takes! i have been writing a new one for Ages and sometimes i get discouraged but it’s honestly okay! the process is actually what matters and you’ll never know if you can actually do it or not unless you try 🫶🏻 also it sounds super interesting! i play starrail a little (im more invested in genshin) and never got around to playing/learning more about hi third even tho the yuri compels me so im invested 🤓
Love being the last doll yet unmanifested is much like Hope being the last being in Pandora's box after all the other evils enter the world. It is the state of being that misfortunes must be suffered to attain. No dawn without the night.
everyone who says homura is selfish or a bad, uncaring person makes me think a lot of people watched the show once years ago and didn’t even pay attention
@@fitmotheyap No she's not she hates herself, she focuses on her goal to protect Madoka. She doesn't care what she will become a demon she just wants Madoka to be happy.
Homura in the series: Okay 👍 *she fights wraiths* Homura in Rebellion: Okay 👍 *she throws all mortality, self love and will to live out the window as hard as she can, for Madoka, who obviously told her to stop doing that* On a serious note i think its less "Homura did nothing/everything wrong" or more "Homura tried her best to do what she perceived was right. There was some wrong and some right to her actions."
Oh believe me, there are indeed some of us who ABSOLUTELY nerd out at the thought of philosophical video essays over media ;D I got excited the moment I saw your video title like AWW YISS new Madoka video essay has dropped!! Thanks for the video! You've brought up some points I've never considered before. I love hearing how people interpret Rebellion or Madoka Magica in general - it's so wonderful to have a franchise that can still surprise me years later. It really enables you to have a fresh new perspective for the next time you sit down and watch the series.
I'd almost given up hope on finding a Homura/Rebellion analysis video that wasn't a fecal abortion. I am so happy and impressed to finally, after ten years, have a video I can point to as someone who understands the source and respect the themes. Nice to see critical analysis isn't as dead in the fandom as I had feared. Well done.
I'd be absolutely interested in hearing about everything you cut out, especially more theology about homura and madoka, feminism and femininity in the series, freud’s interpretation of dreams and the symbols present in homulily’s maze, the Clara dolls scene dissection, and the swan lake parallels. (esp the last three, I'm a sucker for ballet parallels/references and I would love for someone to break down and explain homulily's maze with some freud's interpretation because I don't quote understand everything about her labyrinth, as well as every scene with her Clara dolls more in-depth)
I feel this as a fellow ADHD TH-camr. I've also been working on a video for 2 years, so to see this being done really inspires me. You did a fantastic job rationalizing and explaining different perspectives on viewing Homura. The breakdown of Camus and Nietzsche's philosophies was not only educational but also entertaining. I also appreciate the extra detail you took to tie in Sigmund Freud (I totally missed that on my 3 watches). To see it connected gave me an entirely new perspective and opened up further interpretations. Additionally, looking into Gen Urobuchi further reinforces that you really did your research, which speaks for itself! I really liked the quotes you used to back up your argument points. You gave us all something precious here, which is the gift of knowledge itself, so thank you for such a wonderfully put-together video essay :)
thank you so so much for this comment, i appreciate your words sm! also, YOU GOT THIS!! i have been working on another video essay since i posted this one and it truly seems impossible but we got thissss it will be done and posted eventually, i believe in us! 🙌🏻
this!! homura isn't perfect by any means ofc, as none of the girls are, and homura is morally grey for sure. but that doesn't mean that she doesn't have good and genuineness in her, bc she def does.
Still astounds me how little views this video has. I found your channel because your edits are absolutely amazing, and when I saw a video on Madoka Magica (Especially Homura!) AND philosophy, I was instantly hooked. Two of my favourite things. I'm not smart enough to really go into depth about how much I appreciate this essay, but I've been going through a rough time these past few months and I've watched your video numerous times to help me through it. Even though it didn't go viral I hope you know you did an incredible job putting this out there and it's made its impact.
I woke up this morning and I have been thinking of a way to reply all day but I can’t find the words to express how much your words mean to me! I have been struggling with some insecurities about my writing especially so I’m 🥹 Just last night I started working on a new edit for the first time in months and reading this comment this morning gave me the strength to work on it for the whole day 💌 I have been very busy with school this spring and now that I’m on holiday I have been wanting to write another video essay, so stay tuned! it makes me feel so motivated to know people out there enjoy my few videos :’)
@@mimikyuno I'm so happy I was able to make your day a little better!! I can't wait to see your future projects, but no pressure to get them out anytime soon! I'll be excited to watch them no matter what. :D
I love that you mentioned how Rebellion feels like it used The Allegory Of The Cave. Honestly, Rebellion is up there with The Matrix and Dark City in terms of works that use that allegory.
i cannot express how amazing and wonderful and mindblowing this video is. i can honestly say pmmm and homura have shaped me in a lot of ways since i was a child. its been about 11 years since i first watched the anime and fell in love with it and still to this day i find new things to learn and love and wonder about it, thank you so so much for this. im not knowledgable at all when it comes to philosophy so i never couldve made any of these connections if it wasnt for this video. honestly i cried many times while watching lmao i agree so much on everything you said about homura. thank you so so much for this. i dont know if youre still interested in making a video about the topics you left in your description but i would 100% watch numerous videos about every one of them! thank you again and i hope you're well and stay safe
...Wow! this essay really opened my mind. In my country in highschool native language class is basically literature/philosophy/art, but it's taught in such a way, you're better off learning by heart and forgetting rather than understanding it deeper, unless you picked humanities. Here I got taught much, MUCH more about Nietzsche than in school. All we learned about him were some quick notes that most would take as the common misconceptions you mentioned. I'm actually more interested in his work now! I just wanna say, I've loved this anime since I was 14 and it definitely helped me through life, especially with how I sympathised and related to some aspects of the girls, especially Madoka. It's great to hear such insight on Homura's character compared to some other videos I've seen. When I read fanfics that mentioned the dolls by their japanese names I was on a ride, but thanks to them I got to understand her better XD. Thank you for making this! (>
I never really comment on TH-cam videos but this video essay is CRIMINALLY UNDERRATED thank you so much for verbalizing my very own thoughts on Homura and the show's purpose in general!! You are a spectacular creator, don't let your struggles make you think that you aren't :)
This video has to be my favorite youtube video out there. Homura means so much to me i felt (funnily enough) in despair at the search for analisys that didnt unecessarily villanaized Homura and protrayed her in this light of pure evil when she is the most human there is, i may say my hope of finding one has found itself in this video and what a wonderful video. I kid you not i started wanting to cry at some parts of the video because you just get me, you are the analysis of Homura i was looking for, one who questioned what was being presented to us and not just try to guide itself by pre established values such as evil and good and nothing deeper just a yandere with no redemption. i have to admit although i love philosophy im still very young and have barely consumed philosphy texts outside of my school ethics class which has helped me a lot with guiding myself now that ive watched Madoka Magica again I so badly want to get into Nietzsche, i see some ideas of my own in the things you touched of him and i find myself wanting to read about him even more knowing how Homura is influenced by his philosophy. Homura is a character that absolutely deserves all this analysis and more, she is begging to be analyzed yet people only do so between the restricting roles of good and evil, black and white etc etc. Is true, trying to fit Homura into good or evil is a debate that will never get anybody anywhere because she isnt any and trying to give her a dictatory role that doesnt fully capture her will always fail. I srs dont know how else to explain how much this video made me happy; i only watched Madoka Magica two years ago so i wasnt when the fandom was at its prime, but i still love this anime very deeply and specially Homura, a wonderfully crafted character that i will forever treausure, i am beyond in love with this video Homura for best girl indeed also i read the caption and i woud love your take and some topics you didnt finally include in the script, specially the feminism and feminity in madoka magica cause oh boy there is a lot to talk there and is a fresher and certainly more accurate read in my opinion then those edgy dudes who categorize madoka magica as "not like other magical girls" because its not that type of magical girl anime whatever that means considering Madoka Magica is mostly analyzed by guys who find zero to no exposure of feminist topics on madoka magica, i would love to hear your take on it also all those other topics you cut out as well, your thought process is amazing and i love philosophy and madoka magica which luckily is filled with philosophy
i read this comment yesterday morning and it made me smile so much!! i have been so busy with school stuff that i kinda neglected this channel, and your comment made me want to hurry up and finish these last few courses so i can start creating more content ❣️ philosophy is such a great interest to get because i swear to god, once you learnt enough you start seeing references to philosophers and currents of thought everywhere and it’s very satisfying! and about nietzsche: dude wrote like a madman, so if you want to read him i recommend reading from a secondary source (like, someone summarising and explaining one of his texts); but if you want to read the og definitely find a copy with sidenotes that explain what the hell he’s on about! good luck with everything, thank you for your comment! 💌
@@mimikyuno Im glad i was able to make you smile wih my comment, is only fair i comment after hearing such an amazing take on an amazing character, and im glad you feel motivated to do more content cause i would definitively watch it, but of course whenever you want at the end is about creating content for fun. and yes i started actually readin Nietzsche a bit with no notes just directly and i have had a hard time, ive understood some stuff, but it is hard so i might try to see some explained versions And yes once you open yourself to philosophy it becomes impossible not to find it everywhere its so interesting and this video motivated me so much to start diggin further
I don’t know if you will see this since I’m very late to the party, but this is one of the best analyses I have ever witnessed on anything and I’m shocked it’s not more popular. I recently finished the series and rebellion and I really felt a need for explanation because I knew that Homura wasn’t evil, and that something wasn’t clicking in my brain. Tying Homura’s actions back to several EXTREMELY EARLY things in the movie, and even the scene with Madoka and her mother is so heartwarming because it helps me understand this character a lot better. The constant symbolism with the pomegranates, the lyrics of the dolls, the dolls themselves, all explaining wordlessly in little bits of their own affect on Homura and symbolism of her true feelings. All the quotes taken truly do tie expertly into your psychological analysis, which is something I personally can they enough of and love to see how people take it on. It was nice to see a few hints of comedy here and there in between your amazing tone for a lot of this. I think the final conclusion boils down to this: Homura is a girl who truly didn’t believe in herself, or much else. She got her first kindness from Madoka which sparked something in her, but not quite enough. That was when she was led astray by the witch that Madoka and Mami saved her from. This is what sparked true love (regardless of what kind) in Homura. She still had that timidity in her soul however, which is why the end of the first timeline forced her to watch her only love die in front of her, with her believing it was all her fault for being to cowardish to make a contract. So she made a wish out of pure desire for the one she loved. (Btw people calling it selfish makes no sense to me because, when it comes down to it, she’s doing it all for Madoka, and really just Madoka. People can’t see it as selfishness because it’s truly not a black and white issue as you said) She goes back in time, and she believes she is able to help Madoka as Madoka helped her. However, it all ends once again when Walpurgisnacht arrives. She repeats this cycle again and again, suffering more each time, and making Madoka more likely to become a magical girl as well due to her power growth. One of the timelines even forced her to be sacrificed by Madoka just to go back and do it again, after promising she would save her. The anime timeline is when she puts on a neutral and colorless facade to drill the idea of Madoka not becoming a magical girl through serious means, even going as far as to threaten to murder Sayaka to save her from acting drastic and making a contract. (My favorite scene where I found out who Homura was is when she broke down on the bench telling Madoka to “realize there are people who care about her” which is what made me understand who she was.) In the final moment, she says it’s worse, and Madoka refutes that saying how it’s ok, she will always be with her, and that she’s happy. Homura was fooled by this, and didn’t have the guts to stop Madoka then, forcing her to fly off into godhood. Her journey of the loss of faith she experienced wasn’t because she just didn’t believe in Madoka, she didn’t believe in the Goddess Madoka. The world wasn’t what she would have wanted and she was truly suffering for it anyways, which Homura hates herself for not stopping when she has the chance. She lets herself fall into despair as one final attempt. When she is rescued by Madoka however, she doesn’t hesitate. She refuses to let Madoka suffer any more and takes her goddess powers away, and creates a reborn world where she can live out her wish: to meet Madoka again and to protect her as a girl, not a goddess. She believes this action was unforgivably sinful, calling herself “evil” and “a demon” which is what some of the audience chose to believe. Believing Homura here is misunderstanding everything the team sought out to achieve. In the true end, she is doing all of this out of the 15th doll’s incarnation, LOVE. It was all because of love, which truly is a madness. One that Homura had ever since she was first saved by Madoka and Mami. This is truly her wish coming true and she isn’t in the wrong. She is flawed, which is what makes her so human, but she isn’t wrong, evil, and certainly not a demon. Holy hell that was a lot of writing, but that’s my understanding. I too believe she will be redeemed in the final installment this winter. I genuinely want you to understand just how unbelievably amazing you are for dissecting all of this. I wouldn’t have been able to discover who Homura REALLY was and how she truly is showing us all what *love* is. This has solidified Puella Magi Madoka Magica as my favorite anime ever, and like you, it has ruined my life 🥲. Thank you for this video. Your ADHD 2-year journey is also very relatable to me lmao. Subbed and liked. Great Done. Well Job. (P.S. Homura absolutely is best girl. I have my best girl, but she is best girl for all time.)
I am yet to finish this, and I will put a new comment after, but just wanted to say that as soon as I saw the title, my immediate reaction was: omg, anime and philosophy in one? What a blessed day to have 🤩🤩 Haha, I was inspired to write this when I heard you were hesitating as you think philosophy is boring and dry to most people. Not to me! You made my day
This is so great I keep returning to this video to rewatch it. I especially like the editing in some parts, the choice of background music and idk, you explaining philosophical topics with those OST sounds oddly satisfying. Also, the link to your script doesn't seem to work, youtube is cutting it for some reason.
thank you so much for your comment, and thank you for letting me know about the link! I thought the issue was that the url was too long so I shortened it, but youtube now made adding clickable links to descriptions another privilege for those who have an “advanced identification”. i applied for it via the least dystopian method (which may require months and not even be granted), but hey fingers crossed! meanwhile i’ll leave the shortened link in the description box so it’s easier to copy paste. thank you again for your support! 💌
I love this essay so much. I think ever since I saw the original series to me Homura came off as an absurdist hero. Watching this felt like seeing my own thoughts crystalized and expressed clearly. You did me a great favor in not having to make this essay myself. I cried multiple times, this captured a lot of what I love about the show. Thank you
There are so many things you say that come back in the 4th movie’s trailer this was amazing. I also really like philosophy but I’m still not over with school so I didn’t know all about what u said.It was amazing tho and I love you.
I don't usually leave comments like this, but I just wanna say this video was a treat to watch. As someone who gets sporadic motivation to write really long video essays about my current hyperfixation + philosophy all the darn time but never actually ends up doing anything about it, it was really inspiring to see a video like this. I watch way too many video essays, and they mostly come from really big channels entirely dedicated to regularly uploading video essay content, and it's encouraging to hear about a scrip that was in the works for two years and footage that took a whole summer to edit. I definitely have analyses that have been stuck in notes-app-hell for wayyy longer, and barely know how to put music over a video. Will definitely be subcribing, even if this video was an one-off thing. Wish I had friends who liked pmmm to share this to cause you definitely deserve more views.
@@mimikyuno Alr so, it is confirmed that Walpurgis Rising is releasing Winter 2024 and in the film industry Winter 2024 lasts from January through February. It’s not coming out in January as we would’ve already gotten news, not only that but if the movie were to be released in before February then there would be leaks and stuff. Sry it was kinda long
Okay sorry I can't send you a link i tried but it's no video it s on Google you just look up suspended in dreams on the mitakihara loop line sorry for the wait
But you can do evil things even though you're just doing your best. Most traumatized people are "just doing their best" but they most definitely need help because their actions are harming themselves and others
All the cast members of Madoka Magica tv & movie series are female,Madoka/Angela Carlson & Kyouku/Mary Grace Entrada the straight girls,Sayaka/Johanna Jenner & Mami/Cynthia Malonzo the bisexuals.
⏳ TIMESTAMPS ⏳
Introduction - 00:00
Chapter 1 - Of Selfish Wishes and Hope 02:48
Chapter 2 - Rebellion, from the Cave to the Übermansch 14:05
Chapter 3 - Homura’s true feelings 23:24
Interlude - On Gen Urobuchi, Camus, and Nietzsche 37:17
Chapter 4 - Encomium of Homura: the Fifteenth Doll 44:58
Hey you mentions they redid Homura transformation scene so it sounded like she reverted a bit. Where can I find the non-cannon version of the scene? I'm having some difficulty tracking it down. Thanks and I love the video essay!
@@danielmcsween9054 th-cam.com/video/nJMWu9QJwnU/w-d-xo.htmlsi=onPn-bkFZqQX-l-u here you go! and thank u 🫶🏻
@@mimikyuno Thank you!
"You're not a god. You're just a girl, and I need you."
36:17 The way I felt my brain chemistry change hearing that.
I can honestly say I never tied Madoka's conversation with her mother about intentionally making a 'big mistake' for someone you love to the end of Rebellion. You're right though, it's a central theme of the show, and it fits Rebellion perfectly
aaaaaa
I know!!! it's been more than 10 years and people just belive Homura is bad because that's her persona or something, but they didn't get it, like I know madoka has a lot of symbolism the teeth, the chairs, flowers, dolls, even some of the fruits, etc. and some of them will say "it wasn't that good" but, they weren't there. The time it took to analyse each chapter when it was airing because "that's a lot of different chairs in a single room and there is too little people" and others saying "for some reason this reminds me of Faust and I don't know why".
Even after, when the DVD and BD where out people looking for different things, like "why the siren and the unicorn?" in the recopilation movies why did they add the cementary scene, what was the purpose, why they need to add bone crunching sounds in the Mami scene. and sometimes is a lot for a 12ep anime. not counting the real life circumstances like the storm that delayed the last episodes.
I was there when it was on season, I was there with everyone losing their minds in ep 3, 8, 10. I watched Rebellion in the movie theater. also when people dropped the series in ep 1 because it was too cute. I'll be honest, when the season was starting I watched madoka because Aoki Ume did the desings and then my world was different.
Anyways, I really liked all the essay, Homura is misunderstood by people who only see in black and white. and those who refuse too see more because "is not that deep"
I would love too see you talking about all the other topics, like the clara dolls, which are an important part in the rebellion plot.
“for some reason it reminds me of faust” i wonder why lmao
im so glad you enjoyed this video! people always want to see complex or morally grey characters but when presented with one they suddenly get black and white vision, which is truly a pity.
posting this video for public consumption was a bit less nerve-wrecking than i expected, so i think i will be creating more content like this on the mentioned topics! thank you for your comment ✨
Long live Gray and Gray morality
What is the symbolism of the chairs? I just started watching the series a few days ago and I pointed it out to my husband how it's weird that there's so many chairs in each room. He's like that's some autistic s*** to notice that😂
The way this essay has shaken me to my CORE. I couldn’t love this show more. Homura, they could never make me hate you.😭 With the upcoming movie hastening us towards the end of their story, I wonder how it will all turn out. I’m scared but hopeful too. I appreciate your memes and knowledge of the hidden in plain sight things I couldn’t understand before. Thank you so much!!! ♥️
Found this video linked on I _think_ Reddit, and have had it saved in my Watch Later for the last few days. Seriously, thank you for this, it's so refreshing. I can't believe that so many fans of a show that explicitly makes a point to reject black and white morality keep falling into it. The philosophical lens you bring has given a contextual framework for many of the things I've picked up on but struggled to articulate concisely. Your friends were very right to suggest you upload your musings ♥
(P.S. the memes were delightful, lol. Glad to see someone else noticed the parallel between Madoka's conversation with her mother and Homura's decision to remake reality as a silver cage to protect her.)
This video is so good in how it thoroughly explores concepts, and i must say i really enjoy the editing especially the choice of clips being shown relating to the topic being spoken!!
First of all I appreciate and admire the courage you had to openly share your feelings about philosophy with us in that intro. I love that, thank you❤ Swcondly, I could talk about philosophy and Madoka all day anyday, as Madoka is one of my top shows of all time. So thank you for making this video, I will savor it to it's fullest extent❤
Hey, I'm late as hell and haven't finished the video yet, but I really like the way you explain things so far and would absolutely listen to you talk about any of the other topics in the description. Like, literally any of them.
This is the most amazing video essay I’ve ever watched and I would love to hear you cover the other topics you mentioned in the description💗💗
What Homura did was evil? Yes.
Was she wrong? Hell to the no.
You have to take into consideration that Homura stripped Madoka of her own free will. That's....yes? That's kinda evil. However, no one that heavily criticizes Homura has ever taken into consideration that Madoka's decision is just a temporary solution to a complicated problem.
And Homura has watched Madoka suffering because of her own decisions and Kyuubei's manipulation over *a HUNDRED* of times. Human mind and soul is only that strong and resilient, you know. If she loses her dreams and hopes is over.
And, well, she refuses to give up without a fight. *Anyone who tries to do something over A HUNDRED OF TIMES refuses to give up* so she clings to her sole wish.
In the end, she re does her meeting with Madoka, being strong enough to protect her. She doesn't look too happy about it, perhaps facing finally the expectative vs reality of her wish, hence why she falls at the very end of rebellion.
on my 3rd rewatch of this video
argh now tiis makes me want to make a video essay on madoka magica and honkai impact 3rds parallels n shit but BUT i know its gonna take more than the two years of yours
honestly do it, who cares how long it takes! i have been writing a new one for Ages and sometimes i get discouraged but it’s honestly okay! the process is actually what matters and you’ll never know if you can actually do it or not unless you try 🫶🏻
also it sounds super interesting! i play starrail a little (im more invested in genshin) and never got around to playing/learning more about hi third even tho the yuri compels me so im invested 🤓
"Jesus Christ" 10:42
yeah it is confirmed!!! madoka it is god guys!!!!
Love being the last doll yet unmanifested is much like Hope being the last being in Pandora's box after all the other evils enter the world. It is the state of being that misfortunes must be suffered to attain. No dawn without the night.
you’re so right………… 🏺
everyone who says homura is selfish or a bad, uncaring person makes me think a lot of people watched the show once years ago and didn’t even pay attention
yea i agree.
She is selfish, however that doesn't make her bad.
@@fitmotheyap No she's not she hates herself, she focuses on her goal to protect Madoka. She doesn't care what she will become a demon she just wants Madoka to be happy.
Homura in the series: Okay 👍 *she fights wraiths*
Homura in Rebellion: Okay 👍 *she throws all mortality, self love and will to live out the window as hard as she can, for Madoka, who obviously told her to stop doing that*
On a serious note i think its less "Homura did nothing/everything wrong" or more "Homura tried her best to do what she perceived was right. There was some wrong and some right to her actions."
Oh believe me, there are indeed some of us who ABSOLUTELY nerd out at the thought of philosophical video essays over media ;D I got excited the moment I saw your video title like AWW YISS new Madoka video essay has dropped!!
Thanks for the video! You've brought up some points I've never considered before. I love hearing how people interpret Rebellion or Madoka Magica in general - it's so wonderful to have a franchise that can still surprise me years later. It really enables you to have a fresh new perspective for the next time you sit down and watch the series.
glad I'm not the only one that is digging through yt for essays on madoka
I'd almost given up hope on finding a Homura/Rebellion analysis video that wasn't a fecal abortion. I am so happy and impressed to finally, after ten years, have a video I can point to as someone who understands the source and respect the themes. Nice to see critical analysis isn't as dead in the fandom as I had feared. Well done.
I'd be absolutely interested in hearing about everything you cut out, especially more theology about homura and madoka, feminism and femininity in the series, freud’s interpretation of dreams and the symbols present in homulily’s maze, the Clara dolls scene dissection, and the swan lake parallels. (esp the last three, I'm a sucker for ballet parallels/references and I would love for someone to break down and explain homulily's maze with some freud's interpretation because I don't quote understand everything about her labyrinth, as well as every scene with her Clara dolls more in-depth)
I feel this as a fellow ADHD TH-camr. I've also been working on a video for 2 years, so to see this being done really inspires me.
You did a fantastic job rationalizing and explaining different perspectives on viewing Homura.
The breakdown of Camus and Nietzsche's philosophies was not only educational but also entertaining.
I also appreciate the extra detail you took to tie in Sigmund Freud (I totally missed that on my 3 watches). To see it connected gave me an entirely new perspective and opened up further interpretations.
Additionally, looking into Gen Urobuchi further reinforces that you really did your research, which speaks for itself! I really liked the quotes you used to back up your argument points.
You gave us all something precious here, which is the gift of knowledge itself, so thank you for such a wonderfully put-together video essay :)
thank you so so much for this comment, i appreciate your words sm! also, YOU GOT THIS!! i have been working on another video essay since i posted this one and it truly seems impossible but we got thissss it will be done and posted eventually, i believe in us! 🙌🏻
I love Homura with everything in me I don’t understand people who truly find Homura pure evil
this!! homura isn't perfect by any means ofc, as none of the girls are, and homura is morally grey for sure. but that doesn't mean that she doesn't have good and genuineness in her, bc she def does.
Still astounds me how little views this video has. I found your channel because your edits are absolutely amazing, and when I saw a video on Madoka Magica (Especially Homura!) AND philosophy, I was instantly hooked. Two of my favourite things. I'm not smart enough to really go into depth about how much I appreciate this essay, but I've been going through a rough time these past few months and I've watched your video numerous times to help me through it. Even though it didn't go viral I hope you know you did an incredible job putting this out there and it's made its impact.
I woke up this morning and I have been thinking of a way to reply all day but I can’t find the words to express how much your words mean to me! I have been struggling with some insecurities about my writing especially so I’m 🥹
Just last night I started working on a new edit for the first time in months and reading this comment this morning gave me the strength to work on it for the whole day 💌
I have been very busy with school this spring and now that I’m on holiday I have been wanting to write another video essay, so stay tuned! it makes me feel so motivated to know people out there enjoy my few videos :’)
@@mimikyuno
I'm so happy I was able to make your day a little better!! I can't wait to see your future projects, but no pressure to get them out anytime soon! I'll be excited to watch them no matter what. :D
I love that you mentioned how Rebellion feels like it used The Allegory Of The Cave.
Honestly, Rebellion is up there with The Matrix and Dark City in terms of works that use that allegory.
i would be happy to hear you talk more about Homura (and anything related to her)
SAME especially all of the stuff she cut out
i cannot express how amazing and wonderful and mindblowing this video is. i can honestly say pmmm and homura have shaped me in a lot of ways since i was a child. its been about 11 years since i first watched the anime and fell in love with it and still to this day i find new things to learn and love and wonder about it, thank you so so much for this. im not knowledgable at all when it comes to philosophy so i never couldve made any of these connections if it wasnt for this video. honestly i cried many times while watching lmao i agree so much on everything you said about homura. thank you so so much for this.
i dont know if youre still interested in making a video about the topics you left in your description but i would 100% watch numerous videos about every one of them! thank you again and i hope you're well and stay safe
...Wow! this essay really opened my mind. In my country in highschool native language class is basically literature/philosophy/art, but it's taught in such a way, you're better off learning by heart and forgetting rather than understanding it deeper, unless you picked humanities.
Here I got taught much, MUCH more about Nietzsche than in school. All we learned about him were some quick notes that most would take as the common misconceptions you mentioned. I'm actually more interested in his work now!
I just wanna say, I've loved this anime since I was 14 and it definitely helped me through life, especially with how I sympathised and related to some aspects of the girls, especially Madoka.
It's great to hear such insight on Homura's character compared to some other videos I've seen. When I read fanfics that mentioned the dolls by their japanese names I was on a ride, but thanks to them I got to understand her better XD.
Thank you for making this! (>
I never really comment on TH-cam videos but this video essay is CRIMINALLY UNDERRATED thank you so much for verbalizing my very own thoughts on Homura and the show's purpose in general!! You are a spectacular creator, don't let your struggles make you think that you aren't :)
let's gooooooo
This video has to be my favorite youtube video out there. Homura means so much to me i felt (funnily enough) in despair at the search for analisys that didnt unecessarily villanaized Homura and protrayed her in this light of pure evil when she is the most human there is, i may say my hope of finding one has found itself in this video and what a wonderful video.
I kid you not i started wanting to cry at some parts of the video because you just get me, you are the analysis of Homura i was looking for, one who questioned what was being presented to us and not just try to guide itself by pre established values such as evil and good and nothing deeper just a yandere with no redemption.
i have to admit although i love philosophy im still very young and have barely consumed philosphy texts outside of my school ethics class which has helped me a lot with guiding myself now that ive watched Madoka Magica again
I so badly want to get into Nietzsche, i see some ideas of my own in the things you touched of him and i find myself wanting to read about him even more knowing how Homura is influenced by his philosophy. Homura is a character that absolutely deserves all this analysis and more, she is begging to be analyzed yet people only do so between the restricting roles of good and evil, black and white etc etc.
Is true, trying to fit Homura into good or evil is a debate that will never get anybody anywhere because she isnt any and trying to give her a dictatory role that doesnt fully capture her will always fail.
I srs dont know how else to explain how much this video made me happy; i only watched Madoka Magica two years ago so i wasnt when the fandom was at its prime, but i still love this anime very deeply and specially Homura, a wonderfully crafted character that i will forever treausure, i am beyond in love with this video Homura for best girl indeed
also i read the caption and i woud love your take and some topics you didnt finally include in the script, specially the feminism and feminity in madoka magica cause oh boy there is a lot to talk there and is a fresher and certainly more accurate read in my opinion then those edgy dudes who categorize madoka magica as "not like other magical girls" because its not that type of magical girl anime whatever that means considering Madoka Magica is mostly analyzed by guys who find zero to no exposure of feminist topics on madoka magica, i would love to hear your take on it
also all those other topics you cut out as well, your thought process is amazing and i love philosophy and madoka magica which luckily is filled with philosophy
i read this comment yesterday morning and it made me smile so much!! i have been so busy with school stuff that i kinda neglected this channel, and your comment made me want to hurry up and finish these last few courses so i can start creating more content ❣️
philosophy is such a great interest to get because i swear to god, once you learnt enough you start seeing references to philosophers and currents of thought everywhere and it’s very satisfying! and about nietzsche: dude wrote like a madman, so if you want to read him i recommend reading from a secondary source (like, someone summarising and explaining one of his texts); but if you want to read the og definitely find a copy with sidenotes that explain what the hell he’s on about!
good luck with everything, thank you for your comment! 💌
@@mimikyuno Im glad i was able to make you smile wih my comment, is only fair i comment after hearing such an amazing take on an amazing character, and im glad you feel motivated to do more content cause i would definitively watch it, but of course whenever you want at the end is about creating content for fun.
and yes i started actually readin Nietzsche a bit with no notes just directly and i have had a hard time, ive understood some stuff, but it is hard so i might try to see some explained versions
And yes once you open yourself to philosophy it becomes impossible not to find it everywhere its so interesting and this video motivated me so much to start diggin further
This is a pretty fantastic video. I knew they drew a lot of inspiration from philosophy but I didn't realise it was so deeply entwined
This was so incredible, definitely my favourite essay video on Madoka Magica.
What a great essay! Thank you very much for your work and dedication!
I don’t know if you will see this since I’m very late to the party, but this is one of the best analyses I have ever witnessed on anything and I’m shocked it’s not more popular. I recently finished the series and rebellion and I really felt a need for explanation because I knew that Homura wasn’t evil, and that something wasn’t clicking in my brain. Tying Homura’s actions back to several EXTREMELY EARLY things in the movie, and even the scene with Madoka and her mother is so heartwarming because it helps me understand this character a lot better. The constant symbolism with the pomegranates, the lyrics of the dolls, the dolls themselves, all explaining wordlessly in little bits of their own affect on Homura and symbolism of her true feelings. All the quotes taken truly do tie expertly into your psychological analysis, which is something I personally can they enough of and love to see how people take it on. It was nice to see a few hints of comedy here and there in between your amazing tone for a lot of this. I think the final conclusion boils down to this: Homura is a girl who truly didn’t believe in herself, or much else. She got her first kindness from Madoka which sparked something in her, but not quite enough. That was when she was led astray by the witch that Madoka and Mami saved her from. This is what sparked true love (regardless of what kind) in Homura. She still had that timidity in her soul however, which is why the end of the first timeline forced her to watch her only love die in front of her, with her believing it was all her fault for being to cowardish to make a contract. So she made a wish out of pure desire for the one she loved. (Btw people calling it selfish makes no sense to me because, when it comes down to it, she’s doing it all for Madoka, and really just Madoka. People can’t see it as selfishness because it’s truly not a black and white issue as you said)
She goes back in time, and she believes she is able to help Madoka as Madoka helped her. However, it all ends once again when Walpurgisnacht arrives. She repeats this cycle again and again, suffering more each time, and making Madoka more likely to become a magical girl as well due to her power growth. One of the timelines even forced her to be sacrificed by Madoka just to go back and do it again, after promising she would save her. The anime timeline is when she puts on a neutral and colorless facade to drill the idea of Madoka not becoming a magical girl through serious means, even going as far as to threaten to murder Sayaka to save her from acting drastic and making a contract. (My favorite scene where I found out who Homura was is when she broke down on the bench telling Madoka to “realize there are people who care about her” which is what made me understand who she was.) In the final moment, she says it’s worse, and Madoka refutes that saying how it’s ok, she will always be with her, and that she’s happy. Homura was fooled by this, and didn’t have the guts to stop Madoka then, forcing her to fly off into godhood. Her journey of the loss of faith she experienced wasn’t because she just didn’t believe in Madoka, she didn’t believe in the Goddess Madoka. The world wasn’t what she would have wanted and she was truly suffering for it anyways, which Homura hates herself for not stopping when she has the chance. She lets herself fall into despair as one final attempt. When she is rescued by Madoka however, she doesn’t hesitate. She refuses to let Madoka suffer any more and takes her goddess powers away, and creates a reborn world where she can live out her wish: to meet Madoka again and to protect her as a girl, not a goddess. She believes this action was unforgivably sinful, calling herself “evil” and “a demon” which is what some of the audience chose to believe. Believing Homura here is misunderstanding everything the team sought out to achieve. In the true end, she is doing all of this out of the 15th doll’s incarnation, LOVE. It was all because of love, which truly is a madness. One that Homura had ever since she was first saved by Madoka and Mami. This is truly her wish coming true and she isn’t in the wrong. She is flawed, which is what makes her so human, but she isn’t wrong, evil, and certainly not a demon. Holy hell that was a lot of writing, but that’s my understanding. I too believe she will be redeemed in the final installment this winter. I genuinely want you to understand just how unbelievably amazing you are for dissecting all of this. I wouldn’t have been able to discover who Homura REALLY was and how she truly is showing us all what *love* is. This has solidified Puella Magi Madoka Magica as my favorite anime ever, and like you, it has ruined my life 🥲. Thank you for this video. Your ADHD 2-year journey is also very relatable to me lmao. Subbed and liked. Great Done. Well Job. (P.S. Homura absolutely is best girl. I have my best girl, but she is best girl for all time.)
This video was the best anime character review I've ever watched.
💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗 good stuff
Keep updated thanks there are hardly any channels that does this essay and it was frustrating find one .
TH-cam really needs to get their "fair use" shit in order.
The sheer joy i have when i have found a new essay on rebellion! Evennal after all this yime!
Just found this and it's great! Thank you!
I love this video almost as much as Homura loves Madoka
This was so fascinating! Thank you for making it and sharing!
That was one of the most interesting videos about Madoka, thank you SO MUCH for this.
I am yet to finish this, and I will put a new comment after, but just wanted to say that as soon as I saw the title, my immediate reaction was: omg, anime and philosophy in one? What a blessed day to have 🤩🤩 Haha, I was inspired to write this when I heard you were hesitating as you think philosophy is boring and dry to most people. Not to me! You made my day
This is so great I keep returning to this video to rewatch it. I especially like the editing in some parts, the choice of background music and idk, you explaining philosophical topics with those OST sounds oddly satisfying. Also, the link to your script doesn't seem to work, youtube is cutting it for some reason.
thank you so much for your comment, and thank you for letting me know about the link! I thought the issue was that the url was too long so I shortened it, but youtube now made adding clickable links to descriptions another privilege for those who have an “advanced identification”. i applied for it via the least dystopian method (which may require months and not even be granted), but hey fingers crossed! meanwhile i’ll leave the shortened link in the description box so it’s easier to copy paste. thank you again for your support! 💌
rewatching and relistening to this masterpiece 🖤 mad respect for people who are not afraid to touch philosophy books
I love this essay so much. I think ever since I saw the original series to me Homura came off as an absurdist hero. Watching this felt like seeing my own thoughts crystalized and expressed clearly. You did me a great favor in not having to make this essay myself. I cried multiple times, this captured a lot of what I love about the show. Thank you
Yes, someone finally made the Madoka, Nietzsche video I always wanted to see.
There are so many things you say that come back in the 4th movie’s trailer this was amazing. I also really like philosophy but I’m still not over with school so I didn’t know all about what u said.It was amazing tho and I love you.
Seeing this video made me realize a lot. Thank you for the time you took in creating it!
i loved it soo much ❤️
I don't usually leave comments like this, but I just wanna say this video was a treat to watch. As someone who gets sporadic motivation to write really long video essays about my current hyperfixation + philosophy all the darn time but never actually ends up doing anything about it, it was really inspiring to see a video like this. I watch way too many video essays, and they mostly come from really big channels entirely dedicated to regularly uploading video essay content, and it's encouraging to hear about a scrip that was in the works for two years and footage that took a whole summer to edit. I definitely have analyses that have been stuck in notes-app-hell for wayyy longer, and barely know how to put music over a video. Will definitely be subcribing, even if this video was an one-off thing. Wish I had friends who liked pmmm to share this to cause you definitely deserve more views.
Loved this. This anime got me to read Goethe's Faust (both parts!) so I love the intense literary commitment to analyzing the series.
this was brilliant ❤ thank you
Absolutely amazing video! This deserves much more views!
this video is a masterpiece
Homura did everything wrong, but we love her anyways lol.
NEXT MOVIE RELEASES IN FEB
wait where did you get this info? i saw no news of this anywhere and i follow all the madomagi tags on every social media
@@mimikyuno Alr so, it is confirmed that Walpurgis Rising is releasing Winter 2024 and in the film industry Winter 2024 lasts from January through February. It’s not coming out in January as we would’ve already gotten news, not only that but if the movie were to be released in before February then there would be leaks and stuff.
Sry it was kinda long
this is a good vide o
Amazing video!
Madoka analysis maybe? 🥺
Very cool video.
Have you ever read the essay on madoka magica especially homura after a while called suspended in dreams
This video has an amazing analysis too
@@soulcastle6126 i actually haven’t! do you have a link to it? i’m always up for madomagi essays 🎀
Suspended in dreams on the mitakihara loop line. its on Google it's really good essay
Okay sorry I can't send you a link i tried but it's no video it s on Google you just look up suspended in dreams on the mitakihara loop line sorry for the wait
One of them is not the real girl,only dressing as a girl Rogelio Arcilla,Jr. or Homura/Rogelyn.
You found your target audience, thank you for this video!
song 16:20 plz
Nvm its from that madoka concept movie
pr໐๓໐Ş๓ 🤩
But you can do evil things even though you're just doing your best. Most traumatized people are "just doing their best" but they most definitely need help because their actions are harming themselves and others
All the cast members of Madoka Magica tv & movie series are female,Madoka/Angela Carlson & Kyouku/Mary Grace Entrada the straight girls,Sayaka/Johanna Jenner & Mami/Cynthia Malonzo the bisexuals.
what