It is still applicable to a deaf person. They communicate through sign language or by being able to read lips. Her not being able to hear physically won't change that.
@@ladennayoung2939you shouldn't be allowed to tell a deaf person that unless there is an interpreter there. Makes no sense depending on if that deaf person can read lips or not
After I graduate from Montclair State University, I will be advocating for deaf, hard of hearing people because that interpreter in that scene is the person that I want to become in local areas not just criminal justice such as police officers, everywhere for that matter, you know, courtroom, schools, and other facilities that comes to be a certified ASL Interpreter. That's my future.
As an interpreter, myself, I would like to say good luck! There are few people who are interested in ASL and even fewer who truly respect the nuanced language that it is. I won't sugar-coat it. Learning to interpret is incredibly challenging. It is one thing to be able to hold casual conversations, but it's a whole other ballpark when it comes to interpreting. That being said, the gratification you feel once accomplishing such a feat is amazing! I wish you all the best, and who knows! Perhaps one day we could be colleagues, the Deaf Community is small and tight-knit, and that includes interpreters like us!
Ahh! I absolutely love Marlee Matlin! I'm an ASL Interpreter (peep my pfp lol) and I always get excited when I see ASL in mainstream media, especially when the ASL is accurate. I also love how they always keep their hands in frame, making it easier for Deaf people to see.
So how accurare was the ASL in this episode? I immagine Ms. Matlin will be using ASL correctly, as a point of pride, but what about the two interperters that appear in the episode?
@joaopauloadlergomesdacosta282 The interpreters feel genuine, like it is their actual occupation simply based on their presence and overall attire. They are 100% accurate with their interpretations, right down to using the first-person when verbally interpreting. Like, they aren't saying "she said", they say "I said" because an interpreter is supposed to be as invisible as possible. We are nothing more than a vessel for our Deaf client to communicate through.
I remember this episode. I didnt know who Marlee was at the tkme but im so glad for these youtube downloads. I love matlin now so its so cool to see her in Law and Order SVU
In England I am not sure that this would get to trial as for a prosecution on a charge of assissting a suicide you need the consent of the Attorney - General. It is rarely given in this case if it was done without the doctor being paid then the Attorney General is unlikely to give consent.
okay, I'm deaf as well but I don't understand if she gets put in handcuffed and she can't say anything when she needs to say something then how is she gonna sign? Can't you put it in the front and not the back? so it's fair for a deaf person to say something? I'm afraid that's not right for me.
This episode was sad but i like what she said in court. People she helps kill themselves she says theyre in pain she has to live with every day they dont. Something like that. I understand cause i was there before u dont understand or know till u go through wanting to kill yourself.
Im on the fence about assisted suicide but I'm glad its legal were i live now so people can go out in a peaceful way. I dont support it for people who are suffering from things like depression but if there in exterem physical pain that can not be helps then I think they should have the right to choose cuz if the are serious about ending there life they will do it no mater what. My great grandma is 103 and everyday she says she just wants to die and finally be at peace. Shes super religious so she won't go for assisted suicide but I wouldnt stop her if she did. I know that might sound messed up to some people but hearing her constantly say it whenever we visit or call really gets to you
After Christina Nerrit's first attempt failed due to two maids finding her, Solwey feared Nerrit would lose her nerve, and thus promised to bring two syringes of insulin to her hospital room so that they could die together. Nerrit used the syringe and died shortly after. Solwey, however, did not kill herself that day. Munch convinces Solwey to plead out so that she can live and get a kidney transplant that she initially refused. She was convicted but released 3 months later due to compassionate release from the state.
Actually, if you are in constant pain and the drs wont give you painkillers, ppl get desperate and they do what they feel like is the only answer! I believe that dr assisted suicide is should be 100% legal! The govt has no right to force ppl to live in pain constantly, with no relief!
Yeah , ur hand is cuffed behind ur back , so it's really important for u to know, if say anything it could be used against u in curt of law ! To women who talk😐 And her hand isn't free😐 Very disappointed 😐
props to the assistant who kept signing to her her rights as her boss getting cuffed right in front of her.
I appreciate that the actors only look at the deaf woman when talking to her, instead of either of the interpreters (even if it is only a TV show)
Anyone else realizes that he tells a deaf women that anything she says can and will be used in a court of law as she's cuffing a deaf person?
😂😂😂😂
At least her interpreter is there to translate
It is still applicable to a deaf person. They communicate through sign language or by being able to read lips. Her not being able to hear physically won't change that.
@@ladennayoung2939you shouldn't be allowed to tell a deaf person that unless there is an interpreter there. Makes no sense depending on if that deaf person can read lips or not
Womp womp
The actress who plays the doctor is actually a well known deaf person.
She's cute
She's an amazing actress. Back in the 90s she starred in the series Reasonable Doubts. She also won an Oscar for the movie Children of a Lesser God
The ending where Munch revealed to Amy the last thing he said to his father before he committed suicide was so heartbreaking the first time I saw it
After I graduate from Montclair State University, I will be advocating for deaf, hard of hearing people because that interpreter in that scene is the person that I want to become in local areas not just criminal justice such as police officers, everywhere for that matter, you know, courtroom, schools, and other facilities that comes to be a certified ASL Interpreter. That's my future.
The world needs more people interested in ASL!!!! ❤❤❤❤
Good to hear! Best of luck in your goals! I hope you inspire many others!
As an interpreter, myself, I would like to say good luck!
There are few people who are interested in ASL and even fewer who truly respect the nuanced language that it is.
I won't sugar-coat it. Learning to interpret is incredibly challenging. It is one thing to be able to hold casual conversations, but it's a whole other ballpark when it comes to interpreting.
That being said, the gratification you feel once accomplishing such a feat is amazing! I wish you all the best, and who knows! Perhaps one day we could be colleagues, the Deaf Community is small and tight-knit, and that includes interpreters like us!
Very kind of you to choose a career that helps the deaf
Love it!!!
“You have the right to remain silent”
Yeah no kidding lol 😂
Marlee Matlin was great in this episode. In later episodes Camryn Manheim would play a cop who also is an American Sign Language interpreter.
Mm, which episode as an ASL interpreter?
It looks like they handcuff her from behind. This is usually seen as unlawful as the deaf individual should be allowed to sign or write.
9:03 they missed the perfect opportunity to say "anything you sign will be used against you"
Ahh! I absolutely love Marlee Matlin! I'm an ASL Interpreter (peep my pfp lol) and I always get excited when I see ASL in mainstream media, especially when the ASL is accurate. I also love how they always keep their hands in frame, making it easier for Deaf people to see.
So how accurare was the ASL in this episode? I immagine Ms. Matlin will be using ASL correctly, as a point of pride, but what about the two interperters that appear in the episode?
@joaopauloadlergomesdacosta282 The interpreters feel genuine, like it is their actual occupation simply based on their presence and overall attire.
They are 100% accurate with their interpretations, right down to using the first-person when verbally interpreting.
Like, they aren't saying "she said", they say "I said" because an interpreter is supposed to be as invisible as possible. We are nothing more than a vessel for our Deaf client to communicate through.
Yes disability representation is important
The episode belongs to John Munch R.I.P Richard Belzer.
One of my favorite episodes of SVU
‘Anything you say can be used against you in a court of law’
Should have said
‘Anything you sign can be used against you in a court of law’ 😂
Some deaf people can speak. She as mouthing things. You wouldn't want to lose the case on Miranda because you were making a joke.
That’d be savage to say
Signing _is_ "saying" something though.
@@that.ll_do_pig dam you must be fun, pick apart everything you can because you don’t understand a joke when you see one
@@leonhardeuler675 if you pick apart jokes because you don’t understand them then I’m gonna assume nobody likes you irl
I remember this episode. I didnt know who Marlee was at the tkme but im so glad for these youtube downloads. I love matlin now so its so cool to see her in Law and Order SVU
Look up the series Reasonable Doubts. The pilot ep is available on YT
In England I am not sure that this would get to trial as for a prosecution on a charge of assissting a suicide you need the consent of the Attorney - General. It is rarely given in this case if it was done without the doctor being paid then the Attorney General is unlikely to give consent.
Marlee was always a really good actress.
I have greatly respected Marlee's acting talents ever since I first saw her Oscar-winning performance in Children Of A Lesser God.
Anyone remember the episode where a famous celebrity was accused of Grapeing his fan in a hotel and then puts body in a luggage beg?
yes I just recently watched that one
Which episode
Must have been set in a vineyard.
Funny how something that was seen like this years ago is now just modern day Canadian healthcare....
With MAID in place ?
My mom had MAID. It is respectful and dignified. I’m glad my mom had choice when facing terminal cancer.
Shows that the big brother wants to control if you live or die.
Oh man I haven't watched law and order in long time especially SVU
I liked how Munch grew to care for her
"You have the right to remain silent". HA!! Smh 😅
love this show
okay, I'm deaf as well but I don't understand if she gets put in handcuffed and she can't say anything when she needs to say something then how is she gonna sign? Can't you put it in the front and not the back? so it's fair for a deaf person to say something? I'm afraid that's not right for me.
I know I have a Macabre sense of humor when you realize Munch tells a deaf woman she has the right to remain silent. Really? A deaf woman?
Marlee Matlin is such a lovely woman.
She's way past the right to remain silent......... I'm going to hell aren't I?
I was just watching this episode earlier what a coincidence 😅
This episode was sad but i like what she said in court. People she helps kill themselves she says theyre in pain she has to live with every day they dont. Something like that. I understand cause i was there before u dont understand or know till u go through wanting to kill yourself.
Shouldn’t it be anything you sign can be and will be used against you in a court of law?
As a type one, I completely understood what happened lol
I love Olivia Benson
Im on the fence about assisted suicide but I'm glad its legal were i live now so people can go out in a peaceful way.
I dont support it for people who are suffering from things like depression but if there in exterem physical pain that can not be helps then I think they should have the right to choose cuz if the are serious about ending there life they will do it no mater what.
My great grandma is 103 and everyday she says she just wants to die and finally be at peace. Shes super religious so she won't go for assisted suicide but I wouldnt stop her if she did.
I know that might sound messed up to some people but hearing her constantly say it whenever we visit or call really gets to you
You are so lucky. Animals can be put down but it's illegal to help a human been who can no longer live with their pain.
@@neisci
Animals can be spayed or neutered without their consent. You down with that for humans too?
Amy and Munchs last scene is so sad but its not on youtube 😢
Victoria Newman left Genoa City for New York City .
Spoil me please. What's the full story of this episode?
After Christina Nerrit's first attempt failed due to two maids finding her, Solwey feared Nerrit would lose her nerve, and thus promised to bring two syringes of insulin to her hospital room so that they could die together. Nerrit used the syringe and died shortly after. Solwey, however, did not kill herself that day.
Munch convinces Solwey to plead out so that she can live and get a kidney transplant that she initially refused. She was convicted but released 3 months later due to compassionate release from the state.
@@kliop123432 oooh I see
Actually, if you are in constant pain and the drs wont give you painkillers, ppl get desperate and they do what they feel like is the only answer! I believe that dr assisted suicide is should be 100% legal! The govt has no right to force ppl to live in pain constantly, with no relief!
Reminds me of Dr Kevorkian a bit.
Joey from West Wing!
Not cool man
Yeah , ur hand is cuffed behind ur back , so it's really important for u to know, if say anything it could be used against u in curt of law !
To women who talk😐
And her hand isn't free😐
Very disappointed 😐
This is just wrong.
how is this a crime people who s/a children get away with it if they have a "mental health issue" this is a joke.....
What?
Deaf women in crime please police need support languange difabel
.
Only if the dead woman knew Jesus Christ, otherwise she's in a terrible place.
What’s that got to do with anything here?
@@jeannehall6546 how do we know we have peace after we die?
Ask that freyamccauley- that was the one what started it!
@@freyamccauley We’ll know when we enter the afterlife.
@@freyamccauleypeople who have been pronounced dead but brought back to life have said that it’s the most peace they have experienced