Also, I forgot about after this went live, but thank you to all my patreon supporters. I love you guys, and I promise I'll remember to put your names up. Thank you guys for supporting what I do and helping me make these videos I love. Chad Muffins: artpremium Mushkin Mandletort Hasburrah BeaverNation57
Can you try that in Switzerland with no expansion and open border i want to see how high you can get the GDP just by building constructions and service building only.
Today, none but pre-British overlordship, quite a few. From 1850's to 1910's, the rulers of both Qatar and Bahrain actually kept trying to one-up and claim sovereignty over the other whilst the Saudis kept raiding and stealing bits of their land. @electricVGC
@@elijahbrothers14usa has indeed banned slavery. Modern "westerners" (europe, americas and mostly oceania) never met "traditional slavery", at least in such an extent and in such degree it was 100 or 200 years ago
@ it states in our constitution that slavery is banned unless charged with a crime so technically not really, especially when the US has the highest incarceration rate in the entire world and the biggest prison industrial complex in the entire world is essentially a slave system
I like how half of the issues people have with victoria 3 are just issues people have with real economic policy. "I hate how capitalist re-investment isn't affected by taxes" "Why do I have to pay these people so much" Etc.
It’s great that the game models economics so well. He literally run into the same issues as the real gulf states, an upper strata that doesn’t contribute to the economy, petrodollars you can’t use, and a crippling labor shortage
I have only one issue with Victoria 3. Everytime my country become ritcher than rest of the world very quickly. Everytime I have monopol on production of everything very quckly. Everytime produckts in my country are the most expensive ones. Everytime my people are the richest of the richest, and also the biggest screamers for revolution.
Unlikely. Studies done on this show that countries with less taxes and "more capitalism" became richer in the aggregate. Sounds like the game does economics wrong. There should be an update to reflect the real world
This is how I learnt to play vicky 3, it was my first nation that I've played and was able to get a pretty good GDP + Standard of living in the Russian market back in version 1.2. Also I played Bahrain cause I'm Bahraini
1. So, everyone has supercars, yatchs, mansions, and a private plane. 2. How weird, you pay people a very comfortable wage, you see how quickly poverty is eliminated 3. I find it amusing how quickly the sultan closes the borders once he opened them. Maybe he's going to build some walls or something 4.
"So this is something i really don't like about victoria 3, is if you lower taxes, it doesn't affect the amount your capitalists or your rich people reinvest" That's not victoria 3, that's just real life.
@@wilhelmvon Absolutely it is, if you give rich people tax cuts, they don't reinvest, they hoard it. Look at the real world, trickle down economics don't work.
8:21 I wish i could say that. xD But congratulations man! You have unlocked the "NOT A Paradox Player" achievement! Congrats! I wish you good luck in your relationship!
0:07 actually they already did that in our timeline am from saudi arabia in school and I’ve seen people from all around the arabian world except bahrain and qatar and some african nation’s
There is a mod called "Free Market Construction" that turns construction into a service that can be purchased on demand, imported, and exported. It needs some tweaking and balancing, but I feel it's an excellent concept that Paradox should incorporate.
Historically Bahrain was the world's longest lasting luxury metals exporter. They talk about importing from Bahrain in the bible when Solomon is making the Temple. Ea-Nasir is getting called out for having copper that isn't as nice as the copper from Bahrain. It was a big part of the economy of the early Rashidun Caliphate. Then they ran out of fancy metal :(
Honestly it’d be amazing if you redid this run but actually tried for protectorates and opened the borders earlier, and maybe forming Arabia and snowballing massively
23:40 no it's cuz Bahrain is a part of trucial coast / it's a split state and trucial coast was occupied and because of that the whole state including Bahrain will get devestation by
Historically you should have events like Bahrain tribe wars and formation of Quatar...its really intresting period the victorian era for that region,same goes for Bahrain, Paradox and modders should show some interest and not neglect those regions because from gaming aspect you have like events non stop.
You know who else has a marine focus on their economy? Louisiana. You know who else is famous for shipbuilding? Louisiana. You can’t escape Louisiana forever…
when you have a small nation to play you notice how detailed this game is and how significant each decision is I am just questioning why did you not switch to private health and education :D edit YOU noticed at end it seems nvm :D
May of been able to boost standard of living up more by building a single railway, as transport cost a large amount of their income and is a local good, and it would of eliminated the market access penalty. There is a cap on how much immigration you can get too, so you could of likely managed to get quite a bit-the main issue would of been maintaining the trade routes to import the demanded goods, which would of required either joining a market or expanding the port.
You should redo it with Hamburg (free nation, can join british market, but has good relations into germany/austria/russia, too) or Lübeck (start in prussia market) and make "Hanse" great again.
Yo bro New idea for you Choose any small country Then switch to all major powers, declare independence of ALL their colonies, protectorates, vassals etc. Cuase internal havoc on all of them And come back to your original country and continue the usually
You should've pass open borders and use free grass campaign to fuel the growth of your population. Bc you could expanded your construction sectors, so capitalist construct more abroas so you can tax mora. Also your credit limit is the reserve founds of your local industry, you should have builded some. Bc the same resoning, once your gold reserves are full your extra income gets deleted, so if you build somo local industry you get a deficit/surplus window that let you afford more constraction so your capitalis can expend ttheir extra income
I have a big bahrain
Also, I forgot about after this went live, but thank you to all my patreon supporters. I love you guys, and I promise I'll remember to put your names up. Thank you guys for supporting what I do and helping me make these videos I love.
Chad Muffins:
artpremium
Mushkin Mandletort
Hasburrah
BeaverNation57
Can you try that in Switzerland with no expansion and open border i want to see how high you can get the GDP just by building constructions and service building only.
open the borders
@@lagigabut4600great idea I’d also like that
Pls pls pls pls pls iran
bro cooked with that 0.0GDP
I’m the best Victoria 3 player
@@Chummbo bro the gdp was so high that the game couldnt load it
That was crazy !
This is your Vic 3 Capitalist masterpiece. 0 actual production of goods, just international depredations and profiteering
YOU CHAD MUFFIN, I LOVE YOU. Thank you so much, I appreciate you and will forever remember this moment.
Devastation not from infrastructure. It's because you have a part of a split state and Paradox don't care about fixing bugs.
yep you are correct upvote so he see
Bruh what state are Qatar and Bahrain shared with like the UAE??
Today, none but pre-British overlordship, quite a few. From 1850's to 1910's, the rulers of both Qatar and Bahrain actually kept trying to one-up and claim sovereignty over the other whilst the Saudis kept raiding and stealing bits of their land. @electricVGC
Where is Qatar
@@fatmamostafawi3592 Palau
The one Time that Chumm‘s Clickbait Picture ain‘t clickbait
I finally did it
what the average nation a politician promises looks like:
You banned slavery!? Shit dude they haven’t even done that in real life! 😳🤯
he also gave women rights and cared for the workforce
@@oliwierbroda2575 That's too communist to do in real life...
I’m gonna blow your mind. The US hasn’t banned slavery either.
@@elijahbrothers14usa has indeed banned slavery. Modern "westerners" (europe, americas and mostly oceania) never met "traditional slavery", at least in such an extent and in such degree it was 100 or 200 years ago
@ it states in our constitution that slavery is banned unless charged with a crime so technically not really, especially when the US has the highest incarceration rate in the entire world and the biggest prison industrial complex in the entire world is essentially a slave system
I like how half of the issues people have with victoria 3 are just issues people have with real economic policy.
"I hate how capitalist re-investment isn't affected by taxes"
"Why do I have to pay these people so much"
Etc.
It’s great that the game models economics so well. He literally run into the same issues as the real gulf states, an upper strata that doesn’t contribute to the economy, petrodollars you can’t use, and a crippling labor shortage
I have only one issue with Victoria 3. Everytime my country become ritcher than rest of the world very quickly. Everytime I have monopol on production of everything very quckly. Everytime produckts in my country are the most expensive ones. Everytime my people are the richest of the richest, and also the biggest screamers for revolution.
Unlikely. Studies done on this show that countries with less taxes and "more capitalism" became richer in the aggregate. Sounds like the game does economics wrong.
There should be an update to reflect the real world
Everyone is a billionaire? I think this man has made Venezuela...
As a Venezuelan I confirm that everyone here is a billionaire.
Zimbabwe: Billionaire’s?! Pffft my people are trillionaire’s try to match that!
@@hallooos7585 nah man, the MAGYARS made people QUADRILLIONAIRES
This is how I learnt to play vicky 3, it was my first nation that I've played and was able to get a pretty good GDP + Standard of living in the Russian market back in version 1.2. Also I played Bahrain cause I'm Bahraini
Booo
1. So, everyone has supercars, yatchs, mansions, and a private plane.
2. How weird, you pay people a very comfortable wage, you see how quickly poverty is eliminated
3. I find it amusing how quickly the sultan closes the borders once he opened them. Maybe he's going to build some walls or something
4.
The difference is he wasn't paying his people money his people was paying their employers money this is who Capitalism works
23:20 the devastation was because you're a split state with bahrain so if they're occupied and get devastation it counts towards you
"So this is something i really don't like about victoria 3, is if you lower taxes, it doesn't affect the amount your capitalists or your rich people reinvest" That's not victoria 3, that's just real life.
No it isn’t lol.
@@wilhelmvon Absolutely it is, if you give rich people tax cuts, they don't reinvest, they hoard it. Look at the real world, trickle down economics don't work.
@wilhelmvon it is. Its called trickle down economy but it doesnt work cus rich people never reinvest into the economy
@ they do that’s how they get richer. But even buying yachts and putting money in the bank helps the economy.
the editing for this video kinda hurt my eyes
Was also going to say this, very choppy, fast paced cuts.
19 century Bahrain exporting SHIPS to the BRITISH EMPIRE is very funny to me :)
EVERY MAN A KING
EVERY MAN A KING
Achievement unlocked: It's BahRaining money.
You were getting devastation because your only state is a split state and the other part of it was occupied
This was a shocker. I would be disappointed if I were you
I’m disappointed every day of my life 😞
8:21 I wish i could say that. xD
But congratulations man! You have unlocked the "NOT A Paradox Player" achievement! Congrats! I wish you good luck in your relationship!
It's not just Bahrain; you also have Qatar.
20:52 Wow thanks for the info! I had no idea. it worked like that.
Although it should mean that the capitalists get more to spend later with lower taxes although with a efficiency 20%
Exporting the prduced fish for profit and importing fish to make it cheap in your own country is peak capitalism.
love the video, keep up the good work
0:07 actually they already did that in our timeline am from saudi arabia in school and I’ve seen people from all around the arabian world except bahrain and qatar and some african nation’s
This video shows how broken the economy is in Victoria 3
There is a mod called "Free Market Construction" that turns construction into a service that can be purchased on demand, imported, and exported. It needs some tweaking and balancing, but I feel it's an excellent concept that Paradox should incorporate.
4:00 most progressive V3 player
why is it so edited i feel like im watching tiktok brainrot
Open borders and greener grass, and this would have been so different
Chum:they are getting very rich
Topdown on the number:struggling
the number it simply just goes up
This man did with fish what IRL Bahrain did with oil
Today is a good day if Chumm uploads.
Side note, will you be doing any ChatGPT videos like you did back in the day?
I would love to one day, those vids were super fun to make
It's funny how you sold ships to the British
Historically Bahrain was the world's longest lasting luxury metals exporter. They talk about importing from Bahrain in the bible when Solomon is making the Temple.
Ea-Nasir is getting called out for having copper that isn't as nice as the copper from Bahrain.
It was a big part of the economy of the early Rashidun Caliphate.
Then they ran out of fancy metal :(
bro made irl monaco
as a bahraini bro💀 the big land is qatar while the small land having manama in it is bahrain also we have oil so yeah natural resources..
bro that's qatar. bahrain is the tiny island on the left
That was Bahrain before Qatar became a country and took like 60%+ of their territory
Bros actually good now??!!!! Chumm PLEASE make more content like this
15:36 I think your GDP was so high that the game couldn't process it and gave you zero.
The Arab eats locusts in the desert, the dog of Isfahan eats ice water
What about now little Persian 😂
Honestly it’d be amazing if you redid this run but actually tried for protectorates and opened the borders earlier, and maybe forming Arabia and snowballing massively
Bro just called Arabs Poor Peasant Farmers 💀💀💀
pre-colonialism arabs were poor peasant farmers
So what they were?
@@DZMapthey were peasants, that wasnt a thing in arabia.
@@DZMapwater farmers like Luke Skywalker?
@@DZMappoor fishermen
Just so you know, making profit while your gold reserves are full is just burning money, you should wanna be running a slight deficit at that point.
Everybody is Affluent, wealthy and lavish
With 0 GDP & GDP per capita is ???
because vicky 3 is silly like that
you never noticed how average income is always higher than gdp per capita anyway
23:40 no it's cuz Bahrain is a part of trucial coast / it's a split state and trucial coast was occupied and because of that the whole state including Bahrain will get devestation by
Shouldn't have not banned slavery because to keeping it historically accurate.
Historically you should have events like Bahrain tribe wars and formation of Quatar...its really intresting period the victorian era for that region,same goes for Bahrain, Paradox and modders should show some interest and not neglect those regions because from gaming aspect you have like events non stop.
You know who else has a marine focus on their economy? Louisiana. You know who else is famous for shipbuilding? Louisiana.
You can’t escape Louisiana forever…
NOOOO
when you have a small nation to play you notice how detailed this game is and how significant each decision is
I am just questioning why did you not switch to private health and education :D
edit YOU noticed at end it seems nvm :D
Thanks to the supporters in Chummbo's patreon!
May of been able to boost standard of living up more by building a single railway, as transport cost a large amount of their income and is a local good, and it would of eliminated the market access penalty. There is a cap on how much immigration you can get too, so you could of likely managed to get quite a bit-the main issue would of been maintaining the trade routes to import the demanded goods, which would of required either joining a market or expanding the port.
that 'girlfriend' joke was hilarious! 🤣🤣🤣
Hey chumm you were my top gaming creator this year
This made my day. Thanks for watching, you’re the best
Smithy and chumm? What a great pair! Maybe we could see some MP from you two? 💪🏼🔥
Soon!
Spiffingbrit quaking in his shoes rn..
Huey Long if “Every man a King” wasn’t just a slogan
Personally i think the flashy editing and tone of voice diminishes what would otherwise be a pretty nice video
technically there are already many countries where everyone is a billionaire. some even have 90% or higher trillionaiess
Excellent episode. Like the crazy challenge and the impressive SoL
Lmao. Would've loved to see the GDP ownership map at the end there.
Its 6 in the morning chumm has upload truly a blessing
You should redo it with Hamburg (free nation, can join british market, but has good relations into germany/austria/russia, too) or Lübeck (start in prussia market) and make "Hanse" great again.
Yo, it was a good video. But I think you need to pan and rotate the map some more; that would be *chef's kiss* perfect.
Only thing I know about bahrain I learnt from a man I was sat next to in an airplane, apparently the king is quite ok
I remember when he had 6k subs, loves his vids ❤
Glad to see you still haha
6:21 Is there actually a bug with LF, or did a joke go over my head?
Bahrain actually did irl
Yo bro
New idea for you
Choose any small country
Then switch to all major powers, declare independence of ALL their colonies, protectorates, vassals etc.
Cuase internal havoc on all of them
And come back to your original country and continue the usually
I chumm my pants every time I see you upload
Everyone in Venezuela is a billionaire IRL
Yuup Chumm keep it up! Waiting on the Tahiti run 🔥💯
Greetings from Bahrain 🇧🇭👋
Try with mods to import services and offshore construxtion and ships
Bro buit Bahrain from real life
Every man a sultan
Fun fact:That big peninsula is Qatar not Bahrain. Bahrain is the small island to its northwest
0 GDP, over 20 standard of living and 69% literacy. Nice.
I love this kind of video❤
You should've pass open borders and use free grass campaign to fuel the growth of your population. Bc you could expanded your construction sectors, so capitalist construct more abroas so you can tax mora. Also your credit limit is the reserve founds of your local industry, you should have builded some. Bc the same resoning, once your gold reserves are full your extra income gets deleted, so if you build somo local industry you get a deficit/surplus window that let you afford more constraction so your capitalis can expend ttheir extra income
Wait what that’s quatar and that island beside it is barhin
Would this be like earthly paradise or not!?
Bro the transition sound effect is extremely distracting
Bahrain? Poor? Bro got his economy wrong😂
Slavery is barbaric. Let's use minimum wage workers in foreign country. Oh yes, this is beautifully Vic3.
You could’ve make pop like 0-1 and inflation 1000000000000000000000% so everyone would be billionaire
the small island is bahrain the mainland is qatar
You don’t need to over edit the video. Cut it to fast in the long time will hurt people eyes. ( i’m editor. So consider that!)
In other languages Cthulhu is actually pronounced something like “Ktulkhu” so more hushing sounds and less ^UwU^
you are extremely cool, what an honest laugh you had ;)))
Is that qatar?
Why Chumm doesn't know word "pounds"?
He’s american
@marshallallen2474 Shouldn't he you use miles per square people?
Would forming Scandinavian help to pay the bills?
Good gameplay bro 👍🏼
I appreciate you as always bro
What's the laissez-faire bug?
Idk if they fixed it, but with laissez faire, sometimes your financial districts won’t build things
Bro tell us single in 888 different languages
I don't think there was enough transitions and zoom ins tbh
Technically its Qatar and the small island beside it its Bahrain