“Whose Side Are You On?” Julia Hartley-Brewer’s FIERCE Clash With Labour MP
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2024
- Keir Starmer is facing an internal party row over his plan to keep the Conservatives’ two-child benefit cap.
Angela Rayner has reportedly labelled the policy as ‘obscene and inhumane.’
TalkTV’s Julia Hartley-Brewer challenges Shadow Culture Secretary Lucy Powell over whether she supports the policy.
Julia: “Who’s side are you on?”
Lucy Powell: “Well look both things are true.”
Julia: “It’s obscene and inhumane but you are going to keep it?”
#talktv #talkradio #clash #labour
Should the Labour party keep the Conservatives’ two-child benefit cap?
If you can't afford a child you shouldn't have 1 !
Simply
Literally paying folk to have kids 🤦♂️
We all know who would benefit the most .........
YES!
@@TonyToning-ne7uqexactly
"We will have better relationships with France" (How?).
"We will have return agreements in place" (How?).
It's all bull. Neither party want to stop it.
Must agree with you hole hearted !!!!
@@davidbarrs9721 Go and see a doctor.
@@davidbarrs9721 Whole David.
100%
@fluxington it's becoming pretty difficult to see a doctor these days if you haven't noticed.
Well done Lucy Powell you have just stuffed Labours chances.....
I doubt it.
The problem of course is the very outdated and mega-inefficient two party system.
One of them gets in govt and screws everything up,at the next GE,the other lot get in and screw everything up and so it goes,on and on.
I’m 69 and never known this once great country to be so hideously broken and divided.
I,along with I suspect,millions of other voters are politically homeless and the danger of this is the rise of extremism within the indigenous population who are frustrated as hell and more distant from our “masters” than ever before.
I have decided to vote for ReformUK next time and will probably be called a racist.
No she hasn't...the dumbfk sheeple will still vote for them....the UK's worst enemy....our own electorate....
If you want to save our country, never vote for the Tories,Labour, Liberals,or Greens ever again
Monster raving loony party is the only sensible choice.
😂😂😂
Genius
I’ll be voting for whoever has the best manifesto and plans to improve the lives of the many not the few.
Which instantly rules out the tories.
A vote for any of the above is a vote for the WEF
@@kaysussex4991 no it isn’t
@@kaysussex4991 and nobody wants the Women's Expeditionary Force in charge.
With people like her this country is doomed
Perfect example of being able to speak and not say anything
I mean look at the state of this MP doing an interview with a biker jacket on 😂😂😂😂
They just don't give a fig, 2 minutes after this interview she'll be sneering and laughing, and calling us racists.
Imagine a male programmer creates software based on logic, compared to a female programmer who creates software based on her emotions 🤔
She’s going to magic a new curriculum for computer science for girls adding in equality, diversity and inclusion plus gender studies😂😂
I can't believe what this hells angel is saying.
Not hard to see why we are in the state we're in when this is our clsss of leaders.
Can someone enlighten me to the 'comprehensive' plan that Yvette Cooper has set out to tackle the migrant issue?
😂 what a crock of rubbish, all she is doing is digging a huge hole for herself...
These MPs are excellent at saying a lot of words without actually saying or solving anything!
This is why I have never voted for this lot in my life
Never vote Labourstan ☪️
Angela Rayner regards anything thought of, or said by Tories as obscene and inhumane. Like all who claim or beleive themselves to be Socialists, she thinks that whatever SHE does is right, however mad, inconsistent with reality or just plain stupid it is.
It makes me laugh that the Labour party think people actually believe that they will sort immigration - when we all know that their solution is just going to be to allow everyone in. At the end of the interview I like how she said there will be lots of good Labour policies that they will not bring in because of the economic situation - nothing like getting your excuses in early (in this case even before they are elected).
I'm an engineer in a high tech job. We have schools come in all time. They force young girls to come to the our office, and none I have meat in the last 5 years are interested. The head of HR even did a STEM for girls week for local schools, giving away free stuff, not one girl took part. Basic facts ---girls like people---boys like things.
Absolutely.
Have heard this for years, nothing will change.
Absolutely CLUELESS! No one should vote Labour or Conservative EVER AGAIN!!!
Basically they will do nothing!! It will be far worse under Labour! And that’s saying something!!
Wat a load of hot Air yet a gain😫
Who ate all the PIES? Who ate all the pies ?😥🍿🍿🍿🍿🍿
No paperwork, no entry. That will speed things up. Part of the problem is the lack of identification.
If you stop the benefits they wont come! SIMPLE. Labour all talk and no Action
What she means is, she'll let them all stay and then invite all of their family's to join them as well.. Absolutely clueless... 🤬 🤬 🤬 🤬 🤬
How embarrassing, they have no clue. Just waffling as ever.
Why can’t the public see how many of these people are processed each day, a scorecard if you like then we can see for ourselves especially as Labour improves the process
Here goes the merry go round. Haven't we heard this all before and again nothing will get done. It makes one wonder how the British tourist industry are surviving the closure of hotels to migrants?
She was an unemployed art teacher until she decided to become a Labour MP as the qualifications needed were lower = be woke and female and or POC.
If they cleared the backlog of migrant applications tomorrow it would not stop them coming over by boat.
The only Party to deal with all of this is the Reform Party.
Does the MP realise that if a subject is boring, then it is boring to boys and girls, I cannot see how that is a valid argument.
This from the likes of Labour MPs that blocked the deportation of a criminal Immigrant out of our country who then murdered a British subject, they were complicit in that murder, if not aiding him to commit that murder because otherwise they would have been put on the plane and removed from our country and that person now would be still alive
none of them want to stop them
What's Labour's plan, then? Give them all homes?
So, if, giving the benefit of the doubt on the side of the migrant.. They pass.. They're allowed to stay legally...
Er
Where are they going to stay!
It doesn't solve anything regarding accommodation, does it.
Correct me if I’m wrong but our nation is an island surrounded by water, how difficult is it to prevent people from illegally entering an island? Seriously! It’s not like the USA where 7 MILLION people illegal immigrants have already walked across the border into the USA.
Oh yes we need to address how women are disadvantaged now days!!🙄🙄🙄
Labour will do exactly what they did last time to reduce the asylum
Backlog. They’re going to have an amnesty and allow anyone currently in the UK with an asylum
Claim to stay and then claim they’ve sorted the problem. And just like the last time they did that, it will send a signal to all the economic migrants in Asia and Africa that the UK is a soft touch and they’ll flood over in the boats like they have done since they had the last amnesty. Not to mention the fact that all those given permission to remain will be submitting family reunion applications for their family members to join. Sadly it looks like labour will get in but the country will fall to its knees so quickly that I don’t think they’ll be able to see out a full term.
Great interview. Easy to see what is wrong in this great country. Vote tory ,labour, or tory. You on road to disaster.
Q. What would you do to tackle the migration problem?
A. Give them the right to stay.
Where are they going to live?
The one quick solution to this problem is to just take them all back to France until they go through the legal process if these people can afford to pay for a boat ride then they can afford to go through the legal procedures.
Reform ...enough said
Anyone who thinks our politicians don’t want this level of net migration are living in la la land.
10:09 Isn't "interest rates going through roof" the same as "the cost of borrowing going through the roof, if we let this moronic party squirm it's way back in to power, this country is doomed.
Its quite surprising that she says it wasn't as bad when Labour were last in power because they were coming over in the back of trucks then. This is a new way of getting across the channel and why would France have better relations with the Labour party.
Just a joke of a politician 😡😡😡
She looks like a Labour MP.
does not matter who you vote for they say they are going to do this and that it never happens and their should be a law if they do not keep to what they say it should mean jail or banded from being an mp .
The world is a stage ......all of these creatures are laughing at you.....
they will be more efficient, because they will just let them in without checks and grant them everything they want
Wasn’t it labour that fixed the “illegal migration” issue we had last time, they just made them all “legal migrants”! Job done.
When a Polly speaks with such a broad Yorky accent - you know they are clueless.
Lucy Powel is speaking on behalf of the Labour party and she is just talking a load of CRAP .
'Sound good on paper.'
We know who's side she's on! 🤣🧐🤬
Sound bites and spin...YOU WILL DO NOTHING,ZILCH NADA go away.
The jacket 😂
Durrr, you can spot the liebour at 200 paces .Who would benefit from the abolition of the two child benifit limit ,let me think every native Briton I know has 2 children .Only certain other people have 4-5 and six children as standard
This country is a third world end of because of MPs like this
Labour telling us about ethics 😂
Hopefully people will wake up and see that MPs on all sides work for one cause and that's their own pockets.
It's a nightmare, labour would be worse than the useless conservatives. Reform is our only hope of any common sense
SUPPORT THE BLADE RUNNERS
And when they are given citizenship, where are they going to live and who is going to pay for that.
They are, because they will be able to work and contribute to the economy!!!
@@robertgannon-cx2mm
I believe most will work in low paid jobs at best. They will need benefits to support them. They will require somewhere to live , private or social, both of which are in short supply, therefore adding to the housing crisis that so many face. Whilst helping to drive rents up
I just don’t buy the line that this immigration will benefit those all ready here.
Don’t blame anyone for coming here thought!!
Typical Labour answers!
They have ALL the 'why's', but NONE of the 'how's'!
Everyone & their dogs know exactly WHY stuff needs to be done, including the incumbent Tory Govt, but the thing is, there are sooooo many stumbling-blocks, & argumentative pedants, stalling every single move made to solve the issues, that nothing seems to be actioned!
Can we please work in the National interest for a change, instead of idiot 'point-scoring'?!?!
That's not a plan, we want it stopped, period
Why is there even a process for illegal migrants, especially from Albania and other non conflict countries! Straight back in the boats they saved up to charter.
Labour couldn't run a bath let alone a country!!!
Looking at and listening to this ridiculous woman reminds me why I would NEVER vote Labour.
Gammons gonna gammon
Thats an MP! How standards have slipped below zero.
These people wouldn't get a job in the private sector they're beyond hope
The low standard of MP we have in this country...
standards slipped decades ago
@@rayalbion9637 i blame blair! like i do fdoe everything !
It's a biker chick!
Absolutely clueless, I’m genuinely scared about the future of this country if these clowns get in. The Tories are bad enough, get ready for things getting a whole lot worse! Vote Reform.
I'm scared either of them get in. Its like choosing your favourite executioner
Reform will help nutty labour
The dishonesty is breathtaking
I don't even think it's dishonesty! These people especially this brainless f@t Manc t@rt really believe what they're saying! The crux of the problem imo.
we've just had two terms of THE MOST DISHONEST GOVT EVER. Good God.. more of the Tory sh*tstorm??? There's not much of a choice is there ???
tony blair said in sky news last week we need to increase immigration and rejoin the EU in the future under the new labour government you cannot trust labour
And you’re surprised why..?!
I hope people can now see that the level of Labour MPs is abysmal.
We are no longer represented by any party....especially Labour .....they hate the working class more than the tories
And the left have the nerve to call tories corrupt
👍👍👍👍
Christ. I've never seen anyone with such a strong dislike of reality.
I take it that you are looking at the mirror ?
@@fredarcher7264 Do you care to elaborate? Do you think she made good points or something?
Brilliant.
@@fredarcher7264What a useless comment. Can you not discuss without being rude? Guess not.
@@user-sg2nt7dq4w The irony in defending an individual as caustic and intolerant as Brew Head .
The French wave the boats off. What planet is this woman on.
Planet Labour.
They havnt forgiven us for Trafalger and Waterloo.
@@ivorproblem1332indeed and well said 👍👏🤣🤣
Labour will deal with the backlog ....by granting them all amnesty and citizenship
Guaranteed.
you know mate
Yep and with no checks at all.
That would be brilliant!!!
I remember the days when MPs weren't dressed like members of bike gangs🙄
This woman and others like her could be in charge of the country soon. Be afraid.
Be very afraid!!
The thought of Angela Rayner fills me with horror. If the country is going to be badly run then it should be badly run by clowns who are at least educated
Not only that, be HORRified
Anyone that thinks Labour will sort this problem are seriously deluded.
Anyone who thinks anything could be worse than under the Tories is also deluded
@@paulsimpson3269 Russia couldn't get worse than under the Romanovs, and Iran couldn't get worse than under the Shah?
@@paulsimpson3269 You are in for a surprise.Obviously you have forgotten previous Labour government
@@rogerwoodhouse7945😂😂😂😂😂😂
Reform certainly won't
Another Labour MP talking and actually saying nothing.
1 million this year
1 million next year
Fruit picking very busy?
Opps don't forget
Massive heat climate
Middle East and Europe 🌍
Another 1 million
No wonder UK sinking like the Titanic
Street wise TAL.......am off to north pole
N
She said nothing about what they would do. She also didn’t say wether her dealings were with the migrants or the constituents. My gues it’s with the migrant.
@@Talboy-d7gthe EU is sinking faster than the UK
Absolutely
Comes from the top brass.
If Labour cannot see that throwing money at the French,does nothing after all the money in the past given to them,then they do not deserve to be M.P.'s
Well said load of rubbish !!!
What's with all the commas and apostrophes ?
@@johnristheanswer My un-educatated little brain,Johnny.
@maidsubrena I agree,makes sense to me...
Liebour won't just throw money at the French - their plan is to return the UK to the thrall of the EU.
This would neutralise the economic threat that the UK poses to the EU (or at least the threat we would pose if our government had the balls to fully embrace Brexit). That's a win for the EU.
This would also ensure EU socialist policies were foisted upon the UK, regardless of whether Liebour were in power or not. That's a win for Liebour.
This MP has just stopped me from ever voting Labour !!!! No idea at all.
The reality is Labour would clear this up in one swoop, it's called The Open Door Policy.
The Tories are doing a good job at the open door policy by themselves.
@@Bacon4Rashers Every time the Gov't. try to sort it, the lefty lawyers rub their hands with glee saying... more legal aid money for me.
You mean a wider open door policy than we have now
Both parties are WEF stooges.
Absolutely. They will deal with the backlog by granting asylum for all on the list without any kind of checks.
Who voted this woman to be an MP? She spews word salad and can only criticise tories with no solution. She's not representing the voters.
Blind fools who only vote on a colour and not policy
Gender quotas
Listen to Angela Rayner, she is exactly the same way and offers no solutions but just plays to the misery by focussing on berating, criticising and mocking the opposition. They have absolutely nothing to offer except their own misery.
@@aglaisio thanks. Will do
i do know one thing women are just as crap at getting things done as men ,just look at the women in charge at all tick a box levels and see the mess they are in ,man or women it should be the best person for a job not woke ideology, positive discrimination is discrimination at its worst as they know they are doing it
Watching that Labour MP makes me realise that we should all vote for the Reform Party.
correct there both the same
Tice has the personality of a damp flannel.
Yep. Enough is enough
Why? What's Reforms policy on education? What's their policy on addressing climate change? What's their policy on ASC? How will they reduce inflation, reduce the debt, and create growth?
You surely mean The Reclaim Party
Wow she never stopped talking but said nothing.
Another Labour MP who wouldnt stand up to scrutiny in a debate with Baldrick. At least when he had a cunning plan it sort of gave you a laugh if nothing else.
And he had a plan , all labour do is knock the tories without solutions
Who needs Baldrick when you've got Julie Hartley Brewer?
@@pjduff7577 When your only plan is the worst plan ever and most expensive Labour shouldn't back it, I'd bet their plans, which they obviously do have is much better than the hundreds of millions of pounds the Rwanda plan has cost and is going to continue to cost, But what is worse is that there are stupid people out there who continue to back this corrupt and incompetent party despite all of the wasted billions and billions, them blame other party's... Go figure!!!! They walk among us!
There’s a joke in here somewhere about ‘I have a cunning plan’. But I can’t think what it is.
Lmfao 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😜👍
What hope has this country got? Choosing between the two main parties is like choosing between the electric chair or lethal injection.
With the choice shown at least you will know the result not like the politicians bullshit we have to listen to every day
Yvette cooper was part of the open door policy when Blair said not many would come across from the eu.
Correct..the number was 16,000 that Brown and Blair were touting, absolute lying b@sterds.
Loads of Polish people came over and worked their arses off. Doing the jobs lazy people wouldn't touch. It's the dinghy divers that are purely taking the piss!
In many areas there has been a reduction of English workers by 98% within twenty years. So it's not integration but actually unlawful foreign occupation and discrimination against us.
FINALLY… A very truthful & factual comment that cuts to the bone. And for once TH-cam has not censored it. Very good to see. And yes Blair has a Feckin lot to answer for…
@@bonglandgreg tell me about it. I worked for a company & was the ONLY UK person there. Not kidding. A few of them could speak some English, most were very hostile despite being in another country. Not surprisingly the dude who spoke the best English was safe. The others made no attempt to speak English & were very rude & hostile. Why would they?
Well done Lucy…you’ve just lost my vote at the next election
never had it lol
Labour party is the the party of the scrounger
A nightmare Labour Government looks odds on to win the next election, but you wait after 6 , ,months to a year of a Labour Government these useful idiots that voted for Labour will be severely regretting there voting decision, and want them out
i am surprised you ever even considered them in the first place!
@@davidanderson7138me too 😂
So Labours policy is let everyone in
same as conservatives then
It always has been and always will be unfortunatel.
Where are we going to dump their excrement and piss, in the water supply, or round our beaches. Labour has not decided.
@@user-sg2nt7dq4w You know that will confuse our new arrivals. We will be wondering why they're using tampons as handkerchief.
@@user-sg2nt7dq4w I once took a girl to a posh French restaurant, we all washed our fingers In the lemon water, seconds later she downs the finger bowl meant for washing your hands, calls the waitress over and asks for another shot of finger bowl juice.
Some things you cannot teach.
Well done Lucy you have done what MP'S do best spoke a load of dribble
The laws are already in place and if they called a state of emergency then the boats can be stopped straight away and it would all be legal and above all it just lacks the will to do it .
The government don't want to do it
There’s only one thing to say here. Vote Reform.
😂😂😂😂😂
And if you do you will split the vote and let labour.
@@sugarkane4830 Not if every sane person in this country votes Reform
All main parties are as bad as each other! vote Reform it’s our only hope.
tony blair said in sky news last week we need to increase immigration and rejoin the EU in the future under the new labour government you cannot trust labour
God help us if labour get in
God help us if labour get into power
Totally agree, freedom of movement destroyed
@@BLITSolutions2014 yes. It's very sinister what the Fabians / WEF / Israel lobby have done to Labour. They're not the party of the people anymore. It's frightening. It least you know what you're getting with the tories, though they do take too much for themselves & were also bought by the lobby groups.
Do these fools think the general public believes a single word they say.
but she doesn’t SAY anything …. meaningless drivel
Why do most of the shadow cabinet remind me of idealised primary school teachers. Imagen them presiding over any crisis!
Because that's your last memory of education so you have no better reference.
@@sueyourself5413 haha love it. But you know I’m right!
@@user-sg2nt7dq4w that’s what I was trying to say!
Another thick labour mp talking crap
@@user-sg2nt7dq4w Is one of the letters W.