In 1880th years Zola traveled across France. He visited a poor rural district of the country to observe the living and working conditions of striking coal miners. Germinal is a result of that experience. So this story is completely realistic. The life of workers was difficult without any hope for a "light future". But ideas for a new life began to germinate. Thank you! IT's nice choice
I liked it! Thank you. I’ve just read Germinal. And you described this book 👌 . Zola excellently showed communication between different people , philosophy of class conflict, and seeds of new life (Germinal). Bravo. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🧡
Hi! This book is still familiar to me from your video. But it must be interesting. I read half of the Strugatsky book, Monday starts on Saturday. It was your recommendation too. I can't keep up with you 👏👏👏
I remember that Germinal is one of the 📚 big Zola’s series. It’s a very revolutionary book in old time. I haven’t read others book from Series. But I feel to must do it. 😄 thank you for the video and great review
Thank you for the book! After your video, I have made up that Revolution should happen this year that we understand how we have lived well for previous years. It's a joke
Well done! It’s gloomy book. 😭😭😭I wanted that Katherine and Ettienn would make a family, but she passed away in a mine. 🥲 too many people died. Why must new life build after a catastrophe?
@@vovashko Never ever expect a happy ending when you're reading Zola 😄. His main characters always get dragged through the dirt. I'm surprised that Etienne made it to the end lol. Great review!
As always an interesting book 👏🏻this is particularly true in our hard pandemic time. We should understand that life can be a lot worse. Thanks!
Well said!
In 1880th years Zola traveled across France. He visited a poor rural district of the country to observe the living and working conditions of striking coal miners. Germinal is a result of that experience. So this story is completely realistic. The life of workers was difficult without any hope for a "light future". But ideas for a new life began to germinate. Thank you! IT's nice choice
Thanks! And for your insight as well!
Thank you for the information! This book reminds me Les Miserables from Victor Hugo.
There is some resemblance!
I liked it! Thank you. I’ve just read Germinal. And you described this book 👌 . Zola excellently showed communication between different people , philosophy of class conflict, and seeds of new life (Germinal). Bravo. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🧡
True!
Hi! This book is still familiar to me from your video. But it must be interesting. I read half of the Strugatsky book, Monday starts on Saturday. It was your recommendation too. I can't keep up with you 👏👏👏
Hah, no worries! What do you think of Strugatsky book so far?
@@vovashko It's funny! I admire Strugatsky's fantasy!
I remember that Germinal is one of the 📚 big Zola’s series. It’s a very revolutionary book in old time. I haven’t read others book from Series. But I feel to must do it. 😄 thank you for the video and great review
Thank you! I’ll also check some others from him. He wrote around 12 novels as far as I remember.
Thank you 🙏
Germinal sounds like a growth book that provides perspective.
Thank you for the book! After your video, I have made up that Revolution should happen this year that we understand how we have lived well for previous years. It's a joke
It's interesting. I heard about Zola and his novels, but I haven't read them yet. I must read it, thank you
Thanks for watching!
Thanks! I appreciate your job especially pictures of main heroes ! 👍
Thanks!
I liked it! Thank you!!!! I want not to repeat the ugliest period history! I wish to people would live happy! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
The book was written in my winter list! Thanks 😊
Of course!
Yes! 👍 The poverty is enormous power, which can change world. Thank you
Thanks 👍 French literature! Next topic may be trip to France?
Haha, could be 😉
Thank you! Book club 👍👍👍
I’m glad you liked it!
Привет.Интересно.Глубоко.Доходчиво.Молодец.👌👍👏💯❤
Thank you 🙏
Молодец. Очень интересно. Умница. Продолжай. @👏👍❤️
Well done! It’s gloomy book. 😭😭😭I wanted that Katherine and Ettienn would make a family, but she passed away in a mine. 🥲 too many people died. Why must new life build after a
catastrophe?
I was rooting for them the whole book, and it was disheartening to see her die in the end
Thank you 🙏
@@vovashko Never ever expect a happy ending when you're reading Zola 😄. His main characters always get dragged through the dirt. I'm surprised that Etienne made it to the end lol. Great review!
Good job 👍 unfortunately, modern miners live in poverty . they work more easy , but a mine remains a dangerous place.
Yeah, unfortunately not much changed