I thought it was a smart move, removing their most popular video at the same time as they were getting flak for not showing a certain other one. It gave them a few plausible deniability options. ;)
th-cam.com/video/2ZCWCGebAuU/w-d-xo.html they cut this part " that's and in the 1980s and in the 1980s and 90s Israeli soldiers had left booby trap toys in southern Lebanon that exploded when excited children pick them up"
How dare you delete the original video that was getting traction, and upload a shorter version. The truth lives on. Full written speech is available on PressTV.
Absolutely sickening that the original video was taken off and replaced by this trimmed version! Oxford Union are inadvertently fuelling antisemitism: the idea that Jews control media! The new president of the Union should be ashamed of himself!
@@youngflexman Yup. Google, who owns TH-cam, is on Israel's side. They don't want the video becoming too popular and thus get recommended in the algorithm to people ignorant on the subject matter.
They probably wish they could just remove her speech altogether. Here's to another million views. As Susan Abulhawa's speech is brilliant and nothing they do will change that.
@OxfordUnion - absolutely disgraceful to have deleted the original. For such a prestigious institution to resort to censoring free speech, you undermine the very principles of open dialogue and intellectual integrity that you claim to uphold.
Oxford is just a networking facility for Britain’s inter-generational ruling elite. It produces pompous, arrogant, selfish graduates, a lot of whom go on to maintain a deeply unequal society, which rips most people off.
They’ve edited out the sections of the speech which detail Israel’s war crimes - the part where she describes the s**ual torture/abuse of Palestinian doctors, the booby trapping of toys to target children. These are all substantiated statements of fact but they’re censored. Because how dare Brits hear what a regime that we provide arms and political backing to does. Because the far right are allowed to speak freely to spread their hate but a Palestinian woman is not allowed the same freedom.
@@soulfulfreedomheart2505 they prevent the upload of mossab hassan debate until someone else posted a leak version of the voice recording. now they re-upload some of the videos so the timestamp of the uploaded videos is aligned. shame to oxford for hiding their ugly truth
This isn't the original speech by Susan, this is a carved up version that the Israeli lobby have pressured Oxford Uni to upload instead of the original, so much for Oxford Union being the home of free speech. Please see below for the wording that Zionists wanted you not to hear. First cut 00:03.49 to 00:05.05 and in the 1980s and 90s, Israeli soldiers had left booby-trapped toys in Southern Lebanon that exploded when excited children picked them up. Second cut 00:08.38 to 00:03.57 "if Palestinians were systematically raping Jewish Drs and other captives with hot metal rods, jagged and electrified sticks and fire extinguishers. Sometimes raping them to death as happened with Dr Adnan Al-Bursh and others. Third cut 00:10.52 to 00:11.01 These notions of entitlement and privilege, of being divinely favourer or blessed or chosen. Forth cut 00:11.49 to 00:12.12 You carved out our hearths, because it's clear that you do not know how to live in the world without dominating others. You have crossed all lines and nurtured the most vile of human impulses. Fifth cut 00:12.18 to 00:12.24 And they are seeing the reality of who you are and who you have always been. Sixth cut 10:16 these notions of entitlement and privilege, of being divinely favoured, blessed, or chosen"
Absolutely disgraceful to delete the previously uploaded video of Susan's speech, which had hundreds of thousands of views, and replace it with a shortened, edited version. Remember, they wouldn't try to silence you if your voice didn't matter. Keep speaking up for Palestinian freedom and justice!!!!
@@mISSsophisa they're in the comment section. Someone posted all the edited out bits and it is SO OBVIOUS who's behind it!!!!!! Every time I post the edited parts, my comment gets deleted.
Disgraceful that you have edited Susans historic speech. The Union should be totally ashamed of censoring this courageous woman! Kindly set the original video to public again so that you can again claim to hold the principles of free speech dear.
@@barrybarry-b5h Then debunk them. If this or that particular accusation is not well attested, you should be able to demonstrate it. But that's not really the issue, is it? The issue is that her speech was overwhelmingly true and was getting very wide circulation. That is why the Oxford Union was pressured to take it down and why they did the next "best" thing of replacing it with an edited version to slow its spread by restarting the view counter and thereby reducing its likelihood of appearing in people's feeds. It its the most cynical and cowardly form of censorship and will be a stain on the reputation of the Oxford Union as the supposed "last bastion of free speech."
it's funny that she says that Jews do not belong to that land, because Jews lived on this land and had a Jewish kingdom when Abu what's her names' ancestors were still living in the Arabian peninsula, worshipping idols and burying women alive.
@@THEG12EG They were not Arabs. Arabs migrated to the area in the 7th century, long after the Jews lived there. Jews were expelled from that land to many places, Europe included.
Although edited by the pressure of a state wanted for war crimes. This was truly the slam-dunk speech of the whole debate!The speech that will be remembered and go down as one of the greatest speeches of our time.
I could watch this brilliant speech only until the first huge lie came @1:21 "...conquering what remained of Palestine in 1967". Until 1967 the West bank was occupied by Jordan and Gaza was occupied by Egypt.
Bc they intended to leave a pro Israel speaker out and then were pressured to upload his speech so they shortened and edited them all to try to pretend they are unbiased.
They do that on a lot of videos even with opposition speakers like Hassan Yousuf. Like when he asked the Oxford union to raise their hands if they would have contacted authorities to warn Israel about October 7th and only 5% of the audience raised their hands. They cut that out of the video.
Dear Oxford Union, would you like to be transparent and explain your reasoning for removing parts of Susan’s outstanding speech? And for deleting the original video of her which had close to 1M views? Or is the truth just too scary for you too??
The Israeli Hasbara forced the Oxford Union to remove the original speech with a million views, edit it and reupload the shorter version to make it appear lower than the Mossad Mosab rant. Sneaky Zios..
And they taught them to tie their shoelaces and how to put one foot in front of the other. Are you not tired of the lies? Do you think this awful arrogant attitude makes you more likeable to others?
Can you imagine the outcry if Oxford Union dared edit and censor parts of the fantastic historic speeches made by Malcolm X and James Baldwin in Oxford Union?
Truly Orwellian times when the censorship is this strong. Even during an active genocide. Never forget the guilty and its enablers. Oxford Union, history will not forget.
Oxford deleted her original speech because it was getting too much traction. And reuploads never get pushed by the youtube algorithm as hard as an original video. Oxford is a disgrace.
Five times. Go see her tweet about it, and my transcript of the censored bits. Mea culpa: In fact, 5 parts were cut from the video. I didn't count how many interruptions.
@suzannenobel6809 and one can argue that the preposition was denying and justifying the horrors of October 7th, where civilians and even babies suffered unspeakable things (not by accident, but they were target). Part of the problem with this is the unwillingness to see the other part as humans. Everyone sees the other as monsters, which is understandable for both parts but ultimately counterproductive.
Oxford Union: By trying to de-promote this speech by deleting the widely viewed original, you are failing to understand what Susan Abulhawa said: This is over, no more impunity, no more a free path for oppressors. Think carefully about which side of history you are on.
even oxford can't avoid from Z lobbyists. They deleted the original, shortened it, reuploaded it, hopefully will get less view than the original one...
So much for freedom of speech. To delete the original speech of a Palestinian speaker and upload an edited version without her consent is despicable. Worse you do this after she had to speak in the presence of actors directly involved in the ongoing genocide of her people, in the face of constant aggressive heckling. We almost never hear Palestinian voices directly. For you to act like this under pressure from those seeking the annihilation of the Palestinian people is unforgivable. It makes you complicit. Shame on you.
it will go down in history as a huge lie haha, a bunch of lies. Booby trapped toys, food cans and poisoned food. Do you really believe this? Have you researched it?
@@Elizadoolittle1948 yeah it will go down in history as one of the most absolutely ignorant and intellectually dishonest speeches ever. No accountability for the Palestinians and their actions, such bad faith in argumentation by focusing solely on emotional appeals, lack of understanding about basics of how the rules of war work, etc.
If you read through the comments carefully you can see exactly which parts of this amazing speech have been removed because it hurt somebody's feelings, never mind the deaths of tens (or more likely hundreds) of thousands of Palestinians that are etched into every line of this address by Susan.
@3:47 they cut this part out "...and in the 1980s and 90s, Israeli soldiers had left booby-trapped toys in southern Lebanon that exploded when excited children picked them up."
All the parts that were cut: First cut @3:49 and in the 1980s and 90s, Israeli soldiers had left booby-trapped toys in Southern Lebanon that exploded when excited children picked them up. Second cut @8:38 "if Palestinians were systematically raping Jewish Drs and other captives with hot metal rods, jagged and electrified sticks and fire extinguishers. Sometimes raping them to death as happened with Dr Adnan Al-Bursh and others. Third cut @10:52 These notions of entitlement and privilege, of being divinely favourer or blessed or chosen. Forth cut @11:49 You carved out our hearths, because it's clear that you do not know how to live in the world without dominating others. You have crossed all lines and nurtured the most vile of human impulses. Fifth cut @12:18 And they are seeing the reality of who you are and who you have always been.
@@nikimassey3970 where? give the timestamp. Let's watch you embarrass yourself. Or are you gonna be like the rest of the zios in the comment section, once their lies are exposed they delete their comments and disappear... we'll see about this one.
Why would you make the previous, unedited video private, while uploading this obviously edited version? Why the change? Be transparent about why Oxford Union made this change. It’s because there was an external pressure campaign by supporters of apartheid and genocide.
@@barrybarry-b5h This isn't the original speech by Susan, this is a carved up version that the Israeli lobby have pressured Oxford Uni to upload instead of the original, so much for Oxford Union being the home of free speech. Please see below for the wording that Zionists wanted you not to hear. First cut 00:03.49 to 00:05.05 and in the 1980s and 90s, Israeli soldiers had left booby-trapped toys in Southern Lebanon that exploded when excited children picked them up. Second cut 00:08.38 to 00:03.57 "if Palestinians were systematically raping Jewish Drs and other captives with hot metal rods, jagged and electrified sticks and fire extinguishers. Sometimes raping them to death as happened with Dr Adnan Al-Bursh and others. Third cut 00:10.52 to 00:11.01 These notions of entitlement and privilege, of being divinely favourer or blessed or chosen. Forth cut 00:11.49 to 00:12.12 You carved out our hearths, because it's clear that you do not know how to live in the world without dominating others. You have crossed all lines and nurtured the most vile of human impulses. Fifth cut 00:12.18 to 00:12.24 And they are seeing the reality of who you are and who you have always been. Regarding the first statement: "But a much more sinister accusation has also circulated since the 90s - that of bombs being dropped by Israeli aircraft in southern Lebanon intentionally concealed in children's toys. Lebanese newspaper L'Orient-Le Jour reported on the phenomenon in 1997, citing a number of examples including a nine-year-old girl who had her right hand shredded after finding a "big apple-green plastic jeep, with six big black wheels" that blew up in her hand after finding it near her village. They also mentioned the example of a child who was left with severe burns after finding a booby-trapped flashlight and another girl who was killed after exclaiming "I found a doll!" before being blown up. An officer of the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (Unifil) confirmed to AFP at the time that the objects were mainly dropped by helicopter." You missed a few that these evils want censored: add at 10:16 who harbored the same supremacist ideologies
The Israeli Hasbara forced the Oxford Union to remove the original speech with a million views, edit it and reupload the shorter version to make it appear lower than the Mossad Mosab rant. Sneaky Zios…
Susan spoke so beautifully and moving that it brought me to tears and I am not even Paletinian, Jewish or Middle Eastern. I am just one of millions who have morality and humanity still in my heart.
12:33 which olive trees, is it an University Debate or a poem night? Jews are native to this land and live there as a civilization since 3000 years. What this woman is talking about?!
She’s saying an olive tree can take anywhere from 3- 12 years to bear fruit and only a person alien to that land can destroy it as we have been seeing for years.
Wow, Suan. You are an amazing speaker. You clearly articulated how every Palestinian truly feels. Please keep speaking. Your voice is so important to the Palestinians
13:36 basically she says: is not your land, we are natives, go to Poland. And she supposed to be an intellectual. Please, somebody can tell her about Dawid's Kingdom? Or how Jews ended up in Poland?
She is saying the Europeans that came over to her land after the holocaust and started carrying out there own holocaust are foreign to that land even their foreign names had to be changed to fit in with the region
@@karolinarumin7462 I think you should listen to what she said again it was just facts and she said it will go back to its multi religion/ multi ethnic glory. Before 1948 the holy land was home to Jews , Christian’s and Muslims who lived together in peace for over 1200 years.
@@filmfan7895 This glory was never existed, sorry to disappoint you. Pogrom in Hebron in 1929 is one example of how far from that utopia she paints it was.
Not to be whatever but the Palestinians and their supporters are much more professional, civil and spoke based on facts. It shows they’re the real indigenous to the land. Susan and Mohammed el Kurd both shined like stars. Susan is not only one of my favourite writers and an excellent speaker but an amazing role model for everyone not only Palestinians. She’s the definition of selflessness.
Please explain why you deleted her speech when it had a million views, shortened it, and then reuploaded it?
I thought it was a smart move, removing their most popular video at the same time as they were getting flak for not showing a certain other one. It gave them a few plausible deniability options. ;)
@@Vee-Hive what other one?
Exactly
Legal reasons because she supports Hamas-a terrorist organization.
th-cam.com/video/2ZCWCGebAuU/w-d-xo.html they cut this part " that's and in the
1980s and in the 1980s and 90s Israeli
soldiers had left booby trap toys in
southern Lebanon that exploded when
excited children pick them
up"
Deleting the original upload of this video which got a million views, is criminal.
Does it make those who had indeed viewed it to ‘unview’ it?
@in-x-orable2769 ; the algorithms reset and limit it from becoming more viral to avoid more people seeing it
The lies told in this video are more criminal.
@tafferski the people that think that are few and shrinking fast.
@@Freeeedumb It doesn't matter what people think, things are either true or false.
Why did you delete her speech when it had almost 1 million view? It could reach more people than
Zio lobby most likely
@@alpha-2235Jewish Lobby and AIPAC 👿
because speaking out against a genocide is "antisemitism" now
Zionist censorship
so many lies . hamas is the one to blame for all this
How dare you delete the original video that was getting traction, and upload a shorter version. The truth lives on. Full written speech is available on PressTV.
Thanks
oh so this is the censored version?
Absolutely sickening that the original video was taken off and replaced by this trimmed version! Oxford Union are inadvertently fuelling antisemitism: the idea that Jews control media! The new president of the Union should be ashamed of himself!
Thank you
Zionists told them to do so
Why did you delete her speech and than reupload it again? It had almost 1 Million views!
That’s exactly the reason they deleted.
I was wondering the same exact thing! I was confused when I saw this video and how recently it was uploaded
@@youngflexman Yup. Google, who owns TH-cam, is on Israel's side. They don't want the video becoming too popular and thus get recommended in the algorithm to people ignorant on the subject matter.
They removed the live reactions... The claps and the interruptions when Zionists lose their minds.
They probably wish they could just remove her speech altogether. Here's to another million views. As Susan Abulhawa's speech is brilliant and nothing they do will change that.
@OxfordUnion - absolutely disgraceful to have deleted the original. For such a prestigious institution to resort to censoring free speech, you undermine the very principles of open dialogue and intellectual integrity that you claim to uphold.
Oxford is just a networking facility for Britain’s inter-generational ruling elite. It produces pompous, arrogant, selfish graduates, a lot of whom go on to maintain a deeply unequal society, which rips most people off.
That's suspicious. Why did you take Susan Abulhawa's speech down only to re-uploaded it again?
They’ve edited out the sections of the speech which detail Israel’s war crimes - the part where she describes the s**ual torture/abuse of Palestinian doctors, the booby trapping of toys to target children. These are all substantiated statements of fact but they’re censored. Because how dare Brits hear what a regime that we provide arms and political backing to does. Because the far right are allowed to speak freely to spread their hate but a Palestinian woman is not allowed the same freedom.
Censored version here.
Zionist censorship
Zionist own media
@@soulfulfreedomheart2505 they prevent the upload of mossab hassan debate until someone else posted a leak version of the voice recording.
now they re-upload some of the videos so the timestamp of the uploaded videos is aligned. shame to oxford for hiding their ugly truth
This isn't the original speech by Susan, this is a carved up version that the Israeli lobby have pressured Oxford Uni to upload instead of the original, so much for Oxford Union being the home of free speech. Please see below for the wording that Zionists wanted you not to hear.
First cut 00:03.49 to 00:05.05
and in the 1980s and 90s, Israeli soldiers had left booby-trapped toys in Southern Lebanon that exploded when excited children picked them up.
Second cut 00:08.38 to 00:03.57
"if Palestinians were systematically raping Jewish Drs and other captives with hot metal rods, jagged and electrified sticks and fire extinguishers. Sometimes raping them to death as happened with Dr Adnan Al-Bursh and others.
Third cut 00:10.52 to 00:11.01
These notions of entitlement and privilege, of being divinely favourer or blessed or chosen.
Forth cut 00:11.49 to 00:12.12
You carved out our hearths, because it's clear that you do not know how to live in the world without dominating others. You have crossed all lines and nurtured the most vile of human impulses.
Fifth cut 00:12.18 to 00:12.24
And they are seeing the reality of who you are and who you have always been.
Sixth cut 10:16
these notions of entitlement and privilege, of being divinely favoured, blessed, or chosen"
This right here!!!
Fantastic work. Well done.
My sincere respect for your protection of the truth.
Thank you! Why tf would they delete those
@Brina.-gb6ib Why are most of our comments deleted or shadow banned these days - The same reason I expect.
1. Haifa Massacre 1937
2. Jerusalem Massacre 1937
3. Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939
4. Haifa Massacre 1939
5. Haifa Massacre 1947
6. Abbasiya Massacre 1947
7. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947
8. Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947
9. Jerusalem Massacre 1947
10. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947
11. Jaffa Massacre 1948
12. Deir Yassin Massacre 1948
13. Tantura Massacre 1948
14. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956
15. Jerusalem Massacre 1967
16. Bahro Al Baquar 1972
17. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982
18. Al Aqsa Mosque Massacre 1990
19. Ibrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994
20. Jenin Refugee Camp April 2002
21. Gaza Massacre 2008-09
22. Gaza Massacre 2012
23. Gaza Massacre 2014
24. Gaza Massacre 2018-19
25. Gaza Massacre 2021
26. Gaza Massacre 2023 ongoing
SO DO NOT LET ANYONE CONVINCE YOU THAT IT STARTED ON OCTOBER 7TH
Free Palestine from Israel’s illegal inhumane treatment, apartheid, land stealing & genocide against the Palestinian people 🇵🇸
Battle of Khaybar 628CE #FKMHD
SHAME ON THE OXFORD UNION FOR DELETING THE ORIGINAL VIDEO!!!
Why did you delete the original video and re upload an edited version?
The did that with a few speeches
Zionist own media
You will never know how it feels to be loved and supported by those who have nothing to gain from you, and in fact, everything to lose.
^ this!!!
Cowards. Deleted the most popular video and uploaded an edited one.
Absolutely disgraceful to delete the previously uploaded video of Susan's speech, which had hundreds of thousands of views, and replace it with a shortened, edited version.
Remember, they wouldn't
try to silence you if your voice didn't matter. Keep speaking up for Palestinian freedom
and justice!!!!
What exactly they cut out?
she must have been really evil 😂
It probably had to many views because of all the people who commented „where is Mosab’s speech“ 😀
@@mISSsophisa they're in the comment section. Someone posted all the edited out bits and it is SO OBVIOUS who's behind it!!!!!! Every time I post the edited parts, my comment gets deleted.
@@zq_77 I was going to post them. They seem to have dissapeared
Disgraceful that you have edited Susans historic speech. The Union should be totally ashamed of censoring this courageous woman! Kindly set the original video to public again so that you can again claim to hold the principles of free speech dear.
she had a lot of lies and hate in her speech.
@@barrybarry-b5hhahaha that what you guys call the basic truth you don't like
@@barrybarry-b5h Then debunk them. If this or that particular accusation is not well attested, you should be able to demonstrate it. But that's not really the issue, is it? The issue is that her speech was overwhelmingly true and was getting very wide circulation. That is why the Oxford Union was pressured to take it down and why they did the next "best" thing of replacing it with an edited version to slow its spread by restarting the view counter and thereby reducing its likelihood of appearing in people's feeds. It its the most cynical and cowardly form of censorship and will be a stain on the reputation of the Oxford Union as the supposed "last bastion of free speech."
@@barrybarry-b5hzio
@@christophergunderson3960 It's mainly hearsay propaganda. It hasn't been confirmed that Al-bursch was raped to death but it's in the speech as truth.
Deleting the original is a shameful act of cowardice, I hope all involved have the decency to step down after this.
" You will never belong to that land, natives of the land would never harm the olive trees "
Let that sink in
it's funny that she says that Jews do not belong to that land, because Jews lived on this land and had a Jewish kingdom when Abu what's her names' ancestors were still living in the Arabian peninsula, worshipping idols and burying women alive.
@ Yea they were Arabs not Polish
@@THEG12EG They were not Arabs. Arabs migrated to the area in the 7th century, long after the Jews lived there. Jews were expelled from that land to many places, Europe included.
So why does Hamas do nothing but destroy the ‘olive trees’?
Although edited by the pressure of a state wanted for war crimes. This was truly the slam-dunk speech of the whole debate!The speech that will be remembered and go down as one of the greatest speeches of our time.
I could watch this brilliant speech only until the first huge lie came @1:21 "...conquering what remained of Palestine in 1967". Until 1967 the West bank was occupied by Jordan and Gaza was occupied by Egypt.
Taken down and uploaded again disgusting was there a problem with how many people had viewed it upset certain people
Why was the original upload deleted, and this shortened version uploaded?
Bc they intended to leave a pro Israel speaker out and then were pressured to upload his speech so they shortened and edited them all to try to pretend they are unbiased.
Why has the orginsl video which had a million views got deleted and reuploaded with much less reach? Stinks.
they've edited out parts of her speech!!! you can find the edited out bits in the comment by @ vdubber252k
They deleted the original video 😂😂😂.
Because it got too viral
And your reason for deleting original upload?
they've edited out parts of her speech!!! you can find the edited out bits in the comment by @ vdubber252k
Pressure from Zios
they censored parts of it, by editing 5 parts out, and re-uploaded it.
The real speech is still on Archive.
where?
I believe this is the original th-cam.com/video/Lp9pbNYWnh4/w-d-xo.html
@@zq_77 Susan tweeted the link to it, below which I tweeted a transcript of the bits that OU "disappeared". Ted's link is also good.
why did you delete some of the video and reupload it?
They do that on a lot of videos even with opposition speakers like Hassan Yousuf. Like when he asked the Oxford union to raise their hands if they would have contacted authorities to warn Israel about October 7th and only 5% of the audience raised their hands. They cut that out of the video.
Wow. Can’t believe they deleted her original video which had hundreds of thousands of views. That evil lobby is relentless!
Dear Oxford Union, would you like to be transparent and explain your reasoning for removing parts of Susan’s outstanding speech? And for deleting the original video of her which had close to 1M views?
Or is the truth just too scary for you too??
The Israeli Hasbara forced the Oxford Union to remove the original speech with a million views, edit it and reupload the shorter version to make it appear lower than the Mossad Mosab rant.
Sneaky Zios..
""No one native to that land, would dare do such a thing to the olives""...indeed. Without question, a significant inescapable truth is thus exposed.
"No one native to that land would dare to do such a thing to the olives"
And they taught them to tie their shoelaces and how to put one foot in front of the other. Are you not tired of the lies? Do you think this awful arrogant attitude makes you more likeable to others?
@JDshao I’m arrogant but not the lady who used olive trees to prop up the idea Arabs are the indigenous ones? You are batty
@@rbb.828 of course.. definitely right. Enjoy the bubble
@@rbb.828 Palestinians aren't Arabs. They're the descendants of the Israelites, my fellow European.
@@rbb.828
yah the Jews
Despite I appreciate organizing this debate, not okay you removed the video and uploaded it again. . Such a brilliant speech...
Can you imagine the outcry if Oxford Union dared edit and censor parts of the fantastic historic speeches made by Malcolm X and James Baldwin in Oxford Union?
Waaw this woman put it so eloquently
This is one of the worlds most historic speeches
This has to be one of the most beautiful speeches I’ve ever heard in my lifetime….
Truly Orwellian times when the censorship is this strong. Even during an active genocide. Never forget the guilty and its enablers. Oxford Union, history will not forget.
Oxford deleted her original speech because it was getting too much traction. And reuploads never get pushed by the youtube algorithm as hard as an original video. Oxford is a disgrace.
Yeah, the Oxford Uni is clearly against her position.
Ok then.
The debate chair literally spoke on behalf of her position.
Why did you delete the original video with a million views? Spineless, shameless.
Stop the genocide.❤
The original video began with Susana saying she would take no Point Of Order so keep your hands down. She was then interrupted like 3 to 4 times
Yes, I noticed, too. Only 3 to 4 times, lucky her! It was so much better than what the opposition had to face.
Well, it was far more respectful than what the children in support of the terrorists did to the other speakers.
Five times. Go see her tweet about it, and my transcript of the censored bits.
Mea culpa: In fact, 5 parts were cut from the video. I didn't count how many interruptions.
@@min181094well the opposition was denying and justifying the ongoing Nakba so I don’t blame ppl being upset when their ppl are getting killed
@suzannenobel6809 and one can argue that the preposition was denying and justifying the horrors of October 7th, where civilians and even babies suffered unspeakable things (not by accident, but they were target). Part of the problem with this is the unwillingness to see the other part as humans. Everyone sees the other as monsters, which is understandable for both parts but ultimately counterproductive.
Oxford Union: By trying to de-promote this speech by deleting the widely viewed original, you are failing to understand what Susan Abulhawa said: This is over, no more impunity, no more a free path for oppressors. Think carefully about which side of history you are on.
even oxford can't avoid from Z lobbyists. They deleted the original, shortened it, reuploaded it, hopefully will get less view than the original one...
Bruh, they censored Israel’s videos too. Chill
Please can Oxford Union reupload the original unedited video.
Susan the whole world stands with 🇵🇸🕊️ you are a legend!
Nope
@@Cellobass324 listen to the speech and suffer in silence....
So much for freedom of speech. To delete the original speech of a Palestinian speaker and upload an edited version without her consent is despicable. Worse you do this after she had to speak in the presence of actors directly involved in the ongoing genocide of her people, in the face of constant aggressive heckling. We almost never hear Palestinian voices directly. For you to act like this under pressure from those seeking the annihilation of the Palestinian people is unforgivable. It makes you complicit. Shame on you.
I remember watching this video a week back. Why is it reuploaded ? We see yoy oxford union.
This speech will go down in history. What an evisceration of Zionism.
No it won’t
@@ericharary
Oh yes it will 😊
it will go down in history as a huge lie haha, a bunch of lies. Booby trapped toys, food cans and poisoned food. Do you really believe this? Have you researched it?
@@Elizadoolittle1948 yeah it will go down in history as one of the most absolutely ignorant and intellectually dishonest speeches ever. No accountability for the Palestinians and their actions, such bad faith in argumentation by focusing solely on emotional appeals, lack of understanding about basics of how the rules of war work, etc.
The speech in this video has been censored. There are 5 censored parts. See Susan's tweet.
Why did you deleted her original speech Video😡
Shame on you for deleting the Original video! This is censorship
If you read through the comments carefully you can see exactly which parts of this amazing speech have been removed because it hurt somebody's feelings, never mind the deaths of tens (or more likely hundreds) of thousands of Palestinians that are etched into every line of this address by Susan.
Epic speech. Bless you Susan.
@3:47 they cut this part out "...and in the 1980s and 90s, Israeli soldiers had left booby-trapped toys in southern Lebanon that exploded when excited children picked them up."
All the parts that were cut:
First cut @3:49
and in the 1980s and 90s, Israeli soldiers had left booby-trapped toys in Southern Lebanon that exploded when excited children picked them up.
Second cut @8:38
"if Palestinians were systematically raping Jewish Drs and other captives with hot metal rods, jagged and electrified sticks and fire extinguishers. Sometimes raping them to death as happened with Dr Adnan Al-Bursh and others.
Third cut @10:52
These notions of entitlement and privilege, of being divinely favourer or blessed or chosen.
Forth cut @11:49
You carved out our hearths, because it's clear that you do not know how to live in the world without dominating others. You have crossed all lines and nurtured the most vile of human impulses.
Fifth cut @12:18
And they are seeing the reality of who you are and who you have always been.
@KernowDamo please take a look
I’M SHOCKED by this. freedom of speech is a LIE
Nope. That's in there.
Any other conspiracy theories?
@@nikimassey3970 where? give the timestamp. Let's watch you embarrass yourself. Or are you gonna be like the rest of the zios in the comment section, once their lies are exposed they delete their comments and disappear... we'll see about this one.
Oxford is terrible. Why didn't they upload all speakers videos from both sides unedited so it shows you are not taking sides?
The problem was that the people took sides!! The obvious side, the human side, the side against genocide side.
@adrianahuls4983 Why did they show up when they knew the genocidal monsters will be speaking?
Important parts of the speech have been censored. Shameful.
To delete the original video because it reach 1 million wow just wow. History will condemn you OXFORD
Why you deleted her brillant speech when it reached over 1 million view ? Why ? Explain why ?
they've edited out parts of her speech!!! you can find the edited out bits in the comment by @ vdubber252k
The game is up...... justice is prevailing! Humanity is winning!
One of the most beautiful and true homages to Palestine to be ever heard.
Thank you Susan we love you ❤
She is a terror supporter
is this OxfordUnion or ZionistUnion? why did you delete the older video which had millions of views and uploaded a short version her speech?
Oxford Union's reputation is totally done with the censorship they are doing on this debate.
Cambridge Union would never delete the speech shorten it and reupload it just saying
Stop the genocide ❤
They cannot take the truth and sit without interruptions....
Just too powerful 😢😢
Shame on the people who dare to interrupt her
Why would you make the previous, unedited video private, while uploading this obviously edited version? Why the change? Be transparent about why Oxford Union made this change. It’s because there was an external pressure campaign by supporters of apartheid and genocide.
Luckily we have her full speech in the internet archive which she posted on her Twitter account.
Really disgusting how you delete the original video , you clearly do not care for freedom of speech
not only that, they've edited out parts of her speech!!! you can find the edited out bits in the comment by @ vdubber252k
WHY IS THIS BEING REUPLOADED?!????
Why not?
They need to hide the truth from western populations. Because if the truth is out then people will turn against the barbarism of the Zionists.
@@michaelorellana9303 truthfully why?
Because the truth needs to be heard by all
@@Rapport24 I agree. They should not have taken this video down.
Why did you delete her original video?????!!
they reuploaded it to unmute an interruption from the opposition. they were helping her
@@barrybarry-b5h This isn't the original speech by Susan, this is a carved up version that the Israeli lobby have pressured Oxford Uni to upload instead of the original, so much for Oxford Union being the home of free speech. Please see below for the wording that Zionists wanted you not to hear.
First cut 00:03.49 to 00:05.05
and in the 1980s and 90s, Israeli soldiers had left booby-trapped toys in Southern Lebanon that exploded when excited children picked them up.
Second cut 00:08.38 to 00:03.57
"if Palestinians were systematically raping Jewish Drs and other captives with hot metal rods, jagged and electrified sticks and fire extinguishers. Sometimes raping them to death as happened with Dr Adnan Al-Bursh and others.
Third cut 00:10.52 to 00:11.01
These notions of entitlement and privilege, of being divinely favourer or blessed or chosen.
Forth cut 00:11.49 to 00:12.12
You carved out our hearths, because it's clear that you do not know how to live in the world without dominating others. You have crossed all lines and nurtured the most vile of human impulses.
Fifth cut 00:12.18 to 00:12.24
And they are seeing the reality of who you are and who you have always been.
Regarding the first statement: "But a much more sinister accusation has also circulated since the 90s - that of bombs being dropped by Israeli aircraft in southern Lebanon intentionally concealed in children's toys. Lebanese newspaper L'Orient-Le Jour reported on the phenomenon in 1997, citing a number of examples including a nine-year-old girl who had her right hand shredded after finding a "big apple-green plastic jeep, with six big black wheels" that blew up in her hand after finding it near her village. They also mentioned the example of a child who was left with severe burns after finding a booby-trapped flashlight and another girl who was killed after exclaiming "I found a doll!" before being blown up. An officer of the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (Unifil) confirmed to AFP at the time that the objects were mainly dropped by helicopter."
You missed a few that these evils want censored: add at 10:16 who harbored the same supremacist ideologies
@@barrybarry-b5hno that’s not true! They censored it and removed all the views and likes.
th-cam.com/video/Lp9pbNYWnh4/w-d-xo.htmlsi=3_CiX68JVMTZQsQb
The Israeli Hasbara forced the Oxford Union to remove the original speech with a million views, edit it and reupload the shorter version to make it appear lower than the Mossad Mosab rant.
Sneaky Zios…
“Your impunity and arrogance will come to an end”
What a powerful speech. Every single word is true. The world is with Palestine.
Why did you censor Susan's' speech Oxford Union? Shame on you.
Best history lesson taught to the colonizers that they have never had a chance to learned from their schools, college and university.
Susan spoke so beautifully and moving that it brought me to tears and I am not even Paletinian, Jewish or Middle Eastern. I am just one of millions who have morality and humanity still in my heart.
Half of Oxford Unions subscribers viewed this then they took it down and shortened it, how shameful
JUST WOW!!!
YOU ARE AMAZING!
Wow I am so moved…there is no coming back from this speech. There is no debate. There is only this.
Why has this been censored? Are you interested in truth and justice or are you stenographers for the genocide?
Stop the genocide
great speech
12:33 which olive trees, is it an University Debate or a poem night? Jews are native to this land and live there as a civilization since 3000 years. What this woman is talking about?!
She’s saying an olive tree can take anywhere from 3- 12 years to bear fruit and only a person alien to that land can destroy it as we have been seeing for years.
Does anyone know what did they delete from her speech? Why did they re-upload the speech?
Nothing deleted, just the intro remark. Zios probably made pressure on the union to remove it. It had near million views
Zios got scared
Maybe because she's spewing inaccurate claims that promote hate.
@@onurio316 love me crying hasbara bots
@@onurio316 The Zionist project is a hateful, genocidal project. Stop projecting onto those who are fighting for justice, freedom, and human rights.
I can’t believe they deleted it! Whattttt? Why? Unethical! Cowards!
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ Brave sister and Thanks
Wow, Suan. You are an amazing speaker. You clearly articulated how every Palestinian truly feels. Please keep speaking. Your voice is so important to the Palestinians
13:36 basically she says: is not your land, we are natives, go to Poland. And she supposed to be an intellectual. Please, somebody can tell her about Dawid's Kingdom? Or how Jews ended up in Poland?
She is saying the Europeans that came over to her land after the holocaust and started carrying out there own holocaust are foreign to that land even their foreign names had to be changed to fit in with the region
@filmfan7895 Europeans after who came her grandparents
@@karolinarumin7462 I think you should listen to what she said again it was just facts and she said it will go back to its multi religion/ multi ethnic glory. Before 1948 the holy land was home to Jews , Christian’s and Muslims who lived together in peace for over 1200 years.
@@filmfan7895 This glory was never existed, sorry to disappoint you. Pogrom in Hebron in 1929 is one example of how far from that utopia she paints it was.
Where can I go to hear the uncensored version of this? Thank you.
Perhaps Middle East Eye or DamoRants (Damo reads the original text)
th-cam.com/video/Lp9pbNYWnh4/w-d-xo.htmlsi=3_CiX68JVMTZQsQb
@@sara_phoebe Thanks!
This is what power looks like
Why they removed the video with many views??
The original unedited version was better.
This speech is an edited version of the original. The original one was uploaded before and had almost 1 million views.
Restore the original speech. This is disgusting betrayal.
This lady brought something new and unique to the debating stage. I'll listen again and again
The lady deserves a literature award for her weird imagination.
She's a writer, writes some fantasies not related to reality
@@marymay3343 says you. do wanna tell us which parts of her speech are "imagined"?
I have done, and again.
Why they removed her video with 1 million of views??
Why did you delete her video
Shame on Oxford.
SHAME ON YOU OXFORD
If other TH-camr would record and upload the unedited origin, it would be better.
Not to be whatever but the Palestinians and their supporters are much more professional, civil and spoke based on facts. It shows they’re the real indigenous to the land. Susan and Mohammed el Kurd both shined like stars. Susan is not only one of my favourite writers and an excellent speaker but an amazing role model for everyone not only Palestinians. She’s the definition of selflessness.
Lovely speech ❤
Release the original video with almost 1 million views!!!