@@robertociai6205 I think they both have their strong points, although Gary used to sing Blood on the Rooftops, which is one of my favourite songs and has been missing from Steve’s set list since his departure.
@@andrewlong6438 Of course Nad practiced, his voice just can’t reach that high anymore and that’s perfectly fine. I like hearing Nad sing now whether or not it’s in the right key
@@arthuranderson844 ...Steve alone...brilliant composer/musician.. hasnt got the overall ....sound scape....that Genesis warrants....in him....he jus mechanically plonks the material away....that clarinet doesnt bring anything to the table...worse...the vocalist...could well be an android...so....out....
Squonk is the first song Phil Collins recorded as the official new lead singer right after Peter Gabriel left at the end of the Lamb Lies Down Tour. The album this comes from, A Trick of the Tail is an absolute work of art. Vocally challenging work indeed.
Wow first genesis song I heard been a fan ever since 44yrs ago omg
Cannot wait to see Steve Hackett May 15th here in USA.
Thanks for posting this,first night for me at the globe fantastic gig I thought the sound was well engineered
You can actually get most of these concerts on TH-cam you can get it for your TV streaming service or many other ways
Wind and watering the last genesis record with Steve Hackett They was only 4 ……..and after 3 …….
tal vez una de las canciones mas difíciles de cantar y de interpretar de la histora de la banda.
Most of their music is complex with lyrics open to interpretation & one's imagination. That's what I luv about Genesis!
Love Steve Hackett. Hits my ears funny that they transposed the song down. I assume it's out of deference to the singer.
Quien toca la batería??
“Who plays the drums?”
Craig Blundell
craigblundell.com/
@@benny_2_2 Gary O'Toole had more style. Come back, Gary isnt time for the retirement
@@robertociai6205 I think they both have their strong points, although Gary used to sing Blood on the Rooftops, which is one of my favourite songs and has been missing from Steve’s set list since his departure.
Wrong key. I know it's all the way down to see instead of deep but that doesn't sit well with me
Been a while since Nad's song it, vocals evolve
@@arthuranderson844 This is why you practice it before you go on tour.
@@andrewlong6438 Of course Nad practiced, his voice just can’t reach that high anymore and that’s perfectly fine. I like hearing Nad sing now whether or not it’s in the right key
...that clarinet ...jus dulls it.....
Think of it as a synthesizer, they sound similar.
@@arthuranderson844 ...Steve alone...brilliant composer/musician.. hasnt got the overall ....sound scape....that Genesis warrants....in him....he jus mechanically plonks the material away....that clarinet doesnt bring anything to the table...worse...the vocalist...could well be an android...so....out....
I don't like the whole step change.
A song that is a hard work for all the singers that made covers of the Gabriel age.
Post Gabriel
Squonk is the first song Phil Collins recorded as the official new lead singer right after Peter Gabriel left at the end of the Lamb Lies Down Tour. The album this comes from, A Trick of the Tail is an absolute work of art. Vocally challenging work indeed.
Nad does a good job with most of the Phil and Peter vocals, this is a little more difficult than it seems
@@porkbelly0713 Respect for Nad, but .....
@@robertociai6205 Sure he's awfull in that
Lacklustre drumming flatens the track.
While I think the snare lacks crack, the performance is a good cover of Phil's take on Bonham (Phil's words, not mine).
Weak.
Better than Genesis...
It is Genesis, from way back when.
NO, not really. But very nice to hear this music still being played live.