Let's Compare ( Popeye ) REMAKE
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ก.พ. 2013
- Video Locations:
Arcade 0:18
Odyssey 2 2:26
Apple 2 4:16
Atari 2600 5:45
Intellivision 7:19
Atari 5200 / 800 / XE/XL 8:53
Commodore 64 10:27
Colecovision 12:01
TI99 13:36
Amiga 15:10
NES 16:54
Java Mobile 18:28 ( Has Sound Issues ) Emulation is not 100%
Game and Watch 20:02
ZX Spectrum ( PROTOTYPE .. NO SOUND ) 21:02
Creds 22:46
Description Source:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Popeye_%...
Popeye (ポパイ, Popai?) is a 1982 arcade game developed and released by Nintendo based on the Popeye cartoon characters licensed from King Features Syndicate. Some sources[2][3][4] claim that Ikegami Tsushinki also did design work on Popeye.
The Family Computer (Famicom) saw an educational sequel on November 22, 1983: Popeye no Eigo Asobi, an English teaching game akin to the later Donkey Kong Jr. Math.
In Popeye, two players can alternate playing or one player can play alone. The top five highest scores are kept along with the player's three initials. Popeye was available in standard and cocktail configurations.
Steve Harris, founder of the magazine Electronic Gaming Monthly, holds the world record score of 1,232,250 earned on August 8, 1983 according to Twin Galaxies International Scoreboard.
The Popeye characters were originally going to be used in the game that later became Donkey Kong.
Game Play
The object of the game was for Popeye to collect a certain number of items (24 hearts, 16 musical notes, or the letters in the word "help" - depending on the level) while avoiding the Sea Hag, Brutus / originally Bluto (Brutus was the name given to the character in the King Features cartoon series, Popeye the Sailor) and other dangers. The player can make Popeye walk back and forth and up and down stairs and ladders with an 8-way joystick. There is a punch button, but unlike similar games of the period, no jump button. (Conversely, Brutus can jump down a level and also jump up to hit Popeye if he is directly above.) Each level has a can of spinach. If Popeye punches the can, he becomes temporarily invincible and can knock out Brutus just by running into him; although after a few seconds Brutus will swim back out and be ready for action again.
In Round 1 (the dock scene) of each three-round cycle is a punching bag, which Popeye can use to knock loose a nearby barrel from its position near the top of the playing field. If the barrel falls onto Brutus' head, the player earns bonus points (based on where Brutus was attacked) and renders Brutus harmless for several seconds.
Otherwise Popeye's attacks did nothing to his nemesis; although the attack button did destroy items that could hurt Popeye such as bottles, vultures and skulls.
Other licensed Popeye characters in the game are Olive Oyl, Swee' Pea, and Wimpy, though they are mostly decorative and do not add heavily to the gameplay. Wimpy appears in Round 2 (the street scene) on one end of the see-saw in the lower left corner of the field, to act as a counterweight. Swee' Pea floats high above, with bonus points to be earned if Popeye can spring off the see-saw and touch him. - เกม
Fun fact: This is the only licensed game developed my Shigeru Miyamoto. Fun fact 2: Miyamoto wanted to develop a Popeye game as his first project for Nintendo, but they had difficulty getting the rights from King Features Syndicate. The result is Miyamoto created Donkey Kong.
Krendall2 Well looks like Mario or Jumpman Pauline or Donkey Kong were inspired by Popeye Olive and Bluto and And Nintendo's landlord or something.
It's a good thing that the original Popeye video game ended up becoming "Donkey Kong" instead; Otherwise, we probably wouldn't have one of the greatest video game heroes of all time if that happened.
Fact 2 is common knowledge
Super Popeye Bros just doesn’t have the same ring
@@keatonthekoopatroopa246 Yes, Nintendo of America's landlord was named Mario. The character's look and original occupation of a carpenter was apparently inspired by a neighbor of Miyamoto's at the time.
The Odyssey 2 port has The Hulk in it, awesome.
CTFU
Odyssey 2, the best game ever, tall green man chasing smoul pink man running through a elevator and ladders. a pink girl throughing shoes at you.
Considering the limitations of the system the Atari 2600 port is pretty impressive let us never speak of the odyssey 2 port again.
The O2 port is one of the most abstract ports of any game I've seen. Like, the gameplay looks fine but the graphics don't make much sense if you've never played the game on another system
TheBambam2371 odyssey port was trash
#odyssey #iscrap #never #talk #aboutit #please
Nick Ortega I know that read it again
I agree the odyssey 2 port sucks.
Damn, 2600 version is a pretty impresive port. You can actually tell its Popeye. Its cool when the limitations are used in a creative way.
How are the limitations used in a creative way
@@Ballowax Because you can tell its Popeye with only like 8 pixels.
Agreed, you could really feel the arcade version there.
Oh, my God. That Odyssey 2 port.
Harvey Rothman they def shoulda taken more time to develop that
It was pretty fitting the programmers put a bunch of ???????? at the bottom of the screen. Reflects the game real well.
@@jeffjackson9679 you had to input names and I guess wingnut didn’t put a name. When you don’t input a name, your name is ??????.
Okay when you're version is beaten by the Atari 2600 version you know you've failed. What happened Apple?
*YOUR VERSION
lol, somebody rushed the game to make money...
the video game crash
The moment you realize that Bluto's face is a 5 in the Atari 5200 version.
Can't unsee it now.
Creepy
That was the first things I noticed. It goes from 2 and 5 as he goes left and right.
Huh. I thought it was a 2?
I always saw it and it’s annoying! The 2nd 5200 homebew enhancement version really knocked it out of the park though.
In the Atari 2600 version, the hearts look like actual human hearts
The Odyssey 2's the best port. The devs even beat the arcade with STUPENDOUS effort on production alone.
Job well done. Job well done. *Golfclap*
Love how Brutus' face could be done seamlessly with just the use of the number 5 in some ports. Genius.
+jllovit Really? The Odyssey 2 port is the worst!
All Access Gaming
We need to expose you more on the concept of sarcasm, my friend.
***** I knew it was a joke! No need!
Bluto's head in the Apple II port would've given me nightmares had I played it when I was a kid
Are you drunk or something? Look again 3:33
maybe the best graphics ever seen at that time!! 1982 arcade version looks incredible for that year!
The walking sound of Popeye in the 2600 version, sounds like the sound turtles make when kicked in Super Mario Brothers from NES.
Holy shit, it does! I never noticed that and I used to play this game a lot as a kid!
Good job, captain obvious
@@SONICBOOM1889 how does that make him captain obvious?
You mean koopas
To me, Olive in the Amiga version looks like a malnourished person with no will to live.
So true! What's up with that? Almost looks deliberate.
Lol
Apple 2 devs: Wait how are we going to program Olive into the game? We filled up the whole game with 6 colors! What are we going to do?
Another Apple 2 dev: Just forget her. It's not like she was that big of a part of the game...
I used to have the NES version. But thanks for putting up the Odyssey 2 version. I will now have nightmares! Apparently, a small albino is being hunted by the pink Predator from above throwing shit at him, while a giant green alien from below is trying to kill him. HIs only hope is to eat one of the aliens detached balls. And when he does, the alien flies around the screen and gives out a horrible shrieking sound. I mean how would you like it if someone ate one of your balls? Yep. Nightmares.
Olive Oyl almost looks depressed in the Amiga version.
Yeah, had no idea they had an Amiga version too. She definitely looks to have a hunchback.
The Amiga version was an unofficial fanmade port. Just pointing that out
Yea she's sluggish lol and is that Brutus or a pirate
Petman1325 actually she does
She looks like Eugene the Jeep.
The Odyssey 2 port made NES looks 64 bit.
Anything that makes the Atari 2600 look halfway good is a really horrible port
I don't know if this glitch happens in any of the other versions, but in the C64 version, when you hit Bluto (Brutus) while in spinach mode, and he goes flying across the screen, if you hit the punching bag which releases the bucket, and time it perfectly so that it lands on his head, it'll freeze him in place but in that animation. Bluto is no longer a threat for the remainder of that level (or life, Popeye can still fail by not catching all the hearts in time, or get hit by a bottle)
15:44 it's amazing the screen shaking as the arcade, Amiga always had that "extra" that made you love her more and more. ❤❤❤
NES had the best port!
God that Odyssey II version makes me appreciate Atari 2600 Pac-Man, and the Apple Ii version isn't much better
Missing background music aside, this is once again an excellent arcade conversion from Parker Brothers for the TI-99/4A and holds it's own handily among the other same-generation machines. Milton Bradley may be much more closely associated with the 4A, but with Popeye, Frogger, QBert (easily the best home-computer conversion at the time) and the recently released Tutankham, it was Parker Brothers who created the most compelling arcade-based titles for the TI-99.
Considering the hardware though, the Odyssey2 port must have been a real labour of love. and the programmer actually pulled it off (even including the spinach theme!)! Yhay ois no small feat on such limited hardware. Huge Kudos!
Also, I loved the hell out of the mobile phone port that Namco did when I had my LG cellphone on Verizon years ago. Sure, the extra features cost me from data usage, but it was really nice being able to earn tokens just to be able to read some of the original color and B&W comics. That, and the extra and bonus stages really helped further enhance the Arrange Mode.
In the Atari 5200 version, which is the one I played as a kid, I always thought it was funny how Bluto's head was the number 5.
By the standard of doing what you could with the hardware you had, the 2600 version really is one of the best ports. Many of the other ports on much more capable systems had no excuse to be so different from the arcade.
The best port of Popeye is probably an unofficial conversion called Sailor Man for the TRS80 color computer. It’s really worth including because it outshines all these other versions and really showcases what the Coco is capable of.
Very right! That's a very good port.
NES Version will always be king for me as it was one of the first NES games I had back in the day. I love the music in it and still play it to this day
Besides the arcade version in my opinion the best one is that of NES followed by the Colecovision.
I spent so much money in playing Popeye in game centers during my holidays in the 1980s...When Colecovision was launched in my country (Italy) I immediately purchased the console. Guess which was the first cartdrige...Popeye of course!
Great video! Surprisingly, the C64 version looks the closest to the arcade at a glance. Odyssey 2 version would have been a huge disappointment back in the day. I actually had both of those systems in the 1980s and never realized they had Popeye.
The arcade version is amazing
I loved the popeye game on the spectrum by the same people who did the Trap Door game.. class!
The C64 port is pretty impressive, but Brutus doesn't have his tells that indicate what he'll do next, making the game very hard to play.
Arcade and Nintendo version are my favs
Throwing the Game & Watch in there was a nice touch!
:D thanks ! I try to get as much as possible.
Lmfao.Popeye looked like Quagmire in the Atari 5200 version :P
+Mike Sweeney O_O ... Maybe He's Quagmires dad !! :O
+Gaming History Source Quagmire's dad is a transgender
maybe it's one of Popeye's 3 Nephews Sons then..........lol
Giggity.
Mike Sweeney
Amazed at how nice the TI99 version is graphically.
The Arcade Popeye Probably Has The Best Sounds & Graphics Of Any Arcade Game Ever Made! WOW! :D That Is Simply The Best Looking Arcade Game I Have Ever Seen!
For its limitations I thought the 2600 had a pretty good port.
+Rex Overbey There's only so much you can do on a system with 128 bytes of RAM.
The 2600 version is almost always an excercise in "what can the system actually do that looks/plays a bit like the arcade".
I'm guessing this version is pretty uncommon. I've never seen it in my life. Looks great!
I had it
And in this version Brutus will still try to come after you after you ate the spinach
To celebrate My birthday today. I'm going to go ahead & release some of the remakes that I have been working on. I hope You guys enjoy the new updated videos. But I'm still FAR from finished with the others. SO hang on tight ! ;) I will be uploading a new video this weekend as well. Let's Compare ( Jungle Hunt ). :D Stay tuned !
Best version: Nes, absolutely, then C64. The Java edition is horrible, absolutely.
Wow, the Colecovision gives the NES a run for it's money.
1. Arcade
2. NES
3. Colecovision
I would say the Commodore 64 was a better port with NES right after.
I used to have the Colecovision version growing up!
Pretty good VIC-20 homebrew of it was also released. Loved this game in the local takeaway on school holidays
Thank You very much. I really appreciate comments like these. :)I hope You continue to enjoy these videos for years to come.
Olive Oyl looks ridiculous on the C-64! LOL
What's wrong with Olive in the Amiga version? She looks anorexic and about to keel over!!
And she looks so depressive
She looks like Euginia Cooney
LOL
atari 5200
brutus has a 5 in his head XD
that was funny, it was either a 5 or 2 depending on which way he was facing
And a three
A three in the Apple II version
...Or the letter "S" as his head...
It's Bluto, not Brutus
I clicked on this because I thought it was a comparison of Popeye cartoons over the years...lol. My brother has a Popeye cocktail table arcade game. Popeye is one of my favorite games.
The Colecovision and NES versions were probably the best.The Amiga and Spectrum versions were interesting as i never saw these before.As for the Odyssey 2 version ,to quote an infamous AVGN phrase "what were they thinking?!"
Thanks for uploading.
I share Your sentiment but I believe it could have been even better. In fact I believe the NES could have handled at least a 98% accurate port. Larger sprites & an opening sequence would have sent this version over the top. Have You seen the Opcode remakes of Donkey Kong & Pac-man for the colecovision ? Absolutely astounding ! I'm sure the NES could have handled much much more. Thanks for commenting.
omg the arcade version is incredibly good for its time
You just bought back my childhood memories 😃 with that game.
NES, Commodore 64 and then Colecovision.
Loved the arcade Popeye, liked it more than Donkey Kong and Mario Bros. even. Coleco and NES had the best ports though I hate what they did to the Popeye sprite in the NES version.
No system did the arcade true justice. However, the NES and the Colecovision versions would probably be the ones I'd pick. Oh, and the Odyssey 2 is unbearably horrible - how was this even released??
NES is closest to the arcade version.
Oh my god, thank you! I love your series... =)
LOVED this in the arcade... back in the day we were blown away by the graphics. Used to play the ColecoVision version a lot too.
One of the few arcade games of the time to use a double resolution monitor. The only other game I can think of that used one was Paperboy.
Wingnut4427/GHS Just wanted to let you know that your videos are AWESOME. Brought back MANY memories of my 80's childhood playing these games in the Arcade or on the systems I had - Colecovision, Commodore Vic-20, Commodore 64, Atari 7800, and the NES. Thanks again for the TLC, time and effort you put into these videos. As for Gamer Daily - he's just a total RUDE a-hole!
Thanks man ! I appreciate that. I'm not too worried about Gamer Daily. I make enough off of these videos to put food on the table for a couple of weeks so it doesn't concern me what he thinks. I'm glad You enjoy these videos & I hope You'll continue to enjoy them for years to come. I am going to have to take a few weeks off from producing however. Need to find a job & don't have much time to dedicate to it. But ! I'll be back at it as soon as I get back on My feet. :)
wingnut4427 Thanks for the quick reply. If anyone deserves a few weeks off it's you. I'm currently doing assignments for Kelly Temp so I too am looking (hoping) that one of them will lead to a full time job. If you are ever in the NYC area, there is a place called Brooklyn Barcade that has all the classics of the 80's (Donkey Kong, Dig-Dug etc) and GREAT microbrews all on tap.
PS.. just was wondering what consoles you played on (besides the Atari 2600) back in the day?
Scooter Ahlers I owned quite a few. 2600, 7800, Amiga ( Didn't use it too much ) Odyssey 2, pong, Colecovision, Coleco table top Pacman, Intellivision, Commodore 64, NES, SNES, Jaguar, Sega Master System, Genesis, Sega CD, 32 X , Saturn, Dreamcast, Nintendo 64, game cube, & several others. I ended up selling My collection because I'm a bit claustrophobic & couldn't deal with the clutter. I used the money to buy a car. I didn't sell everything though. Still have My Wii, Saturn, Dreamcast, GBA, & my Coleco Table top games. Pac-man, Donkey Kong, & Galaxian. Still would like to have Frogger though. :)
I do love gaming but prefer using emulators because it doesn't create a mess in My home & it makes recording less of a hassle. If you were to step into My home today You would see that it doesn't contain a lot of clutter.
wingnut4427 Cool collection you had/still have. I currently have the Wii, PS 2, PS 3, Gamecube, NES, and Atari 2600. The NES and 2600 still work perfectly. Also are there any games that you are really great at? I do have a couple of scores listed with Twin Galaxies - 2.4 Million on Dig-Dug, 140,500 on D2K - Jumpman Returns, 353,550 on Crazy Climber. My Brother Eric is the World Record Holder on Toobin, Paperboy (Easy Street), and Robotron 2084.
Wingnut4427 - I used to have the Coleco Pac-Man mini cabinet. Recently saw that someone managed to put a mini monitor into a Coleco mini Donkey Kong cabinet -thus an actual (MAME) working arcade Donkey Kong in the palm of your hands. Hopefully he has Donkey Kong Jr. and D2K in that too:)
I had the coleco vision version played the hell out of it best version at the time it came out besides arcade
Is Olive a zombie in the Amiga one?
I was highly impressed with the Texas Instruments version and surprised how well the 2600 version came out. Very few versions had the full movement of Brutus, like him being able to jump down a level. That always scared the hell out of me as a kid!
You missed!! the Game and Watch PANORAMA versión. It's the most beautiful of them all and the most fun among all the versions.
indeed. There were some versions that I had that would only operate in Pal mode. I'm considering updating those vids as well. but it will be in due time. :) thanks for the comment.
Colecovision version= Olive is a duck XD
We did get a “remake” for popeye on the switch but I’d hardly call it one as it was little more than an asset flip hastily thrown together by another company that just happened to get the popeye license (It’s been delisted now)
Wow. No shock they went with Don Priestly's Speccy version of Popeye after seeing that prototype.
Only version I ever played was Arcade and even today the game seems hard as heck but guess I don't practice often enough.
Strange fact: The villain in the arcade game is identified as Brutus, the version of Bluto who exists because of poor legal research.
(Why is Bluto sometimes Brutus? Well, King Features, the comics syndicate with the rights to Popeye, believed *incorrectly* that they didn't own Bluto. He was a villain from E. C. Segar's comic strip, but a rather minor and obscure one, elevated to major status only by Fleischer Studios' cartoon shorts, which made him Popeye's recurring archnemesis in endless damsel-in-distress plots. King Features, who I guess had a lazy legal department, mistakenly thought the Fleischers had invented Bluto entirely, and came up with "Brutus" as a substitute character, who appeared under that name in the cartoons made for TV in the Sixties and after. And in this game.)
One of the best games that I played in arcades and Greek-owned UK restaurants, back around 1983! (Star Wars and Mr Do also) That Odyssey version is set in a dystopian Popeye future world?
Let's Compare ( Popeye )
Arcade 0:18
Odyssey 2 2:26
Apple 2 4:16
Atari 2600 5:45
Intellivision 7:19
Atari 800 8:53
Commodore 64 10:27
Colecovision 12:01
Texas Instruments TI-99/4A 13:36
Amiga 15:10
Nintendo Entertainment System 16:54
Java Mobile 18:28
Game and Watch 20:02
ZX Spectrum 21:02
if it was up to me when playing Popeye, I would save the Spinach until the last item pickup so that it would work more like in the cartoons (acting as a deus ex machina for Popeye in the last stretch)
There is also another Game & Watch Popeye in two formats: Panorama Screen and Tabletop.
Wow i cant believe the differences in these Versions ! cool Video, one of the all time classic arcades in my opinion although i could never get far in it as a kid usually lost at 2nd stage a lot,
Thanks man. :) I'll get Your video for TH-cam spotlight up soon. Been busy with the holiday. :)
enjoyed the video and happy birthday.
I had this on the Coleco as a kid. Looking at all of them the Coleco version really does look good.
That odyssey port cant be officially licensed. There's no way a port of a game based on a popular cartoon like Popeye would reduce the characters to unrecognizable stick figures like that, and I dont think they were even still making Odyssey games by 1982
Atari 5200 almost sounded like the original
Better than the atari 2600
The arcade version seems to use some sound fx from mario bros
The Odyssey 2 Port is like when you ask your mom for a pair of Nikes but you got Keds instead
This is an arcade classic!
correct. I actually had to add sound effects to help make the footage a little more bearable. lol You would be amazed at how much editing some of these require.
The Amiga port is from Bignonia, a couple of sceners dedicated to port some C64 classics to the Amiga.
Algo converted Donkey Kong and Frantic Freddie, which are both great.
There are some remakes on Popeye cartoons. They are: Let's Get Movin' in 1936 and A Hole In One in 1957, Customers Wanted in 1939 and Penny Antics in 1955, Two Alarm Fire in 1934 and Fireman's Brawl in 1953, Protek The Weakingisk in 1937 and Barking Dogs Don't Bite in 1949, Flies Ain't Human in 1941 and Fly's Last Flight in 1948, Me Musical Nephews in 1942 and Riot in Rhythm in 1950, and Dizzy Divers in 1934 and Peep In The Deep in 1946.
I played the Colecovision one back in the day. It had a funny glitch on the second level. Just chase Bluto to the see saw after getting the spinach and he'll spin across the screen indefinitely until the end of the level.
Pretty clear that the Apple II port was a homebrew. But why the hell didn't it have an official Popeye release? Or Donkey Jr., for that matter, when the Donkey Kong and Mario Bros. ports were done so well?!?! 🤔
To be fair, the Odyssey 2 version was an unfinished Parker Brothers prototype and never released.
I used to love watching the cartoon
Happy birthday man. I'm just curious if for some of the C64 ports if you tried seeing how they ran when setting the emulator to NTSC mode? Having a copy of Ms. Pac-Man on cartridge, and Dig-Dug, Jumpman Junior, and Pac-Man on floppy disk I can say they run considerably faster on my NTSC Commodore 128 and 64.
I use to play the ColecoVision version a lot as a kid.
Happy birthday, Wingnut! :D
I know, not that many. The arcade version also had some pretty good sprite work as well with the way they did those designs. I sorta liked it when you leave a heart sinking in the water and Olive Oyl comes down and scolds you for it.
Blutos head on 5200 lol it really is just the number five!
If I had to guess what the Odyssey 2 version was without knowing, I would think it was about Egyptian mythology, it looks like the Nile and some pyramids at the bottom, some sort of goddess at the top, and the green thing looks like a monstrous giant.
Colecovision was the I grew up with. I loved this game.
Amiga version = Olive is a zombie XDDDD
Arcade & Nes for sure , 2600 have arcade bit sound
Jesus Christ! Going from the arcade original straight to the terrible Oddyssey2 version is insanely jarring. I mean, I know you always start with the arcade version and then you do the consoles based on the year they were released, but geez! What a huge difference!
It looks like the NES version was the best port of this game.
Thumb up if you're a a moldy oldy like me who actually played this on a home system.
Likebeggar