another thing I would add to Jeongyeon is that her breath support isn't that good right now, also finally someone that agrees with Tzuyu being slightly better than Chae, and with Dahyun being above Sana and Momo.
Non of them besides jihyo if nayeon wasn't so nasally she would higher than her. Jeongyeon literally only one out of the top 6 that didn't improve she's been the same place for years. Nayeon was closer to A then her at one point.
@rina_core Tzuyu is probably the only one who keeps taking vocal lessons from time to time because aside from her none of the others have improved that much. Also, I watched some of your videos and I want to thank you for being objective, most people out there are purely biased.
And i just want adding to Mina case She is need to open her mouth a little bit more wide when she's singing. Maybe her confidence that like you said ruining her singing ability. But overall i like Mina vocals color and tone the most than other member.
Yess, but people always blaming Mina said stealing Jy place as a lead vocalist lol, despite her old positions, but i dont trust that positions now. I think they had a new unofficial positions but since them is a 3rd gen and has solo activity so Jyp not gonna make confirmed or anything else
are we sure about nayeon and jeongyeon? i think also jeongyeon regressed a little if you listen to her live in the last years, maybe because of the anxiety. i would have put nayeon second, objectively speaking
@@Rina_verse I respectfully disagree. It is clear that Nayeon has much improved Jeongyeon regressed a little bit but is still above Nayeon, just because the concept fits Nayeon more doesn't mean she's a better vocalist
actually for me，mina has very great potential and innate skill compared to other members. She quite smart and has some developed vocal techniques. she really knows what is her limitations and strengths. During some of their vlive or youtubelive, she shows a lot consistent vibrato and falsetto and even not running out of breathe. The only thing is she really anxious and unconfident especially we can see on the encore stage, she will turn to the back and didn't look at the camera when she sings. It make her lock her projection and larynx. Tzuyu is not a smart or innated talented singer but i respect her hardworking. I can see she put a lot of effort compared to others and jyp didn't give her some much working schedules Which means she have more time to improve and she also willing to take lessons. I will say sana and nayeon are regressrd a lot especially sana. I think both of their vocal cords are getting damaged because always sing the notes that out of their range without correct techniques. Both of them become more and more nasality and i dont think they can be healed anymore. Chaeyoung and Dahyun seems like didn't really care about their improvement in their vocal. Both of them are facing the repeated problems over the time. For Momo,the first thing she need to do is abandon her "special" singing style which has lead a obstacle to her improvement. Jeongyeon has regressed. I think the major problem is her health issues. She become more out of breath nowadays and miss out some notes. Jihyo is good but need more training. She can support some low notes and high notes but inconsistent. She likes to use more airy styles when she sings low notes but it sounds too much sometimes. She is not really know where need to put the airy and where should not as well as not good enough to fully control the airy. Jihyo also have inaccurate pitches problem even not really make her sounds bad but is imperfect. Her quality of high notes also quite not consistent. She need to have more professional training and someone direct her.
Yess, but people always blaming Mina said stealing Jy place as a lead vocalist lol, despite her old positions, but i dont trust that positions now. I think they had a new unofficial positions but since them is a 3rd gen and has solo activity so Jyp not gonna make confirmed or anything else.
si bien todas tienen fallos, algunas siguen igual desde hace años, igual siguen siendo Twice, aunque no se si sea valido decirlo, aun podrian mejorar, hasta 2027 pueden pasar muchas cosas, y ojala todo lo que les depare el futuro a la voz de las chicas sea bueno, despues de todo, nadie sabe como pueden cambiar las cosas de aqui a mañana
Despite her old positions, but i dont trust that positions now lol. I think they had a new unofficial positions but since them is a 3rd gen and has solo activity so Jyp not gonna make confirmed or anything else
Mina is my utt I agree so much with the part it says she sounds limited... She has amazing potential and has great vocal moments, but her lack of confidence makes her seem like she can't get better than that. I would love if she tried to release her solo album like tzuyu one day! It would be a great begining 😅
Chae It's better than Tzuyu, Tzuyu in Run Away seems very tense and she forces her notes, and Chaeyeong for me in the live has a better control of her voice !
@@kanmanivn1475I know your comment is 3 weeks old, but watch Twice's cover of IU's song (I can't remember the name right now) Chaeyoung sounded better in her tone than Tzuyu
@ know ur comments is from today but watch twice all mr removed live versions. Tzuyu sounds better than chae because most of the time chaeyoung does not sing live .. lol
If Mina trained the avarege of 2 years like the other members she would be so good. I hope she trained by herself if she want to continue singing (and not move to acting) her tone is really good.
Sana is still better than Dahyun. While she had a very questionable period around Talk That Talk, she has certainly improved again as shown in her concert materials. Dahyun is getting thinner and thinner day by day
@@Rina_verse nuh uh, just cuz she has an airy voice doesnt mean shes more grounded, thats a stereotype that people have made that cutesy voiced idols are relaxed or grounded just cuz they sound like that, sana in general has more depth and a better reach at notes than dahyun, even a healthier belter
another thing I would add to Jeongyeon is that her breath support isn't that good right now, also finally someone that agrees with Tzuyu being slightly better than Chae, and with Dahyun being above Sana and Momo.
Non of them besides jihyo if nayeon wasn't so nasally she would higher than her. Jeongyeon literally only one out of the top 6 that didn't improve she's been the same place for years. Nayeon was closer to A then her at one point.
@rina_core Tzuyu is probably the only one who keeps taking vocal lessons from time to time because aside from her none of the others have improved that much. Also, I watched some of your videos and I want to thank you for being objective, most people out there are purely biased.
@@Aelinash true tzuyu on a good day sound better then everyone in group
@@Rina_verse true, she surprised me the most when I went to their concerts
@@Aelinash she surprised with one spark her pretty chorus was really good and done well
i am so happy with tzuyu evolution
It may have improved but she still sounds bad
@@satoshimay2438 stay mad lol
@@satoshimay2438 keep crying
And i just want adding to Mina case
She is need to open her mouth a little bit more wide when she's singing. Maybe her confidence that like you said ruining her singing ability. But overall i like Mina vocals color and tone the most than other member.
Despite not being the best vocalist, Mina is my favorite voice in Twice. I could see her release a solo like IU's Palette for example
Yess, but people always blaming Mina said stealing Jy place as a lead vocalist lol, despite her old positions, but i dont trust that positions now. I think they had a new unofficial positions but since them is a 3rd gen and has solo activity so Jyp not gonna make confirmed or anything else
are we sure about nayeon and jeongyeon? i think also jeongyeon regressed a little if you listen to her live in the last years, maybe because of the anxiety. i would have put nayeon second, objectively speaking
Nayeon regressed jeongyeon has always been the same. Nayeon excessive nasality causes a drop in quality. I would read the analysis to understand
@@Rina_verse I respectfully disagree. It is clear that Nayeon has much improved Jeongyeon regressed a little bit but is still above Nayeon, just because the concept fits Nayeon more doesn't mean she's a better vocalist
actually for me，mina has very great potential and innate skill compared to other members. She quite smart and has some developed vocal techniques. she really knows what is her limitations and strengths. During some of their vlive or youtubelive, she shows a lot consistent vibrato and falsetto and even not running out of breathe. The only thing is she really anxious and unconfident especially we can see on the encore stage, she will turn to the back and didn't look at the camera when she sings. It make her lock her projection and larynx. Tzuyu is not a smart or innated talented singer but i respect her hardworking. I can see she put a lot of effort compared to others and jyp didn't give her some much working schedules Which means she have more time to improve and she also willing to take lessons. I will say sana and nayeon are regressrd a lot especially sana. I think both of their vocal cords are getting damaged because always sing the notes that out of their range without correct techniques. Both of them become more and more nasality and i dont think they can be healed anymore. Chaeyoung and Dahyun seems like didn't really care about their improvement in their vocal. Both of them are facing the repeated problems over the time. For Momo,the first thing she need to do is abandon her "special" singing style which has lead a obstacle to her improvement. Jeongyeon has regressed. I think the major problem is her health issues. She become more out of breath nowadays and miss out some notes. Jihyo is good but need more training. She can support some low notes and high notes but inconsistent. She likes to use more airy styles when she sings low notes but it sounds too much sometimes. She is not really know where need to put the airy and where should not as well as not good enough to fully control the airy. Jihyo also have inaccurate pitches problem even not really make her sounds bad but is imperfect. Her quality of high notes also quite not consistent. She need to have more professional training and someone direct her.
Yess, but people always blaming Mina said stealing Jy place as a lead vocalist lol, despite her old positions, but i dont trust that positions now. I think they had a new unofficial positions but since them is a 3rd gen and has solo activity so Jyp not gonna make confirmed or anything else.
mina Bb3/B3-G4/G#4
Nayeon solid G#3
@@BP-tm6ye you do know low weak are inconsistent. Mina quality is pair with low weak. Jennie yujin and mina are three low weak.
si bien todas tienen fallos, algunas siguen igual desde hace años, igual siguen siendo Twice, aunque no se si sea valido decirlo, aun podrian mejorar, hasta 2027 pueden pasar muchas cosas, y ojala todo lo que les depare el futuro a la voz de las chicas sea bueno, despues de todo, nadie sabe como pueden cambiar las cosas de aqui a mañana
Nayeon’s low notes & Jihyo mother 🥰
hear misamo jealousy. i love sana vocals
Mina has a great tone though. Such a mellow and gentle voice
Despite her old positions, but i dont trust that positions now lol. I think they had a new unofficial positions but since them is a 3rd gen and has solo activity so Jyp not gonna make confirmed or anything else
Mina is my utt
I agree so much with the part it says she sounds limited...
She has amazing potential and has great vocal moments, but her lack of confidence makes her seem like she can't get better than that.
I would love if she tried to release her solo album like tzuyu one day! It would be a great begining 😅
Chae It's better than Tzuyu, Tzuyu in Run Away seems very tense and she forces her notes, and Chaeyeong for me in the live has a better control of her voice !
@@Miyeonijihyobias debatable. I would say chae>tzuyu but it depends on the person ig
Live?? Chaeyoung usually skips singing live lol
@@kanmanivn1475I know your comment is 3 weeks old, but watch Twice's cover of IU's song (I can't remember the name right now) Chaeyoung sounded better in her tone than Tzuyu
@ know ur comments is from today but watch twice all mr removed live versions. Tzuyu sounds better than chae because most of the time chaeyoung does not sing live .. lol
If Mina trained the avarege of 2 years like the other members she would be so good. I hope she trained by herself if she want to continue singing (and not move to acting) her tone is really good.
not really jyp vocal style is what holding them all back. And she needs to be confident in voice
Sana is still better than Dahyun. While she had a very questionable period around Talk That Talk, she has certainly improved again as shown in her concert materials. Dahyun is getting thinner and thinner day by day
Trust me there's no improvement and if there is its like 0.0000001 and debating about anyone below chaeyoung makes no sense but dahyun wins hands down
@@Rina_verseher tomality in projectionsin mixed reg and lows are obv better than dahyun bfr now
@@thedivinefolktales3555 be so real and stop deluled yourself.
@@thedivinefolktales3555 And dahyun is more grounded then Sana stop
@@Rina_verse nuh uh, just cuz she has an airy voice doesnt mean shes more grounded, thats a stereotype that people have made that cutesy voiced idols are relaxed or grounded just cuz they sound like that, sana in general has more depth and a better reach at notes than dahyun, even a healthier belter
Helpp what is the song that momo sang?
What was Chae singing?
@@ArrozConPollo_34 of my face
mina have some A4s
and finally someone knows that nayeon A4s and Bb4s are inconsistent specially in ready to be tour
her A4s are at best not part of her CR
@@Rina_verse yes
Sauce songs on Tzuyu lines please ? Why i didn't recognize that song? 😭😭
The current vocal tiers?
Nayeon: C- ?
Jeongyeon: C- ?
Jihyo: C or C+ ?
Momo: F ?
Sana: F ?
Mina: E+ ?
Chaeyoung: E- or E or E+?
Tzuyu: E- or E or E+ ?
hell no
@rina_core What are they? I just want to know 🙃
@@Kaizen-klf Nayeon D+,Jeongyeon D+, Jihyo C
this rank is full of bullshit
Stay mad😽
then go make your own ranking