→ Become a Real Tool Reviews Subscriber: th-cam.com/users/dmcguinn1 → Instagram: instagram.com/realtoolreviews → Facebook: facebook.com/realtoolreviews
In addition, as a Harbor Freight employee, i can say that even adding the two year replacement plan on the Earthquake the price still comes in ridiculously lower than Snap-On. Also, when you purchase the two year replacement plan....that ADDS two years to the 90 days (i.e. it starts on day 91 and goes for two more years) giving you 27 months of replacement coverage. Loving the comparisons!!! Keep them coming!!! :)
I own a crap load of harbor freight tools. I think they are great for people who do their own work around the house. Work on their own cars etc. As long as you don't plan on using their tools everyday, 99% of harbor freight tools are great.
Haha I use mine everyday for work. Make a great living by them. I can afford the snap on prices but why? I'm there to make money and provide. Not to add tool debt lol
How about this: Years ago, I bought mostly Harbor Freight stuff because I was a forgetful moron and would work on something, fix it and then use whatever I fixed to finish the job (Farm equip.) and let the tools lay around in the dirt, rain etc. I was also young and poor and worked sometimes 18 hrs a day to put food in our mouths. The impact guns then were a hit or miss from HF. It may work forever but only put out 150 ft lbs, OR, put out 500ft lbs and work for a month. I used them because I couldn't even afford to buy a Snap On sticker for my lunch box. As time went on the HF products (some.....) started to improve SLOWLY and in the last 5 years HF tools have improved 500%. It isn't because HF started making better stuff. It's because the Chinese are starting to get their act together, modernizing their factories and learning to apply quality control. I can remember when the words "Made in Japan" on a wrench or socket translated into "Busted knuckles" and today we wouldn't blink an eye or worry about almost anything made there. If Snap On or MATCO or MAC don't wake up soon they will be out of business. They need to understand that the niche market they are in is soon gone. The arguments being presented by the Snap On fans were valid even 5 years ago. Advocating the high price=high quality thing now is the only platform they have left after watching this video. If you have a mortgage payment every month in tools and reality strikes home, it doesn't take long to realize the tasty Kool Aid from the guy in the tool truck may just be poison after all? So to justify their situation and numb reality the normal human psychological response is to grasp at whatever is left...........
lol back in my day it was Taiwan that was the real junk, now Taiwan has stepped it up and the words made in china is the risky one, everything usually gets better, snap on has slowly gotten worse .
Hey bud, I have used the snap-on gun for over 10 years and I have never had to rebuild it. I love it. It gives you the sense of security when your working on customer's cars that the tires are properly mounted. To me that is priceless!!!!
It is refreshing to see such a well done test using the correct equipment . Most Harbor Freight tools these days are pretty good , they have improved greatly over the years .
I have the XT and it is a monster. Getting it for $114 is a great deal, too. I am a home garage mechanic, but with 4 vehicles, and 2 sons with 20 year old, used cars, we have used these tools A LOT over the last 20 years and I can put the "bad" tools on 1/2 of one hand. It's about expectation...and overall, Harbor Freight stuff has far exceeded most expectations while saving me a TON of money along the way. Good review!!
Just bought the Earthquake today after seeing it used and evaluated previously. Just excited about getting a new tool brought me here to check it out more. I have a 115 volt corded electric unit that does not impress me after failing to remove the rusted rim nuts off of my tractor to replace rims and tires. I used a 3/4 in breaker bar to remove the rusted rim nuts and not terribly difficult with a short cheater pipe. Time for a new impact gun. Great video Sir, thank you! :)
I am surprised I thought for sure snap on would blow the earth quake away. This is why I love your videos. I hope your realize how helpful you are to those looking to buy as tools. Thanks much keep the great vids flowing
I've had an earthquake impact as a professional mechanic for a while now. It has provided me extremely reliable service and has consistently performed on par with guns from Mac and snap on. i will admit IR consistently makes the best air tools on the market though. For a start up mechanic, DYI'r, or even a seasoned professional there is absolutely no shame in having an earthquake impact, or even some other hf tools in your box. If you are looking for the elite in air tools however, choose IR
i do a little bit of repair work on my income properties and have no issues with the limited hours i put on my tool shop tools from menards, cheapest ones they sell. if you want a chevy get a chevy if you want to look flashy and last a little longer get a luxury car. each have their place
The way this guy delivers information without pausing to think about what to say is insane. He packs information into every sentence, very nice reviews!
The question is lifespan. My impact wrenches are Mastercraft from Canadian Tire, all metal. I've used them professionally for years and they're still going strong. The only impact that's ever failed on me was a 3/8 drive Craftsman my dad had put about 20 years of pro use on before I got it. I just can't justify spending $500 for something I can get for $100.
Just looked through the current Canadian Tire flier, check this out. 100 pc air tool kit. 1/2" impact, 3/8 ratchet, air chisel, die grinder with bits, a blow gun, a tire filler with dial gauge, and a pile of accessories.... regular price $329.99, on sale for $99.99 - sale starts Dec 2
***** The flyer says "Merry Madness Sale" Dec 2-8. Product# 58-9368-6 www.canadiantire.ca/en/pdp/mastercraft-100-piece-air-tool-kit-0589368p.html Sale is at Terrace BC store, might not be at every store.
I'm an Infiniti Master Tech. I have tools (Hand and Power) from many different brands. Craftsman, snap on, matco, mac, harbor freight, you name it. I've had nothing but great experience with harbor freight. You can't beat the prices! I walked out of harbor freight with a $100 receipt that would of cost me easily over $1K on the snap on truck. Sometimes it's ok to go cheap if the tool is good quality and gets the job done. This video just sold me on trying the XT as my newest tool. Thanks for the video!
I have used Harbor Freight tools for many years and I honestly see them just as reliable as the name brand Snap On and others. Being I don't make much money as it is, I'm simply not going to pay a 500% markup because some company wants more because of their name. And with the 1/2" Harbor Freight coming in at $124 with discounts and coupons, even if it broke or failed and I had to get another one, I would still be coming in cheaper in the long run rather than wasting $505 for a Snap On.
Lightpaws Hird The only time I don't buy harbor freight is if there's an American made alternative, otherwise it's likely the same exact tool just without the brand name.
Lightpaws Hird one of the only times I don't buy harbor freight is when it comes to safety stuff (straps, ties downs,etc.)....it really is cheap Chinese crap...it just sux that everyone local isn't monetarily comparable. If it gets a lot of use and it is important, then I would go with another brand. Jmo
I am a mechanic at Firestone, bought the earth quake, it lasted 3 weeks. Currently running a Craftsman pro series oil bath gun, it is great and was $250
I have been wrenching for, Honestly longer than most of you have been alive. (I was expected to change out of my school clothes and into my work clothes to help my dad, coming home from kindergarden!) So well over 50 years. I have used just about every tool imaginable. I worked in the shipyards and then as a diesel mechanic, then a diesel shop manager. Many years ago I got a cheap set of tools and tool box with the idea that when they broke or wore out I would replace them off the truck. I have a MUCH larger box now and it has some snap-on and cornwell and even a few mac, etc., but surprisingly I still have a lot of that original set and have added some harbor freight as well. The other guys would give me a hard time over my "cheap" stuff and that was o.k. Most of my collection has been with me for decades. The harbor freight stuff that is somewhat newer, relatively speaking, works quite well and I am very pleased with it. I always smile when the other guys come to burrow my earthquake 3/8" impact driver. It got more use than most of the other drivers because everyone liked it so much "for tight spaces" It still performs just great. I am not going to knock the tool truck equipment. It has its place. You can finance your purchases, the truck comes by once a week at a regular time and day. But lets be honest those "conveniences" are not free. The driver has to make a living and I don't blame him for that. I will just say that many of the tools in my box have been there longer than many of the mechanics who have one through the snap-on, etc. which have been replaced one or more times. (in some cases many more). The way I have looked at it is to find what I feel is a good value in a tool and if it gives out on you, just replace it with one from the truck. While many folks will only purchase a tool truck brand, I see them going into debt to the driver for many thousands of dollars. I always pay cash for my tool truck purchases, because I can afford to buy a tool once in a while, thanks to the cost savings on the Harbor Freight and like tools. Maybe I have just beaten the odds but my philosophy has served me well...
Well said and true. There is just too much tool vanity/ and showing off like a woman with an overpriced "designer" purse . Like I said earlier in this example The harbor frieght one is fine for the average guy for 150.00 I would buy an IR 2131ti for 250.00 But I am like you and use mine hard all the time. That IR is every bit as good or better quality than the snap on at 600.00 . The tool truck companies have an insane markup to the driver usually 100% or more then he has to do the same to carry the guy on payments at the shop. Its insane what they end up paying. But to those guys its usually about look at me and my Channel impact or Duuny and Burke wrench or my Saks 5th ave socket set basically. Yes they are very nice but not worth 5 times the price of other usa made tools imho. I was lucky i guess I grew up poor and had an auto parts that sold S&K hand tools and I soon learned why they never failed and the import wrenches/sockets broke. Again they are 1/3-1/4 the price of snap on but forged american steel hand tools.However I would buy the china 3lb hammers and xtra heavy pry bars. etc.Its all about knowing what doesnt need to be precision or strong . I would never buy a cheap china torque wrench but yet I also would never pay tool truck prices for a usa one. 1 snapped off bolt by using a uncalibrated cheapo would pay for the better american calibrated one and still be 1/3-1/4 the price of tool truck brands. Just my opinion.fwiw
I agree. I have one of these Harbor Freight XT 1/2" impact wrenches. I use it every day in a professional shop. Love checking out all these comments and watching the Snap-On fanboys get all upset because somebody didn't pay $500.00 for a wrench.
Finally someone that makes sense,,,,I actually read all of it..Well said,,way too much male EGOs out there. Idiots,,Go ahead pay more,,,for the same freaking shit.
As a weekend mechanic I have been using the earthquake xt for 2 years. I oil it at the start of each day of use and it performs the same as the first day. I've had no reliability issues with it at all. For the price point it is perfect for the average backyard mechanic who doesn't need to use it day in and day out. The snap on model is much more durable being made of a solid metal housing but just isn't necessary for most unless you need it for your profession. Thanks for the great video with real tested specs!!
Really enjoyed the video. I've had my snap on mg725 for 5 years now. 3 of us run these around 140 working pressure and they last 2 to 3 years with everyday use before they blow the front seal and slowly lose power. Snap on does rebuild the entire impact for $130 which is affordable. Might recommend some of the new guys try out the earthquake to save some money.
Yeah but how are they built? What materials they use inside? This is why i love when AVE does his reviews because he take the things apart and explains everything and if it’s going to last.
He also makes up words & speaks in gibberish when he doesnt understand something --- yet deletes comments from actual engineers when they question his results. Hmmmmm..... Patreon....cough......bumming money.....cough cough.....donate now....cough cough.....
Real Tool Reviews not really he actually goes and makes another video explaining where he messed up. 🤷🏻♂️ But again he lets you know if something is actually worth buying according to what’s inside
I bought the Harbor Freight XT recently have been extremely impressed. They now come with a rubber cover. I've been wary of buying power tools from Harbor Freight because they just don't seem to last, so I was a initially bit cautious about purchasing the Earthquake XT. But it was on sale, plus they gave me 20% off, which made it right around $100, so I figured I'd bite and see how it performed. I've been pleasantly surprised. It feels good and solid in your hands and it's been able to do everything I asked, including removing some really stubborn bolts on my old Jeep. The big power dial on the back is great. It makes the settings easy to change even if you're wearing gloves. It's also surprisingly quieter than my old gun. There's no odd clanking or loose play in it anywhere, and with the rubber cover and regular oiling, I'm hoping it can last for a good long time. We'll see how it goes, but so far, no buyer's remorse.
Nick G I think it's funny looking at all the idols that just call it Chinese junk after it just smashed a over priced POS snapon. Some people are pretty damn stupid. By the way our snapon truck doesn't warranty shit when it's commercial use. Go figure.
Nick G I'd rather still buy American because you KNOW it'll last much longer and you're not actively being a traitor to your country :) tell me how that earthquake is doing in 6 months ...
Oh Really? I work on trucks and never had a problem, cant blame snap-on for YOUR shitty rep when my guy will bend over backwards for me any time I need something, he even warrantys blue point for me.
+CDubs HasIt Okay, how does doing what's best for you make you a traitor to your country? Now tell me what your country has done for you to save you $400? I'll tell you, not a bloody thing. Your country doesn't give a shit about you, so you have to watch out for yourself. I am number 1 in my book, not my country, so I have to do what's best for me and not what's best for my country. And besides, if you're really worried about the tool you're buying at HF then get the 2 year warranty with it. That still means you are ahead $350, at least! And then in 6 months, if it breaks, or 24 months, you're still protected because the 24 months starts after the original 90 day warranty ends, so you actually get a warranty for 27 months. Sounds like a pretty good deal/value to me. If it breaks after that then you simply go get another one and/or get the original one repaired or both and you're still way ahead of the game even if you buy another 24 month warranty on your new tool. And if you really are a mechanic you can fix your tool because you can buy repair parts for it. Sounds like a no brainer to me! Just saying. lol
if you use H.B. airtools daily as an auto tech they won't last no more than a month. and I do oil my tools. their air ratchets are junk. snap on is better. before you knock our country remember we kicked your ass in 1776, bailed you out of 2 world wars if it wernt for Americans you would be speaking German
I got both of them. Just bought the earthquake 2 months ago when my snapon failed on a weekend while working out of town. Ran to HF and picked up one of their Earthquake XT 1/2 guns and it works great. The big dial on the back is awesome! I like reducing my power a lot especially when removing bolts with a swivel and extension so i don’t launch the socket clear across the shop if I accidentally pull the trigger a bit to hard. The big dial on the back makes that a lot simpler.
snap-fuck makes good air tools and ratchets other tools by them are not worth the price for e screwdrivers ... for this video i would take snap on over earth quake any day ..... i love quality
I have all Snap-on-tools never have liked Harbor Freight but after watching video I might check them out and see how I like them. Thanks for a very good video.
man.... i dont know what you do for a living............ but you have a voice made for speaking, and the tone is golden.... just wanted to say thanks for being a well spoken and articulate host.... and for the valuable information, well done all around !
Wow! Just the review that I'm looking for! I'm a WEEKEND DIY'er and I purchased the XT a month ago for $130 to upgrade my CHF IW that I purchased 7 years ago. The CHF IW shows a bit of a lag on it's torque because of its age but still works great for the LIGHT work I do to my track vehicle, so I jumped on in on the XT because mainly for its PRICE second, its CLAIMS. Well, your tests verified it! Thank you! Bottom line is, If I have a business that uses these tools EVERYDAY with harsh work load, I would buy the SO IW for RELIABILITY AND DURABILITY, but I'm a weekend hobbyist and I can not JUSTIFY the cost of the SNAP ON so I have to GAMBLE on the low end IW. Great job again on this "in depth" tests of these two great product! God Speed!
It's also about how many you can buy. Let's say the HF tools aren't as good for sake of argument. I can buy 4 of these EQs vs 1 of the Snapon. Even if the HF one lasts 5 years and the Snapon lasts 20 I'll still spend the same amount but out WAY less initially. Now let's talk theft. Someone takes your EQ "Well shit..." Someone takes your Snapon "HOLY FUCK ME NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!"
TexasGTO certain tools from snap on are definitely worth paying for. even their open end box wrench with flank drive won't spread like literally every other make wrench on the market. I've been a tech for 10 years and am a certified world class Tech. snap on is definitely over priced but they still have buyers why do you think that is? because they have insanely quality stuff..
They have buyers because people think the tools make them better mechanics and its just not the case. Also a lot of the UTI type tech schools push tool truck tools because they get payed too, they tell the students you need snapon because everything else wont last. plus there is much better tool company's like Proto who make much higher quality stuff then snapon for about the same price. Proto makes the best pneumatics money can buy more power, more comfort, lighter weight, better balance, and more adjustability.
Our shop has several Earthquake XT's and they are really used a ton. I find if I want a heavy slugger I use the XT 20 volt 1/2 drive and it takes almost anything off and I have never busted a bolt either with the easy to change variable torque. I was very skeptical when I first picked one up but now I actually prefer them. Snap on is now just riding on it's name folks. The only downside I have seen with Earthquake is the battery release is broken on some of the tools but we have had some real morons using them as well.
I am a mechanic like my father, He bought a lot of snap-on, Mac and so on, his tools cost more than my new car and he had a debt to these tool trucks for ever, I on the other hand never went that route, I bought Craftsman when they where made in the USA, I did buy a Ingersoll Rand 235 now that gun is about mid $200.00, I really like it, it has 1000lbs torque in reverse I love the gun. To all you new mechanics tools will be your biggest cost to your tool box buy wisely to prevent from being in debt.
I have been using Earthquake 1/2 inch impact since it hit the shelf for 79.00$. It was bought for an emergency roadside repair. It worked so good I now use earthquake pneumatics exclusively. For the money. The weight. The abuse on your wrist. Earthquake is the best. Thank you for and real laboratory condition test!
So as a long time owner of Snap-On including the MG725, Im not surprised by this. I'll never again spend my hard earned money on a snappy one when IR surpasses all these
I own the older Snap-On IM6500 and it just keeps on going. I think that is the key difference with Snap On and lower priced impact wrenches and tools in general. I've used my Snap On impact in a professional environment for approximately 15 years now and it has never failed to perform. While I can not speak for or against the Earthquake impact wrench specifically (and I do think it is quite impressive for the price) I found out long ago that you usually give up longevity when you purchase bargain priced tools. Yes, I've had Snap On tools fail prematurely and yes I've bought 'Chinese bargain tools' that have performed well but generally the pro tools last much, much longer and break far less often. Lets face it, when you are in the middle of an important job the money saved on a Harbor Freight tool is quickly lost in down time when it fails. Not to mention the busted knuckles and bruised ribs.
I owned the mg725 that I bought used for 80 bucks. The hammer housing cracked. So I went out and bought the earthquake and was absolutely beyond disappointed. The trigger isn't nearly as nice, it vibrates through your wrist twice as much And ya it can take off most bolts the snapon can but stubborn rusty bolts it easily takes double the amount of time to remove the bolt. This gun is perfect for the at home mechanic, not for professional use. I welded by hammer housing back together in my mg725 and kept using it and it still works great. Earthquake is just a backup now. Using an impact to do a tire rotation in your driveway and using one professionally as a flat rate mechanic the choice is obvious, spend the money and buy snapon or Ingersoll Rand
Real Tool Review, thanks for a well informed, accurate review. I always buy two tools at less of a cost of a name brand. I always have a back up available without having to wait for the replacement item under warranty, and it improves my cash flow. Thanks for the review
what a great video!! thank you as a mechanic i want to make sure i have good tools to do a good job, and i'm thinking that the earthquake is the better tool, just doesn't have "snap on" written on it to make it cost a fortune
john waller get an IR they're better than snapon. my Kevlar air cat impact is a beast for half the price of snapon. but let's be real that harbor freight won't hold up for reliability. snapon hand tools are the best hands down but air is different.
consider aircat. I ditched my mac's for them. I got 2 aircats of each kind for less than the a single mac one.. and the come with 2 year warranty at no extra cost. I find them better than IR. I am also a big fan of astro nano for.. hard to reach places, i have both the 1822 (1/2") and 1828 (3/8") and since i only use them when i am in a hard to reach place.. am really not worried about them breaking.
Based on past experience, the HF may be DOA out of the box. It is a good thing they will swap it on the spot. You are HF's QC department. They sure don't check them in China. That being said, I often go that route. The second one has been OK so far
mds19238 That is purely depedant on your dealer. I've had the same dealer for over 10yrs, and if it dies during warranty he will either swap it out straight away, or leave a loaner while yours is sent off.
Purchased just before your video was released with warranty, using it for something I should have been using a 1" impact, granted I torn it up, but I was back-up and running within the hour. This time with my 1" impact. Great tool for the price. Could even afford a "cold one" after the job was done. Great review.
Great review. I have the previous model Earthquake from HF, which replaced a 1990s Blue Point AT500c that died after 2 decades of abuse. The Earthquake is doing just fine. Sure is a nice chunk less expensive than the Snap On / Blue Point!. FWIW, I am considerably heavier than you, and when the impact can't do the job, I simply lean into my breaker bar. I saw your HF to snap on to others comparison of breaker bars. Mine are older, but I have both HF / Pittburgh and Snap On breaker bars without the plastic handles. My results are similar to yours at considerably higher torque. (370lb operator on the end of a 24" tool, you do the math...) The biggest thing here is that Harbor Freight has REALLY stepped up their game over the past few years in particular. I am not sure I would rely on their stuff if I made my primary income with them, but for side work, home hobbyist, or iffy shop / jobsite conditions where tools have bad odds of growing feet and walking off and Harbor Freight becomes VERY appealing...
Great Test RTR! I worked at an auto recycling yard, we punished these guns day in and day out. With the dirtiest of compressed air supply Harbor Freight Earthquake Impacts will rattle off the toughest nut year after year. "The best bang for your buck!"
Great vid. Just bought an Earthquake XT for axle/spindle nuts on a truck. Broke them loose no problem. Clicked 150 ft lbs on a Tq wrench. Lowest setting didn't move much, if any from 150ft lbs. Used the cotter pin hole as a reference and marked nut, to measure movement. Then on 2nd setting, turned the nut 1/8-1/4 in. Close to 290 ft lbs, I hope. Front end feels solid.
True there is the big price/quality thing. For a home garage, get the cheap stuff, but if this is a business that can not afford down time like a mechanic's garage or an assembly line in a plant, you want something that will last years without failing. Just shutting a line down for 20 minutes while maintenance replaces a tool can cost hundreds of dollars in manufacturing that day. Likely though the Snap-on one is also serviceable and can be fixed by simply replacing a few O-rings. Every time the shop I worked for tried to save money on tools and such they usually turned out losing money in the long run. Even a simple thing like a screw presenter (you manufacturing guys might know of these), they tried $400 all the way up to $1500 ones. The $400 would last maybe a week and would require maintenance regularly and would fall apart after a year tops. The $1500 was indestructible and lasted 10+ years with little maintenance. That is the difference between a Milwaukee heat gun that will run 20,000 hours compared to a Tool Shop one that lasts 50 hours... $200 vs $20. Which one will cost more in the long run? Same thing with things like drill bits. Do you spend $20 on a cheap set or $20 on one good drill bit. Long story short it is not the specs but the reliability that is important for industrial/business use. Remember time is money.
I doubt any. The Snap-on though looks to have a large metal plate on the back with a rubber seal and 4 allen bolts that lets you rebuild it. They likely sell cheap rebuild kits with o-rings and such to service hem. This way say annually they can have them rebuilt during downtime or rotate through inventory so these things will last for 25 years or more. Too many people always gravitate to the cheapest crap out there. I am not saying Snap-on is the best or worth the price. there might be other better companies out there, but there is something called brand recognition and loyalty. These things exist for a reason. As a consumer I know Harbor Freight petals a lot of cheap junk, while Snap-on is good, but expensive. If I was a company, though, I would spend more money for quality and reliability in a heartbeat. For a casual user... buy what you can afford, but understand that you might be buying another one in a few years. If you have the money than get the good stuff.
Not entirely disagreeing...but for the price of the HF you can have a spare for every one you have in service and still be $200 to the good of the snap-on.
Yes but many products can not stand up to the use a shop or factory will throw at them. The frustration of cheap tool is horrible for an assembly line. Time is money. You cut costs on material going into products as long as they still work and pass the tests, but tooling has to cycle sometimes thousands of times a day and last 10+ years. A cheap Harbor Freight pneumatic screwdriver might last a month... more than most home users would ever using in a lifetime, but that means they might go through 100+ cheap drivers in the life of that assembly line. I managed to take home several leftover tools from lines that were discontinued and they deemed the tools not worth salvaging. Even these beat up tools are 10x better that buying a cheap tool at HF. My favorite is a Milwaukee heat gun. This thing is probably 25 years old, been dropped 1000 times, been cycled over 100,000 times, and probably run for a couple of years of on time and it still works great.
All in All ~ My Opinion.... It ALL comes down to Name and how Big Your Wallet is.... I'm a Power Transmission Technician of 30+ yrs. It's been known for yrs. that "Snap-On" (HAD) the best Tool & Wrench Warranty = LIFE TIME... Most of My Tools ARE "Snap-On". But when Grey (Heavy Tool) & Craftsman/Mastercraft (Almost the same LQQK as Snap-On) Offered the SAME LIFE TIME Warranty. My Hand Tools Started to become a Mixture of Snap-On & Craftsman/Mastercraft. Why??? NOT LQQKING at $Price$ like most Mechanic's are not really concerned with cost (We're LQQKING for a TOOL that will Last and Not let us down (BREAK) during a Repair)... My Own Experience became.... You can buy a Brand New Shiny & Expensive "Snap-On" Tool Grrr8. (BUT) if that Tool Breaks You have to wait until MONDAY when the Snap-On Truck Shows up to Replace it. Buy a Brand New Craftsman/Mastercraft Tool Grrr8 too. (BUT) if that Tool Breaks you can jump in Your Car and go to the Closest Canadian Tire/Sears Store and get a Replacement. (As long as it's not a Specialty Tool). As far as an Impact Gun? I've had em' ALL... My Favorite Impact Gun is the one that most Old School Mechanic's use. (Ingersoll Rand) It's Durable, Stronger than a Snap-On and they "NEVER" Die!!! Lmao. Again, ALL in ALL it all comes down to how much $$$ you have to Spend on Tools... Are You buying Tools to LQQK Impressive to your Co-worker's or Friends (i.e. $8,400 +++ on a Snap-On Rolling Tool Box???). OR Buying Tools that will get the Job done and will be Affordable and Last??? I Bought My Tools based on Longevity.... I still have ALL My Snap-On, Grey, Craftsman/Mastercraft and even Professional today... My Opinion. I'm very Impressed with this Video (it's a Grrr8 Comparison) BUT, Myself from Experience I'd Buy the Ingersoll Rand that probably sell in the Range of $450.00 and up. Grrr8 Video "Real Tool Reviews" :)
I bought the Earthquake when I was changing the torque converter on my Ford Edge. It worked great for all my needs during that time. With the cost savings with the coupon and the extended warranty, I feel this was a great buy for a shade tree mechanics needs. This was a great review, regardless of some of the idiotic comments below. I really appreciate the time you put into this.
This is like the tortoise and the hare scenario. Snap-on has been riding their reputation and not changing, improving or innovating much. Companies like Harbor Freight have been catching up or surpassing their competition by making their product as good or better for a fraction of the cost. I'm thankful for videos like this that demonstrate both tools abilities and dispell some of the stereotypes between the brands. Snap-on should be worried as they're the hare right now and the race is long.
Aron Hall-Terraciano but really I was thinking this the entire time. I know the snap-on will out last that harbor freight tool. Just curious to see how horrible the machining and casting inside it is to hit that price point.
i have them both. Been using the snap on mg725 for years and now I bought the xt and keep that one on my cart instead. snap on's become my "backup." My mac dealer had the boots to the old ingersoll titanium 2135ti and it fits the XT perfectly. so between buying the gun for $119, extended warranty was like $35 and a boot for $25, i'm still hundreds less. anytime it couldnt get a bolt off, I'd switch to the snap on to see if it'd get it. it failed everytime too.
My IR takes it out or breaks it, just the way i like it. Never in 39 years has it not removed or broke it trying to. If it's bad enough to break coming out it needed replaced anyway.
I almost purchased the earthquake yesterday but I decided to wait until I heard more about it. Now I am kicking myself that I didn't purchase it yesterday. Thanks for the comparison tests because now my mind is definitely made up, go Harbor Freight. 😎
I have to say..I love harbor freight...I always felt snap on is totally over priced. I'm no rich man trying to have the best name tools ..I'm a family man with bills n I like to save money. my harbor freight and craftsman do me just fine. people say your only as good as your tools... that's Bs. I do just as good of work if not better then most garages in my area. because I'm not one of those " it will be fine" that way.. I make sure it's done right the first time.. and at the end of the day..I made more money to keep then shell out for snapon name.. ty for this video..keep them coming.
Hence the reason your living pay check to pay check. I know its a hard lesson to learn, but Snap-on tools are worth their price. You will eventually learn this, or ended up in the lower pay scale where they seem like a luxury item.
Break the Snap on and wait for the replacement, crap out the Earthquake go get another. I'm still waiting for Snap on to replace a hook scribe from 2010!
TractorMan104 that's for sure. my HF red earthquake gets used and abused on a daily basis with no lube due to techs that don't like lubing it and still lasts a hell of a long time. I can go down to HF and grab a replacement with no hassle.
If you have a Snap On truck in your area, they usually take good care of their customers. Still though, you've got to wait. Or take the Earthquake to Harbor Freight and have a new tool the same day. And the employees are Harbor Freight will NEVER argue with you and couldn't care less why it doesn't work anymore. You're getting a new tool. lol
I recently bought the Earthquake XT for $25 on sale. Yes, Twenty Five Dollars. I use it with a tiny 8gallon compressor and It’s amazing even with that. If you’re looking to buy this, it’s seriously a great product
This was a great video! I honestly thought the Snap On was going to destroy the competition but I was pleasantly surprised. When it comes to buying tools by brand, what matters is longevity, and it's application. If you buy a Snap On tool, you know that you're getting a quality product that you'll get tons of use out of, but it's gonna cost you. Harbor Freight tools are better suited for at home for something that's handy to have e around. They don't break the budget, and some of their stuff is surprisingly good. But I always avoid their expendable items, like sandpaper or drill bits. They aren't worth it. There are other great tool brands out there as well. A lot of Kobalt's tools look so similar to Snap On's, and I've been damn pleased with everything of theirs I've bought. Another awesome often overlooked brand is S-K. They cost a premium as well, but they're 100% American made (they claim to be the only tool manufacturer left to be). My dad has a bunch of old S-K tools on his farm for decades that have held up to a ton of abuse and still work just fine. Craftsmen...that's just a sad story. They're a shadow of their former self. I remember if you broke a tool, you could walk up to the counter in Sears and they would grab you a new one off the shelf. No questions asked. Now, they interrogate you, require 3 forms of ID, and a video of what you were doing that caused the tool to break. But if you want a decent Craftsmen, you can shell out the cash for their "Professional" line. Craftsmen used to be just Craftsmen...a great tool with a kickass warranty. Now Pittsburgh Tools has them beat. At least they don't claim to be the best out there.
wartooth6 i can actually walk up to the sears in houston & get warranty's no questions asked just take the socket or messed up wrenches but they actually rebuild them now before they used to be off the shell lol just a month ago i took 5 messed up wrenches & got them replace in 15 mins
Great no B.S. comparison. Between those two I would go with the Earthquake along with an extended warranty. I just can't justify the Snap on price tag, and yes I own quite a few of their tools. Albeit for now with all the options out there I will just stick with my tried and true Ingersoll Rand.
Got my mg725 on eBay for $200 used in good condition and it’s done anything I’ve needed it to do working on heavy duty trucks. The main selling point for me is the ability to rebuild your impact if it takes a shit, and the snap on truck comes to my shop weekly. I would be curious to see a working test on these impacts to see how long they each hold up being used daily.
Jacob Budke My Matco 1/2" gun is about ten years old, I've put about three drops of oil in it since I've owned it and it keeps on cranking. It's a rebranded Ingersoll Rand.
i used 1 for a few years, and i agree, best impacts ever. We now have a snapon thing at my job and i dont really like it. It makes lots of noise but dosn't seem as strong. Its a pain in the ass to get to a lower power level, and it only seems to go at 1 speeds wich is full speed. With the ingersoll rand you had some feel to the trigger and could spin it at a low speed by just pressing a little and it worked great. And that thing got everything loose without a problem. And if it would you would snap a half inch drive on it anyway.
One of the best things I like about it, other than what you said above, is that the forward and reverse controls are on the back of the impact and can easily be used with my thumb. Unlike both impacts in this video.
HF is getting stingy with 20% coupon use and there is a ever growing list of exceptions. I believe anything in the Earthquake series is on the list. That means that to get a discount you have to wait for a Super Coupon that is for the particular Earthquake tool you want. This also applies to all jacks and compressors.
8 years as a full time tech at a chevy/subaru dealer I have 6 harbor freight air tools and 2 have been replaced 1 was in 90 day warranty I paid 12 bucks for a die grinder that lasted me 7 years you just can't beat HF sometimes my impacts are craftsman professional and are also 8 years old IR built and have held up well it all comes down to maintaining the tool oil it and don't use it like an idiot and chances are it will last quite a while I despise snap on air tools but I have damn near the entire SO 14.4 cordless setup with 6 batteries it all depends on what you are using the tools for every day this channel is great created an account just to subscribe to it :)
Because if you use these tools daily, after 7 or 8 years, you will have spent the same amount of money re buying the HF tool as you would have if you just spent the money to begin with.
@@punk303 I have S.O. tools and Tools from H.F.. Some of the HF shit has outlasted the S.O.. A lot of the time the S.O. tool truck is a dick about replacement as well. I no longer buy S.O. tools because their quality equals price motto is just a spiel.
From my experience using tools from all different vendors I found that claiming the warranty from tools that are sold out of tool trucks are almost impossible to claim. However, I have to understand that the tool trucks are privately owned franchises and they have to take on the initial cost of honoring a warranty. I think there is still something good to be said about having a brick-and-mortar location in today's web market place. Thank you for doing these videos.
Ive used the original earthquake for two years in a shop. I use it all day long at home. Never a single problem. Also use it as a hammer. Heavy but strong.
I have two of the older Earthquare 1/2" impacts. Still running strong many years later. I thought about upgrading to their newer impact (reminds me more of the IR style impact) but why should I if my older units are still chooching along?
Agree, I'd buy two HF's at half the price of one snap on. I'd have a back up immediately available to finish the job should it fail. If I had a snap on, I'd be out of service until a replacement is sent or delivered via truck, or figuring some workaround. Disappointed customer. Besides, two HB at half the price of a snap on means I can splurge on lunch m
I have a tool box full of different tools and some cost more than I would have liked and some cost less than what some would call brand name but all do the job to my satisfaction. I own several HF tools including an earthquake model air rachet that I cannot say enough about. It works! Never fails. Best air rachet I've ever owned. Additionally all of my HF tools have continued to serve me well.
I have the Earthquake XT, I use it for full time small engine repair. It is a beast. I run it at the proper 90 psi on a 30 gal 175 psi compressor, 3/8 hose and 1/4 fittings. For the price, you cant beat it. Now if you want something that will last, an IR titanium might last longer. Both a great options, just depends on how heavily its used.
I realize you published this video quite some time ago but I just watched it for the first time. Excellent job, IMO. You obviously did plenty of research and figured out just how to do a side-by-side comparison “by the numbers” which appeared (is, IMO) completely unbiased. I have seen other comparisons which I would call far less objective. The claim I have frequently heard is that Snap-On has superior build quality and given the price difference, it should. I’d like to see some kind of a durability test for products like these but it would be a more costly exercise as the sample size would need to be much larger to due to variability between individual tools. I do not have either of these impact guns. I have a pneumatic Mastercraft unit from Canadian Tire (I live in Canada). I believe it is a rebranded IR unit but not certain. I also have a Mastercraft electric impact unit. I don’t use these units often but when I need them, they are invaluable. More recently, I have found myself wanting an impact gun but not wanting to fiddle with a compressor and hose or a cord. I frequently use a cordless impact driver in these circumstances with a socket adapter. I may have to use a breaker bar to get something started but after that: it works well enough. I have come across some of your other videos on occasion and generally found them to be excellent as well. I have decided to stop finding then by accident and subscribe to your channel. Keep up the good work.
OK, guys, here's the deal. I can speak to this because I worked 20+years as a certified tech and even ran my own shop, worked for a company that sold high end construction tools (a H.F. mainstay) around the corner from Harbor Freight where wife is a manager and has worked there 12 years over which time I've brought home a LOT of H.F. tools and, of course, many thousands of dollars in Snap On, Mac and Matco told as well. Here's what many years and lots of shop hours has tought me, having thrown my share of broken tools across the shop. The observation that Harbor Freight has steadily increased overall quality and product lines is true. The fact that some of their stuff is, and always will be, not worth bringing home is true BUT not nearly the quantity of their items are bad as used to be. What's the solution?? First, use some common sense. Don't expect to pay 20 bucks for a tool and expect it to hold up like a $150 tool. But... Some of the H.F. tools WILL last for a reasonable life span if you don't punish and abuse your tools. Some times you can buy three or four HF tools for the price of on big name. But how do you decide? The rules are pretty simple. Remember that H.F. tools are cheaper for a reason. lighter, lesser quality materials means a shorter working life and a more fragile tool. They don't take being dropped and pushed too their limit very long. First, look at the tool and how its built and do a little due diligence as to a particular tool, if it holds up, what is the cost compared to the name brand, etc. Second, if you have the luxury of being able to head off and replace a tool if something breaks or quits in the middle of a job OR if you buy a backup (or two) because it's cheap enough then buy the H.F. presuming it will do the job in the first place. If a busted tool will stop production and put you in a real bind, like working in a high production shop or high stress job then spend the big dollars. Don't be afraid to try them, just have realistic expectations of what to expect. Most importantly, though, and especially if you're buying a power tool, BUY THE WARRANTY. There is usually a 90 day standard warranty but for a couple bucks extra you can get a one or two year warranty and even if you run over your tool with a semi they will replace it. Just keep your receipt!!!
Just got the XT. Haven't been able to use it much just to take a couple lug nuts off but it's quieter than my currently broken ingersoll rand which I've had for 10 years and has been bullet proof and powerful this whole time. Hopefully will get my many years of use out of this XT. If not, will be going back to my good old IG.
I've saved a ton of money maintaining and repairing my own vehicles BECAUSE I can afford the Harbor Freight version of the unobtanium tool. It's a no brainer for me.
Yes, I get where you are coming from. Much easier to 'pay yourself' for working on your own vehicles with a cheap tool you use infrequently (but will now have for future use) than to drop $500 on one tool. Might as well pay the mechanic at that point - would probably be cheaper and is definitely easier. As a professional (general contractor, carpenter and woodworker), I do love my high quality tools though! There IS a difference in build-quality and when it is a write-off as well, that is my no-brainer... :D
This must be the best in depth review on the planet. For the average diyer, Harbour Freight wins, no competition !! Top class value and top class review.
I agree. I'm only interested in the ability to LOOSEN bolts with an impact gun. You should use a torque wrench to tighten the bolts afterwards, so I couldn't care a hill of beans over the forward impact force. HF wins with the variable impact force on reverse. Using an impact driver to tighten bolts will strip threads and snap bolts. There's a reason why manufacturers specify torque values in the owners manuals!!! If you're a "professional" that doesn't care about the customers property, then it's not something to worry about if you torque the lug nuts of his wheels to 450 ft lbs. The average car owner/property owner DOES care.
→ Become a Real Tool Reviews Subscriber: th-cam.com/users/dmcguinn1
→ Instagram: instagram.com/realtoolreviews
→ Facebook: facebook.com/realtoolreviews
5:00 Snap-On protective cover, same price as the Earthquake impact gun.
In addition, as a Harbor Freight employee, i can say that even adding the two year replacement plan on the Earthquake the price still comes in ridiculously lower than Snap-On. Also, when you purchase the two year replacement plan....that ADDS two years to the 90 days (i.e. it starts on day 91 and goes for two more years) giving you 27 months of replacement coverage. Loving the comparisons!!! Keep them coming!!! :)
I still point people to this video to this day. Thank you for doing honest, quality reviews!
I own a crap load of harbor freight tools. I think they are great for people who do their own work around the house. Work on their own cars etc. As long as you don't plan on using their tools everyday, 99% of harbor freight tools are great.
a great Mother's Day Gift....
kelvenguard I got some for my mother as a retirement gift.
Haha I use mine everyday for work. Make a great living by them. I can afford the snap on prices but why? I'm there to make money and provide. Not to add tool debt lol
HF supplies this working class guy.
I use them daily as well. These stores are popping up everywhere so if you have a problem with one its easy to exchange it for another,which is rare.
This guy packs a lot of info in his videos. I like the non BS approach
I will paint the earthquake green
Best comment in here and no one seems to notice
Just get the tool protector, slip it on the earthquake.
@@itslegit7362 but that snap on tool protector will cost as much as a new earthquake
UltraNon that was funny!
Or get the snap on green cover.
My ambitions: snap-on
my bankaccount: harbor freight
avoid s/o. not worth the money
My bank account:flea market!
How about this: Years ago, I bought mostly Harbor Freight stuff because I was a forgetful moron and would work on something, fix it and then use whatever I fixed to finish the job (Farm equip.) and let the tools lay around in the dirt, rain etc. I was also young and poor and worked sometimes 18 hrs a day to put food in our mouths. The impact guns then were a hit or miss from HF. It may work forever but only put out 150 ft lbs, OR, put out 500ft lbs and work for a month. I used them because I couldn't even afford to buy a Snap On sticker for my lunch box.
As time went on the HF products (some.....) started to improve SLOWLY and in the last 5 years HF tools have improved 500%. It isn't because HF started making better stuff. It's because the Chinese are starting to get their act together, modernizing their factories and learning to apply quality control. I can remember when the words "Made in Japan" on a wrench or socket translated into "Busted knuckles" and today we wouldn't blink an eye or worry about almost anything made there.
If Snap On or MATCO or MAC don't wake up soon they will be out of business. They need to understand that the niche market they are in is soon gone. The arguments being presented by the Snap On fans were valid even 5 years ago. Advocating the high price=high quality thing now is the only platform they have left after watching this video. If you have a mortgage payment every month in tools and reality strikes home, it doesn't take long to realize the tasty Kool Aid from the guy in the tool truck may just be poison after all? So to justify their situation and numb reality the normal human psychological response is to grasp at whatever is left...........
couldnt of said it any better myself, i fuckin love snap on man
@@bach2458 Did u read the whole thing?
wtf is wrong with you???
lol back in my day it was Taiwan that was the real junk, now Taiwan has stepped it up and the words made in china is the risky one, everything usually gets better, snap on has slowly gotten worse .
@@JC-wh9pj ... Who? Whaaaaa? OH! With Noah! ROFL
Hey bud, I have used the snap-on gun for over 10 years and I have never had to rebuild it. I love it. It gives you the sense of security when your working on customer's cars that the tires are properly mounted. To me that is priceless!!!!
It is refreshing to see such a well done test using the correct equipment . Most Harbor Freight tools these days are pretty good , they have improved greatly over the years .
I have the XT and it is a monster. Getting it for $114 is a great deal, too. I am a home garage mechanic, but with 4 vehicles, and 2 sons with 20 year old, used cars, we have used these tools A LOT over the last 20 years and I can put the "bad" tools on 1/2 of one hand. It's about expectation...and overall, Harbor Freight stuff has far exceeded most expectations while saving me a TON of money along the way. Good review!!
Just bought the Earthquake today after seeing it used and evaluated previously. Just excited about getting a new tool brought me here to check it out more.
I have a 115 volt corded electric unit that does not impress me after failing to remove the rusted rim nuts off of my tractor to replace rims and tires. I used a 3/4 in breaker bar to remove
the rusted rim nuts and not terribly difficult with a short cheater pipe. Time for a new impact gun. Great video Sir, thank you! :)
I am surprised I thought for sure snap on would blow the earth quake away. This is why I love your videos. I hope your realize how helpful you are to those looking to buy as tools. Thanks much keep the great vids flowing
I've had an earthquake impact as a professional mechanic for a while now. It has provided me extremely reliable service and has consistently performed on par with guns from Mac and snap on. i will admit IR consistently makes the best air tools on the market though. For a start up mechanic, DYI'r, or even a seasoned professional there is absolutely no shame in having an earthquake impact, or even some other hf tools in your box. If you are looking for the elite in air tools however, choose IR
i do a little bit of repair work on my income properties and have no issues with the limited hours i put on my tool shop tools from menards, cheapest ones they sell. if you want a chevy get a chevy if you want to look flashy and last a little longer get a luxury car. each have their place
The way this guy delivers information without pausing to think about what to say is insane. He packs information into every sentence, very nice reviews!
Dude, this is an AWESOME video! GREAT job
Thanks Charles!
Awesome!
HumbleMechanic v
The question is lifespan. My impact wrenches are Mastercraft from Canadian Tire, all metal. I've used them professionally for years and they're still going strong. The only impact that's ever failed on me was a 3/8 drive Craftsman my dad had put about 20 years of pro use on before I got it. I just can't justify spending $500 for something I can get for $100.
Just looked through the current Canadian Tire flier, check this out. 100 pc air tool kit. 1/2" impact, 3/8 ratchet, air chisel, die grinder with bits, a blow gun, a tire filler with dial gauge, and a pile of accessories.... regular price $329.99, on sale for $99.99 - sale starts Dec 2
I don't see that in this week's flyer. Do you have a link to the product page?
*****
The flyer says "Merry Madness Sale" Dec 2-8. Product# 58-9368-6
www.canadiantire.ca/en/pdp/mastercraft-100-piece-air-tool-kit-0589368p.html Sale is at Terrace BC store, might not be at every store.
I totally agree with you. Any tool is going to last you if you take proper care of it and I'm sure you do as did your father.
Nowhere near 1000 ft. lbs torque on that impact.
I'm an Infiniti Master Tech. I have tools (Hand and Power) from many different brands. Craftsman, snap on, matco, mac, harbor freight, you name it. I've had nothing but great experience with harbor freight. You can't beat the prices! I walked out of harbor freight with a $100 receipt that would of cost me easily over $1K on the snap on truck. Sometimes it's ok to go cheap if the tool is good quality and gets the job done. This video just sold me on trying the XT as my newest tool. Thanks for the video!
I have used Harbor Freight tools for many years and I honestly see them just as reliable as the name brand Snap On and others. Being I don't make much money as it is, I'm simply not going to pay a 500% markup because some company wants more because of their name. And with the 1/2" Harbor Freight coming in at $124 with discounts and coupons, even if it broke or failed and I had to get another one, I would still be coming in cheaper in the long run rather than wasting $505 for a Snap On.
Lightpaws Hird The only time I don't buy harbor freight is if there's an American made alternative, otherwise it's likely the same exact tool just without the brand name.
Lightpaws Hird one of the only times I don't buy harbor freight is when it comes to safety stuff (straps, ties downs,etc.)....it really is cheap Chinese crap...it just sux that everyone local isn't monetarily comparable. If it gets a lot of use and it is important, then I would go with another brand. Jmo
Lightpaws Hird
exactly, you could burn through a few of these Harbor Freight impact wrenches and still be under the cost of 1 snap on impact
Ignoramuses and indifference are the reason US mfrs and jobs are gone to China and Asia.
One of the very best, most exhaustive comparison reviews I've seen about anything...great job!
I am a mechanic at Firestone, bought the earth quake, it lasted 3 weeks. Currently running a Craftsman pro series oil bath gun, it is great and was $250
I have been wrenching for, Honestly longer than most of you have been alive. (I was expected to change out of my school clothes and into my work clothes to help my dad, coming home from kindergarden!) So well over 50 years. I have used just about every tool imaginable. I worked in the shipyards and then as a diesel mechanic, then a diesel shop manager. Many years ago I got a cheap set of tools and tool box with the idea that when they broke or wore out I would replace them off the truck. I have a MUCH larger box now and it has some snap-on and cornwell and even a few mac, etc., but surprisingly I still have a lot of that original set and have added some harbor freight as well. The other guys would give me a hard time over my "cheap" stuff and that was o.k. Most of my collection has been with me for decades. The harbor freight stuff that is somewhat newer, relatively speaking, works quite well and I am very pleased with it. I always smile when the other guys come to burrow my earthquake 3/8" impact driver. It got more use than most of the other drivers because everyone liked it so much "for tight spaces" It still performs just great. I am not going to knock the tool truck equipment. It has its place. You can finance your purchases, the truck comes by once a week at a regular time and day. But lets be honest those "conveniences" are not free. The driver has to make a living and I don't blame him for that. I will just say that many of the tools in my box have been there longer than many of the mechanics who have one through the snap-on, etc. which have been replaced one or more times. (in some cases many more). The way I have looked at it is to find what I feel is a good value in a tool and if it gives out on you, just replace it with one from the truck. While many folks will only purchase a tool truck brand, I see them going into debt to the driver for many thousands of dollars. I always pay cash for my tool truck purchases, because I can afford to buy a tool once in a while, thanks to the cost savings on the Harbor Freight and like tools. Maybe I have just beaten the odds but my philosophy has served me well...
Tl;dr
Well said and true. There is just too much tool vanity/ and showing off like a woman with an overpriced "designer" purse . Like I said earlier in this example The harbor frieght one is fine for the average guy for 150.00 I would buy an IR 2131ti for 250.00 But I am like you and use mine hard all the time. That IR is every bit as good or better quality than the snap on at 600.00 . The tool truck companies have an insane markup to the driver usually 100% or more then he has to do the same to carry the guy on payments at the shop. Its insane what they end up paying. But to those guys its usually about look at me and my Channel impact or Duuny and Burke wrench or my Saks 5th ave socket set basically. Yes they are very nice but not worth 5 times the price of other usa made tools imho. I was lucky i guess I grew up poor and had an auto parts that sold S&K hand tools and I soon learned why they never failed and the import wrenches/sockets broke. Again they are 1/3-1/4 the price of snap on but forged american steel hand tools.However I would buy the china 3lb hammers and xtra heavy pry bars. etc.Its all about knowing what doesnt need to be precision or strong . I would never buy a cheap china torque wrench but yet I also would never pay tool truck prices for a usa one. 1 snapped off bolt by using a uncalibrated cheapo would pay for the better american calibrated one and still be 1/3-1/4 the price of tool truck brands. Just my opinion.fwiw
Forest
Read as, "I have the attention span of a fruit fly." Or, an average human these days. SMH
I agree. I have one of these Harbor Freight XT 1/2" impact wrenches. I use it every day in a professional shop. Love checking out all these comments and watching the Snap-On fanboys get all upset because somebody didn't pay $500.00 for a wrench.
Finally someone that makes sense,,,,I actually read all of it..Well said,,way too much male EGOs out there. Idiots,,Go ahead pay more,,,for the same freaking shit.
At 500 bucks you would think Snap-On could throw in the plastic boot.
They do lol
Aquarium Samurai truuuueeeeeee
Most pussies bitch about something.
Mine did
They do the boots is in your add after you buy it.🤣
Nice job. I am heavy equip mech.32 yrs. Earthquake is winner. The impact sockets at hearbor freight do great also!
I purchased a new Earthquake XT last week and it actually came with a rubber boot cover within the box. Awesome!
This was a clean, unbiased review. Now if we could get AvE to do the teardown...
As a weekend mechanic I have been using the earthquake xt for 2 years. I oil it at the start of each day of use and it performs the same as the first day. I've had no reliability issues with it at all. For the price point it is perfect for the average backyard mechanic who doesn't need to use it day in and day out. The snap on model is much more durable being made of a solid metal housing but just isn't necessary for most unless you need it for your profession. Thanks for the great video with real tested specs!!
Really enjoyed the video. I've had my snap on mg725 for 5 years now. 3 of us run these around 140 working pressure and they last 2 to 3 years with everyday use before they blow the front seal and slowly lose power. Snap on does rebuild the entire impact for $130 which is affordable. Might recommend some of the new guys try out the earthquake to save some money.
Have the snap on and love it. Had no idea the earthquake would be so competitive. great review - thank you!
I've had one of the older, smaller Earthquakes for around 7-8yrs. It is AMAZINGLY strong to this day. Has never failed me.
yea mine is going on 20 years and i abuse it.
Test them again after 2 years of heavy use, my Snapon has never let me down even after 6 years havent even needed to rebuild it
Jay Bisky Snap on comes with lifetime warranty. ..
Real Tool Reviews said two years for this impact.
Noah Rule right I'm saying I haven't had to even send it out
Noah Rule , only hand tools get a life time warranty with snapon air tools are a max of 2 yrs
Don P I just had mine rebuilt after 6 hard years of use everyday. It's 150 bucks and snap on sends you a brand new one
Earthquake w/ 2year warranty (I've had one for 6years and it's still kicking strong)
mine has lasted 20 years! heavy dealership use and abuse
Yeah but how are they built? What materials they use inside? This is why i love when AVE does his reviews because he take the things apart and explains everything and if it’s going to last.
He also makes up words & speaks in gibberish when he doesnt understand something --- yet deletes comments from actual engineers when they question his results. Hmmmmm..... Patreon....cough......bumming money.....cough cough.....donate now....cough cough.....
Real Tool Reviews not really he actually goes and makes another video explaining where he messed up. 🤷🏻♂️ But again he lets you know if something is actually worth buying according to what’s inside
Snap On all the way! But wait, I need a loan to get it while with HF I just need a coupon. Thank you!
thank goodness TH-cam can still be used for GOOD. thanks for giving an honest non bias review.
I bought the Harbor Freight XT recently have been extremely impressed. They now come with a rubber cover. I've been wary of buying power tools from Harbor Freight because they just don't seem to last, so I was a initially bit cautious about purchasing the Earthquake XT. But it was on sale, plus they gave me 20% off, which made it right around $100, so I figured I'd bite and see how it performed. I've been pleasantly surprised. It feels good and solid in your hands and it's been able to do everything I asked, including removing some really stubborn bolts on my old Jeep. The big power dial on the back is great. It makes the settings easy to change even if you're wearing gloves. It's also surprisingly quieter than my old gun. There's no odd clanking or loose play in it anywhere, and with the rubber cover and regular oiling, I'm hoping it can last for a good long time. We'll see how it goes, but so far, no buyer's remorse.
I bought one of these earthquakes when they first came out. Use it every day in the shop. Still works great. The stubby is awesome too.
The butt hurt of the people that wasted their money on snap on air tools 😂😂
Nick G I think it's funny looking at all the idols that just call it Chinese junk after it just smashed a over priced POS snapon. Some people are pretty damn stupid. By the way our snapon truck doesn't warranty shit when it's commercial use. Go figure.
Nick G I'd rather still buy American because you KNOW it'll last much longer and you're not actively being a traitor to your country :) tell me how that earthquake is doing in 6 months ...
Oh Really? I work on trucks and never had a problem, cant blame snap-on for YOUR shitty rep when my guy will bend over backwards for me any time I need something, he even warrantys blue point for me.
+CDubs HasIt Okay, how does doing what's best for you make you a traitor to your country? Now tell me what your country has done for you to save you $400? I'll tell you, not a bloody thing. Your country doesn't give a shit about you, so you have to watch out for yourself. I am number 1 in my book, not my country, so I have to do what's best for me and not what's best for my country. And besides, if you're really worried about the tool you're buying at HF then get the 2 year warranty with it. That still means you are ahead $350, at least! And then in 6 months, if it breaks, or 24 months, you're still protected because the 24 months starts after the original 90 day warranty ends, so you actually get a warranty for 27 months. Sounds like a pretty good deal/value to me. If it breaks after that then you simply go get another one and/or get the original one repaired or both and you're still way ahead of the game even if you buy another 24 month warranty on your new tool. And if you really are a mechanic you can fix your tool because you can buy repair parts for it. Sounds like a no brainer to me! Just saying. lol
if you use H.B. airtools daily as an auto tech they won't last no more than a month. and I do oil my tools. their air ratchets are junk. snap on is better. before you knock our country remember we kicked your ass in 1776, bailed you out of 2 world wars if it wernt for Americans you would be speaking German
I got both of them. Just bought the earthquake 2 months ago when my snapon failed on a weekend while working out of town. Ran to HF and picked up one of their Earthquake XT 1/2 guns and it works great. The big dial on the back is awesome! I like reducing my power a lot especially when removing bolts with a swivel and extension so i don’t launch the socket clear across the shop if I accidentally pull the trigger a bit to hard. The big dial on the back makes that a lot simpler.
can we get these tools over to AvE for a second review???
now that.. is a great idea!
BOLTR
christian munn I'd love to see a side by side teardown!
Done!
snap-fuck makes good air tools and ratchets other tools by them are not worth the price for e screwdrivers ... for this video i would take snap on over earth quake any day ..... i love quality
I have all Snap-on-tools never have liked Harbor Freight but after watching video I might check them out and see how I like them. Thanks for a very good video.
I bought the earthquake based on this video, your results, and the price difference a year or so ago, and am very happy with it so far!
man.... i dont know what you do for a living............ but you have a voice made for speaking, and the tone is golden.... just wanted to say thanks for being a well spoken and articulate host.... and for the valuable information, well done all around !
Thanks!
Sounds like a tour guide for a museum
Reminds me of one of the characters from Big Bang theory that swapped his slacks for carharts
bruce elmore he needs to be on TV for sure
I was thinking the same thing. Very easy to understand, and he doesn't say, "Um" and "uh" every other word.
I'm a professional automotive technician and I use the earthquake xt every day and I love it. I've been impressed by it since the day I bought it
Wow! Just the review that I'm looking for! I'm a WEEKEND DIY'er and I purchased the XT a month ago for $130 to upgrade my CHF IW that I purchased 7 years ago. The CHF IW shows a bit of a lag on it's torque because of its age but still works great for the LIGHT work I do to my track vehicle, so I jumped on in on the XT because mainly for its PRICE second, its CLAIMS. Well, your tests verified it! Thank you!
Bottom line is, If I have a business that uses these tools EVERYDAY with harsh work load, I would buy the SO IW for RELIABILITY AND DURABILITY, but I'm a weekend hobbyist and I can not JUSTIFY the cost of the SNAP ON so I have to GAMBLE on the low end IW. Great job again on this "in depth" tests of these two great product! God Speed!
the way this dude says "on" is killing me
bad13luck13 I thought he was saying snap-one lol
bad13luck13 "Snap-oun".
ooooon... lol
bad13luck13 bats on the dancefloor
awnn
It's also about how many you can buy. Let's say the HF tools aren't as good for sake of argument. I can buy 4 of these EQs vs 1 of the Snapon. Even if the HF one lasts 5 years and the Snapon lasts 20 I'll still spend the same amount but out WAY less initially. Now let's talk theft. Someone takes your EQ "Well shit..." Someone takes your Snapon "HOLY FUCK ME NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!"
TexasGTO certain tools from snap on are definitely worth paying for. even their open end box wrench with flank drive won't spread like literally every other make wrench on the market. I've been a tech for 10 years and am a certified world class Tech. snap on is definitely over priced but they still have buyers why do you think that is? because they have insanely quality stuff..
They have buyers because people think the tools make them better mechanics and its just not the case. Also a lot of the UTI type tech schools push tool truck tools because they get payed too, they tell the students you need snapon because everything else wont last. plus there is much better tool company's like Proto who make much higher quality stuff then snapon for about the same price. Proto makes the best pneumatics money can buy more power, more comfort, lighter weight, better balance, and more adjustability.
Our shop has several Earthquake XT's and they are really used a ton.
I find if I want a heavy slugger I use the XT 20 volt 1/2 drive and it takes almost anything off and I have never busted a bolt either with the easy to change variable torque. I was very skeptical when I first picked one up but now I actually prefer them.
Snap on is now just riding on it's name folks.
The only downside I have seen with Earthquake is the battery release is broken on some of the tools but we have had some real morons using them as well.
I remember when you were just starting on garage journal. Good for you brother!
Thanks!
I am a mechanic like my father, He bought a lot of snap-on, Mac and so on, his tools cost more than my new car and he had a debt to these tool trucks for ever, I on the other hand never went that route, I bought Craftsman when they where made in the USA, I did buy a Ingersoll Rand 235 now that gun is about mid $200.00, I really like it, it has 1000lbs torque in reverse I love the gun. To all you new mechanics tools will be your biggest cost to your tool box buy wisely to prevent from being in debt.
The ingersoll gun is my go to, and everyone copies it. I havent spent a day in a long time without my 2135 ti in my hands.
I only have debt for my Cornwell tool boxes but then I pay off tools from any tool truck on the spot.
Ive ownes several impact guns over the last 16 years. Ingersol rand has been my favorite, the best in my opinion.
I'm a mechanic... Buy cheap shit, your coworkers will steal them anyway!!
I have been using Earthquake 1/2 inch impact since it hit the shelf for 79.00$. It was bought for an emergency roadside repair. It worked so good I now use earthquake pneumatics exclusively. For the money. The weight. The abuse on your wrist. Earthquake is the best. Thank you for and real laboratory condition test!
So as a long time owner of Snap-On including the MG725, Im not surprised by this. I'll never again spend my hard earned money on a snappy one when IR surpasses all these
plskillyourself
Instead of IR (my last one was the Thundergun) try a nitrocat 1200k, more power, less money and a whole lot quieter
I own the older Snap-On IM6500 and it just keeps on going. I think that is the key difference with Snap On and lower priced impact wrenches and tools in general. I've used my Snap On impact in a professional environment for approximately 15 years now and it has never failed to perform. While I can not speak for or against the Earthquake impact wrench specifically (and I do think it is quite impressive for the price) I found out long ago that you usually give up longevity when you purchase bargain priced tools. Yes, I've had Snap On tools fail prematurely and yes I've bought 'Chinese bargain tools' that have performed well but generally the pro tools last much, much longer and break far less often. Lets face it, when you are in the middle of an important job the money saved on a Harbor Freight tool is quickly lost in down time when it fails. Not to mention the busted knuckles and bruised ribs.
I owned the mg725 that I bought used for 80 bucks. The hammer housing cracked. So I went out and bought the earthquake and was absolutely beyond disappointed. The trigger isn't nearly as nice, it vibrates through your wrist twice as much And ya it can take off most bolts the snapon can but stubborn rusty bolts it easily takes double the amount of time to remove the bolt. This gun is perfect for the at home mechanic, not for professional use. I welded by hammer housing back together in my mg725 and kept using it and it still works great. Earthquake is just a backup now. Using an impact to do a tire rotation in your driveway and using one professionally as a flat rate mechanic the choice is obvious, spend the money and buy snapon or Ingersoll Rand
this is how a tool review should be done... you have set the bar
Darn good review, tv show quality imo.
Thanks!
👍 👍
Real Tool Review, thanks for a well informed, accurate review. I always buy two tools at less of a cost of a name brand. I always have a back up available without having to wait for the replacement item under warranty, and it improves my cash flow. Thanks for the review
what a great video!! thank you as a mechanic i want to make sure i have good tools to do a good job, and i'm thinking that the earthquake is the better tool, just doesn't have "snap on" written on it to make it cost a fortune
john waller get an IR they're better than snapon. my Kevlar air cat impact is a beast for half the price of snapon. but let's be real that harbor freight won't hold up for reliability. snapon hand tools are the best hands down but air is different.
consider aircat. I ditched my mac's for them. I got 2 aircats of each kind for less than the a single mac one.. and the come with 2 year warranty at no extra cost. I find them better than IR. I am also a big fan of astro nano for.. hard to reach places, i have both the 1822 (1/2") and 1828 (3/8") and since i only use them when i am in a hard to reach place.. am really not worried about them breaking.
yes IR and aircats are the best
It is my understanding that HF will replace (under warranty) the failed unit where as Snap-on will make you wait while it's at the repair center.
Based on past experience, the HF may be DOA out of the box. It is a good thing they will swap it on the spot. You are HF's QC department. They sure don't check them in China. That being said, I often go that route. The second one has been OK so far
mds19238 That is purely depedant on your dealer. I've had the same dealer for over 10yrs, and if it dies during warranty he will either swap it out straight away, or leave a loaner while yours is sent off.
Purchased just before your video was released with warranty, using it for something I should have been using a 1" impact, granted I torn it up, but I was back-up and running within the hour. This time with my 1" impact. Great tool for the price. Could even afford a "cold one" after the job was done. Great review.
Great review. I have the previous model Earthquake from HF, which replaced a 1990s Blue Point AT500c that died after 2 decades of abuse. The Earthquake is doing just fine. Sure is a nice chunk less expensive than the Snap On / Blue Point!. FWIW, I am considerably heavier than you, and when the impact can't do the job, I simply lean into my breaker bar. I saw your HF to snap on to others comparison of breaker bars. Mine are older, but I have both HF / Pittburgh and Snap On breaker bars without the plastic handles. My results are similar to yours at considerably higher torque. (370lb operator on the end of a 24" tool, you do the math...)
The biggest thing here is that Harbor Freight has REALLY stepped up their game over the past few years in particular. I am not sure I would rely on their stuff if I made my primary income with them, but for side work, home hobbyist, or iffy shop / jobsite conditions where tools have bad odds of growing feet and walking off and Harbor Freight becomes VERY appealing...
Great Test RTR!
I worked at an auto recycling yard, we punished these guns day in and day out. With the dirtiest of compressed air supply Harbor Freight Earthquake Impacts will rattle off the toughest nut year after year. "The best bang for your buck!"
Great vid. Just bought an Earthquake XT for axle/spindle nuts on a truck. Broke them loose no problem. Clicked 150 ft lbs on a Tq wrench. Lowest setting didn't move much, if any from 150ft lbs. Used the cotter pin hole as a reference and marked nut, to measure movement. Then on 2nd setting, turned the nut 1/8-1/4 in. Close to 290 ft lbs, I hope. Front end feels solid.
True there is the big price/quality thing. For a home garage, get the cheap stuff, but if this is a business that can not afford down time like a mechanic's garage or an assembly line in a plant, you want something that will last years without failing. Just shutting a line down for 20 minutes while maintenance replaces a tool can cost hundreds of dollars in manufacturing that day. Likely though the Snap-on one is also serviceable and can be fixed by simply replacing a few O-rings.
Every time the shop I worked for tried to save money on tools and such they usually turned out losing money in the long run. Even a simple thing like a screw presenter (you manufacturing guys might know of these), they tried $400 all the way up to $1500 ones. The $400 would last maybe a week and would require maintenance regularly and would fall apart after a year tops. The $1500 was indestructible and lasted 10+ years with little maintenance. That is the difference between a Milwaukee heat gun that will run 20,000 hours compared to a Tool Shop one that lasts 50 hours... $200 vs $20. Which one will cost more in the long run? Same thing with things like drill bits. Do you spend $20 on a cheap set or $20 on one good drill bit.
Long story short it is not the specs but the reliability that is important for industrial/business use. Remember time is money.
Todd Abbott I'd be curious what the serviceability is with the HF.
I doubt any. The Snap-on though looks to have a large metal plate on the back with a rubber seal and 4 allen bolts that lets you rebuild it. They likely sell cheap rebuild kits with o-rings and such to service hem. This way say annually they can have them rebuilt during downtime or rotate through inventory so these things will last for 25 years or more.
Too many people always gravitate to the cheapest crap out there. I am not saying Snap-on is the best or worth the price. there might be other better companies out there, but there is something called brand recognition and loyalty. These things exist for a reason. As a consumer I know Harbor Freight petals a lot of cheap junk, while Snap-on is good, but expensive. If I was a company, though, I would spend more money for quality and reliability in a heartbeat. For a casual user... buy what you can afford, but understand that you might be buying another one in a few years. If you have the money than get the good stuff.
Not entirely disagreeing...but for the price of the HF you can have a spare for every one you have in service and still be $200 to the good of the snap-on.
Yes but many products can not stand up to the use a shop or factory will throw at them. The frustration of cheap tool is horrible for an assembly line. Time is money. You cut costs on material going into products as long as they still work and pass the tests, but tooling has to cycle sometimes thousands of times a day and last 10+ years. A cheap Harbor Freight pneumatic screwdriver might last a month... more than most home users would ever using in a lifetime, but that means they might go through 100+ cheap drivers in the life of that assembly line.
I managed to take home several leftover tools from lines that were discontinued and they deemed the tools not worth salvaging. Even these beat up tools are 10x better that buying a cheap tool at HF. My favorite is a Milwaukee heat gun. This thing is probably 25 years old, been dropped 1000 times, been cycled over 100,000 times, and probably run for a couple of years of on time and it still works great.
All in All ~ My Opinion.... It ALL comes down to Name and how Big Your Wallet is.... I'm a Power Transmission Technician of 30+ yrs. It's been known for yrs. that "Snap-On" (HAD) the best Tool & Wrench Warranty = LIFE TIME... Most of My Tools ARE "Snap-On". But when Grey (Heavy Tool) & Craftsman/Mastercraft (Almost the same LQQK as Snap-On) Offered the SAME LIFE TIME Warranty. My Hand Tools Started to become a Mixture of Snap-On & Craftsman/Mastercraft. Why??? NOT LQQKING at $Price$ like most Mechanic's are not really concerned with cost (We're LQQKING for a TOOL that will Last and Not let us down (BREAK) during a Repair)... My Own Experience became.... You can buy a Brand New Shiny & Expensive "Snap-On" Tool Grrr8. (BUT) if that Tool Breaks You have to wait until MONDAY when the Snap-On Truck Shows up to Replace it. Buy a Brand New Craftsman/Mastercraft Tool Grrr8 too. (BUT) if that Tool Breaks you can jump in Your Car and go to the Closest Canadian Tire/Sears Store and get a Replacement. (As long as it's not a Specialty Tool). As far as an Impact Gun? I've had em' ALL... My Favorite Impact Gun is the one that most Old School Mechanic's use. (Ingersoll Rand) It's Durable, Stronger than a Snap-On and they "NEVER" Die!!! Lmao. Again, ALL in ALL it all comes down to how much $$$ you have to Spend on Tools... Are You buying Tools to LQQK Impressive to your Co-worker's or Friends (i.e. $8,400 +++ on a Snap-On Rolling Tool Box???). OR Buying Tools that will get the Job done and will be Affordable and Last??? I Bought My Tools based on Longevity.... I still have ALL My Snap-On, Grey, Craftsman/Mastercraft and even Professional today... My Opinion. I'm very Impressed with this Video (it's a Grrr8 Comparison) BUT, Myself from Experience I'd Buy the Ingersoll Rand that probably sell in the Range of $450.00 and up.
Grrr8 Video "Real Tool Reviews" :)
The next impact I buy will be an Earthquake XT when my Ingersol Rand gives up the ghost. BTW, excellent video and very fair to both brands.
I bought the Earthquake when I was changing the torque converter on my Ford Edge. It worked great for all my needs during that time. With the cost savings with the coupon and the extended warranty, I feel this was a great buy for a shade tree mechanics needs. This was a great review, regardless of some of the idiotic comments below. I really appreciate the time you put into this.
This is like the tortoise and the hare scenario. Snap-on has been riding their reputation and not changing, improving or innovating much. Companies like Harbor Freight have been catching up or surpassing their competition by making their product as good or better for a fraction of the cost.
I'm thankful for videos like this that demonstrate both tools abilities and dispell some of the stereotypes between the brands. Snap-on should be worried as they're the hare right now and the race is long.
Send some to @AvE and lets see how skookum the interiors are compared to one another.
Aron Hall-Terraciano focus you fack...
Aron Hall-Terraciano but really I was thinking this the entire time. I know the snap-on will out last that harbor freight tool. Just curious to see how horrible the machining and casting inside it is to hit that price point.
Yeah but will it chooch?
But, will the dick snapper outlast 3 harbor friggers?
son of a diddley
A fair and informative comparison, no hype and no hidden agenda.
i have them both. Been using the snap on mg725 for years and now I bought the xt and keep that one on my cart instead. snap on's become my "backup." My mac dealer had the boots to the old ingersoll titanium 2135ti and it fits the XT perfectly. so between buying the gun for $119, extended warranty was like $35 and a boot for $25, i'm still hundreds less. anytime it couldnt get a bolt off, I'd switch to the snap on to see if it'd get it. it failed everytime too.
My IR takes it out or breaks it, just the way i like it. Never in 39 years has it not removed or broke it trying to. If it's bad enough to break coming out it needed replaced anyway.
I almost purchased the earthquake yesterday but I decided to wait until I heard more about it. Now I am kicking myself that I didn't purchase it yesterday. Thanks for the comparison tests because now my mind is definitely made up, go Harbor Freight. 😎
I bought the earthquake to rebuild the front end on my 2000 Suburban. No complaints from me. It did everything I asked it to. Out standing video.
I have to say..I love harbor freight...I always felt snap on is totally over priced. I'm no rich man trying to have the best name tools ..I'm a family man with bills n I like to save money. my harbor freight and craftsman do me just fine. people say your only as good as your tools... that's Bs. I do just as good of work if not better then most garages in my area. because I'm not one of those " it will be fine" that way.. I make sure it's done right the first time.. and at the end of the day..I made more money to keep then shell out for snapon name.. ty for this video..keep them coming.
The tools don't make the mechanic, but they sure make the job easier.
Hence the reason your living pay check to pay check. I know its a hard lesson to learn, but Snap-on tools are worth their price. You will eventually learn this, or ended up in the lower pay scale where they seem like a luxury item.
Break the Snap on and wait for the replacement, crap out the Earthquake go get another. I'm still waiting for Snap on to replace a hook scribe from 2010!
TractorMan104 that's for sure. my HF red earthquake gets used and abused on a daily basis with no lube due to techs that don't like lubing it and still lasts a hell of a long time. I can go down to HF and grab a replacement with no hassle.
TractorMan104 I'm still waiting for a freakin snap on wobble socket that I sent in 3 weeks ago.
You must have a bad Snapon guy.
Squatch Hammer yeah he sucks.
If you have a Snap On truck in your area, they usually take good care of their customers. Still though, you've got to wait. Or take the Earthquake to Harbor Freight and have a new tool the same day. And the employees are Harbor Freight will NEVER argue with you and couldn't care less why it doesn't work anymore. You're getting a new tool. lol
I recently bought the Earthquake XT for $25 on sale. Yes, Twenty Five Dollars. I use it with a tiny 8gallon compressor and It’s amazing even with that. If you’re looking to buy this, it’s seriously a great product
This was a great video! I honestly thought the Snap On was going to destroy the competition but I was pleasantly surprised.
When it comes to buying tools by brand, what matters is longevity, and it's application. If you buy a Snap On tool, you know that you're getting a quality product that you'll get tons of use out of, but it's gonna cost you.
Harbor Freight tools are better suited for at home for something that's handy to have e around. They don't break the budget, and some of their stuff is surprisingly good. But I always avoid their expendable items, like sandpaper or drill bits. They aren't worth it.
There are other great tool brands out there as well. A lot of Kobalt's tools look so similar to Snap On's, and I've been damn pleased with everything of theirs I've bought. Another awesome often overlooked brand is S-K. They cost a premium as well, but they're 100% American made (they claim to be the only tool manufacturer left to be). My dad has a bunch of old S-K tools on his farm for decades that have held up to a ton of abuse and still work just fine.
Craftsmen...that's just a sad story. They're a shadow of their former self. I remember if you broke a tool, you could walk up to the counter in Sears and they would grab you a new one off the shelf. No questions asked. Now, they interrogate you, require 3 forms of ID, and a video of what you were doing that caused the tool to break. But if you want a decent Craftsmen, you can shell out the cash for their "Professional" line. Craftsmen used to be just Craftsmen...a great tool with a kickass warranty. Now Pittsburgh Tools has them beat. At least they don't claim to be the best out there.
very well stated!
wartooth6 i can actually walk up to the sears in houston & get warranty's no questions asked just take the socket or messed up wrenches but they actually rebuild them now before they used to be off the shell lol just a month ago i took 5 messed up wrenches & got them replace in 15 mins
ToyotaRacing
Dennis Hewitt Dennis Hewitt
u have a sears craftmen is fadding from my tool box as
Great no B.S. comparison. Between those two I would go with the Earthquake along with an extended warranty. I just can't justify the Snap on price tag, and yes I own quite a few of their tools. Albeit for now with all the options out there I will just stick with my tried and true Ingersoll Rand.
Got my mg725 on eBay for $200 used in good condition and it’s done anything I’ve needed it to do working on heavy duty trucks. The main selling point for me is the ability to rebuild your impact if it takes a shit, and the snap on truck comes to my shop weekly. I would be curious to see a working test on these impacts to see how long they each hold up being used daily.
Ingersoll Rand is my favorite Impact never have had a problem
Jacob Budke My Matco 1/2" gun is about ten years old, I've put about three drops of oil in it since I've owned it and it keeps on cranking. It's a rebranded Ingersoll Rand.
Mine too. I got the 2135Ti. Bought it back in 2003 and even crushed it under a lift. Just had to replace the composite body and it's still kicking.
i used 1 for a few years, and i agree, best impacts ever. We now have a snapon thing at my job and i dont really like it. It makes lots of noise but dosn't seem as strong. Its a pain in the ass to get to a lower power level, and it only seems to go at 1 speeds wich is full speed. With the ingersoll rand you had some feel to the trigger and could spin it at a low speed by just pressing a little and it worked great. And that thing got everything loose without a problem. And if it would you would snap a half inch drive on it anyway.
One of the best things I like about it, other than what you said above, is that the forward and reverse controls are on the back of the impact and can easily be used with my thumb. Unlike both impacts in this video.
Jacob Budke I have ingersoll and snap on. ingersoll is great even at 10years old. if it can't do it my snap on will. snap on is twice as much. :(
Ive been wanting this video!! Thank you, love your reviews. that ive. seen so far.
Purchasing the XT next week.
Boysya Thanks for that info ill go today.
Boysya Ok again thank you ill look for the coupon. Much appreciated.
rcsix3rd
HF is getting stingy with 20% coupon use and there is a ever growing list of exceptions. I believe anything in the Earthquake series is on the list. That means that to get a discount you have to wait for a Super Coupon that is for the particular Earthquake tool you want. This also applies to all jacks and compressors.
8 years as a full time tech at a chevy/subaru dealer I have 6 harbor freight air tools and 2 have been replaced 1 was in 90 day warranty I paid 12 bucks for a die grinder that lasted me 7 years you just can't beat HF sometimes my impacts are craftsman professional and are also 8 years old IR built and have held up well it all comes down to maintaining the tool oil it and don't use it like an idiot and chances are it will last quite a while I despise snap on air tools but I have damn near the entire SO 14.4 cordless setup with 6 batteries it all depends on what you are using the tools for every day this channel is great created an account just to subscribe to it :)
Why anyone continues to buy overpriced Snap-on tools is a mystery.
Because if you use these tools daily, after 7 or 8 years, you will have spent the same amount of money re buying the HF tool as you would have if you just spent the money to begin with.
@@punk303 can you show proof of that? Because thats another spiel the snap on guy always throws out...
HF has lifetime warranty 🤷🏽♂️
@@punk303 I have S.O. tools and Tools from H.F.. Some of the HF shit has outlasted the S.O.. A lot of the time the S.O. tool truck is a dick about replacement as well. I no longer buy S.O. tools because their quality equals price motto is just a spiel.
ONLY if Snap-on has the ONLY tool that can do the job. But I will never pay $$$ for a tool that a $ can do.
SWEET! Can you test the Earthquake XT Stubby 1/2" impact?
From my experience using tools from all different vendors I found that claiming the warranty from tools that are sold out of tool trucks are almost impossible to claim. However, I have to understand that the tool trucks are privately owned franchises and they have to take on the initial cost of honoring a warranty. I think there is still something good to be said about having a brick-and-mortar location in today's web market place. Thank you for doing these videos.
Ive used the original earthquake for two years in a shop. I use it all day long at home. Never a single problem. Also use it as a hammer. Heavy but strong.
I have two of the older Earthquare 1/2" impacts. Still running strong many years later. I thought about upgrading to their newer impact (reminds me more of the IR style impact) but why should I if my older units are still chooching along?
You shouldn't, if you want to blow your money on something you can send it to me.
Use good tool oil. I switched to Matco oil and got another six months. My Earthquake may be dead from using HF fluid.
So cool how this guy just compares both tools and don't judge either one but lets us the viewers decide.
i dont even own a air compressor or any snap or earthquake tools...what am i doing here
loll
same
Didn't need to read past "i dont even own a air compressor"::D
Just being a nuisance haha
LOL! I wonder if I'm arguing with people about tools on this channel, when they don't even own anything to run them and have no experience! ROTFL!
At the price difference you could buy 2 earthquakes with a huge amount of extra tools
Agree, I'd buy two HF's at half the price of one snap on. I'd have a back up immediately available to finish the job should it fail. If I had a snap on, I'd be out of service until a replacement is sent or delivered via truck, or figuring some workaround. Disappointed customer. Besides, two HB at half the price of a snap on means I can splurge on lunch m
you can always take it back to HF and exchange it if it breaks...
Did u hast the prices? U could buy 3 and 1/2 HB for the price of one snap on paper weight
@@pamancave1150 or you could go on ebay and get a used snap on and get a tool that will actually last. I got the EQ and the pos broke within a week.
tonymengela 4
I have a tool box full of different tools and some cost more than I would have liked and some cost less than what some would call brand name but all do the job to my satisfaction. I own several HF tools including an earthquake model air rachet that I cannot say enough about. It works! Never fails. Best air rachet I've ever owned. Additionally all of my HF tools have continued to serve me well.
So, Harbor freight's warranty is simply price. :-) I can buy 4 of them for the price of the snap-off. :-)
Harbor Freight is comin to Getcha..!!
I have the Earthquake XT, I use it for full time small engine repair. It is a beast. I run it at the proper 90 psi on a 30 gal 175 psi compressor, 3/8 hose and 1/4 fittings. For the price, you cant beat it. Now if you want something that will last, an IR titanium might last longer. Both a great options, just depends on how heavily its used.
I realize you published this video quite some time ago but I just watched it for the first time. Excellent job, IMO. You obviously did plenty of research and figured out just how to do a side-by-side comparison “by the numbers” which appeared (is, IMO) completely unbiased. I have seen other comparisons which I would call far less objective. The claim I have frequently heard is that Snap-On has superior build quality and given the price difference, it should. I’d like to see some kind of a durability test for products like these but it would be a more costly exercise as the sample size would need to be much larger to due to variability between individual tools.
I do not have either of these impact guns. I have a pneumatic Mastercraft unit from Canadian Tire (I live in Canada). I believe it is a rebranded IR unit but not certain. I also have a Mastercraft electric impact unit. I don’t use these units often but when I need them, they are invaluable. More recently, I have found myself wanting an impact gun but not wanting to fiddle with a compressor and hose or a cord. I frequently use a cordless impact driver in these circumstances with a socket adapter. I may have to use a breaker bar to get something started but after that: it works well enough.
I have come across some of your other videos on occasion and generally found them to be excellent as well. I have decided to stop finding then by accident and subscribe to your channel. Keep up the good work.
What do you mean durability test? Are you planning on accidentally hitting it with a hammer? Or inadvertently throwing it across the shop?
Love me
@@zatrogamer why be a douchebag? You know what he means. Durability on a day to day use basis. smh
OK, guys, here's the deal. I can speak to this because I worked 20+years as a certified tech and even ran my own shop, worked for a company that sold high end construction tools (a H.F. mainstay) around the corner from Harbor Freight where wife is a manager and has worked there 12 years over which time I've brought home a LOT of H.F. tools and, of course, many thousands of dollars in Snap On, Mac and Matco told as well. Here's what many years and lots of shop hours has tought me, having thrown my share of broken tools across the shop.
The observation that Harbor Freight has steadily increased overall quality and product lines is true. The fact that some of their stuff is, and always will be, not worth bringing home is true BUT not nearly the quantity of their items are bad as used to be.
What's the solution??
First, use some common sense. Don't expect to pay 20 bucks for a tool and expect it to hold up like a $150 tool. But...
Some of the H.F. tools WILL last for a reasonable life span if you don't punish and abuse your tools. Some times you can buy three or four HF tools for the price of on big name. But how do you decide?
The rules are pretty simple. Remember that H.F. tools are cheaper for a reason. lighter, lesser quality materials means a shorter working life and a more fragile tool. They don't take being dropped and pushed too their limit very long.
First, look at the tool and how its built and do a little due diligence as to a particular tool, if it holds up, what is the cost compared to the name brand, etc.
Second, if you have the luxury of being able to head off and replace a tool if something breaks or quits in the middle of a job OR if you buy a backup (or two) because it's cheap enough then buy the H.F. presuming it will do the job in the first place.
If a busted tool will stop production and put you in a real bind, like working in a high production shop or high stress job then spend the big dollars. Don't be afraid to try them, just have realistic expectations of what to expect.
Most importantly, though, and especially if you're buying a power tool, BUY THE WARRANTY. There is usually a 90 day standard warranty but for a couple bucks extra you can get a one or two year warranty and even if you run over your tool with a semi they will replace it. Just keep your receipt!!!
Just got the XT. Haven't been able to use it much just to take a couple lug nuts off but it's quieter than my currently broken ingersoll rand which I've had for 10 years and has been bullet proof and powerful this whole time. Hopefully will get my many years of use out of this XT. If not, will be going back to my good old IG.
I've saved a ton of money maintaining and repairing my own vehicles BECAUSE I can afford the Harbor Freight version of the unobtanium tool. It's a no brainer for me.
Yes, I get where you are coming from. Much easier to 'pay yourself' for working on your own vehicles with a cheap tool you use infrequently (but will now have for future use) than to drop $500 on one tool. Might as well pay the mechanic at that point - would probably be cheaper and is definitely easier. As a professional (general contractor, carpenter and woodworker), I do love my high quality tools though! There IS a difference in build-quality and when it is a write-off as well, that is my no-brainer... :D
This must be the best in depth review on the planet. For the average diyer, Harbour Freight wins, no competition !! Top class value and top class review.
I agree. I'm only interested in the ability to LOOSEN bolts with an impact gun. You should use a torque wrench to tighten the bolts afterwards, so I couldn't care a hill of beans over the forward impact force. HF wins with the variable impact force on reverse.
Using an impact driver to tighten bolts will strip threads and snap bolts. There's a reason why manufacturers specify torque values in the owners manuals!!!
If you're a "professional" that doesn't care about the customers property, then it's not something to worry about if you torque the lug nuts of his wheels to 450 ft lbs. The average car owner/property owner DOES care.
It's amazing the tests you put these 2 impact guns. I'm really impressed... Time to go read my Harbor Freight mag.