ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 พ.ค. 2024
- What are we teaching our children? This panel takes the fight out of the classroom, PTA, and school board meeting and brings it to real life. From sex ed to critical race theory, parents, teachers, and students hash out the most controversial topics in our K-12 schools.
00:00 Intro
00:49 The Purpose of Education
02:45 Who Should Decide What’s Being Taught?
09:58 Home School vs Private School vs Public School
21:48 Sex Education
24:46 Critical Race Theory (CRT)
35:47 US History
38:10 Where Do We Go From Here?
Watch more like this:
Minorities Debate Skin Bleaching, Appropriation and Colorism
• Minorities Debate Colo...
Gun Owners & Users Debate America’s Gun Problem
• Gun Owners & Users Deb...
"Be A Man”: Modernists and Traditionalists Debate Masculinity
• 'Be A Man': Modernists...
Click here to subscribe to VICE: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-VICE
About VICE:
The Definitive Guide To Enlightening Information. From every corner of the planet, our immersive, caustic, ground-breaking and often bizarre stories have changed the way people think about culture, crime, art, parties, fashion, protest, the internet and other subjects that don't even have names yet. Browse the growing library and discover corners of the world you never knew existed. Welcome to VICE.
Connect with VICE:
Check out our full video catalog: bit.ly/VICE-Videos
Videos, daily editorial and more: vice.com
More videos from the VICE network: www. vicevideo
Click here to get the best of VICE daily: bit.ly/1SquZ6v
Like VICE on Facebook: vice
Follow VICE on Twitter: / vice
Follow us on Instagram: / vice
Follow us on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@vice?lang=en
The VICE TH-cam Network:
VICE: / vice
MUNCHIES: / munchies
VICE News: / vicenews
VICELAND: / vicelandtv
Vice Life: / broadly
Noisey: / noisey
Motherboard: / motherboardtv
VICE Sports: / noc
i-D: / idmagazine
Waypoint: / waypointvice
#debate #education - บันเทิง
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 63 | คู่เอก "ยอดภูผา vs โซเนอร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RGVmBsegKEI/mqdefault.jpg)
WATCH NEXT: A diverse panel debates the root of colorism and its impact today. - th-cam.com/video/Nzn2f9FVuKo/w-d-xo.html
Good stuff Vice!
A fetish is not an identity 🆔
just came from ur vid on andrew tate and u have comments allowed here but not on that vid? You guys are so bs lmao this the last time i click on a vice vid
VICE...I've posted this on several videos in this panel series...the short cut is great and we appreciate the content. However, it's clear that there's more footage. These panels are great! Why don't you let us, YOUR VIEWERS, benefit from the having access to the entire conversation? Can you not release both?
This discussion is the epitome of "we need a discussion about this discussion about this...." Only a couple of the people in here talked about real-world applications. The rest was useless posturing.
as someone who was homeschooled, when protecting your child from the “bad world” you’re just leaving your child unprepared for the real world
A sheltered child makes a soft adult
1000% agree!!!👏🏼👏🏼
I agree, I was homeschooled up until 8th grade and it was one of the worst things that I ever went through. There needs to be more oversight when it comes to homeschooling.
VEEY WELL SAID!
Not necessarily. I think it’s all about the approach/execution
I think the problem is- parents don’t realize that just because you raise your kids one way doesn’t mean that your kids won’t experience life outside of your beliefs and eventually change what they believe.
Beautifully written!!!
Of course they do. Parents were kids once. They just want their children to have certain core values
@@thehater6189
You don’t get to DEMAND that your kids have certain core values. Thats entitled and problematic.
@JaySlayz4Dayz what? No, I'm definitely going to demand that my children be brave, kind and strong willed. Im going to demand they are not liars or cheats either. Problematic would be just letting children do whatever they want. Absolutely not. I come from a long line of real ones.
@@JaySlayz4DayzI’m just curious what do you think your role as parent is then? and if you aren’t a parent what is a parents responsibility when it comes to raising their child?
I’m surprised I don’t see comments praising the high school girl! For being much younger and a current student who is affected by the things being discussed/decisions adults make around/for her education, she was very well spoken and had great comments contributing to the conversation! At her age I don’t think I would’ve been as confident and knowledgeable esp around a group of adults in a discussion like this
I think she's great! Very bright young person. Gives me hope for the future. 🖖
Wait ✋ I thought she was a teacher 🙈😄 , just a really young one
The real problem is that parents aren’t disciplining their bad, spoiled kids and encouraging them to do better academically, so they hold all the other good students back (due to limited resources and time). I was the quiet kid and I can remember many times feeling genuine sympathy for my overwhelmed teachers whenever the troubled kids wouldn’t stop being clowns and wasting everyone’s learning time. Teachers aren’t babysitters or daycare workers. It’s getting worse and worse and that’s a huge reason why many educators are quitting.
completely missed the point -
@@quicktoreason2722nope shes not
@@quicktoreason2722no they didn't. Majority of Parents won't even show up for school planning events. To be clear, I'm only speaking about my district. Which is a bottom 10 district in the nation. And we have one of the only school boards that are actually paid. For reference they make about 30,000 a year. This year we just started talking about disassembling the school board. Our city got roughly 80 million. Parents wouldn't even show up to vote on where that money should be spent for their kids in the city. No after school programs came back. And we are closing down 11 schools. Those schools have the most IEPs and 504s. Which means next year some classrooms in the elementary schools will have 40 to 60 students in them. Not to mention the teacher shortage. There are many contributing factors. The terrible parenting is the root cause of a lot of issues in the classroom right now. We can't even get to discussing what the kids should be learning. Because it's not a learning environment anymore. I'm the parent teacher liaison for my son's school. These last two years have been very trying to say the least. (In full disclosure, my son was private schooled the majority of his life. We switched to public school because of a robotics program he loves. The program he's in at his public school still places him in a different "education system" than the rest of the school. Because it's an international program. 93% of his school academically does not qualify). My son is not a straight a student not even close. He just has parents who Ask to see his grades and make time to teach him how to study.
terrible parenting? Are you in their shoes? Parents shouldnt have to feel the need to constantly be checking on the school board to make good decisions but now with all the mess that the board has done, parents have to. While juggling to survive in this environment where both parents are required to work to make a decent living wage to even get by. most parents are working paycheque to paycheque - and now on top of that already demanding commitment they have to also baby sit the school board. The very fact that you think people are terrible parents because you have the privilege to find time to go and be more involved shows how disconnected from reality you are. Considering your kid was "private schooled" proves my point exactly. Its like those new mothers who suddenly act like they know what all baby's are about and how they know more than everyone else. crazy. Your lived experience is just that, your lived experience. not everyone is on that same boat - The problem here is the Unionized teachers that feel like they are impenetrable. Teachers unions needs to be abolished and we need better access to teachers that actually want to teach kids things that they can further their future with. None of this sexualized education, just important subjects that actually matter.
@@datarock57
@@quicktoreason2722 I have taught in schools of different academic levels in both private and public sector. The role of teacher is a job, and everyone capable would like jobs that's secure (unless it pays really well). Abolishing unions would simply make the entire profession felt unprotected and lose a ton of members. I think you can call for adjustments in the way unions work, but abolishing is going to destroy the local education system. (I'm not in US so I don't know any further but I'm sure that prediction is a reasonably foreseeable outcome.)
On the topic of parents involvement, parenting is a natural responsibility. In majority of species in the animal kingdom, the young learn to hunt, to run, to socialise from their family. They also learn values and attitudes from the same source. Children from families that values education usually out-performs the other end of the spectrum in academics and beyond curriculum achievements. Not because they are somehow more talented, but because their family have cultivated a habit of valuing and committing to learn. It has nothing to do with family income, some of the most committed parents I've known are Asian immigrants with low income jobs. Those believe education is the most reliable way to a brighter future and so they would encourage their child to commit into learning. It does not take much extra time or money to let your children know you care about their wellbeing and future.
If taking 20-30 minutes a day to have chat, to let the children feel that they are loved, to help them organise their progress, to praise them for trying to improve are too much to ask for, I think they shouldn't have had any child or they deserved to be blamed as a 'terrible parent'.
Teach students how to think. Not what to think. Always question, be curious, and never stop learning.
The best and most mature comment.
too bad conservative parents who want to homeschool or do homeschool won't take this into consideration
@@MsDudette21 also it is really important to have children experience group dynamics! not everyone has the money to send them to a sport club 3 times a week & also schools are so much more diverse & better at preparing them for the average ppl they will interact with later
@@MsDudette21 too bad that liberals want to teach children what to think and not how to think.
@@michaellovullo7363 the most educated states are also the ones that vote blue. The least educated are the ones that vote red. Stay mad loser
I actually applaud vice's attempt to have civil discussions from different opinions.
We need more of this.
I think they are finally trying to be fair after being called out multiples times for not being objective. I will give them the credit on this one though, hopefully they realized their fucks ups
Vice is a bs page they are one sided lmao
Really? :/ Getting a bunch of ignorants to spread misinformation without context. It would be more of a civil and educational discussion if it actually had educated people like college professors and Drs to speak on such topics or at the very least a fact checker in the room to shut down the misinformation being spread.
...Like the bereft vermin saying "the British ended slavery", like the enslaved people didn't revolt and free themselves, they kept revolting, fighting back the colonisers ( the British, French, Spanish, Dutch etc). The African-Haitian people had just defeated the colonisers, which helped in forcing the British to sign papers, largely because the British are sneaky and wanted to pay themselves, as they made sure they paid the enslavers reparations and not the once enslaved (sickeningly, African-Haitians and Black British people for e.g were forced to pay the enslavers reparations and not the other way around for their enslavement). Also, since those papers were signed, the British and the French and virtually all the coloniser nations, have used neo colonialist tactics to keep the once enslaved Black nations oppressed, like in places like the Caribbean, where even the British monarchy is still the head of state, once enslaved nations to this day, their head of office still a British coloniser.
Pretty sad how closed minded, the generations that say they seek more open minds. We do celebrate conversations like this.
One one my biggest pet peeves with homeschooling is that most parents absolutely do not have the knowledge to teach high school level classes. I'm an engineer with a master's degree in bioengineering: I can teach my high schooler Honors class levels in both math and biology. Can I teach honors level history, chemistry, english? No. No one can boast to have advanced knowledge in all subjects enough to teach on all subjects and not harm their child's learning. Parents need to communicate with their kids at home on social issues and religious beliefs, but don't fool yourselves homeschoolers: your children do learn less than mine.
Its called cyber school. Get a clue
@@jonnyfendi2003 If you say so, but don't forget that unlike what most people like to believe, not all opinions are equal. There is a reason humans gather in places of knowledge and share ideas: this is how we are wired to learn, for the most part. My experience in middle class American has shown me that not many people can successfully teach above elementary grade levels and this is a generous assumption on most people.
Just this for an example: I hired a PhD candidate to tutor my son in mathematics online twice a week: he still learns better in school than with her, even though she is highly qualified. It's the setting that makes the difference and he is 15. Also, has straight As in all subject with honors classes in math, biology, honors and literature.
Exactly, most homeschoolers don't have a mother who's an ex-teacher
I am a psych major with minors in family studies and business management. My 9 year old is home schooled and is doing a 3 year course of classes on Vet Science, has put in 200 hours of volunteer work at a local animal shelter and also volunteers at a vet clinic. Assists surgeries, gives oral meds. She can do the math to determine meds based on an animal's weight and the recommendation for the med. And then physically give it to them. Including anesthesia. She is also taking a 2 year series of courses on marine biology that will culminate with a camp in another country. She has done 3 years of Spanish, as well as ASL and Latin. She has just stated volunteering reading at a toddler group. She goes to lessons on finances with a local investment banker who gives kids lessons. I do about 20 hours a week of one on one education with her outside of what I outsource. Homeschooling does not mean the parent is the only transmitter of the education. I am not a science pro and my second language is French.. Atleast not natural sciences. I don't need to be as a homeschool parent. I just need to facilitate my child's education and outsource as needed and wanted. Oh, by the way she has a 10th grade reading level at last standardized testing over the summer. If she was in public school she would be in 3rd grade. Please tell me what more she would be learning in school.
@@raes8520 My point exactly: you are a psych major and highly educated. Most people I see on these panels are not and do not have the capacity to educate their children like you do. Also, you mentioned she is 9 years old and reads at a 10 grade level, which is wonderful and in line with your own education, but I respectfully doubt you would be qualified to teach 10th grade math, chemistry and physics, just as I would not be able to teach english literature. We all have our own areas of expertise and there is a limit to what a single person can do in regards to teach advanced notions. I am sure your daughter is doing wonderful now, but she does have a highly educated mother to teach her.
The very idea of giving teachers an opportunity to not talk about slavery as a part of American history is baffling to me. You are depriving students of the truth when you exclude certain topics from education.
OMG MRS POMEROY WAS MY FRESHMAN ENGLISH TEACHER! I’m so shocked to see her on here. She was pregnant with her first kid while teaching us and decided to be a stay at home mom after. So happy to see her on here, I’ll never forget reading Romeo and Juliet with her ❤
That's so cool!
I am an elementary teacher in a public school. The topic of “indoctrination” really makes me frustrated. I work at an urban school in a neighborhood where students are predominantly lower income. We have a large percentage of our school below grade level and unable to read. This “indoctrination” everyone talks about is not a core issue and isn’t happening at any school in my city. Can we talk about how to help these struggling students, low attendance rates, lack of parental involvement. I teach kindergarten and over half my class is NOT prepared for school in many aspects. Parental involvement is crucial to a child’s success.
Thank you
As a person of color the "indoctrination" fou feel is non existent is actually a highly effective way to enslave the minds of my people. I see people so indoctrinated that they don't know if they are a male or female, think they're American, have no knowledge of what they're nationality is and believe they are black or African American. They also after graduating can't build a house, grow food, cook, sew, not know that herbs are medicine, etc. This actually makes you dumb and cripples you. Seperation is necessary we need our own curriculum. We dont even speak our Native tongue which further pushes us away from each other instead of binding us.
I can tell you, as a person fresh out of high school, that indoctrination is a BIG ongoing issue in my old school and many in my community.
Many teachers fail to keep their political beliefs and personal lives out of the classroom, and there are more teachers constantly telling or emotionally manipulating students into sharing the same political beliefs as them than those who don't.
These include topics such as abortion, lgbtq+, political parties, racism, sexism, oppression, social topics, and many social events as they happened (the students' opinions on them)
I had a few teachers who openly racist, mostly against white people or students who made racist comments about white people without being reprimanded or punished in any way.
I had many teachers put students against each other on political and social debates where students were encouraged by teachers to manipulate and shame others into agreeing with the popular opinion or teacher's opinion. Some teachers even participated in shaming students who didn't agree with views. For instance, shaming students who didn't believe trans should be allowed in the bathroom of their choice.
It was such a sickening environment in that aspect, and this type of thing is more prevalent than people think. It needs to stop.
I whole heartedly agree with parental involvement. I tried to be meaningfully involved with my son in the public school system... Let me clarify what I mean by being "meaningfully involved": Simply asking every teacher what curriculum they are using, so I can follow along at home. When I asked this simple question, I was ignored or simply pointed to the education standards by the state. It was like these teachers had no idea what the word "curriculum" means.
My local education system is not set up for meaningful parental involvement in my opinion. It's set up and encouraged for parents to join PTA, so they can chaperone dances and bring teachers muffins. Those are probably nice extras, but I'm a single mom, and I don't have time for fru-fru. I want to know the meat and potatoes of what my son is being presented with in school. It's so frustrating that this basic request is being treated like it's coming from a 3-headed alien. It's why I pulled my son out of public school despite being a product of it myself.
I can imagine that teachers spend A LOT of time trying to "redirect" and address problematic behavior in the classroom. My district's approach to discipline was laughable. If the parents feel the pain of their misbehaved children (meaning they have consequences themselves) we will see behavior change and schools improve.
Literally. We don’t have time to indoctrinate kids, we’re to busy bringing everyone up to speed so we can continue in the class
I loved how respectful everyone was even though there was clearly tension in the room. As someone who was homeschooled, I felt very prepared for the real world because I wasn’t swayed in my beliefs. I had a strong foundation so when I was faced with the world, I was able to critically examine what others were saying was true. I was apart of a collaborative homeschooling setting where I didn’t just have my mom teaching me but other mothers teaching me and my friends which allowed for a community and multiple perspectives. I think settings like co-ops, charter schools, and parents setting up classes for other students out of their homes are great ways to allow for students to interact with different communities but also allow for there to be immense choice for parents. Homeschooling can be made accessible but we need to create communities if we want to make that happen.
As long as you're prepared to live and work in the world with other people, like me , an African American Queer woman without barring me of services because you don't like my lifestyle, then I can totally say homeschooling was good for you. As long as your parents weren't Jim Jones in this mess, great on you.
I generally prefer state schools which are public schools to USA but in UK public schools are a type of private schools. There’s not really a homeschool system in my country. People generally dislike school home schools because unfortunately in most cases a single parent like their mum & dad. Only gives there opinions of things. When they need multiple opinions & not just what their parents believe. Like general schools tho, home schools need to improve along with system of eduction, however the way you have it homeschool. Is a more modern way of home schooling. Even tho you’re not necessary going to change my mind. I still believe a national curriculum is needed tho but it has to include homeschooling as well. All religions & non religious beliefs should be taught regardless of people opinions or beliefs of it. My view is single sex schools shouldn’t exist as it doesn’t prepare them for work or life because they are always see another sexes outside the school. I believe holistic approach is best way to teach.
0:52: 🎓 The purpose of education is to support individuals and society as a whole through diverse education.
4:19: 👪 Parents' voices have been demonized in the education process, with criticism labeled as terrorism, but parents are ultimately responsible for their children's upbringing.
8:08: 🗣 The video discusses the balance between safe conversations and controversial topics in the classroom.
12:04: 🏫 The speaker advocates for school choice as a solution to the school-to-prison pipeline issue in public schools.
15:57: 👩🏫 Homeschooling allows parents to bond and learn alongside their children, benefiting both parties.
19:58: 🏳🌈 The video discusses the topics of transgender individuals, LGBTQ trends, and teaching about gender identity in schools.
24:01: 📚 The importance of teaching safe sex in schools to address the issue of teenage pregnancy and lack of parental guidance.
27:58: 📚 Teachers in some communities in Texas are not teaching key facts of American history due to the influence of critical race theory.
31:46: ! The video discusses the topic of White Privilege and whether it should be taught in schools.
35:58: 📚 The speaker discusses the unbalanced teaching of U.S. history in K-12 education, particularly in relation to Critical Race Theory (CRT), and highlights the need for a more holistic perspective.
39:50: ✨ The importance of teaching tolerance, kindness, and critical thinking in education to build a better generation.
Recap by Tammy AI
Thanks for saving my time! Amazing summary tool! Tammy AI
Thanks for the summary.
THANK YOU!!!
Dude educators are so chill compared to the ego battles from other debates - very nice to see a respectable panel,and i think they definitely set the bar for future debate panels
Educators are very special ❤
The people in other debates already have their own followings usually. So complete narcissists
Ok groomer
They have patience from dealing with kids all day
@@danzaathedancer7761 the Left wing teachers are "very special" lol.
I believe financial literacy should be emphasized and taught more in the US education system. I’m not surprised it wasn’t a discussion point in this conversation but the more financial literate we are, the more options and choices we can make to how we want to live our life, and teach our kids to be the next generation of leaders in this country.
God damn this should be number one comment
They can't because if we were all financially literate the debt based illusion of our system with shatter and collapse
YES. Economics through all the grades
Because education is about indoctrination. That's why things are set up so that the average parents are too busy with work so they can't homeschool and take control of what their kids learn/believe. So the government can take care of it and mold the kids into the perfect money making machine.
The biggest obstacle to making good financial decisions are conflicts of interest. There's a massive conflict of interest in education because teachers are usually required to have advanced degrees that come from universities that are themselves run by people with advanced university degrees. Advanced degrees, as of the last few decades, require a high amount of student debt. Financially, it makes no sense at all to take on that much debt in order to qualify for a job that pays that little, so the pool of people who teach not only tends to exclude the financially literate (or at least anyone who prioritizes financial success) but it also tends to favor going into debt and pursuing careers that make no financial sense.
So I personally wouldn't trust most teachers to teach my kids financial literacy. If you hire someone to mow your lawn, and that person runs their own business, chances are high that person has a better grasp of finances than any randomly selected teacher.
The Homeschool parents were really revealing. They complain about indoctrination in schools, yet clearly only want their kids thinking one way about everything. If it's something you don't like, its "indoctrination"; but if you agree than its "education". Of course parents have a right be involved in education, but exposing children to different views and people is also important.
Exactly. By limiting what your child consumes and the ideals/beliefs they’re surrounded by, you’re giving them more hurdles to get over in adulthood. You’ll never be surrounded by people who think exactly like you, and by having a child in school, you’re teaching them to not only exist and work with people who are vastly different from them, but they’ll also grow from being around those people
I don't agree, I went to public school and was exposed to terrible things, drugs, criminal behavior, bullying, survival of the fittest mentality. I can understand why parents would opt for homeschool to avoid all those pitfalls. Also it's not the children don't socialize or interact with other people from different background etc. So yes it's okay to be selective in how you're children are exposed to different ideas and views that could being them harm or bad association.
A parent's job is to "indoctrinate" or teach a child the moral and principled world views that they want the child to have. The truth is, the most influential of all educational factors is the interactions between a parent and a child, not a teacher and a child. Public education has evolved as a way of leveling the playing field, not as a means to achieve excellence. In today's world, for many children, home schooling and school choice is often the better way in so-called progressive areas..
Kids are indoctrinated into this world at an early age. The LGBT folks want to indoctrinate into their belief system just like a normal parent wants to indoctrinate. I want my kid to be exposed to lgbt materials when they are old enough to have their own identity so they can be accepting of different value systems but understand their value system is not one that sees high numbers of suicide etc.
It's your responsibility to indoctrinate your child genius... Not the governments.
I love this argument that we don’t trust parents to educate their kids. That’s 💯 true bc right now the majority of parents are sending their kids to school completely unprepared, without emotional regulation and executive functioning skills, and with an inability to grapple through problems. So no. You’re not raising your kids in a way that helps them be successful. Most kids are getting those skills at school.
This was a pretty good conversation, but I wish there was more discussion about academic performance. That is something we are struggling with as a country. The topic of education seems to always devolve into social issues. Some interesting topics would have been the role of homework and standardized testing and the issue of underperforming kids being passed in order to boost school ratings.
Thank you! Everyone in the comments is commending how 'respectful' this panel was, when ultimately it was just a debate around social politics, rather than topics that pertain specifically to education, such as homework and testing. They could have even talked about the accessibility of tertiary eduction and school fees, the privatisation of schooling and even school shootings.
Blacks neglect education because it's their culture
Me too. The conversations about gender, sexuality, and CRT are important, but I was more focused on HOW were being taught less of what we're being taught. As a high schooler that is dual enrolled with a college, I see the discrepancies within our school system, and they're failing us. They're saying that oh we need to learn how to do reading writing and arithmetic, but no one is retaining any of it. We are just doing it to get a grade or a title, and we've been gaslit, guilt tripped, and manipulated our whole lives. I really wish we could have a more organic learning experience rather than soak up material, do home work, turn assignments, then take a test. It's not working and I speak for a lot of us when I say this.
@@justicefoster955 How do you organically learn algebra, geometry, Grammer, or spelling?
@@reddirtwalker8041 What do you mean by 'organically' do you care to elaborate.
As a school speech language pathologist, I wish there was someone who worked in special education on this as well. I think the aspects of special education were missed in this debate and that’s such a huge and important part of education as well.
VERY TRUE! That is a major variable left out on how school choice could be a benefit or a detriment to special needs. Personally I think it would be a benefit because you could get schools that focus on it rather than it be an afterthought.
Who cares… we need to indoctrinate all young ppl into being LQBTQ
A lot of parents realize that many private schools do not have the supports to adequately give their children equitable access and return to public schools.
I agree. I think that should be part of this discussion. As someone who had an IEP I don’t believe public school is the answer in many neighborhoods. The reason is because in many school districts without the proper staffing or great programs you are only as strong as your weakest student in those classes. I needed just a little extra time, the ability to take tests in a classroom alone and extra homework. Unfortunately they said the regular classes couldn’t accommodate that so they put me in special education classes. That held me back so much. There was no medium between the two classes and that hurt me so bad. I do understand that many schools have the resources to teach each student individually at their level, which is AMAZING. For the schools that don’t have that ability, if the parent is able to, I believe homeschooling or a private school that can accommodate is the best option. Some schools don’t even have the ability to have “special education” rooms and the children with behavioral problems get put into classrooms with the other children. I tutored in a 6th grade classroom that is like that. These children got all the attention and other children began to act out too or be stressed. The class took 20-30 minutes between subjects to calm down which means they lost vital teaching time.
I think this debate is more for the majority, as they wouldn't have enough time to delve into the very small parts of schools. Special education only makes up about 14% of the schools statewide, give or take.
What a great conversation! Major praise for the High School student! What an amazing young woman.
fun fact: i went to private school and i was never taught sex ed- a lot of my friends that left to go back to public school for HS ended up getting knocked up 😳
I've seen a number of these Vice Debates, and I have to say THIS is probably the most civil and respectful of all. Congratulations, to you parents and educators for being such a great example of being civil, respectful, and authentic. If American society is filled by people of your kind of openness and respect, and you raise your children with this degree of respect and sincerity, then there is hope for the greatest country in the world.
The people in this debate lack the usual snark. I liked it.
Why are there always a majority brown people in these when it's a white country, built by whites?
All these debates just prove that conservatives are more on the mark. The left is trying to run from natural law
Aye, I totally agree! And was thinking this while I was watching. Even people's defensiveness was respectful.
Also as a commenter said, "no snarkiness."
I loved it.
Figured the all women panel was the most hostile one lol
Every time I paused to disagree and have a discussion with myself about what someone said the next person who spoke said exactly what I just said out loud to myself. Im glad this panel actually had the balls to speak up against what some of the others were saying. This panel is exactly why ppl lean toward home schooling. You never know what type of teacher you will get. They are honestly HIT or MISSSS.
I get it. It's scary.
Lmao I’m so glad some else said they do this too
@@LifeStrike2030you are completely wrong! I teach my children. Not only book smarts! But survival skills, money skills, chores, how to work on vehicles, gardening, everything that a child should learn growing up.. I am open minded! And let my kids explore and ask questions. I guarantee you my home schooled child will surpass any public/private school child!
@@loganscotthouse1590 I can guarantee that your kid is more likely to be molested than any public or private school kid.
And you more likely to b the molester than any teacher
I would want my kid taught by at least one teacher who is the complete opposite of me so they can learn more! Be more open minded and tolerant, and get more perspectives on the world we live in! There’s a lot to learn from people we know nothing about! Why have we lost that or don’t want that?!
True bro
You say that but if they were pushing the opposite values you believe for 8 hours a day you would change your tune immediately
@@Thisismyhandle8383 I can honestly say, my entire life all through elementary and high school, I never had a single teacher push any sort of value.. Some would discuss their beliefs, but honestly most teachers are afraid to even speak to one side or the other on any political issue due to the fear of backlash from parents and administration. I don't think that presenting a view that is in opposition to oneself is harmful though.
"Education is not simply the learning of facts, but training the mind to think."
Albert Einstein
I am shocked that that not a single member of this panel addressed the most profound problem within the education system in the United States of America: Utter and complete lack of parental/guardian accountability for the infractions of students. The majority of students, k-12, are simply out of control, spoiled, petulant, rude, inconsiderate, and intellectually challenged. 🙄
I just commented this on another video about a student pepper spraying a teacher that took her phone that she was using to cheat. Lack of parenting and lack of consistent real world consequences or accountability create an out of control student population.
@@bluesky5384, indeed. It is revolting.
Because so are their parents. :-/
It’s both sides. Teachers also need to actually care about teaching kids. They can’t just look at it as a job because it’s not just a job it’s teaching.
There was a time I agreed with you 100%. However, now, if you take an earnest interest in your children's education, you are punished and may even go to jail and be labeled a terrorist.
As a german student, i look at this with shock. The differences in cultures are so real and i gotta say i am thankful to live in germany, since we actually have a good and (mostly) working education without huge conflicts about what is taught and how it is taught.
because what america needs to do is follow a country who trips over itself in all instances apologizing for historical atrocities, and almost completley framing its history after the fact. i can burn an american flag in my front yard, but would be arrested for doing the same thing to the star spangled banner in berlin.
the US is much younger than germany but does a better comprehensive job of teaching its history than a nation scared to venture out pre-unification of various german landers.
I graduated from a DOD school in Germany that gave a dual diploma if one was to qualify. I'm so glad to have had that opportunity.
@@azih8626 it’s not that deep bro. 😂😂 America is the pits education wise.
Y’all need to learn that education is about critical thinking, not all this emotions and feelings drama.
@@azih8626 you need to learn about American propaganda, try reading the American dream 21st century and you’ll see you are just spreading American propaganda talking points lol and meanwhile america has committed just as many atrocities and has never apologized for it doesn’t make it a better country lol, I have more respect for a country that holds itself accountable than one that just continues to try and genocide native Americans and covers it up with “we are the best country in the world” which isn’t even true by a long shot lmfao
Germany is a socialist sh!t hole
What's shocking is that 9 adults are asked what is the reason for school and only 1 said to be literate.
As someone who works on foster care cases, I can assure you that it’s never a good idea to rely completely on parents to make the best decisions for their children. Those decisions need to be within reason and they need to be in collaboration with education professionals.
And the wider community
This is alarming. Leave your bias out of this conversation. Parents should have the choice. Don't use your bubble to make informed decisions for the rest of us.
I don’t think you critically evaluated what they were saying. Not every parent is a good parent let alone a reliable one. There are many parents that make terrible decisions for their children, parents should not get all rights to decide how their child should be raised because with that kind of logic it can lead to justification of abusive parenting methods and abuse of power.
@@Drowning_GirlJust something to think about, realistically anyone is capable of having children and therefore being a parent. Now think about how dumb you find the average person, and realize HALF of the population is dumber than that... I think parents absolutely should be involved in their child's education, but I don't think all parents are capable of making the BEST choices, especially with topics that they have no experience in, or have a particular bias. The more educated children are, the better our society as a whole will be, even if it's something the parents don't like or agree with such as gay marriage or transgenderism.
Just because there are some messed up parents, doesn’t mean the rights of all parents should be stripped.
Only those parents who show they make bad parenting choices should officials step in; we can’t just make a blanket decision like that for all parents.
This was an amazing conversation. But when bro said “it’s the Cardi B music!” I burst out laughin so hard 🤣🤣🤣🤣
😅 Bro was very ignorant for that comment… you as a parent should have control over what your child is listening to at a certain age
@@aaronjones9227agreed they should have parental control on they Apple Music or some 😂😂
HE said it with his CHEST too LOLOL!
Straight face😂
That part, and when the teacher in the blazer and jeans in the back row said, “Ok bro. Real talk though. Brother to brother..” 😅
I found that to be funny too.
In all seriousness though, I really enjoyed this panel of such diverse speakers who were able to respectfully and productively share and voice their thoughts, opinions, and beliefs with one another without it turning sour. What I really loved about this also is that everyone had the best interest of our societies children and next generations to come in mind. It is conversations like this that give me hope for the world we live in.
It is refreshing to witness a civil & respectful conversation between people with very different opinions. We need more of this.
YES!! Even though it got “heated”, everyone was awesome!
The feminism panel left me w/ "PTSD"/jaded when it comes to Vice debates, so whenever one pops up I immediately read the comment section to discern if it went well or off the rails. So far it seems this one went well enough.
This convo is civil and respectful but some of the members are so incredibly uneducated on certain topics that it's hard to understand anything from their point of view. One of the conservatives doesn't understand a lot of the things that he doesn't think should be taught in schools. I know this is edited and there would have been more to the conversation but the rebuttals to his view of CRT and what indoctrination is, shows how these bubbles that they live in can be so damaging to our society. The failure to understand white privilege and how he disagrees to factual information blows my mind.
No we don't. The Right is almost always wrong and all these talks do is waste time. That's like me sitting down with a racist to discuss race. My energy would be better spent organizing ppl in my community, and on the state level to combat the right.
I agree, was healing almost to see people communicate with grace and tolerance
I wish they would have addressed the fact that every child unfortunately doesn't have capable parents to teach them everything they need if anything. Public school could be their only opportunity for knowledge etc
A problem is that parents have to spend a lot of time working for the system instead of being able to do stuff in their own surrounding and being able to manage. We used to have parents coming together and teaching their children.
1 full time job should be enougj to provide for a household. This is a problem. Im not saying only one person makes money, but both parents should be able to work 20 hours a week so they work 40 hours a week to provide for they family.
I had the pleasure of having Teacher Frambrini teach my son that year at Vincent Academy! He was very kind to me as a parent and taught advanced math to the students!
I really wish they would have touched on bullying and the no tolerance policy. I would have loved to hear the teachers perspectives on it. Both of my children have faced bullying and both of my children have been punished for defending themselves from bullies who were physically threatening them. The no tolerance policy needs to have some common sense. We know a 12yr old girl who was just suspended for busting a kids lip while trying to stop him from throwing her down a flight of stairs. But because she hit him she got in trouble. It's becoming a huge issues in schools and with the increase of not just school shootings but suicides among middle and high school children it really needs to be addressed.
Great point. That's part of the reason why I said I homeschool. They just edited it conveniently to make it seem like I was saying to shield them from LGBT kids. When I said "to keep my kids away from YOUR bad kids" was actually more aligned with your point contextually. Seems they chopped it up to push an agenda to try to discredit me. It backfired.
We need to introduce combat sports and weight lifting in middle schools. These teach discipline, the importance of standing up for yourself and they build lots of confidence as participants see themselves progressing in them.
@@Redditor6079 I can respect that. I did mixed martial arts at age 15 back before it was mainstream... UFC was pay per view only then so there were no fights available for minors lol
Teachers are too busy teaching kids LGBT stuff or white primacy stuff.
It will never change. A kid came up behind me and started choking me. I broke out of it and knocked him out. I got a week suspension and he got nothing but a giant black eye. A teacher watched the whole incident too. The teacher told the principal we were rough housing and that I took it to far.
I had Sex Ed in the 5th grade. It was a week long curriculum that concluded with a parents night. Mothers with daughters and fathers with sons, we watched our own informational film and then had our own Q and A with our parent or guardian. There was a licensed health expert in the room the whole time to address any concerns or deeper questions.
And you forget half of it 😂
Humans have been breeding for thousands of years without se.x ed
@@rojayreid908 🤣🤣
@@rojayreid908 You were probably the immature one who was uncomfortably laughing the whole sex ed class. Huh?
@@jasonolinger7585 everyone was laughing stop it and don't pretend you retain anything in that class in 5th grade. Maybe some things but most things you gonna forget, especially at that age.
Sad to see how conversations about education now automatically devolve into a sex/gender conversation…this is I’m the least of our problems people!
NOT "Its the Cardi B music" PLEASE????😂💀
What I really liked about this episode is the respect and civility everyone showed towards one another. Everybody was free to state their opinion and actually listened, which is something that is becoming rarer and rarer by the day. Civil discourse fosters mutual understanding and helps depolarize our views
They are educators they are use to these debates
Y’all don’t have free speech
Additionally, they have a moderator and are being filmed. Could be different, especially from the folks on the far-right (literally and metaphorically speaking).
@@BicycleFunkIt’s usually the far left that go wild and start being uncivilized in these debates lol
@@davishoward7235 sure you're not talking about the guys who think there is a dark web of baby blood drinking satanists pulling all the strings?
"it's the cardi b music" with a straight face and the other parents nodding in the background had me dying. Glad we've found the source of teen pregnancy
It was an example, they be canceling Xmas music but wet a$$ pu$$y gets played on the radio, if you don't see the problem then you are the problem
I mean he has a point. You can’t blame it all on Cardi B, but this glorification of sex in female made music nowadays is going to have an effect on the young generation of girls listening to it.
@@sashasguitarcovers5921 it’s up to the parents whether they’re allowing their children to see things like that. even cardi herself doesn’t let her daughter listen to her music.
the double take I took loool I was like WOW
@@sashasguitarcovers5921 yea and COD makes kids shooters
I knew a lot of homeschool kids growing up and they were weird as hell, socially stunted, and missed out on so many cool opportunities. I'm sure it doesn't always happen, but often that is true. Also homeschool is an easy way for abusive parents to hide their abuse, those kids might never be around a mandated reporter.
Also I'm a teacher, as is my husband and when we get homeschooled children that come to our school for the first time in their lives, they are far behind the other children.
This is just my experience.
The only comments this account has ever made have been on this video. You're bald faced lying. You completely made that up.
I spend my childhood in Mexico and homeschooling isn’t a thing (or wasn’t back then.) honestly, I find hard to believe that someone can be able to school and educate someone on their own.
@@marcosbravo4293 I bet, when all you know is indoctrination it would be hard to believe any other reality. Mexico is NOT the model example for effective education.
@@Drisco757 I didn’t say that, did I? I didn’t even say homeschooling was bad…
Were you homeschooled?
@@marcosbravo4293 I didn't say you said that. No I was not homeschooled
This is excellent. Our country has some very sophisticated enemies, and they've discovered how to amplify a minor difference of opinion to a national debate rising to epic proportions. Every single person here has an intelligent, valuable perspective. Every single one is an awesome American. Live and let live, and ask your local school if they could use any help this year. Drop off a pack of pencils. Anything. We've still got public education, for now. Make the most of it. Respect.
Having finished this episode I have to be honest. That was in my opinion the best and most wholesome episode I've seen so far. Different opinions, respectful conversations and conclusions at the end where everyone seem to have benefitted from the talks. Certainly not an end I would have expected but one I'm actually even grateful for, because it builds hope in a better tomorrow.
@ciizar6941
I agree. This is the best VICE panel ever. It was actually balanced between left and right, which helped immensely. It really seemed like both sides agreed about what should be taught concerning race…a hopeful sign. Clearly, those on the left here don’t know how the powers that be have formulated CRT. It is extraordinarily toxic and divisive. And those on the right are just as naive, not seeing that much of the anti-CRT movement has out-and-out racist motivations.
It felt like, if left to their own devices, unencumbered with their respective leadership’s manipulations, these 8 could iron out a fairly decent curriculum on racial relations.
It was different on the sexual side of things. There, there was no common ground to speak of. Which is exactly what I would have expected. I don’t think there really is any genuine common ground that is discoverable. One side wants to inappropriately expose and indoctrinate kids from a very early age, and the other wants to inappropriately shelter them till they’re 35.
Vice is better than most will give credit. 90% of their material you wouldn’t find approached the same manner elsewhere.
Not everyone represented by each person here think like the person who represents them.
NONSENSE. YOU ARE NAIEVE. THIS IS WRONG. A MARGINAL FEW POPULATION IS RUNNING THE REST OF US NORMAL HUMANS. I DO NOT BUY IT FOR ONE MINUTE. IT IS SICKENING. AND YOU ARE FALLING FOR IT. BECAUSE THEY KNOW THE COZY TALKING POINTS TO USE. SERIOUSLY, WOULD YOU WANT THESE FREAKS TO BE ALONE WITH YOUR CHILD? NO AND YOU KNOW IT.
this is, by far, the most respectful convo I've seen in the series.
But NOTHING was accomplished. And nothing of value was shared. You spent time listening to people who LOVE to hear themselves talk and regurgitate positions they've been fed. That's all it was. You could have sat there just as easily and brought as much to the table.
@@teejay3272bro what, get a hobby
@@bald_flop8063 Must suck to be simple minded. You're a target. Good luck with that puddin'.
@@teejay3272 Welcome to VICE, where they point out stuff like "OMG YOU SHOULD PAY ATTENTION TO THIS" and don't EVER follow through with any concrete plan of change or action or even care to show how people are willing to change their views in favor of empathy and respect for humans. Conservative values are not society encouraging, they are inwardly destructive by design. It's plain as day, they need to just come out and say it isntead of continuing to try and get clicks from every side possible
@@vapensmoke Good comment. I've worked in a professional capacity in "the media" for quite a while so I have a pretty good idea of how the sausage gets made. Vice does some solid reporting but this was pure theater. They were checking a box. What's unfortunate is that it appears that the comments are mostly positive and revolve around "respectful debate." It really speaks to an uninformed and lazy populous. As long as the surface is appealing there's no need to dig deeper. And that's as common on the "left" as it is on the "right." Two sides of the same coin. And when they meet, under the guise of a false equivalency, no one wins.
Wait. Let me scratch that. I guess conservatives win because they're being given a seat at the grown up table to spew extremism. The grievance collectors from the left win because "look at me." Who loses is everyone else.
37:02 brilliant point made about 1 min later- “That’s exactly what CRT is”- talking about not just the struggle but also talents & success of BIPOC. If everyone would understand the actual definition, then we would have a more solid foundation to have a productive discussion about it.
This was a brilliant debate!
Everyone calmly offering their own perspective and really listening to the opinions of the other people, very refreshing and uplifting to watch, as one of the panellists said, no ''bad guy" in the conversation.
I got halfway through this, and was infuriated. They are focusing a very limited range of topics, and it just ended up coming to social issues. I wish they chose more ideas like standardized testing or common core or ones that involved less misinformation and were based on facts
Exactly
Hence my rant above. No one wants to discuss facts anymore. Social problems are a smokescreen for the reality of the public school crisis.
They still got that jellyfish photo on windows ? That's over 10 years old damn
Yes! It's all about social agendas.
That's what vice does it's all about social problems just nonsense
I love how this debate went. It's rare to see a respectful debate. We need more of this in the world
I always 'see' respectful debate when people are face to face. The internet drives the uncivil type.
Respect and kindness. Maybe adults/parents should start modeling it and we wouldn't need to teach kids on it.
Yes even though I didn't agree with some that is the kind of debating we need. Our leaders could learn a thing or two from this group.
@Tamara Smith exactly! No matter the setting, military, school, society in general..it always starts at the top and trickles down. This is honestly why I can't stand the post-2016 political climate. When you have a leader spreading non-stop vitriol, the citizens will follow suit.
@@thevulgarscientist2207 influencers? How so?
They were really respectful, I love that.
I'm a trained Educator in Nigeria both in teaching and administration. I will really love to be in a panel like this just to rub minds.
40:55 where he was saying that he wishes to see parents at the PTA meetings and such.. something like that wasn't possible for me where I am from a single-working-parent household. My dad pulled well over 50-60 hours a week working anyone from 4am-3pm, sometimes earlier and/or later. My dad would have to drop me off at my grandmother's in the middle of the night so my relatives could take me to school. Aside from my dad working long hours, he immigrated here from China and only get a partial 3rd grade education. He took some adult school here in the US to learn some English so he could get by. But PTA meetings for someone like him and many parents of friends and classmates from my generation/graduating class are all in a similar situation.
Going to a PTA meeting was by far a waste of time back then because they had other chores to do around the house or prepare for the next work day.
Like others have mentioned, the education system is due for a revamp. Many parents now, not all, have been born and raised in the States now and can afford to do much of the things our parents wished to do. And that is similar to much of every other aspect in the US. Things we wished we could do, or wished our parents could do back then- we can do now for our next generation.
My mom and dad taught us to never stop asking why when people give you information, always challenge what you hear, former your own opinions, and understand the facts and how they were proven. My wife and I have the same approach to our two kids and I'm happy that they are always searching for more information. I don't always have the answer FOR them but searching with them makes for some interesting conversations
THE PROBLEM IS THE WOKE SOCIALISTS who are distancing liberals and conservatives
Well Raph, they keep deleting my respons to you. His name is Gyorgy Lakacs. He was the Hungarian secretary of education during the soviet union. Read about what he did
I learned this in my late 20s when it came to questioning my own biases
@silentj624 knowledge is not a destination, it's a journey. I'm 35 and I'm progressing in my journey. Keep striving forward and keep growing 💪
Just because a child is attending school doesn’t mean the parents can’t educate alongside the school. Parents, in general, need to take a bigger role in the education of their own children. I also think it’s important for children to be introduced to other ideals from other people.
Also, what a horribly bold view that ALL lgbtqia+ people have been abused and molested 🙄
Another reason why we can’t trust parents alone to educate their children alone. That man has all of his children believing someone is only lgbtqia because they were abused. I CANNOT 🙄 white supremacists do the same, teaching their children their baseless beliefs about race as fact 🙄🙄😒
Exactly this. It’s the black and white mentality some people have where they perpetuate this belief that schools have absolute control over their children, and that they as parents are powerless to stop it. They act like the parent is completely removed from the educational process. That’s not the case at all if parents are involved and invested in their children’s education, and take the time to learn alongside them.
And some parents want to be the ones introducing their child to other ideas at an age the parents feel their child should be exposed to, if at all.
So true. Parents should take an active role in educating their children on topics or issues they will encounter. This day and age, social media or other school kids will teach kids about the world more than the parents. Parents that are tapped in will know that and take either a proactive approach to the issues or topics or will have to be in panicked reactive state when issues or topics arise. Some of the issues and topics of the world are not a matter of if the child will have to face it, but when.
im no completely disagreeing, i definitely belief parents need to be more involved and i wish mime were. but what about the children who dont have parents to be involved or are neglected by theirs, what happens to them?
This was a very respectful debate and everyone seemed to listen to each other and hear different opinions. It's nice seeing people coming together like this.
This was great. Every single one of them had such insight and genuine care and concern for our youth. Would be nice if our swamp government could talk to each other and find reason like these folks did. Thanks for posting!
Now THATS how you do a debate! No talking over one another, name calling, spitefulness etc. Great job to vice for setting this up and finding some really good debaters from both sides of the aisle
Great Panel. One thing I think is really important and has not been brought up is there are lots of kids out there who see school as a safe haven, they literally rely on educators and their fellow students because of a toxic or abusive home.
So why not help those students individually? If the situation is that bad for them at home why not work to get those students out of the toxic situation? Isn't that better than having them for 6-8 hours a day 5 days a week only to have them return to the toxic situation every day?
What's your point?. They should keep going to public school ( if that's their parents' choice. ) but you can't force other parents to keep their kids in there bc your child needs an outlet and likes their teacher.
@@user-vg8ez9cu6u Where did he day force kids to go to public school? Stop inventing statements to argue against.
I'll say, if a child views school as a safe haven, that parent probably isn't prioritizing education planning or school choice in their plans. This is a valid issue, but I don't see it as a valid point regarding education choice conversation.
This would firmly fall in Child Protective Services and safety intervention systems realm. Which most people agree is in deep need of reform and deep policy retooling.
I agree! As someone who grew up in a toxic and abusive household and also fell through the cracks because I looked like I came from a "good" household, I think there should be time in there where kids are taught what abuse looks like, what is okay and not okay and the damaging effects of words and actions we as individuals and as groups can have on others, and what is unacceptable regardless of age or race or power dynamic. And then from there have a place for kids to find resources.
The trouble with me is that I was so isolated that I had no concept of what healthy relationships should look like, and how warped my perceptions were, to even articulate that there even WAS a problem, even though my behavior/actions/grades clearly reflected that, there was never anywhere to go with those issues.
Please do this again. It was awesome! GREAT dialogue!!!
This was a healthy conversation. Agree to disagree without being rude to each other
I don’t know where you found these people, but they’re all rockstars. So well spoken, able to articulate, and willing to understand others with differing viewpoints.
Unfortunately, a lot of them could not produce a valid argument. You may respect their demeanor, but I can't agree that all of them were competent at presenting a valid argument. Being nice and cordial is great, but we need thinkers to tackle these problems.
I’m convinced that I did not watch the same video as most people in the comments, there were a lot of talking points in this video that have been debunked previously that are being regurgitated. Just because they were civil doesn’t mean it was a good debate/discussion.
I felt like this at times too. Though it was nice seeing people be civil with such clear differences of opinion, it was simply just that. Very clear that some of them were more divisive than others and the rest just weren’t trying to make an explosion happen. I saw another comment about them needing fact checkers in the room and I am so behind that because the misinformation is still a little rampant here
thank you. I felt like the teachers especially were holding back because they wanted the discussion to be productive. Maybe it's the edit, but I was disappointed that so many of this debunked myths weren't categorically corrected.
what parts of the video were debunked? i’m a bit confused
20:00 the suit adjusting and the "aight" got me crying in laughter
So impressed with how respectful everyone was. I really would have struggled.
“It’s the Cardi B music” 😂😂 I know he wasn’t joking but that makes it even funnier
☠️
“Pull up your pants and stop watching communist tik toks! My son saw a vape pen and now he’s shitting in a litter box!!! I haven’t seen him do it but I know he wants to!”
Black Ben Shapiro was making me seeth w/ frustration on his points.
*Cardi B grinning off camera*
@@Blackronin357 CJ was the best member on the panel. Makeup guy on the other hand...
Not going to lie, this vice host by far was the best one and the most neutral with questions, also fair. She should do all of them
I so wish my children had educators like Desmond at their public school in Arkansas. They seem like they genuinely care about their students, and they’re also a terrific communicator!
“Did you choose to be straight, sir?!” Oh my god I screamed, what an amazing response.
lmao and then he goes on to talk about being attracted to an attractive trans woman and looses his attraction after finding out they were a man at one time, like bruh.. you totally just proved their point....
Everyday I choose to be straight. Only one empty urinal? Nah man I’m wasting the toilet bowl in the stall.
Making yourself LOOK like a woman doesn’t mean you are one 🤷🏽♂️ that’s the thing!
If we want our children to to brought up to be respectful, educated, and productive citizens, they need to see their teachers and parents having conversations like this. Learning from each other by actually listening. Not being afraid to speak their mind. Coming prepared with examples and evidence. Well done panel!
Well said education not indoctrination is how we teach its important for teachers to not have a bias and keep it open for discussion
@@austinsavage5962 bingo. All this gender theory stuff needs to be left up to the parents, not the teachers.
@@daMillenialTrucker agreed that has no place in school
@@austinsavage5962 just teach my kids what you taught and leave all the extra stuff to me. I would punish the hell out of my boys if I had caught drift that they were picking on someone because they're gay or trans.
Agreed, one of the key ways to raise children to be respectful is to promote inclusion and awareness of the world around us.
23:56 "it's the cardi b music", I f*ing lost it, I laughted my @ss off, that was pretty random 😂
As someone who watches a lot of these panels, this is definitely one of the best ones; absolutely worth the time!
Wow that was such a great debate! So respectful and open!!❤❤❤ I don’t get to see that anymore
The idea that parents should have a say what is taught to kids sounds great in theory. But have y’all been outside?? Some parents are really damn dumb. Like super dumb. It takes no intelligence to be a parent.
Bingo. I’ve had two parents reach out this year and tell me I’m indoctrinating their children by teaching evolution and not creationism and they compared evolution to mysticism lmao
It takes no intelligence to pass or graduate now and get to a piece of paper that certifies you as "smart."
@macciddy7689 sentences like that explains why. Where did the solar system evolve from?
Evolution and creationism are both theories on why life exists, Evolution skips the creation of the solar system and agree's with the big bang. Neither can be proven or disproven.
Teach both as theories.
Just because your parents are dumb, doesn’t mean everyone else’s parents are dumb. Not your kid, not your choice.
@@NoName-1239that comment alone told me you’re just another child left behind. George Bush has to pay for his crimes. LMAO.
This was actually a really good panel, everyone for the most part was very respectful to each other
I totally agree with you🎉
Panels are supposed to be representative, Republican and right-wing beliefs are regularly in the minority and regularly represent less than 40% of the population to the point where they haven't won a popular vote in 2 decades, why tf do they represent 50% or more of every panel? why are all the conservatives who are invited onto these debate stages literally professional lobbyists and pundits while they invite some retired teacher to represent the left. What a joke. Anyone who thinks this is unbiased news is an ignoramus who didn't even think to google the names of the people speaking...
@@freedy1696 Conservatives are the minorities and haven't won the popular vote in two decades? No wonder our country is progressively getting more and more screwed up
@@jlopez4889 lol, have fun being a minority
@@freedy1696 conservatives are 38% of the population while lefties are 25%
What a great debate: topic is very current; many viewpoints were calmly and eloquently expressed with respect; this is how politics and ideologies should be, with questions and answers; problems and the sources explored and possible options and resolutions openly discussed to see them down the longer road. The bad ideas will be discarded and we are more likely to build consensus around hopeful solutions to implement. Wish politicians would do more of this town hall open talk.
as a dad this is very eye opening and im more RESPECTFUL on the mindest of our EDUCATION teachers
Gosh this whole conversation was fantastic 👏🏻
And this is how we should be talking to each other, instead of yelling and screaming are viewpoints and talking down the opposite of ours.
@@daMillenialTrucker Have you ever lied, lusted sexually at the opposite sex, disrespected parents, stolen, thought bad thoughts, hated someone, sinned sexually (fornication, Adultery …) etc
All humans have sinned in thought, word or deed. Therefore, none of us are good and able to get into Heaven and will be justly judged and sent to eternity in Hell! But God out of His love sent his son Jesus (also God in Human flesh) to die on the cross for our sins and rise again from the dead (nobody can do that only God).
Jesus said if you Repent of your sins and put your complete trust in Him for your salvation, you’ll have eternal life, given to you as a gift (this message is not to be ignored; seek God today). Your thoughts?
John 14: 6 Jesus said to him, “I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.
. 16 For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whoever believes in Him should not perish but have everlasting life. 17 For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world, but that the world through Him might be saved.
18 “He who believes in Him is not condemned; but he who does not believe is condemned already, because he has not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God. 19 And this is the condemnation, that the light has come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil.
20 For everyone practicing evil hates the light and does not come to the light, lest his deeds should be exposed. 21 But he who does the truth comes to the light, that his deeds may be clearly seen, that they have been done in God.”
“The time is fulfilled, and the kingdom of God [g]is at hand. Repent, and believe in the gospel.”
Frfr I'm surprised
NONSENSE. YOU ARE NAIEVE. THESE FREAKS WOULD ABUSE YOUR KIDS IN A HEARTBEAT IF GIVEN THE CHANCE. THEY HAVE FIGURED OUT HOW TO INFILTRATE THE SYSTEM TO HAVE ACCESS TO YOUR KIDS. STOP FOOLING YOURSELF. THEY KNOW EXACTLY WHICH TALKING POINTS TO USE TO GET YOUR HEART STRINGS. IT IS ALL BS AND DESIGNED TO PUT PEDIFILES IN OUR SCHOOLS. YOU REMEMBER WHAT I HAVE SAID HERE. 10 YRS FROM NOW REEXAMINE WHAT THE OUTCOME OF THE UPCOMING GENERATION IS GOING TO BE. THEY WILL HOLD US ACCOUNTABLE FOR THIS ABUSE.
The one lady that said public schools are segregated failed to mention that schools in the United States are funded based on property taxes.
She also doesn't want the students to know WHY schools are so highly segregated.... but wants to use it as a talking point against the school system.
In nyc they spend 30k per pupil. N California is not far behind. White n Asian parents are more willing to send their kids to private school. In Nyc 92% of the of the highly competitive schools are attended by white and Asian. Hard work pays.
Nobody wants to go to a crime infested "blaque" school where you get called "white" for simply showing an interest in academics
@@BarbeeSpeaksit’s because when there are blacks, there is more crime and poverty. And that’s because blacks have adopted a degenerate culture of retarded rap music that celebrates drugs, murder, promiscuous behavior, etc. all the things that destroy society. When the culture changes, those neighborhoods will change for the better, and there will be better properties with higher values and higher property taxes. The single parent percentage in the black community is 74% and that is absolutely insane. That needs to change first and foremost before any real positive change can occur
@@glenlivet9394 gasp! You're so brilliant. Just solved an entire problem in one go. I hope you're proud of yourself buddy.*
When it comes to the conversation of homeschooling and how the majority of public figures like "founding fathers" were homescheeld or only went to school until third grade: an important part of the narrative that was left out was how nascent pubic education is and the requirements that you send your children to school and don't just assimilate them into the workforce. The history of public education is fresh and important to learn, esepically currently when there seems to be an intense dismantling of the public education sphere. Great video with different persepctives.
Bro when did teachers become so pretentious. Every one has become so kind of activist. Timmy is 17 and can't even do fractions while some 3rd grader in South Korea just mastered precalc and did 37 book reports this year
THIS WAS NOT LONG ENOUGH! Only 40 mins?! Educators have so much to contribute to our understanding of what is ACTUALLY happening in education.
Thanks Vice! Great episode!
You say this but educators are caught time after time after time indoctrinating youth. It's a shame that million of kids can't read at grade level, and teachers are boasting to their parents.
It’s wild how people who went to school now act as if school is this scary place where they are teaching people things that wouldn’t learn at home.
I wish this convo was longer for the sake of the educators
Yes! Maybe two sessions / videos: one leaning to cultural/social, etc. views. Another more academic (or not academic enough).
I attended 6th grade at a K-6 elementary school. The first year of sex ed was in 6th grade, the sum of it was anatomy and consent. It was during a anonymous Q&A three girls realized they were being molested and learned that keeping secrets of who is touching their bodies is damaging. I whole heartedly agree that sex ed is important and should be reasonable and responsibly taught by a public educator or a group of licensed health educators for a few hours over a two to three day period.
Great point
Exactly. Kids don't know they are being molested unfortunately. I remember reading something where the girl kept telling her mom the uncle or some family member kept touching her "cookie" and the mom didn't think it was a big deal and brushed the little girl off numerous times, and come to find out, the little girl had meant he was touching her v (idk if we can say the word on TH-cam?)and then the mom finally cared and started freaking out but who knows how long it continued to go on before the mom finally realized. Ever since then, I said I'm going to teach my baby the proper words.
this one was really good!!!
I thought a lot of parents were humbled during the pandemic about how hard it really is to teach children.
"Never let your schooling interfere with your education " - Mark Twain
What does this mean?
@@esther8262 it's an exercise of critical thinking. Food for thought
Are you criticizing conservative or liberal?
@@Joe-rl4pv Why are you calling me stupid?
@@beatrizgalvani neither
These are so so hard to watch sometimes but it’s so fascinating and I love it!! Such healthy debating and it’s beautiful.
“healthy debating” umm yea right all the liberals are trying to cram bs down their throats. They are living in a dream world.
@@Sheahova that’s a two way street especially in this debate babe. You’re clearly only hearing what you wanna hear. Either watch it again and LISTEN or shut up.
Just found this video, and even though it’s a year old…I found it a breath of fresh air. Disagree with several comments but have mad respect for everyone who spoke.
the body language in the front row adds a whole new level of interest to this conversation
The way that man with full seriousness said "It's that Cardi B music" as the cause of sexual promiscuity took me tf out 🤣🤣
lol same but its kinda true
I laughed out loud 😂
He’s a religious lunatic who’s probably on a watchlist.
@@infidon9229 yeah...
He is to young to be giving off “get of my lawn” vibes.
the high schooler holding her own!! Smart
the smartest one there
She's bright, but she used Texas as an example of how the community decides the curriculum. However Texas is 40th in the nation for education and last for mental healthcare.
I think it's worth noting the method she brought up is a failed one. Not to her discredit, but you want to provide the results of your example for context.
Right!
Amazing panel! Very mature and developed minds having challenging and engaging conversations that will push us as society to do better. Fantastic!
I like that this was a largely productive conversation. It makes me happy for the future.
Kudos to the entire panel, this was very mature. Though almost each person had a different opinion, they all delivered their opinions very well that even those who didn't agree with it enjoyed the delivery. The lady leading the discussion really understands her job. Love love love.
It's a really beautiful world out here when we respect each other and are willing to listen to other people's experiences and perspectives.
I agree with you. The moderator for this panel let them talk & didn’t push her ideas lead or stop the conversation, she was neutral during their talking points. This is one of the best ones I’ve watched.
The respect each teacher had for one another is the most important lesson here.
Their soldiers in the same war
the sickness of woke agenda is the most important here
@@MrRayDeaz 😂 all ways one of you germs around.
I really enjoyed Phillips perspectives...kudos
I remember as a child, having parents be part of the classroom a few times a year. Particularly when it came to class parties and fun events. Parents would bring goodies and gifts for us students. Some parents did this for their own children when it came to birthdays etc. Others did this for the emotional offering of support to the students in my class because they were sympathetic and empathetic of certain kids' home lives. Having healthy parent role models in the classroom is a healthy thing and I don't see a problem with it.
The problem is parents don't even show up nowadays. They get angry when you even ask them to.
Apparently teen pregnancy didn’t exist before Cardi B.
One of the biggest issues I find in these forums is the fact that so many participants are misinformed on what they’re opposing. Several people in the room didn’t know what CRT or white privilege is, so there can’t be a productive conversation about whether or not it should be taught in schools.
So much time is spent arguing over the definition of the subjects, and far less time spent discussing the issue of how schools are supposed to “fix themselves” without adequate funding.
Blaming Black and brown music for corrupting "the children" is an old narrative to justify bigotry. First it was Jazz, then Rock & Roll, etc. It's as if white people only found out about sex through Black music...I don't know how they were procreating before they interacted with Black ppl or heard Black music. Maybe it was through divine intervention?!?
I hear you and I agree that it's frustrating to see stubborn ignorance but it is satisfying to see someone share a powerful point only to have it deflated in front of them because they thought it meant something else or because it quickly contradicts something they said earlier and they just realized it.
It would richen the dialog if there wasn't so much time educating people about their misconstrued beliefs though. Still, I thought it was a great vid.
Schools have adequate funding. The funding simply needs to be spent to benefit the students, not the faculty.
@@SarcasticData great point 😂
@@darcyfraser6493 you can’t get one without the other. If you want top talent to teach students, it requires money. Schools should have well payed educators and highly funded students. No choice needed.
Having an active HS student in this was actually a pretty cool move by Vice
I agree, she is very brilliant and provided great context to the discussion.
@@darrienjames30 which one was he?
"My voice should be heard" - teenager
Lol.
@@kayvonmansouri Right? I didn't catch that at all. I thought they were all teachers
@@kayvonmansouri She was in the front row wearing the white and red sweater.
We need many more of these conversations! This was a great discussion.
this is a powerful conversation.
This series of "debates" (really, just good open conversations) is excellent because it recognizes every participant's humanity. More of this please, it's what we need!
Expect when you look at the reality that alot is cut out of the video from this "debate". Whether or not you agree with a viewpoint any editing involved allows biases to leak through, these need to be raw and uncut to be a true debate.
or lessening a opinion
Except they're from VICE, so on average they have 2 leftists per conservative and a leftist controlling the conversation.
"it's the Cardi B music" hahahahahahahahahaha i caaaaan't 🤣
The problem with the US education system is simple:
Good education teaches people how to think. The US education system tries to teach people what to think.
Wrong