I’ve always loved how well the cymbalist of the Scots Guard band played the cymbals like opening it to let the crash ring out and the way he lifts them up at 2:52
So, may I ask, what is the official rule for others in the military saluting the Queen's Guard and Band while they are marching in formation? Is it optional? I notice sometimes, the guards at the barracks gate salute the band and guard, today they saluted only after the band passed... Sometimes they don't salute at all... Sometimes only one of the gatekeepers will salute, sometimes it seems as if they purposely look away, I presume so they don't need to salute? As I watch the videos, I picked up on the inconsistency. Just wondering. Cheers.
They will salute the officer of the guard (as is standard anywhere, salute should always be given to their commission). Sometimes, they'll salute after the band has passed and just before the officer passes them, or what's a little more common, is that they'll salute when the front of the band passes them, and stand easy once the whole guard has passed - more coordinated that way. You are right to notice how some of those on gate don't salute, it's usually those with rifles, as they're actively looking for any threats who could enter the barracks or engage with the guard. Those otherwise, will salute (poor practice if they don't). Edit: As ‘Curious Until Newly Told’ rightfully said, DoM in the band ranks (being an officer) will also be saluted to.
Thanks for posting this question. I have often wondered about the inconsistency. I prefer that the guard(s) at the barracks gate salute both the band and the guard that follows.
From what I recall, it’s actually this: you always salute a formed-up party of 20 or more troops under arms who pass you. The band is not under arms; the duties who are mounting the guard are. Humans being humans, and soldiers being soldiers, it’s not consistent because people forget, don’t know, never knew, etc…. If it were about saluting the officer, gate guards would also salute when the band passes, as the Director of Music (marching, without an instrument) is an officer. Anyone want to pull out the relevant sections of the Drill Manual so we can be sure?!?
@@leobruce7196 In the US, an "Honor Guard" marching in formation is to be saluted by anyone in uniform (unless carrying arms, in which case the arms will be presented, if practical). As they are saluting the honorable formation itself. I was assuming the Queens Guard marching in formation garnered a similar respect. Thanks for the info.
![แฟนแนวใด๋ - ยูริ โตเกียวมิวสิค [ SyncVersion ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Fm8oDwos2uc/mqdefault.jpg)
Love them,,Love the marches , everything about them ,,My that was sooooo good great video
list of marches:
1. Stirling Castle
2. Scarlet and Gold
3. The Glaswegian
4. Washington Greys
5. Scottish Emblem
6. Milanollo
I’ve always loved how well the cymbalist of the Scots Guard band played the cymbals like opening it to let the crash ring out and the way he lifts them up at 2:52
Fantastic Scots Guards. Loved the music
Fantastic M events well done
Awasom band
So, may I ask, what is the official rule for others in the military saluting the Queen's Guard and Band while they are marching in formation? Is it optional? I notice sometimes, the guards at the barracks gate salute the band and guard, today they saluted only after the band passed... Sometimes they don't salute at all... Sometimes only one of the gatekeepers will salute, sometimes it seems as if they purposely look away, I presume so they don't need to salute? As I watch the videos, I picked up on the inconsistency. Just wondering. Cheers.
They will salute the officer of the guard (as is standard anywhere, salute should always be given to their commission). Sometimes, they'll salute after the band has passed and just before the officer passes them, or what's a little more common, is that they'll salute when the front of the band passes them, and stand easy once the whole guard has passed - more coordinated that way.
You are right to notice how some of those on gate don't salute, it's usually those with rifles, as they're actively looking for any threats who could enter the barracks or engage with the guard. Those otherwise, will salute (poor practice if they don't).
Edit: As ‘Curious Until Newly Told’ rightfully said, DoM in the band ranks (being an officer) will also be saluted to.
@@leobruce7196 I prefer the second method that you mention. Thanks for your comment.
Thanks for posting this question. I have often wondered about the inconsistency. I prefer that the guard(s) at the barracks gate salute both the band and the guard that follows.
From what I recall, it’s actually this: you always salute a formed-up party of 20 or more troops under arms who pass you. The band is not under arms; the duties who are mounting the guard are.
Humans being humans, and soldiers being soldiers, it’s not consistent because people forget, don’t know, never knew, etc….
If it were about saluting the officer, gate guards would also salute when the band passes, as the Director of Music (marching, without an instrument) is an officer.
Anyone want to pull out the relevant sections of the Drill Manual so we can be sure?!?
@@leobruce7196 In the US, an "Honor Guard" marching in formation is to be saluted by anyone in uniform (unless carrying arms, in which case the arms will be presented, if practical). As they are saluting the honorable formation itself. I was assuming the Queens Guard marching in formation garnered a similar respect. Thanks for the info.
I painted that shop next to Savilles tho
Music
Red shield
Birdcage walk
Grenadiers return
Washington post
To your guard
Fame and glory
Rubbish vid!
Mate, you’re wrong. First march is “Stirling Castle.” 😅
And you don’t need to list down the names of the marches, already listed.