Teaching 9th Grade in a 93% Mormon Town
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ก.ย. 2024
- Empower your critical thinking and stay informed on breaking news by subscribing through my link ground.news/al... to get 40% off the Vantage Plan for unlimited access this month.
A few resources I mention in the video:
*Why I left the Mormon Church: (www.mormontrut...)
*Religious affiliation in American Fork, Utah: (www.bestplaces...)
*Other demographic data in American Fork, Utah:
(datausa.io/pro...)
*Story of BYU’s LGBTQIA club:
(www.usgabyu.co...)
*Tyler Glenn’s music video for his song Trash about Mormonism/Joseph Smith:
( • Tyler Glenn - Trash )
*Child sexual abuse facts:
(www.nctsn.org/...)
A few videos that may interest you:
*My Mormon endowment explained video: ( • Secret Mormon Temple C... )
*Mormon garments explained video: ( • Mormon Garments Explained )
*Every rule I followed as a Mormon: ( • Every Rule I Followed ... )
*My Mormon mission was a waste: ( • Mormon Missions Explai... )
*Complete story of my Mormon wedding: ( • Mormon Temple Weddings... )
- where to find me -
Patreon (ad free & bonus content): shorturl.at/8bpnw
TikTok: / alyssadgrenfell
Instagram: / alyssadgrenfell
Blog: www.mormontrut...
Email me: alyssadgrenfell@gmail.com
- support my channel -
Venmo: venmo.com/u/Al...
Empower your critical thinking and stay informed on breaking news by subscribing through my link ground.news/alyssa to get 40% off the Vantage Plan for unlimited access this month.
fascinating
@@kinghenryxl1747
@@alyssadgrenfell The club for true spoonfed puppets who want to follow someone who left the church for sex.
Honestly, a lot of the shit your students did are just adolescent shenanigans and are done by kids all over the world I have taught 7th-12th grades in Texas for 16 years, and I've got some stories, too. That being said, the overwhelming majority of my students weren't all members of the same holier-than-though sect claiming moral superiority over everyone else while acting like an asshole to someone who shows them kindness and patience.
@@clb8645 quiet braindead.
Oh my gosh I was one of your students!! No wonder why your face looked so familiar. I always felt so bad about the class and the kids were awful in it!! It’s crazy listening to all of this because I remember this English class so vividly especially every thing we studied. I just want to say that some of the things you taught have stuck with me from all these years and appreciate what you taught. That class was rough with the kids in it, they were straight up rude and disrespectful, it always bothered me, being a shy and quiet kid. So I’m so so sorry for that. It’s crazy to see you do something so amazing now and reconnect to some degree. Love your stuff, keep it up!
As a teacher, I love this comment! That’s all teachers want is to make a positive impression on our students.
I hope you've healed. She deemed like a great teacher.
Proof?
Here's hoping you left the church and never looked back!
Oh this is so sweet. I hope she sees this
I lived in a half-Mormon area and we were all taught in church that black people were black because they "hadn't been valiant in the pre-existence" (pre-mortal life). It was very much taught and understood and accepted by everyone. No one seemed to have a problem with it. Suddenly no one would say that anymore after 1978.
"The new Stevie Wonder album just got dropped, he says some stuff on it maybe we should change things."
“And I believe… that in 1978, God changed his mind about black people (black people)” #TheBookofMormon
I was taught that in the 2000s. I know they continued to teach that in the 2010s, judging by what others have shared with me. It is a pervasive part of mormon oral doctrine, even if they try to pretend that it never happened.
What's crazy is how easily they seemingly erase these teachings from newer generations of the membership. I was in such an active family and yet never heard this till I was an adult. They're so good at gaslighting people into thinking the church has never been problematic/racist/sexist/etc.
I still heard that, mostly among Mormons in social settings, but occasionally at church, in the 80s. The whole thing about skin darkening in response to evil behavior (with the Lamanites) was still in the primary manual. I had a teacher of color in 1985 at public school, and I loved her, and she taught anti-racism at times. That was very dissonance-creating experience, since my dad was overtly racist and had a copy of “Mormonism and the N--o,” which is basically the official racist handbook sold in LDS bookstores in the 70s. It was a very confusing thing for a child, to be taught that the gospel is unchanging, when it is very obviously drastically changing.
"If you think that teaching history is activism, maybe you should think about why teaching history promotes people to be activists."
Just brilliant.
I have. It’s because it’s pr0pagnda.
@@bluecannibaleyes what parts?
This woman is rock solid. Respect!
Very profound.
it depends on what history you select to teach
"Not bullying someone to the point of suicide is so woke."
This sums up the world we live in so well! Thanks!
THIS. WTF humanity??
Such a terrible thing to be.
Could be the new Twitter motto.
Internet culture is why this is, well, that and the unscrutinized corporate monopoly control of every aspect of our lives.
I was one of the utah teens that attempted. I was so sensitive and undiagnosed autistic and also queer af but didnt know it. i was bullied constantly. Teachers like you kept me going. Thank you for talking about this.
(I'm 27 now, still struggling but alive and happy to be alive and loudly myself in washington)
I want to move to Washington, seems so nice
@@aviatornic2839 it is a lot nicer than Utah entirely
I moved from Utah to Washington 56 years ago when I was 20-ish, and yeah it’s way better here ❤
This story is nauseating honestly. "Racism isn't even a problem anymore" while actively committing racist bullying
It's actually a surprisingly common "anti woke" talking point.
Alot of people who want to pretend racism isn't a thing will point to people like MLK (a person they would of hated back in the day) and say: "racism was ended by [insert name], therefore we dont need any more progress".
@@virtualcombat6425Or worse: “We had a Black president, therefore no more racism! To that I say, “are you f@#!ing serious?” and quickly walk away from that clueless person.
@@mxnjones precisely. I think alot of people underestimate the amount of cultural and economic effects cause alot of what would be considered racism, and simple things like having a president that happens to have dark skin isn't going to change that.
And this is coming from someone who doesn't live in the U.S.
Those racists think that you pointing out their racism is "racism"
Honestly, having lived in a mostly white town(had one black kid in my classes in high school) while also having lived in a mixed race area of California and then the south.
I’ll just chop up their thoughts to ignorance. It’s very hard to see racism in a place that white. A place will easily integrate one family without too much issue.
California was honestly very tribal.
When I got to the south I was insulated by being in the military.
I dated a girl who I perceived as probably more left politically drop a racial slur randomly at one point.
Then had her mom tell me about the integration problems at a certain school she was told to ignore and not report.
I do think how we talk about racism could be better. We always go to the most egregious which is great to get attention.
The most common racism is you just don’t get the job or the house. It’s very subtle and often very hard to perceive. Even the racist person will rationalize it. Because most people aren’t a cartoon bigot. They would just be a little uncomfortable with a black man at work.
When I taught in a daycare, I had a child's father yell at me for trying to change his son's view on playing with children of another race. The little boy wouldn't play with another child or his sister because they were Indian (From India). I told the little boy that this was unacceptable, and wasn't right. I made him say that he was sorry to them, and asked "Where did you learn that this is okay?" He never told me. But, his dad came up to me the next day and yelled at me for teaching the boy that his actions were not okay. He actually asked: "Why are you asking my son to play with those Indians?" I said, "Because, they are good kids and we need to be kind to everyone. Not, just people that are like us."
This makes me so sad to read. I am white and my husband is Indian. I visited India with him recently and everyone was so kind, welcoming, and giving. I wish we cared more about these kinds of things instead of caring about skin color.
I’m a teacher as well and have had a very similar experience to yours but involving a different group of people. It sickens me that people can be so gross and ignorant towards others.
@@amlc6045are you Canadian?
Hoped you learned your lesson, Agenda 47 will strip those migrants of the citizenship they stole from you and your (God willing) white christian children. Of course youll come up with UNPATRIOTIC answer that reeks of SOCIALIST propaganda so I'll just pray that God has mercy on your bruning soul in heck ❤
I would've said something like "because we all have to work together with each other, including me having to deal with you". And this is why I'm not teaching or working retail lmao
Were they being mean to them? Not wanting to play with them is not the same as being unkind. Freedom of association should be respected.
Emmett Till was my mom’s cousin, their cousin Wheeler Parker was with Emmett the day/night of the events, and my grandfather was the one to drive Wheeler up north in the middle of the night to make sure he wouldn’t be taken by Emmett’s murderers. I grew up hearing his story a million times from our family, but I hardly ever had teachers that knew his story, let alone ones that taught it. It’s so cool to me that you cared to share this with your students, and I am SO sorry that you had this experience. You are wonderful and brilliant!
(Also, his mother’s name is pronounced like “May-Mee”!)
That's why we need to teach all of history! I never heard of Emmet Till until I was an adult. I never heard of the Oklahoma City massacre until the anniversary of the events. We cannot learn from the past when we hide the past. You and your family have my sincere sympathy.
I’m surprised more people didn’t learn it. Where I grew up everyone learned about Emmet Till in history class. My teacher showed pictures of his body. I’m also a history teacher and I’m pretty sure he’s name dropped in the curriculum standards we use for social studies. Problem with teaching is that that in some states teaching it could get me fired or arrested because “critical race theory”.
Your cousin's story needs to be told in schools and I think its one of the most important cases in history regarding racism, hatred and intolerance.
I think I was vaguely aware of it but not the details.
It’s was whole day in history class at my high school. Part civil rights section.
Wait…THATS MY SCHOOL?! I can’t believe that it’s in a video, I’m literally going into 9th grade and I feel so lost and depressed. I was Mormon for a bit but my family stopped going and didn’t really care for it. My mom and dad grew up with extremely Mormon parents. I’ve learned a lot of things about Mormonism and it’s very cult like in some ways… I’m also a quiet kid in general and listen to others more than I would talk. I hear a lot of the kids calling things gay and just being disrespectful to teachers and other students in general. I personally am bi and if I ever said that I was, I probably would be bullied for it. Thanks for speaking on these topics! 😔🫶
You seem like a good kid. Keep your head up.
Hey. I don't mean to shove down your throat, but as one myself, I would really recommend Christianity. I struggled with religious legalism ('do x, y and z or you're not right with God') when I was younger, but God started to call me out of that a few years ago. The biggest thing with Christianity is learning about the love of God for us, shown most strongly by Jesus' becoming man dying on the cross, and how to love Him in return-- everything that we do is just a product of our love.
It gets muddled by other things sometimes, probably because it's hard to grasp, but that's the whole of it--the love of God.
John 3:16
As a bi there is no welcoming religion. Not even Buddhism. I'm sorry. Faith is good. Organised religion is the opium of the people.
as someone who is also bi, im not sure if thisll help, but in these types of schools (going to a catholic school with homophobes, but its definitely not as batshit as this) its really important to find your people and stick with them. massive luck to you tho, hold strong 🫡
I come from a very "macho" culture in Puerto Rico and at least in my generation and location most kids around me, particularly the stronger ones, would protect the weaker kids from bullies... What I saw in Utah was just pure bully behavior. I love my upbringing and we were pretty conservative but part of being a "macho" is not to be an abuser because abusers are cowards.
I love that, strength not for the sake of strength, but strength for the sake of protecting those less strong is what it really means to be a man 🤘🏼
She was surprised simply because she never spent any time around people FROM Utah before moving there and teaching their hideous kids.
They are just plain awful people. They've ALWAYS been like this, back in the early 80's their kids were JUST LIKE this.
Now she knows.
It's just how it is.
“abusers are cowards” is something to remember
One of my school trips when I was 14 was to the Anne Frank house. I don't know if you've ever visited it but it has very graphic images of the concentration camp mass graves and filled gas chambers.
Two of my class mates started hysterically laughing at the pictures. Something that infuriated many of us as we tried to make sense of what were seeing. Our teacher explained to us that not everyone always knows how to deal with cetain emotions and will react in very 'odd' ways as they process their feelings and perhaps shield their true emotions towards peers by, in this case, laughing.
Putting his emotions and judgement to one side, the teacher took the two outside and explained in a calm manner how their reaction made him feel and then asked how they were really feeling. One laughed again, but the other became emotional.
I was reminded of this memory watching your (once again fantastic) content.
It sounds like you had a fantastic, insightful teacher.
Really insightful and empathetic teacher. A lot of teens will respond to stuff like that in absolutely shocking and disrespectful ways and a lot of times it is just because they can't maturely process or deal with those emotions yet.
Two of my classmates last year took a selfie in Auschwitz concentration camp. With smiles and everything, I finished 11th grade, they are supposed to be almost fully mature. I still don't know why they did that in an acual concentration camp.
@@NinaMalecka-ux8trtheir parents didn't model good behaviour and didn't require them to mature
Well that's a very controversial topic and well...
Those mates might not be :"dealing with odd emotions" so much as with propaganda.
I commend you for sharing the photo, you are indeed living to the legacy of that poor kid mother.
Thank you for your comment
As a father to a mixed race teenage boy, I see that and think “that could have been my kid.”
I had never seen it despite knowing the horrible story, and it will live with me.
@@alyssadgrenfell tell the whole story about how he grabbed that young married woman and what he said to her. Tell the part about how they thought it was the body of an adult man. Don't repeat the fake propaganda story about how he was "just a little whistling 14 year old".
@@aa-yt7wo where is this energy when its one of your friends or desired political careerists? Noo, its all fake metoo shit unless it feeds into your confirmation bias.
@@alyssadgrenfell you are succeeding. I'm not from the US, and we did not go into that much detail, we barely learned about Rosa Parks
It’s funny how you ended up being a teacher of sorts now, just not the kind that your father expected and honestly I’m glad you came to this point on your journey and teach what you do.
I’ve had that same thought before
The lord works in mysterious ways 🤪
I was thinking, why she is giving the same vibe as Hannah Alonzo, who makes anti-MLM content. They are both teachers! Makes sense (beside the similarity of topics)
I did my student teaching in a Utah high school, and it was a nightmare! In my first couple days, when I'd literally done nothing but observe (as was the plan), my mentor teacher told me that I didn't have what it takes to be a teacher and should find something else to do with my life. I hadn't even done any teaching yet! (I'm sure her judgment had nothing to do with me being a wheelchair user.🙄) The teachers had no respect for me, and no respect from their students, so of course it didn't go well when I tried to step in and teach.... But that was 18 years ago, and I'm a very happy and respected teacher in Oregon now!
The kids assumed that racism no longer exists only because they never personally experienced or witnessed it. Many (if not most) of them have probably never even traveled far outside of the Mormon Corridor!
Why I made my husband turn down a job in Idaho. First of all we are Canadian. Second, almost the whole town was Mormon. We’re not. I knew we wouldn’t be able to handle it.
Good decision imo, in my experience Idaho is even worse than Utah
You made a good choice. I was living in Wisconsin at the time and got a job offer in Utah. I turned down the job because I had met former Mormons in college and knew from them it was a cult. Moved to NYC instead. Still don't regret it.
New York, yuky. I had to say that. Been there, done that, bought the T-shirt, got out, threw away the T-Shirt.
I made my wife turn down her job offer for the same reason
Good call. Sorry Idahoans who don't suck. I know you exist.
Even IF racism was "not a thing anymore" why wouldn't you discuss it? Is history not important? It's the wrong way to look at things...
Exactly. Never understood that argument
I mean a lot of people criticise English class because they only learn about long time dead authors and classics they would never read.
@@catalayalafaye5337because english class is about empathy and media literacy. You have to understand how to put things in their historical contexts and find meaning or use of it today. it's actually a very useful skill. albert einstein said "education is not the learning of facts, but the training of the mind to think."
@@idkanymore5921fr people complain about learning nothing in school but then they have horrible media literacy with modern shows and online posts like i promise you your school taught you media literacy, just not in the direct way you think because technology changes too quickly for that atm
It’s like saying “World War II ended, therefore no one needs to talk about it anymore because it was all resolved and doesn’t matter anymore”
As a lesbian in utah, I got told so many times by boys that they would fix me :/
Oh, if only I had a penny for the times I had that line said to me. I'd be a very rich woman! 🙄🤷🏻♥️
@@vikkiledgard8483 Dudes just can't handle hot chicks not being interested in them.
Can't fix what isn't broken LOL
I'm also a lesbian in utah and.. things are interesting for sure
I can fix you all of you.
As someone who grew up in the suburbs of Utah and attended public high school here, I can confirm that all of this is true. Some of these Mormon kids were the most cruel people I’ve ever met. The culture here is actually crazy even when I was in fourth grade, my friends would bring me books of Mormon to give me at recess. I was one of the very few non-Mormon kids in our class at one point. I was even told that I was a horrible person because I was not Mormon.
the thing that makes it so weird is that generally, Mormons put on that "overly and overtly nice" schtick around non-mormons, at least at first? They act like they're the nicest people you've ever met, but then behind closed doors or when among their own things are different. It's super odd
Anyone who reads up on the mountain meadows massacre - which id guess isnt a popular subject in utah - would get a pretty good idea of what mormons are really like. Amd what they are capable of.
Imagine those kids saying "racism doesn't exist" does a racism laughing at a kid who died from a hate crime
Classic mormon hypocrisy
Mormonism as a religion was founded by a literal con-artist. Ol' Joseph Smith had no idea how cultish his followers would become
The story about the girl who asked about the character's pregnancy reminded me of 2 things I lived with friends of mine in a Utah public high school too. I was a foreign exchange student in a Utah hs for a year, I'm not from the USA so I was quite confused about a few of these things. First, one of my friends was terrified that she might be pregnant, she was so scared to go get a pregnancy test, I told her that I would accompany her to a Planned Parenthood place to get one (I didn't know much about where to get it in the USA but I knew PP helps so my thought was just to go ask them), she immediately refused at hearing PP being mentioned, we continued talking and she seemed to be very confused about what had happened, even saying she thought she might have been raped which of course made all my alarms go off because that's a super important and strong thing, and when she continued talking, it turns out she had hugged her bf with their underwear on, definitely no intercourse. She didn't know how people get pregnant, we were 15. It also made me worry that people are so lacking in knowledge that they might not clearly recognise a rape situation.
The other story is from a different friend whose parents were very strictly Mormon, they watched every movie before she was allowed to watch it to determine whether it was correct (she wasn't allowed to watch Phantom of the Opera for example). She was allowed to read a romance book about a wounded soldier, and there was a sex scene. She came to the group of friends at lunch time SHOCKED that there was a sex scene and her shock was that it was there but mostly because the woman was infertile. I was very confused, but I had to be the one to tell this 14-15 year old that people have sex because they enjoy it and not only for reproduction. She seemed very surprised. I'm still shocked to this day. This all happened in 2015-2016 btw.
Mormons are taught that Planned Parenthood is evil because they do abortions there, and they think abortions are super bad murder or something 🙄 I literally had no idea what else PP does until I became an atheist in adulthood, but I'm sapphic ace so it didn't end up being that vital for me anyways. Crazy stories but I can totally see both happening in Utah.
Do you like it when others are mean to you? This is the question I would ask a bully.
They would say," no. "
Then my response was then , " Why are you doing it?" I would also tell kids that it's harder to be nice to others, but worth it.
Also, I would make the bully think of better ways to act verse how they did. The bully would also be kicked our of the Afterschool Program as we followed the Zero Tolerance for Bullying.
This was as a Prevention Specialist.
@@angietyndall7337 I'm unable to see what your reply has to do with this person's comment???
Sex ed is so important. Refusing to teach kids and youth basics about sex ed, relationships, and consent makes these children perfect victims for abuse. ❤
@@chloecamille5390they probably meant to put it in the general comment section, not as a response to this particular post. Harmless mistake.
My husband had similar nightmares teaching high school in Idaho… and he enjoyed teaching. When he moved on to teaching at the college level, he received consistently high teacher evaluations.
However, being one of only two non-LDS teachers in a 90-something percent school district, it didn’t take long for my husband to know he had a target on his back.
He had the worst problems with kids whose parents were on the school board and/or whose dads were bishops. Because he could not discipline them. Inevitably, the principal would get complaints if he so much as issued a detention. He was told to let the principal handle disciplinary problems. So then my husband sent those kids to the principal.
The budget cuts that the state had threatened were passed. Naturally, he and the other non-LDS teacher were let go. The excuse was his “inability” to maintain classroom discipline - despite the fact that his fellow teachers and most of his students knew he was being sabotaged.
I went to school in a district that while neither in Utah or majority Mormon (only 10-15%), there were Mormons in positions of power on the school board, city council, and main town employer. The kids of those power players were frequently disrespectful towards their classmates and teachers, especially the boys. Your story is sadly familiar to me. Fortunately, the “Mormon Mafia” eventually fell apart due to retirements and elected officials being voted out.
As a non-mormon, I have experienced this when all of the non-mormon were "released" during a slowdown while Mormons were hired during the same week.
Thankfully the main employer where I grew up couldn’t pull a stunt like that due to being part of the federal government.
One more example for separation of church and state.
@@KarenHawes I wouldn’t have minded free periods for religious studies if it were easily available for students of all religions. In Idaho, nobody gets elective credit anymore for seminary, which I think is fair enough, considering that only LDS public school students got the privilege. It’s bad enough that the “free periods” do not accommodate non-LDS students. But at least LDS students are being treated with a little less blatant favoritism.
Still, the one time I attended a sacrament meeting (I was an invited guest musician), one of the speakers lamented that LDS public school students no longer got credit for seminary.
This Catholic high school graduate, who busted her butt to maintain her scholarship eligibility and whose parents sacrificed to cover the remaining tuition so she could receive religious education during school hours and who sacrificed more time and tuition so her children could receive the same privilege, had to bite her tongue to keep from yelling, “Well, cry me a river!”
Thankfully the friend who invited me understood why I was so offended. One significant part of my religious education was visiting different places of worship, talking with various religious leaders, and learning what it’s like to be Jewish, Greek Orthodox, Presbyterian, etc., in our community. I think all LDS students should do the same, because while some know non-LDS are second class citizens here and love it, I think most are just oblivious - which is why my daughter, after transferring to the public schools, continued to begin all student led prayer with a sign of the cross as just a reminder that not all the students are LDS, but they’re entitled to the same rights.
I attended 8th, 9th and 10th grades in a Utah public school. It was an eye opening experience. I was, like you, a rule follower. Quiet, introverted, wore no makeup, had long straight hair, modestly dressed, polite. Had a very important surname in the LDS church.
Just...one...minor issue...Wasn't Mormon. Never had been Mormon. Was immediately mistaken for one.
What I would have done: Break the mormon stuff. Openly drink coffee. Wear open stuff. Maybe even prank students into mormon blasphemy.
I feel like if you’re not Mormon in Utah, there will be some aspects of the culture you’ll assimilate in. Am I right?
It depends on whether they follow the rule from the Apostle John that anyone who hates a brother or a sister is blinded by the darkness. (1 John 2:9)
However, I get confused regarding how much of the real Bible gets accepted by Mormons, especially if they try to make strict rituals, as opposed to say following how the Apostle James says that faith must be shown with taking care of people’s needs (James 2:15-17).
@@evannibbe9375,
You need to read the Fables of Conman Smith to understand the cult's doctrines.
And you weren’t canceled for going to school in “Mormon-face” or “Cultural Appropriation”?
As someone who used to teach 9th grade English in a wealthy area of Texas, this video gave me flashbacks. Sometimes the kids were bad but it was the parents and the enabling that got to me. Teaching in the US is very, very bad right now. Teachers are facing level of abuses that make the actual act of teaching nearly impossible.
I’m nonbinary, sapphic, and visibly neurodivergent. My experience of majority-christian school in Utah has been quite difficult. I have few friends, all of them are queer as well, and we were targeted by other kids for entire years.
I would have to buddy up with my friends during lunch if they wanted to leave our table for anything so they wouldn’t be alone. Kids would still harass us there too though, doing things like purposefully spilling food or drink at our table or bumping into us.
We were consistently made fun of, called slurs, barked at, had our belongings stolen or ruined, and lots of other nasty things. Two of my friends even left the school due to mental health issues. I just remember wishing everyone would mature already and be kinder.
For people who claim to hold such good values, they really can be awful. I’m moving schools this year though, so hopefully it will be better.
Thank you for talking about this.
@@recreationalmcnukes3966 ancap bhvr
@@leighdownunder not exactly an ancap, just somebody who would like to not chuck people in cages for speaking truthful words that hurt delusional peoples feelings.
@@recreationalmcnukes3966 “ancapistan” goes so hard rn
@@leighdownunder it's really telling that you got no argument other than: haha ancap pfp
@@leighdownunder so if people are logically able to debunk your ideas, and it hurts your feelings, they should be thrown in jail right? thats a hate crime in 2024, right?
I grew up in utah county and i moved to washington my senior year of high school. It was the most intense culture shock. You dont realize how much the mormon culture affects EVERYTHING until you move away
Oh man I experienced that culture shock moving from Salt Lake City to Seattle a month after graduating HS. Mormonism is literally threaded through EVERYTHING in Utah!
"until you move away"
And land in Baltimore, almost entirely Catholic. Similar phenomenon, different religion.
That must be a shock. WA is one of the most athiest places in the US. Any interesting anecdotes?
@@KaletheQuick "WA is one of the most athiest places in the US."
The Cascade mountains are more than just a rain barrier; eastern Washington is culturally distinct from western Washington.
@@thomasmaughan4798 I am fully aware of the various demographic nuance of my domain. Thanks.
35 students per class is way too many.
Welcome to the public education system
Damn, this is a culture shock for me! Here in Brazil that's considered an ideal class size, because it often can go up to 50+ students in both elementary and high school. In public, free, schools, 50's the norm, in private, paid, schools, it's an occasional occurrence. My current senior HS class, in a private school, has 55. I've heard public schools with much, much more than that.
She made sure we knew they were mostly white. I guess we're supposed to make some assumptions based on their skin color.
@@brazman4722 Americans have no idea how good they have it (as usual) and don't realize we often squander the resources we have. The worst part about our education system is that it's decided upon by political fraudsters instead of education experts. It's a mish-mash of broken pieces state-by-state, instead of a unified RATIONAL curriculum, like every other advanced country has. We simply REFUSE TO LEARN what has been successful around the world so of course our students' performance is sub-par.
@@scootermisty YES, IT'S FUNDAMENTAL to the story! What is she supposed to do, PRETEND it wasn't?
Denial of racism is the new racism.
I’ve been a high school English teacher in the UK for nearly 10 years. What you say about temperament is so true - teaching really isn’t for everyone, and I have full respect for anyone who tries it and leaves. So much better to get out than stay and end up hating yourself and the kids.
It’s totally crazy to me that in Mormonism your Dad effectively has the right to choose your career.
Also I have the privilege of teaching in a place where racism and bigotry like the awfulness you describe is not tolerated. I can’t imagine sticking around in the circumstances you describe. Hideous.
I barely made it to the end of the year and giving my resignation was such a relief. But everyone knew I hated it by the time it was over. Thank you for all you do as a teacher, you have all my respect
I am not Mormon, never have been, but I do have a similar story to "your Dad chooses your career". I am physically disabled, so when I was starting college, my mother told me to go into teaching because "teachers sit down most of the day." This coming from a woman who quit school two weeks into 9th grade in the 60s. I quit my teaching degree a year into it, and got an English degree instead. However, I did substitute teach for four months back right before the pandemic hit. Ya'll, I almost never sat down, I had to try to be subtle and lean against desks as much as possible to get off my feet.
@@angelastokerThis reminds me of my time as a substitute teacher! I was always up and walking around all the time…so exhausting!
I used to teach in the us and will be teaching in the uk very soon. It’s wildly different in the us. It’s not really about temperament in the US. Everyone is leaving because it’s so horrible. Yes, I know there is a teacher shortage in the uk, but it’s so bad in the us that in many states you don’t even need a license/certification/degree to teach.
Also the pay is wildly different. As a teacher in the us, I will never be able to buy a house on my own. In the uk, I’ll be able to buy one after about 5 years. (For a comparison, my last year teaching in the us, I worked part time at a bookstore to make ends meet. I made less, between my two jobs, than the assistant manager of that bookstore. I had a masters and had been teaching for 4 years, in education for 8) We also have to plan to have children in late may, because we only get 10 sick days per year
Moved out oof the south cause I hated the racism and it was too big for me to outstubborn.
"the most righteous were the most cruel". Yeah, this is how righteousness works...
This is how conservatives conserve the quality and nature of their societies and why they despise and disapprove of liberals so much. 💔🇺🇸
Anyone with anger or cruelty in their heart is not righteous. Please don't get false piety mixed up with true righteousness.
@@MH-be6hr I'm a conservative and I have never sought to conserve anything through violence or cruelty. Instead, I try to convince others with my words and my life not to throw their value away for the latest fads. ❤ It's good to move forward, correct wrongs, learn from the past, become better. It's also good to know fire burns and gravity is a fact. It's the heedless rushing headlong into the next fad without carefully considering the consequences that most conservatives take issue with.
@@sandigrace2271Mate, that’s kinda what conservation is. The goal is to conserve, and not exactly always just the “good” bits either, but the bad bits as well. You as a conservative may not be cruel and righteous, but unfortunately, theres enough of them who are for that statement to hold some water.
Just because you don’t think someone isn’t righteous for whatever reason, either it be cruelty, piety, or whatever else, doesn’t mean said person doesn’t see themselves as truly righteous for their actions, or even view you as a being false believer for not following in their tow, or going to the same lengths they do.
We like to think those who have the same beliefs as us who preform violence, or go to extremity, aren’t true believers, or followers, to whatever cause we follow, or beliefs we hold- they’re “different” from us. But unfortunately, those lot of folks typically view themselves as being true practitioners, correct/justified in their actions, and even tend to be significantly more active at expressing said views for their beliefs… They’re also a lot closer to us than at times comfortable with.
And sometimes the cruel and righteous types ARE the majority thanks to the very nature of said doctrine and beliefs they follow, abiding to the letter, and regardless of the belief system, the cruel and righteous tend to be the most active and aggressive group when it comes to implementing said beliefs, but also trying to crush anyone who not only oppose them, but even those with similar views failing to follow said extremity, or preform some pushback.
@@sandigrace2271 hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
"that racist time was so long ago" Ahh yes, back in thee olden days of 55, when you're parents (or maybe grandparents) were young. Back then television was called television, and phones were connected to the wall. Just think all the current politicians we have today were just starting their careers in office! Oh yes, such a by gone era of yore.
Oh no, Mormons in Utah are still actively racist, but there's a very few black people in Utah. Their racism comes less in the form of n***r and more in the form of pearl clutching and treating the few they see like zoo animals. Utah Mormons see them as useful inclusions to prove Utah has gotten past it's racism, but if blacks ever became a risk of becoming a large minority, the racism would come back out in full force.
Given 1955 is almost 70 years ago. It woul be grandparents or great grandparents for these kids. Likely great as mormons pump out babies fast.
Doesn't mean racism like ended then
I grew up in Juab County in Utah and this is so accurate. I tell my mom all the bullying and horrid things these kids said and did to me when I was young and she has a hard time believing it because, "their family is so nice and they go to church every week". I hated growing up there and I still do not like or want to associate with the people I grew up with. Every time I go back, my mom says, "there's so and so, go say hi" and I always have to tell her that I do NOT want to associate with someone who bullied me and treated me like garbage our whole childhood and she always hits me with,"I'm sure they have changed, you know they went on a mission". Even if they've changed I do NOT want to associate with someone who treated me the ways they did. I was very mormon and a rule follower all growing up and no matter what I did, even when I started to rebel like them, they still treated me horribly. I talk to my siblings and one person (who is my sister from another mister) from there, who I grew up with and she has been my best friend since second grade.
I also grew up in Juab County and moved out as soon as I could. While I was never bullied, I still hate going back to visit my mom because it's a vipers nest of immature hateful people. Yes, there are some kind and welcoming people here and there, but on the whole, it makes me feel sick to listen to people's conversations. I'm glad I got out. 😅
Is Brandon Flowers still worshipped?
I grew up in Juab County as well as was bullied.
I have a niece who thought she was lesbian and finally came around and married a nice guy.
@@kaylynnirvinesthetics liar.
1) grew up in rural utah (non-mormon), and my 4th grade utah history class centered around watching the film "Legacy" at the Joseph Smith Memorial Building. It was a BFD, as we had to bus in from about an hour away.
2) I would say that perhaps the nicest part of being isolated as an LGBTQIA student was that they wouldn't touch me or get close to me because they were afraid I would "turn them gay", which really saved me a lot of time.
also, 3) I was told I shouldn't bother going to college, since I could just work in construction until I found a man to take care of me......(this was late 90s, early 2000s).
4) I also got proposed to 4 separate times between 9th and 11th grade, by boys who said they thought I would "make a really good mormon" and asked me to wait for them to get back from their missions.
Sadly, I dropped out of high school, have never been married, and have three graduate degrees...so I have really let everyone down.
Thank you for sharing your stories.
Your last sentence made me giggle 😄
I hope you really don't feel like you let everyone down? I think you are doing (and have done) fantastically well. Three graduate degrees?! 💪🏆👍🏻♥️♥️♥️
Please tell me that one of those degrees is in costruction management.
@@chloecamille5390"thank you for sharing your stories"?
@@xXxzAAa0aAAzxXx oh I'm sooo sorry let me clarify, person adding so much to this thread, I meant the second to last sentence because the last one was an aside to the content creator.
As a retired male Utah high school teacher of 30 years in the Salt Lake School District, I’m so sorry for how you were treated. Over my career there were many good students of all races and religions. Most of my best relationships were with non lds kids. The cliques of lds students were stifling. The non lds kids could have a decent conversation with me. Some lds kids could, as well. Lds kids were too busy with church to learn how to communicate with an adult. There were a handful of Mormon kids who were just the greatest. You are an amazing teacher today and I think you’ve found your calling.
Retired here also. Some groups were worse than others but I definitely had years where the mormon cliques were awful. Teacher shopping for active mormon teachers was common. Quid pro quo was the motivation.
Choose A career that makes more money!!! 💵💵
@@MH-be6hrI’ve been retired 9 years, loved my career and am living very comfortably money-wise.
@@MH-be6hrWe need teachers, and they deserve better pay for the work they do.
My family moved to Utah as non mormons when I was in early elementary school. It was a crash course culture shock for all of us. My mom worked in a junior high school cafeteria. The stories she would come home with were wild! Kids would try to bully her, a grown woman because she wore a cross necklace. Young boys would brag that they held the priesthood, so they could get away with not cleaning up after themselves and believed they had authority over my mom. Luckily she had one LDS coworker that was open to answering my mom's questions about mormonism, and was very kind to her. She was the ONLY LDS person we came into contact with that was open to a discussing her faith with us in a non condemning way.
As someone who went to a Utah junior high school, I value your experience and can only imagine how hard it was, and you were a practicing member at the time!
Alyssa, your story about connecting deeply with one of your students and hearing your voice crack when you spoke about the horrible bullying he endured cut deep. You may have been a first year teacher who felt you were naive, but a true educator looks for students who think outside of the box like he did and encourages them to pursue those thoughts. You likely made a positive impact on his life when he needed it the most. Maybe teaching in a Utah public school wasn't for you, but you are a teacher through and through. Makes sense - you are the only reason I know half as much about mormonism as I do now. Thank you for being vulnerable and sharing your stories. ❤
I'm mixed (father is black, mother is white) and I've experienced racism from a young age in my evangelic christian school. A teacher said that my hair was ugly bc it's curly, a group of students put me on a slave role while making a theater about colonization in Brazil, people said I looked "dirty" bc of my skin color, a few years later my classmates laughed at the movie T.H.U.G (which talks about racism and police violence) while I was in tears knowing similar things happened to my father and could happen to me or anyone that looks like me. Now, in college getting a degree in History, I aspire to teach kids about our past and in some way reduce that kind of awful behavior white kids are allowed to have, lacking total empathy towards their black or mixed peers.
(Sorry for any spelling mistakes, English isn't my first language but I rlly wanted to talk about it. From all your videos that I watched, this one story and the one about homophobic comments touched me the most).
I am so so sorry.
No one should ever have to go through that. Thank you for sharing that story. I hope every day that one day we’ll get past this stupidity and treat humans like humans. Needless to say, in the U.S. it seems to be going back the other way lately, and it’s horrible.
@@Ceibhfhionn thank you, bud!
@@Wud-f2r thank u, I rlly do hope things get better even though hate groups seem to be growing worldwide. As a future teacher, hope my work gets to change that a little bit.
Honestly, I didn't spot any spelling mistakes in your comment! In fact, your 'non-native' English is a whole lot better than some native English speakers!! 💪💪💪💪👍🏻 You're going to be fantastic at breaking down those barriers. Good for you! Bravo 👏🏻 👏🏻 👏🏻 ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Hey. Just an FYI Till’s mom’s name is pronounced “Mae-mee”, to pronounce it as mammy could inadvertently be seen as pejorative. What you are doing is super important and I don’t want your message to be lost because you accidentally said her name wrong. Some people look for any reason to reject a message, I dont want a simple mispronunciation to cause someone to have cringe reaction. You are doing a great job. I have learned so much from your channel and I want you to be encouraged. Keep up the good work and keep learning and growing.
Thanks for that! I was disturbed by her name, so I’m glad to hear her name is “Mae-mee”. It would have been tragic if she actually had the other name.
Sorry to be stupid, but why would it be so bad?
@Stooge2 there's an old stereotype called the mammy, that's basically a black slave woman who does childcare work for the white family
@@Stooge2 “Mammy” pronounced “mah mee” is a word that has been used as a stereotype to depict black woman as slaves in domestic roles in a white home; such as black women taking care of the white children of their slave masters. This stereotype often portrayed these woman as enjoying slavery due to their perceived aptitude for childcare, and has be used for justification of slavery. And slavery is ALWAYS unjust.
For full context, I’m not black and don’t want to speak over any black people who know more about this as their voices have much more value here, but I also think that I’d like to leave an explanation if no one else does.
@@kirbylover5418 thanks!
RIP, Emmett 😞
I'm sorry for how humanity failed you 💔
Not "humanity". WHITE PEOPLE. MY people had NOTHING to do with it. Do you see how that works?
Can you see how language is part of racism now, even if you didn't intend it? Solving racism is not just about a simple fix, it's about white people fundamentally thinking differently.
35-40 is a ridiculous class size for a single teacher.
Really ? As a student (the more privileged kind) in my country all the way from elementary to college always a class above 30 sometimes 50+ were not un common
@@augustuslunasol10thapostle i'm not saying it's uncommon. although, 35 is definitely on the upper limit of what i saw in my time in german schools 10-20 years ago. Classes i was in personally were mostly in the mid 20s.
I'm saying, it has been known for a while that large classes have a multitude of disadvantages for everyone involved, which should frankly be obvious.
There is simply less space and time for individuals to recieve the attention and help they need.
my teachers would always disregard the hateful things my peers would say and often laugh along with it, it was really sad to see
I'm my 9th grade Geograpy class I heard Hitler jokes, holocaust jokes, jokes about massacre, jokes about pretty much everything. But don't worry they were respectful during seminary
As an ex 9th grader from Utah who thought those jokes were funny they are more or less a coping mechanism for the horrors of the world.
I'm a 70's kid and where I grew up ALL the racist jokes were Frenchman jokes.
We lived across the boarder from Canada.
Cops in schools will always seem totally batshit insane to me.
@@google_is_a_criminal*”WORDS CAN NOT DESCRIBE HOW MUCH I HATE FRANCE RIGHT NOW.”*
-Soldier, TF2
Hey Alyssa! I'm not mormon but was raised very christian so there are a few things I can relate to in your stories - but outside of all that you're such a powerful, insightful, articulate speaker. So much respect for you.
Please keep speaking on your experiences. I feel like open-mindedness is becoming a less common trait every day, we REALLY need more people like you out here.
I taught for over 42 years. What you experienced was how some kids treat new teachers. You are correct in assuming that you were picked on because of your youth and inexperience. The fact that you administrators did nothing is appalling.
Like you, when I first started teaching, I was often mistaken for a student. However, being African American, I was a pretty strict teacher. I loved my students, but, I didn't put up with BS. However, I never had students who were so overtly disrespectful. I'm sorry that you were bullied and nothing was done to hold those kids accountable.
Finally, if it became known that I was secretly put on any social media account, I would've protested to the superintendent. What awful human beings they were at that age! I do hope that they've matured since then and realize how wrong they were. That is my hope.
Funny story. I used to live in American Fork and it is still very mormon. I left the church and one of the first things I got was a tarot card set. I don't believe in tarot cards but they are fun. (don't get me wrong if you believe in tarot cards thats perfectly fine no shame here). I was anxious for them to arrive from amazon and wanted to get to the package before my parents did because my family is very religious. This was when I still lived with my parents. My mom got to the cards before I did and I snatched them and went downstairs to put in my room. When I went upstairs my mom was waiting for me and said exactly "please promise me you won't become a witch or a furry." So moral of the story it seems like if you do anything that doesn't go with the religion you are destined to become a furry 😂
This is so funny omg 😭😭😭 Such a comically ignorant comment towards you and also furries! Dang!
What amuses me is that she even knew what a furry was. Must've been a common occurrence within the community 🤣
My dad used to shame me for wanting to become a doctor instead of a stay-at-home mother to a large family. He said I was selfish and violating God's role for women.
Nevertheless, I continued to pursue my goal of going to medical school until I was badly injured and left disabled after being hit by a drunk driver on my way to work.
No man has ever asked me to marry him, either.
she made furries sound so cool wtf
@@MH-be6hr Just know you are stronger then most. You have quite the resilience. And besides you need no mad lol. Well unless you want to find someone you will.
you are so well spoken and so socially aware and it made me so happy to hear. i was raised in a completely opposite area, in northern california: where we were actively taught how to be aware and active and it’s so great to see that there are people on the other side of the table that can recognize the importance of that within communities that don’t prioritize that.
The part about gay people genuinely made me cry. I didn't grow up mormon but I grew up catholic and went to catholic schools all my life until I graduated. I had never came out to anyone except my very closest friends who I knew weren't homophobic but I know the feeling of not being able to be openly gay in a school environment. On top of that around the time I realised that I was actually gay (I have always known, but couldn't really admit it to myself until i was like 13) my school fired a teacher for being gay. That was genuinely the reason. The teacher never brought it up, never pushed or even mentioned it to the students but they found out through some legal documents. That made me, a lesbian in the closet, even more scared cause if even that teacher who never even mentioned being gay was "caught", what if I also do? So I had really bad paranoia and anxiety but luckily I made it out. I had thought about taking my life a lot but was too scared to because in my eyes taking your own life was a sin and disrespecting god. But at the same time I also didn't want to live a life full of sin. I was never bullied for it luckily, but I still find it hard to accept that I am a lesbian even like 7 years later. I'm slowly accepting myself more and more. But yeah it's genuinely so sad to see that homophobia is still widespread and my little sister still goes to that school and it's still a really homophobic environment so the story of that boy really moved me. I really hope the church both of the mormons and catholics will become more inclusive or at least accepting. Cause I was a believer too and if I had been taught that god loves me no matter who I love I probably wouldn't be having such a hard time accepting myself right now.
I’m Catholic and believe that God loves you no matter what! Most of my Catholic friends believe the same and hope the Church will officially change.❤
@@user-fr4ye3yd7v That's luckily also what most of my catholic friends believed but unfortunately not the church itself and since the school was and is still owned by the church homophobia was pretty much pushed on us even indirectly. I did leave the church now because i no longer believe in it but most of my friends are still religious and not homophobic. It's just the church as an organisation that i personally don't wanna support financially anymore (even though they get a lot of the tax money so even if you leave the church you still partly fund it). I still respect people who believe in god but if trains have more rights than gay people in the eyes of the church then that's not really what i support lol. some of my friends have also left the church but continue to believe in god without paying church tax and therefore supporting the organisation but i do neither cause i don't wanna support it and additionally don't believe in god anymore
Public school teachers have also been fired for being gay, as well. On the recent past. And, there are still schools who have this “rule” on the books today. I am very involved in my union (20+ year public school teacher).
More and more, traditional public schools are not a good thing for many students. Students can be SO MEAN. Some parents are t much better. And, of course, there are teachers who are just as bad…unfortunately. The amount of students who have major anxiety just entering the school, being in the school (especially the cafeteria and hallways), etc. is VERY concerning to me. Many of these students have a high absenteeism rate, as well. Makes me very sad for the state of our country and our educational system.
I wonder sometimes if our Higher Power created so much diversity amongst us in order to test us…after all, it was Jesus’s message that we all love one another. It blows my mind that so many organized religions spew so much hate. There’s a huge difference between religion and spirituality.
@@WhatAWonderfulNameItIs Here public state owned schools can't fire teachers for the reason that they're gay (Germany) but since the school is church owned (even though the church paradoxically is largely funded by the state) they can pretty much do what they want in the name of religious freedom unfortunately. So yeah if it were a state owned school that would not slide but of course the church finds every little loophole in the law...
I had heard that the mother had him in the casket as he was, to impress on people what brutality had been suffered. But I did not know that picture existed. OMG, anyone who laughed at that has no soul.
She did indeed. The open casket was to say, “Look what they did. Look what these horrible men did to my son.”
@@mariesabine2385 In a sad way I'm glad I saw the pictjres but it was so horrifying. I once clicked on the photo of a young lady who had been horribly injured and burned when a drunk driver hit her car. I can't unsee that and wish I could.
@@deniseeulert2503 I’m so sorry
The sticky notes probably mean they were racist trolls but usually, the more horrifying and serious something is, the more likely teenagers are to laugh out of tension and awkwardness. They don’t know what to do with emotions like that.
I saw the photo in school at a similar age to these kids, our entire class was silent- pure horror, we couldn’t think of anything to say- to mock it blows my mind.
To your essay writing friend: I love you. I'm here for you, love. You're older now, and I hope so much you see this video and know Alyssa and everyone in the comments care for you.
I really dislike mormon culture, as an ex mormon I find it stunning how different life feels and how much wider my perspective on the world is when I stopped being surrounded by the chronic group-think in the church. I have several gay family members and I remember hearing unbelievably horrible things being said by one of my young men’s leaders about “The Gays” and all of my peers were laughing and agreeing with him, I yelled at him and he was too scared to tell my parents that I cursed him out but I very rarely went to any youth activities after that and thankfully my family is now fully out of the church and we’re much happier now. Only 2 people I knew in the church are still my friends after I left and they’re amazing people, but I remember how lonely it felt realizing that my “Friends” were only my friends under the condition that I was one of them.
We're always glad to see the weak dross and offal leave the church. It makes us stronger and really seems to make the posers happy. Hope you're in that group.
@@JohnDLee-im4lo Your profile says you’ve left over 100 comments on this channel, just move on bro LOL
@@ZekeLawl I still have a few comments to leave. Besides thanking you for your welcome absence from the church, I must let you know that you are not missed by anyone! Thanks again.
@@JohnDLee-im4lo Hopefully they’re giving you some tithing back in exchange for this white knight behavior and insulting your brothers and sisters who have left
@@JohnDLee-im4lo If i’m not missed by anyone how come they won’t stop coming to my door LOL. Seriously man, this channel was never meant for you. This is a sanctuary for victims of your cult and people looking to leave it, you actively chose to click on this or seek it out and now you’re just being a keyboard warrior for at least 12 days according to your profile. Let’s make a deal, I’ll never go to church again if you never come back here 🤣
I can listen to your voice all day. Your rambles are so engaging.
Even if you’re in the closet but live with deeply homophobic people, it greatly effects how you view yourself. I’m a bisexual woman and I view myself as offensive, dangerous, aggressive and inherently wrong / dirty.
I'm sapphic ace and non binary and I definitely relate. It took a lot to work through how mormonism made me view myself 😞
I’m so sorry that you are feeling that way. You’re not dangerous, you’re not wrong, you’re not any of those bad things. Your bisexuality is valid, healthy, human, and normal. I hope you can get into a safer environment as soon as possible. Peace and respect ✌️🏳️🌈🩷💜💙
I am so sorry you feel this way :( No one should feel dirty for being queer. I think being in the closet means that people share their homophobic views without having to consider the outcome/cost of speaking that way. You are not dirty for being bisexual, and I hope you can come to see that for yourself, but I know it is a long journey.
I am sorry about your experience. I’m demi/bisexual but consider myself blessed to have been raised Catholic rather than LDS. Having lived the greater part of my life in southern and eastern Idaho, I am very familiar with LDS culture and the extreme pressure to marry (and only a member of the opposite sex).
Now I did end up marrying a man. However, being raised to respect singleness and celibacy as no less important than marriage, knowing that I had options, being raised by parents who had honest compassion for LGBTQ+ people, being taught that an orientation, like any other characteristic, isn’t a sin, being equipped with the tools to live honestly with my orientation and my faith (being demi definitely helps), etc., took a lot of pressure off me.
I don’t envy women who were taught that they can’t reach the celestial kingdom without being married for time and eternity to a Mormon man, especially while my Church has canonized women of all walks of life, single and married.
The idea that acting on (or as frequently happens among us on the ace spectrum, contrary to) our orientation is in no way less forgivable than fornication/adultery committed by cis-het people has helped many of us keep our faith.
No, it’s not always easy. I’m in a group of LGBTQ+ Catholics and hear all about their struggles. As for me, I wish I were raised in a generation that wasn’t so hypersexual, when saying, “I can’t possibly be attracted to someone if I’m not in love first,” didn’t get me labeled a “prude” by my peers. But that’s a problem with how society generally expects everyone to have sex and treats it like it’s essential for a complete life. Not a problem with my religion.
I am also a bisexual woman, and I fully agree! I spent 20+ years of my life identifying as straight, even though my first kiss was with a girl, even though I wrote love poems to girls in my class right next to my crushes on boys, even though I thought everyone was beautiful regardless of gender for as long as I could remember. I identified incorrectly because I grew up in a homophobic community and church, and I felt like there was no other option than being straight.
You're not alone. You are normal. You are valued. You are worthy of love. I hope that someday soon you can find a community that helps you feel that you can be yourself without fear or judgment.
Love this topic. I was a high school teacher in a very Mormon area of Arizona. Lasted four whole years. Now I have student loan debt and I’m not teaching anymore. I should add that I am not Mormon and have never been. I grew up in Florida so seeing seminary right next to the high school and finding they actually put it on the students schedules was very surprising.
They not only out it on your schedule, if you're non Mormon every year during enrollment there will conveniently be a block innthe schedule where "there's no classes available... We have Seminary available though."
Dealt with that for three school years straight after moving to Utah until my parents threatened a lawsuit if they tried forcing their Cult on me ever again.
@@darknessandlife777that was not how it was at my high school in Arizona-you had to specifically get signed parent permission for the “religious-based elective hour” and then my Mormon friends would have Seminary on their schedules when we got them in July. But I was also not in the Mormon hot-spots
30-40 out of 180 is still extremely high 💀 Jesus Christ
I was a non morman in Utah churches and I was always treated differently because I wasn't in their cliques and I was ignored by them. I don't know why but I was always catcalled and sexual harassed by the mormon boys. It's so confusing to me considering what they're taught
Ahhh,,,another victim.
@@JohnDLee-im4lo maybe you should teach your boys not to touch girls when they don't ask for it
You're a breath of fresh air of someone stepping out of the cultural heritage box they were stuffed into since childhood. How entrenched we all are into our cultural/tribal nonsense. Your teaching credential hasn't been wasted, as teaching at its core is about insight and critical thinking, and you're a shining example of that.
hey bro, just wanted to say I'm proud of you. That shit ain't easy but it's so, SO worth it.
Rock on :)
Alyssa, your empathy and care for the essay writing student is so clear. I know that regret can completely take over our memories in situations like that and it’s so tough to look back on events where we should’ve acted differently. You were a positive influence in his life for seeing him for the bright young person he was. You yourself were young, and deserve grace, especially considering how far you’ve come and how deeply you still care for that student in particular. Thank you for being so vulnerable in this video, hopefully students like him can see these videos and know that they’re loved and seen. ❤
Greatly appreciate your videos Alyssa! You're so articulate and thoughtful.
And I appreciate you watching and commenting! It honestly means so much that I get to share these stories with people.
@@alyssadgrenfell Your commentary regarding "if you think teaching history is activism" is so spot on. I study social movements and you could not be more correct with that argument.
My first year teaching was in Utah too. It was the year we shut down from the pandemic. I am not Mormon and I never was or will be. That was my first introduction to what Mormon culture was like. I have trauma from Utah that I am still working on healing from. Thank you for sharing.
Great, now you've got me crying 😢. You didn't fail him. You were there for him. Had an open discussion, and offered all the support you knew how to give. You've got such a nice caring nature and heart. If you weren't still upset and a bit worried THAT would be bad. But it still clearly upsets you because you care so much. That's a wonderful quality. It probably meant more to him than you think. Thank you for bringing sunshine into a life that really needed it.❤🤗
Alyssa, I am so glad that this atheist found your channel. How great that you have the courage to share your difficult journey with us all.
You are a good soul. When you described your frustration over the problem kids' ignorance about modern racism, I could feel how disappointing this was for you as a young teacher. When you told us about the child that was bullied and had attempted to take his own life,
the tears in your eyes touched me. Adolescent boys are a nasty bunch, I know, I was one. I think you are an exemplary role model for many reasons. You are probably making a difference to many lives with your channel and, even though you think you are not, you are truly the kind of teacher we all, young or old, can look up to. Keep teaching.
Racism, bigotry, xenophobia, homophobia…are learned. 😢
😞💔
they all have the common root - prejudice.
And how do you get prejudice? By either of two possibilities: Being taught or experienced it.
We humans have the innate pull to categorize things. If you have a very limited wealth of experience, you use that to construct your worldview. If you don't have any at all, you don't know what to expect and thus form your opinion around the experience you will form.
So, what is the first 'experience' a kid will have? ... Being taught. A kid is unable to categorize these things on their own, so they need a framework. If you have a kid that has never had any comments about gay people, they will not have any reaction to a gay person. In that case, though, they may build up prejudices based on that persons behaviour - this is, in most cases, not a problem since, on average, a human will be human, but in unfortunate cases, this may warp their worldview (i.e. there was a serial killer who targeted woman due to his experience growing up with his mother and sister).
TL;DR: Yes, these are all learned, some by being taught, some by being experienced. And the less contact points they have, the harder it will be to make them rething their position.
Very based ideas
@@stls800 long walk -> short pier please!
th-cam.com/video/VPf6ITsjsgk/w-d-xo.htmlsi=LY960t9P6G8bjl4b
I’m an exvangelical high school English teacher, and I had forgotten until just this moment that my career was inspired by a prayer at a church where someone laid hands on my head and “prophesied” that I would teach literacy to children. Wow.
I am a gay man that left the Mormon Church. I was in the Mormon church for 16 years. I found the Mormon Church to be extremely closed minded with no concept what it is like to be different. Thankfully there are people that are different. I could never live in any dominate religious community! 🤨 And I am much happier to be out of the Mormon Church and not be around it anymore!🥳
We're always glad to see the weak dross and offal leave the church. It makes us stronger and really seems to make the posers happy.
@@JohnDLee-im4lo "church" 😆
@@viculty4724 "vacuity" 😆
@@JohnDLee-im4locults are always like this
@@djavanalderromero Idiots too...
this is a seriously great video. i appreciate you sharing this 🤗
This video brought me to tears. How horrible. I commend you so so much for sharing this.
My high school English teacher had a very similar experience to yours, where unfortunately the kid succeeded in his attempt. It was also her first year of teaching and I distinctly remember being in class one day and we were reading from a book and she called in this kid, Tim, to read the next few lines. He had a stutter and really struggled to get through it so there were several other kids laughing at him. She told them to be quiet and pay attention. I remember wanting to tell them to shut up but not doing it. About 2 weeks later we got the news that he had passed. It broke my heart and has stuck with me ever since and I can't imagine how my teacher must have felt.
You're not alone in this experience and I'm going to share your story with her so she knows she's also not alone.
thank you for talking about the lack of s. ed. for children and teens. i have noticed that most people advocating against s. ed. for children are, at best, ignorant and, at worst, concerned their vict.m will learn what is happening. education is power. right on
Many years ago, two young men (Mormon missionaries) knocked on my door. I was home taking care of two babies, while my wife was away on a long trip. I turned away the two men, because I was not interested in what they were pushing. A few moments later, they knocked on my door again. They saw I had my hands full with twin babies, and they asked if they could do anything for me. They offered to mow my lawn, or clean the house. I knew that they were offering from the kindness of their hearts, because I already told them I wasn't interested in their religion. I will never forget that moment of kindness from a pair of Mormon missionaries. BTW, I'm still not a Mormon.
I remember my friend group I had since elementary school almost completely dropped me when they found out I was attending the GSA club. I didn't even think I was personally gay, I was just wanting to be supportive. One of my quorum peers ended up reporting me to the bishop that I was attending, and kept updating said bishop on who I was hanging out with.
I had almost no one, but teachers like you who stood up ad tried their best to quell the casual homophobia really helped me keep going. If all my friends and family hated me, I knew my teacher still cared. I stopped an attempt after remembering how sad one of my teachers would be. They were the only tether I had in some of my worst moments as a teen. Thank you for doing your best
Damn thats actually really sad
I live in Arizona, and as a queer a-gender person, I was bullied like this all through school. After my third attempt on my life, my dad encouraged me to drop out of high school and get my GED. I am successful today and have never been happier!
So glad you are alive ❤
@@meowzerzzzthank you 🥹🥰
Me too, genuinely so proud ❤
I'm working on getting my GED right now, I'm almost there, I just have the math test left! I have such solidarity towards people who chosen the GED route, it's not an easy decision to make and I second-guess my decision every day. I love hearing success stories from GED takers, it helps calm my nerves and motivates me
@@bubblegumnnebulayou’ve got this! I am so proud of you for choosing the path that’s right for you.
I’m a high schooler in Utah and I really like the band Queen. Sophomore year I was Freddie Mercury for Halloween, specifically Freddie from the I Want to Break Free music video, which all the band members had dressed in drag for. I went to school with a fake mustache and everything, it was so darn funny and I was excited to go to school. I got pointed at all day, people passing in the hallway said “ew”, and my white, Mormon friends who planned as a group to all be princesses for Halloween appeared to be uncomfortable around me. I’m not even LGBTQ, and that’s how I was treated for dressing up in a funny costume for Halloween!! I could only imagine how the actual LGBTQ kids at my school, some of which are my friends, are treated every single day. It’s unacceptable.
I’ve also experienced racism as a person of color in Utah high school. Utah is NOT a diverse state. Everyone is extremely assuming and they believe many negative stereotypes of race. Of course this isn’t true for everyone here, and I’ve had good experiences in high school, but I believe that the horrible ways that people have been taught to treat one another can and should be changed, which is why I believe it is important to bring these things up and discuss our experiences with them.
This absolutely lines up with having watched two of my kids go through the Utah school system. I'm glad there was at least someone like your for a year down there. My kids did have a few fantastic teachers along the way but boy howdy the stories they have of some of the others, and even worse, the LDS kids they grew up with are just horrifying.
Boy what a first year for teaching! I'm sorry for all that you endured along with your faith awakening. That's crazy! I Live in Utah and have a degree in Education but only substitute teach for time being. I could relate on some of your experiences. I'm happy for where you are at in life and truly feel you are Educating Now and in a Safer Environment than Ever! Keep Doing You! And Thankyou! ❤
Having grown up in the mormon church and lived many years in Utah, in my experience it is one of the most racist, prejudiced, hate-filled cultures I've experienced.
It’s unfortunate. They style themselves as precisely the opposite, but it’s all just an act. (For the most part anyways.)
I could tell this was a very emotionally draining video to put together. Thank you for sharing your experiences, and for caring about the students who were ostracized by their classmates. I hope that one who had to withdraw from school went on to a much better situation and is living a full and happy life now…
Hi there, I am currently going to Utah Public School. I am going into my Junior year. My family is exmormon and this video is very accurate to a lot of parts of mormon high school culture. The story of you saying that the kid said, "I don't have any issue with gay people, I just don't want them around me" is one of the most accurate things I have ever heard. I do think things have gotten better, but the amount of white kids I've heard say the n-word really does make this video ring true.
@@BoazSzczesny Do you think that those kids casually saying the n-word have even gotten to know a Black person? Are they or their families’ that scared of people who look a little different than them, whose culture they have no problems with pillaging to their hearts’ content?
I was a social studies/English teacher at a Utah school that had a large population of LGBTQ+ students. I remember being about two years into that job and feeling like, if there was a God who had a plan for me, this is where he would want me to be. Of course my Mormon relatives thought this line of thinking was so completely flawed, but I loved that job, and I had a passion for teaching and for working with those kids. That being said, it did take its toll on my mental health. I can't even count the number of students who left to go to long-term treatment programs who never came back. I lost several to suicide, and one was murdered by their own father. Those that did stay had stories of bullying, abuse, SA, and more. It was heartbreaking. In the classoom and the school, there were hard lines drawn between the LDS students and the LGBTQ+ students. They hated each other, and while many learned to co-exist, it didn't stop me from having to break up multiple arguments between the two groups over the years. I worked there up until the end of the 2022/2023 school year, and those last few years also brought restrictive laws passed by the state legislature about trans students in sports, what kinds of books were and were not allowed (and the process for getting them approved), CRT, and more. I actually had to stop buying books for my classroom because I did not have the staff or the resources to go through the state-mandated process of getting those books approved. I had to construct my lessons very carefully so as not to even remotely suggest that I might be teaching CRT (I wasn't, but some people will accuse you of it anyway). Thankfully, most parents at the school were supportive, but many were not really involved and didn't want to be, which further added to the stress and frustration on my plate. After six years, I was burned out, and the salary would not cover the cost of living in Salt Lake anymore. I finally quit and moved on to other things. If I had one message for parents and students, it would be this: Please consider the negative impacts that your teachings have on children (yours and other children). All of the hate and fighting is disruptive to learning. It literally ruins and even ends lives. Teachers are already overwhelmed, and students have enough things to tear each other apart over without adding things like religiously-sanctioned racism and homophobia to the list. No one in a school should have to spend time and resources cleaning up that mess, and no one should have their life ruined because of it. I haven't decided yet if I will go back to teaching, but if I do, it will be imperative for me to find some kind of support system in or out of school to help me deal with the larger impacts that religion has on public schools. I've heard from others who have taught or worked out of state that this issue is fairly unique to Utah in the sense that the exclusion that happens here is so calculated and planned (it's not your standard school-yard bullying). That's scary to think about and something that I hope more people take notice of and try to change for the better.
Thank you for all you did you did for your students. It's heartbreaking to hear what they -- and teachers like you -- endured.
gosh this is so sad to hear. even more because the compensation and support level is so low for teachers. Yours was a very important job.
@@fairywingsonroses Indeed. Parents are supposed to be the primary teachers of our children. When we do our job right, we make the jobs of our schoolteachers a lot easier
Sitting up in Canada, I watch America and wonder why folks would want to like in a theocratic state. My parents generation (born 1920s) saw first hand the theory tic state of Quebec (1850-1960, roughly). It was extremely repressive. One consequence of la Revolution Tranquille (1950-1980s) was the death of the Catholic Church in Quebec. Attendance went from 95% weekly to 20% at Easter, baptisms, weddings, funerals. More couples in Quebec live common law rather than even civil marriage, let alone religious services.
I anticipate that one response to the orgy of repression and destruction the religious right in the USA is having will be a sudden increase in rate of abandoning religions. The statisticians say that religion is irreversibly in decline in America, though a generation or two behind W. Europe, AUS, NZ, Canada.
The religious right should look at the Catholic Church in Québec, and learn to moderate their teachings. Otherwise they may find their churches empty.
19:40 Kids saying "Racism isnt around now" and then they say the hamburger thing... wtf actually their parents and faith failed them
I went to a highschool in Idaho as a non-mormon kid and watching this video and reading comments pointing out that mormon kids often just... didn't have empathy for others really explains a lot about why my school was like that.
You have a beautiful heart. The world is better for you sharing your perspective and experiences. Please continue this important work.
being a highschooler in a mormon town as a non mormon person is crazy
Being gay and out is one of the hardest things you can go through, especially in high school. I reflect on what happened to me and I now am still disgusted that the administration of my school did nothing about. I have been told to unalive myself on many occasions and the school was aware of this. This is not a Mormon thing but a nation wide phenomenon. In a school near me, a kid unalived himself for being bi with a shotgun. The kids who did so were not punished at all. People complain that pride month is silly and unnecessary but we still have teens all over the country who think they should not exist because they are queer. The sad part about my story is that I only graduated from high school a year ago and it is still happening. I hope that we as a society can learn to treat each other better.
I’ve been out of school for awhile, but went to a heavily evangelical Christian high school as a somewhat openly queer person (open secret sort of - I didn’t ever bring it up, but most people knew. If other queer kids wanted to talk about it with me, I would). Was heavily ostracized, banned from participating in certain school functions, constantly told that being the way I am was sinful. I dated another student at one point and, despite keeping it a secret and never being physically affectionate at school, people found us out and reported us to the school administration. We both got threatened with expulsion and outed to our parents without our knowledge or consent. Of courseee I struggled with suicidal ideation, idk how you could not. I’m so sorry your administration did nothing to help, and it’s heartbreaking how common that story is.
I’m currently a kid in a Utah public school and I’m queer (I’m currently mostly closeted, only my friends know about it so I haven’t had anything happen to me). Most of my friends are queer as well. At the end of last school year, my friend put on face paint that were the pride and trans flag since it was pride month and she wanted to show pride. She told me later on in the school day that people in the hallways would yell the f slur at her because of her face paint. There’s also a lot of boys in my school who will call their friends gay as an insult. Once In my English class, we were reading a book where one of the characters was gay. Some boys in my class thought it was funny and made a weird joke about it (I can’t remember what it was) and then my English teacher got mad at them. Another thing that happens a lot is that girls in my school will call their friends their wives and be like “we’re married now” and it just comes across like they’re mocking queer women and they’re relationships. But my experiences aren’t as severe as the ones Alyssa talked about in her video
Alyssa I must say I believe what you're doing right now is exactly what you should be doing. Your bravery and insight in sharing your experiences is doing this world far more good than you'll ever know. THANK YOU!
I can hardly remember anything from middle and high school in Utah. Due to bullying and queer trauma, as well as some childhood trauma I hadn't dealt with yet at the time, I repressed my memories of public school entirely. A couple years ago I went back to my high school to drop off a thank you note to the only teacher who was kind to me, and it was as if I had never been in the building before. Nothing even looked familiar to me. If I try to remember middle and high school, all that comes back to me is a deep feeling of pain. Utah is not a good place to grow up, especially if you're not white and cishet.
Sending love 💕 Glad you’re out of there.
I'm so sorry.
I've been a substitute teacher for some time now, and I had a particular bad set of students in one of the high school core classes. They did all the things, eat in class, cause messes and not clean up, play loud music, talk back, stink bombs, rough-housing, messing with my personal effects, etc. I complained to the principal and VPs, and instead of disciplining the students, they sent another teacher, the academic coach, to tell me how to teach better. Now, I have subbed a lot of classes; physics, chem, gen sci, history, art, alg I, alg II, geometry, stats, trig, calc, etc, and IMHHO, the number one biggest determinant on behavior / scholastic integrity: Is it a required class? All the required classes typically had problematic kids. These were the kids that had to be there. Whereas the higher maths, sciences, and AP / honors classes didn't have problems. Oh, and that academic coach that told me all the things she does to keep her class well behaved?!? She only taught honors and AP. She didn't even have a regular English class.
There are lots of factors that go into why certain students are in AP or honors courses. Some of those factors include zip code, family wealth, and race. Most of that is out of a kids control. If they have gotten private tutoring for 10 years and have a wealthy intact family with a nice home, they are more likely to be in the honors class. If you grow up poor, live in a low income zip code, have a difficult home life, are a margined identity, you are more likely to be slated to be in the general class. I personally, as a teacher, don’t think there should be tracked classes like this. Or if there are tracked classes, then gen ed classes should have a small student number cap than honors/ap, to make it more manageable for educators. And for teachers who have these classes to be given an additional stipend. Because without it, all the good teachers will before whatever they can to get the honors/ap classes with easier kids. And the inexperienced or bad teachers get gen ed, and those kids get the bad teachers, so the kids who need even better instruction to get up to speed are given the worst teachers in the school. It’s part of the school to prison pipeline.
@@Natalie.D Yeah, I think those are all good points. I just found it ironic that the teacher telling me how to deal with the gen ed students is the one that had all the great kids.
I’ve been a teacher - yes they do have these issues. I’m a teacher of color and the amount of racism I saw was SHOCKING. Also, kids of color are often overlooked for ap/advanced classes. I was even told once to only recommend white kids for ib classes and kids of color for avid classes because ib is more difficult. (That was in 2019)
@@Natalie.Dthis!! You are so right!!
You should’ve asked the coach to MODEL effective teaching and show you how she makes the students behave.
Trans woman here, and grew up Mormon & in Davis County.
And I remember saying all the same racist/queerphobic things growing up, which I of course regret. And I CANNOT imagine what it would be like to be a teacher, it must have been awful…
I subscribed and gave you a like. Thank you for sharing such personal experiences, they need to be heard. Those who are ready to grow will understand. Keep up the good work, because our society needs help!
I feel infinitely more [harmy] hearing what they said about Emmet Till. That was a CHILD. He was REAL, and ALIVE, and BARELY OLDER than my parents.
That’s awful.
My son gets soooo angry when other kids disrespect the teacher. Teaching your boy to be conscient of what women are living in their working environnement is the most important thing a mother has to do. This is why the patriarkat wants ignorant young moms, so they don't even know that they CAN do that.
Your presentation is so honest and real, Alyssa. Such a breath of fresh air. Much thanks.
For an introvert you speak so well and I love your compassion for others
Conservatives be like "History is woke"
Was raised Mormon in Idaho and just wanted to say that all the worst people I've ever met are "members."
Some great people I know are Mormon as well but I would say the cops rule applies: not all of them are evil corrupt abusers of power but it sure is hard for the few good apples to do the right thing.
I stopped attending church when as a teenager I got a call from one of my best friends (also a minor at the time) sobbing after she was sexually assaulted in a "worthiness interview" by a trusted adult church leader. I can never forget that phone call as long as I live.
The problem is less in the actual taught doctrine of the LDS church (although certainly weird) and much more the cultural side of it. Mormon scripture is all about being kind and not judging others and being like Christ. But if you've ever lived in a Mormon community you would never ever be able to guess that.
Oh Alyssa you made me cry with that story of the boy who was bullied. Hopefully he is watching and can see how much you care.
In gr5 we watched soldiers in WWI dying. Some got tossed in the air from mines or explosions.
I cried.
Other kids laughed.
I asked the teacher, why are they laughing?
She said "I don't know."
thank you for being a queer (??) kid's emotional support english teacher - a queer kid with an emotional support english teacher
In a rare piece of engagement I was able to sit through your entire video and was moved by your heartfelt testimony. As a teacher who also experienced a crisis of faith of sorts, I recalled my own days as a teacher in state school as you recounted your own. Sadly, the situation you described is not limited to your Mormon town, or even I fear, to America, but is something I also experienced living and working in Europe.
I have one little piece of advice to you if you ever decide to return to teaching. I was amused by the part in your story where you described being completely stressed trying to learn 180 kids' names. I had exactly the same problem and for years I tried all sorts of things to try to remember them, including flash cards at one point. Faces, no problem, but names and faces together, forget it. I really was getting very stressed about it but one day, I realised something: the kids who stood out, whether they did or said something clever, or whether they just were somehow a little bit different, these were the kids whose names I remembered quite effortlessly. After this I dropped all pretense of fooling myself or them, that I would remember everyone's name. And so, I began every new class at the beginning of the year, with a confession, and a challenge. I would tell them, I am not good at remembering names but there was one thing they could do that would almost guarantee I remember them which was simply this.
Be remarkable.
Alas, the culture of education and the mediocrity many young people endure is more or less universal. There were some remarkable people there and I am hoping that others heard the message and that later, as you say, figured out what to do with it. Like you I left state teaching. Difference is seldom tolerated there and much less celebrated. The system and the culture around it are not built for the individual. We aren't all meant to be remarkable but the least we can do is at least permit the possibility.
As a current student as of 2024 the stuff that Alyssa is talking about still happens. It's awful what some students have done and how they treat other people different from them. The things her students have done are truly sickening and I hope that some of them have realized the things they did were not okay.