Now I am 66 and saw them for the first time last week in Portland Oregon. I'll never be the same. There were a few "older" people there, and the others couldn't have cared less about our age. I was four rows of standing people from Shirley.
WOAAAAAA AWESOME!!! in the end of 'not my idea' she goes into a slight cover of new order - temptation!!! been watching garbage vids this afternoon and it's making me miss the past so much. its like, too much.
I think they rocked the house down, one of their better performances as far as sound goes. Garbage is quite unique. I have a great amount of respect they all put their time and effort into the songwriting,.. Shirley got lucky meeting these songwriters as so did they , they took a chance and chance did them well as Shirley became their lead frontwoman, A great band and concert. thanks for posting this :)
Flying bounce house couldnt have said it better great comment. Yea Garbage is no joke ..some true musicianship and professional skill and some kill arraingmennts.
with this live performance ,,one of their best in my opinion ,, i realised ,,that at that point in their career (1998) while other bands were breaking up due to infighting , drug overdoses ,contract disputes and an asortment of other record industry woes and ailments garbage kept right on trucking and releasing really good albums even with 2012s lp not your kind of people they are a reminder to myself and every fan of theirs that in order to stay in the music bizz you have to evolve adapt and keep digging to keep making music that in my opinion will be their lasting legacy + I think Butch Vig was a genious for starting his own band kind of like going one day in a studio with some massively famous band and going ,,man fuck this shit ,,,,,the rest is history my friends
This a great recording!!! Love it how she used to be "pissed off" and a little more "vengeful" in her ad-libs/outro's in the beginning of their career; however, nothing wrong at all being "happy" now. I've seen 'em 4 times and wish they'd come back close to me in Columbia, SC!!! Fantastic performance of Dumb and Push It (using the "quiet" chorus...original concept). Thanks for posting this...very well done!
Shirley singing "You can touch me if you want" or "Pour your misery down on me" is still giving me goosebumps after more than 20 years. I wish I had been there because this place is not very far from here (I live in Germany). But firstly, I was only 16 years old in 1998 (maybe a bit too young to travel to a festival on my own, the Loreley rock is about 200 kilometres away from my hometown) and actually, I started to fall in love with Garbage one or two years later.
Maybe that is, because "Garbage" are just Phantastic ??? Übrigens, ich lebe in der Nähe von Frankfurt, und als junger Mann war ich öfters auf der Lorelei... Hab da da schon ziemliche Knaller gesehn ;-)
thanks sooooo much for this video!! I'm from Argentina, and we just had them here a couple of days ago, for the 1st time in their career!!! Amazing the energy they transmit live!!
Nice to be stumbling upon this! I used to have this gig on video tape, however Garbage had been pretty much off my radar since then. Am gonna check out more recent stuff, too. Shirley's an awesome singer - Great voice and presence.
Vocalista gabage nome dela Saw Shirley ela muito linda moça maravilhosa canta muito legal gostei muito bom demais valeu 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Yes - I get it. Much of recent tours at other links is from phones or such, is horrible. This concert (1998) is wonderful by comparison 'because' it is filmed in Hi-Def with great audio by a film crew. Sorry for any confusion I may have caused.
Bleok Phy wrote: 1998...iPhone... --------------- Yes - I get it. Much of recent tours at other links is from phones or such, is horrible. This concert (1998) is wonderful by comparison 'because' it is filmed in Hi-Def with great audio by a film crew. Sorry for any confusion I may have caused.
por que al bajista de garbage nunca lo integraron al grupo o lo tomaron en cuenta para fotos o como parte del grupo en si, siempre me he preguntado eso.
![Garbage - Open Air Festival @ Lorelei Rock [June 20th, 1998] FESTIVAL SLOT](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/X9Nls3VLgVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![[ TEASER ] เงาะป่า - วงL.กฮ. | TMG RECORD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/M4ObdFfcPww/mqdefault.jpg)
0:18 Dumb
4:24 Not My Idea
8:19 Push It
12:39 Queer
18:19 Special
22:04 My Lover's Box
25:49 Stupid Girl
30:03 Temptation Waits
35:13 Trip My Wire
39:44 Crush
44:34 Vow
50:08 I think I'm Paranoid
53:56 When I Grow Up
58:11 Only Happy When It Rains
спасибо тебе, добрый человек.
Thanks!!
Very helpful, thanks! So it was easier for me to switch to my favourite songs, Queer and Only Happy When It Rains!
Hero
Thanks ;)
Now I am 66 and saw them for the first time last week in Portland Oregon. I'll never be the same. There were a few "older" people there, and the others couldn't have cared less about our age. I was four rows of standing people from Shirley.
Fantastic band for all ages
Now your dead.
You misspelled you're@@Raw-guitar
Nothing better than a great rock band, with a strong beat and melody, and beautiful Shirley Manson fronting them. Damned great performance.
0:18 Dumb
4:24 Not My Idea
8:19 Push It
12:39 Queer
18:19 Special
22:04 My Lover's Box
25:49 Stupid Girl
30:03 Temptation Waits
35:13 Trip My Wire
39:44 Crush
44:34 Vow
50:08 I think I'm Paranoid
53:56 When I Grow Up
58:11 Only Happy When It Rains
One of the best shows I've ever seen of them! I love her for being so brave and strong!
WOAAAAAA AWESOME!!! in the end of 'not my idea' she goes into a slight cover of new order - temptation!!! been watching garbage vids this afternoon and it's making me miss the past so much. its like, too much.
Shirley, strong woman, great singer, great band, strong lyrics. I like Garbage.
they were just a bunch of guys in a band before they met Shirley! Nobody cared for them before they found a female lead.
I think they rocked the house down, one of their better performances as far as sound goes. Garbage is quite unique. I have a great amount of respect they all put their time and effort into the songwriting,.. Shirley got lucky meeting these songwriters as so did they , they took a chance and chance did them well as Shirley became their lead frontwoman, A great band and concert. thanks for posting this :)
Good stuff all around
Flying bounce house couldnt have said it better great comment. Yea Garbage is no joke ..some true musicianship and professional skill and some kill arraingmennts.
My only thing is why the stage is so distant from the crowd ....has less intimacy.
0:18 Dumb
4:24 Not My Idea
8:19 Push It
12:39 Queer
18:19 Special
22:04 My Lover's Box
25:49 Stupid Girl
30:03 Temptation Waits
35:13 Trip My Wire
39:44 Crush
44:34 Vow
50:08 I think I'm Paranoid
53:56 When I Grow Up
58:11 Only Happy When It Rains
nostalgia al 100%, recuerdos de adolecente, excelente concierto,..
th-cam.com/video/IxsIdw94A04/w-d-xo.html al estilo 90'
with this live performance ,,one of their best in my opinion ,, i realised ,,that at that point in their career (1998) while other bands were breaking up due to infighting , drug overdoses ,contract disputes and an asortment of other record industry woes and ailments garbage kept right on trucking and releasing really good albums even with 2012s lp not your kind of people they are a reminder to myself and every fan of theirs that in order to stay in the music bizz you have to evolve adapt and keep digging to keep making music that in my opinion will be their lasting legacy + I think Butch Vig was a genious for starting his own band kind of like going one day in a studio with some massively famous band and going ,,man fuck this shit ,,,,,the rest is history my friends
This a great recording!!! Love it how she used to be "pissed off" and a little more "vengeful" in her ad-libs/outro's in the beginning of their career; however, nothing wrong at all being "happy" now. I've seen 'em 4 times and wish they'd come back close to me in Columbia, SC!!! Fantastic performance of Dumb and Push It (using the "quiet" chorus...original concept). Thanks for posting this...very well done!
Well, 7 years down the line, how do you rate their latest offering?
Sounds anything but happy to me :-)
What a show. What a god damn amazing performance. I wish I had been there.
I was. with Beastie Boys headlining. Can t remember too much though.
Shirley singing "You can touch me if you want" or "Pour your misery down on me" is still giving me goosebumps after more than 20 years. I wish I had been there because this place is not very far from here (I live in Germany). But firstly, I was only 16 years old in 1998 (maybe a bit too young to travel to a festival on my own, the Loreley rock is about 200 kilometres away from my hometown) and actually, I started to fall in love with Garbage one or two years later.
Maybe that is, because "Garbage" are just Phantastic ???
Übrigens, ich lebe in der Nähe von Frankfurt, und als junger Mann war ich öfters auf der Lorelei...
Hab da da schon ziemliche Knaller gesehn ;-)
I WAS THERE...GREAT MOMENTS 😍
Amazing concert. Can't belive this was almost 15 years ago...
thanks sooooo much for this video!! I'm from Argentina, and we just had them here a couple of days ago, for the 1st time in their career!!! Amazing the energy they transmit live!!
Dumb 0:18, Not My Idea 4:24, Push It 8:19, Queer 12:39, Special 18:19, My Lover's Box 22:04, Stupid Girl 25:49, Temptation Waits 30:03, Trip My Wire 35:13, #1 Crush 39:44, Vow 44:34, I think I'm Paranoid 50:08, When I Grow Up 53:56, Only Happy When It Rains 58:11
Shirley, I adore you. Hello from Saint-Petersburg, Russia!
Ver o meu comentário gostei muito bom demais valeu obrigado parabéns pelo convite 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Temptation Waits rocks so hard on this.
What is it about Shirley? Hypnotic talent
Nice to be stumbling upon this! I used to have this gig on video tape, however Garbage had been pretty much off my radar since then. Am gonna check out more recent stuff, too. Shirley's an awesome singer - Great voice and presence.
yes Shirley is the best !
She's got a great sense of humour, I've found out meanwhile :))
Awesome. Love Shirley and the gang!
Awesome - Fantastic etc.. etc...
Great performance. The 96 Rockpalast show is their best imo, but this one is damn near perfect as well.
Steve on the keys with the old spooky movie thing was great. Duke's guitar worked right into that minor key. Man oh man that was good.
Great performance! I'm so excited I'll be finally able to see them live in a couple of months!
Possibly one of the coolest shows of 90's alternative rock!
One of the few performances of Dumb on video and an excellent one too!
Vocalista gabage nome dela Saw Shirley ela muito linda moça maravilhosa canta muito legal gostei muito bom demais valeu 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Yes - I get it.
Much of recent tours at other links is from phones or such, is horrible. This concert (1998) is wonderful by comparison 'because' it is filmed in Hi-Def with great audio by a film crew.
Sorry for any confusion I may have caused.
Thank you very much!
beautiful concert!
I'm a darkling since I was 12 and my love for Garbage determined my life :) I owe them a lot
I love the double high jump at 27:00.
Как же я её обожаю!!!!!!!!!
Now THIS is the Garbage I remember.
SIMPLY THE BEST
Thanks for uploading!
I love this band
It is a testament to their appeal that the oldest and youngest of us love their music. I hope they come to Portland Oregon.
Peu connue en France;
Mais, J'adore;
Une petite merveille que Je me suis empressé de faire découvrir à des ami(e)s, tous aussi accros, maintenant
i love garbage
Really good concert. Loads of energy
Awesome!!
toujour aussi bon garbage ! vivement le 22 novembre au zenith !
Bientôt. Ailleurs. Avril 2019..🦉
Push It was perfect and faithful to the original!
Great performance
Boa tarde sou Leandro Taubaté SP sou fã da bamda gabage nome dela Saw Shirley muito linda demais valeu parabéns 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
4 guys and 1 hot ginger kicking ass,just awesome!!!
LUV how she sings temptatation at the end of Not My Idea... mash that sh-- up, baby!
Fantastic!
amo questo concerto, con shirley così natural...
recorded professionally. the band sounds great. never had such a good look at them.
Garbage is so great live!
amazing show!
Used to be I'm Only Happy When It Rains was my favorite song. I'm feeling much better😅
... and - 480p with great audio - - thanks for not posting stuff made from an iPhone somewhere in the audience. Really.
I am seeing them in Portland, Oregon on 9/27!
I have this show on CD, it sounds amazing. I found it by chance looking for disk 2.0. It's called garbage 2.5
Thx!
awesome!
Yes!
My crush forever
I cant believe this have 16 years old.
And now it's been 20 years! 😀
she was so angry while perfoming Special, it seems that those crazy freaking two guys in the crowd were the matter
She seemed angry the whole show!
Think was the sound
the performance for pushit is so perfect. fucking amazed
toujours..
O melhor da Shirley e o melhor de tudo.
Ohhhh parece ayer!! Shirleyyyyyyy!!😚😚😚
j'adore !
Awesomeness
I loved trip my wire... Shirley shows her great voice in that song
egyszerűen csodálatosak. - le vagyok nyűgözve, akárhányszor látok tőlük valamit.
Awesome Show! Today band sucks!
Wow - I just stopped by to see what this was and ...Wow ... I'm still here...!
Put this band on Mt. Rushmore - seriously.
Muito bommmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm. 🇧🇷 💙🥀
espectacular que recuerdos
The anger she has in "Special" is just off the charts. That and bleed like me is still my two favorite songs.
She was mad because she had problems with her ear monitors. She swipes at the receiver on her back a few times.
The method woman on Special. Given her some space there on the end. Lordy. Didn't expect that.
i agree with you
You had me at Shirley...
Vow is excellent in this show
I see Shirley's all set for the gym.
Sorry for multiple postings - the link or something said "error".
Sorry - not my fault.
Love Garbage - ect...
Stop reading this and watch Shirley.
;-)
Ima Only Happy When I see u Shirley.
Хорошенькая рыженькая... 🤘🤘🤘🤘
Bleok Phy wrote:
1998...iPhone...
---------------
Yes - I get it.
Much of recent tours at other links is from phones or such, is horrible. This concert (1998) is wonderful by comparison 'because' it is filmed in Hi-Def with great audio by a film crew.
Sorry for any confusion I may have caused.
Great show, stupid girl was the highlight though!
Vinícius Oliveira GO!!!
+Vinícius Oliveira trip my wire!
Nineteen Ninety Eight. Long ago and far away
FANTASTIC GARBAGE !!!!! I love Shirley M. ;-)))
Shirley manson one of the very best Front ladies Of her era
Only five people kickin' ass!
_you thought I was a little girl ..._ I can believe more than few people took her for one. And got a rude awakening.
a-f@$%-mazing someone please record more of this band.
oh lucky! well i hope they come to wisconsin...
C'est pour vous rpima 8
the perfect frontwoman for a rock band..
por que al bajista de garbage nunca lo integraron al grupo o lo tomaron en cuenta para fotos o como parte del grupo en si, siempre me he preguntado eso.
El bajo en los discos lo tocan los guitarristas
You don't see sexy Shirley with a guitar very often 24:08