It's scary how good of an orchestrator Bach was in the 17th century. Every part in this fantastic chamber work fits on a functional, balance, textural, and melodic level.
you probably dont care at all but does anybody know of a tool to get back into an instagram account..? I somehow lost the password. I love any tricks you can offer me
@Jesiah Jakob i really appreciate your reply. I got to the site through google and Im in the hacking process now. Seems to take quite some time so I will reply here later with my results.
Trills are the best, i love playing trills on my clarinet. But i have to confess that it sounds better on harpsichord! All this concerto in amazing, from beggin to the end
The Largo is amazingly written. Bach somehow maintains the theme of the melody, yet constantly changes it in a way that is almost like a set of variations.
The ornamental triplet of the measure 3 (Which is repeated all masterpiece) is just precious, insightful and marvelous. As always, Johann Sebastian Bach 12/10. Thank you GeruBach for this video.
It is! Especially that 2nd movement. Everytime I hear that movement that scene from Woody Allen's "Hanna & her Sisters" where Michael Caine seduces Barbra Hershey with poetry and music just pops in my head. Thanks Hollywood.
Interesting, I haven't seen it, probably because it's more of an older movie; I'm only 15! Also I'm not too into movies, but music often plays a big role in conveying their emotion so I can understand.
It's not easy to find the Harpsichord version of this piece instead of piano. I used to know the piano version but then I heard the Harpsichord version in the film "Hannah and Her Sisters" and i was blown away
Beautiful indeed! I must admit that I prefer Bach's concerti in minor keys rather than the ones in major keys. Yet.. the major key concerti do have very solemn middle movements. Ahh... they are all beautiful!
This can also be played on Piano or even so Pipe Organ. All of Bach's Keyboard Concertos exist as arrangments for 2 Keyboards (basically Piano Reducion Scores) and this concerto turns out to be an arrangment of a now reconstructed Concerto in G Minor for Oboe (or Violin, or in my Case 5 String Cello playing the Solo Violin part down an Octve).
ce sont certains interpretes qui peuvent être obsédés par les trilles quand ils joue t Bach. il faut les faire au moment opportuns, pas sytématiquement.
I notice a pattern of these concertos, the 1st and 3rd movements are fast while the middle one contrasted slower and more emotional. Thinking aloud...Very nice, as always.
At 4:48, there was a trill that was played but not notated. Is this on the instrumentalists whim? I love this piece, but i always tend towards the more minor pieces. It seems as if emotion can be felt and portrayed in a truer form when in minor.
In barock music a lot of interpretation is to the instrumentalists. composers din't write al the possible trillers, but you're always free to play a triller if you think it's a good time to use a triller.
ToryK13 Yes, that is why Mozart and Haydn composer almost entirely of major key compositions. They were typically composing for their music to be played to accompany a party or upbeat play, and since minor keys were more dramatic overall, they were discouraged. Baroque composers didn’t have such limitations.
Great Harpsichord!, the Great Genius J. S. Bach ; it's so powerfull, too beauty. Thanks for this. Could you to make a video about the Passacaglia and Fugue in C minor BWV 582? by bach, it's very beautiful to me. Thanks again :)
I'm glad someone noticed this. This is one of my favorite moments of Bach, such an ingenious way of establishing a new tonal center immediately after a rest.
Specifically about the Largo: did you base this off of The English Concert's interpretation, or is that the "widely accepted" way of playing it, if there is even such a notion? I'm not very learned in these things but curious because this is one of my favourite pieces of music but I only really like one interpretation of it (which yours is identical to!)
Where do you get this music? I am learning this on piano, but if you've ever heard the piano version, it sounds clunky and slow. I need the harpsichord transcription. Perhaps you could provide it? Or is there a Website I could go on?
![Bach - Violin Concerto in G Minor BWV 1056R - 1. Moderato [Violin Sheet Music]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vXXAEj5_gBc/mqdefault.jpg)
It's scary how good of an orchestrator Bach was in the 17th century. Every part in this fantastic chamber work fits on a functional, balance, textural, and melodic level.
*18th
you probably dont care at all but does anybody know of a tool to get back into an instagram account..?
I somehow lost the password. I love any tricks you can offer me
@Chaim Jude instablaster =)
@Jesiah Jakob i really appreciate your reply. I got to the site through google and Im in the hacking process now.
Seems to take quite some time so I will reply here later with my results.
@Jesiah Jakob It did the trick and I now got access to my account again. Im so happy!
Thank you so much, you saved my ass!
i love how bach uses a chord progression again and again and turning them into a new piece like the 2nd movement
I love hearing trills on the harpsichord! I love all of the movements of this concerto!
I love playing trills and other embellishments on my harpsichord ^__^
Trills are the best, i love playing trills on my clarinet. But i have to confess that it sounds better on harpsichord! All this concerto in amazing, from beggin to the end
The largo movement is one of the most beautiful pieces of music I've ever heard. Every time I listen to it I enter a bit of a trance-like state.
Playing it it's even better :)
The Sinfonia at the beginning of Cantata 156 is essentially the same thing played with an oboe solo
Yeah !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Music with an unfulfillable sense of longing . . .
th-cam.com/video/8liNR8T1IJY/w-d-xo.html "Tony Stevens (Jessé) If you could remember" COPIED BACH >:(
The Largo is amazingly written. Bach somehow maintains the theme of the melody, yet constantly changes it in a way that is almost like a set of variations.
It was actually composed by Telemann.
At the time, composers didn't mind these "musical favours".
@@gaopinghu7332 Can you please name what 's this Telemann's melody is, I'd like to compare
@@razvilka Telemann's oboe concerto in g major, first movement.
The ornamental triplet of the measure 3 (Which is repeated all masterpiece) is just precious, insightful and marvelous. As always, Johann Sebastian Bach 12/10. Thank you GeruBach for this video.
I have never heard of such a sophisticated piece!The 2nd movement of this concerto is one of my favorite parts.
Bach and the baroque era had the most clear, logical and most disciplined of musical grammar.
I actually love the first movement. Maybe my favorite piece by Bach
Such a powerfull movement! Is like a great opening but very dark
I love how you attached the score together with the music for advanced listeners. It's very useful!
I know nothing about classical music, but I know I love this!!! Also interesting to see how far above this comment section is from most others.
I especially love the second movement, for some reason!
Me too
Bach seems to have liked it as well, Bach repurposed it for other works
It plays in Woody Allen's Hannah and Her Sisters
and the second movement of bwv1068
The reason is that it's simply one of the most beautiful pieces of music.
The ending to the Largo was one of the most beautiful things ever.
Даже слов нет! Полное восхищение! ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Incredibly well played and the support and musical tutorials for the audience are phenomenal...thanks!!
1:17 is sooo beautiful
This is a lovely one.
It is! Especially that 2nd movement. Everytime I hear that movement that scene from Woody Allen's "Hanna & her Sisters" where Michael Caine seduces Barbra Hershey with poetry and music just pops in my head. Thanks Hollywood.
Interesting, I haven't seen it, probably because it's more of an older movie; I'm only 15! Also I'm not too into movies, but music often plays a big role in conveying their emotion so I can understand.
Bravissimo, I will never grow tired of Bach's music!
곡도 좋고 해석도 좋고 편집도 좋고..
People seem to love the largo the most, but the 1st movement is criminally underrated
The second movement is so difficult to count!! It may sound simple but it's definitely a difficult one.
Yes, it is quite deceptively ornate. It's amazing how Bach can create a world in 20 measures.
Amazing!!
I appreciate that you uploaded this work.
3:30
It's not easy to find the Harpsichord version of this piece instead of piano. I used to know the piano version but then I heard the Harpsichord version in the film "Hannah and Her Sisters" and i was blown away
The Largo melody is almost tone row in design.
There's BWV 1056R which is the G Minor Violin/Oboe version available from Barenreiter verlag.
This is very nice, thank you genubach!
Beautiful.
Beautiful indeed! I must admit that I prefer Bach's concerti in minor keys rather than the ones in major keys. Yet.. the major key concerti do have very solemn middle movements. Ahh... they are all beautiful!
So true :)
This can also be played on Piano or even so Pipe Organ. All of Bach's Keyboard Concertos exist as arrangments for 2 Keyboards (basically Piano Reducion Scores) and this concerto turns out to be an arrangment of a now reconstructed Concerto in G Minor for Oboe (or Violin, or in my Case 5 String Cello playing the Solo Violin part down an Octve).
Bach just simply wasnt human
He was the best musical human, a human archetype
The Largo was used in the movie "Slaughter House Five" based on the book by Kurt Vonnegut. I find it to be somewhat haunting yet so beautiful.
i luv that largo
Thanks for uploading!
Damn Bach was pretty obsessed with trills.
Normally ornaments are not written, ornaments were very much improvised!
Trills are a harpsichord thing due to the short sustain. On the piano, you would play them differently.
ce sont certains interpretes qui peuvent être obsédés par les trilles quand ils joue t Bach. il faut les faire au moment opportuns, pas sytématiquement.
Beautiful cadenza!
Una catedral sonora !!
El genio de Eisenach en uno de sus conciertos más bellos (en especial, el segundo movimiento.
I was waiting for this...bravissimo to gerubach and J.S Bach ;)
Bach: with him everything it's possible Everywhere...
Do you have the sheet music of the cadenza? I loved it. I'll be playing this concerto in a month and I want to add it. Thank you!
It sounds improvised! How did your performance go?
I notice a pattern of these concertos, the 1st and 3rd movements are fast while the middle one contrasted slower and more emotional. Thinking aloud...Very nice, as always.
Josh R Sonata allegro form.
because it is the basic foundation of a concerto...1st movement fast and 2nd movement slow...and 3rd is fast again
Josh R start thinking silently
d minor concerto bwv 1052
Thanks for posting.
The second movement is similar to Telemann's oboe concerto in g major TWV51
Is It Trevor Pinnock on the keyboard?
Does anyone know?
Yes, it's Trevor Pinnock. It shows the performers towards the end of the video.
Bach era e é um gênio que retratava o espírito humano através da música e atemporal e infinito sua música vai ser sempre ouvida mesmo daqui a mil anos
I love the largo with pizzicato
this is sick
Beautiful~
At 4:48, there was a trill that was played but not notated. Is this on the instrumentalists whim?
I love this piece, but i always tend towards the more minor pieces. It seems as if emotion can be felt and portrayed in a truer form when in minor.
In barock music a lot of interpretation is to the instrumentalists. composers din't write al the possible trillers, but you're always free to play a triller if you think it's a good time to use a triller.
ToryK13 I also find that minor is a much easier key to compose in.
The trill is in the manuscript.
ToryK13 Yes, that is why Mozart and Haydn composer almost entirely of major key compositions. They were typically composing for their music to be played to accompany a party or upbeat play, and since minor keys were more dramatic overall, they were discouraged. Baroque composers didn’t have such limitations.
That turn at 8:00 sounds so cool if you listen for it.
kills me that they're not doing the pizzicatos in such a good performance, could've been perfect
Thank you.
Thank you!!!!
Great Harpsichord!, the Great Genius J. S. Bach ; it's so powerfull, too beauty. Thanks for this. Could you to make a video about the Passacaglia and Fugue in C minor BWV 582? by bach, it's very beautiful to me. Thanks again :)
Here you go, enjoy!: th-cam.com/video/7S2pm1g70DI/w-d-xo.html
8:42 E flat minor
I'm glad someone noticed this. This is one of my favorite moments of Bach, such an ingenious way of establishing a new tonal center immediately after a rest.
1st Movement is a Banger
much better than any other musician
gerubach Let's do Scrolling Piano Reduction Scores with the Barenreiter Piano Reductions to these Concertos cause they're easier to read.
Wow, this piece has such an inertia to it. Get out of the way and just listen!!
Would you do the video for the violin concerto? Yes 1056 too.
Отлично!
The 2nd movement is good, but I love the 3rd movement.
Specifically about the Largo: did you base this off of The English Concert's interpretation, or is that the "widely accepted" way of playing it, if there is even such a notion? I'm not very learned in these things but curious because this is one of my favourite pieces of music but I only really like one interpretation of it (which yours is identical to!)
This IS the English Concert - see 9:57
Ensemble Changing Dynamics: 2:12 - 2:22
Increase Volume By Density: 1:15
Direct Tone Colour Comparison 2:16 - 2:26
Largo Section Emphasises Tone Colour 3:30
Ensemble Terraced Dynamics 7:07
More Call And Responce 9:25
9:11 Cadenza
Great
Good~
Where do you get this music? I am learning this on piano, but if you've ever heard the piano version, it sounds clunky and slow. I need the harpsichord transcription. Perhaps you could provide it? Or is there a Website I could go on?
imslp.nl/imglnks/usimg/4/4b/IMSLP02260-Bach_-_BGA_-_BWV_1056.pdf
gerubach Thank you! Also thank you for the fast reply.
Anthony Mack Would you also happen to have the individual Harpsichord part for this? I might try to play this with my high school orchestra.
Hi Not found
I recognize the melody of the third movement...
It’s like the one from the Violin Concerto in G minor, isn’t it?
It is in triple meter like the final movement you speak of. Although they are not very similar, they both have a dance-like feeling to them.
3:28
it´s normal dance listening to this music?? XD
Where can I get the sheet music for this? Sorta hard to find the sheet music for just the harpsichord.
2𝓃𝒹 ℒ𝒶𝓇ℊℴ ℳℯ𝓁ℴ𝒹𝓎 𝒾𝓈 ℬ𝒲𝒱 156 𝒜𝓇𝒾ℴ𝓈ℴ
el segundo se parece al adagio de oboe en D
The performers are ignoring the pizz. markings
The score sheet might be wrong.
Hannah and Her Sisters
This track on Spotify???
Simplesmente genial a pena é que nós os brasileiros perdemos nosso tempo e nos empobrecemos a cada dia com tanta porcaria que se ouve por aí.
This is good, but listen to Gould!
who plays?
The tempo is much too fast ! ! When you turn speed to 0.75 it sounds much better.
"Hannah and her sisters" brought me here
😐😑
1st note is wrongly played !
Clearly there's an inferior mordente in there,.. 3 notes,... why on earth people adds more?
This version in Spotify ???
2:45
3:12
7:23
1:35