The ending Arthur deserves, this makes me smile, I like to think he lives a long and happy life. This is the best fan video I've ever seen, the most deep and powerful.
@@I_JetFuture_I As much I would've liked this, I agree. All those happily ever after endings people think up for Arthur wouldn't have made his arc as ultimately impactful imo.
I also always thought the idea of old(er) Arthur would be so cool. Arthur becomes this gruff, but wise old gunslinger who's seen it and done it all going from state to state in the west and doing vigilante work, helping people when he can and maybe eventually becomes a deputy or sheriff of a small town.
@@Fugitive685 Play Red Dead Redemption 1. He's THE Legendary Gunslinger, the only one not to be a fraud besides maybe Black Belle and Flaco. He trained John in Rdr1 to be the best gunslinger, too, making him a waaaay better shooter. He never even dies to a gunfight, he was that good. He dies of age. And when he's like, in his late 60s? He's gunslinging down in Mexico, protecting the people from revolutionaries and government soldiers (since Mexico was a shitshow in 1911)
for anyone saying it would be unrealistic for arthur to not die due to tb, he could survive getting mauled by a bear for ten seconds and then push it off and scare it off afterwards far into his disease
Those are gameplay factors. Realistically Arthur would be screaming in pain on the ground for everytime you got shot in game. But he doesn’t actually get shot storywise just like he doesn’t get attacked by a bear storywise so you can’t compare the 2. Tb back then almost always resulted in death it’s likely Arthur could’ve realistically survived longer but he wouldn’t have realistically healed and be cured from it, not in this time period anyway
@@josephstalin2606 People especially with Rockstar games seem to not differentiate between the gameplay and canonical versions of the protagonists. As in no, Arthur's actual kill count wasn't in the thousands nor did he survive multiple grizzly attacks. In fact, he's only the victim of one during the mission *'Exit, Pursued by a Bruised Ego'.* Arthur at most, would've lived a several years after 1899 with TB but not up to his 60s or 70s.
@@josephstalin2606 he did get attacked by a bear story wise when he went hunting with Hosea which was a specific incident of him getting attacked by a bear
@@theonlydon- No he doesn’t get attacked by a bear story wise tf? You think John can get attacked by wolves and be incapacitated for 3 weeks but Arthur gets mauled by a bear and is seen in the next cutscene perfectly fine? You’re supposed to shoot the bear and back up and the bear doesn’t even attack you it bumps into you and runs away if you got attacked in that scene it’s because you wanted to but the game clearly doesn’t intend Arthur to actually be attacked otherwise it would’ve forced that like with John in the epilogue
@@josephstalin2606 story wise yes he does get mauled. If you don’t shoot the bear with Hosea in time then you get mauled. And story wise Arthur survives
This was beautiful, Dream. Seeing Arthur live out his days with Charlotte and a child, head west and see what's unfortunately become of his old family and checking on John to see the fruits of his redemption laid in front of him was cathartic and fulfilling to say the least. The ending(s) we got made the most sense with the story, but I would've loved to see Arthur experience something like this too after losing so much.
@@jameson4844 Same. They could've went the cheap route and had him with Sadie which makes little sense beyond appeasing the section of fans who desperately ship them together but they didn't.
@@themadtitan7603 the man literally hits folks with "you can't shoot a fart outta of you're own ass". John's dialogue is an absolute joy in rdr1 but considering the fact that years take place after the events of rdr2, it ain't a stretch to say that he changed bit by bit over time. No one really stays the exact same over the courses of time
@@Punpun6745 Eh, I'd say it's a stretch. It's unlikely that someone goes from an awkward guy who can't finish a sentence without stammering and has lines like these to magically becoming this witty, eloquently spoken cowboy in just a few years. Even then, it's still unsatisfying because we never saw him evolve to that point. Like it would've been preferable if by the epilogue, John started acting like his RDR1 self.
@@themadtitan7603 that was the whole point to because he was still like young lad who hasn't grown up off of his britches yet basically Red Dead Redemption 1 shows him more mature without Red Dead Redemption 2 we wouldn't know John Marston personality before and after
@@tylerhodges11 so I dont wanna be a a-hole but Arthur was in his thirties during 1899 so if you do the math he would be an old man or at least 50 or 40
@@spencerpower06467 if u do the math he was born in 63 soe he would be 36 in 1899 which would make him 40 in 1903 and so he would be 47 in 1911 that's not old during his time bud ppl were still fighting Indians in there 40s in the 1800s that's still not old now in today's America idk wym
This was the kind of ending I wanted for Arthur. He found his own personal redemption in a way, before his death, but I would have liked to see him survive to find some happiness. He deserved it.
That would, in a way, be disrespectful of Arthur's last wish. He wanted to die on that mountain protecting John. Arthur surviving but still dealing with TB would have been more unnecessary suffering on his part. Besides, Arthur finding out what happens to Bill and Javier would have depressed him even more. Plus there's always the chance that him and Dutch would reconcile (after Micah's death of course) so he might just join the new gang and end up fighting (and getting killed by ) John later on.
Forget that he still have a bounty on his head, sooner or later someone might come looking for him. Your past will always come back to visit you remember
And then they both continue to become even more wanted men for killing a federal agent and the government and military continue to terrorize Johns ranch and chase them down til ALL of them are dead (Johns family included)
Man you made my dream come true you really are RED DEAD DREAM come true. Thank you for all the effort you put in in making these videos I really love and admire your work
After Arthur's condition worsened in chapter four, the van der linde gang decided it was time to search for the miracle tonic one piece to save arthur. The gang traveled to the fabled island of tahiti in search of the tonic and saved arthurs life. The end
I agree Arthur living out his days in peace with a wife and child would be beuailful but when Micah, Dutch, Bill and Javier gangs killing some many people I feel it would be his duty to stop them
I like the idea of Arthur surviving and the events on RDR1 playing out. Arthur would then find out about John, Javier, Bill and Dutch's deaths and go find Jack Marston and together they hunt down Edgar Ross.
His ending with Charlotte, and them growing old together kinda makes sense. Given the brief yet decent bond that Arthur made with Hamish, and given that you could see that they had similar interests and ideas, Arthur living in the woods in a cabin, after his outlaw days, is something that I could see, especially given that Arthur definitely did not enjoy the city. His ending up with Charlotte, well I guess it could happen, though to tell you the truth I kind of got the idea that Arthur and Sadie seem to be a better match, especially given that Arthur is very very stubborn, it seems like he would need someone whose character is almost equally as strong as his to help reel him in from time to time. My one regret about the game is playing a protagonist who just like John, dies at the end. Maybe Rockstar will make an alternate timeline, one where Arthur doesn't catch TB, yet the rest of the events play out pretty-much as they did, and we get to play as an older Arthur Morgan, and therefore have more adventures with him. I know the idea is probably pretty farfetched, but who's to say it couldn't happen, especially given the fact that in one of the Stranger missions they kinda seemed to flirt with the idea of time travel and all.
After Sadie's husband was murdered and then who knows what happened to her before Dutch and Arthur showed up I don't think she was capable of anything like that. There's a reason he tells her that there more ghosts then people
I have to agree cause initially it would have without tb it would have been like slow tension before all hell break loose but seeing as rockstar was doing worker crunch we didn't get that storyline
I wish the game had ended like this, but because Rockstar Games was incredibly smart, they first released Red Dead Redemption and made it play with John, so this did not happen.
I don't think he would marry her. She loved her late husband and the only reason she is still out there is because of him. Even if Arthur had feelings for her I doubt they would be mutual. Notice how she kissed him on the cheek, she is showing gratitude rather than any romantic feeling.
I see Arthur and John end up meeting halfway through chapter 1 and chapter in the epilogue. They meet again, build the house, and then Arthur goes to California with a new name or something. At the end before he rides off he helps you kill Micah, and then before he leaves for good, he lets you know to speak of his name to no one, ever.
I'm playing through red dead redemption 2 again and this video peaked my interest. I would hope that Arthur still would have had some small communications with the Marston family enough that Jack might have known where Arthur was. so how cool would it have been if in the last mission of rdr1 if Arthur and Jack both showed up and both lit Ross up getting revenge for John. How funny would it have been to see Ross standing they're fishing and turning around and looking at Arthur. Arthur: "How the fish biting?" Ross: "wait do I know you?" Arthur "oh how the tables have turned. You once cornered me and this boy years back in the same way we are now." Ross: "...Arthur?! I thought you where dead. The hell you do. You want me to kill you?" Arthur: "You see you killed my friend and this boy's dad so we're here to kill you."
The ending where Arthur fell into a coma and woke up, so he got the cure for tb which came out in 1907 in the epilogue he found John, and lived with John, after a month John and Arthur built a house for Mary to surprise her so Arthur found Mary, so Arthur is neighbors with John
@@Arthur_calahan I did that I wondered all over the map finding anything and everything. heck I spent many hours I can't remember i accomplish over fifty percent of the game's completion in chapter 2.
I really don't get it.......why did they name the game RDR2 while this game ain't supposed to be a sequel it's prequel, RDR0(zero) would made more sense
2 years after not being able to play this as it was removed from game pass I can finally afford the game in 7 days and I will get to play this masterpiece again
the only way this would have made sense if that black doctor from Rhodes somehow found him, gave him just enough meds to survive, and sent him to Charlotte
If only the ending of RDR 2 had been like this. If Arthur had never caught TB (Tuberculosis), he would have gone to live with Charlotte, and I believe Arthur and Charlotte would have been a great couple and lit out the rest of their days together.
Hello friend I’m still not getting your notifications I have no idea why but every now and again I will come to your channel and watch your videos you impress me a lot could you give me a tip how can you make the characters mouths move
This would been amazing. Imagine if they made a huge DLC where you play through rdr1 with Arthur and John! They woulda survived the barn shooting cause if they both duel wield with dead eye, Ross and his men would all be dead. And uncle coulda live to see another day during that mission.
Great video I would have loved to have a dlc where he faked his death and lives the remaining of his months as a redeemed man on helping people and being a deputy. Also to see him have his own house to live in!
Unfortunately arthur morgan wasn't ment to survive but if he did survive the end I don't think he would have "beat" TB do to the stress his body was in. I think he would try to prolong his life by moving out west, if he recovered enough he could have lived a little while but eventually his TB would have killed him. He would probably make it to his mid to late 40s.
I wish rdr2 would give us a massive update where we can change the endings and events in the game like kill Dutch and Javier and bill in this game where the gang completely falls apart and there all pointing guns at each other Arthur can go into dead eye and shoot Micah and Dutch
POV: John marston is hired by Edgar Ross and he has to hunt down the remaining gang members and with each death of the old gang, John loses more and more morality and after Dutch Is killed John gets some horrific news, the last target. Arthur Morgan, still alive but retired and Not once turned to a sinful life, the past gang members took lots of mental trial and error for John to finally kill, javier, bill, Dutch, and now he has to shoot the man he once called a brother or it’s johns life that will be taken, John arrives at Arthur’s home and has a brief conversation with him before John gives Arthur a rundown of what must happen and he holds Arthur at gunpoint but John immediately remembers all the times Arthur and John had….all those years of being this brotherhood, it must come to an end because of Johns decisions…deciding that this act of killing his own brother his (not related) family member would hurt him too much, John turns the gun on himself
i feel like it could be possible for arthur to survive if he left with john, went to the desert then rested at a hotel for a while with severe medical attention. The dryness and the rest would fight off the TB
i was hoping that Dr. Marko Dragic finds Arthur's body and decides to transplant new lungs on Arthur and then revive him using The Machine(the one that gave life to the robot) and Arthur wakes up inside a cryogenic tube
Arthur: You, Abigail and Jack, go live your lives. John: And you? Arthur: I reckon I’m gonna head West, somewhere dry… see if I can shake this goddamn cough. This is actually a real dialog between them during the last train heist mission when John and Arthur go take the dynamite before meeting with the others. I think it is only triggered if Arthur has low honor, but it could have been nice to have a chapter 7 after all that mess where you play as a weak Arthur in New Austin trying to get back on his feet and move on by himself.
Im 19. Jahrhundert war die Überlebenschance bei Tuberkulose (auch bekannt als Schwindsucht) deutlich geringer als heute. Es gab jedoch Menschen, die die Krankheit überlebten.
The ending we all wanted
I preferred the actual ending
The ending Arthur deserves, this makes me smile, I like to think he lives a long and happy life. This is the best fan video I've ever seen, the most deep and powerful.
@@I_JetFuture_I As much I would've liked this, I agree. All those happily ever after endings people think up for Arthur wouldn't have made his arc as ultimately impactful imo.
Either that or killing Micah then instead of in the epilogue
I prefer Arthur marries Mary, they get a son and live with Marston family at beecher's hope.
I also always thought the idea of old(er) Arthur would be so cool. Arthur becomes this gruff, but wise old gunslinger who's seen it and done it all going from state to state in the west and doing vigilante work, helping people when he can and maybe eventually becomes a deputy or sheriff of a small town.
So... he becomes Landon Ricketts?
@@nutball3756 who is that?
@@Fugitive685 Play Red Dead Redemption 1. He's THE Legendary Gunslinger, the only one not to be a fraud besides maybe Black Belle and Flaco. He trained John in Rdr1 to be the best gunslinger, too, making him a waaaay better shooter. He never even dies to a gunfight, he was that good. He dies of age. And when he's like, in his late 60s? He's gunslinging down in Mexico, protecting the people from revolutionaries and government soldiers (since Mexico was a shitshow in 1911)
@@nutball3756 it's not on PS4 store
@@Fugitive685 it was 360 and ps3 era. Don't think it ever came over to the next gen.
for anyone saying it would be unrealistic for arthur to not die due to tb, he could survive getting mauled by a bear for ten seconds and then push it off and scare it off afterwards far into his disease
Those are gameplay factors. Realistically Arthur would be screaming in pain on the ground for everytime you got shot in game. But he doesn’t actually get shot storywise just like he doesn’t get attacked by a bear storywise so you can’t compare the 2. Tb back then almost always resulted in death it’s likely Arthur could’ve realistically survived longer but he wouldn’t have realistically healed and be cured from it, not in this time period anyway
@@josephstalin2606 People especially with Rockstar games seem to not differentiate between the gameplay and canonical versions of the protagonists. As in no, Arthur's actual kill count wasn't in the thousands nor did he survive multiple grizzly attacks. In fact, he's only the victim of one during the mission *'Exit, Pursued by a Bruised Ego'.* Arthur at most, would've lived a several years after 1899 with TB but not up to his 60s or 70s.
@@josephstalin2606 he did get attacked by a bear story wise when he went hunting with Hosea which was a specific incident of him getting attacked by a bear
@@theonlydon- No he doesn’t get attacked by a bear story wise tf? You think John can get attacked by wolves and be incapacitated for 3 weeks but Arthur gets mauled by a bear and is seen in the next cutscene perfectly fine? You’re supposed to shoot the bear and back up and the bear doesn’t even attack you it bumps into you and runs away if you got attacked in that scene it’s because you wanted to but the game clearly doesn’t intend Arthur to actually be attacked otherwise it would’ve forced that like with John in the epilogue
@@josephstalin2606 story wise yes he does get mauled. If you don’t shoot the bear with Hosea in time then you get mauled. And story wise Arthur survives
This was beautiful, Dream. Seeing Arthur live out his days with Charlotte and a child, head west and see what's unfortunately become of his old family and checking on John to see the fruits of his redemption laid in front of him was cathartic and fulfilling to say the least.
The ending(s) we got made the most sense with the story, but I would've loved to see Arthur experience something like this too after losing so much.
Thanks a lot, mate. I really think his life would be good with Charlotte living remotely.
@@Reddeaddreams What mod is that
Glad it wasn’t with Sadie
@@jameson4844 Same. They could've went the cheap route and had him with Sadie which makes little sense beyond appeasing the section of fans who desperately ship them together but they didn't.
Charlotte is nice but i'd say Arthur's true romance was Mary Linton.
Their should’ve been a Non Canon Ending where Arthur Survives, Johns Dialogue can’t compete with Arthurs
I’m mean what’s better
“SIR!”
Or
“HEY THEIR FELLER!”
Tbf, John's dialogue is a massive downgrade from RDR1. In the first game, even his greets/antagonizes were on a whole other level imo.
@@themadtitan7603 the man literally hits folks with "you can't shoot a fart outta of you're own ass". John's dialogue is an absolute joy in rdr1 but considering the fact that years take place after the events of rdr2, it ain't a stretch to say that he changed bit by bit over time. No one really stays the exact same over the courses of time
@@Punpun6745 Eh, I'd say it's a stretch. It's unlikely that someone goes from an awkward guy who can't finish a sentence without stammering and has lines like these to magically becoming this witty, eloquently spoken cowboy in just a few years. Even then, it's still unsatisfying because we never saw him evolve to that point. Like it would've been preferable if by the epilogue, John started acting like his RDR1 self.
@@themadtitan7603 that was the whole point to because he was still like young lad who hasn't grown up off of his britches yet basically Red Dead Redemption 1 shows him more mature without Red Dead Redemption 2 we wouldn't know John Marston personality before and after
Imagine Charles telling John about how he didnt find Arthurs body but found horse tracks instead
Yes he would be gone to find a life for himself, a little family becoming a wise old man and dying of age
@spencerpower5782 not old age he wouldn't have made it to 1911 maybe 1909 or 1910 not 1911
@@tylerhodges11 so I dont wanna be a a-hole but Arthur was in his thirties during 1899 so if you do the math he would be an old man or at least 50 or 40
@@spencerpower06467 if u do the math he was born in 63 soe he would be 36 in 1899 which would make him 40 in 1903 and so he would be 47 in 1911 that's not old during his time bud ppl were still fighting Indians in there 40s in the 1800s that's still not old now in today's America idk wym
@@spencerpower06467 bro he would be like 47 in 1911 that's not old lmal he would be dead befor then anyway
This was the kind of ending I wanted for Arthur. He found his own personal redemption in a way, before his death, but I would have liked to see him survive to find some happiness. He deserved it.
I think we all do but Arthur said it best when he said something like “you don’t get to live a bad life and good things happen to you”
That would, in a way, be disrespectful of Arthur's last wish. He wanted to die on that mountain protecting John. Arthur surviving but still dealing with TB would have been more unnecessary suffering on his part. Besides, Arthur finding out what happens to Bill and Javier would have depressed him even more. Plus there's always the chance that him and Dutch would reconcile (after Micah's death of course) so he might just join the new gang and end up fighting (and getting killed by ) John later on.
@@MarvinT0606 There is NO WAY Arthur would forgive Dutch, if anything he would kill them all with John
@@kjaskjusagreed since dutch left to him and John to whatever while having Micah in his ear
We want dlc with alternative ending where arthur will live to old age
better than undead nightmare 2
I would rather have a play as Dutch or Micah dlc Arthur is over with
And years later jack would have same relationship with Arthur like how John and uncle are
Forget that he still have a bounty on his head, sooner or later someone might come looking for him. Your past will always come back to visit you remember
THIS IS AMAZING. thank you so much for taking the time to make it for us ♥
Glad you enjoyed the work.❤️
Yeah
THe alternate timeline where Arthur put a bandana over his face while collecting debts
Dude , you are amazing ! ❤ This is the Ending everyone wanted for Arthur !
This hits different after beating the game
Dude... This is my favorite video you've made! It was perfectly edited and really expanded on Arthur and I loved it dude!!! Keep it up man!
Thanks mate for always supporting my work.
Imagine R* hits us with the rdr1 remake and in John’s last cutscenes Arthur shows up and saves him. Then both of them go after Ross.
And then they both continue to become even more wanted men for killing a federal agent and the government and military continue to terrorize Johns ranch and chase them down til ALL of them are dead (Johns family included)
Maybe you're joking but that'd be silly. It would undermine both RDR1 and RDR2's stories at the same time.
ahhh? that is silly that would mess up the whole timeline
thank god red dead redemption fans dont write the story
@@acejettt Kids takes jokes very serious nowadays.Fucking hell it’s a goddamn joke.Lighten up fanboys
Man you made my dream come true you really are RED DEAD DREAM come true. Thank you for all the effort you put in in making these videos I really love and admire your work
Glad you enjoyed my work yes i always try to bring best creative things possible on red dead
I finished the game yesterday all I gotta say is rest in peace Arthur and thank you for everything.
Best character hand down in whole gaming history
After Arthur's condition worsened in chapter four, the van der linde gang decided it was time to search for the miracle tonic one piece to save arthur. The gang traveled to the fabled island of tahiti in search of the tonic and saved arthurs life. The end
My plan WORKED
all it took was Tahitian mangoes eaten of the chests of a bunch of native girls to cure Arthur's TB. Now if only they could find the cure for Lumbago.
I need this
Can't save him from tb especially in 1899 no cure then lol
Imagine Arthur didn't die ,but he keep it secret to everyone
I agree Arthur living out his days in peace with a wife and child would be beuailful but when Micah, Dutch, Bill and Javier gangs killing some many people I feel it would be his duty to stop them
A old Arthur hunting down the rest of the gang to keep John and his family safe
@@Ryan-by8vj i think if somehow arthur survived he could have made dutch sane again.
I like the idea of Arthur surviving and the events on RDR1 playing out. Arthur would then find out about John, Javier, Bill and Dutch's deaths and go find Jack Marston and together they hunt down Edgar Ross.
he'd be on his way to build a lil' house
Imagine him helping John build *his* house.
The grief they’d all be giving each other 😅
What if rockstar did a “rdr2 what if?”
alternate universe where an old jack marston travels back in time and gives poor arthur morgan some antibiotics to cure his TB
His ending with Charlotte, and them growing old together kinda makes sense. Given the brief yet decent bond that Arthur made with Hamish, and given that you could see that they had similar interests and ideas, Arthur living in the woods in a cabin, after his outlaw days, is something that I could see, especially given that Arthur definitely did not enjoy the city.
His ending up with Charlotte, well I guess it could happen, though to tell you the truth I kind of got the idea that Arthur and Sadie seem to be a better match, especially given that Arthur is very very stubborn, it seems like he would need someone whose character is almost equally as strong as his to help reel him in from time to time.
My one regret about the game is playing a protagonist who just like John, dies at the end. Maybe Rockstar will make an alternate timeline, one where Arthur doesn't catch TB, yet the rest of the events play out pretty-much as they did, and we get to play as an older Arthur Morgan, and therefore have more adventures with him.
I know the idea is probably pretty farfetched, but who's to say it couldn't happen, especially given the fact that in one of the Stranger missions they kinda seemed to flirt with the idea of time travel and all.
After Sadie's husband was murdered and then who knows what happened to her before Dutch and Arthur showed up I don't think she was capable of anything like that. There's a reason he tells her that there more ghosts then people
I have to agree cause initially it would have without tb it would have been like slow tension before all hell break loose but seeing as rockstar was doing worker crunch we didn't get that storyline
@@windmaster9- "Worker crunch," what are you talking about?
This would be a good 100% secret ending
Ultra High Honor ending
@@Reddeaddreams Hes Honor was too good so it gave up
The attention to detail is so good he doesn't have his satchel and hat because he gave them to john I just noticed.
If Arthur was alive after RDR2:
By the events of the epilogue, he would be 44
By the events of RDR1, he would 48
I wish the game had ended like this, but because Rockstar Games was incredibly smart, they first released Red Dead Redemption and made it play with John, so this did not happen.
Arthur: *Wakes up on the mountain having a coughing fit and coughs up a fish bone*
Arthur: "... God dammit, Pearson..."
I don't think he would marry her. She loved her late husband and the only reason she is still out there is because of him. Even if Arthur had feelings for her I doubt they would be mutual. Notice how she kissed him on the cheek, she is showing gratitude rather than any romantic feeling.
This is the best thing that I have ever seen! Thank you!
Thanks mate
I see Arthur and John end up meeting halfway through chapter 1 and chapter in the epilogue. They meet again, build the house, and then Arthur goes to California with a new name or something. At the end before he rides off he helps you kill Micah, and then before he leaves for good, he lets you know to speak of his name to no one, ever.
Hey Niko it’s Roman let’s go bowling
He was believed Arthur still alive about 8 years now...
Perfection at last.
Glad you think so!
I'm playing through red dead redemption 2 again and this video peaked my interest. I would hope that Arthur still would have had some small communications with the Marston family enough that Jack might have known where Arthur was. so how cool would it have been if in the last mission of rdr1 if Arthur and Jack both showed up and both lit Ross up getting revenge for John. How funny would it have been to see Ross standing they're fishing and turning around and looking at Arthur.
Arthur: "How the fish biting?"
Ross: "wait do I know you?"
Arthur "oh how the tables have turned. You once cornered me and this boy years back in the same way we are now."
Ross: "...Arthur?! I thought you where dead. The hell you do. You want me to kill you?"
Arthur: "You see you killed my friend and this boy's dad so we're here to kill you."
Arthur is older than durch😂
Arthur morgan was 36 in the game. Duch was around mid to late 40s early 50s I think.
@@magiczero4yeah i know but i mean that in 1911 Arthur looked older than Dutch
@@Leonardo-hg8sc I know what you mean. Must be lumbago
Imagining Arthur like a Landon Ricketts seems absolutely badass
Nice Video This would of made a nice ending for Arthur
The ending where Arthur fell into a coma and woke up, so he got the cure for tb which came out in 1907 in the epilogue he found John, and lived with John, after a month John and Arthur built a house for Mary to surprise her so Arthur found Mary, so Arthur is neighbors with John
Imagine John and Arthur hunting down the gang members, and arthur standing by john when the government raid the ranch
Or, arthur lives in hiding, suffering to tb where john finds him years later, while hunting the gang
Love this
Him and Charlotte, exactly what I wanted. Bill, Javier, and Dutch would’ve been dead a lot sooner in RDR1.
Awesome
Arthur casually washes his TB away
He would be like Doc Holliday, a dead man walking who has nothing to lose.
I like this ending so in rdr1 you can switch your character just like in gta V, nice scolfield btw
Watching this after Arthur died to full the hole in my heart.
The part where Arthur saw Johns land and the ending he truly deserved
You know it’s weirdly possible in a way instead of him being buried it was a dead Pinkerton
Hey there Mister-U hit the nail on the head
Thank you for this
Arthur: *uses health cure* goes back to normal
I thought we can heal tuberculosis with some native american wonderherb. I wish we had options.
I thought they were going to do that lol
End of arthur: his horse dies. But in this video the horse says: oh hey arthur!!
i loved rdr2 replayed it 50 ish times and i never stop thinking that their is a chance he didnt die
yooo too cool. make moreee. we need moreeeee
You did that video good
Thanks friend
@@Reddeaddreams no problem
I could see that I could also see him living in the old veterans house in ambarino with the guys horse, since the veteran is now dead
yeah there can be multiple scenerios for What If
We all wanted to find a cure for TB. Or avoid getting sick all together. But no it was Arthur's unavoidable fate.
Just don’t do the Thomas Downes mission
@@Arthur_calahan I did that I wondered all over the map finding anything and everything. heck I spent many hours I can't remember i accomplish over fifty percent of the game's completion in chapter 2.
Some fans believe Arthur didn't have TB he had lung cancer due to this fact nobody was infected by Arthur
Arthur: sees a ghost of his biggest enemy (rat)
Arthur: NAHT AGEN
I wish their was an ending where he survived and ran away with Mary
Same
Or Sadie
If this happened we wouldn't have RDR
Which ultimately leads to RDR2 not existing
🤯
I really don't get it.......why did they name the game RDR2 while this game ain't supposed to be a sequel it's prequel, RDR0(zero) would made more sense
@@محمدمهدی-ض7ل8ع I mean it works.
Aww that was nice. Thank you
Thankyou for appreciating it😊
"I was bad man" all players "NO YOU WASN'T"
Damn Arthur rocks that poncho well
Imagine if Arthur had acted like he died and just went to Tahiti
You deserve a million views
Thanks a ton!
The reason why Arthur died because he's not the main character john is but I still don't care.
Tuberculosis: hey what's up bro
Plot twist
This is the canon ending and we never see Arthur in rdr1 because that part of the map got locked by the Upper Montana river
you should of added a scene where after john and sadie leave mount hagen, arthur comes out of no where and smokes one over micah's corpse
The mission we wanted was *Arthur Morgan rides again*
I feel like Arthur would've prevented a lot of the heartache john had to endure in the first game.
The ending we all wanted love the vid do you know the mods you used for this video
all i want for the rdr series is a rdr2 zombies or a third game taking place years before the black water heist maybe them recruiting all the members
I have created a playlist on my channel regarding that, showcasing all gang members united by Dutch and their backstories
there i go cryin at the drop of a hat again....
Arthur morgan lookin older than Dutch in 1911 🔥
2 years after not being able to play this as it was removed from game pass I can finally afford the game in 7 days and I will get to play this masterpiece again
great you are going to have good time
@@Reddeaddreams turns out I’m getting it early
@@Reddeaddreams I am definitely going to have a good time :>
Ahh yes Arthur and Charlotte that's the ending I wish we gotten I loved this.
What if the person you encounter in Mexico in RDR1 is not Landon Rickets but Arthur Morgan.
Even if he won the fight he would still die cuz he was sick
Nah He was to good from TB So it just left
the only way this would have made sense if that black doctor from Rhodes somehow found him, gave him just enough meds to survive, and sent him to Charlotte
If only the ending of RDR 2 had been like this. If Arthur had never caught TB (Tuberculosis), he would have gone to live with Charlotte, and I believe Arthur and Charlotte would have been a great couple and lit out the rest of their days together.
Hello friend I’m still not getting your notifications I have no idea why but every now and again I will come to your channel and watch your videos you impress me a lot could you give me a tip how can you make the characters mouths move
Thnankyou i have given your answer in your previous comment
@@Reddeaddreams thank you my friend
Arthur aged 30 years in 12 year
Arthur if he smoked:
Because in rdr1 it says tobacco fights tuberculosis
Smoking INCREASES the chance of getting it idiot
Hawkeye: "don't give me hope"
This would been amazing. Imagine if they made a huge DLC where you play through rdr1 with Arthur and John! They woulda survived the barn shooting cause if they both duel wield with dead eye, Ross and his men would all be dead. And uncle coulda live to see another day during that mission.
Great video I would have loved to have a dlc where he faked his death and lives the remaining of his months as a redeemed man on helping people and being a deputy. Also to see him have his own house to live in!
that poncho is sick ash! howd u get it??
Whyem DLC mod
Unfortunately arthur morgan wasn't ment to survive but if he did survive the end I don't think he would have "beat" TB do to the stress his body was in. I think he would try to prolong his life by moving out west, if he recovered enough he could have lived a little while but eventually his TB would have killed him. He would probably make it to his mid to late 40s.
I wish rdr2 would give us a massive update where we can change the endings and events in the game like kill Dutch and Javier and bill in this game where the gang completely falls apart and there all pointing guns at each other Arthur can go into dead eye and shoot Micah and Dutch
POV: John marston is hired by Edgar Ross and he has to hunt down the remaining gang members and with each death of the old gang, John loses more and more morality and after Dutch Is killed John gets some horrific news, the last target. Arthur Morgan, still alive but retired and Not once turned to a sinful life, the past gang members took lots of mental trial and error for John to finally kill, javier, bill, Dutch, and now he has to shoot the man he once called a brother or it’s johns life that will be taken, John arrives at Arthur’s home and has a brief conversation with him before John gives Arthur a rundown of what must happen and he holds Arthur at gunpoint but John immediately remembers all the times Arthur and John had….all those years of being this brotherhood, it must come to an end because of Johns decisions…deciding that this act of killing his own brother his (not related) family member would hurt him too much, John turns the gun on himself
Dude this sounds awesome. I like the Idea!
i feel like it could be possible for arthur to survive if he left with john, went to the desert then rested at a hotel for a while with severe medical attention. The dryness and the rest would fight off the TB
we hope so
i was hoping that Dr. Marko Dragic finds Arthur's body and decides to transplant new lungs on Arthur and then revive him using The Machine(the one that gave life to the robot) and Arthur wakes up inside a cryogenic tube
the real sad truth is that even if he lived he would have died due to tuberculosis
Arthur: You, Abigail and Jack, go live your lives.
John: And you?
Arthur: I reckon I’m gonna head West, somewhere dry… see if I can shake this goddamn cough.
This is actually a real dialog between them during the last train heist mission when John and Arthur go take the dynamite before meeting with the others. I think it is only triggered if Arthur has low honor, but it could have been nice to have a chapter 7 after all that mess where you play as a weak Arthur in New Austin trying to get back on his feet and move on by himself.
Bro wtf that’s the same horse I had when Arthur died and the same outfit
oh, nice
This is a ending I can get behind 🔥🔥🔥
Im 19. Jahrhundert war die Überlebenschance bei Tuberkulose (auch bekannt als Schwindsucht) deutlich geringer als heute. Es gab jedoch Menschen, die die Krankheit überlebten.
They were in good condition but Arthur wasn't.........
Atleast you could make that he atleast contacts John he was his very close friend to be honest, but other than that this video is perfect! 👌
John was Arthur's brother.