To say that this video was anything short of extraordinary would be a gross deviation from any form of reality as you understand it. What a powerful explanation of Arts power! I'm happy to report that my greatest take away from this class has nothing to do with Art, except to associate it to the power of its influence to move a culture. The true take-away for me in much more a sociological one than an artist one. But, in my own analysis of this class, I've discovered the importance of Art (in its many forms) to change a world for positive, healthy, love of mankind reasons, and that is so much more than any particular piece of artistic expression and it's aesthetic beauty.
I think a lot of people commenting are too blinded by the fact that she's talking about black art and black artists to realize that that is the purpose of the video. She's using black art as the example on how culture changes. And don't treat it as if different races have the same culture, because they don't. It's not racist, it's fact. She is simply exploring the progression of black culture through art. You could easily do the same thing about whites, indians, chinese, japanese, etc.
She's giving an example to prove her point. What better way to talk about how culture changes through art than going into detail on her own and how it has changed? The reason she uses race/nation to talk about culture is because her race does have a developed culture of it's own. I have to simply disagree on where you see her focus and emphasis. She points you to focus on what people are in an effort to explain why they do/make something.
...We are made of a wide variety of culture, we need to remember that and embrace it, that we are children born of many wolrds colliding, bringing new things into this world because of this mixture. The matrix is based on anime fight scenes, anime comes from astro boy, that manga comes from western comics, which are a visual variation on books, book massproduced version of scripture and that a written adaption of local legends.we're all human, countries are just lines drawn in sand with a stick
yes but art changes inidividual knowledge into public knowledge, instead of one artist feeling they hate bankers, suddenly everyone knows everyone else is sick of bankers and that means we have enough people to rebel.
i disliked because i think its the other way around. How cultural change shapes the art created instead of vice versa, art just reflects the sentiments
And you don't think there are numerous other nationalities among the other groups as well? If you insist: Irish German Italian Polish Russian French Swedish Danish Greek Spanish Armenian Albanian Austrian British Belgian Bulgarian Finland Georgian Iceland Dutch Portugal Turkish Croatia Czech Latvia Iran Slovakia Ukraine Romania Norway Lithuanian Scottish Or any other fucking group that I haven't mentioned or made a reference to. Sorry if I generalized to far for you to understand what I meant.
LOL this comment section.... I dont agree with every single thing stated here... But you know what it was super interesting and i was able to see it in the lense of "this is a talk about and a specific culture"..... and thats ok... in fact the title of this is a pun... lol
I just feel like there is no need to look at race as something to should be split, no one deserves more attention then the next. We are all living beings and should try and cherish each other as equals. Just my opinion though.
Their voice is so perfect sounding, it almost doesn't look like it comes from them!! Though I never understood why people have to split things up into "black" this or "hispanic" that (especially since if there was a "white" catigory it would be 'racist' to most people), they didn't do that bad of a job.
Ok. I just thought your first two comments seemed a little....racist. But that's just my thought. You seem to at least have an argument for why you feel the way you do, so I agree in that this probably won't go anywhere. I hope the best and good luck!
I gotta agree somewhat. Its good to look at eachother as equals, but this isn't really about race. More about the culture and how its displayed. Either way I am neutral to this talk. Rather uninteresting.
1). You did not mean that. You didn't talk about that at all. You just went headfirst and declared something false that wasn't even mentioned in the video. 2). Smh. 3). When did I say what the topic was? You're not making any sense at all. I simply said that what you thought the topic was isn't the correct interpretation of her talk. Look at the title of the video if you really want to know the topic. 4). Watch it again. You obviously have no idea what you're talking about.
"whites" really? half the world has the same culture? you were racist in your explanation :p you should have used names like "Nordic Europeans, Celtic/British, Latin Europeans, Indians, eastern Asians (or more specific), etc." as "whites" have like 30-40% of all the DIFFERENT cultures in the world
To say that this video was anything short of extraordinary would be a gross deviation from any form of reality as you understand it. What a powerful explanation of Arts power! I'm happy to report that my greatest take away from this class has nothing to do with Art, except to associate it to the power of its influence to move a culture. The true take-away for me in much more a sociological one than an artist one. But, in my own analysis of this class, I've discovered the importance of Art (in its many forms) to change a world for positive, healthy, love of mankind reasons, and that is so much more than any particular piece of artistic expression and it's aesthetic beauty.
Cool story bro...
It is all about the dialogue.
I think a lot of people commenting are too blinded by the fact that she's talking about black art and black artists to realize that that is the purpose of the video. She's using black art as the example on how culture changes. And don't treat it as if different races have the same culture, because they don't. It's not racist, it's fact. She is simply exploring the progression of black culture through art. You could easily do the same thing about whites, indians, chinese, japanese, etc.
She's giving an example to prove her point. What better way to talk about how culture changes through art than going into detail on her own and how it has changed?
The reason she uses race/nation to talk about culture is because her race does have a developed culture of it's own. I have to simply disagree on where you see her focus and emphasis.
She points you to focus on what people are in an effort to explain why they do/make something.
All these comments on the speaker being racist are false. Good job Thelma!
...We are made of a wide variety of culture, we need to remember that and embrace it, that we are children born of many wolrds colliding, bringing new things into this world because of this mixture. The matrix is based on anime fight scenes, anime comes from astro boy, that manga comes from western comics, which are a visual variation on books, book massproduced version of scripture and that a written adaption of local legends.we're all human, countries are just lines drawn in sand with a stick
This was helpful for my studies
i think its the other way around. cultural change shapes the art created instead of vice versa, art just reflects the sentiments
but in some cases it's the art that sparks the cultural change
I love this!! thanks! I create "cultural/multicultural art" and was looking for other artists who do the same thing...this was a great find
soooooo good i liked this alot.
This was an awesome lecture!
yes but art changes inidividual knowledge into public knowledge, instead of one artist feeling they hate bankers, suddenly everyone knows everyone else is sick of bankers and that means we have enough people to rebel.
This is exactly what I needed!!!
i disliked because i think its the other way around. How cultural change shapes the art created instead of vice versa, art just reflects the sentiments
And you don't think there are numerous other nationalities among the other groups as well? If you insist:
Irish
German
Italian
Polish
Russian
French
Swedish
Danish
Greek
Spanish
Armenian
Albanian
Austrian
British
Belgian
Bulgarian
Finland
Georgian
Iceland
Dutch
Portugal
Turkish
Croatia
Czech
Latvia
Iran
Slovakia
Ukraine
Romania
Norway
Lithuanian
Scottish
Or any other fucking group that I haven't mentioned or made a reference to. Sorry if I generalized to far for you to understand what I meant.
LOL this comment section.... I dont agree with every single thing stated here... But you know what it was super interesting and i was able to see it in the lense of "this is a talk about and a specific culture"..... and thats ok... in fact the title of this is a pun... lol
I just feel like there is no need to look at race as something to should be split, no one deserves more attention then the next. We are all living beings and should try and cherish each other as equals. Just my opinion though.
There may be not be a ‘need’ but this is the reality we live in
Their voice is so perfect sounding, it almost doesn't look like it comes from them!!
Though I never understood why people have to split things up into "black" this or "hispanic" that (especially since if there was a "white" catigory it would be 'racist' to most people), they didn't do that bad of a job.
I don't think I've heard that parable before. Interesting.
Are you referring to someone? Or are you just sharing that with us?
You seem to be confusing black with the n word, Im guessing theres a lot of things you have no idea about
Can't tell if trolling or stupid.
me too
Ok. I just thought your first two comments seemed a little....racist. But that's just my thought. You seem to at least have an argument for why you feel the way you do, so I agree in that this probably won't go anywhere.
I hope the best and good luck!
Then you would probably be studying European art from the 1500s onwards. Oh look, race can be used to talk about culture. Gasp.
Racists actually watching TED talks? I'm impressed
The TED forum is too large to touch upon such topics.
I gotta agree somewhat. Its good to look at eachother as equals, but this isn't really about race. More about the culture and how its displayed. Either way I am neutral to this talk. Rather uninteresting.
Well, not all of them get mad and a lot white people get more mad then the black ones
1). You did not mean that. You didn't talk about that at all. You just went headfirst and declared something false that wasn't even mentioned in the video.
2). Smh.
3). When did I say what the topic was? You're not making any sense at all. I simply said that what you thought the topic was isn't the correct interpretation of her talk. Look at the title of the video if you really want to know the topic.
4). Watch it again. You obviously have no idea what you're talking about.
Because thats their race and if you aren't one of them, then you should watch out what say about them or other races.
I think they're held in different locations, but I'm not 100%. :3
i really have no idea why afrikan americans can blatantly say black, but when someone else does they get mad
Wow the blatant ignorance in the comments.
Damn i thought we were in the 21st century.....But i guess not because there are tons of racist neanderthal commenters here
#iWAAOG
Art is Shit.
What is I said I study White Art?
"whites" really? half the world has the same culture? you were racist in your explanation :p
you should have used names like "Nordic Europeans, Celtic/British, Latin Europeans, Indians, eastern Asians (or more specific), etc." as "whites" have like 30-40% of all the DIFFERENT cultures in the world
don't care much for art
yawn.