Survival vs Bushcraft Knives. What is the Difference?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ก.พ. 2023
- Ever wondered what the difference is between bushcraft knives and survival knives? In this video, I talk about the key differences between both knives, so you can make an informed decision on which one to use.
Bushcraft knives are designed for more precise tasks such as carving, splitting, cleaning, and skinning. This type of knife is great for carving intricate designs in wood, skinning game, and other delicate tasks.
On the other hand, survival knives are designed for more rugged tasks such as chopping, sawing, and slicing. These knives generally have a wider, thicker blade which are great for cutting through brush, carving logs, and other more heavy-duty tasks.
So, when making your decision on which knife to use, it's important to consider the tasks you plan on doing. If you're looking for a knife for more precise tasks, then a bushcraft knife is for you. If you're looking for a knife for more rugged tasks, then a survival knife is the better choice.
I hope this video helps you to understand the differences between bushcraft and survival knives. Now, you can make an informed decision on which one to use. Thanks for watching! - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
In my experience, a good knife is a good knife, period. For the past couple of seasons, I used a mora HD carbon companion to thoroughly field-process numerous deer along with deboning and quartering the meat. You don’t have to split the pelvis-use your knife to follow where the meat meets the bone and then eventually sever the tendon holding the ball joint together. Freeing the hindquarters this way eliminates worrying about the bladder and colon, and you can thank a Greek butcher for this valuable information.
I think alike as you
I agree, since I’ve done the same with a similar grind Helle puukko-like belt knife on caribou and moose. I’ll add though that I like having a second thinner bladed boning style knife in my pack mainly for getting out back straps and tender loins.
You’re right about the thinner blade having its purpose. I was experimenting with trying to go as light as possible without sacrificing efficiency, and I found that particular mora to be excellent for my big-game kit. Since I do more scouting and hunting than anything else, I laid out all of my gear and eliminated what was unnecessary: the “two is one and one is none “ rule is okay for home, camp, and vehicle; but it’s bs in the woods. When I was a kid, I once carried a fully loaded pack while rabbit hunting. That woke me up.
Correct, A knife is a knife, aka a piece of seel.
This video is supposedly about bushcraft vs survival. What has butchering a deer got to do with that?
Butchering a dead deer has got sweet f.a. to do with bushcraft or Survival. A good knife is anything you have on you that will cut!!
So this is the way I describe the difference between survival and bushcraft to my kids… “survival is when you have to and bushcraft is when you want to” …you name it. Eat, build, create, gather, explore. And the more you learn the more the distinction matters less.
Good distinction. Thanks for sharing your thoughts
I saw a similar one the other day: Survival is like getting back from .... , while bushcraft is going out to ....., in order to get the skills to get back from! I thought that was quite cool.
This has been the best explanation to differentiate between the categories of “survival” vs “bushcraft” I’ve seen on YT.
Thanks! I’m glad it was useful info
I agree. I've watched several others. Now, I feel I really understand. Clear and helpful "Description" notes as well.
I have had alox Swiss Army knife since 1988. It did everything I needed knife for : camping, fishing, hunting, cooking you name it. Had to replace it a few years back due to blade becoming too tin and small from sharpening. My new knife is alox pioneer x . Add Maglite solitaire and bic mini lighter and that is all I need.
I carry a Spartan SAK, a Maglite Solitaire and a Fischer space pen in a leather pocket organizer that I received as a gift. I thought it would be gimmicky but it turns out to be the most comfortable way to carry those items in my pocket. Keeps everything flat against my thigh. Pretty cheap on Amazon too.
Very sensible knife and light. You can whip out a SAK in public without causing a panic, and the Solitaire has pretty good battery life and is just bright enough to get the job done without disturbing anything outside the immediate area.
@@MrPloppy1You should repost this comment as a main comment - hiding here as a reply comment is a little pity because your comment is very good
I really like what you said about materials. Obviously there is the constant back and forth between carbon vs stainless for the blades, but I never considered the sheath materials as well. I knew that the main advantage or the fallkniven zytel was that it is waterproof and that it has some intentional play of the blade so that if it gets wet and freezes, it would allow you to get the blade out. I haven’t considered resistance to fuel, oil, fire, etc as the strenghts of the sheath.
Thanks for the thoughts. In my experience sheath material can have a big role to play. I remember my bark river bushcraft blade becoming completely useless to me on the second day of a trip because the day before the snow soaked the sheath and rusted up my knife overnight. But also yeah in any scenario you can imagine, there are also elements that would destroy a leather sheath. Even spray paint for cars can damage leather
zytel is just plastic.
@@MovieGuy666 saying that is like saying “it’s just steel” for anything that is made by it. It would imply that knives and pots are made from the same stuff.
Not all plastics are equal
Excellent definitions and Very helpful. I've been involved for many seasons in wilderness survival and yours is the first to detail the why's and what's between Bush crafting & Survival; thanks again
Glad you enjoyed it!!
The best knife in my opinion is the one you have on ya when you need one . Just saying . I know that a number of people will disagree with me but I like a hollow grind . Back in the late sixties and early seventies I carried the Puma White Hunter it got me through 18 months of Vietnam and it still serves me today .
Hollow grid is great for a lot of tasks! Thanks for your thoughts
You summed it up very well .For myself I find a fine middle ground in grind material and cost with a Cold Steel SRK in V10 with a attached fire rod. In the States at gun shows around $50.00 US.
Great clear explanation on the basic differences in outdoor knives. So many people buy their first knives and select the 2nd best choice. Great quality video Fella.👊
Glad it was helpful! Thanks for your feedback man. Means a lot coming from yourself
The term "survival" knife is a marketing ploy. Survive what? Inevitably, someone talks about a survival knife and then proceeds to talk about chopping wood for a shelter, processing firewood or killing a bear with their bare hands. No one has needed to do those things to "survive" in 125 years. 80% of Americans live in an urban area. People really mean is they want a "wilderness" or "back country" all-in-one knife. Let's be honest, If I told you I was going to drop you off in the middle of nowhere and made you pick a "survival" blade, you would select an axe, not a knife, 10 out of 10 times.
@@papimaximus95interesting, most of the contestants on Alone choose a knife
@@VincentBalmont Define "Most"? For Seasons 1-8 there were a total of 77 participants. Of those 55 selected a knife while 66 and 67 selected a saw or axe, respectively. That is 87% saw/axe vs 71% knife.
Some thoughts:
Firstly, I thought about what the woodsmen of a century ago carried out in the wild. Generally, they seem to have preferred a large, heavy-bladed knife that could be used to perform many and various tasks about the camp and in the wilderness - often this would be like a bowie knife. In the business of living in the wild, finesse didn't often carry a high priority; for example fine, evenly spaced feathersticks etc.
Secondly, I thought of the chef in the kitchen. How many chefs (or cooks) normally rely on only one knife? Very few. They would have several - each of them the best for a specific task.
Thirdly, I thought of how one would actually end up in a survival situation (excluding aeroplane pilots). Usually (but not exclusively) it would be the result of a trip away from "civilization" where something went wrong and they are now in IT! This would logically presuppose that, prior to such an adventure, there would have been some sort of preparation phase, and consideration about what kit to take along. I think this is a reasonable and logical deduction. One could therefore accommodate a proper knife selection. Also other tools, eg a folding saw, or possible an axe.
Taking all this in account, it seems to me that an adventurer (just like a chef) would consider what would be needed for what purposes and plan accordingly. I would think a prudent adventurer would select more than one knife: possibly a large knife (like a Cold Steel Trail Master), a medium size knife (like a Cold Steel SRK (or ESEE 4), and a smaller knife, say a Mora Skandi grind knife. He/she might even have a SAK and/or Leatherman on his/her belt.
The "only ONE knife" scenario is a popular one for the sake of discussion and debate, but with little practical application. Also, with this all in mind, it would mean that each knife choice could have the specific grind choice one would prefer for the particular application, instead of relying on one grind for all jobs.
In the words of that great man Lord Baden Powell (founder of the Boy Scouts movement), "Be prepared!"
In all this there is not, of course, only one CORRECT answer, as personal preference will always play a major decision-making role.
Thanks for your response here! I agree with you on almost all of that and no there is not one correct answer. Personally I’ve never adhered to the one tool option, preferring to carry at least a folding saw, and a small axe depending on the type of trip and camping style. Usually I’ll have a few pieces from my carving kit with me too (mora 106). So absolutely each to their own. I wanted to make this video to try and simplify some of the terms people that are new to all this might be coming up against and not really knowing where to start! Great comment! thanks again
@@artoftheoutdoors Point taken, and a job well done. On the inclusion of the axe - if weight is in any way an issue, I'd ditch the axe first. One can split logs quite well using wooden wedges (using that nice CS Trail Master to make them) and some time. If one is camping out and have a vehicle, then an axe is very handy (and I enjoy using them!) However, some sort of saw is an absolute - you MUST have one!
Thank you for the time taken to respond.
Thank god, you didn't live a century ago, you'd have a hard time to survive in the wild.
If you make fire with the flint-and-steel-method, because ferrorods and lighters weren't invented yet, making excellent feathersticks is absolutely essential.
As knives were quite expensive that time, most people couldn't afford more than one, so they purchased the biggest affordable one - that would not often be a Bowie, much more likely an Old Hickory or a Hudson Bay Company Knife.
@@mannihh5274 I'm well practiced with fint and steel. Charcloth or amadou processing skills would probably be more valuable than making feathersticks, especially here in Finland where the primary tinder source is birch bark. Also, I wasnt saying I cant make a featherstick, I'm saying its more difficult for a beginner with a flat or sabre grind. Thanks for your feedback though
@@artoftheoutdoors - I'm living in Germany and finding amadou is not that easy here, and for charcloth you have to sacrifice the cloth, which was expensive then.
Feathersticks are free and available everywhere. We have often quite some wind here, so it's really challenging to start a fire with fine materials, that easily get blown away.
Great informational video - very well spoken. I love the scandi grind but when I discovered the convex grind of a bark river knife I fell head over heels in love!!! Needless to say, I now own quite a few bark river knives. The Fallkniven F1 is one of the best knives ever made in my opinion. I think it makes one heck of a bushcraft knife as well. It is a very versatile knife. New sub here - love the content!!!
I didn’t want to get to complicated in the video going into convex grids. But yes! Seriously good knives
Love the animated illustrations between the grinds! Now I know the differences after watching many so-called Bush crafters or survivalists on TH-cam. Thx
I’m glad it helps 😁
Wow that Fallkniven S1x is absolutely beautiful. After hearing you describe it I just ordered myself one. Thank you and great video 👍
Good choice! Where did you order it from?
@@artoftheoutdoors Knife Country USA
It was on sale for $211 with free shipping. It's my first time using the site but it was the best deal I could find.
Another strong point for fallkniven knives is that after I use my f1 and a1 to process deer and other game I boil the knife and the sheath for sanitary reasons and it works out great. I always hated sticking a bloody knife back in a leather sheath after field dressing game.
Good feedback! Thanks
I don't do that, ever.
Short, sharp and straight to the point. Excellent.
I appreciate that!
Excellent chat. very clear and objective. I liked it even more because I have a BK2 and ESEE 4. Two great tools. I also have the Mora for bushcraft services. Hugs from Rio de Janeiro Brazil
Thank you! I’m glad you liked it
the bk2 is a tank of a blade....a true beater,i have one along with the Terävä Jääkäripuukko 140.....both totally reliable in survival situations,great video i gave it a thumbs up
Thanks 😊 yeah it’s a beast of a knife I love it
I can’t find a Ka bar bk2 that looks like that one
Hey I really enjoyed this video. The topic of survival knives creates a lot of debate and your observations are a very useful addition. Thanks.
I’m glad you enjoyed it!
The first time I'm watching one of your videos and I'd say that it was pretty spot on as far as content VS length. I think you covered the essentials so weary well done.
Best regards Conny from Finland the land of puukko 😉
Thanks for your kind words. Glad you enjoyed the video
When I got my first scandi-gring knife, a Mora 510 (or 511), I couldn't believe how good it was at hogging off excess wood fast. I was thinking this style of knife is the best for making a quick primitive style bow. Good video, thanks
Exactly! Thanks for the comment Steve
Very nice points! I have been using my Jääkäripuukko 110 as my go to bush knife! If the apocalypse zombie comes, then I will grab my BK-7! A "survival knife" may be used as a self defense tool, so a bigger blade would be better in my opinion. Greetings from Sweden 🇸🇪
Greetings 😁
Very well spoken and presented. I don't think it will take you long to reach 10k subscribers and well beyond with this sort of content.
While big, heavy knives have a purpose (in a survival situation), I do find a shorter blade to have more control and practical purpose out in the bush. Bigger is not always better. But there are many factors. Greetings from Cape Town. Looking forward to more content.
greetings! and thanks for the kind words! bigger is definitely NOT always better, you're right
Thumbs up. Great delivery. Good points. You have an endearing nature, which goes beyond just the content.
One important factor for which donates the difference between a bushcraft knife and a survival knife is simply the length of blade. And the reason being is when I'm batoning, I have more area to hit with the baton (striking wood).
So for a proper survival knife for me I need about a seven inch blade. The longer (and chunkier) the blade the bigger the diameter of wood I can split.
Hope all that is legible.
Respect from England.
Good points! Thanks Colin
Great information....I had never really given the topic too much thought before. Now I will have to re-think the knives I have, and what/when I would use and carry them.
Thank you. Glad it was useful to you
The BK2 is a sabre grind ground knife. This is considered as its own grind ( theoretically, it is just a very high scandi with a secondary bevel) and has different characteristics as a scandi and a flat ground knife. These scandi ground knives were of course also meant to prepare food and process meat and hide as well as wood processing.
Yeah I was thinking about that Sabre afterwards. Whether I should include that info too. But you’re totally right. in my experience there’s very little difference between that and a flat grind, except when batonning through firewood. Regarding food prep, scandis are definitely not good at that in my experience, especially veges and things. Doable? Of course, but not ideal. But skinning for sure. Thanks for the feedback
@@Butch_Deezlsteak I disagree with both. The most Scandis I know come in true scandi. And on your second I want to remind you about blade geometry which is the most important factor in blade performance.
Scandi is the grind wich is worst for food. It it was never meant to be.
@@donaldpriebsch Scandis get the job done. But if you want to bring along a kitchen knife while camping, be my guest.
@@huejanus5505 i would suggest a Opinel for that job. Weights next to nothing and dont need space in your Rig.
For me, survival knife is what you have on you at the time. It would be crazy to think I’m going to have _that _ knife when I’m suddenly trusted upon that situation, unless I’m carrying it with me wherever I am.
That’s fair enough! But I suppose if the best knife you had on you was the only one you owned, you’d want to know that you chose a knife worth carrying
@@artoftheoutdoors Yes, that's a good point. However in today's society, you are severely restricted in terms of what you are _allowed_ to carry. Which means folders and even the best folder money can buy comes short when compared to simple fixed blade. (okay maybe Cold Steel 4Max or Hinderer may possibly surpass fixed blades but...) Maybe the best solution is like what Ray Mears said, knowledge weighs nothing.
Very helpful now to decide what’s most important.
Awesome content my dude! Thanks for the calm and collected delivery while still teaching. Fallkniven is something I will have to look into!
Thank you for the kind words. Glad you like the content
Poll for everyone: What are the most important specs of an outdoorsman knife when choosing one? Examples: price, length, full tang, width, weight, tip type.
The easiest way to answer this question is to give my selection (Note: not ONE knife - I don't believe in that.) From that you can easily see what the specs are.
Large knife: Cold Steel Trail Master San Mai III - this for the heavy work and probably carried in the pack, but not always.
Belt knife: CS SRK San Mai III - this would always be on my belt, and it would be the go-to knife for most medium size tasks.
Folder: Victorinox Ranger grip series - I'd consider which one depending on requirements, but must have a saw and scissors. Carried on a belt lanyard hanging in the trouser pocket.
In addition, I would always carry a folding Silky saw (Pocket Boy, or Gomboy).
I would not carry an axe. For me an axe is for a permanent or semi-permanent camp, or where the outing includes some mode of transport (eg horse, quad bike, or pickup truck/car.)
How does that sound?
Full Tang
@@paulhorn24 Why?
I've seen this touted by many TH-camrs, and often wondered why some are so obsessed about it? Also, "full" in what respect? Does it mean the full length of the handle, the full width of the handle, or both?
For example, the Cold Steel Trail Master has neither a full length, nor full width tang, yet I've never heard of a handle snapping off at the crosspiece! Same with Falkniven knives. And both have been main stream Top 5 best knives for decades!
@@dennisleighton2812 obviously i can’t speak for all, but I prefer full width and full length because of the resulting weight of the half of knife which is the grip/handle. I don’t like Top-heavy knives. JM2C.
Hello from Ukraine here! Been 2 weeks in russian occupation in Feb-Mar 2022 (Irpin-Bucha area). Got mortar shelling and lost electricity and gas (propane, not gasoline) that is used for cooking and heating, pretty soon after the russian invasion.
Knife-wise, did not need anything special. Used 1-kilo local-made axe to split wood and heat the house using the fireplace. Had a "survival" blade from Bear Grylls, but barely used it a couple of times.
Stay safe. Long live Ukraine!
Thanks for your thoughts man! Stay safe 🤜🏻❤️🤛🏻
I find it very saddening that two Orthodox Christian nations are at war. I have been praying for peace from the beginning. There are powers that want and need any kind of strife in order to justify their existence, and-more sooner than later-everyone will have to pick a side. It’s my fervent hope that everyone picks Jesus’s side.
🇬🇧✌️🇺🇦
I really appreciate the info. Would like to see side by side usage comparisons on the different scandi grind vs a couple others doing the same tasks and going over why each style works better at different tasks.
I appreciate the extra details and info. I know I “ramble” as well.
Thanks Rob! I’ll have to do a follow up video and some point
Nice explanation. I have had the BK2 for years. Just love it for preparing a camp fire.
Thanks! Glad you liked the video
If you are in a city you are not in a survival situation, unless there is a civil war going on. In such case you need a gun way more than a knife.
I’ve been dropped into an abandoned city for training in Africa and it was 100% a survival situation. And what about what’s going on in Ukraine?
100% wrong mate
Have you been in a car crash? How about in an armed robbery? How many earthquakes with the house falling over you have you been? How about fire in your house? .... this is from the top of my head
@@StefanStoykov And how exactly a knife will save you from a fire or debris falling on your head? Yeah in a severe car crash a knife can cut the belt in case it is stuck, that's why I leave a knife in my car solely for that purpose.
Don't get me wrong, I love knifes, I own several, and not a single firearm. Where I live you cannot carry a gun for your protection. Knives are useful in the bush and for utility uses. But they will not magically gain more functions in the case of a civil war or the zombie apocalypse !
Not when the ammo runs out
Survival knife will survive even without you and bushcraft knife will craft bushes. That's it.
👍🏻
A good discussion indeed.
I agree with you about the BK-2 being the best overall “survival” knife….
I would have one too, but I really like my TOPS Outpost Command… a similar knife with a bit wider blade and a little bit heavier.
Good choice 👍🏻
Great video straight to the point
This was the best video I have seen covering this topic.
Wow. Thank you 😁
Very good site, I can see that you have done your homework on the subject and have experience. Greetings from a bush war veteran in South Africa. I have an original Wilkinson Sword survival knife (tactically modified) as well as a Lion. Steel product, and Extrema Ratio kukri / parang type machete for bush clearing. Another category of knife is that of the military field knife. Thank you, I like your style and have subbed!
Hahah thank you! Now a parang is definitely a tool I’m not familiar with but I’ve seen people do amazing things with them. Thanks for watching 😊
Awesome content and ideas. As you say so many options and thought and so many work!! Personally i recently found a knife that fits a wide range of skills and all my other knives keep loosing to. A Kellam Ranger Puukko in 80crv2. It keeps up with any of my scandi grind knives for bushcraft and isn't that bad for processing animals.. not heavy and strong. I think it's a highly underrated knife.
I’ve never heard of them. Will definitely check em out thanks 😁
Best vid I’ve seen explaining all of this, great job 👍🏻
Wow! Thank you 😊
Very detailed analysis of these blades perfect time some/most of us could watch and learn for much longer very good quality content very good time explaining. You got the important differences with similarities of them/ pros and cons. Awesome work
Thank you! I’m glad it was useful information to you
A little tip put your notes above or behind the camera for future videos, cutting your eyes to the left for your notes. For some reason, it's bugging the crap out of me, lol, but other than that, it was a great video explaining the difference a bush knife and a survival knife. Thanks for your time and effort 👌🏻
I didn’t have notes in front of me. Just my way of talking/looking 😅
Great to see an Irish lad doing excellent content like this - looking forward to seeing the rest of your stuff. Subscribed. Best of luck with your channel from Dublin.
Thanks man. Very much appreciated
Very good context. Vid length is just right, thanks.
Thanks for the feedback
Lots of good information enabling an informed choice. Thank you.
Thanks Ronald! It’s supposed to help make a choice 😊
Thank you for sharing your thoughts on knives. Your knowledge is very good and I tend to agree with your opinions. I believe you’re correct about materials used to make knives but I suppose I’m lazy because regardless of style I prefer low maintenance materials. I noticed you didn’t say anything about concave grinds, a common grind I’ve seen on many budget (I don’t say cheap anymore) knives. It’s not a favorite profile of mine due to it being a bit less robust than other profiles. That said I do believe familiarity with your chosen tool makes the most difference when using the tool. That unfortunately isn’t something I’ve seen for sale anywhere; I’ve only gained familiarity from using the tools I have.
Thanks for the feedback I’m
Glad you enjoyed the video! When you say concave I presume you’re talking about hollow grinds. I didn’t go into that because I don’t own any and don’t have a lot of experience with them 🙂
Hollow grinds are great slicers.
And thus make good hunting skinning knives.
Another option for the same use is a thin flat grind knife.
It's not the length of the content, more about the content itself, so this is really good, cheers
Glad you enjoyed it mate
Hi. I loved the illustrations of the knife grinds. It was great for the newbies like me, it made sense. Thank you
Thanks! Glad it helped 😊
great video man!
if i may add my 2 cents, my favorite all around is the varusteleka terava jakaaripuukko 110 its a mouth full..but just a rock solid medium sized blade, affordable and a workhorse.
holds an edge pretty well. but just overall toughness and the price in my opinion is hard to beat. i use it everyday at work. and at home. give it a look or review if you havent already.
again great video, be safe out there!
Thanks for the input! Yea a few people have recommended that, so I’ll be checking it out for sure 😊
I opted for the 140 for increased chopping/batoning capability and for using on SAR missions, but I love all the same things about it that you mentioned for the 110. While it handles all wood processing tasks well, it's a little beefier than typical bushcraft blades and I would have no problem relying on it in a survival scenario.
Great video! Great definition of which is which, while emphasizing the lines are blurred in some applications.
Thank you! It’s difficult to find the lines for sure. No right or wrong answers but definitely there are some differences
Great video, thanks!
I carry a Scandi grind, a flat grind for food prep etc. And a hatchet. I can see how a survival knife could be pushed to do the work of all three and save some weight :)
Yeah! As you can see from the comments there are a million options! Personally I carry a small axe and usually a scandi for an overnight camp
That was helpful and enjoyable. Thank you.
Glad it was helpful! 😊
This was an amazing video! Learned so much! Gracias!
Thanks a lot dude
Im new to knife purchasing. Info was great and confirmed my new purchases to b what i needed. Looking forward to more of your videos :)
That’s great to hear as you are exactly the kind of person that I’m aiming this video at. Glad it helped
nice video bro, liked a lot!! thanks for the information, actually helped a lot too. always good to carrie those informations along with yourself in the woods
Excellent! I’m glad it was useful to you 😁
GREAT VIDEO! ALL GOOD INFO TO KEEP IN MIND FOR MY NEXT KNIFE BUILD!
Nice
Perfect! Thank you!
You're welcome!
Just popped up in my recommendations. Excellent. Subbed.
Thank you 😁
Thanks for this. I've learned something!
Glad it was helpful 🤜🏻🤛🏻
Thank you for a great video!
My pleasure! Glad you enjoyed it 😊
All around 👍 excellent video bud. Thanks
Thanks man
That cleared up the question for me.
Glad it was useful
Very good video, well done and very informative. One most of what you said, but just didn't have it all in one Mental File. The explanation on blade grinds and their uses was very useful, as was the explanation about full tang vs rat tails and Rambo knives, which are usually just cheap metal welded to a cheap metal tube. The weld is the common failure point. I have several of the knives that you featured. I love my Fallkniven S1, but I just really hate the sheath. I had a guy on etsy make me a kydex one that I like a lot better. I really like the handle material on my Esee. Even cheap Mora knives are a good bang for the buck.
Awesome! Thanks for the feedback I’m glad this info was succinct and helpful to you
Being Irish I did not know we had survivalist in our lineage it's good to see a fellow Irishman living in the woods like the leprechaun top of the morning to you lad hopefully you find a pot of gold just jokin great video
Thanks
very informative without being pretentious or preachy. you're a natural presenter. keep up the good work. nice collection by the way. have you seen the new morakniv range with the wood handles? they look nice at least. would be curious to know how they perform. cheers! 👍
Thank you for the kind words. I’ve seen the new Morakniv tea and I’ve heard terrible things. The handles soaking up water and loosening. Plus of course the price is insane
@@artoftheoutdoors interesting. yeah, can't see spending that kind of cash. most of the time it's too much knife for me anyways. The Victorinox Ranger Grip is usually more than enough for me.
I really enjoyed your tutorial I am more of a folding blade enthusiast but I'm developing an interest in fixed blade The survival I do is in Urban environment what I'm trying to say is Q.C.Q . On the average I carry two blades my primary and backup secondary on my person and I'm noticing that people starting to carry small fix blade. Anyway I really enjoyed your tutorial thank you😊
I’m glad you enjoyed
A lot of people consider the Becker BK2 great for urban survival. Many call it a pry bar with an edge..
Well thought out. I carry a RAT 7 as a one tool survival blade. The longer blade makes batoning through wood easier.
Nice choice! Thanks for watching
Good video. I would only add handle differences like shape. That with a bushcrafter you want a handle to be ergonomic and comfy for long hours of work with no hot spots. But for a survival you would want something more grippy more guards to prevent slippage from the hand like when said that you might chop with the knife or want to baton threw a log.
Good points also. Thanks
Great Video! I learned a few things I didn't know! Alot of good information!
Thanks for taking the time to watch
Good discussion of a foggy distinction, although you, perhaps wisely, omitted any mention of the type of survival knife that contains elements of a kit or design features that allow it to, for example, measure angles to function as a level or estimate distances.
Thanks! I find those types of tools to be very gimmicky and don’t serve their purpose very well
Good video, maybe do something more in depth in terms of how you use each blade and what your thought process is for selection.
Cheers!
Thanks for the feedback! Honestly I don’t think they’re “used” differently necessarily. Definitely something to explore though. Cheers 😁
Terrific video. Thank you
Thank you 😁
Thank you for the lesson
Thanks. Not a lesson just some thoughts 😁 I’m glad you enjoyed it
A thoughtful video on these concepts
Thank you for watching
Hello from Oklahoma! Good Video! Explained well. Thanks!
Thanks !!
I tend to carry three blades if I go off into an isolated area:
1/. My survival knife - chunky 7" blade, carried on my person
2/. A secondary splitting tool, such as small wood machete, Sherade Froe, or cleaver - carried in my hip bag or backpack
3/. A finer work blade: a Mora, or lockable folding blade, or a multitool. Usually a Scandi grind to slice, carve and shave wood.
This way I have two forms of splitting wood. One is a redundant blade in case I lose my main splitting tool.
Very nice. Well prepared 🙂 I usually just have my main knife (usually a Garberg or S1X) and a saw and then a mora 106 for small camp tasks
Excellent description of knives
Thank you 😊
I've learned something, Thx ! 👍🙏
Glad you enjoyed it
I’m old, Spent 24 years in the Army and even more hunting and fishing.
I have used and bought so many knives. I now just use the mora garberg it’s tough and does everything I need. Not fancy but it works
I absolutely love the Garberg. I had it with me on the day I shot this vid but it didn’t make it into the cut. Fantastic knife
Knives will always be a personal choice. Use what you like.
Fun talk! Weird how some people get stuck on crazy absolutes with this topic. You should do more knife stuff!
Thanks I’m glad it resonated with you. And yea, I’m really not trying to tell anyone this or that is “better” or “the best”, simply that if you’re new to these terms then what the hell does it all mean 😁 thanks for the feedback
@Art of the Outdoors My pleasure brother!
Top shelf video braw ❤ just found your channel. Fantastic content braw as always.
Thank you dude
I really like the way you went with this video. I’m an experienced knife user and thought you made great knife choices 🔪🎸
Thanks Paul!
Good content and information on the differences! 😊
Thanks David
All in a very good video imo. One telling factor is I didn't find myself fast forwarding to skip 'rambling' comments.
Hahah well that’s good to hear! Thanks
Rambly is good for those of us who don’t know a lot about the subject. Thank you for your passion in fixed blades and going on and on… lol!!
Im glad it was helpful!
Awesome video, really enjoyed. Hope you are on you way to many many more subs, you deserve it!
Wow thanks for the kind words mate! Let’s see what 2023 brings
Great video! (wellgreat channel in general).
Cheers from a fellow outdoors lover / knife enthusiast from a village of Fiskars, Finland!
ah nice! have always wanted to visit Fiskars. Thanks for the kind words
Very useful video. Inspired us to get our knives out to have a look at them and understand more about them. Thank you.
No problem
Bought a TOPS BOB Fieldcraft 4.5 right before a trip to the Alpines here in BC Canada, I got to say that knife is a damn beast, I used it to cook, baton, featherstick even filleted a fish with it, now it wasn't the best for any sort of butchering because of the beefy blade but it got the job done without losing it's edge, still seems just as sharp as when I got it, still got to patina though it as I did get the 1095 carbon steel version. If anyone is looking for a good knife, I definitely suggest it as one to take a look at however if you aren't wanting to maintain a carbon steel knife, there is a 154cm stainless version of it, another one of my favorite knives is an Esee 4, although it is a little smaller and less beefy, the Esee 5 I've heard is really good as well but I have never owned or even held one
Nice man! TOPS seem to have a great record. I have a tracker but haven’t had a chance to properly use it yet. Thanks for the feedback
Thanks. Love your jumper and overshirt. Where'd you get them?
Thanks! The shirt is Patagonia and the jumper is Royk
Excellent. Simple and concise, and I'm better informed. Flaxen Saxon.
Hi! Thanks for your feedback. I’m glad it was useful to you
Good, thoughtful discussion!
Glad it resonates. Thanks for your feedback
Nice video! A question that is often asked. I’m half Norwegian and I love my Scandi knives, but they aren’t survival knives. They are made for wood and meat processing. Prost
For me, the survival knives I've settled on are a couple from White River. Ursus 45 in Cpm3v, and a firecraft 3.5 in Magnacut, both with kydex sheath and ferro rods. I have a Fallkniven F1 as well, it's a great knife. Those are my favorite knives to travel with just in case me job tried to un-life me.
3v is good stuff. Until you lose your sharpening tools or forget one and now you have a dull paper weight. Magnacut is just over glorified s35vn. AEB-L is stronger and easier to sharpen. O1 can’t be beat in terms of toughness/ maintainability. Kydex is nice and light. I just wish it held up as good as leather. Kydex tends to warp really bad in the heat. It also tends to become very brittle in freezing temps and crack/shatter. Don’t get me wrong, I love supersteels and kydex occasionally. But I would really recommend considering any and all odds that can happen when considering your “survival kit”.
Nice choices all round there
@@pubplays368o1 most definitely can be beat in toughness. Magnacut is tougher than o1 for instance. Magnacut is cool if you highly value corrosion resistance and it’s edge holding potential is impressive given its other properties. I would choose aebl/14c if it was a survival knife that may need to be resharpened in the field with natural stones or whatever…but magnacut would be more than fine for bushcraft
Not to say there’s anything wrong with o1 it’s a fine steel but i do prefer 52100 to be a little different. Realistically there’s prob not a lot of noticeable difference between them tho. If I was wanting a big, indestructible chopper/beater/sharpened pry bar, I’d go with 8670 or maybe 80crv2 (another favorite)
In the words of Cody Lundin, when one's knowledge & skills increase one can effectively use about any knife.
I can do everything with a slip joint swiss army camper pocket knife or an imperial sod buster that I can do with my Mora companion.
Imagine, our ancestors were professional bush crafters/survivors/hunters/fishermen using only stone blade knives. . .
amazing how successful they were without 200 dollar, full tang, pry bar, tacticool knives.
100% dude
Very nice comprehensive video with good information! Cheers, brother. 🥃
Thank you! I’m glad you liked it
Good basic info. Thanks.
My pleasure
From SERE training, through bushcraft, overlanding, hiking, hunting, etc... I've found the classic K-Bar style knife to be very very hard to beat. I do carry an ONYX EDC replaceable blade knife on the daily and it has been my go to for skinning and daily duties for several years. However, it does not hold up to wood working, splitting, carving, and field craft types of things, but it is so much better at boning, and fine work that i carry the big knife on the pack and the precision tool in the pocket.
Interesting. Never liked the military knives myself. Everyone has their preferences
Grind is probably a good main difference after intent of design. I generally think of survival knives as being big and tough for chopping, whereas bushcraft is more for fine carving. I would also say survival knives should perform as a hunting knife, bushcraft knife, and a hatchet, so you want that multipurpose geometry, with enough sharpness for some skinning and machete use. Some survival knives are also designed to escape from vehicles, so you may find saw serrations for cutting sheet metal, a glass breaker, and/or seat belt cutter, while the sheath may include a fire starter, knife sharpener, cordage, fishing line, and/or compass. So survival knives really try to do-all in one simple package the best they can.
Good points! Thanks for sharing
Hello 👋 my outdoors friend, greetings from Northern California. Thank you for sharing this informative video. You helped to further my knowledge regarding knives. Ll the best to you. Stay safe out there. 🤗
Hey! Thanks for watching I’m glad you enjoyed it