Very nice summary to understand everything related to the event. Wanted to know about rumour related to pregnant women inside the golden temple during operation blue star
You're videos are the best in India, or I must say among the best in the world... I've been refering to your videos for some time now, and it really helped me in getting on track... Thank you so much for your videos and the nice presentation... I do have some suggestions for the next videos you can consider... 1. American civil war 2. Simon Boliver and South American revolutions.. 3. Age of explorations 4. American Presidents 5. The great depression. 6. Crusades 7. Gupta period. 8. Buddhism and the councils. 9. Mughal empire 10. Roman Empire 11. Renaissance 12. Space Race 13. Caliphate 14. Napoleon 15. History of Russia 16. Indian independence struggle 17. Martin Luther king and his movements 18. African colonization 19. Neo colonialism 20. Cuba - Castro and Che Guvera
Though separate country for Sikhs should not be allowed seeing Hindus and Sikhs living together n sharing common Dharmic traditions but Sikhs do deserved more importance seeing their loyalty to this land, the contribution of Gurus in protecting our land and religion. Even the Kashmiri Pandits were saved by Sikhs. So more importance is deserved. Jai Hind
He is a Rajasthani and he doesn't want to disclose that they are the root cause of Punjab problem. He is giving misleading information to the students.
The government increased its activities against Sikhs in late the 70s which led to massacre of thirteen Sikhs in 1978 who were peacefully protesting against an Indian agent who was preaching anti Sikh material. When Sikhs filed a case in the supreme court in Punjab, it was heard in Haryana because the majority was Hindus in that state. Those majority people (Hindus) accused Sikhs for causing the trouble and the agent and his followers were released. This really outraged Sikhs. At that time a person named Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale started preaching Sikhism in Punjab and all over India. He spoke against Indian activities against Sikhs. His speeches made Sikhs realize that they were not free in India. They were being treated like second class citizens. Sikhs started demanding more rights and wanted to be treated like first class citizens. Sikhs launched a peaceful march. A band of 51 Sikhs would go to protest peacefully and would get arrested by the police. But Indian government didn't care and more than 150,000 Sikhs were arrested. This lasted for more than two years. In between this time, the police burnt copies of Sri Guru Granth Sahib at Mehta Choank, killed many Sikhs in fake encounters. But not a single case was filed. On the other hand when a Hindu was killed by police, prime minister Indira Gandhi herself came over to his house and gave his family money. His case was filed within hours. But police and the government did not do anything when copies of Sri Guru Granth Sahib were burnt. Many Sikhs were killed but their families didn't receive anything from the government. Indian government completely showed that one Hindu's life was more important than not only 150 Sikhs that were killed but also Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. When Sikhs lost all the hopes from the government, they raised arms as instructed by Guru Gobind Singh Ji to get freedom. Seeing this Indian government launched a sudden attack on Golden Temple and killed thousands of Sikhs. Other 45 Gurdwaras were also attacked by the army. Women were dishonored. Many innocent children were killed. After the attack was over all Sikhs inside the Golden Temple were taken out, lined up and then shot dead. Reference library which included many hand written scriptures and priceless antiques was burnt. One bullet had gone through Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Indian troops walked inside Golden Temple with their shoes on. They smoked cigarettes, drank alcohol inside the Gurdwara which was highly disrespectful to the Sikh faith. If there was Khalistan, there would have been no attack on the Golden Temple. After Indira Gandhi was killed, Hindus killed more than 5,000 Sikhs within three days in Delihi alone thousands more all over India. This genocide of Sikhs was led by the ruling party Congress. Sajjan Kumar (still alive), Lalat Makan and Arjan Das (killed by Sukhdev Singh and Harjinder Singh) were Congressmen who played a major role in masterminding and carrying out this genocide. They were given orders by Rajiv Gandhi, Narsima Rao and Attal Bihar Vaajpai. Many Hindu criminals were released from jails to kill Sikhs and each was given 500 rupees and one bottle of liquor. Congressmen gave Hindus the list of Sikhs' properties and their home addresses. Hindus went from house to house, dragged Sikhs, especially young males, out of their homes and burnt them alive. Their properties were looted and destroyed. Hindus' target was to kill Sikh males from age 10 to 40. Women above age of 14 were dishonored. This went on without any interruption from the police. In fact, the police was helping these mobs. Every bus on the road was stopped and checked if there were any Sikhs traveling in it. If they found any Sikh, he was killed on the spot. Police was motivating the mobs by saying "If Sikhs were given even one day to kill Hindus, they would've killed all Hindus in India. You, on the other hand are too slow." These brutal things happened to Sikhs in India. If there was Khalistan there would not have been any Sikh genocide and Hindus would not have dared to attack Sikhs. Sikhs are being killed in fake encounters. There is disappearance of Sikh youth in Punjab. Indian government has killed from 1 to 1.2 million Sikhs and about 70 thousand Sikhs are in jail. Here are some of the methods of torture, humiliation and atrocities used by Indian Government against the Sikhs. These are taken from www.saintsoldiers.net To interrogate the Sikhs, a round log of wood is placed on their legs, and after putting heavy weight on the log it is rotated on the legs. Chilly powder is sprinkled in the eyes and sex organs of the Sikhs. Sikhs are hung upside down from the ceilings till they became unconscious. The body joints are battered. Electric shocks are administered to the genitals making most of the youth impotent Sikh women, during interrogation, are hurt in their sex organs. Filthy abuse is showered on them. Violence is inflicted on the parents in presence of their sons and daughters and vice-versa. Brothers are forced to beat sisters and vice versa. violence is inflicted on adult girls after stripping them naked and their sex organs are damaged. They are sexually assaulted, pregnancies are terminated of the expectant females. Crotchets are pulled apart. The victims of inhuman violence are made to sit naked in winter, and under the sun in summer, kept sleepless for days in solitary cells. Sikhs are subjected to severe beatings and filthy abuse in the presence of their village folks. Dead bodies of Sikhs killed in fake encounters are not handed over to their parents to conceal marks of excessive violence The state manipulates tailored post mortem reports from the doctors, and burns the dead bodies of the Sikhs after falsely declaring them unclaimed. All sorts of excesses are made on the parents of underground Sikh youths. Indiscriminate atrocities are committed on the parents of the underground youth of the area where some militant action takes place. Atrocities are committed without caring for one's age, health, life or death. If some one luckily survives such brutal excesses, it is well and good But if one dies while under "interrogation", then such a dead body is taken out, pierced with some bullets, and a news item is sent that a dreaded terrorist has been shot dead in an encounter Houses of underground Sikh youths are demolished, their belongings are looted, crops destroyed, their tube well motors are taken away, and they are prevented from sowing crops. Even animals of the families of underground Sikh youth are subjected to police anger. After summoning the families to the police station, villagers are told not to take care of the animals of the families of the underground youth. Generally the animals starve to death. False cases are registered against innocent Sikh youths, later they are let off taking fat bribes. Reporters giving true reports are arrested, an undeclared censorship is imposed on them to stop them from exposing police atrocities. Peaceful protests by the Human rights organizations are prohibited. Press is used to launch vicious and false propaganda against the Sikhs. Hardened criminals are inducted into Sikh movement to help in arresting the Sikh revolutionaries and sabotage the movement. Such criminals are inducted to tarnish the fair name of the Sikh revolutionaries are now called the "Black Cats" in the Punjab. Under SSP Izhar Alam, such criminal gangs were named the "Alam Sena." Besides, such police sponsored bands of criminals also operated under the name of Panthic Tiger Force and "Red Brigade." The director general of the police himself admitted about the "Black Cats" bands. In his interview to the India Today on Sept. 15, 188, KPS Gill had announced without an iota of shame that the security forces in Punjab cannot do anything without the help of secret bands (Black Cats). Thousands of innocent pilgrims, children, females, aged people, who got encircled in the Golden Temple during Operation Bluestar were made to die through starvation and thirst. The whole of Punjab was converted into a vast jail by clamping curfew on the entire area. The army bulletin branded all Amritdhaaree's as terrorists. Indian army desecrated the Gurdwaras and committed such atrocities on the Sikhs that even the soul of Ahmed Shah Abdali might have felt ashamed of. The targets of army guns were none else but religious persons, devotees, pilgrims, ladies, old people, children or some militants whom the Indian government deemed as terrorists. No neutral observer was allowed to take stock of the situation. The injured during the attack on the Golden Temple were subjected to extreme partiality. Whereas every assistance and facility was made available to the injured army personnel, there was no such provision for the wounded belonging to the other side. The number of prisoners taken was rather small. There is ample scope for doubt that the Indian army had thought it better to eliminate the thousands of people seized in the Golden Temple instead of taking them prisoners or having to provide them with medical assistance. No need was felt to perform religious rites for the dead pilgrims and devotees. Before consigning the dead bodies to flames, no effort was made to identify them. No relatives were informed. No dead bodies were handed over to the next of kin. In such a situation only the dead or those wishing to be dead could be present at the last rites. All dead bodies were placed in heaps and then con- signed to flames. IT was never insured that among the dead there could also be some Muslim devotees. To cremate is against the tenets of Islam. No need was felt to give a list of the dead to the Red Cross or any other International Agency Despite such atrocities, no commission was appointed to go into this dark episode. Even the British, the foreign rulers, had cared to appoint the Hunter commission to inquire into the Jallianwalla Massacre which was of a much less magnitude on the other hand. Th
For us to understand this, we must move deep, very deep. This was not a movement just started by Sikhs of their own will. Yes, the Sikhs were treated poorly and were not given due respect. As a result of vote-bank politics, the Sikhs were ill-treated and were not given the development that was required. But, how did it start? This movement was instigated and instigated for various selfish reasons of Mrs. Indira Gandhi and Bhutto. In Pakistan, there was a movement known as the Jinnahpur movement. In India, there was a Kashmir issue and also of-course a lot of problems due to vote bank politics. Indira Gandhi wanted to use the Sikhs to help herself get out of the vote-bank issues and hence decided to use the Sikhs for that. Also, the jinnahpur movement in Pakistan would also come to an end with the help of Sikhs. Thus instigating the Sikhs for Khalistan. The jinnahpur movement was a headache for Pakistan and the Kashmir issue and vote-bank politics was a issue for Mrs. Indira Gandhi. Since Sikhs were there in both countries, it was most ideal for both to use them. Of course, Khalistan would never have been formed as the government only wanted to use the Sikhs. Of course, such truth never is out in the open but this a part of the truth. These Sikhs then fell into the trap and weapons were supplied to them by Mrs. Indira Gandhi herself. She started helping them for her own selfish cause. And, then the Sikhs realized that they were in a trap and used their power against Indira Gandhi, they started biting the hands that fed them. I can in no way blame the Sikhs as they were ill-treated. It was not entirely their fault. The Sikhs have always served the country and to treat them in such a manner is a national shame. The government should know how to deal with their people and how to treat them. This system needs to change. It is a sad thing that the Sikhs have been driven out of their own motherland. We must take all steps to bring them and resolve issues in peace.
15307 Indian Army soldiers killed in operation Bluestar by only 150-250 singhs... Written by general kuldeep Brar who led army in operation Bluestar In his second book.....
English Translation given below. ਸਤਿਕਾਰਯੋਗ ਰਾਠੌੜ ਸਾਹਿਬ, ਤੁਸੀਂ ਬਹੁਤ ਹੀ ਵਧੀਆ ਵੀਡੀਓ ਬਣਾਈ ਹੈ ਅਤੇ ਇੱਕ ਪਾਸੇ ਦਾ ਸੱਚ ਬਿਆਨ ਵੀ ਕੀਤਾ ਹੈ ਜੋ ਕਿ ਭਾਰਤੀ ਮੀਡੀਆ ਨੇ ਦਿਖਾਇਆ ਅਤੇ ਸਰਕਾਰ ਨੇ ਪੇਸ਼ ਕੀਤਾ ਸੀ। ਪਰ ਦੂਜੇ ਪਾਸੇ ਦੀ ਸਚਾਈ ਕਦੇ ਵੀ ਸਾਹਮਣੇ ਨਹੀਂ ਆਉਣ ਦਿੱਤੀ। ਸੰਤ ਜਰਨੈਲ ਸਿੰਘ ਇੱਕ ਨਿਰੋਲ ਸੰਤ ਸਨ ਜਿਨ੍ਹਾਂ ਨੇ ਆਖਰੀ ਦਮ ਤੱਕ ਖਾਲਿਸਤਾਨ ਦੀ ਮੰਗ ਨਹੀਂ ਕੀਤੀ ਸਿਰਫ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦੇ ਹੱਕ ਮੰਗੇ ਸਨ। ਉਹਨਾਂ ਨੇ ਕਦੇ ਵੀ ਕਿਸੇ ਉਪਰ ਆਪਣੀ ਤਰਫ ਤੋਂ ਪਹਿਲਾਂ ਹਮਲਾ ਨਹੀਂ ਕੀਤਾ ਹਮੇਸ਼ਾ ਜੁਆਬੀ ਕਾਰਵਾਈ ਹੀ ਕੀਤੀ। ਇਹ ਸਾਰਾ ਸਾਕਾ ਕਾਂਗਰਸ ਅਤੇ ਅਕਾਲੀ ਸਰਕਾਰ ਦੀ ਆਪਸੀ ਰਾਜਨੀਤਿਕ ਰੰਜਸ਼ ਦਾ ਨਤੀਜਾ ਸੀ ਅਤੇ ਜਿਸ ਦਾ ਖਾਮਿਆਜਾ ਸਿੱਖਾਂ ਅਤੇ ਪੰਜਾਬੀਆਂ ਨੂੰ ਭੁਗਤਣਾ ਪਿਆ। Respected Rathor Ji, You have made a very good video and present the single side truth which was was presented by Indian media and Govt. of India. But the truth of the another side never come outside. Saint Jarnail Singh was a pure religious Saint who never demanded the Khalistan up to his last breath. He demanded just the right of the Punjab and Sikhs. He never attacked on anyone first from his own side he always reply the others actions This all operation was the result of the political games of the Congress as well as the Akalis and for all these things re-payed by the Punjabis and Sikhs. Thanks and Regards, Pavitar Singh
Don't worry now we have social media. We can bring the truth in front the people. So work for the ethical purposes of the media.. You will be success in your missions..
Issue dealt very comprehensively & Excellently explained... Just more empasis on its imapct/analysis need... Thanks for giving holistic understanding..
Mai v sikh han bt khalistan banan de khilaf han, Te mera sare sikha nu ik msg, socho j khalistan bnya ta patna sahib, bangla sahib, nanded sahib, hemkund sahib, alag desh ch chle jaane , ajj desh de hr kone te sikh rehnde, uhna di v socho, ajj sikha di poore desh ch respect aa, kisi guru ne ni keha v inj alag hoke rho, sanu alag sooba punjab milya hoya oh kafi aa..
@@G.O.A.T-a1 yeh dimag se paidal he corona me lakho logo ko khana khilaare guruduware bnd hokr be lngar nhi roka or tere jaise aake bss bdi bdi baate krte hai.
*Grampanchayat, Mp election, Cm election ke baare me video banayiye* Election k liye kaise khade rahe, Kya requirements hai ye sab मे दावे के साथ कहता हू Channel का Growth भी होगा और Public को knowledge भी आयेगा
A friend told me. If you want to fight, be prepare to receive punches. I afraid to do harm because the consequence is very severe. Thanks. Now I understand how this is all started.
Nice video sir...... Hindu love Sikhs.....but humanity is above over religion......India is above over religion.......and army did same things........bcoz indian army has no religion.......they live for India,die for India. And sorry sardar ji,for 1984 riot.
just sorry......why didn't u ask supreme cournt to hang the leaders...who did sikh genocide.........sorry to say....if someone raped ur sisters and mothers and then say sorry...how would u feel.......if our time come we will show u how the justice have been done.....the victims of 84 genocide are still in courts...bloody system
vikash kumar Well I dnt think Khalistan is a solution .....think fellow Sikhs .......we will be a small country ........west pakistan punjab will still be in pak ....so no use of khalistan 1984 .....bitch indira paid price .........she killed thousand Sikhs now she is in hell .
@@sukhpreetsingh-tk9nn BRO WHEN THERE IS A RIOT, BOTH COMMUNITIES SUFFER. I KNOW MANY HINDU FAMILIES IN PUNJAB WHO WERE KILLED. IT WAS UNFORTUNATE ACCEPT IT. KASMIRI PUNDITS WERE ALSO KILLED, TOH WOH SEPERATE COUNTRY KI DEMAND KAREN?
vikash kumar you don’t have to feel sorry u haven’t done anything in this the Gandhi family indra gandhi done operation blur star sikhs sent her into the hell
@@sukhpreetsingh-tk9nn verra je es bande de gal sachi hundi phir GURU GOBIND SINGH JI khade SIKH dharam na banude DHARAM de layi raaj hunda e naki raaj layi dharam
“History is written by the victor” this quote is very important, especially in this presentation. All the information this man gave was based on the history written by the Indian government. All the history given was bias because it was written by Indian government. If you actually look at the history from both sides. You could tell that jarnail Singh was a saint and a martyr, not a terrorist. But because the victors (India) wrote the history. Of course they were not going to write anything bad about themselves. So this presentation is very bias.
Dr mahipal singh rathore please ask me.Where you from read or got this facts.Is it any reasonable source or buy any book from market.Please read book of genral kuldeep brar book operation blue star. You get very good knowledge and 80%correct.Near to reality .
Hi Indians , it's sad that we are dividing in the name of religion . Our country is a diversed cultural country that is the soul of our country 'Unity in diversity' , we should not go for exclusive nationalism ..... We want inclusive nationalism ... We except all.... no need of hindu country or muslim or Sikh . Our country should except all culture and race We have nearly 150 languages so how we could go for a single national language? All languages are National . But for the sake of easynes we could give majority language for official purpose. India should have inclusive nationalism .
sukhrajcse people should decide will not give bribe ...Then government will change ... And government is the people only ....We should understand they are at our service not our boss.....The new generation will change for sure....
If there was a Sikh country, no one would have attacked Gurdwaras and killed Sikhs. If there was a Sikh country, the situation would have been different and Punjab wouldn't be stuck between the nuclear war of India and Pakistan. If there is a war, the whole of Punjab will be destroyed. How does their community service help solving the real problems of Sikhs? The Indian government is spending billions of rupees to bring Sikhism into the fold of Hinduism. How does their community service help Sikhs to stop Indian government, RSS and Noormahals from attacking their Sikh brothers in Punjab and India? How? Sikhs are fighting to keep their distinction and appearance, to save their religion and to keep Sikhi alive. If that means a separate country then why not? It doesn't mean we want to divide the world but shouldn't we think about securing Sikh faith first and all the virtues it stands for? If the Indian government doesn't like us and doesn't want to live with Sikhs, then why shouldn't we just be separated? When we gain power we can promote Sikhi and teach the message of the Gurus and universal brotherhood. Can this not be done? Khalistan is not for bad purpose. When I ask any non-Punjabi Sikh about Khalistan, the vast majority have the same answer that they don't want to be separated or wouldn't want to move to Khalistan. But who says you have to move. Sikhs will still live in other countries. But most of Sikhnet people reply in exactly the same words. Sounds like they need to learn the true purpose of fighting. Perhaps they are sticking with community service a whole lot but what if those people we want to help turn against us, should we not fight to defend ourselves? If yes, then that's exactly what Sikhs are doing. If no, then that is not Sikhi. Now some general questions from Punjabi people. These are the people who are not Amritdhari. They don't practice Sikhism at all. They eat meat, drink alcohol, smoke and do everything that is prohibited by Gurus and yet they call themselves Sikhs. Before I go into their questions, I want to say that only an Amritdhari person is a Sikh. One who follows Guru's teaching is a Sikh and Khalistan is for Sikhs. Everyone will have religious freedom but people who commit adultery, smoke, drink alcohol etc. will not be allowed to live there because not only Sikhism but also all religions prohibit these things. How would Khalistan survive economically? Well, how did India and Pakistan survive after independence? UAE gained its independence in 1971 and it is surviving. Same way Khalistan will survive but it will not be a third world country because Sikhs are very hard working people. Punjab is a cultivated land and it provides most of the food for India. Punjab produces corn, wheat, sugarcanes, sporting goods, clothing, industrial material and many other commodities. Khalistani government will keep this stuff as much as it needs and the rest will be shipped out to other countries as a trade and in return oil and other necessities will be bought. No one in Khalistan will die out of hunger because if Punjab can provide food for 90% of the Indian population then it surely can provide food for everyone in Khalistan because the population in Khalistan will be a lot less than Indian population. Who will be the leader of Khalistan? Panj Pyare will be the leaders of Khalistan. Elections will be held every four years and people will choose Panj Pyare. These Panj Pyare will rule under the authority of Akaal Takhat Sahib. Every city will have Panj Pyare as its leader. There will be no bad leaders in Khalistan because when Khalsa Panth starts doing Naam Simran in the morning, it will gain spiritual power which no one will be able to destroy. Foundation of Khalistan will be laid upon the power of Naam Simran. Guru Gobind Singh Ji said "When Khalsa starts following the true path of the Guru Granth Sahib and abandons all the bad things, I will give them sovereignty." So when the time for Khalistan comes, every Sikh will be a true Sikh and there will be no bad people in Sikhism. Guru Ji said "Raaj Karega Khalsa Aakki Rahe Na Koe" which means Khalsa shall rule and there will be no one against Khalsa. Khalsa Raj (Khalistan) shall come for sure. Khalistan will be a true Khalsa Raj. What about sea ports? There are 42 landlocked countries in the world that are surviving. To say or think that just because of lack of seaport Khalistan will not survive is irrational. There are many third world countries that have sea ports such as Sri Lanka, and Brazil. Landlocked countries are helped by their neighboring countries that have seaports. In return these countries get money and/or something else in exchange. There are numerous possibilities in business. We can use Pakistan’s and/or India’s seaports. I don’t think there is any country that does not want to do business and make profit. How exactly would this work depends on the future, circumstances and situations. Oil can also be imported through India or Pakistan. United Nations is working on passing a treaty that would help landlocked countries get access to seaports. We can survive without a seaport. What would happen if there is war between Pakistan and India? Khalistan will be a neutral country and will be a buffer state between the two countries. With Khalistan as a buffer state both countries will feel safe from each other. Neither Pakistan nor India would dare to step on Khalistan's boundaries. India has fought two wars with Pakistan and every time Pakistan was defeated because only Sikhs fought on the boundaries of Punjab. Sikhs are a martial race. British recognized that soon after Punjab was annexed. Guru Gobind Singh Ji made Sikhs saint-warriors. Sikhs in Khalistan will be true saints and warriors. They will have power of Naam Simran because they will free Khalistan on the power of Naam Simran and one who has this power is never afraid of anyone other than God. By doing Nam Simran one never fears death. We have numerous example from the 18th century. Sikh country will be very powerful and Pakistan would not try to mess with it. Hindus can't fight, so there is no question that Indian government will ever dream of attacking Khalistan. If there is war between India and Pakistan, they will have to fight it outside of Sikh territory. What about control over Gurdwaras outside of Khalistan? Well, all the Gurdwaras will be directly controlled by the Khalistani government run under Akaal Takhat Sahib. Currently, Indian government is not doing anything about the Gurdwaras in Pakistan, Afghanistan and other countries because the Indian government doesn't want Sikhs to be attached with their Gurdwaras. Indian government thinks the only way to destroy Sikhism is to keep Sikhs away from Guru Granth Sahib's message and the Gurdwaras. Gurdwaras outside of India are still standing without the support of Indian government but when there is Khalistan, the government will do its best to take care of these holy places and agreements will be made with the other countries that would give us the direct control over the Gurdwaras. We can negotiate with Pakistani government and have control over our Gurdwaras and they can have control over their mosques. We will negotiate with Pakistani government to give us the control over Sikh Gurdwaras. Committees will be established to manage these Gurdwaras. Monthly reports will be submitted to the officials (not necessarily to the federal government). The money of the Gurdwaras will be spent in managing the Gurdwaras, Sikh schools, parchaar, helping the poor and needy. There is no constitution? Yes there is but people just never search for it. Khalistan will be totally based on the principles of Sikhi. Gurbani is the constitution. There is not and can never be a better constitution than Gurbani. Guru Ji wrote this constitution more than 400 years ago. But look at the reality. Constitution of the USA was written ten years after thirteen colonies gained independence. Constitution of India was written three years after it gained independence. If these countries can write their constitution after independence then why can't we? No country is perfect. Every country has loopholes in its laws and policies so expecting flawless plans and policies from Khalistanis is not realistic. Laws can be changed. India has amended its constitution many times. So, do not expect a perfect constitution and policies from Khalistan.
What u have written painstakingly was also propagated by Jinnah in the name of Islam. See the results with your own eyes. See the doomsday of pakistan, cause it was created on the basis of a lie that a single religious country would be a paradise. Despite having warrior muslims, following righteous pathway of islam, low population, hardworking, acces to seaport, having tje most fertile lamd of east punjab it is a failed state. Due to the secessionist propaganda of jinnah millions were killed, displaced from their birthplace forcefully. The country was made by shedding of blood of millions, still it is propagating the same in kashmir. How could even allah spare such a country?
@0.19 Sikh genocide not anti-Sikh riots @23:59 Lala Jagat Narain also wrote rubbish about the Sikh Gurus. Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale was a Sikh nationalist. You should have also mentioned something about the Punjab independence referendum 2020. We 'the Sikhs and Punjabis' won't stop, until we get back our lost country or something equivalent in south Asia. We are not Indians, nor Pakistanis, we are Punjabis.
You have enjoyed this video but he has given you misleading information. He is a Rajasthani and he doesn't tell you that they are the root cause of Punjab problem
v v nice video.... earlier information that was spread in our country n as u told facts r so different.....facts spread r political....bt will go with education n exam point of view....
Aisaa nhi bataya ki bhimdrawale ke samarthko ne Hindu bhu betio ki b ijjat bachai ... Aur jo balatkar hote the Punjab me uske wo sakhat khilaaf tha .. khalistan ki maang kbhi b nhi hui ... 5 June ka din isliye choose kiya k jayada se jayada sikho ko khatam kiya jaye means genocide ... Harmandir sahib me akele attack nhi kiya balki 37 aur gurdwaras me bhi attack hua ... Sikh library se truck bhar k religious books Delhi lejiyaaa giya
Please do more research before uploading. Wrong information about Guru Granth Sahib Ji right in the beginning and why Guru Arjan Dev Ji were executed. Didn't watch further as couldn't take any more.....
My hearty thanks to study IQ for making videos in english
Iam sikh I love my india
jai hind
Nidhi Shree your name doesnot suggest so!
Very nice summary to understand everything related to the event. Wanted to know about rumour related to pregnant women inside the golden temple during operation blue star
You're videos are the best in India, or I must say among the best in the world... I've been refering to your videos for some time now, and it really helped me in getting on track... Thank you so much for your videos and the nice presentation...
I do have some suggestions for the next videos you can consider...
1. American civil war
2. Simon Boliver and South American revolutions..
3. Age of explorations
4. American Presidents
5. The great depression.
6. Crusades
7. Gupta period.
8. Buddhism and the councils.
9. Mughal empire
10. Roman Empire
11. Renaissance
12. Space Race
13. Caliphate
14. Napoleon
15. History of Russia
16. Indian independence struggle
17. Martin Luther king and his movements
18. African colonization
19. Neo colonialism
20. Cuba - Castro and Che Guvera
Though separate country for Sikhs should not be allowed seeing Hindus and Sikhs living together n sharing common Dharmic traditions but Sikhs do deserved more importance seeing their loyalty to this land, the contribution of Gurus in protecting our land and religion. Even the Kashmiri Pandits were saved by Sikhs. So more importance is deserved. Jai Hind
Yah
He is a Rajasthani and he doesn't want to disclose that they are the root cause of Punjab problem. He is giving misleading information to the students.
Pls sir make a video about all the important supreme court cases such as kesavnanda etc
Areeb Kazmi kesavanand bharti
But why did army select that day when large number of people were visiting the place?
He is misleading the students in the name of Khalistan.
No one had demanded Khalistan. This is a propaganda to hide the actual cause i.e. water
These Rajasthani are looting Punjab's water and they have not given a single penny to Punjab
If you want to know the truth then watch Subramaniam Swammy's interview
Substly drafted, Very well explained & delicious twist 👍👍👍
The government increased its activities against Sikhs in late the 70s which led to massacre of thirteen Sikhs in 1978 who were peacefully protesting against an Indian agent who was preaching anti Sikh material. When Sikhs filed a case in the supreme court in Punjab, it was heard in Haryana because the majority was Hindus in that state. Those majority people (Hindus) accused Sikhs for causing the trouble and the agent and his followers were released. This really outraged Sikhs. At that time a person named Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale started preaching Sikhism in Punjab and all over India. He spoke against Indian activities against Sikhs. His speeches made Sikhs realize that they were not free in India. They were being treated like second class citizens. Sikhs started demanding more rights and wanted to be treated like first class citizens.
Sikhs launched a peaceful march. A band of 51 Sikhs would go to protest peacefully and would get arrested by the police. But Indian government didn't care and more than 150,000 Sikhs were arrested. This lasted for more than two years. In between this time, the police burnt copies of Sri Guru Granth Sahib at Mehta Choank, killed many Sikhs in fake encounters. But not a single case was filed. On the other hand when a Hindu was killed by police, prime minister Indira Gandhi herself came over to his house and gave his family money. His case was filed within hours. But police and the government did not do anything when copies of Sri Guru Granth Sahib were burnt. Many Sikhs were killed but their families didn't receive anything from the government. Indian government completely showed that one Hindu's life was more important than not only 150 Sikhs that were killed but also Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
When Sikhs lost all the hopes from the government, they raised arms as instructed by Guru Gobind Singh Ji to get freedom. Seeing this Indian government launched a sudden attack on Golden Temple and killed thousands of Sikhs. Other 45 Gurdwaras were also attacked by the army. Women were dishonored. Many innocent children were killed. After the attack was over all Sikhs inside the Golden Temple were taken out, lined up and then shot dead. Reference library which included many hand written scriptures and priceless antiques was burnt. One bullet had gone through Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Indian troops walked inside Golden Temple with their shoes on. They smoked cigarettes, drank alcohol inside the Gurdwara which was highly disrespectful to the Sikh faith. If there was Khalistan, there would have been no attack on the Golden Temple.
After Indira Gandhi was killed, Hindus killed more than 5,000 Sikhs within three days in Delihi alone thousands more all over India. This genocide of Sikhs was led by the ruling party Congress. Sajjan Kumar (still alive), Lalat Makan and Arjan Das (killed by Sukhdev Singh and Harjinder Singh) were Congressmen who played a major role in masterminding and carrying out this genocide. They were given orders by Rajiv Gandhi, Narsima Rao and Attal Bihar Vaajpai. Many Hindu criminals were released from jails to kill Sikhs and each was given 500 rupees and one bottle of liquor. Congressmen gave Hindus the list of Sikhs' properties and their home addresses. Hindus went from house to house, dragged Sikhs, especially young males, out of their homes and burnt them alive. Their properties were looted and destroyed. Hindus' target was to kill Sikh males from age 10 to 40. Women above age of 14 were dishonored. This went on without any interruption from the police. In fact, the police was helping these mobs. Every bus on the road was stopped and checked if there were any Sikhs traveling in it. If they found any Sikh, he was killed on the spot. Police was motivating the mobs by saying "If Sikhs were given even one day to kill Hindus, they would've killed all Hindus in India. You, on the other hand are too slow." These brutal things happened to Sikhs in India. If there was Khalistan there would not have been any Sikh genocide and Hindus would not have dared to attack Sikhs.
Sikhs are being killed in fake encounters. There is disappearance of Sikh youth in Punjab. Indian government has killed from 1 to 1.2 million Sikhs and about 70 thousand Sikhs are in jail. Here are some of the methods of torture, humiliation and atrocities used by Indian Government against the Sikhs. These are taken from www.saintsoldiers.net
To interrogate the Sikhs, a round log of wood is placed on their legs, and after putting heavy weight on the log it is rotated on the legs.
Chilly powder is sprinkled in the eyes and sex organs of the Sikhs.
Sikhs are hung upside down from the ceilings till they became unconscious.
The body joints are battered.
Electric shocks are administered to the genitals making most of the youth impotent
Sikh women, during interrogation, are hurt in their sex organs. Filthy abuse is showered on them.
Violence is inflicted on the parents in presence of their sons and daughters and vice-versa.
Brothers are forced to beat sisters and vice versa. violence is inflicted on adult girls after stripping them naked and their sex organs are damaged. They are sexually assaulted, pregnancies are terminated of the expectant females.
Crotchets are pulled apart.
The victims of inhuman violence are made to sit naked in winter, and under the sun in summer, kept sleepless for days in solitary cells.
Sikhs are subjected to severe beatings and filthy abuse in the presence of their village folks.
Dead bodies of Sikhs killed in fake encounters are not handed over to their parents to conceal marks of excessive violence
The state manipulates tailored post mortem reports from the doctors, and burns the dead bodies of the Sikhs after falsely declaring them unclaimed.
All sorts of excesses are made on the parents of underground Sikh youths.
Indiscriminate atrocities are committed on the parents of the underground youth of the area where some militant action takes place.
Atrocities are committed without caring for one's age, health, life or death. If some one luckily survives such brutal excesses, it is well and good But if one dies while under "interrogation", then such a dead body is taken out, pierced with some bullets, and a news item is sent that a dreaded terrorist has been shot dead in an encounter
Houses of underground Sikh youths are demolished, their belongings are looted, crops destroyed, their tube well motors are taken away, and they are prevented from sowing crops.
Even animals of the families of underground Sikh youth are subjected to police anger. After summoning the families to the police station, villagers are told not to take care of the animals of the families of the underground youth. Generally the animals starve to death.
False cases are registered against innocent Sikh youths, later they are let off taking fat bribes.
Reporters giving true reports are arrested, an undeclared censorship is imposed on them to stop them from exposing police atrocities.
Peaceful protests by the Human rights organizations are prohibited.
Press is used to launch vicious and false propaganda against the Sikhs.
Hardened criminals are inducted into Sikh movement to help in arresting the Sikh revolutionaries and sabotage the movement. Such criminals are inducted to tarnish the fair name of the Sikh revolutionaries are now called the "Black Cats" in the Punjab. Under SSP Izhar Alam, such criminal gangs were named the "Alam Sena." Besides, such police sponsored bands of criminals also operated under the name of Panthic Tiger Force and "Red Brigade." The director general of the police himself admitted about the "Black Cats" bands. In his interview to the India Today on Sept. 15, 188, KPS Gill had announced without an iota of shame that the security forces in Punjab cannot do anything without the help of secret bands (Black Cats).
Thousands of innocent pilgrims, children, females, aged people, who got encircled in the Golden Temple during Operation Bluestar were made to die through starvation and thirst. The whole of Punjab was converted into a vast jail by clamping curfew on the entire area. The army bulletin branded all Amritdhaaree's as terrorists.
Indian army desecrated the Gurdwaras and committed such atrocities on the Sikhs that even the soul of Ahmed Shah Abdali might have felt ashamed of.
The targets of army guns were none else but religious persons, devotees, pilgrims, ladies, old people, children or some militants whom the Indian government deemed as terrorists.
No neutral observer was allowed to take stock of the situation.
The injured during the attack on the Golden Temple were subjected to extreme partiality. Whereas every assistance and facility was made available to the injured army personnel, there was no such provision for the wounded belonging to the other side.
The number of prisoners taken was rather small. There is ample scope for doubt that the Indian army had thought it better to eliminate the thousands of people seized in the Golden Temple instead of taking them prisoners or having to provide them with medical assistance.
No need was felt to perform religious rites for the dead pilgrims and devotees.
Before consigning the dead bodies to flames, no effort was made to identify them. No relatives were informed.
No dead bodies were handed over to the next of kin. In such a situation only the dead or those wishing to be dead could be present at the last rites.
All dead bodies were placed in heaps and then con- signed to flames. IT was never insured that among the dead there could also be some Muslim devotees. To cremate is against the tenets of Islam.
No need was felt to give a list of the dead to the Red Cross or any other International Agency
Despite such atrocities, no commission was appointed to go into this dark episode. Even the British, the foreign rulers, had cared to appoint the Hunter commission to inquire into the Jallianwalla Massacre which was of a much less magnitude on the other hand. Th
For us to understand this, we must move deep, very deep.
This was not a movement just started by Sikhs of their own will.
Yes, the Sikhs were treated poorly and were not given due respect.
As a result of vote-bank politics, the Sikhs were ill-treated and were not given the development that was required. But, how did it start?
This movement was instigated and instigated for various selfish reasons of Mrs. Indira Gandhi and Bhutto.
In Pakistan, there was a movement known as the Jinnahpur movement.
In India, there was a Kashmir issue and also of-course a lot of problems due to vote bank politics.
Indira Gandhi wanted to use the Sikhs to help herself get out of the vote-bank issues and hence decided to use the Sikhs for that.
Also, the jinnahpur movement in Pakistan would also come to an end with the help of Sikhs. Thus instigating the Sikhs for Khalistan.
The jinnahpur movement was a headache for Pakistan and the Kashmir issue and vote-bank politics was a issue for Mrs. Indira Gandhi.
Since Sikhs were there in both countries, it was most ideal for both to use them.
Of course, Khalistan would never have been formed as the government only wanted to use the Sikhs.
Of course, such truth never is out in the open but this a part of the truth.
These Sikhs then fell into the trap and weapons were supplied to them by Mrs. Indira Gandhi herself. She started helping them for her own selfish cause.
And, then the Sikhs realized that they were in a trap and used their power against Indira Gandhi, they started biting the hands that fed them.
I can in no way blame the Sikhs as they were ill-treated. It was not entirely their fault. The Sikhs have always served the country and to treat them in such a manner is a national shame. The government should know how to deal with their people and how to treat them. This system needs to change. It is a sad thing that the Sikhs have been driven out of their own motherland.
We must take all steps to bring them and resolve issues in peace.
Very well explained sir. I had no knowledge why Sikh riots and Indira Gandhi assassination happened. You taught it so well. Thank you so much
He is giving you misleading information
He is a Rajasthani and he doesn't want to disclose that they are the root cause of Punjab problem
No one had demanded a separate country
He is not telling that they are looting Punjab's water and the farmers in Punjab are committing suicides
Bhindranwale had only demanded Chandigarh and refused to share Punjab's water with non riparian states
Very well narrated. Great job.
Pls don't misguide. Bhindranwale is Saint. He fought against terrorist India.
believe me or not my heart was pounding and my body was shivering mentally
Best informative video about khalistan movement and. Operation blue Star and recent updates. 👍
such an elaborative and concise explanation. thanks a lot for such knowledgeable videos. thank you sir
This was such a clearly explained video! 👌 very informative.. It's always important to know our history.. 👍
He has given you misleading information
Correction* Khalistan is a Sikh separatist movement in India ONLY.I googled that!
Btw ur videos are quite informative👍
It was in US Canada and Uk . There are proofs check out Dr, Swamy s videos
In pakistan also
15307 Indian Army soldiers killed in operation Bluestar by only 150-250 singhs... Written by general kuldeep Brar who led army in operation Bluestar
In his second book.....
best channel study iq,
English Translation given below.
ਸਤਿਕਾਰਯੋਗ ਰਾਠੌੜ ਸਾਹਿਬ, ਤੁਸੀਂ ਬਹੁਤ ਹੀ ਵਧੀਆ ਵੀਡੀਓ ਬਣਾਈ ਹੈ ਅਤੇ ਇੱਕ ਪਾਸੇ ਦਾ ਸੱਚ ਬਿਆਨ ਵੀ ਕੀਤਾ ਹੈ ਜੋ ਕਿ ਭਾਰਤੀ ਮੀਡੀਆ ਨੇ ਦਿਖਾਇਆ ਅਤੇ ਸਰਕਾਰ ਨੇ ਪੇਸ਼ ਕੀਤਾ ਸੀ। ਪਰ ਦੂਜੇ ਪਾਸੇ ਦੀ ਸਚਾਈ ਕਦੇ ਵੀ ਸਾਹਮਣੇ ਨਹੀਂ ਆਉਣ ਦਿੱਤੀ। ਸੰਤ ਜਰਨੈਲ ਸਿੰਘ ਇੱਕ ਨਿਰੋਲ ਸੰਤ ਸਨ ਜਿਨ੍ਹਾਂ ਨੇ ਆਖਰੀ ਦਮ ਤੱਕ ਖਾਲਿਸਤਾਨ ਦੀ ਮੰਗ ਨਹੀਂ ਕੀਤੀ ਸਿਰਫ ਪੰਜਾਬ ਦੇ ਹੱਕ ਮੰਗੇ ਸਨ। ਉਹਨਾਂ ਨੇ ਕਦੇ ਵੀ ਕਿਸੇ ਉਪਰ ਆਪਣੀ ਤਰਫ ਤੋਂ ਪਹਿਲਾਂ ਹਮਲਾ ਨਹੀਂ ਕੀਤਾ ਹਮੇਸ਼ਾ ਜੁਆਬੀ ਕਾਰਵਾਈ ਹੀ ਕੀਤੀ। ਇਹ ਸਾਰਾ ਸਾਕਾ ਕਾਂਗਰਸ ਅਤੇ ਅਕਾਲੀ ਸਰਕਾਰ ਦੀ ਆਪਸੀ ਰਾਜਨੀਤਿਕ ਰੰਜਸ਼ ਦਾ ਨਤੀਜਾ ਸੀ ਅਤੇ ਜਿਸ ਦਾ ਖਾਮਿਆਜਾ ਸਿੱਖਾਂ ਅਤੇ ਪੰਜਾਬੀਆਂ ਨੂੰ ਭੁਗਤਣਾ ਪਿਆ।
Respected Rathor Ji, You have made a very good video and present the single side truth which was was presented by Indian media and Govt. of India. But the truth of the another side never come outside. Saint Jarnail Singh was a pure religious Saint who never demanded the Khalistan up to his last breath. He demanded just the right of the Punjab and Sikhs. He never attacked on anyone first from his own side he always reply the others actions This all operation was the result of the political games of the Congress as well as the Akalis and for all these things re-payed by the Punjabis and Sikhs.
Thanks and Regards,
Pavitar Singh
eproc sangrur sachi gaal aa veere.....
Thanks Bro
eproc sangrur dil vala dukhda aa govt dia khania sun ke ......
eproc sangrur veer ki smjhnge lok sarkar ne jhoothi gall kutt kutt andr bharr diti...Sant Jarnail Singh was never wrong...we Respect him like God
Don't worry now we have social media. We can bring the truth in front the people. So work for the ethical purposes of the media.. You will be success in your missions..
NSG has established soon after Golden Temple operation in 1984. 👍 😀
Human Rights Defense and 20000 indian army were killed their by 400 sikhs
@@gregmajidi3655 😂😂 lol only 83 were martyered on the spot and later some of them were martyered by goons
@@subhasishbhowmick8912 yea that's what your media tells you. Keep on listening them. You are paper tigers
@@gregmajidi3655 20000 lol say 20 million. Negative IQ lol.
Great explanation Sir, Please make a video on Naxalism in India- Origin, Reason, their demands, steps taken by govt. etc.
He has given you misleading information. No one had demanded a separate nation
Thnku sir for the lucid explanation.. 🙏
These politicians supports the Khalistan merely for vote.. Shame 😨😰😔
SIR PIZ MAKE VIDEO ON INDUSTREIAL REVOLUTIION
Great Research Sir...
Issue dealt very comprehensively & Excellently explained... Just more empasis on its imapct/analysis need... Thanks for giving holistic understanding..
😅😄😃Who has told you that the information which he has given is correct
You can watch Subramaniam Swammy's interview
if possible make few videos on Naxal movement & left-wing extremism
Loved it sir. Simply wonderful elatiobation.
Mai v sikh han bt khalistan banan de khilaf han, Te mera sare sikha nu ik msg, socho j khalistan bnya ta patna sahib, bangla sahib, nanded sahib, hemkund sahib, alag desh ch chle jaane , ajj desh de hr kone te sikh rehnde, uhna di v socho, ajj sikha di poore desh ch respect aa, kisi guru ne ni keha v inj alag hoke rho, sanu alag sooba punjab milya hoya oh kafi aa..
Inder Dullat true bro .....Indira paid price but still no justice for killing
Chalo Kisi main tho akal mujhe tho laga tha Sare akal se paidal hai
@@G.O.A.T-a1 yeh dimag se paidal he corona me lakho logo ko khana khilaare guruduware bnd hokr be lngar nhi roka or tere jaise aake bss bdi bdi baate krte hai.
ek cmnt likha terko usme bhar bhar ke gaaliya thi but voh cmnt htt gya due to youtube policy
@@G.O.A.T-a1 agar tu samne hota toh btata terko dimag se paidal kya kr skte hai tu ghar nhi bete seedha hospital jata fir shayad shamshaan🤣🤣🤣
Perfect explanation of a very sensitive topic and one more request if you could cover up the north eastern unrest especially the Bodoland issue !
He has given you misleading information
sir plz make the lecture on difference between
republic and federation of countries
*Grampanchayat, Mp election, Cm election ke baare me video banayiye*
Election k liye kaise khade rahe, Kya requirements hai
ye sab
मे दावे के साथ कहता हू Channel का Growth भी होगा और Public को knowledge भी आयेगा
A friend told me. If you want to fight, be prepare to receive punches. I afraid to do harm because the consequence is very severe. Thanks. Now I understand how this is all started.
Sir please make a video on LPG reforms (1990) :)
Nice video sir......
Hindu love Sikhs.....but humanity is above over religion......India is above over religion.......and army did same things........bcoz indian army has no religion.......they live for India,die for India. And sorry sardar ji,for 1984 riot.
just sorry......why didn't u ask supreme cournt to hang the leaders...who did sikh genocide.........sorry to say....if someone raped ur sisters and mothers and then say sorry...how would u feel.......if our time come we will show u how the justice have been done.....the victims of 84 genocide are still in courts...bloody system
vikash kumar Well I dnt think Khalistan is a solution .....think fellow Sikhs .......we will be a small country ........west pakistan punjab will still be in pak ....so no use of khalistan 1984 .....bitch indira paid price .........she killed thousand Sikhs now she is in hell .
@@sukhpreetsingh-tk9nn BRO WHEN THERE IS A RIOT, BOTH COMMUNITIES SUFFER. I KNOW MANY HINDU FAMILIES IN PUNJAB WHO WERE KILLED.
IT WAS UNFORTUNATE ACCEPT IT. KASMIRI PUNDITS WERE ALSO KILLED, TOH WOH SEPERATE COUNTRY KI DEMAND KAREN?
vikash kumar you don’t have to feel sorry u haven’t done anything in this
the Gandhi family
indra gandhi done operation blur star
sikhs sent her into the hell
@@sukhpreetsingh-tk9nn verra je es bande de gal sachi hundi phir GURU GOBIND SINGH JI khade SIKH dharam na banude DHARAM de layi raaj hunda e naki raaj layi dharam
Explain very well thanks
“History is written by the victor” this quote is very important, especially in this presentation. All the information this man gave was based on the history written by the Indian government. All the history given was bias because it was written by Indian government. If you actually look at the history from both sides. You could tell that jarnail Singh was a saint and a martyr, not a terrorist. But because the victors (India) wrote the history. Of course they were not going to write anything bad about themselves. So this presentation is very bias.
BRO IT WAS NOT JUST INDIA, BUT ALSO PUNJAB WHO WON AGAINST THOSE TERRORISTS
@@pranavpratik1062
For your concern
They are not terrorist , come in punjab and ask to people who met them.
Pranav Pratik and you are indian so you would recite whatever told to you by india
Same sentiments as kshmiri separatists saying burhan wani was their bhagath singh.
No proof
Dr mahipal singh rathore please ask me.Where you from read or got this facts.Is it any reasonable source or buy any book from market.Please read book of genral kuldeep brar book operation blue star. You get very good knowledge and 80%correct.Near to reality .
Your Lecture is superb Sir! Thank you so much!
sir plz video k sath PDF b provide kijie revision krna difficult hota h
Shukriya sir,hamare doubt clear karne ke liye
Very very nicely explained
Thank you so much sir.....
You are such an amazing teacher...
Love you sir....
So knowledge about history of punjab
Thank you❤️
A great great video to learn...
What is cost of pendrive course for upsc?
Great insight about the topic..nicely explained thanks
please make a video on axom andulan....
Tons of thanks sir
You brought it so systematically
Great video. Very helpful.
The moral is Army people goes flooded ...Irrespective of religion ,language ..
Very good and informative.
Hi Indians , it's sad that we are dividing in the name of religion . Our country is a diversed cultural country that is the soul of our country 'Unity in diversity' , we should not go for exclusive nationalism ..... We want inclusive nationalism ... We except all.... no need of hindu country or muslim or Sikh . Our country should except all culture and race
We have nearly 150 languages so how we could go for a single national language? All languages are National . But for the sake of easynes we could give majority language for official purpose.
India should have inclusive nationalism .
sukhrajcse people should decide will not give bribe ...Then government will change ... And government is the people only ....We should understand they are at our service not our boss.....The new generation will change for sure....
@sukhrajcse what was khalsa raj we have seen.
No one had demanded a separate nation. He is giving you misleading information
industrial revolution piz make video
rathore sahib purre information le kar video bnya kro
dearest sir,
make a video on 1991 liberalisation of trade
You are amazing sir, thanks you for the perfect history information.
How do you know what ever he said is correct or propaganda?
very insightful
Sir last me jate jate video ki summary bana diya karo {notice} jo ki revision me helpful ho exam purpose ke liye
Thanks
very useful.. tq
u r just amazing...
very useful vedio sir thankyou😊
Thanks for the video. Sir plz try making one on CUBAN MISSILE CRISIS...
He has given you misleading information 😅😄😃
bhai kitne rupe me bike tum, sarkaar k liye ye bhi bata do
It's best video.
Thanks sir
Wow..nicely explainef
controversial, but is it true that Indira Gandhi took the help of British SAS army to this crackdown ???
Excellent session sir.
Still this Khalistan moment is not settled yet ......
1984 After Operation Blue Star , NSG was constituted
21:30 kide nirankare ta DHARAM cho kade hoye a
If there was a Sikh country, no one would have attacked Gurdwaras and killed Sikhs. If there was a Sikh country, the situation would have been different and Punjab wouldn't be stuck between the nuclear war of India and Pakistan. If there is a war, the whole of Punjab will be destroyed. How does their community service help solving the real problems of Sikhs? The Indian government is spending billions of rupees to bring Sikhism into the fold of Hinduism. How does their community service help Sikhs to stop Indian government, RSS and Noormahals from attacking their Sikh brothers in Punjab and India? How?
Sikhs are fighting to keep their distinction and appearance, to save their religion and to keep Sikhi alive. If that means a separate country then why not? It doesn't mean we want to divide the world but shouldn't we think about securing Sikh faith first and all the virtues it stands for? If the Indian government doesn't like us and doesn't want to live with Sikhs, then why shouldn't we just be separated? When we gain power we can promote Sikhi and teach the message of the Gurus and universal brotherhood. Can this not be done? Khalistan is not for bad purpose. When I ask any non-Punjabi Sikh about Khalistan, the vast majority have the same answer that they don't want to be separated or wouldn't want to move to Khalistan. But who says you have to move. Sikhs will still live in other countries. But most of Sikhnet people reply in exactly the same words. Sounds like they need to learn the true purpose of fighting. Perhaps they are sticking with community service a whole lot but what if those people we want to help turn against us, should we not fight to defend ourselves? If yes, then that's exactly what Sikhs are doing. If no, then that is not Sikhi.
Now some general questions from Punjabi people. These are the people who are not Amritdhari. They don't practice Sikhism at all. They eat meat, drink alcohol, smoke and do everything that is prohibited by Gurus and yet they call themselves Sikhs. Before I go into their questions, I want to say that only an Amritdhari person is a Sikh. One who follows Guru's teaching is a Sikh and Khalistan is for Sikhs. Everyone will have religious freedom but people who commit adultery, smoke, drink alcohol etc. will not be allowed to live there because not only Sikhism but also all religions prohibit these things.
How would Khalistan survive economically?
Well, how did India and Pakistan survive after independence? UAE gained its independence in 1971 and it is surviving. Same way Khalistan will survive but it will not be a third world country because Sikhs are very hard working people. Punjab is a cultivated land and it provides most of the food for India. Punjab produces corn, wheat, sugarcanes, sporting goods, clothing, industrial material and many other commodities. Khalistani government will keep this stuff as much as it needs and the rest will be shipped out to other countries as a trade and in return oil and other necessities will be bought. No one in Khalistan will die out of hunger because if Punjab can provide food for 90% of the Indian population then it surely can provide food for everyone in Khalistan because the population in Khalistan will be a lot less than Indian population.
Who will be the leader of Khalistan?
Panj Pyare will be the leaders of Khalistan. Elections will be held every four years and people will choose Panj Pyare. These Panj Pyare will rule under the authority of Akaal Takhat Sahib. Every city will have Panj Pyare as its leader. There will be no bad leaders in Khalistan because when Khalsa Panth starts doing Naam Simran in the morning, it will gain spiritual power which no one will be able to destroy. Foundation of Khalistan will be laid upon the power of Naam Simran. Guru Gobind Singh Ji said "When Khalsa starts following the true path of the Guru Granth Sahib and abandons all the bad things, I will give them sovereignty." So when the time for Khalistan comes, every Sikh will be a true Sikh and there will be no bad people in Sikhism. Guru Ji said "Raaj Karega Khalsa Aakki Rahe Na Koe" which means Khalsa shall rule and there will be no one against Khalsa. Khalsa Raj (Khalistan) shall come for sure. Khalistan will be a true Khalsa Raj.
What about sea ports?
There are 42 landlocked countries in the world that are surviving. To say or think that just because of lack of seaport Khalistan will not survive is irrational. There are many third world countries that have sea ports such as Sri Lanka, and Brazil. Landlocked countries are helped by their neighboring countries that have seaports. In return these countries get money and/or something else in exchange. There are numerous possibilities in business. We can use Pakistan’s and/or India’s seaports. I don’t think there is any country that does not want to do business and make profit. How exactly would this work depends on the future, circumstances and situations. Oil can also be imported through India or Pakistan. United Nations is working on passing a treaty that would help landlocked countries get access to seaports. We can survive without a seaport.
What would happen if there is war between Pakistan and India?
Khalistan will be a neutral country and will be a buffer state between the two countries. With Khalistan as a buffer state both countries will feel safe from each other. Neither Pakistan nor India would dare to step on Khalistan's boundaries. India has fought two wars with Pakistan and every time Pakistan was defeated because only Sikhs fought on the boundaries of Punjab. Sikhs are a martial race. British recognized that soon after Punjab was annexed. Guru Gobind Singh Ji made Sikhs saint-warriors. Sikhs in Khalistan will be true saints and warriors. They will have power of Naam Simran because they will free Khalistan on the power of Naam Simran and one who has this power is never afraid of anyone other than God. By doing Nam Simran one never fears death. We have numerous example from the 18th century. Sikh country will be very powerful and Pakistan would not try to mess with it. Hindus can't fight, so there is no question that Indian government will ever dream of attacking Khalistan. If there is war between India and Pakistan, they will have to fight it outside of Sikh territory.
What about control over Gurdwaras outside of Khalistan?
Well, all the Gurdwaras will be directly controlled by the Khalistani government run under Akaal Takhat Sahib. Currently, Indian government is not doing anything about the Gurdwaras in Pakistan, Afghanistan and other countries because the Indian government doesn't want Sikhs to be attached with their Gurdwaras. Indian government thinks the only way to destroy Sikhism is to keep Sikhs away from Guru Granth Sahib's message and the Gurdwaras. Gurdwaras outside of India are still standing without the support of Indian government but when there is Khalistan, the government will do its best to take care of these holy places and agreements will be made with the other countries that would give us the direct control over the Gurdwaras. We can negotiate with Pakistani government and have control over our Gurdwaras and they can have control over their mosques. We will negotiate with Pakistani government to give us the control over Sikh Gurdwaras. Committees will be established to manage these Gurdwaras. Monthly reports will be submitted to the officials (not necessarily to the federal government). The money of the Gurdwaras will be spent in managing the Gurdwaras, Sikh schools, parchaar, helping the poor and needy.
There is no constitution?
Yes there is but people just never search for it. Khalistan will be totally based on the principles of Sikhi. Gurbani is the constitution. There is not and can never be a better constitution than Gurbani. Guru Ji wrote this constitution more than 400 years ago. But look at the reality. Constitution of the USA was written ten years after thirteen colonies gained independence. Constitution of India was written three years after it gained independence. If these countries can write their constitution after independence then why can't we? No country is perfect. Every country has loopholes in its laws and policies so expecting flawless plans and policies from Khalistanis is not realistic. Laws can be changed. India has amended its constitution many times. So, do not expect a perfect constitution and policies from Khalistan.
What u have written painstakingly was also propagated by Jinnah in the name of Islam. See the results with your own eyes.
See the doomsday of pakistan, cause it was created on the basis of a lie that a single religious country would be a paradise.
Despite having warrior muslims, following righteous pathway of islam, low population, hardworking, acces to seaport, having tje most fertile lamd of east punjab it is a failed state.
Due to the secessionist propaganda of jinnah millions were killed, displaced from their birthplace forcefully. The country was made by shedding of blood of millions, still it is propagating the same in kashmir. How could even allah spare such a country?
Nice video...Thank U
Bhindrawale never interfared with politics you can see it in his speeches, don't spread misleading information
Very well explained
How do you know that he has given you the right information?
He is a Rajasthani and he doesn't want to disclose that they are the root cause of Punjab problem
He is giving you misleading information no one had demanded Khalistan
@@rationalthinker6825 I'm unable to understand your point perfectly... Pls suggest me something so I can get knowledge from a different perspective
@0.19 Sikh genocide not anti-Sikh riots
@23:59 Lala Jagat Narain also wrote rubbish about the Sikh Gurus.
Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale was a Sikh nationalist.
You should have also mentioned something about the Punjab independence referendum 2020.
We 'the Sikhs and Punjabis' won't stop, until we get back our lost country or something equivalent in south Asia. We are not Indians, nor Pakistanis, we are Punjabis.
I must say it is a very bold statement.
Nuclear bomb ka naam suna hai? Judi pe fod denge tumhari 😂😂
@@sarthakmonga9107 NIHANGA da nasm suneya
Read the book by Army person kuldeep singh brar
B.D Pandey was the Governor of Punjab during Operation Blue Star. He has exposed every thing in his book. 👋
It is available on Amazon.
Excellent Video. Enjoyed it!
You have enjoyed this video but he has given you misleading information. He is a Rajasthani and he doesn't tell you that they are the root cause of Punjab problem
Instead of telling you the actual problem he gave you misleading information. No one had demanded Khalistan
v v nice video....
earlier information that was spread in our country n as u told facts r so different.....facts spread r political....bt will go with education n exam point of view....
How do you know that he has given you the right information?
He is a Rajasthani and he doesn't want to disclose that they are the root cause of Punjab problem.
He doesn't tell you that the root cause is loot of Punjab waters
Industrial revolution piz make video
don't this channel have 2 videos on this topic and i guess the content is also same
guru hrgobind singh ji take the guns weapons in akal thakt withe their weapons
nice video sir....thanks a lot for making us understand things easily
He is doing malicious propaganda
thanks ..good job bro
nyc video sirji
great sir
Good explanation
Thank you so much for your effort
Love you Sabrina
@@ibrahimmd414 mulla
He has given you misleading information
watch this is right info
Also watch movie Article 15 , you will know the issues
Aisaa nhi bataya ki bhimdrawale ke samarthko ne Hindu bhu betio ki b ijjat bachai ... Aur jo balatkar hote the Punjab me uske wo sakhat khilaaf tha .. khalistan ki maang kbhi b nhi hui ... 5 June ka din isliye choose kiya k jayada se jayada sikho ko khatam kiya jaye means genocide ... Harmandir sahib me akele attack nhi kiya balki 37 aur gurdwaras me bhi attack hua ... Sikh library se truck bhar k religious books Delhi lejiyaaa giya
And Congress party was behind all of this
I understand paji per isme politics thi hindu nahi the na. Gurudware pe attack nahi hona chahiye tha iska hame dukh hai .
Well xplained!
Type and read on YOU TUBE , "Was Bhindranwale getting Hindus killed?"
Nice video sir.......u keep do this by sharing the knowledge to the hungry educators..........
He has given you misleading information
National security Council formed in 1999
Please do more research before uploading. Wrong information about Guru Granth Sahib Ji right in the beginning and why Guru Arjan Dev Ji were executed. Didn't watch further as couldn't take any more.....
Well explained 👍👍