I am thoroughly impressed with your knowledge of ROK. I’m pretty sure what you have forgotten is more than I’ll ever know in ROK. If you could add more videos on different commander pairings and advise the ratios of All Dam to Health to Def to Attack…I would watch them all! Thank you!
I ended up with 6% all damage on my nev Joan. Hits like a truck and helps with people targeting that march because of the counter att from all damage. Break downs like this are huge Gg on the video answered alot of questions I had
Very detailistic guide. Just to make sure, I suppose in your calculator you take also into account the regular stats that you can see in your city hall, like out of SoC, like the ones coming from altars and alliance tech? Cause there also Attack is much higher so overall that is why health is considered better except for unusually high health marches? I edited my comment just to highlight the level of acknowledge you show, that puts you with all due respect ahead of any other content creator, again and again. Congratulations and many thanks 👍
Great video. Have you tried comparing ring vs horn effectiveness at different battle durations in the combat simulator? I would be interested to see the results.
I haven't tried comparing them directly. They are pretty tricky because it really depends on which commander you are talking about because every active skill is different. And, of course, with AoE commanders it varies as well.
I like the analysis. Not just on all dmg vs other stats, but the relative value of stats on different meta builds. Could you do a similar analysis on mitigations? I know it’s situational (i.e., counterattack reduction is sometimes nearly useless and sometimes mitigating everything coming in and commander dependent). But, on average, all damage reduction vs. skill damage reduction vs counterattack reduction vs normal attack dmg reduction vs stats like health and defense. Heck, vs the benefits of X seconds of silence!
Some of these are quite a bit more complicated than others, and require simulations (which are much harder to do) rather than calculators like the one I have. Calculators have to approximate and use weighted averages. But in general, mitigations have the same impact as buffs. So, all damage reduction is the same "effectiveness" value as all damage increase. If that makes any sense.
Brother i know this old video but please help me Which better full st cav set vip 16 Or 2 st cav set vip 17 I know you need more information or screenshots but please give me answer 🙏
Would all damage be worth more or a less compared to attack with weaker marches? All my equip is epic im in kvk 2, trying to figure out how much all damage is worth vs attack and wether it scales better with strong marches or weaker
How to compare skill dmg, normal attack dmg, counter attack dmg to all damage? Can we say like all dmg = skill + normal dmg… but how these 2 split considering the best 3 marches?
Skill damage is a bit trickier as it depends on the march's base skill damage factor and, of course, how frequently it fires it's skills (it gets especially tricky with Joan who fires more frequently). But normal damage and counter-attack are pretty straightforward to calculate. But yes, all damage includes attack, counter-attack, and skill damage.
Can you be more specific about where this is coming from? Do you mean the RCF? You are right, it doesn't include any Holy Site's from the LK. I can add the RCF pretty easily.
@@moutan100 I can't be 100% confident until I go back through the calculations myself, but because all damage is calculated at the end, my intuition is that this won't affect the ratio at all. That is, all damage -- to my recollection -- should not have the diminishing returns we see with other stats because it is an end of formula multiplier.
Really really soild video to help understand the mechanics. I’ve got 3.7 all damage on a armament set and this helps a tone. Maybe you should or could follow this up with a video on suggested stats for common marches. This will also have a factor on what gear to work on. Lastly. That calculator is amazing. Reminds me a tad of wicks but much more detail. Is it available to download anywhere? Great work
Thanks so much! I tried to pick 3 of the favorite marches people use today, but it will always be a bit different given different gear, VIP, tech levels, etc. I wish I could find a way to make the calculator available in something like Google Sheets, but a lot of it is built on sheets in the background and on formulas / components that Google Sheets doesn't have as an option.
Unfortunately, it is not easy to convert to a Google Sheet where I can share it readily. There are lots of formulas on lots of sheets running in the background and some of the functions only seem to work in Excel, not in Google Sheets.
![How many marches should you run? [Guide] Rise of Kingdoms](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yHfT_rXcg90/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you for all your hard work, the RoK community appreciates you!
The only video in all internet talk about the all damage great video you deserve a like
This is amazing. Really knowledgeable and helpful! You are the Prof. of ROK 😊
I am thoroughly impressed with your knowledge of ROK. I’m pretty sure what you have forgotten is more than I’ll ever know in ROK. If you could add more videos on different commander pairings and advise the ratios of All Dam to Health to Def to Attack…I would watch them all! Thank you!
Thank you sir! I’ve been struggle choosing which armament that I should use between stat and all dame
awesome summary, thanks :)
Great as always! Really great content😘
I ended up with 6% all damage on my nev Joan. Hits like a truck and helps with people targeting that march because of the counter att from all damage. Break downs like this are huge
Gg on the video answered alot of questions I had
Amazing videos, thanks
Very detailistic guide. Just to make sure, I suppose in your calculator you take also into account the regular stats that you can see in your city hall, like out of SoC, like the ones coming from altars and alliance tech? Cause there also Attack is much higher so overall that is why health is considered better except for unusually high health marches?
I edited my comment just to highlight the level of acknowledge you show, that puts you with all due respect ahead of any other content creator, again and again. Congratulations and many thanks 👍
Thanks David. Yes, I assume max individual tech, max allianc tech, and max Kingdom holy sites. It does not include tech from lost Kingdom holy sites.
Great video. Have you tried comparing ring vs horn effectiveness at different battle durations in the combat simulator? I would be interested to see the results.
I haven't tried comparing them directly. They are pretty tricky because it really depends on which commander you are talking about because every active skill is different. And, of course, with AoE commanders it varies as well.
Great video
I like the analysis. Not just on all dmg vs other stats, but the relative value of stats on different meta builds.
Could you do a similar analysis on mitigations? I know it’s situational (i.e., counterattack reduction is sometimes nearly useless and sometimes mitigating everything coming in and commander dependent). But, on average, all damage reduction vs. skill damage reduction vs counterattack reduction vs normal attack dmg reduction vs stats like health and defense. Heck, vs the benefits of X seconds of silence!
Some of these are quite a bit more complicated than others, and require simulations (which are much harder to do) rather than calculators like the one I have. Calculators have to approximate and use weighted averages. But in general, mitigations have the same impact as buffs. So, all damage reduction is the same "effectiveness" value as all damage increase. If that makes any sense.
Brother i know this old video but please help me
Which better
full st cav set vip 16
Or 2 st cav set vip 17
I know you need more information or screenshots but please give me answer 🙏
Amazing work and a great video, keep that up!
Is that sheet public available? Any chance to get access to the it?
Unfortunately some of the functions don't convert to Google sheets so I haven't had success in creating a public version.
@@PsychOutROK What about the excel sheet? Any chance to get the hands on it?
@@Sinneth To be honest, I've put a lot of work into that sheet, so just sharing it outright feels a little like giving my work away for free.
@@PsychOutROK Totally understandable, great work!
Would all damage be worth more or a less compared to attack with weaker marches? All my equip is epic im in kvk 2, trying to figure out how much all damage is worth vs attack and wether it scales better with strong marches or weaker
How to compare skill dmg, normal attack dmg, counter attack dmg to all damage? Can we say like all dmg = skill + normal dmg… but how these 2 split considering the best 3 marches?
Skill damage is a bit trickier as it depends on the march's base skill damage factor and, of course, how frequently it fires it's skills (it gets especially tricky with Joan who fires more frequently). But normal damage and counter-attack are pretty straightforward to calculate.
But yes, all damage includes attack, counter-attack, and skill damage.
Can you please answer about 5% nuke value to attack🙏 how 5%nuke=attack? Or 10 attack=how nuke?🙏🙏🙏 Thank you
Sure. I can do some work on that.
Did you quit the game? I miss your content
Hi..... Could you share excel?
you have forget the 40% damage increase in Soc Kvk
Can you be more specific about where this is coming from? Do you mean the RCF? You are right, it doesn't include any Holy Site's from the LK. I can add the RCF pretty easily.
@@PsychOutROK when we rebuild the fortress with donating heads. We get 40%damage buff after the first stage. If i remember it right. Past glory
@@PsychOutROK i made a matlab code to calculate rok stats as you. With 40% damage from kvk buff it will make damage:health ratio 3:2.
@@moutan100 Yes, I did not include the RCF buff. I can add it later today. I think it is 40%, but I don't remember exactly (not in KVK right now).
@@moutan100 I can't be 100% confident until I go back through the calculations myself, but because all damage is calculated at the end, my intuition is that this won't affect the ratio at all. That is, all damage -- to my recollection -- should not have the diminishing returns we see with other stats because it is an end of formula multiplier.
Really really soild video to help understand the mechanics. I’ve got 3.7 all damage on a armament set and this helps a tone.
Maybe you should or could follow this up with a video on suggested stats for common marches. This will also have a factor on what gear to work on.
Lastly. That calculator is amazing. Reminds me a tad of wicks but much more detail. Is it available to download anywhere?
Great work
Thanks so much! I tried to pick 3 of the favorite marches people use today, but it will always be a bit different given different gear, VIP, tech levels, etc.
I wish I could find a way to make the calculator available in something like Google Sheets, but a lot of it is built on sheets in the background and on formulas / components that Google Sheets doesn't have as an option.
@@PsychOutROK no worries. You may have unearthed a little video series here lol.
Great channel bud
Link for Battle Calculator?
Unfortunately, it is not easy to convert to a Google Sheet where I can share it readily. There are lots of formulas on lots of sheets running in the background and some of the functions only seem to work in Excel, not in Google Sheets.
Is there a way to share the excel?
You want calculated all that?🤦😭
Yeah, I built that sheet. It took a long time.
André Linoge MYM1395 ✌️