Cesar Millan Explains: Do Dogs Get Jealous?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ก.ย. 2024
- Cesar Millan addresses dog jealousy within the Pack. Find more information, advice, and tips on www.cesarsway.com.
SUBSCRIBE: / cesarmillan
Like on Facebook: / cesar.millan
Follow on Twitter: / cesarmillan
This guy a certified GENIUS man.... love him!!
I don't agree.
he is wrong on this. he is also not certified genius. i would wager he would not score above 140 on an iq test
why...he is one great guy... certified genius,... i agree
Tim Lazenby i agree Tim
Yeah, fuck you Lynda!
cesar really exposed how unaware and ignorant the average dog owners are
You mean like the millions of people who watch Cesar even though he is dead wrong about dog behavior and dogs being "pack animals"?
Cesar Millan put dog training back half a century by spouting the nonsensical bullshit he made up without any sort of evidence. iMonikah is correct in saying that Millan is dead wrong about dog behavior. Cesar's entire dog training philosophy of the 'Dominance/Ownership' theory is patently incorrect and absurd...
He incites cult-like following and his followers responds with logical fallacies when presented with counter-argument as you just did, saying how you have a friend who's a dog training as if that's an argument. There are many sources that expose Cesar and his ignorance on the internet. Do your research before you dominate and own your dog like this moron.
+realhumanbean and what argument did you make that is not a logical fallacy? monica certainly didn't make a counter argument, and bringing up an anecdote to illustrate a point, that is an example, not a logical fallacy. you dont even know what a logical fallacybis, you just heard that word and thought to yourself, "i can sound meself some smaartdts if i just say them word." now make an actual syllogism.
***** "What is your argument against dogs being pack animals? "
Try every single research paper about dogs in the past 10 years. Just google it? Seriously, I already gave you links. Stop being so fucking lazy. It's a FACT that dogs are not pack animals now. It doesn't matter that they are descended from wolves, they have COMPLETELY different behaviors.
If you want to debate that Cesar's methods work, then I think you're wrong but at least there's something to debate there. If you want to debate that dogs are pack animals, you''re just embarrassing yourself because pack theory has been disproved for yeaaaars now.
iMonikah have you read every single research paper about dogs in the past 10 years? i know i have read at least several that mentions nothing about dogs not being pack animals. others mention that they are, in fact dogs form packs when abandoned or running loose, a tendency that causes problems in rural areas and suburban areas with abandoned dogs.
So dogs aren't jealous, they're possessive. Understanding the difference helps better understand the dogs behavior
***** I just finally got it...nearly had an incident this morning between my staffy/mastiff and beagle. Mastiff keeps trying to sit on my lap and then pushes the others away using his head and hits them with his paw...now that I understand it I can correct it before anything serious happens.
David Ruiz thanks for repeating what Ceaser said sherlock
He never said possessive. That is false. They only like to maintain spaces, and have no problem doing that with other animals.
They claim objects, people and places.
@@diamondhead5432101 my dog hates anything that has my attention; food, phone, people, animals...
They're not jealous.. Their territorial!
+Danny Medina same with me
They're*
So is my wife
lol explain it adrian
That's exactly what it sounded like to me, territorial.
Those who say Cesar is wrong, we do not speak the language of dogs. We can't understand all of what they say. However, by far, I have never seen the evidence from you people who say Cesar is wrong, but I've seen plenty of Cesar's way that works.
Because they see the dogs more as human than dogs. They put human emotions into the dog, when dogs are more instinct that emotion.
I love Cesar 🥰💚
Last year I met someone who straight up hated Cesar.
I broke off all contact with him. Not on purpose, I just had zero desire to spend time with him.
I believe in energy and influencing with attitude and body language.
@White CIS Cum No, you're just one of those people who goes too far in the other direction and thinks that non-human animals don't have emotions at all.
Which would also mean that they don't have instincts. The difference between human emotions and instincts is the degree to which our more complex minds and modes of thinking enter into it and shape what we're feeling.
I believe this is because too many people think of their dogs as "fur babies" and seek to humanize them instead of looking at them as animals that chose to live among us eons ago.
They claim space the way they claim food. It makes perfect sense. Awesome perspective.
It's not a perspective..
It's a fact that's how dog mind works!
Meanwhile the chihuahua is just sitting there like “I own all there of you, welcome to my space” lol
That’s exactly What I was thinking! 🤣
3 or there
Facts!!!!
@@EgoJinpachi_ sorry three lol
It's funny that Cesar clearly explains why dogs don't get "jealous", and yet people still insist that they do. Cesar is a very smart man. Maybe he just goes over the heads of some people, or they're just programmed to be contrarians. They accuse him over and over of things he clearly doesn't do and has explained in umpteen different ways. So I think any "jealousy" in the argument is coming from humans.
Elizabeth M Maybe his explanation was actually very brief and doesn't explain a lot of different situations where dogs appear to be jealous. Maybe you're just blindly agreeing with whatever he says.
@@jiveturkey2347 i don that petson is blindly following but i do think cesars explanation was too brief. U were right about that part
Seemed like Cesar was explaining one specific scenario where dogs try to keep other dogs away from a person giving them attention. That's not exactly him saying dogs can never get jealous. But hey, if you want to have youtube video titles do the thinking for you, just continue doing what you're doing.
People think dogs are jealous because they see them as humans and they don't understand them.
Elizabeth M Well first of all people really want animals to be like us and feel the same thing.
A lot of things we do for example drugs like smoking weed, it is a natural behavior that animals also do (for example Dolphins get high by using a puffer fish) so it’s not a human thing like we want it to be but a natural thing.
And don’t forget that a lot of humans always thinks that what they know is the truth and that they are always right and never wrong.
I believe that Cesar knows a lot about dogs and i learned a lot from watching his tv shows.
For over a decade, I’ve used every technique that Cesar has given on a Frenchie and Chihuahua who are basically the same age. And have been 100% satisfied.
When you let go of your ego and are willing to seriously learn, to keep your dogs healthy and happy, it’s a no brainer.
Thank you so much Cesar. Much love!
I have watched countless videos with Cesar Millan and I believe he is the best dog trainer ever. And his dogs are the proof: they are stable, content, playful and obedient.
I've always been afraid of dogs but Cesar's relationship with daddy & junior is such an inspiration. I think I'll soon get a dog too =)
Mohsin Abbaas do it you will wished you had did it before...
You won't ever regret it, I promise!
Dogs are amazing. They bring so much happiness and lovewith them. The effort you put will be given back ten fold and then some. Good luck :)
Mohsin Abbaas So did ya get one?😆
No One I know dude, that's why I asked! He's had lots of time to make good on his comment and get one!😎
THE WORLD LOVES YOU CESAR MILLAN!!!! AND the animals feel your PURE HEART AND SPIRIT!!! You are the embassador and translater for ALL DOGS!!! THank you...sooo much....Much Love and Peace...
Those dogs are so beautiful
The little dog is clearly the MVP here.
I am in awe of Cesar, he is an incredible dog psychologist. 💙 love him.
We're from the Croatian. For two weeks we come Frenchie. We will try to raise only by Caesar's instructions. We read all his books and watched all season, "Dog Whisperer." My wife and I love Caesar. Cesar has something superhuman in itself.
When I brought a second dog into the home with the lab, I was concerned about the behaviour between them. But they get along beautifully. They walk together three times a day, they eat at the same time, they sleep near each other every night. The only time I've had issues was not long after I got her all of a sudden the lab was sat in a very tense position in the corner all the time and everytime anyone (dog or human) went near him he'd run off. Very strange, since he normally loves humans, and he had previously been fine with the cocker spaniel (they had been for walks together before we brought her into the home). Took him to the vet, turned out he had a wire embedded into his cheek just beneath his skin, so we couldn't see it. The cocker had kept trying to lick his face and he'd run away. As soon as he had the appropriate vet treatment he and the cocker were happily playing with each other and he was back to his normal confident self:)
That's a good tip, I've always wondered how to manage that and not have a fight
on my hands. You're a genius Cezar and I go by everything you say. God Bless you for the work you do!
Everything he says and does, i cant help but put thumbs up, every time.
This helped a lot
His understanding of animal nature is just amazing
Junior is the most stable dog I’ve ever seen in life!
Thank you very much! This short video answered exactly my question. I knew ;-) it was not the dogs it was my behaviour - as always. Thank you so much for bringing so much understanding and clarity into the dogowners world! Lots of greetings from Germany, Olivia
I swear he makes training dogs so easy. Love your work Ceas!!
You’re amazing sir! I love your strength and the way you can read dogs! I’m so impressed with your soul! You’re gods gift to animals, I believe you’re here on earth to teach animals and humans interactions with animals! You’re a blessing sir!
Most people in the comments don't understand what jealousy is, ironically they throw rocks to a man that gets work done. Thanks for inspiring me to be a good man Cesar.
I love the little chihuahua at his side! :)
Taco! 🌮
@@stuff1784 we love TACO! and tacos 🌮 too 🙂
he's clearly the head of the pack :-)
Oh my God. This is so bloody cool. Like he knows Dogs SOOOO well! I mean I've always loved Cesar but still this was really impressive to see how he's SO SURE about a dogs movements and thinking and reactions. Wow. Love you Cesar❤
This is at least somewhat a matter of what you mean by jealousy. My cousin asked me to house sit his two dogs. One was outgoing and friendly with new people, the other one went and hid and didn't want anything to do with me. I decided to simply ignore the shy one and played ball with the friendly one. Pretty soon the shy one's "jealousy" overcame her shyness and she came out and wanted to play too. Cesar may label that something else, but to me the best word was jealousy.
That seems like trust or insecurity more than jealousy. The dog was being left alone which is a learned behavior of coping, natural dogs are pack animals. What you call jealousy I would call instinct. The dog instinctually wanted to be a part of the temporary pack that you just formed with a member of it's current/former pack. The dog probably didn't want anything to do with you at the time, which is okay sort-of. Once the other pack member trusted you or accepted you as a pack leader the more submissive dog followed the more confident dog. You want to praise the shy dog once it joins the pack so it learns THAT is what you're looking for.
The best thing I learned from Cesar Millan is that a dog is a dog not a human, and while it's nice to paint those human feelings/emotions onto our dogs it can allow them to develop undesirable traits like whining and other out of control states.
*****
I would suggest that human jealousy is no less instinctual than those of other animals, even if we add layers of complexity.
I love you, Caesar!! You've helped change the world. Thank you for all that you do ♥
I love Junior! what a beautiful dog!
Cesar, what we need most of all is these kind of simple insights into what dogs are thinking, and how to apply it to things like digging the flowers, jumping up, getting out of the yard, which are common reasons people give up dogs they love.
The definition of jealousy is: Feeling resentment against someone because of that person's rivalry , success or advantage. Jealousy is a human thing , you people are confused . Do you think that a dog would be jealous of another dog if you feed one dog fresh meat and the other dry food ? The only thing the dog does is claiming or protecting like any other animal would do like birds, reptiles fishes, amphibians insects..ect, ect. if the dogs was jealous it wouldn't allowed the other dog close to Cesar at anytime. You know..? Like an ex girlfriend who stalks you after you told her to it was over and when she sees you with another girl calls you and tells you she is gonna kill your new girlfriend ? That is jealousy !
so you basicaly said everything cesar said? you're like a detective or something.
Darko Dragosavac Yes ,I am something ! and you ?
my chihuahua gets jealous when my mom pets my shoulder and starts saying "good boy" lol! I had a friend who's dogs would also get jealous if you came in contact with another human. dogs get jealous.. also it's not just humans and dogs... funny, there was an experiment where scientists gave one chimpanzee a cucumber for completing a task, and gave another a grape. The chimp who got the cucumber became jealous of the one who got the grape and threw the cucumber at the scientist who was feeding him..
Wow, that sounds like one possessive bitch.
I agree with OP. It depends on how you define Jealousy. One dog wants what the other doesn't have at the time. That describes jealousy to me.
People use the term jealous to mean possessive. For example, men who are possessive of their girlfriends are called jealous.
I love Cesar. He has so insight much to give society. I just had to clarify this as a language problem.
Energy is the best tool for animals communication "keep calm assertive" :D
Saludos.
These dogs vids by ceaser teaches me much more than how to treat dogs. He teaches me life skills. The art of self confidence . The art of our influnce. Our vibe affects those around us.
Compadre Cesar...sos un genio
I’m a dog lover and love watching Cesar videos. I learn a lot of stuff from him
I just want a framed picture of Cesar in my living room.
creepy.
BLESSINGS FOREVER TO CESAR AND OUR LOVING ANIMALS!YOU ARE HERO💖💖💖💖🐕🐕🐕🐕❤❤❤❤ CESAR AND YOU TEACHING US HELP SAVE HELPLESS ANIMALS LIVES!
The interesting thing of this matter is that probably we should define jealousy in a different way, because if being jealous means becoming possessive, then yes, we could say dogs are jealous and when humans are jealous is a sign of possessiveness, no more. Isn't it?
Good point.
That is interesting, but only really applies when, for example, a person is jealous of another because they spend more time with their mutual friend, in which case the first person is being possessive of the friend. But jealousy can also be applied to a person being jealous of another's achievements, in which case it has little to do with possessiveness..
Envy some times people also mistake Jealousy with Envy which is a close second to jealousy.
Envy is when someone has something success, a lover, a home a family, a dog, anything and they feel Envious that you have that nad they don't. how ever, that doens't always equate to something bad and Dogs Might have their version of "envy" which or what Humans like to call "jealousy"
My dog likes to go over to some people and jump in their lap and get pettings, while she looks back at her brother, and when he sees this, he jumps into that persons lap and pushes her off, and then just continuously jumps into their lat wanting attention too. he won't chase or push my dog off, but he will if there is a cat.
That could be called "jealousy" even though it really isn't. a lot of association with "jealousy" is also Negativity. jealousy can turn into resentment. dogs don't resent anything.
Dogs don't have that particular ....feeling i guess, Resentment is more human than dog.
people forget that Dogs,, aren't human. they can be family, but they are not human beings. and thus don't feel thigns like We do
So, do dogs "feel" or "get" jealous of other dogs or humans or other animals?
...
xGlassxAngelx My dog gets both jealous and resentful. If I love on another dog and ignore her attempts at stealing my affection away, she will literally cry and sulk and even turn her head and ignore me for a while. Once I was loving on the other dog and she jumped into my mom's lap and made a big display of talking and licking all over her, while occasionally looking back at me to see if I was paying attention. As much as I respect his other techniques and info, Ceasar, you or none of the other naysayers will ever be ever to convince me otherwise.
When it comes to dogs... This man is an absolute master
I'm planning on getting a German Shepherd. But I'm waiting for the right time. I feel like I know quite a lot, but not enough. There are also obsticles. Such as, when I get a puppy it will need a lot of my time, but by the time I will know enough to get a dog, I will have a job (I currently go to school, where I also have a "training dog" that is a German Shepherd). Anyways, my point is that I learn a lot from you. I'm currently reading your book about the puppies you brought home (it's in Swedish, and I'm not sure of the original title). I've always loved German Shepherds. They're wonderful dogs. We've had a family dog, but she was mostly my mother's, and my mother was the one who raised her. She, the dog, had some issues and I was never really into that breed (I've met others of that breed as well).
It just bugs me how a lot of people get dogs without really knowing much about them. They think that they will know everything necessary to raise their own dog, because "they know people with dogs" or they "had a dog in their family as a kid" or even worse, "dogs are cute. I want one, so let's get one".
A girl I was friends with very recently, wanted to get a dog too. She said she wanted a German Shepherd as well. I asked her out of curiosity: "Why a German Shepherd?" She gave me no good answer really, except "they're cool". That was fine I suppose, but then I started talking about how I'm not sure which breeders to trust, so I can get the most healthy dog as possible (I've also heard, read and learned in "dog practice class" that quite a lot of German Shepherds can suffer from hip dysplasia and such). What did she tell me, then? Something like this: "Nehh. Who cares? Just get a dog from any breeder. Really any dog can get sick. And just enjoy the time you get with it. Live in the now." So... that pretty much ended the conversation.
IDK. With any breeder I'd say make sure you can see the puppies and the parents beforehand. See what condition they've living in. Are they in a comfortable safe environment or are they cooped up in the shed with nothing but the concrete floor to stare at? Keep an eye on the breeders too, what are their attitudes towards the dogs? Are they indifferent or do they seem to genuinely care? If you have any reaosn to suspect the dogs might be in danger, report them to your authority in your country. In the UK the RSPCA and in the US the SPCA.
Also, make sure you get your puppies when they are the correct age, a breeder trying to give you dogs that are too young is a major red flag. Plus, bare in mind that the mother should be at age 1 or higher, if they are younger then that, that is also a red flag.
Also, be weary of hip scores, they are quite commonly faked and the process of getting the hip score requires the breaking of the hip.
Sign of a healthy dog is a shiney coat, bright eyes. The parents shouldn't have a dull coat or dim looking eyes. That's a concern.
I had a german shepard rescue who was saved from a puppy mill. She had a tonne of health issues and behavioural issues that took a lot of work to work through. German shepards are traditionally working dogs so they need a lot of excercise or they'll eat your house (I'm not exaggerating).
One true legend so glad things are going better for him now.
Oh damn never saw it that way! Atleast i learn new things everyday.
wanting what someone else has is Jealousy simplified
Real Magician of Dog world 🙏🙏
Is there really a difference between being jealous and being possessive though?
Yes, look it up.
100% with you on this one. Keep talking dominance, Cesar, and let people ruin the trusting bond with their dogs. Meanwhile me and hundreds of other REAL animal behaviorists will have healthy, respectful relationships with our dogs without physical harm.
Sarah Stegs "Hundreds of other _REAL_ animal behaviourists" won't do shit all compared to Cesar.. he saves more aggressive dogs than anyone else. Period.
Jealousy is a human emotion. Dogs don’t feel anything like that. They’re not capable of it. Any more than they are capable of feeling guilt at chewing up the couch. I’ve always thought it was bizarre that people will argue until they’re blue in the face that in fact their dog experiences a full range of human emotions. I thought these people are just...mistaken and need helping. But I think I’ve realised that that isn’t the case. What I believe is happening is the person has formed essentially a surrogate romantic relationship with the dog, and accepting that the animal is not feeling any of the emotions that are being projected into would undermine the persons view of themselves and a major relationship in their life. I feel more sympathy for them now, but I don’t think it’s possible to change their minds. And the poor dogs are doomed to live in a state of perpetual anxiety and stress.
i think Cesar is one of the best, dogs handler, that can train them, the right way.
0:28 poor Loretta: why u gotta play me like dat, CeeZee?
I can't help but just die from the cuteness of this video.
Cesar, I love you with all my heart
What he is describing is the emotion of jealousy. Jealousy for humans too is very territorial in nature.
i dont get it
Samm Q people get jealous bc they are territorial. What is there not to get?
In my 50 years on this spinning ball, Cesar Milan is by far the ultimate dog expert. It is not the f-ing dog, the problem is the Human's ignorance of dogs and their natural state.
Idk man. When my cat comes over and I start petting him, my dog she will hop on my lap if I do not pet her she will nuzzle into my arm, saying I am her too, my turn! That seems like jealousy. If she were to attack the cat or stop me petting him then I would say possessive.
Probably because the dog sees you as their property.
Caesar you are the best dog trainer ever in the world I have used all your methods with both of my dogs thank you!!!
But isn't that just a fancy way of saying jealous?
I love Cesar Milan you could tell he loves his dogs and nice to see he didn’t cut his ears.
Seems to me to be the perfect explanation for human jealousy, granted, simplified, but basically the same.... claiming
She is such a caring owner and person, Cesar was amazing and he works with both Dog and owner and company to help them have good relations. Absolutely fantastic result.
That sounds like jealousy to me.
Interesting pint of view :-) I think that the difference between claiming and jealousy that Cesar is trying to portray here is that dogs claim also other things, like food for example. Seeing claiming as a dog behavior, and not necessarily as a human emotion like jealousy, and using that in order to get the dog out of his state (pushing him away) can be quite useful. Thank you, Cesar.
Chihuahua is just chilling sniffing butt. Love those dogs :)
He said the most valuable point of the day! Humans allow to be owned.
My dog only gets annoyed or jealous when other dogs want to jump up or bump in to me etc. He doesn't agree with the level of disrespect they demonstrate.
prndownload / that’s not jealousy the dog is just not accepting the behavior or level of excitement those dogs are giving off to the alpha, you are the alpha right? Or do dogs run your household?
Now that makes all the sense in the world....yes Cesar is a genius, so down to earth, gentle and really in turn with
nature's critters. We could all learn from his way....not only with animals, but with people too!
Yes dog can be sometimes jealous
Mine can be horribly jealous, she has destroyed other dog's toys before, just because it annoyed her. She also makes sure to be the top dog as well.
That can and they can be also jealous if the owner hugs a little baby and says how adorable the baby is and leave the dog . The dog would push there way in her hands so she would put the baby down
Ahh finally understand between jealous and to being own by a dog. one of my dog friend does push my dog away when that dog is close to me.. Cesar is the best!
my smallest chihuahua kicks my pitts ass!
and you are a turtle ?
I'm so glad Cesar is back...doing this his show. Not to mention I love his smile. ;) I've learnt so much from him. Which helps because I have a 85 lbs muscle male boxer - a 65 lb female pit who thinks she is a yorkie. I am a petite 83 lbs lady who is the pack leader... I think.? lol... Cesar, I do need help with my pack ;)
Jealous? Or not? I understand and agree with what he is saying.
All he did was explain WHY the dogs are jealous by saying its the human's fault. It still means that they are jealous. He simply called it by another name.. by terms which actually define jealousy itself (dominance, possession, etc). Jealousy is when you have fear or anxiety over an anticipated loss of something of value to you. I like Cesar, but he is human and thus fallible.
He said "one dog wants what the other dog has". ??? Sounds jealous to me.
***** Those 6 dogs are the alphas then. Just like in a family with children, all humans in the family, including the children, are the alphas.
***** But it was still just those 6 that took turn?
Cesar is a very smart man, but he lacks the professional scientific terminology sometimes and uses colloquial terms to relate it to the general public.
Im a masters student in conservation biology and have insight into predatory animals, genetics, and their behaviour. Cesar just has a problem relating scientific behaviour of pack animals (that he knows very well) to the public.
Dogs are possessive, not jealous. Jealousy is a unique semi-complex concept to humans that involves the feelings of the one giving affection, the one receiving affection, and especially the absence of the individual's affection and tying it all together. It's not simply about possession, we go further and tie that to subjective feelings. When Cesar said "The dog wants what the other dog has" That sort of isnt the right way to convey what the dogs were feeling. for example when Cesar Had the female dog with him, she claimed the space and affection around Cesar (possessive) and Junior (the other dog) was just roaming around and got too close, Junior didnt "want what she had" he just got too close to her possession. Junior didn't care the absence of affection and thus was not Jealous of her, and the female dog simply cared about not losing here possession NOT taking into consideration what Junior would feel if he were the one getting affection instead (that would also be jealousy). Dog minds don't get that complex (not because they're dumb but because evolutionarily they dont need to be that complex, theyre not humans)
Omar Morales Luna So what you are saying is, if I have 2 dogs and one bone and I give the bone to one dog, it becomes that dogs possession. The other dog now wants to possess the bone.
That fits my criteria for what jealousy is. It's just the doggy version.
‘Cesar’s Way’ may not be the ONLY way, but it’s the quickest way ...to solve or prevent problems so the loving can happen as soon as possible.
Your own dogs just come to say hello to someone they like, it's not about "claiming" then, it's about just being and exchanging affection. Genuine friendship is above the "Alpha pack leader logic" and doesn't require permission per instance anymore. Junior is an approved and trusted family member, Loretta isn't, and so, she is insecure and slightly competitive.
My bull terriers entered my personal space one at a time or all at once - no competition at all, no permission needed, just "family" existence.
Thankyou Cesar your an angel on earth
yeah well that is what jelousy is all about
Possessiveness is not the same as jealousy. "It's mine, stay away" is not the same as "aw, but I feel unloved, stay away".
No no no
When I feed my one dog and the other one doesn’t get any, it will be jealous that it didn’t get it, so it sometimes attacks the other one.
And that is after all the food is already eaten, it is nothing to do with territorial space.
Exactly... 😂 😂 😂
Nobody explains dogs psychology and behavior better.
Only Cesar.
So they jelly. That’s coveting your neighbor doggo’s hooman. Jealousy is exactly that. Wanting what someone else has.
or is it envy...?
That is envy 👆
I truly respect this man. Cesar u r da man. Y viva mexico. I learned so much i raised a perfectly gentle giant rottweiler his name is KIMBO. With no puppy classes. He helped me change as a person instead of changing how my dog is. Kimbo will protect my house n my family inside it. Kids love him. No aggression at all. Y viva mexico desde chicago. Puro orgullo mexicano. Thank you Cesar.
I bellieve they do get jealous, cause I've personally experienced it. I have a dog and sometimes when she sees me or any other person she likes playing with another dog or cat, she literally cries and barks in a whiny type of way. Like complaining.
These dogs here don't do anything like that at all. They only moved their head, which isvery different.
LastTram 90 My dog is the same way. She's very jealous of our cat. And when we have her in her crate while the cat is out she cries and whines and the whining and crying gets worse when I pick up the cat or the cat comes near me.
LastTram 90
Do you correct your dog, or allow the behavior to continue? So many of Cesar's episodes involve showing pet owners how to correct that type of behavior.
Ceas is amazing understanding dogs!
Cesar I never thought I'd disagree with you, but I have to say my dog definitely gets jealous!
Same with mine lol
I love how dogs are not emotional just instinctive. It makes me love dogs even more. The better the human the better the dog.
In other words, they are jealous... Does Cesar know the definition of jealousy?
lol you're incredibly stupid.
Exactly what i was thinking. He basically reworded the meaning of jealousy lol??
you guys must've missed the part where he said that the dogs are claiming him as their territory.
claiming "territory" is the same thing as claiming a partner as your "own"
mkc3188 To be jealous is to be fearful or wary of losing one's position or situation to someone else.
this guy is a genius. this type of psychology is more real than what the humans do.
"When an other dog wants what the other dog is getting...."
THAT'S JEALOUSY................ this guy lol
you're*
wassup? you mad bro?
just gonna guess you are
Well, jealousy usually involves some kind of resentment towards the other person who has more than you. If junior wants to be near Millan, he's not jealous or mad at the other dog, he'll just be like "whatever" until Cesar calls him back over.
Super Nova It's not jealousy if someone lived in your house even you dont want to what will you do?
You're so brilliant, Cesar!
I think I have to politely disagree with this one. I agree with claiming space, but oh dogs ARE jealous FOR SURE. Have you seen the video of the jealous great dane? My dogs won't come 100% of the time if I call THEIR name, but if I call the other one, they come 100% of the time I call their sibling's name. They claim the space the other is trying to get (but they don't have an aggressive bone in their bodies)they roll on top of me.I do need to work on claiming my space though. If our dogs's favourite chair and couch are taken they will stare at us until we move our legs and if we don't, these 70 pound labraddooddles will climb right on top of you and sleep there. I've been watching a lot Of Cesar so I'm learning. My pup definitely sees me as a pack leader more than my 3 year old. We got her at 8 weeks old. Second sibling gets away with NOTHING.
+Blessedmommy73 I get what you're saying. I think maybe it's more that the dogs just don't have the same reasoning as we do. IDK how to articulate it but I think it's more dominance (not aggressive, but a dog pack , pecking order thing) than jealousy. We tend to humanize our dogs , projecting our opinions on to them to explain behavior. Maybe your dogs are just showing the alpha, beta, etc, roles. And it looks to us like jealousy.
Dedication and training. I have 1 chihuahua 2 rottweilers I would call one and yes they did push the other away did what he showed in the video and learned from it now they don't push each other I'm in charge not them .it worked thanks Caesar
Blessedmommy73 I disagree also. My dog don't even have to stand by me and plain me. And he will growl at any dog walking towards me. He can't stand me to Pat our love on another dog.
Lol you literally explained how your dogs claim you and own you. Hahahaha
so you disagree that the dog is claiming the person and is actually jealous yet then you describe how you let your dog claim you and the space around you. Do you not see the irony here?
He almost always anticipate what's gonna happen (except when a white lab bit him)! This dude is awesome!!!
Sorry but dogs are definitely jealous! I've owned dogs for 49 years. I currently have 3 poodles. One female and 2 males. One of the males is extremely jealous of the other whenever I pat or cuddle him. Saying one dog "owns" the person is the same as jealousy.
+George Nason you're *
George Nason You're obviously very uneducated as indicated by your atrocious spelling and poor grammar, so I won't bother responding to your ridiculous comment. I think anyone reading it can easily determine who is really dumb.
Listen to what he said about the human being dominated. Its similar. A dog can't feel jealous like a human.
+bronzerat012 And, there this idiot goes. I have poor grammar because I said your instead of you're. One, mistake and I'm bashed. In my opinion, I don't think dogs don't get jealous, and you can clearly see that in my other post, but you didn't care about my opinion and choose to make fun of my grammar. Well, you are a very nice person, aren't you? And, you think owning a person means the same thing as jealousy, and who is uneducated? Plus, your just a storyteller, you make up a story and it will always end up in making your point right. That's all you want, to be right.
It's the same concept with a bone. If a dog has it in its mouth or in its area, it will growl or show the other dog that it's his.
But oh, according to you he's "jealous"
Of course not it's just his territory.
Dogs are territorial mammals, they don't have human emotions.
Yes, jealousy is a human emotion, and it's a bad one too.
Love. The. Way. You. Do. Your. Dogs
Dogs do get jealous, I believe that jealousy is present in all pack animals, such as us humans get jealous so do other primates, and just like primates dogs and wolves live in packs.
Listen to Cesar's explanation again. You're thinking in human terms.
Elizabeth M I am actually speaking in pack terms, sorry if you disagree.
Elizabeth M Sorry but your guru is wrong. Jealousy is related to possession and dominance. You can't explain it away by just naming it a term which is part of the very definition of jealousy. Jealousy is the fear of losing something of value to you. When another dog threatens to steal your dogs possession (food, human, toy) and your dog gets upset, thats jealousy.
daboognish88 I think he is just avoiding calling it Jealousy because jealousy is such a human term. humans tend to antropomorphise their animals and put human emotions and attributes to animals. :)
For a lack of a better word i would also call it Jealousy.
***** You can't not use a human term. lol
The reason he avoids the word 'jealous' is because he thinks it has negative connotations. But it is what it is. There is no other word that could describe it because jealousy is exactly what it is.
When a dog gets happy or sad you don't avoid calling it that because they are "human emotions". They aren't just human emotions.. they are emotions that are shared by humans and other animals alike.
Well done, César ! Love learning from you and seeing you in action. For all the haters : just look at the results he gets and all arguments stop dead there.
It is AWESOME how well behaved his dogs are. Their names could be Calm and Cool. Your are a great dog owner and trainer.
This is so helpful. We have a new puppy and he gets between our older dog and us.
Whatever you call it, he gives a great tip on how to avoid conflict.
I...already learned something important. I've already noticed the problem but didn't know what IS the problem. It was just "jealousy" for me. Now I know!
the way he sees even the little head movement and understands it is just awesome
LOL I needed to know this today...LOL Cesar you are wonderful! Thank You God!
I do everything that you do Cesar and everything works great!