@@sksksksk8960 No, off key or off tone means that you sing out of tune with melody of the song. Here, she just sang the lower octave of the melody. As long as you know the melody, you can sing many octave lower or higher and still on key.
@@Insomnia_tic Yea people just tend to sing off-pitch when they sing in their talking register. But I wouldn't call it "off-key". It was the right key. Just pitchy talk-singing.
@@moimeme6533 Yes she wavered on the pitch, but that's out of tune, not out of key. She wasn't out of key, just slightly out of the tune for some bits. This isn't hate, it's just a small detail
@@lifeisconfusing4833 I already said it was "out of tune" in response to the original comment which was mistakenly referencing the octave rather than the (ostensibly intentional) lack of intonation. But to clarify even further, "out of key" is not a phrase generally used by musicians. "Off key" or "Off pitch" which is more common with some musicians could mean _either_ out of tune (e.g. sharp or flat) _or_ singing/playing a different note than what is indicated in the score imo. In theory it would be possible to perform in the wrong key and still be "in tune" for that key but either way it would technically still be "out of tune" and "off key" if it varies from the key signature indicated by the composer.
Now I can't sing whistle notes, I'm just an amateur, however singing in general is supposed to be done effortlessly with the least amount of tension in the throat (and partially face). Then instead of trying to push the notes out they just flow out. Most of it comes down to finding your range, tone, breath support and projection, and to then find the best vocal technique so you can avoid straining your vocal chords (which again generally is all about avoiding unwanted tension and finding the right support from your body) You don't want to sing in an unhealthy way for a long period of time otherwise you can permanently damage your chords.
@@BroadwayVideos you are right and singers should work on core strength for breath support and cuz you push from your core not your throat and whistle notes should only be practised for 10 to 20 min and sould be sung from the back of the throat with a wide open throat
I am definitely the belter. I enjoy singing so much and it’s a lot of fun! I belt because I can do it and take advantage of it while I can. YOUR AN AMAZING SINGER! Girly you are so good!!!!!!!
The crazy thing is, the hardest part for her was the "off key" in the beginning lol.. Everything else came so naturally to her. Holy sh*t she's a beautiful singer and even more beautiful woman😍🥰🤗
While everyone's talking about how good her voice is, me who's wondering why her eyebrows are one dark and the other light😅 between her voice and singing is perfect as usual 🤍
Off-key sounds better than me on-key. Also, "the quiet one" couldn't be more Ariana LOL EDIT: I get it, she's not technically off-key 🙄 I'm just mentioning it explicitly as reference
![일상 속 기분 좋음 [Proto disco meme]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DwmEIaZ7XGQ/mqdefault.jpg)
The off key part isn’t really off key. It’s just an octave lower. Once you know how to sing, it’s hard to intentionally sing off key
Com’ on it can’t be hard just to choose any other key 😁 this was nearly perfectly on key
@@surferofthewaves6128 that’s what I said 😂
isnt that what singing off key mean?
@@sksksksk8960 No, off key or off tone means that you sing out of tune with melody of the song. Here, she just sang the lower octave of the melody. As long as you know the melody, you can sing many octave lower or higher and still on key.
Thank you I thought there is smth wrong with my hearing
the transition from off key to quiet was too smooth 😭😭😂
all the transitions are so smooth
Well you have to learn how to do that that's one of the first if many things they teach you at singing classes
Was it?😅
You know it's power when your phone starts to vibrates your hands while listening lmai
😂😂😂
I love how she does her whistle notes! ♡
ok
She's effortless
The quiet one: so sweet, heartwarming and peaceful. 😊
Thanks ❤
Wow you've got an all range voice. Try out for American idol
It's literally just Dolly parton's version
@@thatadhdkid2009I think I can do the quiet one but I lost control of the voice then literally change sound 😂😂😂
I sing like that, and people always tell me to speak up cause I do theatre but ITS SO HARD I sing quiet 😭
Those transitions tho
Right it was crazy
Right it was crazy
Right it was crazy
Right it was crazy
Right it was crazy
Her “off-key” sounds better then my normal singing 😅
Same. I suck ass at singing. I only sing when I'm home alone. 😂
same bro my singing is shit 😭
Yes omg- my singing sounds like crap, and yep I only sing when I’m alone and if somebody walks in on me I’m like “🤐…what do you need”
IKR 😂
That’s cos it’s not off key it’s just an octave lower
off key: selena gomez
quiet: ariana grande
belter: kelly clarkson
extra: jessie j
whistle: mariah
ariana grande is whistle as well
Ariana Grande is extra
@@shachi9495 have u ever listened to jessi? she’s extra as hell
Extra is xtina
Quiet is billie
Belter is def kelly
Whistler is the queen mariah herself
@@wanwan3864 ig billie is more whisper than quiet
The "quiet one" sounds like Dolly Parton and also, "the extra" one is so funny!
the off key one wasn’t off key it was just the lower octave😭
It was still a little sharp
@@Insomnia_tic ig so but i wouldn’t say its out of key just a little untuned
@@avalovestaylorswift416 true but i think that makes it all the more realistic
@@Insomnia_tic flat
@@Insomnia_tic Yea people just tend to sing off-pitch when they sing in their talking register.
But I wouldn't call it "off-key". It was the right key. Just pitchy talk-singing.
The fact that she did this in one take. That's so difficult to have to do so many different types in that short period of time. Impressive
what in the npc
@@EdwardLubega1165 💀
@@EdwardLubega1165 how is giving a compliment being an npc. You need to go outside.
WOW
@@EdwardLubega1165 you literally started it.
Your "the quiet one" is just so perfect😍 and it's totally sounding like Ariana Grande!😂
It actually reminded me the original, the dolly version
Tinashe 😩
Ariana isn’t quiet lmaooo her tone is just very soft
@@Li-xb1mw they weren’t calling her quiet they were just saying it sounds like her
Nahhh she sounds nothing like her
Her transition is smooth than my whole life💀
😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Shit😂😂😂😂what you going through 😂😂😂
🥳✨
Damn you roasted yourself
You went from Ariana Grande to Celine Dion then to Christina Aguilera and finished with Mariah Carey. 👏🏼
Or here's another one
She went to un-passionate guy to dimash
Started with Selena gomez 😂
@@魚-c3d lfmao
She literally did though😲. I can't un -hear it after seeing this comment😳 And she's really talented too!😮
@@魚-c3d 😩🤦 omg haha why did u have to do her dirty
her control is insane
😭
WHAT A VOICE, GIRL! YOU HAVE TALENT!
That whistle so pure tho 👀🤯🤯💖💖
AMAZING!!! The way you switched from head to chest to falsetto whilst mimicking different types of singers, OMG
The quiet one has my heart😭😭😭
The original song of Dolly Parton is like this
Reminds me of Dolly's version. Both versions are so good
@@Tashwampa it's not the Dolly's version, is the original.
i immediately thought of ariana grande
@@urfirstluvv me too!
Off-key actually isn’t off-key at all, it’s just being sung an octave lower than usual.
no, it's singing out of tune which could occur in any octave
@@moimeme6533 but she was hitting all the right notes, the only difference was that it was an octave lower.
@@oinkoink4407 actually she (obv intentionally) wavered on the pitch in a few spots.
@@moimeme6533 Yes she wavered on the pitch, but that's out of tune, not out of key. She wasn't out of key, just slightly out of the tune for some bits. This isn't hate, it's just a small detail
@@lifeisconfusing4833 I already said it was "out of tune" in response to the original comment which was mistakenly referencing the octave rather than the (ostensibly intentional) lack of intonation. But to clarify even further, "out of key" is not a phrase generally used by musicians. "Off key" or "Off pitch" which is more common with some musicians could mean _either_ out of tune (e.g. sharp or flat) _or_ singing/playing a different note than what is indicated in the score imo. In theory it would be possible to perform in the wrong key and still be "in tune" for that key but either way it would technically still be "out of tune" and "off key" if it varies from the key signature indicated by the composer.
Vocals are fire 🔥🔥🔥 keep singing.
Oh I was so caught off guard when The Quiet One started, it was so soft and so beautiful omgggg
that one is me
@@RoseBrandLovesYouwhy you like flexing so much
@@Vin-xj7mklike the girl in the video isn't flexing💀
the way she can perfectly transition- Please her voice is so beautiful...
I demand a full cover of this with "the quiet one" 🥺🥺
Yeah men, Her voice on that part was very fit to the song.
It's usually called falsetto!!
It sounds like the dolly Parton one
Its like butter.
The quiet one was so beautiful 😍 smooth transitions
Do you know of any full versions of the quiet type of singing this song?
The fact she sang like Ariana, Whitney and Mariah at the same time, it amazes me 💖
She didn't sound like Mariah 💀
the last part made my jaw drop.
i don't but why do people sing like that 😂😂 cuz I find it funny
The transition from quiet to belter got me shook!😳❤️🔥
girl you nailed ALL of these! you have such a beautiful voice ❤
idk why talented PPL are so underrated 🥺😭
The correct answers were:
Billie Eilish
Ariana Grande
Celine Dion
Christina Aguilera
Mariah Carey
All beautiful voices
The first one was more like J.lo.
@@royalpanther6391 😂
Wrong Anette Olzon / Elyze Ryd / Tarja Turunen / Anne Mattila / Anna Puu
@Loli Boba billie eilish cant sing for shit. She just whispers
@Loli Boba think he/she didn't mean that, billie has a low voice everytime she speaks
The extra one is literally Whitney during live performances
That's what I thought 🤣🤣🤚🏾
Whitney is extra in a good way
@@WHandEP3563 yes she uses ad libs and her belting skills as well as holding long notes in different octaves and different keys
That's exactly what I was gonna say, the real Whitney was the extra one lolol
😂😂😂
The way she transitioned to all of them was just beautiful 😍
This young lady can sing
That “I will al I will al I will alwaaAaaAays love you” was addicting
That’s actually how Whitney sung the song live many times!!! This lady is definitely a Nippy Stan🎉
I'm dying at the first one. Someone who sings so damn well can't be off key 😂😂😂😂😂
if the off key one was actually off key then what is my singing 😭
Nah dw, it's just a octave lower not actually off key I don't think
The “quiet” and belter are the prettiest 💜
I was so shoco at the end...
Her whistle is so angelic
Even the microphone couldn't resist this magnificence❤
She killed that! Wow!!❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
Her transitions were seamless!!
the extra one is def my type of vibe 😂
Me too😂
How she effortlessly did the whistle tone girl you got TALENT MY GAWD ❤
Edit: woah this is the most likes I’ve gotten
Maturity is when you realize that you don't sound like any of them-💀
Except the off key one😜
@@82youtubeshared I don't even sound like that😶😂😂
@@priyanshisingh8518 😅😅💀
She sounded horrible
Off key one 😎🤝
I think I just went through all of my emotions listening to your range, thank you very much.
This is really amazing! Great control in all styles and octaves. Wow! She nailed it perfectly.
She is talented
The smooth transition 🥰👏
the whistler 😭 that wass very very amazing 🥹
Wow this girl is so talented!
My mouth opened wider and wider with every transition...AMAZING
You sound so lovely. You go girl.
Ok but that whistle one is no joke. That’s a hella hard one to hit and she nailed it 🐦 🎶
All I can say is God is amazing, such a voice would wake me up even on lazy days
Beautiful transition between those vocal registers!
The transition is not only smooth, but beautiful as heaven 😍
No one can say that you're not gifted your voice is amazing
HOW DID HER FACE NOT TURN RED WHEN SHE DID THE WHISTLE?!?!? DNAG SHES TALENTEX
Now I can't sing whistle notes, I'm just an amateur, however singing in general is supposed to be done effortlessly with the least amount of tension in the throat (and partially face). Then instead of trying to push the notes out they just flow out.
Most of it comes down to finding your range, tone, breath support and projection, and to then find the best vocal technique so you can avoid straining your vocal chords (which again generally is all about avoiding unwanted tension and finding the right support from your body)
You don't want to sing in an unhealthy way for a long period of time otherwise you can permanently damage your chords.
@@BroadwayVideos you are right and singers should work on core strength for breath support and cuz you push from your core not your throat and whistle notes should only be practised for 10 to 20 min and sould be sung from the back of the throat with a wide open throat
She came to show off and boy do I respect her for that. Such talent 🌟
Slayed. My fav is how the off key one was just an octave down, not really off key. 😂
YOUR SWITCH FROM CHEST TO HEAD IS ASTONISHING!! ITS SO SO INCREDIBLY SMOOTH! 😮😮
YOU AN AMAZING SINGER,KEEP IT UP
Can we just talk abt how good those transitions were for one sec. Like how?! Amazing ✨
I am definitely the belter. I enjoy singing so much and it’s a lot of fun! I belt because I can do it and take advantage of it while I can. YOUR AN AMAZING SINGER! Girly you are so good!!!!!!!
That belting and whistle part is just awesome❤
Dolly Parton was a quiet one and Whitney was the extra one
We need a full version
Wicked talented
The switch to each type of singers was smooth
The whistle was beautiful 🥺
Belting>The extra one>whistle it all matches up waaaa it's soo good❤
the fact that she slayed at every one of these tho
The quite one sounds so peaceful and beautiful☺️
Bitch just shattered my TV with that last note. 😂 Very talented and accurate.
nah that whistle note was higher than my brother screaming 💀
Never let them know your next move.
You have all the talents of singing ❤
I can see you are so proud of your whistle part😆😍
That was impressive on all levels. Wow
Went from J.lo to Ariana to Celine to Whitney to Mariah. 😂
that was dope. she’s beautiful too
The crazy thing is, the hardest part for her was the "off key" in the beginning lol.. Everything else came so naturally to her. Holy sh*t she's a beautiful singer and even more beautiful woman😍🥰🤗
That whistle!!!! COME ON MS MAAM!!!!!
Did anyone else get scared when it switched from quiet to belter ?😅
the belter and the quiet one were amazing! legit earned a new sub for that
The off-key one actually sounds so nice🤧✨
That transition to that whistle was so smooth🔥
T A L E N T ! ❤❤❤❤ GOD WHAT A BEAUTY!
I love the quiet one and the belter ❤️🔥
While everyone's talking about how good her voice is, me who's wondering why her eyebrows are one dark and the other light😅 between her voice and singing is perfect as usual 🤍
ANYWAYS-
@@wynitawashington LMAO right? Anyways 🙄
Who cares? This is a singing video not a beauty contest!
It's because the light is hitting one side of her face. Which means it'll naturally look lighter in the light.
can you make covers, quiet one and belter versions :')
Love it 💖
I would say the extra one is the one that studies Whitney’s live performances cause they be knowing them Whitney adlibs 😂❤
Girl the way you can just change your voice is just amazing!
That was AMAZING 👏
Off-key sounds better than me on-key. Also, "the quiet one" couldn't be more Ariana LOL
EDIT: I get it, she's not technically off-key 🙄 I'm just mentioning it explicitly as reference
Isn't that supposed to different pitch? But still in the same notes.
The offkey is literally in key, it just sounds mediocre.
She wasn’t off key
Exactly. The pitch is just an octave lower. She's singing in the right key, though intentionally without much tonal colour or emotion
thats because its actually not off key, its just monotone
just made me feel self-conscious in every way😐😂
😅
So good I love how they just blended together so smoothly!!
Every single whistler I’ve encountered in karaoke was the tallest guy in pink shirt in my company who’s usually quiet
the off key wasnt off key tho💀💀
right? just monotone
It was a bit. But yeah, rather shaky and bland than off key.
it was in a few spots here and there
@@estera4176 not even one bit lol... it was just sung an octave lower
@@moimeme6533 be serious😭
the first one wasn’t off key
It's pretty hard to sing off key
True just different pitch, I was confused as well.
It was intentionally shaky, so she was going on and off key in micro-instances
@@immymahm9535 but it's easy to imitate someone else who is singing off key.
For us non musical, non singers, and tone deaf people can you explain what off key means and pitch please? Thank you
Absolutely beautiful voice ALL KEYS