Managing An Overstocked Fish Tank - Maximizing Your Fish Tank
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ต.ค. 2024
- *******
Book a 1x1 with me:
www.thedirtyta...
Become a better fishkeeper in less than 10mins/week
thedirtytank.s...
In the market for fish, aquatic plants, or merch? We got you covered at:
www.thedirtyta...
** Join me on LIVE - I go live every Monday and Friday on Tictok @ 845pm EST
Get updates and videos before everyone else by subscribing to our membership community!
Products I use:
Dehumidifier: www.amazon.com...
Small pumps: www.amazon.com...
Meds: www.amazon.com...
Shallow Tank: www.amazon.com...
House Plants: www.amazon.com...
Driftwood: www.amazon.com...
Magic Eraser For Cleaning: www.amazon.com...
Fry Food: www.amazon.com...
Heaters: www.amazon.com...
UV Sterlizer: www.amazon.com...
Fertz: www.amazon.com...
Smart Plugs: www.amazon.com...
Water rebirth: www.amazon.com...
Fluval: www.amazon.com...
#fish #fishtank #fishtanks #fishtv #fishcommunity #fishkeeper #fishkeeping #fishkeepinghobby #fishkeepersofinstagram #electricblueacara #chiclids #aquarium #aquascape #aquriumfans #the dirty tank #nanofish, #fyp, #dirttank, #bettafish, #tanksetup, #corydoras #plants #propagate #dirty #filter #tank #howto #plants #paludarium #shrimp #nature #setup #hobby #aquarium #nano #smallfish #crab #nature #wildlife #howto #dirtytank
![[ TEASER ] เงาะป่า - วงL.กฮ. | TMG RECORD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/M4ObdFfcPww/mqdefault.jpg)
Excellent analysis. This discussion is carrying the conversation into levels of understanding that create new knowledge. Very satisfying analysis.
Thanks! I appreciate your comment, great content challenging traditional thinking from your channel as well!
@@thedirtytank traditionally people don't think
I have a roommate who have a dirty tank . Which is 15 gallon aquarium with female pankat tail betta named princess Joyful noises. Because every time when she hear music 🎶. She goes nuts. She 🎶 along with her daddy. Than in New Mexico a guy have 8 male bettas in one tank live peacefully because it's roomy lots of hideouts , well planted with guppy grasses, ornzet swords and Nana anubias. School of 11 dwarf pencil fish.
In 68 gallon long aquarium
@@justinmccain1896THATS THE MOST DEDICATED BETTA TANK EVER
Overstocking can be done easily. In some cases it means weekly water changes. In others, not so much. Lightly stocked tanks with dense plant growth and sources of live food can see non-live bearer fish reproducing at a steady, even high rate. Just something to think about. Everything is a trade off. No one way to do things, just need to figure out what you want and then what that entails.
Exactly. Im 10 gals over the ich rule for my 20 Gal. 13 dwarf Corydoras, 9 Galexy Rasboras, and 6 Pork Chop rasboras. Every is happy. Yet people call me me evil lmO
I "overstock" all my tanks with little or no negative consequences. Plants. Filtration. Water changes. Three keys that you mentioned.
I have a similar tank and never need to change the water, what would cause a need to do that with so many plants? Only way I could see is if you introduce something harmful or if something dies and was sitting in there a long time but I've yet to experience that. Never have any sign of ammonia or nitrites. Nitrates aren't harmful in natural amounts but I usually have just enough.
I have a 29 gallon aquarium chinese theme with 7 platies Gold tuxedo wagtail 2 of them, 1 orange Mickey mouse, Tri color Mickey mouse, gold red, 📍 tail and pineapple. Toy cockpoo, 80 gallon Palarium with monkey 🦎 5 of them, 4 archer fish, 9 each Rudy red and green spotted scats, 2 Albino dragon gobies 4 regular ones, 8 each African and silver moon momos, red mangroves plants, 6 surviving GlassFish out of 12 of them rip, 7 coral reds, 5 coral blue platies, 6 red wag ⚔ tails female, 10 comet pink swordtails female and 1 knight goby. 16 Holstein Friesians, black mouth cur and corgipoo, and 2 Highland ponies.
Quite the list, my friend. Fish on!@@justinmccain1896
My friend ' neighbor ' grandparents had a 40,00 gallon aquarium stock with Pearlweed, Anbius, Hygrophille Pelysperme, Ratata inca, Caboma, 4 melon swords, crypsts, Hydrocoylle, Water Spite, Java Fern. Livestock 5 Angelfish 12 Cardinal tetras, 15 Congo Tetras, 18 pencil fish 🐠 9 🔥 Tetras, 21 Phantom Tetras, 15 Haqain rasboras.
You are well-spoken and have a good delivery.
Dude, get a room
My 10 gallon tank has 23 fish, shrimps and 10 low tech plants (8 different kinds) and it doesn't feel overstocked and the fish are thriving, the fish stock is:
6 zebra danio
6 cardinal tetra
5 corydoras
2 guppies (with 50+ fry, I'll give them away)
1 otocinclus
1 siamese algae eater
1 hillstream loach
1 horseface loach
20 red cherry shrimp (10 big, 10+ newly hatched)
I clean the filter monthly, and do monthly water changes.
I don't know if you mentioned this and I missed it, but the shape of the tank is important too; A long tank will not only allow more length for fish to sort of stretch out in, but also more segregation of adjoining spaces so that animals can have territories. It also gives more surface for the soil to absorb more waste, and subsequently more surface area for plants to root. Basically, just mimic a pond; They tend to be much wider than deep (which also means wider tanks are better than narrow ones).
I always overstock my tanks. I have a lot of filtration, my tank is nicely planted, I always have floating plants (red root floaters are my favorite) which are great at sucking up excess nutrients and as you mentioned I stack my fish. I have never had any issues and I've been keeping fish for over 30 years.
Story of our lives! Happy to know that there are people out there like me! Hello from Ph 🇵🇭...
I have a 29 gallon with 6 corydoras 5 cardinal tetras 9 red nose tetras (with very red noses) 6 glass catfish and 4 ottocinclus and soon to add 2 hillstream loaches and thinking what fish to make my centerpiece fish im between golden rams, honey gouramis or a betta fish. Lots of plants also on the outside of my tank lots of house plants hanging out the back of my tank. Everyone is happy 😊
Each of my endler tanks would _technically_ be defined as overstocked. However, I do give away alot of the excess, i have males in one and females in another and a betta female in the female tank to reduce the population of fry. I choose 1 male to pop into the female tank every once in a while to get certain colors. I scoop out the females close to fry dropping and let them have them in a growout tank. After they drop their fry I put the females back into the female tank. And this also helps keep down the population. My tanks are so full of plants that I don't always see a bunch of them together.
I run a HOB in each tank and I do a 10 to 15% water change every 2 weeks.
im running a 20G tank.
currently stocked with
4 dalmatian mollies
7 neon tetras
5 kuhli loaches (i see them ALL DAY long)
10 shrimp
1 pleco (max size 4 inches)
i also have 9 different plants
7 planted
2 floaters
AND 3 HIDEOUTS
using a 40G sponge filter on a 40G air pump
so far, all is well!
I love the idea of many fish in layers I like to have an overstocked tank as I want a giant amount of 20 or so schooling (only one type) fish and one centerpeice fish at the top
That was a convoluted way of saying "keep fish in layers and have many plants.
"expanded" way
@@MeanOldLady "eXpAnDeD" wAy 🫠
I've never stocked according to the "experts" who all do the 1 to 1 ratio.
Currently have a 29 with 6 neons, 6 harlequin rasboras, 1 bristlenose, 6 ottos, 3 mystery snails, and 5 cory's. I'm still on the lookout for a good centerpiece fish or breeding pair of something (probably rams?) to throw in there. It's loaded with column feeding plants, tons of dwarf sag, a few random root feeder plants, 2 HOB filters, and a HOB plant box I stuffed with some pothos. The pothos plant box added a whole extra root system to the surface where the tetras like to hang out.
I love rams, can't go wrong there!
I've been using live plants for months now and have no ammonia or nitrite problems despite having seven 4-6" goldies in a 55 gallon tank and a quickly filling 29-gallon (3 yoyo loaches, 4 aquatic frogs, 7 white clouds, 3 cherry barbs, 4 albino corys, and soon, several cardinals). I started with amazon swords and pothos clippings, but now I have duckweed, crypts, and several plated and floating plants I can't name. I'd advise those that first stat and want to hurry and get more fish to instead get excited about plants and that will help your fishkeeping experience long-term as they will be healthier and less stressed by both environment and water quality.
Glad i found your site. Very informative. No hype.
Glad you enjoyed
i follow the 1 inch per gallon, massive plant load, and the stacking rule. i have one fish and one tank. the fish is a 20'' black ghost knife who grew up over the past 3 years, and he's in a 20L tank. he spends all day under a huge tree bark cave that is encrusted with flame moss that will fill the tank if i don't thin it. at night he comes out and fills up the middle and surface layers. i feed him earthworms, omega 1sinking cichlid pellets and omega 1 catfish pellets. i have a tiny internal filter that uses a sponge/spray bar and provides a gentle current, and at the other end, a 6'' long air stone that i keep a sack of ceramic biofilter media right on top so current flows through continuously. the fish loves the air bubbles and lounges with the tail half of his body in them most of the day. this summer i bought a 75 gal tank and all the fixings, but haven't set it up yet! so he will get a new tank as soon as i reinforce the dresser i will use as a stand. not sure if it will hold 700 lbs of water!
Great video, just cycling a new tank and very helpful regarding plants dor beginners. I tried to find the excel on fish swimming layers but can't find on your website, do you have a link for the page
This 85 gallon long aquarium has live rocks 4 tall fake plants and 2 small ones 1 medium sized plant 🌿. Fish 2 Hawaiian butterfly fish, 13 Sergeant blackspot Majors 6 purple tangs, Potter 's angelfish, 7 yellowstriped 🐐 fish and 1 red knobs sea star 🌟.
I have a 125 Convict Cichlid tank that has more fish than tank. Somehow they control the environment because I am on my second year with this tank of multiple sized cichlids. Bottom is soils sand and Gravel mix. The soil for the plants and the gravel to stop the sand from compacting. The fish are still making fry and eating fry I guess because I see fry more often than not.
A dirt-ed tank! Nice.
1 inch per gallon is BS. And it always has been.
What is the smallest tank I can keep 34 guppies in?
@harrisn3693 as long as you have the filtration, 25-30 gallons.
Another informative video my guy🤙🏽
Great video very helpful
thanks so much
I have always thought that my tank might be considered overstocked, but now I reassured that I'm doing fine. Also, wouldn't it be fair to say that not all fish of the same length are the same with regard to bioload? For example, 10 inches worth of diminutive dwarf rasboras would be far less bioload than 10 inches of platys, correct?
Yes, 10 inches of say a phoenix Rasbora would be far less bio load than 10 platys. For sure
Looks good
Great video
I have 13 parrot fish and 15 medium african cichlids and 9 small african cichlids in a 55 gallon 4ft tank, with lots of clay pot, changing 20 litres water everyday, running a fx2 filter, they're eating like pig and breeding everyday morning, growing a lot ... The tank looks lively and not empty, don't listen to others and confine yourself, the only thing fish needs is lot of new water everyday and oxygen(spray bar / air stone) with good food...
That is awesome!
About three minutes in, some good comments are being made. I just want to point out that 1" fish vs a 2" fish vs a 3" fish are not merely a 1, 2, 3 ratio of bio load. Longer fish are often much larger than their length ratio would imply - and hence so is their bio load. I'm sure the video points out plants, role of substrate, perhaps not just having fish in layers but fish that eat algae, ramping up slowly...
Wouldn't it be fair to say that not all fish of the same length are the same with regard to bioload? For example, the bioload of a one inch rasbora is quite a bit less than a one inch cory who's far thicker.
Best filtration is a deep substrate not the slow growing plants like anubias , java ferns , etc .
Excellent video! However I looked at your homepage, but it wasn't really working for me :( No matter what I clicked in the menu, it came to a dead end.
My little "problem" with fish in aquariums is that all the fish I like, prefer to be in the middle of the aquariums. I never really find any fish that prefer the bottom for example, and I'm not much for corydoras... My smallest aquarium is a 54L (about 14 gallon) and the biggest is 200L (about 53 gallons). I have a lot of plants and friendly, smaller rainbowfish and guppy. Any suggestion of a fish that could thrive at the lower part of any of my aquariums?
My fish are all over the tank
Good info, do you have any videos exclusively on Cichlids?
Not just on cichlids. I have a few species profiles coming soon on apistogramma, rams, jewels, kribs
One inch per gallon doesn't make much sense because one inch of fish is not a meaningful measure of bioload.
Right a 4 inch kuhli loach vs a 4 inch Oscar or gold fish all have different bioloads.
Buy duckweed?
The Dirty Tank, will that excel downloadable list of fish and their preferred swimming layer be viewable on a phone?
If you have the Microsoft apps on your phone, yes. I think most androids have it defaulted
@@thedirtytank mine doesn't.
Is the loach you mentioned a kuhli, when I do a search that’s what comes up. I’m looking for something to put with my male betta that cleans the bottom of the tank. But they seem kinda colorful, would they be ok?
Yes, Kuhi Loaches. And yes, they should be just fine with a betta!
Pilates are the best fish 😂
What was the name of the first goby you mention? I can't seem to find it.
There's only like 2 or 3 articles about it. It's not well known. It's the Chinese Vermillion Goby or Thou's Vermilion Goby. Goes by both
Overstocking works until it doesn’t. There’s a reason it’s called “overstocking”.