Alexander No I'm pretty sure she has to serve 15months by what the judge said @41:40 or so. He said it was a committed sentence so I think she has to serve that.
lily blu Listen to the judge's ruling on the motion for stay beginning @ 1:01:14 "... I am satisfied that a grant of a stay through the Massachusetts court system only is warranted...while Ms Carter is going to be out on a stay...I have the authority to issue conditions...there will be conditions which will track in large measure the conditions of probation. Violation of any of these conditions could result in the immediate revocation of the stay..." My point isn't that she wasn't sentenced as you wrote. I'm just pointing out that she got a stay of execution on the jail time, and there is a good chance of a successful appeal.
Alexander No, that's what I meant too. Wtf?! I thought she would definitely do the 15 months. I hope you're not right. I don't understand all of the language they use, if ya know what I mean. But for her not to serve some time is just crappy!
It makes my blood boil. She killed this boy! I don't see any other way to see it... He would have been alive I believe if not for her telling him to get back in the truck! She might as well had a gun in her hand and killed him.
@@trishan9537 He probably wouldn't have been alive no matter if carter was involved or not, when you are this mentally ill to the point of suicidal idealization, and then attempting once already, it doesn't just go away. Words are not actions.
I respectfully disagree. It’s a tragedy for the Carter family to know their daughter was involved in this. She’s alive yes, but she nor her family will have a normal life.
Involuntary manslaughter involving a juvenile should be treated as an adult case. To me, it doesn't matter if she's young for that level. Her actions are completely unacceptable and still is the cause of the young man's death. 17 years old going on 18. She should have understood that manslaughter is manslaughter. Age shouldn't be an excuse. Once a person is gone, they will never come back. Michelle Carter, in my opinion, should have had a harsh punishment. Having evidence of the text messages between the two is enough evidence. (I'll stop typing before I start ranting)
I agree also. The fact she wasn’t charged as an adult at 17 years old blows my mind!!! She was less than a year away from being a “legal adult”. She knows right from wrong. Unbelievable
Even my 10yr old, ASD2/ADHD/ODD/depression/anxiety has told me he has friends that have talked to him about killings themselves for different reasons and he has told them not to do it, talk to their parents and try and get help cause it will get better when you get older. He has told me he doesn’t believe it, but the point is he knows to say it to someone. Because he has has these feelings himself I have said the same thing to him and also asked him how would he feel if he told someone to do it and they did?. Your telling me that a 17yr old doesn’t have the common sense to tell someone that even if they don’t believe it themselves
How can anyone call this fair. Is a YOUNG life and time in jail exchangeable for a life lost? I just don't get it. It's sending a strong message that it's quite ok for a young person to coax another person and persevere strongly for them to take their own life. I can't even compute this in my brain. It's wrong on so many levels. Such a ridiculous hand slap. I think the family of Conrad must be livid.
Clearly you have never been so mentally ill you were suicid*l. When you get to this point your mind is already made up, nothing will change it. He had already attempted in the year prior, this feeling and type of depression doesnt just go away.
I go back and forth on this so many times. Having watched the miniseries, which I assume a lot of the dialogue is based on the actual texts, I feel like she was tired of hearing him talk about it, saying his last goodbyes, then remaining alive as if he was playing on her emotions that she took it upon herself to help him get over the hurdle. What gets me are her texts to friends that Conrad’s missing. Regardless, neither of them were acting rationally on 7/12/14.
I agree. But in the end he was going to take his life with or without her words. Teenages always be saying things like that coaxing or not. Conrad’s parents should be responsible too for not been there in hes life a parent knows when there’s something wrong with there kids if there always involve.
She had no remorse she's a sociopath. We have not heard the last from this girl. As far as I'm concerned she's another Casey Anthony oops who also got off
the stay of execution of sentence argument that words or non-presence is not an aggravating factor just set the bullying argument to the stone ages. influencing a suicide with words or inaction is equivalent to accessory to commit such crime. Failing to render aid with such disregard and an attachment to the situation being a party to the situation can be elevated to manslaughter. I think she got off easy. I think this hurts the true fight for the weak and innocent by those that believe that words cannot destroy. The girl is the new PSA for bullies and what consequences can be for assisting a suicide.
I'm sorry but they pretty much just gave her a smack on her hand they should of made an example out of her it don't matter if she never been in trouble before the bitch talked a trouble man into killing himself I would of gave her 10 years I feel no pity for her rip to the poor troubled young man may you be at peace
She should of got more time that's sick how do you talk someone into killing themselves this girl is sick crying now sweetie you should of thought bout that before you talking a young man into killing himself smh
What a sad day for the young man’s family. She should have been made to serve time for her behavior but I would imagine that she will be well remembered and hated for a long time for what she did. Watch your back you POS
I have watched several of these types of videos and almost always - the same crime committed by women get 2-5 year and men 10-20 or life. I know of a lady who pleaded guilty to embezzlement of more than $300,00.00 (felony) and was given only 2 or 3 years or something with parole at 2 or 3 years.
I am a woman and I one hundred percent agree with you. I will also like to say its a man who also suffers from mental issues who shot someone and got off for insanity back in 2011 or 12 well this year in 2022 that same man kill my nephew and two others but in total shot six people so maybe they do suffer we all suffering from something as nobody is perfect and all I got out this man killing my nephew is when he commit crimes he now can use his diagnoses to his advantage all he has to say is I dont remember or havent been on meds and blame facility for not having his meds since they also dont want them to be expose for really not taking care of people like him they weigh it out until it dies down and all have went on with their lives and this devil is right back on streets or suppose to be facility that only cares about State checks more problems the person got the more money they get. All bs but know were not safe when things like these continues to happen. Scary
Wow literally did not let up on the boy when he wanted to live and this judge didn’t do anything to her. This is crazy!!!! Smh 🤦♀️ shameful sentencing for such a disgusting display for care and consideration of another human being’s life and well being.
He was on medication drugs that clog he’s judgement. Yes she made it worse but she was medications too, “Prozac” so if there’s one to blame it’s the parents for neglecting there kids well-being.
She is just used as a pawn to blame for the young man who took his own life. Very unmature kid to commit suicide because she said so. The whole case is stupid and this happens everyday. You just don't hear about it. When your young and have NO relationship experience.
Stringer Media You’re an idiot. People frantically, aggressively and emphatically text someone to kill themselves every day? Not sure where you’re from, but in most places (if not all) this disgusting premeditated behavior DOES NOT happen. Normal people try to contact someone’s parents or resources when their loved one is suicidal. Not encourage the act, method, and execution of that state of mind just to cold bloodily play the grieving girlfriend at an event afterwards in an effort to make friends and get sympathy and pretend that the suicide surprised you when knowing damn well what happened. So your “unmature” comment is preposterous and obviously you didn’t see the trial or know all the facts of this case.
The only way I think she will LEARN Anything is to do JAIL TIME Maximum for a Juvenile so close to 18 as toook a LIFE! ELLL-RIP- ❌✝️🕯️👼♥️👼🕯️✝️🅿️ She can HAVE BEST TREATMENTS In Juvenile Jail surely ?!? ❌🌬️✝️💞✝️🌬️🅿️
Furthermore Michelle "Eyebrow" Carter had terrible and ineffective assistance in counsel. Any decent attorney would have had this case thrown out within 15 minutes.
My brother Bobby was killed in a car train accident 24yrs ago and I feel for the sister of the victim. I miss him deeply and some days I cry all day. Especially dealing with so.w tough things in My family. We were loyal to one another and we taught our younger brothers to stick together no matter what. I miss that loyalty and just having my best friend
Wow, only 15 months! I wish the judge would have made an example out of her. She deserved more time than this.
lily blu and she may never serve time given the stay of execution and possibly-successful and definitely prolonged appeal....
Alexander No I'm pretty sure she has to serve 15months by what the judge said @41:40 or so. He said it was a committed sentence so I think she has to serve that.
lily blu Listen to the judge's ruling on the motion for stay beginning @ 1:01:14 "... I am satisfied that a grant of a stay through the Massachusetts court system only is warranted...while Ms Carter is going to be out on a stay...I have the authority to issue conditions...there will be conditions which will track in large measure the conditions of probation. Violation of any of these conditions could result in the immediate revocation of the stay..."
My point isn't that she wasn't sentenced as you wrote. I'm just pointing out that she got a stay of execution on the jail time, and there is a good chance of a successful appeal.
Alexander No, that's what I meant too. Wtf?! I thought she would definitely do the 15 months. I hope you're not right. I don't understand all of the language they use, if ya know what I mean. But for her not to serve some time is just crappy!
lily blu I agree she should of got the maximum that's crazy what she did
It is NOT a tragedy for 2 families!!!! One still has their child and the does not! She deserved more time. This is appalling.
It makes my blood boil. She killed this boy! I don't see any other way to see it... He would have been alive I believe if not for her telling him to get back in the truck! She might as well had a gun in her hand and killed him.
@@trishan9537 He probably wouldn't have been alive no matter if carter was involved or not, when you are this mentally ill to the point of suicidal idealization, and then attempting once already, it doesn't just go away. Words are not actions.
I respectfully disagree. It’s a tragedy for the Carter family to know their daughter was involved in this. She’s alive yes, but she nor her family will have a normal life.
Mom and dad must of paid big money for those attorneys. Such bull crap
Involuntary manslaughter involving a juvenile should be treated as an adult case. To me, it doesn't matter if she's young for that level. Her actions are completely unacceptable and still is the cause of the young man's death. 17 years old going on 18. She should have understood that manslaughter is manslaughter. Age shouldn't be an excuse. Once a person is gone, they will never come back. Michelle Carter, in my opinion, should have had a harsh punishment. Having evidence of the text messages between the two is enough evidence. (I'll stop typing before I start ranting)
Completely agree
I agree also. The fact she wasn’t charged as an adult at 17 years old blows my mind!!! She was less than a year away from being a “legal adult”. She knows right from wrong. Unbelievable
Conrad deserved justice ⚖
Even my 10yr old, ASD2/ADHD/ODD/depression/anxiety has told me he has friends that have talked to him about killings themselves for different reasons and he has told them not to do it, talk to their parents and try and get help cause it will get better when you get older. He has told me he doesn’t believe it, but the point is he knows to say it to someone. Because he has has these feelings himself I have said the same thing to him and also asked him how would he feel if he told someone to do it and they did?. Your telling me that a 17yr old doesn’t have the common sense to tell someone that even if they don’t believe it themselves
She was released early for “good behavior”, she did serve part of her sentence! Should have been in for a lot longer!
Exactly makes me sick
she should have gotten 37 more years for those eye brows
I was going to note that I don't know if she's crazy but she's got crazy eyebrows for sure.
Yeesssss!!! LMFAOO I just commented on her lovely brows!!!
🐛🐛🐛🐛🐛🐛🐛🐛🐛🐛🐛🐛
Edward you're a male! How could that not turn ya on. Do you go more for the bling snot in the nostril?
This woman should have been sentenced to jail time! She should not have been granted a stay. Unbelievable. What she was convicted of was so horrible.
How can anyone call this fair. Is a YOUNG life and time in jail exchangeable for a life lost? I just don't get it. It's sending a strong message that it's quite ok for a young person to coax another person and persevere strongly for them to take their own life. I can't even compute this in my brain. It's wrong on so many levels. Such a ridiculous hand slap. I think the family of Conrad must be livid.
His is sentencing her as a juvenile. Otherwise, I am sure she would have gotten a longer sentence. And those eyebrows....lord.
Clearly you have never been so mentally ill you were suicid*l. When you get to this point your mind is already made up, nothing will change it. He had already attempted in the year prior, this feeling and type of depression doesnt just go away.
I go back and forth on this so many times. Having watched the miniseries, which I assume a lot of the dialogue is based on the actual texts, I feel like she was tired of hearing him talk about it, saying his last goodbyes, then remaining alive as if he was playing on her emotions that she took it upon herself to help him get over the hurdle. What gets me are her texts to friends that Conrad’s missing. Regardless, neither of them were acting rationally on 7/12/14.
I agree. But in the end he was going to take his life with or without her words. Teenages always be saying things like that coaxing or not. Conrad’s parents should be responsible too for not been there in hes life a parent knows when there’s something wrong with there kids if there always involve.
ITS NOT PERIOD !!!
She had no remorse she's a sociopath. We have not heard the last from this girl. As far as I'm concerned she's another Casey Anthony oops who also got off
Wow. The judge thought this through very thoroughly. She doesn't have to stay jailed, but the only profit she is allowed is fresh air.
the stay of execution of sentence argument that words or non-presence is not an aggravating factor just set the bullying argument to the stone ages. influencing a suicide with words or inaction is equivalent to accessory to commit such crime. Failing to render aid with such disregard and an attachment to the situation being a party to the situation can be elevated to manslaughter. I think she got off easy. I think this hurts the true fight for the weak and innocent by those that believe that words cannot destroy. The girl is the new PSA for bullies and what consequences can be for assisting a suicide.
Yes, I feel the judgement she received is a slap in the face of the Roy family.
I know people think our penalty system here in Canada is lax but we would have taken her off the streets for them eyebrows alone!!
Hahahaha!!! I can’t even look at them any longer 🤦🏼♀️
Then why haven't you gotten rid of Trudeau
I'm sorry but they pretty much just gave her a smack on her hand they should of made an example out of her it don't matter if she never been in trouble before the bitch talked a trouble man into killing himself I would of gave her 10 years I feel no pity for her rip to the poor troubled young man may you be at peace
+ Susan Harkins - Amen! most people share your view...
How much money does her Family have?
She did go to prison on February 11, 2019. Being released early for good behaviour (having served 11 months & 12 days) on January 23, 2020.
🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬
It wasn’t even prison it was a corrections center for women. I’m so angry. 😡
Michelle Carter got off easy. She is a monster!
She should of got more time that's sick how do you talk someone into killing themselves this girl is sick crying now sweetie you should of thought bout that before you talking a young man into killing himself smh
I don't get how she got a stay whatever that is & only 2.5 years she should of gotten more time she deserves to sit in jail
Those eyebrows got life without parole. Not sure how that's gonna work
Not enough she told him to get back in the car
I think this "judge" would have better been serving us if he wasn't a judge. Not sure what else he could fake but I'm more than happy to hear opinions
All I got 2 say is WTF!!!
Fast forward to 2019 and Forward Children as young as 14 are being tried as Adults.
What a sad day for the young man’s family. She should have been made to serve time for her behavior but I would imagine that she will be well remembered and hated for a long time for what she did. Watch your back you POS
Them eyebrows wit that hair 👀 she should have gotten way more time for that alone!🤦🏻♀️
The judge is the New Englander version of Captain Picard lol.
She should have received more time this is ridiculous
Wow these kids these days commit adult crimes and get a slap on the wrist and be sent on their way it's not fair
It was just text messages oh my god just exaggerating
Attorney is overly affectionate - during trial he’d frequently hold her hand
Ya, those brows must turn him on
@@bethcurtin4201 shut up you horrible freak
Judge needs to get ORGANIZED!
She looks like the dentist from the movie "Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer". Doppelganger.
I will never understand how she was not sentenced to at least 10 years in prison.
15 months prison and 15 months of probation, she is lucky!
Is Michelle smirking when the judge says she is a “child before the court”?
*The judge by postponing incarceration mocked the Roy family.*
Is this judge senile?
She was released after 11 months - hardly a punishment
she could care less
I have watched several of these types of videos and almost always - the same crime committed by women get 2-5 year and men 10-20 or life. I know of a lady who pleaded guilty to embezzlement of more than $300,00.00 (felony) and was given only 2 or 3 years or something with parole at 2 or 3 years.
I am a woman and I one hundred percent agree with you. I will also like to say its a man who also suffers from mental issues who shot someone and got off for insanity back in 2011 or 12 well this year in 2022 that same man kill my nephew and two others but in total shot six people so maybe they do suffer we all suffering from something as nobody is perfect and all I got out this man killing my nephew is when he commit crimes he now can use his diagnoses to his advantage all he has to say is I dont remember or havent been on meds and blame facility for not having his meds since they also dont want them to be expose for really not taking care of people like him they weigh it out until it dies down and all have went on with their lives and this devil is right back on streets or suppose to be facility that only cares about State checks more problems the person got the more money they get. All bs but know were not safe when things like these continues to happen. Scary
I dont get that either. Like a woman’s murder isn’t as bad. Beotch’s want equal rights until it comes to things like this!!
Wow literally did not let up on the boy when he wanted to live and this judge didn’t do anything to her. This is crazy!!!! Smh 🤦♀️ shameful sentencing for such a disgusting display for care and consideration of another human being’s life and well being.
that young man would still be alive if it wasn't for her. that was a very light sentence in my opinion.
annnnnd shes out on stay, wow so yeah ok crazy chick walked
Cosmic Kitten what is a stay what does that mean she gets no jail time
until her appeal yep, white girl walked
He committed suicide.
I love the way the defense attorney says "mrs carter"
What is a motion to stay of execution never heard of that
her brows are the real crime
Apparently this place has alot of sick People. Divorce and Girlfriend's and moving their children around. Wow
He was on medication drugs that clog he’s judgement. Yes she made it worse but she was medications too, “Prozac” so if there’s one to blame it’s the parents for neglecting there kids well-being.
Insane
Her eyebrows were getting darker and darker.
Their lives was taken cause they journey on this earth came to in end stop blaming one on others
Wtf-? U on drugs, beyatch. 🥊🗑
Um….. no.
She is just used as a pawn to blame for the young man who took his own life. Very unmature kid to commit suicide because she said so. The whole case is stupid and this happens everyday. You just don't hear about it. When your young and have NO relationship experience.
Immature* 😉
The Nostromo *buttwhole
Stringer Media You’re an idiot. People frantically, aggressively and emphatically text someone to kill themselves every day? Not sure where you’re from, but in most places (if not all) this disgusting premeditated behavior DOES NOT happen. Normal people try to contact someone’s parents or resources when their loved one is suicidal. Not encourage the act, method, and execution of that state of mind just to cold bloodily play the grieving girlfriend at an event afterwards in an effort to make friends and get sympathy and pretend that the suicide surprised you when knowing damn well what happened. So your “unmature” comment is preposterous and obviously you didn’t see the trial or know all the facts of this case.
You’re as sick as she is
You’re*
Wooow!! BS SENTENCE 🤬
First degree murder 40yrs min.
Shut up wtf 🤦🏻♀️
The only way I think she will LEARN Anything is to do JAIL TIME Maximum for a Juvenile so close to 18 as toook a LIFE! ELLL-RIP- ❌✝️🕯️👼♥️👼🕯️✝️🅿️
She can HAVE BEST TREATMENTS In Juvenile Jail surely ?!?
❌🌬️✝️💞✝️🌬️🅿️
🐛🐛EYEBROWS🐛🐛
11:30 What the- Twins??
Monster
👎🏼🤢
Poor girl needs therapy. What a sad sad case.
CUP
0
She should've got 15 year just for thinking those eyebrows looked good. Wow
what's with her eyebrows?
Furthermore Michelle "Eyebrow" Carter had terrible and ineffective assistance in counsel. Any decent attorney would have had this case thrown out within 15 minutes.
Apparently you are a family member
How
You’re as sick as she is
Cocoa? Was this about a family dog?
David Gonzalez no a young troubled man she talked into killing himself
Why are Conrad's parents suing Michelle Carter? It's not going to bring their son back. Everybody's gotta blame somebody.
It’ll be a way to make her pay - as she should a sociopath has no guilt!
Bandid
Awesome defense.
You must be a family member
machiavelli an nietsche are supreme. god is dead and every entity is mortal.
My brother Bobby was killed in a car train accident 24yrs ago and I feel for the sister of the victim. I miss him deeply and some days I cry all day. Especially dealing with so.w tough things in My family. We were loyal to one another and we taught our younger brothers to stick together no matter what. I miss that loyalty and just having my best friend