LAC Standoff: ‘China Testing The Waters-India’s Response, Timing, Political Will’
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.ย. 2024
- NEW DELHI: A roadmap for de-escalating the LAC standoff is in place after Indian and Chinese military commanders met on June 6, as StratNews Global reported earlier today. But what explains the confrontation that began over a month ago? The Chinese have an agenda and I don’t think the current chapter has ended, says China specialist Jayadeva Ranade. Speaking to StratNews Global Editor-in-Chief Nitin A. Gokhale, Ranade, a former intelligence officer, said: ‘They are testing our response, they are testing the timing of our response. They are testing our military and political will’. Lt Gen. Sanjay Kulkarni (retd) who has served as Chief of Staff, 14 Corps, concurs. Even they know military confrontation is not the answer, he says ‘They’re trying to send a message to Southeast Asia, to Taiwan, to Hong Kong, even to America’.
#ChinaIndiaFaceoff #IndiaChinaFaceOff #LadakhFaceOff #LadakhTension #chinaindiaborder #IndiaCheckmatesChina
SUBSCRIBE to our Channel - / @stratnewsglobal
Press the bell icon to not miss updates from StratNewsGlobal.
Follow Us on Social Media:-
Like us on Facebook: / stratnews
Follow us on Twitter: / stratnewsglobal
Follow us on Instagram: / stratnews.global
Website: stratnewsgloba...
Very good discussion! No political fight and Nitin sir gives enough time to the guests to elaborate their Points! Keep up the good work!
Most reliable and realistic information without compromising national security
Very good analysis from the top experts. Happy that you have best panel of experts, and not politicians. Continue doing the Good job, Nitin. Love your programme.
I love your chennel , quality of discussion is excellent. Kindly improve audio quality if possible. Thank you
Very accurate analysis sir..... Keep up the good work.
Respects to the distinguished experts for the analysis & opinions.
That is a perfect example for our mainstream news channels on how a discussion should be held.
# Thank you Nitin Sir .
With all due respect to the StratNews Global, your content and discussions with the guests has no match, being a Defence Aspirant and Defence Strategy Enthusiast this channel is no less than study material for me. Therefore I kindly request you to improve your audio quality as the audio somtimes fail.
Thank you for reading this post.
Major.Kulkarani..seems to be very jovial, generous and mean business ..Super Sir Vanakkam 👍🙏🤺🌈
Discussions are purely technical unbiased and no political addengda. Opinions are from experts in their respective fields. Great to watch.
I totally agree with mr Jayadeva ranade : Chinese won’t do anything haphazardly, if they are here , they are here with solid reasons and strategic thoughts. We need to outdo their thought process by completely focusing on their mind games and studying their actions world over. Great discussions. Always a pleasure to hear the renowned panellists
They must have come to see the beauty
of Ladhak.
😂😂😂
Sir 🙏🙏🙏
It's great to hear wise words from experts. thank you to all three of you.
All great people together.....would like to meet all of you once.
You guys are the best in bringing balanced news and in-depth analysis on defense and strategic affairs
At 19.00 minutes Mr.Kulkarni started telling when we go their hospitality...You see clearly all these Decades India going for Negotiation not the Chinese coming for Negotiation... That's the point China wanted, unless you STOP going for Negotiation China will repeatedly do these incursion...
Amazing Informative Video ! Nitin sir keep bring this kind of video with REAL EXPERTS more often.
तिघेही मराठी आहात, हाच कार्यक्रम मराठीत कराल काय? सामान्य मराठी माणसाला पण कळूद्या.
@Sachinraddy Bappasai Are you a fool? What is the connection between Marathi language and Soniya?
@Sachinraddy Bappasai , keep your political views and retorts to yourself, there is no need to dish out jibes on political lines without any instigation to you.
Also, Mr. Jadhav, all these three panelists might have spoken with each other in Marathi on appropriate forum or youtube channel where Marathi is the primary language of the content. StratNews Global is meant for a wider audience across India, her neighbours in/around Indian Ocean region and wider audience across the globe - so it's fine to discuss the matters in English which is perhaps commonly understood language across the mentioned audience spectrum.
good to see development of strategic thinking channels in India
In Doklam later Chinese built military infrastructure in " their territory ". India did not object then .The whole picture was not shown by media. These experts have no answers.Time they retired.
Beautiful.. thanks 🙏.. now I am not worried
As usual a very interesting discussion. Thanks to all 3 of you.
Thank you for the Ep !
Excellent presentation. Thank you Nitin, Gen Kulkarni and Shri Ranade ji
Sir! What is the pragmatic issue in Pershing for actual LOC ??? Why have we been sticking to the Line of Actual Control and hesitant to talk about our land occupied land by China?
Please deploy KALI LASER Versions as per need and requirements...
*Our attack should be a Surprise to them*
sivan LoL u r such a funny guy... I mean I couldn’t stop laughing... in ur logic Vietnam shld have lost war with USA ... also Cuba shld have accepted defeat with USA bcoz their economy is far less Dan usa... wat a stupid logic ... war won’t happen on economies ... it depends on strategies in those mountains...and regarding balakot pak attacked on our bases we went and attacked theirs... as simple as dat... let’s imagine we havnt killed anyone... but we went upto 70kms far to Pakistan capital Islamabad and came back with out any problem... dat itself is huge win... atleast they know we won’t keep quiet... dats what very imp... what deter u want man... yes a human Dan thing happened bcoz our fighter jet was in their area... but we did what we had to... it’s very clear that if they do anything we wl do some thing
sivan LoL Iam seeing all ur comments on others too... u r here to clearly with some intentions... u have lot of time sitting and writing paragraphs for all other comments... who will have dat much time... there is no point in discussing with u... ur name says sivan... I doubt dat u r pakistani with fake name... we r economically less than China... dat doesn’t mean we r destined to losses... u r here with intentions to degrade military India and everyone... ok take care... I know u wl write again a paragraph... I know ur job is this oly... take care of ur health... bye
sivan as I said again u wrote paragraphs... lol... it’s ok man take care... go and sleep... by the way I live in shanghai from 6yrs if u don’t know... just using vpn and watching these videos ... good nite sweet dreams
Guys actually if there is ia war nobody is gonna win...this ain't plain lands of any other country...it's the Himalayas...no one would be stupid enough to move their troops deep into either of the countries land to face the full might of armours...it would be complete suicide....if the war is conventional then there would be nothing but long and strenuous fights with heavy casualties from both sides, over mere peaks...the fighting will be limited to mountain infantry supported by artillery barrage from both sides...guided missiles will be worthless in Himalayan snow with minimum visibility... choppers will likely help because of lack of visibility risking life of its own soldiers...navy will do trade blockade leaving the Chinese navy to the US...at last we will gain mere territory in Himalayas will high casualties...and yes we will gain cause our race fights better and are tough...both countries economy will be devastated and there will be armstice...
Neither the economy or the willpower will let either of the troops cross Himalayas and get slaughtered....
Le Himalayas- hehe boi😎😎
@@jayakishore3032 bro do you know why do Chinese eat everything and are still weak compared to us vegetarians. Stay safe bro.
Very productive discussion.
Wow!!! I always think how such meetings takes place....
This explains everything
If they are testing then lets give them the real thing and show what India is capable of. React by attacking them and taking the war deep into their territory.
Jai hind from Barcelona Spain
Brilliantly articulated. Kudos Mr Gokhale and the panelists
Have an episode purely on Chinese psychology based on Sun Tzu. Two retd officers ( suggest gen KT Parnaik & Gen Jaishankar with Amity Univ) Shri Ranade and prof kondapalli ( JNU)
Very Good Quality discussion on Critical Matters...Great job Nitin ji
this would not be a problem if Neru would have had the balls to have helped his good neighbor Tibet keep their independence in the 1950s.
Thanks Nitin for giving us such a depth analysis on India-Chaina conflict.
Good discussion🙏
Surprised to hear from veteran Kulkarni that Chinese getting in position close to DBO road and shlok - Galawan valley were they could affect our military traffic and fingers are nothing.and fingers 4-8 are not significant
Why doesn't india take offensive posture by repeating what china does by intruding into Tibet? Why does India need to adhere so rigorously to LAC and always make defensive military moves as well as defensive posture in policy?
Great people great analysis.. 🇮🇳🇮🇳
I salute General Sanjay sir. Very inspiring sir.
Going for Negotiation is a India's routine for Decades... STOP that make China to come to you to Negotiate...
That's the conventional way, China is in commanding position that's the reason.
There r sound issues sir!
Indian generals cannot think beyond liquor and party and self appraisal. This General saab was called here to give us a perspective and not speak about drinks and party. Even though it might be realistic there is a requirement of a greater perspective which the Indian generals r incapable of and as aptly demonstrated by lt gen Sanjay Kulkarni.
Keep up good work mate.This channel deserves 1 million subscribers.
very good video, makes a lot of sense when the moderator and the panel exactly knows what they are talking about
Nitin - you have been as usual Brilliant.
With this China has shown that it doesn't have a stomach when posted a fight , be it this time or Doklam. India will shrug off 1962 war drubbing forever with this incident.
For Pakistani, its not a good news. For last couple of days every anchor in the TV is talking about it as if Pakistani army has stole some land in Kashmir when Indians were napping. Its also bad news that the focus will be back again on POK.
Great
I don’t now these people are laughing,the Chinese are 3 to 4 km in your borderline .
Audio is very frustrating in many of your videos sir. Disturbing the otherwise excellent discussions
Deception being their forte. This may be part of the 1-2 feints before the actual action begins somewhere else (closer home)?
Very sensible talk... I like the way everything is discussed and it gives us more clearity what is really happening. Thanks for discussion
Nice work. Full of information. As someone pointed out, increase audio quality. Keep up the good work.
Please make a video about PLA occupation of gallwan valley....and I hope next time with Ajay Shukla ji....
Have the Chinese occupied Indian territory in Ladakh?
Nobody from indian establishment has a clear answer....
Pakistan is a funny Islamic Republic state.
pork eating,alcohol binging Chinese,who make Mullas dance in public&whose leader Xi thinks Islam is a psychiatrist disease is their friend.And India wit 11lakh mosques where Muslims r free to Preach,practice&Propogate Islam is their enemy. Also 29 Islamic names including Mohammad are banned in China
@@rockybadhe Have the Chinese occupied Indian territory in Ladakh?
Namaste Nitinji, I often follow your channel and appreciate the valued views of different experts opinions on Indian's security aspects. Please have some discussions on fifth generation war fare and cyber war fare in present global situation. How is Indian's preparedness.
Good to see this 👍
Excellent insight and very knowledgeable guests.
please deploy bahubali to the front lines with katappa
Authentic stuff
Ultimate data n details. Mind blowing
Very informative and awesome discussion
Brilliant insights. 🙏
Total nonsense. Where's the proof that both sides agreed to de-escalate? Neither is the Indian government saying so, nor the Chinese. Nitin is dreaming too wildly. He has a right to, but he should not air his dreams publicly. And to say that neither side has crossed LAC is not even laughable. Nitin has lowered his professional reputation greatly in just one day.
Sir pl make playstore app of your channel so we keep getting notification
I have a simpler explanation. Some Chinese general decided to make a name for himself.
Good job 👍
One day we will get back Aksai Chin and occupied parts of Arunachal Pradesh. India’s strategic interest and move should be to liberate Tibet somehow, even if forming alliances with the USA and Australia. Hmmm The future looks very interesting if not dangerous
Lt. Gen. kulkarni kept on going off the track quite some way...He likes to talk...should be introduced to Arnab Goswami...not to Strat news global!
Chinese flew Black Hawk UH 60s in late 80s for air maintenance sorties before he constructed roads linking her posts in East
All these fingers.... In the end the question will be who holds up the middle finger.
Right now, it appears China holing the middle finger up.
Two Greatest expert on sino indian relationship..one Chanakya other lion of Himalayas...boths mind together can handle all the challenges..
My one point questions
Can india not apply same strtegy as china is doing..
Beside covert operations in inner Mongolia, Tibet, Xinjiang, hongkong and ofcourse Taiwan??
sivan That is because we are not expansionist like China, they are experts in this field. In Akshi Chin our goal is to try and get back what was ours, but this is an uphill task, Chinese have a clear edge because of their resolve and steady manoeuvring for decades.
@sivanTo sum up in one sentence, we are *governed by a democratically elected government* whereas China is *ruled by an authoritarian regime,* Period.
@sivan Yes perception differs, I usually advise *Sochh badlo*
Jio
Is it true that during the Mallapuram summit last year Xi Jingping mentioned that he would ask Pakistan to give up Gilgit Baltistan to India in exchange of Azad Kashmir and on condition of India joining the OBOR via CPEC ? That shows the hold China has on Pakistan and also the extent to which Pakistan must be ready to negotiate on Kashmir issue. What are your thoughts if India accepted this proposal considering the Gilgit Baltistan is 6x size of Azad Kashmir and that would mean India would control almost 80-85 % of the Kashmir (incl Ladakh, JK, GB & AC) from 50-55% it rules today. It could also enable India to reach Afghanistan directly and then Tajikistan as well ? Also Perhaps hard negotiations could also land Aksai Chin on the table. India and China are in no position to fight a war as it would destroy both economies so perhaps this is the channel to normalize relations and also secure (relative) peace on the Western Border and let Azad Kashmir on the side for further negotiations?
I have watched your ROAD MAP of De -Esc
...but does this 2 or 3 kms backing off ( de escalation) by either side ...will make any difference ?
Or is this just Symbolic or a good will act ?
They are testing depth when ever they will find weakness then only they will move forward.
I think their feedback came from Pakistan and due to saheen bag and then Corona they thaught India is in vanurable position so they made a move but India deployed real quick and that made them stop.
That video reminds me of their terracotta army...😂😂😂 all bluster
You guys must exercise some common sense. Most army guys are painstakingly trained not to that.
India and China have a boundaries that were never jointly settled before. No marriage can occur unless a man and woman agree. Where do have that agreement between India and China?
You guys must ask that question. It is stupid to talk about strategy, arms, economy, territorial integrity when there is no integrity of territory.
Help both countries by asking them to sit and settle like everyone in the world settled their boundaries . Even China settled with everyone. And India settled with no one.
please improve your sound system
China is a real challenge to Modijis diplomacy and efficiency .
Audio quality is very poor please rectify...
Can we not atone time give a good push back to improve our stock with our nmeighbours having eaten humble pie
Sirs, though am not connected with the GOI or any department whatsoever. I desire to submit that all our claims of being a battle hardened force then why are we caught sleeping on the IndoChina border? Why do we depend on lackadaisal personnel to run our most important functions. To give an example we till a few days back called the Chinese practicing the Wolf strategy, where were we- sleeping as usual!
Recent Cocos Island shared naval base with kangaroos was fine even while Ladakh drama being done by Chini-bhais.
Please improve the sound quality with good microphones for guests
Poor sound quality. Like the program though.
Are we not supposed to be talking with the government of an independent Tibet and not China. But we are foolishly in talks about our own land with a repeat offender occupying territories of other nations. We should stop calling Mainland China & support and fight for independent Tibet.
I have started to hate the word 'perception'. Why do we buy into this 'perception' argument? More than buying into it, we keep parroting it, from politicians to military personnel. It's as if we are speaking for the Chinese. We should not.
Could you add CC (closed caption) to your videos? Thanks
China entered 5 km and retreat 2.5 km 😏 and we are taking about de escalation our appeasement policy towards China is disgusting
@Varun Shekhar today government admit that China intruded 8 km area in ladakh
I am pained presently that by reports on media came to know PLA have squeezed 60 sq.kms. area near the Panging Lake area.
Even during Kargil War times, then, too, Pak Army have kept some sq.kms. area under their domination. We are always looser in Mountain War Tactics.
What is that our Military Intelligence doing all the time?🎆💎
sivan so basically ur prob is with modi and Amit shah... for dat u r trying to blame Indian military... what a looser u r bro...
sivan Some amount of bias is okay, but some of our media outlets and their experts on defence issues cross all limits of false narrative, which even our opponents may not take them seriously.
All maratha panel!
yay!
China might be taking over Gwadar or other Pak areas which we must never allow. Probably we must takeover the Shaksgam valley sooner.
You should worry about Ladakh first.
Sorry aksai chin is ours isnt it
Audio , esp from Gen Kulkarni is very poor
Your video audio quality is always poor
रामायण , माहाभारत कथा
Very poor audio
Very bad audio
For Pakistan India goes for surgical strikes, BUT for China it follows the Roadmap given by China.
Hey genius surgical strikes happened bcoz terrorists killed our ppl.... this is border issue... like any country in world... any country which has border wl have border issues... this starts with talks if it won’t work then fight... just bcoz u don’t like modi don’t think u can talk anything... it’s ok u blast govt for inside country issues... but when outside ppl come it’s our responsibility morally we shld be with govt... u can blast modi and Amit for internal issues
@@jayakishore3032 If India was strong enough China would have thought for 100 times before occupying Indian area and showing muscle to Indian army. Why India has come down to table instead of kicking the butt of China. And where is Uncle Trump whom Modi thought to be his Godfather.
SMART FOX no one cares trump... u r imagining itself god father and all... tell me one thing modi asked trump for help... and no one wants want war... everyone wants to happily sleep in jokes and bco of Covid economy is going down... so it’s time to increase economies with good strategies ... so it’s always good to go with talks unless it goes to bottom.... if war is inevitable let’s die happily... wats the big deal... even if we loose it wl be a memorable war to tell our kids dats all
SMART FOX Wherever our position is strong we show China its place, Arunachal, Sikkim, Doklam etc But Aksai Chin is a different ball game, the boundary demarcation was not done since China occupied Tibet and shifted boundary post clandestinely over a period of seventy years inch by inch to now mile by miles.
@@bvshenoy7259 China always makes strategic moves. But India makes tactical moves. This is how India lost its land. India needs a strong leadership not a Andh Bakht.
Guys!!🙏,...me just a subscriber of this channel .. please share this video link and make this channel...I am doing it since June 4 th
...many copy cats with half baked news celebrating in You Tube
اب چورن بیچتے رہو...... لگے رہو منا بھائی
PKMKB