I've been listening to Blind Curve a lot recently. The fellow in the front row's reaction as Blind Curve (proper) starts, is one of the most touching things I have ever seen. It's as if the song really connected to something within him from years gone by. Even though this is a "Fish" song, H really shines on this one - and it's one of the rare ones that works equally with both singers and eras. Outstanding.
This is THE Fish-era Marillion song. I really like H's voice in those old songs and it's amazing how these guys are so consistently amazing. What other band can play like 80% of their (huge) output on rotation live at this level of musicianship?
@Israel Duque Interesting though to observe that both Rothery and Kelly have used vocalists on their solo project that are closer to Fish in timbre... (Martin Jakubski & Oliver M. Smith)...
Last night you say I Was Cold.. Just leave me alone with my thoughts.. I' m Saving myself So I reached for a bottel and he reached for the door And I picked up the sleeping pills crushed at the floor #Masterpiece
I prefer Marillion with Fish, by far. But this version with Hogarth was a phenomenal performance. People Who dislike are not Marillion fans, but Fish suck balls.
Don't get me wrong: I love also the Hogarth era Marillion but still: I think that this is the one songs that should be performed with seriousness and for memory of John Mylett. To be honest I don't know if this is something that really should be done, or is there sorta an agreement that this song may be performed on a happy note - that's basically all on Hogarth's judgement. For me, this was and is one of those sadder Marillion songs that has a known history of departing someone in final way. I can understand that this was not something Hogarth composed, but my initial guess would be that if Fish would perform Estonia, he wouldn't do it in taunting smiley way as Pete is doing this song 5:30 onwards. Seems that he is amusing the younger folks standing there in the audience and that's just great, really. And still I just love this song and everything Marillion had done so not a biggie, I maybe over reacting. I and all other Marillion fans are blessed to see two sides and eras of a great progressive rock band. Fish was great heads - Hogarth is now showing us the tails. Maybe I need to just sit back, relax and enjoy the ride they are giving :)
I couldn't agree more. Thats an absolutely tone-deaf stage performance from Hogarth. Whats with the gddmn hand gestures already? FEEL the song or dont do it.
I'm not seeing it like that. The themes come naturally to Hogarth, he's written just as much about topics like that (see: the entire AOS album, 3 Minute Boy), and reliving some of the most trying times every night on stage has been emotionally draining for him, so I don't see why he isn't allowed to take it a bit more lightly.
Jeez that solo was effortless for Rothery, just rolled off the guitar. H is beautiful singer, but the song belongs to fish, its too deep, you needed to have been there, its that hidden element that can only be conveyed if you had been there.
This is Fish's story....not Steve's. Hogarth may know the lyrics, but does not know/understand the heart & soul of "Misplaced"..only Fish knew from his personal experiences. Watch the Fish interview on the DVD "Return To Childhood". He goes into more detail on the genesis of "Misplaced Childhood"...the drugs, the Berlin hooker, the pseudo silk komono...etc. I couldn't see Fish singing selections from Marillion's "Brave" concept album. Does not click. Would have been great to see a one-off gig with Fish and his old band mates perform Misplaced in its entirety.
So Bruce Dickinson shouldn't perform songs like 'Iron Maiden' of 'Wrathchild'? Almost every band that exist such a long time got a new singer once along the way. That doesn't mean they can't perfom their back cataloque. I'm glad Marillion still performs these great songs, and H does a great job.
Ironically, Marillion produces the same results on its fans, as well as, their greatest influence, Genesis: no Gabriel, no Genesis; no Fish, no Marillion. LOL
Did you see the person in the audience at 3:21 toss up an inflatable "fish"? Ha ha - wonder if he was trying to send a message? This version is OK (too fast), but he's no Fish.
Во-первых, Фиш сам ушёл и ни разу не пожалел об уходе. Во-вторых, воссоединяться с ними никогда не планировал. И в третьих, Хогарт на несколько голов выше Фиша как вокалист.
This is not Blind Curve! Starts with Passing Strangers wich is not Blind Curve! Finishes in the begining of Pereminter Walk and no Childhood's Ends! Don't ruin the best song ever writen by Marillion!
On principle I agree, but Marillion have always fiddled around with sections. The demo version of MC still has "Lords of the Backstage" as part of side 1 and "Vocal under a Bloodlight" missing. And many live albums only have "Mad" written on the tracklisting when in fact it's "Wave", "Mad" and "The Opium Den", maybe even the second half of "Standing in the Swing".
It’s good but I just think that’s out of his vocal range and so it doesn’t come across well. Hogarth is great at Hogarth but this section of MP is exquisite and this does not do it justice. Immaculate guitar though
Manoel Ferraz go see them live you will find out hogarth has all of that , he is an incredible musician , singer with such a big stage presence get out of the past fish nowadays is utter garbage hogarth is one of the main reasons marillion are one of the best live bands atm
This performance - 2007. The last time they had played this song before was 1991, a 16-year difference. Still, it's almost note-perfect and beautifully sung. Disgusting? No, it's brilliant.
![MARILLION - WARM WET CIRCLES [family]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pzwSuOVE440/mqdefault.jpg)
![MARILLION - WARM WET CIRCLES [family]](/img/tr.png)
![เบิ้ล ปทุมราช - อ้ายกินดอง น้องลาบงัว ft. สแน็ก อัจฉรีย์ [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-OK--KaSPcI/mqdefault.jpg)
Blind Curve has always been my favorite Marillion song! Amazing and brilliant performance!
What a stunning performance by all the guys, and Steve’s solo …. Wow ! 😊❤
As always... more than EXCELLENT !!!
Steve is truly Wonderful... as usual !!!
One of the best Marillion song. Amazing perfomance
I've been listening to Blind Curve a lot recently. The fellow in the front row's reaction as Blind Curve (proper) starts, is one of the most touching things I have ever seen. It's as if the song really connected to something within him from years gone by. Even though this is a "Fish" song, H really shines on this one - and it's one of the rare ones that works equally with both singers and eras. Outstanding.
3:55 , Steve Rothery simply The Best.👏👏👏👏
Underated guitar player. But credit is usually a mediatic thing
This is THE Fish-era Marillion song. I really like H's voice in those old songs and it's amazing how these guys are so consistently amazing. What other band can play like 80% of their (huge) output on rotation live at this level of musicianship?
@Israel Duque Interesting though to observe that both Rothery and Kelly have used vocalists on their solo project that are closer to Fish in timbre... (Martin Jakubski & Oliver M. Smith)...
This is rhe best work from the band in my opinion, they are great musicians but i like Fish voice
Omg this touched my heart !! This is brilliant !
At the 2:12 mark , that guy in the audience in the front row with the crew cut, well really looks like he is emotionally invested into the song
Perfect...Love this...Marillion !!!
Man…I feel bad for the H haters who never learn. Hogarth is the best.
Definitely!
Capolavoro stupefacente !!😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
beautiful..... always was
Simply ridiculously unique and sadly never again
This is a great song! Even though everything has its time and things move on I sometimes do wish they'd still write songs like this from time to time.
Fase sombria de Fish... Me too!! Rsrs I remember... Talk to me
Emotional breakdown at 02:10
I too felt it
admirável momento!
Marillion do this to me as well no other band does this
Lovely guitar solo
Mostruosa😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Damn this solo is better than the recording
Fantastic!!!🎉🎉🎉
Last night you say I Was Cold..
Just leave me alone with my thoughts..
I' m Saving myself
So I reached for a bottel and he reached for the door
And I picked up the sleeping pills crushed at the floor
#Masterpiece
Grande band, super
Rothenys solo is killer
5.39 mins so cool taking a look at those kids.....priceless
Muito bom cara. Simplesmente demais....
Love this
❤❤❤❤❤❤
love love love xxx
Amazing song!
Magnificent!
gracias por esta joya!!!
Impossivel descrever.
show essa banda. bons tempos
" ", there are no words .
A fish😂❤
Amazing !!!
Hogarth is a great singer, but these songs just sound so much better when Derek Dick is singing them.
That is true !!!
no doubt.... it's got to be Fish...
These songs are just meant for h's voice, suites him much better than Derek's
But Derek ain`t with the band anymore?? And as a Marillion singer he has obligations to the band to sing Marillion songs.
Guitar solo kills me ..
👁El ojo
I like marillion with fish, but Steve Hogarth is a good singer
I wish they play next week,Blind Curve in Lisbon.
I was hoping they’d do it like that! I guess not :(
I prefer Marillion with Fish, by far.
But this version with Hogarth was a phenomenal performance.
People Who dislike are not Marillion fans, but Fish suck balls.
Hogarth tends to really nail Fish songs. His performance of Script in 2013 was really powerful. Lots of emotion.
Love this version of this track. Shame it isn't in full
I cannot get any pleasure from this. Only Fish I liked
Don't get me wrong: I love also the Hogarth era Marillion but still: I think that this is the one songs that should be performed with seriousness and for memory of John Mylett. To be honest I don't know if this is something that really should be done, or is there sorta an agreement that this song may be performed on a happy note - that's basically all on Hogarth's judgement. For me, this was and is one of those sadder Marillion songs that has a known history of departing someone in final way. I can understand that this was not something Hogarth composed, but my initial guess would be that if Fish would perform Estonia, he wouldn't do it in taunting smiley way as Pete is doing this song 5:30 onwards. Seems that he is amusing the younger folks standing there in the audience and that's just great, really. And still I just love this song and everything Marillion had done so not a biggie, I maybe over reacting. I and all other Marillion fans are blessed to see two sides and eras of a great progressive rock band. Fish was great heads - Hogarth is now showing us the tails. Maybe I need to just sit back, relax and enjoy the ride they are giving :)
I couldn't agree more. Thats an absolutely tone-deaf stage performance from Hogarth. Whats with the gddmn hand gestures already? FEEL the song or dont do it.
I'm not seeing it like that. The themes come naturally to Hogarth, he's written just as much about topics like that (see: the entire AOS album, 3 Minute Boy), and reliving some of the most trying times every night on stage has been emotionally draining for him, so I don't see why he isn't allowed to take it a bit more lightly.
Love that part 2:00
Lo mejor marillion lo mejor ctm
where the rest of the song?
From which DVD this song is?
THIS STRANGE CONVENTION
www.marillion.com/shop/dvd/tsc.htm
Hogarth sounds amazing on this, makes the track his own
this guy 02:08
Where was this concert at?. ¿Donde tuvo lugar este concierto?
Marillion Weekend 2007, Center Parcs, Port Zelande, Netherlands.
Wo spielt das? Und wann? DVD?
Marillion Weekend 2007, Center Parcs, Port Zelande, Netherlands.
DVD "This Strange Convention", CD "Family"
@@progmeup vielen Dank für die Infos... 🙌
Jeez that solo was effortless for Rothery, just rolled off the guitar. H is beautiful singer, but the song belongs to fish, its too deep, you needed to have been there, its that hidden element that can only be conveyed if you had been there.
I'll admit Hogarth gives this everything he's got but not a patch on Fish singing it.
like fish
Love the Fish era. Sounds better with him. H is Ok but he sings through his nose.
This is Fish's story....not Steve's. Hogarth may know the lyrics, but does not know/understand the heart & soul of "Misplaced"..only Fish knew from his personal experiences. Watch the Fish interview on the DVD "Return To Childhood". He goes into more detail on the genesis of "Misplaced Childhood"...the drugs, the Berlin hooker, the pseudo silk komono...etc. I couldn't see Fish singing selections from Marillion's "Brave" concept album. Does not click. Would have been great to see a one-off gig with Fish and his old band mates perform Misplaced in its entirety.
marillion with fish is another history ,but with steve h isnt bad .i like this song with this singer.
So Bruce Dickinson shouldn't perform songs like 'Iron Maiden' of 'Wrathchild'? Almost every band that exist such a long time got a new singer once along the way. That doesn't mean they can't perfom their back cataloque. I'm glad Marillion still performs these great songs, and H does a great job.
Ignore the haters. This is pure sacrilege. You are correct
HE LEFT THE FUCKING BAND??
Ironically, Marillion produces the same results on its fans, as well as, their greatest influence, Genesis: no Gabriel, no Genesis; no Fish, no Marillion. LOL
inascoltabile...villipendio al maestro FISH
He is not Fish.. Noooooooo
played too fast
Totally..
Did you see the person in the audience at 3:21 toss up an inflatable "fish"? Ha ha - wonder if he was trying to send a message? This version is OK (too fast), but he's no Fish.
Fish, better than, so much... bye...
No, no mames Steve no cantes cosas que no entiendes y que mucho menos puedes.
Che orrore
извращенцы верните фиша!!!!
какого? Который уже говорит вместо того, чтобы петь? Люблю оба периода творчества Мариллиона, но вернуть Фиша сейчас - даже не смешно
Во-первых, Фиш сам ушёл и ни разу не пожалел об уходе. Во-вторых, воссоединяться с ними никогда не планировал. И в третьих, Хогарт на несколько голов выше Фиша как вокалист.
Suena bien pero no es fish
Falta la magia que solo el podía darle
This is not Blind Curve! Starts with Passing Strangers wich is not Blind Curve! Finishes in the begining of Pereminter Walk and no Childhood's Ends! Don't ruin the best song ever writen by Marillion!
On principle I agree, but Marillion have always fiddled around with sections. The demo version of MC still has "Lords of the Backstage" as part of side 1 and "Vocal under a Bloodlight" missing. And many live albums only have "Mad" written on the tracklisting when in fact it's "Wave", "Mad" and "The Opium Den", maybe even the second half of "Standing in the Swing".
No Fish, No Marillion
ignorant fool.
Absolute tosh.
Totally agree
Sorry,no disrespect but FISH on the original for me.Cannot replace that same feeling no matter how hard this guy tries.
It’s good but I just think that’s out of his vocal range and so it doesn’t come across well. Hogarth is great at Hogarth but this section of MP is exquisite and this does not do it justice. Immaculate guitar though
As fish poured his heart out in this song over the death of John Mylett I find it in poor taste they perform this. It's 100% only a fish song.
не в обиду, но это позор!!!
Хогарт поёт лучше Фиша. Фиш вживую вообще петь не умел, декламировал свои стихи. Речитатив - не пение.
Hogarth should stick to his Marillion era songs, leave the iconic songs of the past untouched. Marillion isn’t really Marillion without The Fish!😖
hogarth mi dispiace ma non è arte tua ,dai a Cesare quello che è diCesare!!!
hogarth is a normal singer, nothing special. He don't have the same feeling, originality and authentic personality as fish had
Manoel Ferraz go see them live you will find out hogarth has all of that , he is an incredible musician , singer with such a big stage presence get out of the past fish nowadays is utter garbage hogarth is one of the main reasons marillion are one of the best live bands atm
Indeed had.
YOU FUCKING MORON, GO BACK TO SLEEP.
😂 H is a phenomenal singer and frontman
Disgusting
This performance - 2007. The last time they had played this song before was 1991, a 16-year difference. Still, it's almost note-perfect and beautifully sung. Disgusting? No, it's brilliant.
Sorry, just my personal opinion - but this is so awful I couldn't listen to all of it. Hogarth ruins the genius of Fish.
SHOWS WHAT YOU KNOW ABOUT MUSIC, NOTHING.