I do wish Jackson and his team stuck strictly to the tone of LotR. It seems like it just got away from all of them. But….we live in the timeline where LotR was close to perfect.
I will go against teh grain and call greasebag "not a character". Because he is just a caricature of a character. Actual characters have reasons to be the way they are. Thranduil has a reason to hold elven lives above others. Thorin has a reason to hate elves. Even if the movies dont show it, the bad characters still have reasons to be who they are and be where they are. As bas as the Master of Laketown is, it still makes sense for him to be in a position of power. Simply put, there is more to steal. And he has shown some minor diplomatic competency which makes it vaguely possible for him to get there. Greasebag's entire exsistance makes zero sense. He is just every negative trait and stereotype smushed together. There is literally no sound reason a character like him hasnt starved to death. His greatest asset is being able to identify which way is the wind blowing, only to then immediately follow it up by shouting something completely nonsensical. He is a person that noone should take seriously. He shouldnt have been able to get that high on the totempole
Had to work yesterday, catching up on the stream now,
Absolutely love your content!
Where does one watch the Hobbit M4 book edit?
They have a website, check Google. You need to torrent it via their website.
I do wish Jackson and his team stuck strictly to the tone of LotR. It seems like it just got away from all of them. But….we live in the timeline where LotR was close to perfect.
Did you switch inoffensive and mostly functional around compared to the rings of power autopsy?
We actually see Dwalin in the flashbacks. It's brief and he has a mohawk
Does he explain why inoffensive is now above mostly functional?
I didn't get a notification when this went live.
Hit the bell icon
Where do I find the ROP tier list?
In his ROP final autopsy.
@@DaveE7492 oh ye, I’ve seen that. :)
I will go against teh grain and call greasebag "not a character". Because he is just a caricature of a character.
Actual characters have reasons to be the way they are. Thranduil has a reason to hold elven lives above others. Thorin has a reason to hate elves. Even if the movies dont show it, the bad characters still have reasons to be who they are and be where they are. As bas as the Master of Laketown is, it still makes sense for him to be in a position of power. Simply put, there is more to steal. And he has shown some minor diplomatic competency which makes it vaguely possible for him to get there.
Greasebag's entire exsistance makes zero sense. He is just every negative trait and stereotype smushed together. There is literally no sound reason a character like him hasnt starved to death. His greatest asset is being able to identify which way is the wind blowing, only to then immediately follow it up by shouting something completely nonsensical. He is a person that noone should take seriously. He shouldnt have been able to get that high on the totempole
Clearly the three trolls are S tier characters.