Poor Aruna. They kept her alive for so long, not to live but merely to exist in misery just to appease themselves. It’s a relief that she is finally free. RIP Aruna.
12:03. That expression doesn't help either. Talking about her like she was a child also make me agree with you on that. They tortured her for their own benefits.
She was a beautiful Woman who have a compassion of caring wholeheartedly...she may not know ,those nurses truly cared for her even when her family just left her there in hospital to be looked after by others...although for some ,it will be a released of physical pain if they decide for her to pass ,since she cannot speak or communicate ...Dying naturally by sickness or old age is because your time is up even accidents are unpredictable passing ...so euthanasia is neither accident or natural ..it was no different from taking someone's life....just my opinion not to offend others .
@@justmesweetmay4901 They kept her alive for 42 years with machines, drugs... It is not natural either; It is worse, imo. They played with her body. Without all of this she wouln't be there.
The description of this video mentions she’s working on the Kolkata case! ❤ This video is serving as a prelude to that case. It’s tragic how these cases seem to keep happening. This one, Nirbhaya and now the Kolkata one. When will it end? 😢
@@a.j.cookie9735that’s amazing! India is already not safe for women I don’t know why men can’t just keep it in their pants! You could go out and they’d just look at you, like what is going on in that mind of yours?? India is very scary for women and even more scarier now knowing how the Indian judiciary system handles it, we’re always just told to carry something to defend ourselves it’s so so sad.
I am definitely feeling some kinda way about her nurses. There were many motivations for keeping her alive, but I don't think Aruna's well-being was one of them.
I have heard that one of the reasons they chose to keep Aruna alive was because of the attention they got from the government to all of their demands .
Euthanasia was not yet legal in India during the Aruna Shanbhag case so that’s why there were issues regarding taking her off life support. After a long court battle, she was granted the right to die in peace.
I just read about this today after learning about India's latest case about a female intern. This is so sad, so much needs to be done to make this place a safer place for all.
Unpopular opinion but them keeping her alive for that long with no regards of how being trapped in her own body might've felt for her was selfish and wrong.
@@PolaBeaverso many people, willing to decide what is a good life, and what is a bad life, for others. We tend to look at ourselves and society as advanced. Advanced enough to decide for others what a good life is and what a bad life is. I've heard people in favor of abortion making similar claims. That it's good a poor woman can get an abortion, that saves her and the child from leading a hard life. As if a life with lots of money, is the only good life available. Who's to say how that woman felt about her life. Maybe given the choice, she would've chosen death. On the other hand, she may have been grateful for the life she led. I for one, am glad that no one took her life from her, thinking they were doing her a kindness.
I thought about her the other day. It breaks my heart knowing that the people who supposedly loved her the most moved on without her, and the monster who hated her the most carried on living life like normal.
India has too much sexual violence cases and the government doesn’t seem to be doing anything much about it. Perhaps people of other countries should make a stand against Indian tourism to push their government into action.
Also keep in mind, that India has a large population and among those, there are a relatively large portion of uneducated people as well or people who do not receive proper education. This is a major factor that contributes to sexual assault cases.
@@kiarose5792It does if the only education you get in regards to women, is the equally uneducated and not nice behavior of those around you. A lot of men on this planet do not view women as humans equal to themselves, so they care less about what happens to them. Even their own relatives.
I'd point out that you don't have to be educated to respect other humans and know what's right from wrong. India has lots of other problems and it would be a long comment if I get into them and if I were to start it would be how women are portrayed in their movies and shows. Consent is totally out the window and creépy behaviors like stalking are romantized. Men only view women as objects and that's all. There needs to be a cultural reset and victim blaming has to stop. Any time if a girl is 🍇ed they blame her because she was dressed a certain way. If you don't view women as honorable human beings and that their consent matters you're failing as a human. No amount of degrees can fix this mindset. @@Vim-eo2zy
Govt doesnt seem to be doing much? 😀 Ignorance is bliss.btw, India's cases seem high because of Population. Per capita wise India is one of the lowest sexual crime countries. If u measure a country's wealthiness by GDP per capita, then why not the same when it comes to r@pe statistics?
i cannot believe this. i had to pause and take a moment when megan revealed where the assault took place. i have worked there for quite a few months and oh my god. i cannot believe that such an incident took place over at my workplace. my heart goes out to Aruna.
The perp had freedom after serving some years in prison, while the victim was vegetable for 42 years. Doesn't seem fair enough. Not just 1970s, even in 2020s nearly 99% of SA cases go unreported due to social stigma, let alone sexual harrasment is a daily routine in the country. Indian hospitals and med schools are barely prestigious, I mean even the top med schools and hospitals merely rank 500s-1000s in the entire world. Most other third-world countries rank higher.
RIP Aruna. My sister was in a vegetative state before her passing too but she didn't suffer for as long as Aruna did. Its so painful to think what they both been through and i could see my sister in aruna which isn't easy but at least in this case Aruna's death was not in vain.
It's sickening that these wicked perpetrators can live their lives to the fullest meanwhile their victims are cold in the ground. They may evade justice in this world, but they can't evade justice in the next world
I think it’s important to recognise a few things in this case: 1) Aruna’s life support consisted of food and water. She apparently wasn’t fed through a feeding tube (photos shown here), so she must have swallowed the food that was put in her mouth; 2) Aruna responded to the nurses who cared for her in subtle ways that indicated that she had some consciousness of their presence and care. That is a significant sign of life; 3) Passive suicide is the withdrawal of food and water in order to hasten death. Dying from starvation is a painful and torturous experience. It is not compassionate. It is easy to look at someone like Aruna and make assumptions about their quality of life, but as long as a person is cared for and loved and can express some sense of others (some photos show her smiling) and life we need to be careful that we’re not projecting what we think we would feel in their place. The nurses showed kindness and loving care for Aruna; I’m impressed and thankful for that. May Aruna rest in peace.
Back in school, we had a subject called General Knowledge (or GK), and for one project, we had to collect and stick newspaper cutouts of breaking news. I was in 5th grade in 2013 when Aruna Shanbaug's case resurfaced in the news. I included it in my project, and my mom, who was helping me, explained the whole heartbreaking story. I still remember how sad, angry, and frustrated I felt about how the court handled the plea for her euthanasia. Great work again, Megan! The way you present these heartbreaking stories is truly amazing.
UPDATE: As Indian i read her whole article back in where mentioned that 1 or 2 cleaners staff used to steal food of patients & feed to dog...also there was sexual assault happened which was unnatural totally cuz she was in her period so her attacker knows if he rap*ed her she got pregnant so he choose to rape otherwise...yes being Indian its shame... Indian society n law aren't that strict about rape or domestic violence n dowery... anyway thanks for sharing.... rest in peace Arun❤.
Megan, could you please share information or upload a video about the recent case of an Indian doctor who was tragically raped and murdered at her workplace? I'm looking for a reliable source to stay informed about this incident.
my eyes twitched when reading the title and continued to twitch throughout the video, both out of anger and disgust. I never thought i would develop such a habit but after watching stephanie soo’s videos and yours whether it be this case, the Kolkata case, Junko’s case, or all other cases similar to this one, the feeling of genuine disgust swishes inside. It’s crazy that these stories not only invoke an emotional reaction of out me, but also physical. That’s how twisted these cases are.
You can't put Stephanie in the same category as Megan. Megan is resourceful, truthful, and in no way exaggerating. Megan's way of storytelling is at such a high level. I also love how Megan pronunciation of words from different languages sounds the way it should sound. You can tell this girl practices and does her homework. Just MY opinion, but Stephanie's voice sounds soooooooo annoying.
@@Tominori70 Stephanie also puts incredibly hard work into her projects as well. Most importantly, I am not putting Stephanie and Megan in the same category, I KNOW that they are different but that is NOT at all the point of my comment and it is not what you should be focusing on. Why are you putting stephanie down and implying that stephanie does not conduct extensive studies; as well as the cheap shot you threw at stephanie? Please get your priorities straight. You imply that stephanie exaggerates, to which I implore you to give me an example. Either way, it doesn’t matter because the POINT of my comment is that CASES like these really show how disgusting people can be.
@menuvafei6164 as I have stated, it is MY opinion. I am not putting Stephanie down in order to uplift anyone. Idc if you hated anyone, it is your right. If your feelings are hurt, that's too bad. It's not really an insult if it's my perceived fact. So don't cry your crocodile tears at me
I think the point is that you missed her point. The OP was clearly discussing how the actual cases exposes human wickedness. You were completely off topic. I suggest that you create your own separate post to discuss the topic that you seem so interested in. @Tominori70
Unfortunately, the farther back in time you go, the more horrible life is for women, anywhere in the world, that’s why I refrain from calling the past, “the good old days”. Aruna basically became a vegetable, due to unnatural causes, that is frightening to think about.
If you're talking about the last 250 years, yes. If we're going back further, times were tougher overall, but women had more rights at several points in time than in the early industrialisation era. This also depends on the area they lived in, of course.
And to think that back in the days ( in India ) a person that was sexually assaulted is believed to bring disgrace to her family to the point of not getting justice for what she experienced is just heart breaking
This is why when working in the medical field you must put your feelings aside and think objectively for the patients well being…. May she rest in peace.
I dont know how to feel about the decision to keep someone,who is essentially a vegetable, alive for over 40 years, but when the courts originally decided to allow for Aruna's euthanasia to take place by stopping her intake of food, did this mean they were willing to allow her to slowly starve to death?
Poor lady... the brutality sends shiver down my spine... I noticed that alot of people using the recent Kolkata SA victim in FB reels for reels. They always claimed that they "miss her" but if you're the friend of the departed why would you use picture of her dead!??? Absolutely disgusting!! The people who leaked photos of the victim dead be damned!!! This poor girl now is being used for clicks even after her death.
Bless those nurses who stood beside Aruna long after her own family. They truly loved her. I feel for them she was like a child and who gives up on a defenseless child? As a Christian I believe God gives us life and only HE can take it back.
hi megan, i’m excited to watch this video as you never disappoint with your narration skills. as a request, can you cover the sheena bora case? thank you and sending lots of love and support 💜🫶💜🫶
I used to work in a hospital with a dementia ward, that also housed vegetative and palliative care patients. Everyone that worked there, from the medical to the in-house and hospitality staff had issued instructions to their families about making sure they themselves never wound up in a place like that. One patient had been in there for 36 years! Make sure your power of attorney or the executor of your will knows what your instructions are, if something should happen to you.
A lot of these kinds of cases has been reported recently, especially from countries of SK and India. To our sisters in general please take care and lookout for each other.
@@expiredmilk929 A massive deepfake scandal has erupted in South Korea. Men have created illegal exploitative content by superimposing the faces of their friends, sisters, girlfriends, teachers, and even mothers onto explicit videos, which they then shared among themselves. They even exchanged information on how much sleeping medication would be required for their sisters not to wake up while being touched. There are numerous chat rooms dedicated to sharing these deepfakes, with over 200,000 participants involved. While South Korean women are extremely anxious, incels in Korea are mocking them, and criticizing women who are taking down their photos from social media to protect themselves. In the past, a similar incident known as the "Nth Room" case occurred in Korea, but there was no adequate punishment. As a result, these perpetrators are becoming more brazen, criticizing the victims and labeling those who condemn them as man-haters.
@@expiredmilk929 A massive deepfake scandal has erupted in South Korea. Men have created illegal exploitative content by superimposing the faces of their friends, sisters, girlfriends, teachers, and even mothers onto explicit videos, which they then shared among themselves. They even exchanged information on how much sleeping medication would be required for their sisters not to wake up while being touched. There are numerous chat rooms dedicated to sharing these deepfakes, with over 200,000 participants involved. While South Korean women are extremely anxious, incels in Korea are mocking them, and criticizing women who are taking down their photos from social media to protect themselves. In the past, a similar incident known as the "Nth Room" case occurred in Korea, but there was no adequate punishment. As a result, these perpetrators are becoming more brazen, criticizing the victims and labeling those who condemn them as man-haters.
Urgh! Everytime I hear "India" in crime stories I already know it's going to be about women who were either SA'd, tortured, murdered & everything at the same time & it just makes me mad & sad at the same time. But I'm also glad that these cases are not just cases because they are making the women & everyone in their country fight for a better & safe working environment.
the more i think about the current case in Kolkata i understand how the hospital authorities at rg kar are trying to potray it as in the heat of the moment crime by a unskilled labour/non medic ...much like the case here. So we need everyone here to help us voice our concerns and doubt about the shoddy investigation and cover up of case evidence.
Yeah..Connect two completely unrelated incidents as same and on same pedestal.The amount of hype and false Information spread on RG Kar incident was Politically motivated and deliberate and appalling. There was no BIG Conspiracy like u gullible bengali numbnuts spewed around for passing ur boredom n to blame govt and the college authority for a crime not even they were responsible of. Inspite of the Kolkata police showing extreme efficiency in arresting the culprit within 12 hours, u numbnuts demanded CBI investigation over Rumours, false Information being peddled in social media. And CBI being a lapdog of Anti Bengal Central Govt tried its best to find anu clue to those conspiracy theories of yours, and when they couldnt find any, they blamed the lack of any such evidence as evidenced having been already removed... Wow. What a nice investigation agency. 😀 And i must say bengali numbnuts who sabotage, defame their own state and country r the biggest doomers of their own making. Dont whine why u people r jobless. No one likes to hire self sabotaging thakless clowns like u for a reason.
those nurses were wild, dude. they were like, "but we LIKE her! we want to keep her!" like children getting sad that their mom won't let them keep a squirrel in the house. her quality of life didn't even occur to them lmao
Knowing now what I do about coma patients, my heart hurts for her. She was trapped in a prison of her body for over 4 decades due to the selfish acts of others.
My aunt worked in the same hospital and my mom once saw her. Even when I think about it now I... keep thinking. Why? Why would a man do this? Why her? The reality just slaps me sharp. The shock she suffered and the condition she was in just sends chills down my spine. We will never be able to understand no, don't understand her because we are simply not capable of doing so.
@@nikkimclay5474 really? Then why all women is india is sezxually unsafe everywhere? why only women are asked to dress properly to not provoke men while men can roam around half nakedd???
The abuser was let out, he married n lived a normal life!!! This poor woman had a life worse than death!!! The Angels of the hospital kept her alive!!!!
Thanks Megan, emontional rolercoaster on the last case and now back to "basic" tragedy. Is there a way to know how the laws came along since Arunas passing? Law changes were the only silverligning about this... Still belive the staff member got away due to lack of DNA tests. Very frustrated with this one 😮💨
What a sad case. Having worked and stayed in hospitals before, I think I can understand the views of both sides. There's no right or wrong decision to her living arrangements, I think, as people were only trying to do their best. The fault lay solely on her assailant.
They were being selfish by keeping her alive. She’d already suffered enough why keep her alive to live in that pain each and every single day? That was selfish of them.
Falling in love is a wonderful feeling and so is being in love. But there is no such thing as forever in love, not because of the time frames but because people do stop loving each other. So, I prefer to wish you all "Forever Being Loved" because being loved is the best feeling of love that we actually wanted most and it involve more loves and sources you will get (from family, partner, friends, siblings, colleagues etc) . Even if anyone of them stop loving you, at least there are still other sources of love. Hope that Aruba is in a better place now. Out of pain and out of anymore suffering. 🙏
Hi Megan, Ever since I have accidently stopped by at your channel, I am totally engaged with your stories and your style of presentation. I sense your sincerity upon victims in your delivery of stories and that impress me very much. You might also want to consider the Australian Crimes in your selection (which we have our fair share) and that would add deeper engagement with people from here like us. Anyway, best of luck with your work and hope you will continue this work into the future. Cheers, Rick
I'm wondering in India is there a statute of limitations for murder? Due to her assault she was practically vulnerable to many illnesses so she pretty much succumbed to her wounds the perpetrator should have been charged for murder after she died.
I think KEM Hospital can't let go of her for the sole reason for what happened to her. It happened there so they held themselves accountable for her (could only imagine how muc the hospital bill) ... but damn 42 yrs 😢
I love your videos Megan,I think many are asking to do a video on the Kolkata doctor case but it is not solved yet may be thats the reason she didnt make a video on that !
That one's coming up soon with updates. The case is super complicated so it's taking us some time to make it into a video that could be easily digested!
Honestly, her fiancé and family kinda suck for just “moving on with their lives”. Nobody else gonna mention that it’s kinda messed up to just drop her like that? No advocating for her or at least visiting once in a while? It’s “too upsetting” is such a copout. So she’s stuck unable to live a normal life but seeing her is too hard for you? That’s selfish af.
The nurses loved her as she was one of there own and tried to get her to respond but this poor lady didt get any justice she was let down badly!!! Just like the lady doctor same thing happening again no justice !! 😢😢
Hot take: The nurses were incredibly selfish for essentially dragging out her life for that long. The woman was a vegetable, not living but existing. All while suffering every step of the way...
Who are you to decide her life or death? Just because she can't talk that doesn't mean she wanted to die. In this world there is something call miracle. How do you know 100% he would not survive ?unless you come from the future.(yes she was not survived at the end) but still you have no right to make decision for her
My belief is that only God has the right to call home a soul. Thankfully, the nurses at KEM Hospital never gave up on Aruna and I'll probably get hate replies for this next bit. I have an overwhelming gut feeling that Sohanthl was telling the truth. It absolutely does not justify what happened but just because it was only his word doesn't mean he was lying. It's a terrible tragedy for everyone involved.
Poor Aruna. They kept her alive for so long, not to live but merely to exist in misery just to appease themselves. It’s a relief that she is finally free. RIP Aruna.
12:03. That expression doesn't help either. Talking about her like she was a child also make me agree with you on that.
They tortured her for their own benefits.
She was a beautiful Woman who have a compassion of caring wholeheartedly...she may not know ,those nurses truly cared for her even when her family just left her there in hospital to be looked after by others...although for some ,it will be a released of physical pain if they decide for her to pass ,since she cannot speak or communicate ...Dying naturally by sickness or old age is because your time is up even accidents are unpredictable passing ...so euthanasia is neither accident or natural ..it was no different from taking someone's life....just my opinion not to offend others .
@@justmesweetmay4901 They kept her alive for 42 years with machines, drugs...
It is not natural either; It is worse, imo.
They played with her body.
Without all of this she wouln't be there.
25 years of life for 42 years of living hell. Not fair.
All due to a predator disguised as a janitor, who’s life continues out of jail btw 😤, definitely not fair 😢
And yet, her perpetrator was living his normal life. Shitty law!
if it helps, she was already brain dead. She did not feel hell.
Her loved ones however were holding on to false hope.
@@jade5202 In a way that makes it worse.
The guy is out, married and living in a village
Megan please cover the Kolkata trainee doctor case, everything about it is just so sad and justice hasn’t been served at all! 🙏
yesss i also mentioned her 10 days before
it’ll probably be blocked and banned in india again, stephanie soo covered the crime but the indian govt banned the video
The description of this video mentions she’s working on the Kolkata case! ❤ This video is serving as a prelude to that case. It’s tragic how these cases seem to keep happening. This one, Nirbhaya and now the Kolkata one. When will it end? 😢
@@asparagus5396no it isn’t I can still see it with 2.5million views
@@a.j.cookie9735that’s amazing! India is already not safe for women I don’t know why men can’t just keep it in their pants! You could go out and they’d just look at you, like what is going on in that mind of yours?? India is very scary for women and even more scarier now knowing how the Indian judiciary system handles it, we’re always just told to carry something to defend ourselves it’s so so sad.
I am definitely feeling some kinda way about her nurses. There were many motivations for keeping her alive, but I don't think Aruna's well-being was one of them.
I have heard that one of the reasons they chose to keep Aruna alive was because of the attention they got from the government to all of their demands .
Euthanasia was not yet legal in India during the Aruna Shanbhag case so that’s why there were issues regarding taking her off life support. After a long court battle, she was granted the right to die in peace.
Did she ask to die? We don't know that, you are assuming that.
@@PolaBeaverif you are in that situation, do you still wanna live? Live like a dead for more than half of your life?
40 seconds in...this is a delicate case and only a skilled journo and narrator like you will do a good job explaining it
This story is still relevant considering the recent brutal attack in Calcutta, India on a female doctor. That is a story horrifying as well.
indian men never beating the allegations
I just read about this today after learning about India's latest case about a female intern. This is so sad, so much needs to be done to make this place a safer place for all.
indian men never beating the allegations lmao
This case really makes one think- whether it was better to live on because your body would not give up, or die because the suffering was too much...
Fr..
Unpopular opinion but them keeping her alive for that long with no regards of how being trapped in her own body might've felt for her was selfish and wrong.
I agree in the West families can choose to take loved ones off life support
That's not unpopular. Your opinion is popular. Unfortunately.
@@PolaBeaverso many people, willing to decide what is a good life, and what is a bad life, for others. We tend to look at ourselves and society as advanced. Advanced enough to decide for others what a good life is and what a bad life is. I've heard people in favor of abortion making similar claims. That it's good a poor woman can get an abortion, that saves her and the child from leading a hard life. As if a life with lots of money, is the only good life available. Who's to say how that woman felt about her life. Maybe given the choice, she would've chosen death. On the other hand, she may have been grateful for the life she led. I for one, am glad that no one took her life from her, thinking they were doing her a kindness.
I thought about her the other day. It breaks my heart knowing that the people who supposedly loved her the most moved on without her, and the monster who hated her the most carried on living life like normal.
India has too much sexual violence cases and the government doesn’t seem to be doing anything much about it. Perhaps people of other countries should make a stand against Indian tourism to push their government into action.
Also keep in mind, that India has a large population and among those, there are a relatively large portion of uneducated people as well or people who do not receive proper education. This is a major factor that contributes to sexual assault cases.
Being uneducated dosent affect anybody,s conscience or humanity
@@kiarose5792It does if the only education you get in regards to women, is the equally uneducated and not nice behavior of those around you. A lot of men on this planet do not view women as humans equal to themselves, so they care less about what happens to them. Even their own relatives.
I'd point out that you don't have to be educated to respect other humans and know what's right from wrong. India has lots of other problems and it would be a long comment if I get into them and if I were to start it would be how women are portrayed in their movies and shows. Consent is totally out the window and creépy behaviors like stalking are romantized. Men only view women as objects and that's all. There needs to be a cultural reset and victim blaming has to stop. Any time if a girl is 🍇ed they blame her because she was dressed a certain way. If you don't view women as honorable human beings and that their consent matters you're failing as a human. No amount of degrees can fix this mindset. @@Vim-eo2zy
Govt doesnt seem to be doing much? 😀 Ignorance is bliss.btw, India's cases seem high because of Population. Per capita wise India is one of the lowest sexual crime countries. If u measure a country's wealthiness by GDP per capita, then why not the same when it comes to r@pe statistics?
i cannot believe this. i had to pause and take a moment when megan revealed where the assault took place. i have worked there for quite a few months and oh my god. i cannot believe that such an incident took place over at my workplace. my heart goes out to Aruna.
The perp had freedom after serving some years in prison, while the victim was vegetable for 42 years. Doesn't seem fair enough. Not just 1970s, even in 2020s nearly 99% of SA cases go unreported due to social stigma, let alone sexual harrasment is a daily routine in the country. Indian hospitals and med schools are barely prestigious, I mean even the top med schools and hospitals merely rank 500s-1000s in the entire world. Most other third-world countries rank higher.
People in comas aren’t “vegetables”
best narrator! short and simple i could listen to you for hours
RIP Aruna. My sister was in a vegetative state before her passing too but she didn't suffer for as long as Aruna did. Its so painful to think what they both been through and i could see my sister in aruna which isn't easy but at least in this case Aruna's death was not in vain.
How sickening that that creep has zero remorse after what he did. He just lived his life like nothing happened. I can't fathom it.
Psychopath
It's sickening that these wicked perpetrators can live their lives to the fullest meanwhile their victims are cold in the ground. They may evade justice in this world, but they can't evade justice in the next world
I think it’s important to recognise a few things in this case: 1) Aruna’s life support consisted of food and water. She apparently wasn’t fed through a feeding tube (photos shown here), so she must have swallowed the food that was put in her mouth; 2) Aruna responded to the nurses who cared for her in subtle ways that indicated that she had some consciousness of their presence and care. That is a significant sign of life; 3) Passive suicide is the withdrawal of food and water in order to hasten death. Dying from starvation is a painful and torturous experience. It is not compassionate. It is easy to look at someone like Aruna and make assumptions about their quality of life, but as long as a person is cared for and loved and can express some sense of others (some photos show her smiling) and life we need to be careful that we’re not projecting what we think we would feel in their place. The nurses showed kindness and loving care for Aruna; I’m impressed and thankful for that. May Aruna rest in peace.
Back in school, we had a subject called General Knowledge (or GK), and for one project, we had to collect and stick newspaper cutouts of breaking news. I was in 5th grade in 2013 when Aruna Shanbaug's case resurfaced in the news. I included it in my project, and my mom, who was helping me, explained the whole heartbreaking story. I still remember how sad, angry, and frustrated I felt about how the court handled the plea for her euthanasia.
Great work again, Megan! The way you present these heartbreaking stories is truly amazing.
Megan’s narration makes it much better to understand, thank you for covering these cases so briefly..!
Thank you Megan👍
This case is just... 😢 Looking forward to hearing Megan's skilled, professional coverage ☺️
UPDATE: As Indian i read her whole article back in where mentioned that 1 or 2 cleaners staff used to steal food of patients & feed to dog...also there was sexual assault happened which was unnatural totally cuz she was in her period so her attacker knows if he rap*ed her she got pregnant so he choose to rape otherwise...yes being Indian its shame... Indian society n law aren't that strict about rape or domestic violence n dowery... anyway thanks for sharing.... rest in peace Arun❤.
Oh man, what a tragic story. Thank you Megan for sharing this. Superb storytelling, as always!
Megan, could you please share information or upload a video about the recent case of an Indian doctor who was tragically raped and murdered at her workplace? I'm looking for a reliable source to stay informed about this incident.
I get why the nurses kept looking after her, she was one of them once.
my eyes twitched when reading the title and continued to twitch throughout the video, both out of anger and disgust. I never thought i would develop such a habit but after watching stephanie soo’s videos and yours whether it be this case, the Kolkata case, Junko’s case, or all other cases similar to this one, the feeling of genuine disgust swishes inside. It’s crazy that these stories not only invoke an emotional reaction of out me, but also physical. That’s how twisted these cases are.
You can't put Stephanie in the same category as Megan. Megan is resourceful, truthful, and in no way exaggerating. Megan's way of storytelling is at such a high level. I also love how Megan pronunciation of words from different languages sounds the way it should sound. You can tell this girl practices and does her homework. Just MY opinion, but Stephanie's voice sounds soooooooo annoying.
@@Tominori70 Stephanie also puts incredibly hard work into her projects as well.
Most importantly, I am not putting Stephanie and Megan in the same category, I KNOW that they are different but that is NOT at all the point of my comment and it is not what you should be focusing on. Why are you putting stephanie down and implying that stephanie does not conduct extensive studies; as well as the cheap shot you threw at stephanie? Please get your priorities straight.
You imply that stephanie exaggerates, to which I implore you to give me an example. Either way, it doesn’t matter because the POINT of my comment is that CASES like these really show how disgusting people can be.
@@Tominori70you don’t have to put Stephanie down just to uplift Megan. They both provide wonderful content for us.
@menuvafei6164 as I have stated, it is MY opinion. I am not putting Stephanie down in order to uplift anyone. Idc if you hated anyone, it is your right. If your feelings are hurt, that's too bad. It's not really an insult if it's my perceived fact. So don't cry your crocodile tears at me
I think the point is that you missed her point. The OP was clearly discussing how the actual cases exposes human wickedness. You were completely off topic. I suggest that you create your own separate post to discuss the topic that you seem so interested in. @Tominori70
Unfortunately, the farther back in time you go, the more horrible life is for women, anywhere in the world, that’s why I refrain from calling the past, “the good old days”. Aruna basically became a vegetable, due to unnatural causes, that is frightening to think about.
Yes very true sir
If you're talking about the last 250 years, yes. If we're going back further, times were tougher overall, but women had more rights at several points in time than in the early industrialisation era. This also depends on the area they lived in, of course.
And to think that back in the days ( in India ) a person that was sexually assaulted is believed to bring disgrace to her family to the point of not getting justice for what she experienced is just heart breaking
@@i.b3744 exactly, and we still haven’t made much progress since then
Thankyou for your videos, Ms. Megan. You must be one of the best youtubers covering true crime cases! ❤
Just horrible. A life should not be prolonged like that
This is why when working in the medical field you must put your feelings aside and think objectively for the patients well being…. May she rest in peace.
It is more heartbreaking that her family gave up on her...
I think they did the best they could, given the circumstances. The family had their own lives too.
I dont know how to feel about the decision to keep someone,who is essentially a vegetable, alive for over 40 years, but when the courts originally decided to allow for Aruna's euthanasia to take place by stopping her intake of food, did this mean they were willing to allow her to slowly starve to death?
Yeah that’s cruel
Poor lady... the brutality sends shiver down my spine... I noticed that alot of people using the recent Kolkata SA victim in FB reels for reels. They always claimed that they "miss her" but if you're the friend of the departed why would you use picture of her dead!??? Absolutely disgusting!! The people who leaked photos of the victim dead be damned!!! This poor girl now is being used for clicks even after her death.
Rip Aruna, what a heartbreaking story, that sentence wasn't enough, no justice at all. Thank you Megan
Dear Megan! It happen again 40 yrs later. In today news. The protest turned violent. Singaporean respect the Dr at India & may justice be served.
Even though you talk about these kinds of cases, there is something so calming and soothing about your voice and way of speaking.
Too devastating 😮
Thank u Megan❤
Bless those nurses who stood beside Aruna long after her own family. They truly loved her. I feel for them she was like a child and who gives up on a defenseless child? As a Christian I believe God gives us life and only HE can take it back.
Aruna, rest in peace.
hi megan, i’m excited to watch this video as you never disappoint with your narration skills. as a request, can you cover the sheena bora case? thank you and sending lots of love and support 💜🫶💜🫶
I used to work in a hospital with a dementia ward, that also housed vegetative and palliative care patients. Everyone that worked there, from the medical to the in-house and hospitality staff had issued instructions to their families about making sure they themselves never wound up in a place like that. One patient had been in there for 36 years! Make sure your power of attorney or the executor of your will knows what your instructions are, if something should happen to you.
Perfect timing, it's bed time for me and your voice helps soothe me to sleep. Love your vids Megan, goodnight from Australia ❤
A lot of these kinds of cases has been reported recently, especially from countries of SK and India. To our sisters in general please take care and lookout for each other.
Every persons nightmare and yet, when given the opportunity to end that nightmare, people r suddenly divided.
Thank you for another case Ms. Megan! 💕
Could you create a video about the Telegram incident that recently occurred in South Korea???
korean men saw indian men et all the hate and got jealous
Can you tell me about it?
@@expiredmilk929
A massive deepfake scandal has erupted in South Korea. Men have created illegal exploitative content by superimposing the faces of their friends, sisters, girlfriends, teachers, and even mothers onto explicit videos, which they then shared among themselves. They even exchanged information on how much sleeping medication would be required for their sisters not to wake up while being touched. There are numerous chat rooms dedicated to sharing these deepfakes, with over 200,000 participants involved. While South Korean women are extremely anxious, incels in Korea are mocking them, and criticizing women who are taking down their photos from social media to protect themselves. In the past, a similar incident known as the "Nth Room" case occurred in Korea, but there was no adequate punishment. As a result, these perpetrators are becoming more brazen, criticizing the victims and labeling those who condemn them as man-haters.
@@expiredmilk929
A massive deepfake scandal has erupted in South Korea. Men have created illegal exploitative content by superimposing the faces of their friends, sisters, girlfriends, teachers, and even mothers onto explicit videos, which they then shared among themselves. They even exchanged information on how much sleeping medication would be required for their sisters not to wake up while being touched. There are numerous chat rooms dedicated to sharing these deepfakes, with over 200,000 participants involved. While South Korean women are extremely anxious, incels in Korea are mocking them, and criticizing women who are taking down their photos from social media to protect themselves. In the past, a similar incident known as the "Nth Room" case occurred in Korea, but there was no adequate punishment. As a result, these perpetrators are becoming more brazen, criticizing the victims and labeling those who condemn them as man-haters.
That one was hard to stomach.. poor Aruna. She was in a vegetative state for longer than she was not.
Megan please cover the Sayama incident of 1963. I'll be forever grateful!!
Heartbreaking story. RIP.
Wtf the perp wasnt even arrested or charged just got on with his life like he didnt completely and entirely ruin somebodys life 😠
She changed her dress to go to home, but she never go to home after that 😢
Urgh! Everytime I hear "India" in crime stories I already know it's going to be about women who were either SA'd, tortured, murdered & everything at the same time & it just makes me mad & sad at the same time. But I'm also glad that these cases are not just cases because they are making the women & everyone in their country fight for a better & safe working environment.
Blessed day megan,thank you for this another story, keep safe always❤
the more i think about the current case in Kolkata i understand how the hospital authorities at rg kar are trying to potray it as in the heat of the moment crime by a unskilled labour/non medic ...much like the case here. So we need everyone here to help us voice our concerns and doubt about the shoddy investigation and cover up of case evidence.
Yeah..Connect two completely unrelated incidents as same and on same pedestal.The amount of hype and false Information spread on RG Kar incident was Politically motivated and deliberate and appalling. There was no BIG Conspiracy like u gullible bengali numbnuts spewed around for passing ur boredom n to blame govt and the college authority for a crime not even they were responsible of. Inspite of the Kolkata police showing extreme efficiency in arresting the culprit within 12 hours, u numbnuts demanded CBI investigation over Rumours, false Information being peddled in social media. And CBI being a lapdog of Anti Bengal Central Govt tried its best to find anu clue to those conspiracy theories of yours, and when they couldnt find any, they blamed the lack of any such evidence as evidenced having been already removed... Wow. What a nice investigation agency. 😀 And i must say bengali numbnuts who sabotage, defame their own state and country r the biggest doomers of their own making. Dont whine why u people r jobless. No one likes to hire self sabotaging thakless clowns like u for a reason.
those nurses were wild, dude. they were like, "but we LIKE her! we want to keep her!" like children getting sad that their mom won't let them keep a squirrel in the house. her quality of life didn't even occur to them lmao
Knowing now what I do about coma patients, my heart hurts for her.
She was trapped in a prison of her body for over 4 decades due to the selfish acts of others.
Thank you ❤
So much pain and injustice in the world. Why would you drag out her existence, not life, like that 😢
My aunt worked in the same hospital and my mom once saw her. Even when I think about it now I... keep thinking. Why? Why would a man do this? Why her? The reality just slaps me sharp. The shock she suffered and the condition she was in just sends chills down my spine. We will never be able to understand no, don't understand her because we are simply not capable of doing so.
It saddened me she used to heal people as a profession
Relatable
Not all men, but majority of men everywhere when opportunity comes
Not majority of men that’s not fair
@@nikkimclay5474 really? Then why all women is india is sezxually unsafe everywhere? why only women are asked to dress properly to not provoke men while men can roam around half nakedd???
@@nikkimclay5474well nowadays majority of men.
Good lord. This was just plain 100% unsweetened dread, horror and misery.
God bless and respect to all the nurses ,took turn taking care of her .
The abuser was let out, he married n lived a normal life!!! This poor woman had a life worse than death!!! The Angels of the hospital kept her alive!!!!
Thanks Megan, emontional rolercoaster on the last case and now back to "basic" tragedy.
Is there a way to know how the laws came along since Arunas passing?
Law changes were the only silverligning about this...
Still belive the staff member got away due to lack of DNA tests.
Very frustrated with this one 😮💨
What a sad case. Having worked and stayed in hospitals before, I think I can understand the views of both sides. There's no right or wrong decision to her living arrangements, I think, as people were only trying to do their best. The fault lay solely on her assailant.
They were being selfish by keeping her alive. She’d already suffered enough why keep her alive to live in that pain each and every single day? That was selfish of them.
Falling in love is a wonderful feeling and so is being in love. But there is no such thing as forever in love, not because of the time frames but because people do stop loving each other. So, I prefer to wish you all "Forever Being Loved" because being loved is the best feeling of love that we actually wanted most and it involve more loves and sources you will get (from family, partner, friends, siblings, colleagues etc) .
Even if anyone of them stop loving you, at least there are still other sources of love.
Hope that Aruba is in a better place now. Out of pain and out of anymore suffering. 🙏
Hi Megan,
Ever since I have accidently stopped by at your channel, I am totally engaged with your stories and your style of presentation. I sense your sincerity upon victims in your delivery of stories and that impress me very much. You might also want to consider the Australian Crimes in your selection (which we have our fair share) and that would add deeper engagement with people from here like us. Anyway, best of luck with your work and hope you will continue this work into the future. Cheers, Rick
I ❤ Your Channel You Tell The Cases With So Much Compassion ❤️
Kolkata doctor case story
This is so cruel to keep her alive to suffer like this rip Aruna
Accidentally saw this video thanks for being voice for the voiceless victims
You can tell what kind of person she is by the fact that the nurses happily took care of her for 42 years.
I'm wondering in India is there a statute of limitations for murder? Due to her assault she was practically vulnerable to many illnesses so she pretty much succumbed to her wounds the perpetrator should have been charged for murder after she died.
Everything was so wrong with this case. RIP Aruna you are in a better place now❤
Your hair looks stunning!
Aruna may not get justice from the abuse but God will provide it to her.
I think KEM Hospital can't let go of her for the sole reason for what happened to her. It happened there so they held themselves accountable for her (could only imagine how muc the hospital bill) ... but damn 42 yrs 😢
Love yr videos!❤️
You should also make a research and video about Rosario Baluyot. Another sad story.
Growing up to be a nurse and this case is foul, how could he do her like that 😢😢😢
This, is so heartbreaking.
That, woman was brutally beaten ,sexually assaulted and left in an vegetable state.
I love your videos Megan,I think many are asking to do a video on the Kolkata doctor case but it is not solved yet may be thats the reason she didnt make a video on that !
That one's coming up soon with updates. The case is super complicated so it's taking us some time to make it into a video that could be easily digested!
@@DarkAsiawithMegan Yes i understand the case is sensitive and complex ! and the case is taking new turns everyday .
Such a cruel world for us women.
Young lady..you are so talented and beautiful
Great presentations every TIME! ❤Susan USA
Honestly, her fiancé and family kinda suck for just “moving on with their lives”. Nobody else gonna mention that it’s kinda messed up to just drop her like that? No advocating for her or at least visiting once in a while? It’s “too upsetting” is such a copout. So she’s stuck unable to live a normal life but seeing her is too hard for you? That’s selfish af.
Now every time it’s my birthday I’m going to remember it’s the day she passed away 😭
Saddening 😢😢
Never heard of this before but it is so sad
The nurses loved her as she was one of there own and tried to get her to respond but this poor lady didt get any justice she was let down badly!!! Just like the lady doctor same thing happening again no justice !! 😢😢
Five decades... And nothing has changed.
So brutal that poor woman :(
HATS OFF to those WHO cared to much OF her ❤🫡
Hot take: The nurses were incredibly selfish for essentially dragging out her life for that long. The woman was a vegetable, not living but existing. All while suffering every step of the way...
Who are you to decide her life or death? Just because she can't talk that doesn't mean she wanted to die. In this world there is something call miracle. How do you know 100% he would not survive ?unless you come from the future.(yes she was not survived at the end) but still you have no right to make decision for her
In their religion you cant kill anyone.untill God wants to take the life.
Respect for all the nurses of KEM for keeping her alive🙏🙏
Against her wishes ?
What a sad case for Aruna.
This is tragic story.....
My belief is that only God has the right to call home a soul. Thankfully, the nurses at KEM Hospital never gave up on Aruna and I'll probably get hate replies for this next bit. I have an overwhelming gut feeling that Sohanthl was telling the truth. It absolutely does not justify what happened but just because it was only his word doesn't mean he was lying. It's a terrible tragedy for everyone involved.
Please make a video on rg kar kolkata case