The man is so full of energy. It’s heartening to see someone of his stature speak so freely and frankly on issues that really matter. PS: The students are so dumb.
I am a Hindu ..and I totally agree to Fali Nariman..........Not that a priest should not be a chief minister...but it signals to something very dangerous.......if Mr. Adityanaths speeches are to be analysed...his bias and his basic misunderstanding of Hinduism...is clearly visible
Mahatma Gandhi was a saint and he led India during her struggle for independence. His views too were controversial at times. I think that people's mandate must be respected.,
U no need to b afraid of Hindu priest ruling any state.minorities are free to follow their own religion if they don’t interfere in ours.hindu doesn’t preach violence
look at these semi-literates who are arguing with Shekhar Gupta and passing comments on Fali Nariman. bunch of guys who have probably never been to a real school
Is Piloo Reporter,our famous cricket 🏏umpire,in the audience here!?! Well,I just saw him in the audience! I used to meet him often!🏏 But this Fali Bhai is simply fantastic! Full of knowledge &great interview🌹🏏🙏🌹💞
From where I am in the UK, I am fearful of what is happening in India, and find the appointment of the CM of UP an open advocate of converting India to a Hindu State very alarming. Mr. Nariman has openly said the reasons why he is fearful of what is going on. I very much hope that sense will prevail and the fear that the Muslim community has will be laid to rest.
Across India jamad imposes ban or restrictions on timings on going thru public streets once they get majority - extra-constitutionally. A Democracy which is Impotent to rein in these communal brutes can go. The politicians who are Impotent to deal with these elements can go
Sir, with due respect to you, you have been so honest and forth right. You May be old in age but young in spirit. My pranams to you. Ex ECr Q. was good.and you showed how powerful Election Commission is! But Sri Narasimaha Rao Ex PM clipped TN Seshans wings by appointment of 2 more additional commissioners hence it was dumped once and for all. Sir why not 3 Presidents, 3 PMs, 3CJs and so forth. I think time has come to have 3 Editor in chiefs, 3 moderators to interview etc etc etc. Moderator and the students from Amety who asked the Q. were silly and biased. How ever you wetted their belly! and at the same time told the truth. No wonder nothing should be banned, So why not a person who has got the mandate?. In democracy everything should be fair. Who knows UP CM may look silly to you but who knows, he can do wonders also!. Yours and mine is a guess, but let us hope for the best!!
Divya Satheesh I am a citizen of Bharat, born a Christian, now Agnostic. I support Mr. Modi, Sanatana Dharma and the Ram temple. That said, do realise the magnificence of Sanatana Dharma has been in its inclusivity, it’s tremendous depth and wisdom. I request that Hinduism is not defined in a narrow way, just because other religions may be doing so. Hinduism will survive another 1000 years provided its adherents remain true to its depth and wisdom.
5:19 - Constitution is under threat when a democratically elected person becomes CM of UP. Democracy was not under threat when people without constitutional authority ran the country from 10 Janpath,. Fali go back to your cozy courts where your son can be the judge and you can be the advocate. After half day of hard work you can go back to contemplating. If its summer you don't even have to work that half day.
please dont forget Nehru. Let him torment him into your grave. Leave Fali Nariman alone. The man talks some real sense... know your past -- as Fali says.
I had happened to see this video late, I like and admire Mr. Nariman If I remember correctly he played great role during the emergency. But you're putting the words in his mouth that Modi or BJP will be going towards Emergency, now I am writing this reply in 2019 you saw what happened, BJP is converting the other religious votes into Majority. Now I understand why you started slowly moving towards neutral and detaching yourself from NDTV.
Hahaha.. Now he's almost become pro Modi... He's carefully re-maneuvering himself according to the current people's majority. I have almost lost faith with all our media... Both pro bjp and pro Congress. I miss the times when news channel used to inform you of the news... Now they tell you how to interpret it... They impose their views on to you. Wish India awakens to this and starts boycotting these channels.
Fali himself sound hypocrite and talk like congress or leftist spokes person. When he refers elevation of Yogi as any priest being elevated to be CM, he ignored his educational qualification and career as parliamentarian. His seems to have strong bias. Very disappointing to see such eminent lawyer having colored vision. Shame
@@shashanktikekar16 During Highs time children died because oxygen was not available bevause of ineffeciency Police inspector was tarvetted and murdered be ause he was doing his duty A MP killed whole family because the girl he raped complained and went to the court Police did not want to know
Crores of tax payers hard earned money is wasted because of Yogi on cows and lakhs and crores are wasted on showering flowers on kumaris from the helicopter. Whilst children die due to the lack of oxygen in hospitals.....
True, there should be a collegium. The Election Commission cannot be reduced to conducting elections. Please ,the Elevtion Commission is the most powerful .
What an wonderful way to appreciate emergency as an inoculation for survival of democracy now. The way Indian Constitution has emasculated the people of India unlike what other democracies have achieved in terms of empowerment of people. As per your saying this constitution was framed by 85% persons who were devote Hindus and yet they brought Articles 26 to 30 for denying the education of anything from Hindu scriptures in the schools, why? While others as minorities can, why? The Article 35A which has been smuggled in the Constitution to harm and destroy Article 15 in the J&K state.
- Unconvincing So called public figures peddling agenda - Before Vilifying Hindu Rastra please take pain to Define it - Rajedra Prasad gave the constitution what has been done in last 70 Years to bring Narrative here - Says that odd that a priest is MP / CM but Rajendra Prasad Hindu Orthodox was not odd - Meets PM but does not ask the question which he wants other to ask - Raising the stakes planting in ppls mind that Emergency is coming
In our constitution no mention of any religion to bifurcate the people of the country . We are only made Hindu, Muslim , Christian etc . Instead we could have qualify believer of Hinduism, Islam , Christianity etc . Then this separatism would be diminished to a great extent
Gossips in social media are not necessarily started by common or uncommon people with critical inputs... mostly the vested interests in politics and beyond use the media to seed and spread gossips, mostly vicious and ill conceived to hurt someone or some group, also the ruling party and the govt in order to encash the favours from the sources that benefit by the mischievs
Dear Mr Nariman you say we are hypocrites. You are right. How can you call a fellow who refuses to see the climate change, which is proven scientifically with facts and figures, A fellow who claims that India performed plastic surgery and had airplanes in ravana's time, ENLIGHTENED. Come on sir leave your hypocrisy aside.
Mr Fali you have misleaded intelligently. you said the person should be judge and then a religious person. Again you contradict your statement, not right
Mr Nariman is alleging that bharat becomes a hindu rashtra.nothing wrong.we made a mistake in not announcing a hindu rashtra after independence.he is forgetting a hindu king gave them refuge n enjoying eaual eaual status .let him tour some places in states where majority r minorities in some states. Slowly illegal immigrants r occupying,threatening the locals.all the border states.he is the audacity to blame pm n hindus like aditynath..freedom of sppech.
The top executive of the country in USA the President can context only for two terms. I think in the Indian context, the PM should be for two terms so that more younger generation will get opportunity in the Governance. The Governors should be above politics and should be a learned person commanding respect. Our culture is based on Truth and Dharma. This should be reflected in law and living. Indians are all over the world. Let us hope our cultural heritage which encompasses all humanity and think of world Government for peace and prosperity. The present competition with weapons will be suicidal.
Crook mentality of Shekhar Gupta is out, comparing a democratically elected government with emergency period. Shame on you Shekhar.
5 ปีที่แล้ว
Yes I agree and see my comment on this page. NDTV will never rise up.
5 ปีที่แล้ว +2
I had happened to see this video late, I like and admire Mr. Nariman If I remember correctly he played great role during the emergency. But you're putting the words in his mouth that Modi or BJP will be going towards Emergency, now I am writing this reply in 2019 you saw what happened, BJP is converting the other religious votes into Majority. Now I understand why you started slowly moving towards neutral and detaching yourself from NDTV.
At 06:30, Fali says 'we're being hypocritical. He's absolutely right. Him and his son Justice Rohinton Nariman are the ordained priests, but he seems to be having a problem with a hindu saint becoming a CM. And this guy rarely stays away from appearing before the benches which is son is a part of.. I can't agree more, with you, on this Fali. Yes, you're being hypocrite. '
Dear Harish, I cannot blame you for your unsavoury comments , since you are ignoramus in case of matters pertaining to Zoroastrianism. In Zoroastrianism, like hinduism a son of a priest is taught scriptures and they have to appear before a body of priests and they are given a honorific title called Ervad. There are two type of priests some who are practising priest and some who are working in other professions and give part time services during muktad days (equivalent to Shraddha days in Hinduism). The latter ones or the former have not denounced the world unlike Yogi Adityanath. When one calls himself a yogi, it is presumed that he is an ordained sanyasi. That he has undergone a ceremony under the tutelage of his guru, who has given him diksha or say put him upon the path of sanyas which if he strictly follows may lead him to the path of moksha. Therefore, coming to the point, if he is indeed a true sanyasi having undergone the essential rituals, then that act leads to his civil death in legal parlance, a fact which has been uphold by various judgments right from the times of the therein Privy Council to present time our apex court I.e. Supreme Court. In effect due to the fact that in the eyes of a law the person has suffered from a legal debility called civil death, in effect they cannot hold property in their name, and they cannot even stand for elections in my humble opinion, a fact which has been duly ignored by many legal experts and conveniently by the Election Commissioner. So coming to the point, there is a difference between the status of the doyen whom you have out of ignorance and zeal, and the yogi in question. If yogiji has not undergone those rituals then he should refrain from calling himself a yogi, a honorific term attached to a person who has given up sansarik jeevan. Rest, I believe your goodself is intelligent enough to understand my view point. By the way my view points should not be construed that I possess hatred towards yogi or hinduism or against bjp. We Indians should strive to achieve unity. Hatred for one another will not let us anywhere. We have higher goals to achieve. Our great constitution under its directive principles exhorts us to remain as brothers and sisters and participate in nation building. What we are witnessing in present times is fascism, which if not controlled will bring harm to our beloved country.
Dear Harish, I cannot blame you for your unsavoury comments , since you are ignoramus in case of matters pertaining to Zoroastrianism. In Zoroastrianism, like hinduism a son of a priest is taught scriptures and they have to appear before a body of priests and they are given a honorific title called Ervad. There are two type of priests some who are practising priest and some who are working in other professions and give part time services during muktad days (equivalent to Shraddha days in Hinduism). The latter ones or the former have not denounced the world unlike Yogi Adityanath. When one calls himself a yogi, it is presumed that he is an ordained sanyasi. That he has undergone a ceremony under the tutelage of his guru, who has given him diksha or say put him upon the path of sanyas which if he strictly follows may lead him to the path of moksha. Therefore, coming to the point, if he is indeed a true sanyasi having undergone the essential rituals, then that act leads to his civil death in legal parlance, a fact which has been uphold by various judgments right from the times of the therein Privy Council to present time our apex court I.e. Supreme Court. In effect due to the fact that in the eyes of a law the person has suffered from a legal debility called civil death, in effect they cannot hold property in their name, and they cannot even stand for elections in my humble opinion, a fact which has been duly ignored by many legal experts and conveniently by the Election Commissioner. So coming to the point, there is a difference between the status of the doyen whom you have out of ignorance and zeal, and the yogi in question. If yogiji has not undergone those rituals then he should refrain from calling himself a yogi, a honorific term attached to a person who has given up sansarik jeevan. Rest, I believe your goodself is intelligent enough to understand my view point. By the way my view points should not be construed that I possess hatred towards yogi or hinduism or against bjp. We Indians should strive to achieve unity. Hatred for one another will not let us anywhere. We have higher goals to achieve. Our great constitution under its directive principles exhorts us to remain as brothers and sisters and participate in nation building. What we are witnessing in present times is fascism, which if not controlled will bring harm to our beloved country.
I would like to ask MR NARIMAN has he ever asked when UPA on power, Y GANDHI family only should be our policymakers like SG and RaGa, so I would say is ok for our PM to suggest his party man who can be their CM. So it is obvious Mr NARIAN is also an opportunist.
No doubt he is an eminent person, with great knowledge. But here he blaming something which he is not supporting by crude facts, when facts are given to him which clearly are against his blames/ apprehensions then answers are 1) ignoring it with joke 2) you people decide ( playing victim card that we parsi, Muslim are no where) 3) quoting others that he (swamy) is saying this. So, in my opinion if u are blaming something like this, if u are comparing the time of emergency with present ( no emergency) , and If u are somebody like Fali S. Nariman having that tall judicial stature then ur apprehensions must be followed by clear reasoning. Moreover, when ""nothing should be banned"" , very sorry to say sir, our constitution part 3 Fundamental rights itself come with several reasonable restrictions with them . So it's not easy to sallow down your thinking. U are the champion of fundamental rights, but for u holding chair of CM by yogi being head of religious institution is sign of something evil ( someone was saying NOTHING should be banned) . Though u are one of the torchbearer of fundamental rights in Indian jurisprudence. But sir u should not miss that, this is universal too and yogi is no different.
Being crusader of humanity and democracy , you were the counsel of man who killed thousands of people try to remember wid ur elephant memory how did u do this the conscious keeper of nation😂(ds man was defence counsel of union carbon carbide case- bhopal gas tragedy)
@@marlinmathews5742 make 25 Christian state secular Also Make Israel again Secular Funny thing is that united states openly supports India n Israel to make Religious state
Majority Hindus ki samvidhan se hi es desh me minority ke pm manmohan shing (Sikh) enka boss soniya ji (christchan) aur enka Advicer Ahmad Patel (Muslim) 10sal tak shasan kiya Majority Hindu pm bane to en logoka samvidhan katre me hai Kya ham Hindu logoko en salone kya samja hai
With due respect, Sir, you seem to have forgotten why your ancestors landed in this very country that you are talking about. And absolute shame on you, for building a religious narrative.
The man is so full of energy. It’s heartening to see someone of his stature speak so freely and frankly on issues that really matter.
PS: The students are so dumb.
Yeah specially the first student, fali didnt even try to answer his question 🤣
InstaBlaster.
Sir ,,he would put us jail or so many raids at our places.
all must listern
I love to hear his forthright comments and learn from his vault of knowledge. Praying for his good health.
At his age his sharp clear discussion is remarkable. Bravo sir.
When an emancipated mind speaks u can feel the clarity and love
You expose the " Wrobg turn" we took all these years!
I am a Hindu ..and I totally agree to Fali Nariman..........Not that a priest should not be a chief minister...but it signals to something very dangerous.......if Mr. Adityanaths speeches are to be analysed...his bias and his basic misunderstanding of Hinduism...is clearly visible
Mahatma Gandhi was a saint and he led India during her struggle for independence. His views too were controversial at times. I think that people's mandate must be respected.,
U no need to b afraid of Hindu priest ruling any state.minorities are free to follow their own religion if they don’t interfere in ours.hindu doesn’t preach violence
Appreciate the interview with Jurisr Fali Nariman by Shekhar Gupta of the Print.
Forthright and open. A moral voice.
There must be one special lecture which describes his journey of law profession
look at these semi-literates who are arguing with Shekhar Gupta and passing comments on Fali Nariman. bunch of guys who have probably never been to a real school
I think most of them are listening with utter silence and attention :-)
Very honest and outspoken person! Regards 🙏
Is Piloo Reporter,our famous cricket 🏏umpire,in the audience here!?! Well,I just saw him in the audience! I used to meet him often!🏏 But this Fali Bhai is simply fantastic! Full of knowledge &great interview🌹🏏🙏🌹💞
Nothing but facts well articulated and presented.
Narimanistheiconic personalitiy of the Indian judiciary
Very nice ❤
From where I am in the UK, I am fearful of what is happening in India, and find the appointment of the CM of UP an open advocate of converting India to a Hindu State very alarming. Mr. Nariman has openly said the reasons why he is fearful of what is going on. I very much hope that sense will prevail and the fear that the Muslim community has will be laid to rest.
please stay in uk....forever
Thank you for stating the truth, Sir.🙏
The very majority which gave India a secular constitution is now slowly changing its mind.
Please check the recent delhi riots n the brutal murder of Abhinav Sharma. You will get a clear picture of who is in the verge of a wipe out
Across India jamad imposes ban or restrictions on timings on going thru public streets once they get majority - extra-constitutionally.
A Democracy which is Impotent to rein in these communal brutes can go.
The politicians who are Impotent to deal with these elements can go
Living legend
Sir, with due respect to you, you have been so honest and forth right. You May be old in age but young in spirit. My pranams to you.
Ex ECr Q. was good.and you showed how powerful Election Commission is! But Sri Narasimaha Rao Ex PM clipped TN Seshans wings by appointment of 2 more additional commissioners hence it was dumped once and for all. Sir why not 3 Presidents, 3 PMs, 3CJs and so forth. I think time has come to have 3 Editor in chiefs, 3 moderators to interview etc etc etc.
Moderator and the students from Amety who asked the Q. were silly and biased.
How ever you wetted their belly! and at the same time told the truth.
No wonder nothing should be banned, So why not a person who has got the mandate?.
In democracy everything should be fair. Who knows UP CM may look silly to you but who knows, he can do wonders also!. Yours and mine is a guess, but let us hope for the best!!
🙏💞Fali Bhai is simply fantastic!💞🌹
Marvelous personality
what a great wisdom ?
Excellent and fourth right! Brilliant!
Yes we hindus all elected Mr.Modi and we want hindutva and ram temple.
Divya Satheesh I am a citizen of Bharat, born a Christian, now Agnostic. I support Mr. Modi, Sanatana Dharma and the Ram temple.
That said, do realise the magnificence of Sanatana Dharma has been in its inclusivity, it’s tremendous depth and wisdom. I request that Hinduism is not defined in a narrow way, just because other religions may be doing so. Hinduism will survive another 1000 years provided its adherents remain true to its depth and wisdom.
@@georgem2685 we love Christian community. I studied in Catholic school.
Isse chutiya question nahi dekha mene. How irritating it was.
Amity by the way.
We shall now draw a line between Humanism and Religious Ideologies.
The very majority which gave India a secular constitution is now slowly changing its mind.
5:19 - Constitution is under threat when a democratically elected person becomes CM of UP. Democracy was not under threat when people without constitutional authority ran the country from 10 Janpath,.
Fali go back to your cozy courts where your son can be the judge and you can be the advocate. After half day of hard work you can go back to contemplating. If its summer you don't even have to work that half day.
please dont forget Nehru. Let him torment him into your grave. Leave Fali Nariman alone. The man talks some real sense... know your past -- as Fali says.
The majority isnt "right" always. Chest thumping populism mostly always leads to fascism.
There is a reason Socrates hated democracy.
watched 15 Jan 2022 , find it infinite
I had happened to see this video late, I like and admire Mr. Nariman If I remember correctly he played great role during the emergency. But you're putting the words in his mouth that Modi or BJP will be going towards Emergency, now I am writing this reply in 2019 you saw what happened, BJP is converting the other religious votes into Majority.
Now I understand why you started slowly moving towards neutral and detaching yourself from NDTV.
Hahaha.. Now he's almost become pro Modi... He's carefully re-maneuvering himself according to the current people's majority. I have almost lost faith with all our media... Both pro bjp and pro Congress. I miss the times when news channel used to inform you of the news... Now they tell you how to interpret it... They impose their views on to you. Wish India awakens to this and starts boycotting these channels.
May grow tha humanity* than cast, relegion.
Well it has been a year since yogi became the chief minister and we don't have a hindu state yet . Guess, Fali was wrong.
Never teach your grandma how to suck eggs if not today one day India will be Hindu state
Fali himself sound hypocrite and talk like congress or leftist spokes person. When he refers elevation of Yogi as any priest being elevated to be CM, he ignored his educational qualification and career as parliamentarian. His seems to have strong bias. Very disappointing to see such eminent lawyer having colored vision. Shame
@@shashanktikekar16 During Highs time children died because oxygen was not available bevause of ineffeciency Police inspector was tarvetted and murdered be ause he was doing his duty A MP killed whole family because the girl he raped complained and went to the court Police did not want to know
Crores of tax payers hard earned money is wasted because of Yogi on cows and lakhs and crores are wasted on showering flowers on kumaris from the helicopter.
Whilst children die due to the lack of oxygen in hospitals.....
True, there should be a collegium. The Election Commission cannot be reduced to conducting elections.
Please ,the Elevtion Commission is the most powerful .
What an wonderful way to appreciate emergency as an inoculation for survival of democracy now. The way Indian Constitution has emasculated the people of India unlike what other democracies have achieved in terms of empowerment of people. As per your saying this constitution was framed by 85% persons who were devote Hindus and yet they brought Articles 26 to 30 for denying the education of anything from Hindu scriptures in the schools, why? While others as minorities can, why? The Article 35A which has been smuggled in the Constitution to harm and destroy Article 15 in the J&K state.
Watching in 2020
We gradually going into civil war because of RSS and BJP's ideology.
Be Logical .India have been in a Physical and Psychological WAR for over 1000 years.
And may I know what do you know about their ideology?
Shut up Abdul.
- Unconvincing So called public figures peddling agenda
- Before Vilifying Hindu Rastra please take pain to Define it
- Rajedra Prasad gave the constitution what has been done in last 70 Years to bring Narrative here
- Says that odd that a priest is MP / CM but Rajendra Prasad Hindu Orthodox was not odd
- Meets PM but does not ask the question which he wants other to ask
- Raising the stakes planting in ppls mind that Emergency is coming
Why then you have change the fandamental febric of constitution in Indira period ?
In our constitution no mention of any religion to bifurcate the people of the country . We are only made Hindu, Muslim , Christian etc . Instead we could have qualify believer of Hinduism, Islam , Christianity etc . Then this separatism would be diminished to a great extent
Gossips in social media are not necessarily started by common or uncommon people with critical inputs... mostly the vested interests in politics and beyond use the media to seed and spread gossips, mostly vicious and ill conceived to hurt someone or some group, also the ruling party and the govt in order to encash the favours from the sources that benefit by the mischievs
In place like UP, Bihar. You need CM like Yogi. Nothing to be afraid of.
Can you post subtitles of this video
Irony is his son is a Parsi priest wo became Supreme Court judge later and he opposes a hindu yogi being elected as CM
please invite markandey Katju on the show.
10 'O' clock is early?
Don't talk rubbish. Listen carefully what he said, " I always go early to court and 10 o'clock they would also come to court..."
Dear Mr Nariman you say we are hypocrites. You are right. How can you call a fellow who refuses to see the climate change, which is proven scientifically with facts and figures, A fellow who claims that India performed plastic surgery and had airplanes in ravana's time, ENLIGHTENED. Come on sir leave your hypocrisy aside.
Mr Fali you have misleaded intelligently. you said the person should be judge and then a religious person. Again you contradict your statement, not right
Fali you are totally wrong.
Mr Nariman is alleging that bharat becomes a hindu rashtra.nothing wrong.we made a mistake in not announcing a hindu rashtra after independence.he is forgetting a hindu king gave them refuge n enjoying eaual eaual status .let him tour some places in states where majority r minorities in some states. Slowly illegal immigrants r occupying,threatening the locals.all the border states.he is the audacity to blame pm n hindus like aditynath..freedom of sppech.
फली नरीमन के बदले साधारण वकील क्यो न बुलाया जाय
Where was narimanji during u.p.a.regime.
bhakt
15:00
If parsi priests can become judge, why the fuss when a Hindu priest becomes the CM.
So if tomorrow a Cristian priest becomes a Chief minister of a state ... You will not question ?
there is a difference between judge and CM!!!!! and most of parsis are well educated, not like illiterate yogi
Constitution is made for people not People made for Constitution.. you people don't know the Mood of Indian People. We want to be a Hindu State..
I think most of his prediction on Yogi came false.
There is no sense in asking pm any questio
Because he will say something and mean someting else and do something else
The top executive of the country in USA the President can context only for two terms. I think in the Indian context, the PM should be for two terms so that more younger generation will get opportunity in the Governance.
The Governors should be above politics and should be a learned person commanding respect.
Our culture is based on Truth and Dharma. This should be reflected in law and living.
Indians are all over the world. Let us hope our cultural heritage which encompasses all humanity and think of world Government for peace and prosperity. The present competition with weapons will be suicidal.
Are preists not allowed to be Chief Minister?
Mr.swamy was one of man who fought against emergency face to face
Damn can't believe he's retired... good luck for the future
The students asked such stupid questions
Crook mentality of Shekhar Gupta is out, comparing a democratically elected government with emergency period. Shame on you Shekhar.
Yes I agree and see my comment on this page. NDTV will never rise up.
I had happened to see this video late, I like and admire Mr. Nariman If I remember correctly he played great role during the emergency. But you're putting the words in his mouth that Modi or BJP will be going towards Emergency, now I am writing this reply in 2019 you saw what happened, BJP is converting the other religious votes into Majority.
Now I understand why you started slowly moving towards neutral and detaching yourself from NDTV.
Rajgopal is funny
Yes India is a Hindu country.majority are Hindus here.thats y u r enjoying all the privilege of minorities in India.hindus wrote our constitution.
23:06
At 06:30, Fali says 'we're being hypocritical. He's absolutely right. Him and his son Justice Rohinton Nariman are the ordained priests, but he seems to be having a problem with a hindu saint becoming a CM. And this guy rarely stays away from appearing before the benches which is son is a part of.. I can't agree more, with you, on this Fali. Yes, you're being hypocrite. '
Harish Inamdar that saint! 😂
Is he really a saint ?
He has 28 charges against him, some of them quite serious!
Is he a saint? Really?
You said it, charges. If the court finds him guilty, he'll resign. I am talking about the inherent bias of Fali. Missing the point??
Dear Harish, I cannot blame you for your unsavoury comments , since you are ignoramus in case of matters pertaining to Zoroastrianism. In Zoroastrianism, like hinduism a son of a priest is taught scriptures and they have to appear before a body of priests and they are given a honorific title called Ervad. There are two type of priests some who are practising priest and some who are working in other professions and give part time services during muktad days (equivalent to Shraddha days in Hinduism). The latter ones or the former have not denounced the world unlike Yogi Adityanath. When one calls himself a yogi, it is presumed that he is an ordained sanyasi. That he has undergone a ceremony under the tutelage of his guru, who has given him diksha or say put him upon the path of sanyas which if he strictly follows may lead him to the path of moksha. Therefore, coming to the point, if he is indeed a true sanyasi having undergone the essential rituals, then that act leads to his civil death in legal parlance, a fact which has been uphold by various judgments right from the times of the therein Privy Council to present time our apex court I.e. Supreme Court. In effect due to the fact that in the eyes of a law the person has suffered from a legal debility called civil death, in effect they cannot hold property in their name, and they cannot even stand for elections in my humble opinion, a fact which has been duly ignored by many legal experts and conveniently by the Election Commissioner. So coming to the point, there is a difference between the status of the doyen whom you have out of ignorance and zeal, and the yogi in question. If yogiji has not undergone those rituals then he should refrain from calling himself a yogi, a honorific term attached to a person who has given up sansarik jeevan. Rest, I believe your goodself is intelligent enough to understand my view point. By the way my view points should not be construed that I possess hatred towards yogi or hinduism or against bjp. We Indians should strive to achieve unity. Hatred for one another will not let us anywhere. We have higher goals to achieve. Our great constitution under its directive principles exhorts us to remain as brothers and sisters and participate in nation building. What we are witnessing in present times is fascism, which if not controlled will bring harm to our beloved country.
Dear Harish, I cannot blame you for your unsavoury comments , since you are ignoramus in case of matters pertaining to Zoroastrianism. In Zoroastrianism, like hinduism a son of a priest is taught scriptures and they have to appear before a body of priests and they are given a honorific title called Ervad. There are two type of priests some who are practising priest and some who are working in other professions and give part time services during muktad days (equivalent to Shraddha days in Hinduism). The latter ones or the former have not denounced the world unlike Yogi Adityanath. When one calls himself a yogi, it is presumed that he is an ordained sanyasi. That he has undergone a ceremony under the tutelage of his guru, who has given him diksha or say put him upon the path of sanyas which if he strictly follows may lead him to the path of moksha. Therefore, coming to the point, if he is indeed a true sanyasi having undergone the essential rituals, then that act leads to his civil death in legal parlance, a fact which has been uphold by various judgments right from the times of the therein Privy Council to present time our apex court I.e. Supreme Court. In effect due to the fact that in the eyes of a law the person has suffered from a legal debility called civil death, in effect they cannot hold property in their name, and they cannot even stand for elections in my humble opinion, a fact which has been duly ignored by many legal experts and conveniently by the Election Commissioner. So coming to the point, there is a difference between the status of the doyen whom you have out of ignorance and zeal, and the yogi in question. If yogiji has not undergone those rituals then he should refrain from calling himself a yogi, a honorific term attached to a person who has given up sansarik jeevan. Rest, I believe your goodself is intelligent enough to understand my view point. By the way my view points should not be construed that I possess hatred towards yogi or hinduism or against bjp. We Indians should strive to achieve unity. Hatred for one another will not let us anywhere. We have higher goals to achieve. Our great constitution under its directive principles exhorts us to remain as brothers and sisters and participate in nation building. What we are witnessing in present times is fascism, which if not controlled will bring harm to our beloved country.
Well said Mr Inamdar, i fully agree with you !
guilty before trial ……how can you convict ….. article14&25 give space to everyone…..and yogi was winning politician
I would like to ask MR NARIMAN has he ever asked when UPA on power, Y GANDHI family only should be our policymakers like SG and RaGa, so I would say is ok for our PM to suggest his party man who can be their CM. So it is obvious Mr NARIAN is also an opportunist.
No doubt he is an eminent person, with great knowledge. But here he blaming something which he is not supporting by crude facts, when facts are given to him which clearly are against his blames/ apprehensions then answers are 1) ignoring it with joke
2) you people decide ( playing victim card that we parsi, Muslim are no where)
3) quoting others that he (swamy) is saying this.
So, in my opinion if u are blaming something like this, if u are comparing the time of emergency with present ( no emergency) , and
If u are somebody like Fali S. Nariman having that tall judicial stature then ur apprehensions must be followed by clear reasoning.
Moreover, when ""nothing should be banned"" , very sorry to say sir, our constitution part 3 Fundamental rights itself come with several reasonable restrictions with them . So it's not easy to sallow down your thinking.
U are the champion of fundamental rights, but for u holding chair of CM by yogi being head of religious institution is sign of something evil ( someone was saying NOTHING should be banned) .
Though u are one of the torchbearer of fundamental rights in Indian jurisprudence. But sir u should not miss that, this is universal too and yogi is no different.
Why so fearful of Hindus?
Being crusader of humanity and democracy , you were the counsel of man who killed thousands of people try to remember wid ur elephant memory how did u do this the conscious keeper of nation😂(ds man was defence counsel of union carbon carbide case- bhopal gas tragedy)
Kids disappointed him...am sure
Let's see if Shekhar Gupta LET'S ANYONE SPEAK...
joker old man
mukund kumar u fool
u r great
I mean kuch bhi
What a fool you are do you even realize who he is. It will take forever for you to understand what he says.
@@marlinmathews5742 make 25 Christian state secular
Also Make Israel again Secular
Funny thing is that united states openly supports India n Israel to make Religious state
Majority Hindus ki samvidhan se hi es desh me minority ke pm manmohan shing (Sikh) enka boss soniya ji (christchan) aur enka Advicer Ahmad Patel (Muslim) 10sal tak shasan kiya
Majority Hindu pm bane to en logoka samvidhan katre me hai
Kya ham Hindu logoko en salone kya samja hai
Even if it is Nariman or any else will support for psuedo secularism adopted by the Congress party for 70 years
With due respect, Sir, you seem to have forgotten why your ancestors landed in this very country that you are talking about.
And absolute shame on you, for building a religious narrative.
If you think Nehru's Discovering India is a great book then you must be senile!
Nithyaji -- you sound senile. Or not sound at all.
well if you like your history full of factual inaccuracies and biases, then of course I will sound senile to you :-)
Shit